Two Students

by Pony of Buffy Fire

Rating: mature
Tags: Alternate Universe, Romance, Drama, Equestria Girls
Length: 1573

Starlight Glimmer and Sunset Shimmer hook up.

Sunset comes back to Equestria for a request. She wants some books. But she goes back home with a lot more. Namely, Starlight Glimmer.

Starlight is excited. She just kissed Twilight, and is feeling confident. She comes back to the room after….to see some almost smoochies! She goes with Sunset to another world.

But are they ready for what happens?

All characters are 18-19.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2016-10-02 21:42:58 UTC

We Have Quite A Lot In Common

Sunset Shimmer strolled through the portal. "Hey, Twi. Haven't seen you in a whi-!" Sunset yelled. The sight before her....Twilight and some mare were making out! Twilight broke out of it. "Sunset! Hi!"

The other mare glared. "Who are you?" She stared. This made was pretty, like jaw dropping pretty. Sexy. Starlight, get a hold of yourself. Do not think that. That would be cheating on Twilight! Not that it would be. Twilight doesn't even love me. She sighed, then snapped back to attention, realizing they were talking.

"I am Sunset Shimmer, student of Twilight Sparkle and former student of Celestia. Friends with Princess Cadence, and you are?" Sunset frowned. Who was this mare?

"I am Starlight Glimmer, student of Twilight Sparkle. Was, you are a student too?" Starflight asked in surprise. Sunset blinked. "Yes. But I am a teacher now. Are you?" Starflight frowned and shook her head.

Twilight giggled nervously. "Sunset Shimmer, meet Starflight Glimmer. My students, lovely to see you together. Starlight, can you step out of the room for a moment? Please?"

"My pleasure," she mumbled.

Twilight turned to Sunset. "Sorry about you seeing that. You weren't supposed to....I have your books. Here," she turned to the table and levitated them to her. Sunset grabbed them with her own magic.  It was very awkward. Why, why, why had she gone through?

"It's okay. Really. Is she good?"

Twilight looked up. "What?" Sunset rolled her eyes playfully. "I said, is she good? Good kisser?" Twilight blushed and looked down.

"Come on, I want to know." Sunset bumped her side. "Good, sloppy?" Twilight yelped. "Okay, she's good. Why?"

Sunset nodded and smiled. "Just wanted to know. I mean, wanted to compare." Twilight coughed. "Me? What? Compare?" Sunset patted her on the back. "Hey, Sparky. You okay?"

Twilight looked at her, face pomegranate red. "We...never kissed....unless...human counterpart....have you?"

Sunset shook her head. "Haven't. Want to?" She leaned to Twilight, and after a moment of hesitation, she leaned forward too. Their muzzles met, and a blissful feeling spread across her. Twilight's tongue poked through Sunset's mouth.

"What in Equestria IS GOING ON?!"

They turned around in shock. Starlight had come in, and boy, did she not look happy. She was fuming. "What. Are. You. Doing?" Why? What? How?

Twilight panicked. "Uh, Starlight, you are going with Sunset. Sunset, teach her. Byecomebacksoon!" She pushed them through the portal and threw the books in after. "Have a nice trip!"

"I'm gonna kill her."

~~~

Starlight looked up. "What are you?" She looked down. "What am I?" She poked her leg then poked her stomach. She looked down and saw she had clothes. Why would she be wearing clothes? She hadn't been wearing them when she went through the portal....

"You're a human. I'm a human." Sunset said. "Welcome to the human world."

Starlight stared at her and burst out laughing. "My punishment, huh? Gotta say, wasn't expecting that." She accepted the hand that pulled her up. She dusted herself off. "I mean, I destroyed a perfectly happy day and messed up the timelines. I was expecting Tartarus, but this? Not expecting it at all."

"Huh?"

Starlight looked at Sunset. "She didn't tell you? I'm evil. Which, by the way, reminds me. WHO DO YOU THINK YOU ARE STEALING MY MAREFRIEND? You want me to be evil? Oh, you won't walk away from that."

Sunset grabbed her and pushed her against the statue at an angle that wouldn't push her through the portal. Starlight yelped in surprise. "Hey!"

Sunset held her firmly. "You want to be evil? You want to be a bitch? Guess what, you're staring at the Queen of Bitches. Don't make me wake her up. Or do. I would just love that." Starlight stood still and silent. "Good. Now, one, she isn't your marefriend. Two, we call them girlfriends here. Three, when were you evil? Four, come with me and don't argue unless you want to be destroyed. We clear?" Starlight nodded and whimpered.

"K, let's go." Sunset let go of Starlight and walked off. "My motorcycle is here, but you will have to ride in the back. Here, you take the helmet." Starlight put it on her head and looked at the strange device in front of her. She walked around while observing it when she felt hands lift her up. "Right there. Hold on to me."

Starlight didn't move her hands.

Sunset rolled her eyes. "Hold on or fall off and either die or experience a whole lot of pain." Grunting, Starlight put her hands on Sunset's thin waist. Sunset shivered at the feeling and started the engine. They drove to Sunset's cramped apartment. Starlight gazed at it. "Wow," she finally said. "It's small."

Sunset nodded. "Come on. This neighborhood.....let's just say you don't want to be out at night alone and unarmed."

Starlight shivered and pulled her violet sweater around her tighter. "Ok. Let's go in. Quickly, please." Sunset nodded and turned the key in the door. The door swung open and Starlight peered into the dark. "Here we are."

They stepped in and Sunset flicked on a light switch. She then locked the door.

"Wow, this is pretty nice for being so small. Nice. But I'm a little hungry. Got any food?" Starlight asked. There was a loud banging somewhere and a shout, "GET YOUR HANDS OFFA ME, YOU LOUSY BRAINED MUTTON!" Sunset and Starlight winced.

"Come on, food is this way. You wanna sit on the couch?" Sunset pointed to the green couch with a patchy quilt. "Gift from Applejack," she added, seeing Starlight's confused look. As Starlight sat down, Sunset went to the old fridge and pulled out a cheese pizza.

"We have pizza. It's really good, too. I have four slices left, two for each of us." Sunset Sat down next to Starlight. "So, we can talk about you being evil and eat. You start."

Starlight grabbed a piece and sighed. "Well, it started when my friend Sunburst left for the school of magic. He got his cutie mark, and I didn't, at least not right away. So I enslaved my village and took their cutie marks, but really I still had mine and Twilight and her friends found out and then I had to run because I took their cutie marks too and they got them back. And then I changed Starswirl the Bearded's spell and changed time and caused horrible things but Twilight changed me." Starlight took a breath. She looked at Sunset, who was staring at her with her mouth slightly open.

"I used to be Celestia's student but then I ran away her and caused everyone pain and depression until I went back and stole Twilight's crown and she followed me here and saved me and then the Sirens attacked but no one would listen to me and everyone was fighting but I helped and they trusted me and then Twilight's human counterpart came and turned to a monster and I turned into an angel and saved her." Sunset breathed out. Starlight stared at her and slowly edged closer.

"It seems...we have a lot in common."

Bedtime Already?

Starlight glanced at the mare...woman, rather, in front of her. She was beautiful. They were the same....but different. And that was what made them strong.

Sunset looked at Starlight. Beautiful, strong...perfect. Her phone rang, making them jump. "Hello," Sunset said.

"SUNSET!" Her friends were all on the line. She checked who was calling. Rarity. Her phone rang again. Rainbow. "Hey, who all is here?" Sunset asked.

"Well, I have Pinkie and Applejack on my line." Rarity said. "Got Flutters on mine!" Rainbow said.

"Where is Twi?" Sunset asked. She didn't reply care, though. She wanted to go talk to Starlight. "Oh, she already went to bed."

"Bummer."

Sunset glanced at Starlight, who was watching intently. "Uh, hey, guys....I have to go. Talk to you tomorrow?"

"Sure. Something wrong?"

"Uh, no. Gotta go!" She hung up, leaving her friends very confused.  She returned to the couch.  "So, where were we?"

Starlight giggled. "Explaining what that was?"

Sunset laughed. "That is a communication device called a phone. You can have a number for yourself and your friends have a number, too. You type the number by pressing on the screen. You can talk to them."

Starlight Glimmer blinked. "Wow."

"Yeah. Want to know what else is wow?" Sunset said, sliding closer. Starlight shook her head. "You."

Starlight gasped. "I know. I am a horrible person. But seriously, you're really cute." Starlight leaned to her and kissed her. Sunset stiffened, but leaned in. "That was amazing," they both said.

"Again, shall we?"

They kissed, and Sunset felt something come over her. She stuck her tongue in Starlight's mouth. Starlight put her hands Sunset's breast. Sunset moaned. "Bed...Bed!"

They walked over and immediately started making out. Sunset ripped their shirts off. She lifted Starlight up enough to take off her skirt. Sunset shook off her jacket that was still on. Starlight broke the kiss and licked Sunset's neck. Sunset took off her bra. She reached around Starlight and unhooked hers.

Lust.

~~~

Sunset woke up. She was confused at first, there was someone in the bed with her. She turned to the beautiful girl beside her. Starlight twitched. "Hey, Sunset."

Sunset sighed with joy. "Hi." They kissed, and each one felt a blissful peace spread across them. That was where they belonged.