Pony Mansion Mystery

by CAPTAIN YOSHI HD

Rating: teen
Tags: Adventure, Gore, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Alternate Universe, Main 6, Thriller, Drama, Original Character, Mystery, Spike, Cutie Mark Crusaders, Starlight Glimmer
Length: 10210

The mane six, the CMC and Spike find a mansion a meets these strange ponies, figuring out one of them is the murderer.

Twilight Sparkle, Starlight Glimmer, Applejack, Rainbow Dash, Fluttershy, Pinkie Pie, Rarity, Apple Bloom, Sweetie Belle, Scootaloo, and Spike go to this mansion and meets these strange ponies named Alex Side, Iron Guitar, DYWTBA_Universe, Sir Sonic HD, Blank Check, Epic V, The Secret Dreamer, LaDix.
This is a fan fiction inspired by Minecraft Story Mode Episode 6 - A Portal To Mystery

Published 2016-11-14 00:50:02 UTC
Last updated 2016-11-14 00:50:02 UTC

Chapter 2

The group walked through the door and then down stairs to find a dining room. They walked in saw the group of strange new ponies. The yellow mare with a black and yellow mane and a power-off sign cutie mark spoke to Iron Guitar. "Hey, Iron. Who do you have with you?", she asked.

"Strange new fellows, huh?", the red stallion unicorn with grey mane and a note for a cutie mark.

Iron Guitar gathered up his friends and spoke. "Everypony, meet the princess of friendship, Twilight Sparkle, and her friends, Applejack, Fluttershy, Pinkie Pie, Rainbow Dash, Rarity, Sweetie Belle, Apple Bloom, Scootaloo, and Spike." Iron Guitar's friends weren't expecting to bring other strange ponies.

"And who are your friends?", Twilight asked.

"The yellow pegasus with the yellow and black mane is Epic V." Iron Guitar said. "And she always looks for a battle."

"How do you do?", the yellow pegasus asked.

"I'm her coltfriend, Blank Check.", the red unicorn said, introducing himself. "And I'm always looking for a job where I pay bills."

"The yellow pony with the black mane is John, a.k.a. Do You Want To Build A Universe.", Iron Guitar said. "And he always want to build his own world."

"My friends call me 'Johnny' for long.", the yellow stallion said.

"The blue pegasus with the brown mane is Dan, a.k.a. Sir Sonic HD.", Iron Guitar said. "And he always dreams about being fast."

"My friends call me Danny.", the blue pegasus said.

"The orange pony with the blue mane is The Secret Dreamer.", Iron Guitar said. "And she always wants the power to go to ponies' dreams."

"My friends call me SD.", the orange mare said.

"And the grey stallion is LaDix." Iron Guitar said. "And he's a great singer."

"My friends call me Thomas.", the grey stallion said.

"And the red unicorn is Master Max.", Iron Guitar said. "And he's the leader of the Great Legion."

"My friends just call me Max.", the other red unicorn.

"Those are strange names for ponies like you all.", Pinkie Pie said.

"Don't be rude, Pinkie.", Fluttershy said trying to defend the strange ponies. "It's because they're strange ponies doesn't mean they ARE strange."

"No no, it's ok. We do have strange names.", Johnny said.

"How long have you all lived in this mansion?", Starlight asked.

"4 years.", Blank Check said. "We made this our home."

"That's nice.", Rainbow Dash said. "Also, you know this pony, Alex Side."

"Oh yeah, we totally didn't notice he wasn't with you.", Johnny said. "Where is he?"

"He's dead.", Rainbow Dash said.

"Somepony killed him with a dart.", Apple Bloom said.

"What? That's impossible, how could that happen?", V asked.

"You know, he kind of deserved it.", Max said. Nopony like Alex, he used to insult ponies and having them to get hurt.

"How could you say that?", Thomas asked.

"I have to agree with him, he wasn't the nicest pony.", Blank Check said.

"Kind of reminds me of Trixie before she became friends with Starlight.", Twilight said. The first time when Twilight met Trixie, she was so challenging and wanting to beat her at something. And that other time, she came back and got revenge by banishing her to the Everfree Forest and keeping her friends as slaves.

"Who's Trixie?", Iron Guitar asked.

"Just some magical freak pony who always challenges Twilight to magical battles.", Applejack said.

"If you need us, me and V be at the far end of the table.", Blank Check said.

"Me and SD will be over here by the fire place.", Thomas said.

"Me and Max will be here by the bookshelf.", Iron Guitar said.

"Me and Johnny will be at the middle of the table.", Danny said.

"So, what should we do?", Fluttershy asked.

"I'll ask these ponies questions.", Spike said. "Looks like it's time for Detective Spike to be on the case." He walked over to Blank Check and V. "Hello Blank Check and Epic V."

"Hi.", Blank and V said.

"Mind if I ask you both a few questions?", Spike asked.

"That's no problem at all.", Blank Check said.

"Yeah, I wouldn't talking to a sweet little dragon like you.", V said as she patted Spike on the head.

Spike blushed. "Thanks for the complement.", he said. "Speaking of which, was there drama between Johnny and Alex?"

"I shouldn't get involved in that, now that he's dead.", Blank Check said.

"Yeah, there is something strange going around here.", V said. "I mean, this is a mansion, mansions are supposed to be strange. Not like I'm talking about rumors about this place."

"Epic V, you were pretty upset about Alex getting into anypony's business."

"Oh dear.", V said with a surprised look. "Was I?"

"Yes.", Spike said. "Why?"

"Well, it's just so insufferable.", V said with a groan. "It just happened, and he was curious about what was going on with him. He was just mad, maybe."

"Have any ideas on why would somepony kill Alex?", Spike asked.

"Well, he was grumpy at times.", V said. "You have to ask other people about that."

"I don't want to make it too hard or say something mean about a pony who wants to defend themselves." Blank Check said. But, you met him right, he doesn't get along with anypony easily."

"Well, thanks for the time, guys.", Spike said walking away from the couple.

"Any time, boy-o.", V said.

"Good luck.", Blank Check said.

Spike approached the others. "Got any ideas from them.", Starlight asked.

"Yep, this group is keeping a whole lot of secrets from each other."

"Definitely something.", Rainbow Dash said in a tough voice.

"Looks like I have to talk to Thomas and SD.", Spike said. He walked over to SD and Thomas. "Hello, Thomas and SD. Mind if I ask you a few questions."

"Sure, no problem.", SD said.

"I'm down.", Thomas said.

"Do you have any idea who would want to kill Alex?", Spike asked.

"I never had that problem before, actually.", Thomas said. "But, I know other ponies who did. I hate to say it, but, he was kind of a griefer."

"Yeah, and a douche bag.", SD said. She is lucky that Alex was still alive to hear that.

"Oh really.", Spike said. "And SD you were pretty curious about what was going on with Alex. What's wrong with that?"

"Well, he was a notorious douche bag.", SD said. "I was only curious about what's wrong with him."

"I see.", Spike said. "You know, something tells me that Johnny and Alex don't get along. What's going between those two?"

"Oh yeah, I completely forgot about that.", Thomas said. "Such a shame."

"He broke into his room and accused Johnny furiously, because he was thinking that Johnny was trying to spread rumors about him that aren't true.", SD said explaining the story. "But, he knows that he never did that."

"Does he accuse every single pony in this mansion?", Spike asked.

"Nah, he doesn't get accusive these days.", Thomas said. "Now that he's gone, no more accusing from him."

"Thanks for the answers guys.", Spike said.

"No problem.", Thomas said.

"Any time, Spikey-boy.", SD said.

Spike left the two and went up to his friends.

"Did you get anything from?", Fluttershy asked.

"Yeah, Alex was a douche bag or a griefer.", Spike said. "SD said he accused Johnny for spreading rumors about him that aren't true, even though, he didn't."

"So, Alex and Johnny don't get along very well.", Apple Bloom said.

"No they don't.", Spike said. "Alright now to ask Danny and Johnny some questions. Oh, before I do so, let me tell something to Epic V and Blank Check." Spike walked up to the couple for the second time. "Guys, Apple Bloom told me that she talked to Thomas, and he said he's curious."

"Ha. Good to know.", Blank Check said.

"That's all, guys.", Spike said. "Sorry I made this short."

"No worries, Spike.", V said.

"Thanks, Spike.", Blank Check said. He now walked over to Danny and Johnny. "Hey, Johnny. Hey, Danny."

"Hey, what's going on?", Danny said greeting the little dragon.

"Hey, Spike.", Johnny said.

"Mind if I ask you a few questions?", Spike asked.

"Sure, why not?", Johnny said.

"Yeah, I don't mind at all, really."

"So, do you have any idea why ponies are curious about why Alex Side's all moody?", Spike asked.

"We don't go into his business like everyday, but, sometimes he can get into ours.", Danny said.

"That's true, but, he was targeted by that trap that happened earlier.", Spike said. "Why would somepony do that?"

"He always brags about him being the best pony.", Danny said.

"He would never tell anypony why.", Johnny said.

"What is it that makes him the best?", Spike asked.

"We don't know, exactly.", Johnny said.

"You know, Johnny, you're always hating on Alex.", Spike said. "What's the big deal about that?"

"Well, didn't you met him?", Johnny asked. "Nopony liked him."

"Definately, he wasn't really the nicest pony.", Danny said.

"Why did you ask that?", Johnny asked.

"I talked to Thomas and SD and said that he came upon you and confronted you about spreading rumors about him that aren't true.", Spike said explaining the conversation between him, Thomas and SD.

"Oh, yeah, he did do that.", Johnny said. "He made me feel really guilty about, even though I didn't. Then, I talked to Iron Guitar to take care of the situation. Usually, Iron Guitar is really good at taking care of situations."

"Hold on, is Iron Guitar the leader of this group?", Spike asked.

"Yep, he sure is.", Danny said.

"Get out of town.", Spike said thinking that the blue Pegasus is joking.

"We're serious.", Danny said being honest.

"Alright, I believe you.", Spike said.

"Speaking of which, are you sure you talked to Thomas and SD about what happened between me and Alex?", Johnny asked.

"Yes.", Spike said. "Why?"

"You do not want to talk to Thomas too much.", Danny said. "He's like the blabber mouth."

Danny and Spike giggled, then they heard Thomas shout to them. "Hey, what did you say?!", he said.

They both gasped and Danny put a hoof to Spike's mouth. "Nothing.", he said.

"Yeah right.", Thomas said not believing the giggling two.

"What? We didn't.", Danny said trying to lie again.

Danny removed his hoof from Spike's mouth. "Whoo, that was close.", Spike said.

"Yeah, it sure was.", Danny said agreeing with the small dragon.

"Well, that's all for now.", Spike said. "See you two later."

"Thanks.", Johnny said.

"What he said.", Danny said.

Johnny: "We'll be right here if you want to come back, Spike.", Johnny said.

Spike walked and walked up to his friends.

"Did you find anything?", Applejack asked.

"Yeah.", Spike said. "For some reason, Alex likes to get into ponies' business. And Johnny told me that Iron Guitar is the leader of this group."

"Really, how long?", Apple Bloom asked.

"I don't know.", Spike said. "But, once I talk to Iron Guitar and Max, we'll know." He walked up to Max and Iron Guitar. "Greetings, IG and Max."

"Hello.", Iron Guitar said.

"What's up?", Max asked.

"I need to ask you some questions.", Spike said.

"Oh really, what do you need to know?", Max asked.

"Iron Guitar, how long have you been the leader of this group?", Spike asked.

"Five years.", Iron Guitar said. "How did you?"

"I talked to Johnny and Danny.", Spike said. "Also, I heard you're good at solving ponies' problems. Like when Alex accused of Johnny of spreading rumors about him that aren't true, even though he didn't do that. Why would he do something like that?"

"That is true, he did accuse Johnny of that.", Iron Guitar. "But, I took good care of it. Every time when Alex causes trouble, then I have to talk to him."

"And every time when he thinks somepony did something wrong to him, he's got to get upset about it.", Max said.

"Is that like one way for him?", Spike asked.

"He thinks it is.", Max asked.

"Is there anymore you want to ask us?", Iron Guitar asked curious.

"Nah.", Spike said. "That's about it. See you."

"Thanks.", Iron Guitar said.

"Ta Ta for now.", Max said.

Spike walked up to his friends.

"Hey, did you get anything from Fapster Max?", Starlight asked.

"Master Max?", Spike said correcting Starlight.

"Yeah, that's what I meant.", Starlight said. "Did you get anything from them?"

"Yeah, they told me every time when Alex thinks somepony did something wrong to him, he's got to get upset about it.", Spike said. "And every time when he causes trouble, Iron Guitar has to talk to him.

"Wow, guess there was a lot of things we never knew about Alex.", Applejack said.

"So, Alex Side was a notorious douche bag, he gets upset if he thinks somepony did something mean to him, Iron Guitar has to talk to him every time when he causes trouble.", Spike said. "But, I don't think that's about it, there's got to be something missing here."

"I think I could help you with situation.", Iron Guitar said approaching the mane group.

"How long has Alex been like he was before he got killed?", Starlight asked.

"He's been like he was for a while.", Iron Guitar said. "He thinks he's better at everything, and every time when somepony in our team did something, he has to take credit for it."

"If he's a bad pony, could he be working for somepony?", Pinkie Pie asked.

"Maybe, well-- Wait, what?", Iron Guitar said confused. He raised an eyebrow. "No, why would you ask that?"

"We met a lot of bad ponies who were in Ponyville.", Twilight added.

"Really, like who?", Iron Guitar asked.

"Well, we dealt with Trixie, Queen Chrysalis, King Sombra, and Tirek.", Applejack said.

Iron Guitar: "I don't think we know those ponies."

"Whoa, whoa, whoa.", Rainbow Dash said. "How do you not know them, didn't you live in Ponyville before you and your gang moved here."

"Me and my gang lived in a dimension before coming to this mansion.", Iron Guitar said. "There's a key that can open a portal back to that dimension where we used to live. We needed to leave that dimension, because I planned to go on an adventure, then we lost it. So, we decided to live here."

Apple Bloom remembered that she found that strange looking key on the ground before they got in. "Hey, I actually found it.", she said.

"Really, you found it?", Iron Guitar asked surprised.

Apple Bloom tried to reveal the key. "I assume you--" But Iron Guitar grabbed her arm to stop her. "No wait!", he said with a warning. "You shouldn't take that out, not while everypony's around. The murderer might want that. Everypony, take a seat around the table."

Iron Guitar and Spike sat at the left end of the table and the others sat at the other seats, the others sat at the sides of the table.

"If you guys don't know yet, there's a murderer here and whoever it is, it's after the key to our dimension where we used to live.", Iron Guitar said. Then, all of sudden, Iron Guitar's chair tipped over, part of the floor opened, and he fell into a fan. Iron Guitar's body disintegrated.

Fluttershy screamed and fainted. The lights went out, everypony panicked. "Oh no, here it goes again!", Rarity screamed.

"I can't see!", V panicked.

"V, I got you, Sweetie.", Blank Check said.

"Am I stepping on hair?", Scootaloo asked.

"Excuse me, that's my tail.", Johnny said.

"Oops. Sorry.", Scootaloo said.

"Panic! Panic! Panic! Panic! Panic!", Max exclaimed.

"Somepony get the lights!", Spike said.

A blue light flashed, there were floating glowing pumpkins. Then, they saw the suited pony with a white pumpkin head on the wall. "Greetings, ponies.", the creature said. "I am the white pumpkin. To any of you who has the dimensional key, you must bring it to me, so I don't have to kill you all." The lights turned off again. Once they turned back on, the monster disappeared.

"He killed Iron Guitar!", SD screamed.

"No! No! No! We've got to get out of here! I don't know what's going on!", Max panicked.

"I'm too cute to die!", V screamed.

"And I'm too handsome to die!", Thomas screamed.

"We got to get out of here!", Danny screamed.

"And there's no such thing as white pumpkins.", Johnny said.

"Everypony run!", Blank Check screamed.

"Everypony, calm down!", Rainbow Dash said trying to calm the group down. The others weren't listening. "They're not listening to me, Twilight."

"I know, we just need to find this white pumpkin.", Twilight said.

"And, how is it so real?", Sweetie Belle asked. "There's no such thing as white pumpkins."

"There's booby traps in this mansion!", Max exclaimed.

"There's got to be a way out of here!", Johnny screamed.

"Everypony, out the door.", Danny said. He ran to the exit door, then they heard scream from him. "AHHHHHHHHH! MANTICORE!" The ponies ran to the exit door and saw a manticore just outside the door. Danny shook and tried to reach the close button, but, he was too scared to move.

"SOMEPONY, CLOSE THE DOOR!", Twilight screamed. Spike ran for the button, and pressed it before the beast would get in.

"Danny, are you ok?", Thomas asked.

"Yeah, I'm fine.", Danny said.

"OK, something strange is literally going on.", Apple Bloom said.

"What's strange?", Sweetie Belle said. "The manticore or the pictures in that room?"

"Wait! Did you say 'pictures'?", Scootaloo asked.

The ponies walked into the room and saw pictures of Thomas, Johnny, Danny, Epic V, Blank Check, SD, Max, Iron Guitar, and Alex Side. "The pictures of Iron Guitar and Alex had red X's on them.", Starlight said.

"There are pictures... of them." ,Rarity said.

"This is so weird.", Fluttershy said.

"Should we check in that room?", Applejack said.

The ponies walked into the other room and they saw a large picture of the mane six and Spike, but, didn't include Starlight. "Wow, look at that picture.", Twilight said.

"It's us!", Pinkie Pie said.

"And I'm not included in that picture.", Starlight said.

"We shot that picture before we met you, Starlight.", Rainbow Dash said.

"And look at that one!", Scootaloo said.

Then they saw a picture of the CMC. Apple Bloom stepped away from the picture and shook with fear. Applejack stood next to her and patted her on the back. "It's alright, little sis.", she said. "Nothing bad is going to happen to you, as long as I'm here."

Rarity did the same. "Don't you worry, Sweetie.", she said. "I'll have you safe and sound with me."

Rainbow Dash was concerned about Scootaloo. "You're not scared, are you?", she asked.

"Of course not, I'm always the daring one.", Scootaloo said.

"That's nice, but, we need to figure out who that white pumpkin is.", V said.

"We know.", Spike said. "We just need to find evidence that has to do with it. And I have a plan, Scootaloo and RD, you go back to the kitchen and find something that caused that trap to happen. And it looks like it's time for me to interrogate some ponies. But, I'm only going to interrogate three of you. And I choose Johnny, Blank Check, and SD." Blank, Johnny, and SD gulped and stepped forward.

Twilight wasn't sure if she likes the idea. "Um... Spike, don't you think it's a little bit immature to interrogate ponies."

"Trust me, Twi.", Spike said. "It's just for the evidence."

"Which pony are you going to pick first?", Applejack asked.

"The first one I'm interrogating... is Blank Check.", Spike said pointing at Blank Check.

"You're accusing my coltfriend?!", V asked in a shocked way.

"V, calm down.", Twilight said trying to calm V down. "He's not accusing anypony, he just need some answers."

"And, is there any room where we can talk?", Spike asked.

"There's a library next door.", Danny said pointing at a door on the right.

"That could work.", Spike said winking at Danny.

They both walked into the library where there's books all around, seats and a fireplace. Blank took his seat. "Spike, I know there's been a lot of talk today, but I'm not a killer, I would never hurt V, I love her."

"Well, how long have you two known each other?", Spike asked.

"For a while, we done a lot of things together.", Blank Check said. "We talk, we tickle each other, we do stupid stuff, and we go out for picnics. I'll did what was make her happy, and we have keep ourselves together. Otherwise, I'll lose her."

"Well, do you know anything about poison darts?", Spike asked.

"Yes, they're deadly, they're useful, but never used one before.", Blank Check said. "Johnny told me how to make them, Then, I told Thomas and Danny how to make them as well."

"One last question: who do you think stole a key?", Spike asked.

"I don't know, maybe Alex.", Blank Check said. "He could a stealer at times. But, if I had a key, I would take V for long walks on the beach or do stuff there for the second time."

"Have you ever went to the beach?, Spike asked.

"Yeah, where there's a lot of water and sunshine.", Blank Check said. "Oh, and that one time me and Thomas buried V in the sand up to her chest."

"Sounds fun, me and my best friends did it to Twilight once.", Spike said. "And there's always water there, pretend it was a replacement."

"With what?", Blank Check asked.

"I don't know, there's sometimes eighty fillies in it at a time crapping.", Spike said.

"Then, the replacement would be poop, that doesn't look like a very accurate beach.", Blank Check said. "You know, me and SD have been competing on where to find it and who gets to use it. If you want to talk to a great competitive, I'd talk to her."

"Thanks for your time.", Spike said. "Oh, and send SD in here."

Blank got off his seat. "Your very welcome, Spike.", he said. He paused faced Spike again. "Hold on, about the beach conversation, did you say you and your friends buried Twilight in the sand once?"

"Yeah.", Spike answered. "Why?"

"How did she react?", Blank Check asked.

"Oh, we put a lot of sand on her.", Spike said. "She got so scared." He and Blank Check started laughing.

Twilight peeked her head in. "I heard that.", she said. "I wasn't scared, and that wasn't a lot of sand."

"OK, I take it back.", Spike said. "We didn't put a lot of sand on her, we only got up to her chest, and she fell asleep once we got started. That's about it, you can go."

"Alright.", Blank Check said. "Thanks again." He turned away from Spike and head out the door.

SD came in with a nervous look on her face. "I'm telling you, Spike, you got the wrong mare, honest.", she pleaded. "I would never hurt anypony. If anypony's been wronged here, it's me. And about that key, Iron Guitar uses it when we travel. Max told us somepony stole from us."

"Oh, really.", Spike said. "But, do you think that Alex is a douche bag is actually true?"

"It IS true, why would you think Alex isn't?", SD asked. "When you met him, he was yelling at you. He often doesn't get along with guests in this mansion. And Blank being so jealous of me being competitive of where the key is. I'm not a killer, you have to believe me."

"Well, do you know anything about poison darts?", Spike asked.

"Of course not, I've never seen anything like that before.", SD said.

"So, you using poisonous darts as weapons don't ring a bell?", Spike asked.

"Yep, no bell.", SD said. "And have you talked to Johnny yet? He loves using those types of weapons. And you should talk to him, he's a weaponry champion."

"Sounds nice, does he use amazing stuff?", Spike asked.

"Of course he does.", SD said.

"I bet you know who stole the key.", Spike said.

"I'm not good at accusing ponies.", SD said. "But, the two ponies I would accuse are Johnny and Blank."

"You can go now.", Spike said.

"Thanks for your time, Spike.", SD said. "And I'll send Johnny in here."

SD turned away from Spike and walked out. Johnny walked in the room with a nervous look on his face. "Spike, I'm telling you, this is crazy.", Johnny said. "Totally a misunderstanding." He took a seat.

"I don't want any lies, Johnny.", Spike said.

"Spike, listen, I maybe a weaponry champion, but, I would never kill any of my friends.", Johnny said.

"SD told me you would like to take keys from ponies.", Spike said.

"Well, keys are useful.", Johnny said. "But, I never steal it from anypony."

Spike gave Johnny a stern glare.

"Please, Spike.", Johnny pleaded. "Tell me what's on your mind."

"Do you anything about poison darts?", Spike asked.

"Nope, never seen anything like it before.", Johnny said. "You would have to talk to Blank about that, he's good about weaponry history. He can barely teach a class."

"That's cool.", Spike said. "By the way, who do you think took the key?"

"I not good knowing who stole something.", Johnny said. "Blank was the one who wanted that key and SD got pissed about it. I think he made up that story just to make everypony think we don't have it anymore."

"You're excused, Johnny.", Spike said.

"Thank you, Spike.", Johnny said. "I'm glad you said that, because this room is freaking me out." He walked out the door.

Spike stood by the fireplace, Fluttershy came in and walked up to the baby purple dragon. "Hey, Spike.", she said.

"Hey, Fluttershy.", Spike said.

"Did you really think interrogating those ponies was a great idea?", Fluttershy asked.

"It was the only way to get answers, I had to.", Spike said.

"You did a great job, Spike.", Fluttershy said.

Spike smiled. "Thank you.", he said "Now, lets go back out with the others."

They both walked out of the library. The rest of the ponies saw Spike. "Please don't tell me it's Blank Check.", V said hopefully.

"Did you figure out who's the white pumpkin?", Max asked.

"SD explained a lot of things in there.", Blank Check said.

"Blank was in there longer.", SD said.

"Everypony calm down, only I get to choose.", Spike said. "I would like to thank you all for answering my questions. So, the pony I'm suspecting... Blank Check."

Everypony gasped. "WHAT!?", V said.

"No way. No freaking way. Are you serious right now?!", Blank Check said.

"You're going to make them torture my coltfriend?! ARE YOU KIDDING ME!?", V said shouting at her own friends.

"If there's a prison in here, I say lock him in the library.", Pinkie Pie said.

Rarity: "PINKIE PIE!", Rarity said.

"Whoops.", Pinkie Pie said.

"I agree with that.", Thomas said.

"Guys, I can't be it.", Blank Check said. "There's got to be something else we can do."

"We're really sorry, Blank.", Danny said. "But, we can't take any chances."

Danny and his friends (except for V) walked with Blank into the library and locked him up. V was heartbroken.

"I can't believe you accused him like that!", V said as tears ran down her eyes. "You're the worst."

"V, it's not the end of the world.", Twilight said calming V down. "It's just what Spike ordered."

"I don't care what you say!", V said releasing her loud voice at Twilight. "I wish he was the white pumpkin, we would totally lock him up in a prison with a group of bears." She walked out of the room with a sad look on her face.

Rarity was shocked. "HEY! Nopony makes threats towards my little Spikey-wikey.", she said trying to defend Spike. "He would never murder anypony."

"Let it go, Rarity.", Spike said. "I did what I needed to do."

"But, why did you suspect Blank like that, Spike?", Rarity asked. "It was kind of... mean."

"I needed to make a guess.", Spike said.

"If the killer was around here, he would kill us to.", Applejack said. "We need to figure out how these traps work."

Scootaloo and Rainbow Dash ran into the room. "Girls, we found evidence.", Scootaloo said. "There was a button underneath the table, and the white pumpkin thing was an inflatable replica hanging on a rope."

"That's nice, but, how are we going to figure out the trap that triggered Alex Side?", Sweetie Belle asked.

"It must've been triggered near by.", Spike said.

"We should probably investigate that trap then.", Rainbow Dash said.

"You guys go on ahead, I'll stick with these ponies.", Sweetie Belle said.

The others (except for Blank) walked out of the library.

"You mean us?", Thomas asked.

"Sure, you all don't mind being with my little sister, do you?", Rarity asked with a grin.

"No problem.", SD said.

The others looked around the room, but, V was nowhere to be seen. "Where's V?", Danny asked.

"Outside the room on that door.", Applejack said. "She was upset about Spike suspecting Blank in front of everypony."

Danny faced the ground and sighed.

"What's wrong, Danny?", Max asked.

"It's my fault.", Danny said. "I'm the one who got V upset by putting Blank in the library by himself, I'll go talk to her and fix things up."

"We'll see you in a bit, Sweetie Belle.", Twilight said.

"OK.", Sweetie Belle said.

Spike and his friends went back into the kitchen where Alex was killed.

"Um... what are we looking for?", Fluttershy asked.

"There are too many loose ends flying around - a lot of evidence that doesn't add up.", Spike said. "We need to find concrete evidence."

"No problem, I'm looking out for it.", Fluttershy said.

Spike walked over to a group of ovens "These ovens have been busy since we got here.", Spike said. "Who needs that much food?" He walked over to a strange painting and saw eyeholes on it. "Does this painting have eyeholes?"

Twilight turned around and saw them. "Oh yeah.", Twilight said. "How did I not see them?"

"I guess somepony was using it for an inspection.", Rainbow Dash said.

"What happens if I take it off the wall?", Spike said.

"Hmm... I don't know.", Applejack said. "Try it and see what there is."

Spike took the painting off the wall and saw a passage. "A passage, let's see where it takes us.", he said.

"Spike, wait.", Twilight said. "I found a lever."

"Oh really.", Spike said. "I think that is what caused Alex to get killed."

"Pull it see what happens.", Scootaloo suggested. "But, let's make sure nopony is near that trap."

Spike pulled the lever and poison darts darted from the trap.

"Ah, so that's what happened.", Rarity said.

"You know, girls, this passage might be where the white pumpkin is getting around the mansion.", Spike said examining the passage.

"I'm with Spike on this one, let's go.", Rarity said.

Spike and the ponies walked through the whole passage, there were ladders and stairs. Then, Rainbow Dash thought about Blank Check. "I hope Blank Check is alright.", she said. "I feel really bad when I saw his own friends lock him in the library."

"Unless he is the white pumpkin.", Pinkie Pie said.

"In that case, we're all keeping everypony safe.", Fluttershy said.

"Pretty much.", Apple Bloom said.

"And I do hope we're finding what we're looking for.", Scootaloo said.

They all turned and saw a back of a painting with eyeholes.

"What do you think it is?", Starlight asked.

Rainbow Dash turned to her right and saw a lever. "No clue.", she said. "Hey look, a lever, let's pull it and see what happens."

"Rainbow, stop.", Twilight said warning the blue Pegasus. "We should touch stuff we don't know."

"Oh yeah, right.", Rainbow Dash said. "Sorry."

Spike walked to the painting and peeked his eyes through the holes.

"See anything yet?", Rarity asked.

"It's the library.", Spike said.

Spike looked around and saw Blank Check sitting on a chair. He gasped.

"What is it, What do you see?", Applejack asked.

"I see Blank locked up in there.", Spike said. "And I see more traps."

"What traps are there?", Scootaloo asked.

"A lava trap and two dart dispensers.", Spike said.

Johnny came in the library, checking on the red unicorn.

"Johnny, what are you doing here?", Blank Check asked.

"I stuck in past that small white unicorn, Sweetie Belle, I think.", Johnny said. "We need to talk."

"OK, what do you want to talk about.", Blank Check said.

"I know you pushed the button.", Johnny said. "Sweetie Belle told us everything."

"No, I would never do anything like that.", Blank Check said.

"It's ok, it was only an accident.", Johnny said. "I'm still your friend."

"Thanks for cheering me up.", Blank Check said. "And, yeah it was an accident."

Then, Spike saw glowing yellow eyes from another painting with eyeholes by the door. The glowing eyes saw Spike's eyes, then he gasped.

"Spike, what else is in there?", Twilight asked.

"The white pumpkin, he's in there.", Spike said.

"Let's go kick his butt.", Rainbow Dash said with a confident voice.

Spike punched the painting and they all ran into the library.

"Whoa!", Blank Check said. "What's going on here?"

"The white pumpkin, he's in here.", Spike said warning the two strange ponies.

"Where is he?", Johnny asked. "I don't see him."

Then, a trap door open in the fireplace, spiders came crawling out. A group of bars surrounded the door.

"What's happening in there?", Fluttershy asked behind the door.

The fireplace opened and spiders crawled in the library. "There's spiders everywhere!", Spike said. He ran to the painting where the white pumpkin was and broke it down.

"Why you little--", the White Pumpkin shouted.

Then, spiders jumped on Johnny, he screamed as the black creatures attacked him. Then, he was gone. "Johnny!", Spike screamed.

"Whadda shame.", the White Pumpkin said. "Gotta run."

The white monster ran off into the fireplace.

"You all deal with the spiders, I'm going after that monster.", Spike said. He ran into the fireplace where there was a secret passage. He ran to his left, then he took a right, then he took another left. Then, there were stairs, he ran up them and went into a pitch black room. Spike shook with fear. "Hello,... is there anypony in here?" The lights flashed on, then he saw the white pumpkin. He jumped on the creature and the pumpkin fell off the head. He looked down to look at the murderers face, it was Sweetie Belle. He gasped.

"Sweetie Belle?!", Spike said with a surprised tone.

"Spike, I'm glad you're here.", Sweetie Belle said. "That was strange wasn't it?"

"Sweetie Belle...?", Spike said.

"What?", Sweetie Belle asked.

"YOUR THE MURDERER?!", Spike asked, yelling.

"What?! No!", Sweetie Belle said. "He found me and stuffed this pumpkin on my head."

"Nice story, but, you should put it down before somepony notices.", Spike said.

Max, Thomas, Blank, V, SD, the mane seven, and the two crusaders arrived. The generous white unicorn saw her own sister holding the pumpkin with her magic.

"What's going on here?", Max asked.

Rarity saw her sister holding the mask. "Sweetie Belle?!", she said.

"You caught the white pumpkin!", Thomas yelled.

"No I didn't, the monster found my friend and stuffed the pumpkin on her head.", Spike said trying to explain.

"Please don't touch my sister, she never hurts anypony!", Rarity said trying to plead the others.

"That doesn't match up.", Danny said. "Blank, you saw those spiders kill Johnny, right?"

"Of course I did, so I can't be the white pumpkin.", Blank Check said.

"It's the facts, Spike, she pushed that button at the table.", SD said. "This all happened when your friends came here. And now Johnny's gone.

"I say we tie her up and cook her alive.", Danny said.

"Whoa! Whoa! Whoa!", Thomas said. "Are you saying we should eat her?"

"No, you're not doing that to my friend's sister.", Spike said.

"He's right, I am not eating no filly!", V said. "What do you think this is, we all going to be cannibals now?"

"Yeah, and Spike's friends did save me.", Blank Check said. "And most of all, I am not going to eat, Sweetie Belle."

Rarity sighed with relief. "Thank you, Blank Check, Darling.", she said hugging the red unicorn.

"No problem.", Blank Check said.

Danny sighed with frustration. "Fine, we'll let her live.", Danny said.

Sweetie Belle sighed with relief. "Thank you!", Sweetie Belle said.

Danny still glared at the little white filly. "But, we still got to do something about you.", He said.

"Like what, lock her in a closet?", Pinkie Pie asked sarcastically.

"PINKIE PIE, you're on their side now!?", Twilight yelled with shock.

"Nah, I'm just joking.", Pinkie Pie said.

"That sounds great.", Danny said.

"No, wait. I didn't mean "really" lock her in the closet.", Pinkie Pie said. "I take it back."

"Too late for that, no take backs.", Danny said. "I keeping guard of her, because I still don't trust her."

"Don't worry, Spike, I'll watch her.", Starlight said. "And you're coming with me as well, Sir Sonic."

"Call me 'Danny'.", Danny said.

"Doesn't matter what I get to call you.", Starlight said.

"Says the pony who was once a villain.", Starlight said.

"Don't remind me.", Starlight said.

"Yeah, and quiet.", Danny said. "Prisoners aren't supposed to talk."

Starlight, Sweetie Belle, and Danny walked out together. Now, Sweetie Belle's in dead meat.

"Great! Starlight and Danny have my little sister hostage, and we found a room we haven't been in yet!", Rarity yelled.

"Rarity, calm yourself, we just need to clear her name.", Apple Bloom said.

"My plan is: we interrogate them until they crack.", Spike said.

"Good one, Spike.", Scootaloo said.

Spike walked over to a couch and sat with Blank, V, SD, Max, and Thomas.

"What do you want?", V asked.

"Hey, I thought we were cool now, you were on my side earlier.", Spike said.

"True, but, I still don't trust you after you accused Blank.", V said.

"I know Spike thought I was the white pumpkin, but, Spike did save my life.", Blank Check said. "We should all trust him, he's a hero."

"Well, I don't think he is.", V said.

"V, if you're not going to trust him, then leave and stay out of this.", SD said.

"Fine!", V said. She got off the couch and left the group.

"You are innocent, Blank.", Spike said. "But, I still think you're a suspect, SD."

"Honestly now?", SD asked.

"Where were you when I was chasing the white pumpkin?", Spike asked.

"I was singing in a corner hugging my back-hooves in my face, humming to myself.", SD said. "It calms me down."

"Thanks for your time, guys.", Spike said. He got off the couch and walked over to V.

"If you got a question for me, spit it out.", V said.

"Were you suspicious about Sweetie Belle being the murderer?", Spike asked.

"Not really suspicious AS Sweetie Belle."

"Where were you when I was chasing the white pumpkin?", Spike said.

"Drinking water, I get thirsty when I'm nervous.", V said.

"Don't go anywhere.", Spike said.

"I won't.", V said

Spike turned and saw a painting of the white pumpkin. He walked over to it and broke it down. Behind the painting, there was another secret passage.

"Another passage.", Spike said. "You all stay here, I'll go myself."

"No, I like to come with you, I want to see what else that little brat has planned.", Thomas said.

Rarity's face turned red and slapped Thomas in the face. "HOW DARE YOU INSULT MY SISTER!", she yelled furiously.

"Rarity, calm down.", Twilight said.

"Calm down?", Rarity said. "My sister has been taken hostage because of that monster!"

"That's why Spike's going in there to find out the murderer is.", Fluttershy said.

"Don't worry, guys, I'll be fine.", Spike said. "I'll be back when I find evidence."

Spike started running through the passage.

Twilight watched and worried. "Be careful, Spike.", she said.

Chapter 3

Meanwhile, Spike was shaking in fear. He looked around where he was heading. He hears echos of his footsteps, and strange echos out of nowhere. "Don't worry, Spike.", he said. "It's just a cave, there's no need to be afraid of." He walked to his left and heard hoofsteps from behind him. He tried to peek behind a corner, but, he was too afraid. "It must b-be him." He got prepared to strike for the monster, he sprung out of the corner, yelling, with his claws preparing to attack. But, it wasn't the white pumpkin, it was Rarity. She screamed at Spike's jumpscare. Spike was surprised. "Rarity, what are you doing here?", he asked.

"I wanted to help you.", Rarity said.

"Help me?", he asked. "Didn't I tell you wait with the others? I needed to do this alone."

"Yes, but... , I just worried about Sweetie Belle.", Rarity said.

Spike walked with Rarity through the passage. "Rarity, I know you're worried about your sister.", Spike said. "But, it's ok, I'll find evidence if I find the white pumpkin's lair."

"Thank you, Spike.", Spike said. "And I'm sorry that I went after you, even though, you told me to stay with the others."

"No worries, Rarity.", Spike said. "At least, I am here alone... with you." He stroked under Rarity's chin.

Rarity giggled. "Hehehehehe stop hahahaha very ticklish."

Then, they both heard hoofsteps.

"Rarity, how are you making those hoofstep noise without moving your hooves?", Spike asked.

Rarity looked down at her hooves. "My hooves aren't doing anything.", she said. "I say it's your tiny little feet."

Spike looked at his feet. "My feet aren't doing anything.", he said.

They turned around and saw a shadow of a pony. "The white pumpkin.", Spike said.

"He heard us.", Spike said.

They both walked slowly back to that corner, and prepared to strike at the creature. They both screamed then try to attack the strange pony, then they saw Max standing in front of them screaming. Max was holding something with his magic until he dropped after the dragon and the unicorn tried to attack him.

"Max?", Spike asked.

"You two, what's the big idea?", Max asked. "You trying to give me a heart attack?"

"We thought you were the white pumpkin.", Rarity said.

Max picked the thing that he was holding back up, Spike and Rarity saw that the object was the portal key. "Max, is that the key?", Spike asked.

"Yes it is.", Max said. "I stole it."

"You stole it from your own group?", Rarity asked.

"Yes, and this was what I wanted to tell you.", Max said. "And I'm not the white pumpkin, I was just trying to prank my group. Also, I wanted it to be harmless."

"So it's your fault?", Spike said.

"No, I just wanted to keep it a secret for a while.", Max said. "Also, I was keeping it safe from the white pumpkin. Remember what Iron Guitar said? He's after this."

"I think you should give it back to Blank.", Spike said.

"Yeah, I think that will be the best option.", Max said.

"Well, why didn't come in the library if you had it?", Rarity asked.

"I was terrified, I didn't want my friends to get upset at me if I told them I had it.", Max said.

"Well, you are lucky that I didn't pick you then you would just lie to me about it.", Spike said. "C'mon, let's finish this mission."

The three walked together until they found a door. They walked through it and saw blue banners with Danny on it, and there was one chest.

"Wow, look at these banners.", Rarity said. "And why do they say "Sir Sonic HD" on them?"

"We normally call him 'Danny', his real name is 'Sir Sonic HD'."

"Yeah, Iron Guitar did say what his name was, didn't he?", Spike asked.

"Yeah.", Rarity said. "But, can we see what's in that chest?"

Spike walked over to the chest and opened it up. He looked inside a grabbed a picture of himself.

"Is this my picture of me with an x on it?", Spike asked.

"I think so, Spike.", Rarity said. "Look what else is in there."

Spike looked inside again and saw a bunch of paintings with x's on them. "It's pictures of all of us in this mansion, but, I can't find Danny's picture.", Spike said.

"Well, didn't you see the those pictures of our and friends and Sweetie Belle's friends.", Rarity asked. "There were groups in one picture each. If there is one pony left out of the pictures with x's on them, that must mean one of us is the White Pumpkin."

"This must be easy to solve.", Max said. "Who do you think the white pumpkin is?"

Spike thought for a second and realized something. He finally knows who the White Pumpkin is. "The white pumpkin... is Danny.", he said.

"If he's the white pumpkin,... then he might kill our friends and MY LITTLE SISTER!", Rarity said.

"We have to go back to the others.", Spike said. They all ran out of the lair.

Chapter 1

The skies was black with a group of rain clouds, a flock of hawks soared through. A bolt of thunder crashed on a roof of a mansion. It was called "The Mansion of the Strange Ponies", it was abandoned for a thousand years until a group of ponies found it. One of ponies has a secret lair under the house, nothing but dangerous creatures lived in that place. For a while, one of those ponies are planning a secret attack and finding a way to go back to it's real home.

Meanwhile, the Mane Six, the CMC, Starlight Glimmer and Spike were walking to that place for a visit. The cutie marks of the rest of the mane six glowed and told them where they needed to go and they decided to take Spike, Starlight and the CMC with them. They stopped and took a look at the mansion, they weren't sure if they want to go in yet.

"Is it abandoned?", Fluttershy asked. She was too nervous to go into that mansion.

"I don't know, Fluttershy." Twilight said. "I did look at this in a book, I figured we should check it out."

"You seem really confident about this whole adventure." Twilight said. "And I do agree with you we should check it out."

"If there was any danger in that mansion, I'm your pony.", Rainbow Dash. Back in the day, she thought she would act tough when she and her friends were in the abandoned library where Celestia and Luna used to be at.

"I think you should let Fluttershy do the work, Rainbow.", Applejack said. "She could tame them."

"But, if there are zombies in that mansion. They could easily eat her.", Rarity said. She has a big fear of zombies eating her alive. One time, she had a dream where she was in the everfree forest and sees this creepy pony with sharp teeth and black fur preparing to attack her.

"Everypony knows zombies aren't real, Rarity.", Sweetie Belle said. She read a bunch of stories that have to do with zombies and always believes that they are just make-believe.

"Yeah, why are you all into this whole zombie thing?", Scootaloo asked. "Are you trying remind us about that one time when we tried chase that one chicken that wanted to turn us into stone."

"That was a cockatrice, Scootaloo.", Apple Bloom said. "You don't remember what that creature was."

"Of course, I remember what it was." Scootaloo said back. "I just misremembered that."

"Alright, Alright." Twilight said. "Enough with the chit chat, lets go check it out."

"Wait!", Apple Bloom said. "I found something."

"What did you find, Apple Bloom?", Applejack said. Her sister shows her the item she found.

"I found a key.", the little yellow pony said.

"It's green.", Scootaloo said. "Hmm, wonder why."

"Girls.", Twilight said. "Can we please move on?"

"Oh, right.", Apple Bloom said. "Sorry, Twilight."

They walked around the mansion to find a entrance door. Spike looked at the windows and saw a black suited pony with a giant white pumpkin for a head. The strange pumpkin headed pony looked back at Spike and he gasped. Lightning flashed and the pumpkin head disappeared. Spike rubbed his eyes and checked to see if the strange pony was still there.

"Spike, you alright.", Applejack said. "You seem awfully paranoid."

Spike shook with fear "I saw something or somepony in the window up there.", he said.

Applejack didn't look at the creature when it disappeared from the window. "What did it look like?", Applejack asked.

This made Spike even more afraid. "It was wearing a black suit and it had a white pumpkin around it's head.", he said.

"What?", Spike said. "There's no such thing as white pumpkins."

"Seriously, where's a door.", Apple Bloom said. They looked and looked and the door was nowhere to be found.

An idea flew into Starlight's head. "If we can't find a door, we're going to have to teleport our way in.", she said.

"Seriously, how are we going to do that?", Fluttershy asked. "Not all of us are unicorns."

"Watch me.", Starlight said. "I do it like this." Her horn lit up and they all teleported into a room.

"Well, that should do the trick.", Rainbow Dash said. "Why haven't I thought of that?"

They all found themselves in kitchen. "Um, is this a kitchen?", Spike asked.

"I think so, Spike.", Scootaloo asked. "How many stoves are there in here?"

"There could cookies laying around.", Sweetie Belle said. "I'm hungry."

"Sweetie Belle, there's no time to start cooking.", Apple Bloom said. "And I'm not eating cookies in here."

Then, they heard two voices arguing from behind a door. The door bashed open and what they saw was two strange ponies. The white pony was a stallion with chin-hair, red and yellow mane and tail, and the cutie mark was a pencil surrounded by a note. The dark blue pony was also a stallion with a green mane shaped like Vinyl's mane and wearing a black jacket.

"I worked real hard on that meal!", the white pony said. "You know it's good!"

"Calm down.", the dark blue pony said. "I know that meal was good, you worked good on that"

The blue pony turned and saw the huge group of ponies and the little dragon.

"Oh, hello.", the dark blue pony said in a friendly way. "We didn't see you standing there."

"Hello.", Twilight said. "Are the owners of this mansion."

"Of course this our mansion!", the white pony yelled. "Were you all thinking we don't live here?!

"Alex! Easy, I'll do the talking.", the dark blue pony said calmly. "What are your names, strange fellows?"

"I'm Princess Twilight Sparkle.", Twilight said. "This sweet little dragon is Spike, the blue Pegasus with the Rainbow mane is Rainbow Dash, the orange pony with the cowgirl hat is Applejack, the pink pony is Pinkie Pie, the white unicorn is Rarity, the yellow Pegasus is Fluttershy, the yellow pony with the red mane is Apple Bloom, the smaller white unicorn is Sweetie Belle, and the orange Pegasus is Scootaloo."

"Those names sound a little bit moronic.", the white stallion said. "Those names are different than ours."

"Don't make fun of us, alright, pal." Spike said. "It's because we have different names than yours doesn't mean they're morons, moron."

"WHY YOU LITTLE BRAT!", the white stallion yelled. "I'LL BREAK YOUR NECK!"

"Alex! What did I tell you?", the dark blue pony said. "I told you I'll do the talking."

"You're right. You're right.", the white stallion said calmly. "I'm sorry, I'm okay."

"Wait.", Twilight said. "We never got your names."

"Oh yeah, I forgot.", the dark blue pony said. "I am Iron Guitar, a.k.a. THE IRON PONY."

"Wait.", Applejack said. "If your the "Iron Pony", doesn't that make you a competitor?"

"That's how my name works, I'm a rock star.", Iron Guitar said. "And this is my friend Alex Side. He doesn't get along with the others very well."

"Others?", Rarity said. "You mean there's more in this mansion."

"Exactly.", Iron Guitar said. "He always tries to get them into trouble."

"Oh, so that's how you think of me?!", Alex asked. "I thought we were buddies and now you have to tell them I cause them trouble!"

"Alex, I'm only telling them so they would know.", Iron Guitar said. "I'm not doing that just to get on your nerves."

"Whatever.", Alex said fiercely. "Worst day ever, we get guests in this mansion and now this. All I get is ponies spreading rumors about me that aren't true and we lost our portal key and we'll never go to our original home."

Then, all of a sudden, the lights went out. The ponies started bumping into each other and knocking stuff off the table.

"Hey, who turned out the lights?!", Pinkie Pie said "I think I bumped into something!"

"I can't see!" Starlight screamed. "Twilight, light your horn!"

Then, something darted into Alex's body and knocked him out. Everypony stopped moving.

"Alex, are you ok?", Iron Guitar said. "Where are you?"

The lights flashed back on. The ponies looked at the ground and gasped. Alex had a dart in his back and his face was green. Spike ran to Alex and pulled the dart out his back.

"Alex, are you still breathing?", Spike asked. "Say something."

"Spike, come closer.", Alex said. Spike got closer to his face. He spoke one last time. "You have a dog's name." Then, he was gone.

"Alex? Alex?! Oh no!", Iron Guitar said in a horrified tone. "My friend is gone, what am I going to do now?"

"Iron Guitar, I know this is intense.", Twilight said. "But, you have to pull it together."

"She's right, Sugar cube.", Applejack said. "We just need to figure out who did this."

"Right. Of course.", Iron Guitar said calmly. "But, what are we going to do with the body?"

"Calm yourself, Darling." Rarity said softly. "We can leave here, until we find the murderer."

Spike looked at the dart and analyzed it. "Girls, I know what this is.", he said. "This is a poison dart."

"If it's a poison dart, does it mean it's deadly.", Starlight asked. "I'm not good with this deadly stuff."

"I think so, Starlight.", Spike said. "Look like this is a job for 'Detective Spike'."

"Don't worry, Iron.", Twilight said. "We find who ever did this."

"Thank you, Princess.", Iron Guitar said. "Before we do so, I like you to meet my friends."

They all walked out of the kitchen leaving Alex's body laying on the ground.

Chapter 4

When the three ran to the others, they didn't see Danny with them. "Where's Danny?", Spike asked. "We need to talk to him."

"I'm right here.", Danny said. "What do you need to talk about?"

"Spike, is there something going on here?", Twilight asked.

"He figured out who the White Pumpkin is.", Rarity said.

"Really?", Apple Bloom said. "Who is it?"

Spike turned to Danny, getting ready to expose him. "Danny... is the white pumpkin.", he said.

"What?", Danny said. "That's crazy talk, we Sweetie Belle with pumpkin head right after poor Johnny was taken out."

"He is making a lot of sense, Spike.", Applejack said. "Got any evidence to back it up?"

"Yes I do.", Spike said.

"Well, what do you got?", SD asked.

"There was a group of pictures of all us with x's on them, except for Danny.", Spike said explaining the whole thing.

"That doesn't explain anything, Sweetie Belle looks more guiltier-looking.", Danny said.

"What about what went on next?", Spike asked. "When we were down in the basement we saw something that made a lot of proof."

"Oh really, and what's that?", Danny asked.

"A group of blue banners that say 'Sir Sonic HD'."

Danny's jaw dropped and his eyes shrunk.

"Danny is this all true?", V asked.

"This whole thing has to do with you wanting that portal so you can get away with it.", Spike said.

Danny clapped slowly. "Very clever, Spike.", he said. "And you're right, you caught me, I am... the murderer."

"I can't believe our own best friend would stab us all in the back.", Thomas said.

"I knew it wasn't me.", Sweetie Belle said.

"But, Danny, I don't understand, why that portal key?", Spike asked.

"Because I've been stuck in this world full of itty, bitty, wimpy creatures, with a portal to another dimension right in my hooves.", Danny said.

"Well, why did you lie to us?", Thomas asked.

"I was trying to earn your friendship for it.", Danny said.

"Danny, how could you?", Blank Check said. "We shared cookies together."

"Ha, well, the joke's on you.", Spike said. "Max had it the whole time."

"He had what?!", Blank Check and SD said, shocked.

"Are you serious right now?!", Max asked, surprised.

"Max, Really?", Danny asked.

"It ain't my fault I stole it, I was keeping it safe.", Max said.

"It doesn't excuse all of the terrible things you did to your own friends.", Spike said.

"Spoken like a creature who's been stuck in a place you don't belong.", Danny said.

"We need to do something with you, 'Sir Sonic HD'.", Rainbow Dash said with a threat.

"I say we lock him in a room and let animals eat him alive.", Fluttershy said.

"No! No! I won't let you all do that!", Danny yelled with fright. "This is your fault, YOU DID THIS TO ME!"

"No, you did this to yourself.", Spike said.

"Stay back!", Danny said warning the gang of ponies ganging up on him. "I'll fight you, EVERY SINGLE ONE OF YOU!" He stepped back four times, then, his left back hoof pressed a button and a harpoon shot out of the ceiling, stabbing the dark blue Pegasus through the torso. Everypony screamed and Pinkie Pie threw her guts up.

"Was that there before we came back?", Max asked.

"I don't think so, he must've set this up if none of us were here.", Rarity said.

"And he did that to himself.", Apple Bloom said.

"But, let me be honest, he kinda deserved it.", Scootaloo said.

"You know, I can't believe he's gone.", V said. "But, good lord, stabbed through the stomach could be way worse."

"If he asked us for help, we could've avoid this.", Starlight said.

Rainbow Dash looked out the window and saw daylight. "Look ponies, I can see daylight.", she said.

"Looks like it's time to go home.", Applejack said.

"We're all free.", SD said happily.

"And alive, but, lets get out of this mansion.", Sweetie Belle said. "There could be traps anywhere."

The group walked out the front door. Rainbow Dash took a deep breath through her nose. "Sweet smell of success.", she said.

"I kinda feel bad for the ponies who didn't get to smell it: Alex side, Iron Guitar, Johnny, and Danny.", Blank Check said.

"I'm just glad we stopped Danny.", Spike said.

"Pretty much.", Thomas said.

V needed to say something to Spike. She felt really after how much she treated him. "Hey, Spike.", she said.

Spike turned and saw V walking to him. "Yeah.", he said.

"I was wrong, I never should've treated you badly after you accusing Blank.", V said. "But in the end, you really are a hero."

They both smiled. V kissed Spike on the cheek. "That's for everything.", she said.

Spike blushed. "Thanks.", he said.

"Well, I guess this goodbye until next time, maybe.", SD said.

"You know, we might stay in this world so we can visit you ponies.", Thomas said. "That's because we can't find the portal key."

"Actually, Max has got you covered.", Spike said.

"Hold on, you stole the portal key?", Blank Check asked.

Max revealed the portal key in front of his friends. "Yes I did, I had it with me the whole time.", Max said. "And I wanted it to be a prank, a harmless prank, and I am so so sorry."

"I can't believe this.", V said. "Why would you do that?"

"Leave him alone, guys.", Spike said. "He did say it wasn't his fault."

"Yeah, he did say that.", SD said.

"Guys, shouldn't we be going now?", Thomas asked.

"Sure, Thomas.", Blank Check said.

"I'm not really good with goodbyes, but, thanks for everything.", SD said.

"Later, y'all.", Thomas said.

"Goodbye, and thank you.", V and Blank said together.

"Byyyyyyyyyyye.", Max said.

The group walks away.

"What a bunch of strange ponies.", Sweetie Belle said.

"You've done a great job, Spike." "I'm so proud of you."

"We're all proud of you.", Fluttershy said.

"You deserve a gem once we get home.", Rarity said.

The day was saved, thanks to... Detective Spike.