Rainbow was laying in the bed, unable to sleep. She usually didn’t have a problem falling asleep, but after everything that had happened tonight, she wasn’t feeling tired at all. Plus, she’d managed a long nap today; she’d slept through the entire afternoon and into the evening. Her sleep schedule was probably all sorts of fucked up. It happened to her sometimes, she’d get better eventually. Usually after a night of heavy drinking reset her system.

Did Fluttershy keep any alcohol? Would Dash have to bring some over? The more she thought about it, the more she realized that she’d never had any drinks at Shy’s house. Fluttershy would drink when she hung out with the girls, but didn’t seem like the kind of mare to keep bottles of booze around. Then again, Fluttershy was turning out to have a few hidden vices. Hidden booze would be a welcome surprise at this point.

Dash scrutinized the nightstand, eying some of Shy’s toys. All the things that Ruby had brought out were still in the room, and a few were still untouched, positioned around the candle like some kind of kinky shrine to indecency. The unsettling fact that everything on that table belonged to Fluttershy, and probably had been used by Fluttershy, did not escape Dash. The leather and chains that Ruby had tied her up with lay in a messy pile on the floor, along with the short metal bar that had held her legs firmly apart. Only the red ball gag had made it back on the nightstand, and it had dried spit on it.

Looking closer, she recognized some of the toys, while others remained a mystery. There were sequentially sized balls made of glass all strung together, a pink whip with a heart shaped tip, a few animal collars of different sizes, and two recognizable dildos amongst the collection. There was more, but her eyes kept crawling back to the dildos. One was lime green with a few weird looking prongs sticking out of it, and the other was a partially translucent pink recreation of a dick. The pink one was much larger than a real dick, but looked stretchier.

Dash briefly wanted to touch them to see what they felt like, then realized that Fluttershy had probably used them. Frustrated, disturbed, and potentially aroused at the thought, she rolled over in disgust as her cheeks warmed in embarrassment. She didn’t want to look at the things anymore.

Rainbow wasn’t sure how to handle Fluttershy being a perv. On one hand, it was gross. On the other, it made Dash’s heart beat like a sickeningly loud drum. Sweet, kind, loving Shy was certainly not innocent.

The thought was maddening.

It wouldn’t have been so bad if it was just the giant pink dildo, but there was so much more than just that. The collection lent an air of mystery to Shy that Rainbow couldn’t stop ruminating over. Shy had definitely used everything on that table for something. Rainbow tried to guess what the glass balls on a string were for. Were they some kind of gag? Maybe a weird flogging tool like the whip? She tried to imagine getting smacked with them, and it didn’t seem like it would be fun. They were also certainly not for swallowing. And then there was a rubber thing that was too short and fat to be a dildo. It was weirdly roundish, like a rubber radish, and had a ring on one end, probably to pull on. Rainbow had no idea what it was for. Fluttershy probably understood it intimately.

Groaning in frustration she clenched her eyes shut and wished this was some kind of prank, or even a bad dream. She wanted to go to sleep, but couldn’t stop thinking about everything that had happened. The bed smelled uncomfortably like her, and worse, also smelled like him. To top it off, Shy’s scent permeated everything in the room. Rainbow shifted uncomfortably finding a damp spot with her knee.

That must have been where she was laying when he raped her.

She rolled over to the side and scooted away from the uncomfortable dampness. Maybe she should just go downstairs. Watching Shy and Ruby talk it out was probably better than staying up there and having to think. She really didn’t want to think, and at least if Ruby was nearby she could be pissed at him instead of thinking.

Ruby was going to come upstairs at some point, and he was going to use her again. Rainbow shuddered, disgusted with herself. She knew that she’d let him, that had been the deal after all. Hell, it was for more than the deal. She considered that if she could fall asleep, maybe he wouldn’t wake her up. Of course, there was no way she could fall asleep. Rainbow bit her lip in frustration. It didn’t matter. She had said that she would play nice. That meant she had to participate. Maybe she was more afraid of that.

When Ruby had forced her earlier, she’d been tied up at first. All she could do was wrap her bound arms around his neck and thrust her hips. She’d done enough to let him know that she could hurt him if she wanted, briefly reminding him that she could break his neck, but he’d gotten free when… Well, when she was distracted. Then he’d forced her down and had bored into her in the eyes.

And then he took her.

She remembered his eyes when he had pinned her. Those eyes weren’t the eyes of a loving, caring pony. They were the eyes of a dangerous predator. What had happened between them wasn’t sex like Dash knew. It was something else. A violent, primal struggle for dominance that had sent her heart soaring. She’d always thought that sex was something lovey dovey ponies did with each other. Something caring and intimate. Something like what Fluttershy had tried to do to her.

Dash grumbled into the mattress as her stomach was filled with butterflies. Little pink nausea inducing butterflies.

What Ruby had done to her wasn’t loving or caring. It was vastly different than what Fluttershy had done, even if some things had been the same. It had been violent. It had been a battle; one that Dash had lost. And then he’d thoroughly humiliated her. The humiliation wasn’t what he made her say. It was the why of it. It was why she had stayed in the room after he had left. It was why there was the damp spot, and why she’d needed to wash her hands so completely before her dinner. This was a private humiliation, one between Ruby and her.

The fact that she’d loved it made her feel sick.

Dash felt tears well up in her eyes. Something was wrong with her. The thing that Ruby had done to her that was sex but wasn’t had twisted some small part of her around and now it didn’t want to be twisted back. Just a little part inside of her had turned around backwards and was whispering traitorous thoughts to the rest of her mind. She just wanted it to shut up.

She decided that it was his eyes. Those cruel crystal blue eyes had looked almost alien while he was… while it happened.

She’d played along because she said she would, but it was more than that once he’d pinned her. Her body had become a dangerous live wire, and his touch had made her spark. It had been exhilarating, and in a way, eye opening.

Rainbow screamed into a pillow, muffling her frustration.

She fucking hated Ruby. His stupid purple coat and his stupid wavy hair made him look like a pansy nerd. He wasn’t fit at all, he looked like he had been an athlete, but spent the last three years sitting on his ass doing nothing. He was a dick, just looking out for himself. He also treated her like just a piece of meat. She was so much more than just her body, but even then all he wanted to use was the little part that made mares and stallions different. She was a living being, not a walking vagina for him to use whenever.

But worse than that, he had this underlying aura of desperation. Like he’d given up on life and was empty of hope, or light. She hated people like that, and usually just stayed the fuck away. Those kind of people were caustic at best. Not to mention how fucking annoying he was, always focused on math or rules, or bossing her around.

It really pissed off Dash how much Fluttershy seemed to like him. Dash felt her stomach sink at the thought. Shy had been ecstatic when he was fucking her, she was absolutely remorseless about their debauchery.

Dash groaned as she flopped the pillow next to her and stared at the ceiling. Now there was something she was deathly afraid of. Fluttershy’s kinky side had been set loose, and she was going to indulge it with whomever was closest. And if Dash didn’t stick around, then it would be Ruby. Ruby wouldn’t even care, he’d just use her like a piece of meat. Even if Fluttershy wanted it, she deserved better than that. She deserved to be cared for, not just used by some ungrateful asshole.

Dash wasn’t doing this because she wanted Fluttershy’s attention, no, she just didn’t want Shy to give it to Ruby; Shy might become attached to him. The thought of Shy and Ruby making a quiet little home together in her cabin absolutely terrified Rainbow. They’d spend all their time together doing stupid pervy things, and then Ruby would be dragged to all the girls outings, and Rainbow would have to see his stupid face and pretend to like it for Fluttershy’s sake.

All while Rainbow would know what they did as soon as they went home, and knowing that Ruby didn’t actually care for Shy at all. Not like she did. It made her stomach sick, and her blood boil. That wasn’t an option. Not while she could still do something.

Rainbow was protective of Fluttershy. She always had been. And Ruby was a jerkwad who only cared about himself. He’d eventually hurt Shy, Rainbow knew it. She just had to put up with his crap until then, and then they’d kick Ruby out together. Rainbow would stick around and console her, and do what she could to make Shy feel better. Anything to help her forget Ruby.

Rainbow stared at the ceiling, imagining her and Shy flying together once this bullshit was over. She’d hang out for a few weeks, maybe permanently move in to help around the house.

Rainbow smiled as she began to finally relax.

()()()()()

Fluttershy grinned devilishly as she lead Mr. Rubinstein up the stairs, her heart beating quickly. She’d left the downstairs messy with dishes on the table, and knew that she’d have plenty of cleaning to do tomorrow, but that was tomorrow Fluttershy’s problem. Right now Fluttershy had plans to make things more messy.

Mr. Rubinstein was behind her, slightly confused about the whole thing, but visibly eager.
Fluttershy was beginning to enjoy that they tended to not wear clothes now. It was so much easier to see when Mr. Rubinstein was excited, and the ease of access for everybody was nice. Still, some lingerie might be fun later. She had a few sets for herself, but she doubted that Dash had anything of the sort. Sadly, there was no way hers would fit Dash. Fluttershy frowned, deciding to worry about that later. For now, naked was better.

When they got to her room, the first thing she noticed was Dash laying on her back, staring at the ceiling.

Fluttershy paused. The idea had seemed like a lot of fun when she was sitting on Mr. Rubinstein’s lap getting fingered, but now she was having second thoughts. Dash wasn’t going to enjoy this. Fluttershy frowned again as her stomach slightly dropped.

For a moment, she wished that Dash had just left. Fluttershy could indulge herself, and Ruby, without feeling guilty. She struggled with that thought. It was so much more complex than that. She could still do what she wanted with Ruby and not bother Dash too much, but Dash was here now. And with Dash here now, she wanted to do things with Ruby and Dash. And Dash would also be upset if they excluded her, probably feeling like Fluttershy was trying to protect her. Which wasn’t far off from the truth.

But she wasn’t going to just include Dash either. Rainbow apparently had a hard time telling Fluttershy “no,” and Fluttershy didn’t want a repeat of last night. The only solution was was intimidating, but was what needed to happen anyways. They needed a talk. In private.

“Mr. Rubinstein? Can I have a few minutes to talk with Rainbow?” Hopefully Mr. Rubinstein could wait a little while.

He continued to look confused. “I guess? I’ll just stay outside for a moment.”

“Thank you.” She nodded gratefully.

He awkwardly took a step back, and closed the door, leaving Fluttershy and Rainbow in the room together.

Rainbow slowly turned her head, and looked lazily at Fluttershy. “Sup Shy?”

Sighing, Fluttershy made her way to the bed, and plopped down on it next to Dash. “We need to talk.”

Rainbow frowned and rolled her eyes. “We just spent a whole dinner talking. I’m sick of talking.”

Fluttershy rolled over so she was facing her friend. The bed smelled distractingly like sex. Absentmindedly, she noted that she’d have to clean the mattress and the sheets tomorrow. Although, it did mean she didn’t have to worry about getting it more dirty.

“Dash, I… I don’t want to hurt you.”

Rainbow looked at her and then smirked. “Shy, I think you’d bruise first if you hit me. You aren’t going to hurt me, I’m pretty tough.” She then chuckled slightly, probably imagining Fluttershy pathetically trying to punch her.

“That’s not what I mean, Dash.”

Rainbow’s mirth quickly fled. “Yeah, I know.”

Fluttershy took a big breath. This was hard, but important. She could do this. Her friend was unhappy, and Fluttershy needed to tell Rainbow how she felt.”I… I kind of was hoping you’d leave, you know?”

Dash immediately looked hurt. “Shy…”

Fluttershy shook her head, fighting back her sudden fear. She couldn’t stop. If she stopped to cry or hide or run, then Dash would think she wanted her gone. “No, not like that. I mean…”

Rainbow rolled over on the bed to look away from Fluttershy. “It’s fine. I get it. I fucking get it.”

Fluttershy panicked, and lurched forward in the bed, wrapping her arm around Dash. “No! You don’t! I want you to stay too! It’s… complicated. Everything is complicated right now, but I need you to listen.”

Dash stayed still for a moment, and then Fluttershy felt her hand being gently grabbed. “Okay.”

Dash’s hand was warm around Fluttershy’s, and firm. She took another breath. Dash was willing to listen, so Fluttershy needed to talk. She opened her mouth, and the words just fell out like a waterfall. “I like you too, Dash. You’re my best friend, and I’ve always wanted to share this side of me with you. Getting the opportunity is exciting. In a way, it’s almost like a little dream of mine coming true. But this side of me is… umm… greedy.”

Dash stayed quiet, not looking at her but not letting go of her hand either.

“If you weren’t here, then I wouldn’t worry about you. But since you’re here, every time I start to think about naughty things, umm… well, I think about you too.”

Dash squeezed her hand.

Sighing, she continued. “And I know you don’t like this kind of thing. So I don’t want to make you get involved.”

Fluttershy steeled herself. This was the part that wasn’t very kind.

“But if I don’t, then I keep thinking about you, and the greedy part of me wants you, too. I don’t want to hurt you Dash, but I do want to… umm… be with you.”

Dash kept holding her hand, but spoke up. “So if I wasn’t here, then you wouldn’t want to be with me?”

Fluttershy sighed, snuggling closer to Dash’s back. “Sort of I guess. I’d still think about you, but you wouldn’t be right here. It… wouldn’t be the same.”

“Oh.” Dash was uncharacteristically quiet.

Fluttershy squeezed her. “I just don’t want to do what I did to you again. That was awful, and I can never take it back. That’s what I mean. I just don’t want to hurt you.”

Dash curled up slightly, squeezing her hand hard, and then relaxed, melting back into the position she was before. “Okay.”

Fluttershy was startled by the unexpectedly quick response, but also relieved. “You’ll go?”

“No.”

“No? But…”

Rainbow rolled over while keeping a firm hold on Fluttershy’s hand. “No. I’m going to stay.” She looked determined.

Fluttershy gulped, suddenly intimidated. “Um… Oh.”

Dash used her hand to force Fluttershy onto her back surprisingly fast. Fluttershy meeped as Rainbow climbed on top of her, and looked down at her with a steely resolve. Fluttershy always knew that Rainbow was strong, but to feel it so suddenly used against her was… surprising.

“I want to stay with you Shy. And if that means indulging your perv stuff, then fine. Whatever.” Rainbow slowly looked up and down Fluttershy’s naked body and sighed, followed by a smile. “Ruby might have to fight for me sometimes, but you?”

Rainbow grabbed Fluttershy’s other hand and pinned it to the top of the mattress as she put the other hand next to it.

Fluttershy blushed as her breath caught in her throat. Rainbow was poised over her with an uncharacteristically hungry look, pinning her firmly to the bed. Rainbows short, messy hair seemed to dance in the candlelight, and her eyes glinted strangely. Her body was tense and strong, resting on Fluttershy’s stomach.

Rainbow was so much stronger than Fluttershy when she wanted to be. Fluttershy’s wings slowly spread underneath her while she looked Rainbow’s lithe body over. Slowly, Rainbow lowered herself onto Fluttershy. Fluttershy stared, wide eyed as Dash pressed their lips together in a sudden, but gentle kiss.

It was a brief kiss, warm and soft, and then it was over. Dash’s head slipped by hers and rested on her shoulder where she whispered. “You can have me whenever you want… Just… use me to make you feel good.”

Fluttershy shivered as Rainbow’s hands let go of hers and trailed down her arms. The sensation was electric. She shifted slightly as Dash melted into her, relaxing and hanging her head over Fluttershy’s shoulder.

Fluttershy gasped, she’d forgot to breathe. “Oh my.” She was very conscious of the fact that they were both naked, and things were pressed against, or very close to, other things across the length of their bodies. Dash was quite serious.

“Oh… um… Are you sure?” Fluttershy stumbled for words.

Dash’s response was quick, and she gave all of Fluttershy a squeeze. “Yeah. I’ll do anything to make you happy, Shy. And I’ll enjoy it. Okay?” Rainbow squeezed Fluttershy slightly harder, hugging her. “Whatever you want, whenever you want it.”

Fluttershy gently hugged her back, but thought about the situation. This wasn’t right. She didn’t know why Rainbow was being this accommodating, but it wasn’t right. Rainbow didn’t want to do these things. A small voice in her head told her to enjoy it, forget about the worry, and just let Rainbow make her own decisions. She was an adult.

“Rainbow… this isn’t healthy for you.” Fluttershy ignored that little voice.

Rainbow began to laugh. “Really? Hah! Shy… Maybe you and Ruby are more like each other than I realized.”

Fluttershy ignored that, unsure about how to take it. “Rainbow, if you don’t want to do these sorts of things don’t make yourself. Not for me, and not for Ruby. You are more important than that.”

Rainbow pulled up from the crook of her neck and looked at Fluttershy, seemingly happy. “And that, that right there is why I’m serious. I mean it, Shy.” Rainbow smirked at Fluttershy. “Whatever your twisted pervy mind desires.” She leaned forward, gently pecking Fluttershy’s lips with a soft kiss. She pulled away and smirked again as Fluttershy blushed hard. “Anything at all.”

Fluttershy gulped. Her lips were still tingling, and her body was warm. Very warm. And Rainbow looked happy. That had to be good right? This had to be okay. Rainbow was fully capable of making her own decisions. She was an adult. Almost drowning in the pounding of her own heart, Fluttershy decided that they were both adults─consenting adults.

Fluttershy blinked as her imagination ran wild. “Anything?”

“Anything.” Rainbow slid down into another kiss with her, and a hot tongue slipped between her lips.

Fluttershy quivered as the indecision was stolen from her by a probing tongue. Dash had said anything, and was quickly going to regret that she’d said it.

Of course, then Fluttershy was going to make her love that she’d said it.

()()()()()

Ruby was getting bored. It’d been a few minutes, he had heard some whispering, some giggling, and then suspicious noises. Should he bust in and interrupt whatever they were doing? Or should he just go downstairs and wait until they were done? They were his slaves, but they’d had an intense dinner and probably did need some time. Hopefully Fluttershy had worked out whatever she had to do with Dash. Maybe she was apologizing for earlier.

It was better for him if they got along and worked together. He didn’t want them at each other’s throats, that just seemed wrong. He rubbed his fingers together, still feeling the wetness from Fluttershy. That mare was something else. She went from serious to playful at the drop of a hat. She’d probably went in with the intent of having a serious discussion and turned it into some kind of sex thing.

He started to fantasize about it. Fluttershy was probably on top of Rainbow, whispering things into her ear as the blue mare blushed. Of course, Fluttershy wouldn’t be content to just talk. Her hand was probably trailing down Rainbow’s body, touching her and squeezing. Dash was probably blushing profusely, unsure of what to do but unable to resist the sexually aggressive mare.

“Mr. Rubinstein, you can come in now.” Fluttershy’s voice broke him out of his fantasy. Shaking his head to clear it, he opened the door and went inside. He still had an erection, but he doubted Fluttershy would mind. Dash would just have to deal with it. He looked across the room and his amused smirk died on his face at what he saw.

It turned out that his imagination hadn’t been far off.

Fluttershy was laying on top of Rainbow Dash, and they were face to face. She had her tail held high, in a clear invitation for Ruby, and her legs spread slightly apart. Dash had her hands resting on either side of Fluttershy’s flanks, and was pulling on the flesh, spreading Fluttershy’s pink pucker slightly to accentuate the invite. Dash was looking at the ceiling, her face beat red in embarrassment while she was doing her best to ignore Rubinstein, and Fluttershy was looking over her shoulder with half lidded eyes directly at him.

Rubinstein said the only thing that came to mind, “Buh?”

“Oh. Don’t worry. Dash helped me got ready for you. I’m going to have to buy more lube tomorrow.” Fluttershy smiled sweetly, but Rubinstein didn’t see it. Instead, his eyes were locked on her clearly invitational asshole.

He slowly walked towards the bed, getting a closer look. Fluttershy’s pink puckered skin was shining, coated in a clear sheen of lube as the bottle lay next to them on the bed, empty and on its side. Her mound below twitched as she momentarily tightened her pussy while she turned forward to look at Rainbow’s now bright red face. She smiled at Rainbow. “Are you ready, Dash?”

Dash slowly nodded as Rubinstein climbed onto the bed. He wasn’t quite sure what was going on, but there was no way he was turning down this invitation.

()()()()()

Fluttershy felt her heart pounding in her chest. Rainbow’s body was like a small fire underneath her, and the hands pulling her soft cheeks apart were shaking. Best of all was Rainbow’s face!

Poor Rainbow was being a trooper about all of this, but her face was flushed bright red in sheer mortified embarrassment. She probably hadn’t figured it would be like this. Fluttershy gave Rainbow a reassuring peck on the lips, causing Dash to nervously smile back at her. Dash was always so strong and powerful looking, it was strangely adorable to see her bashfully smiling back at Fluttershy like this. Fluttershy mentally noted that she really liked seeing her friend’s nervous smile. Dash’s smile faltered as Mr. Rubinstein climbed up over Fluttershy’s back.

Fluttershy had done anal before, just never quite like this. Still, she wasn’t worried. She’d made it to the largest size in the anal trainer kit she’d bought, and had been more than a little rough with herself. She knew that just needed lots of lube. And Dash had helped her get plenty of lube up in there, even if she had blushed the entire time.

Mr. Rubinstein settled his weight on Fluttershy, causing her to squeak in surprise. He was heavier than she’d remembered. Still, it was nice being surrounded by warm, naked ponies. Fluttershy relaxed comfortably as his arms went around her side, entangling with Dash’s and sealing her in the middle of a pony sandwich. Dash was nervously eying Mr. Rubinstein over Fluttershy’s shoulder, while flickering her eyes back to Fluttershy occasionally. But even then, she dutifully held Fluttershy’s ass spread wide.

Fluttershy quivered as she felt Mr. Rubinstein’s tip touch her naked flesh. He was warm, so much warmer than the toys had been. She licked her lips in anticipation, and contemplated Dash. Her friend had said that she’d do anything, so Fluttershy had asked her to do this. So far, Dash had been embarrassed, but had happily done everything that Fluttershy had asked. Fluttershy was going to do more to her later, but for now all Dash had to do was hold her spread open for Ruby.

She’d figured that was an easy way to get Dash loosened up, and wasn’t too much at first. Dash had said not to feel guilty, so Fluttershy was trying very hard to not think about how this could go bad. Instead, she thought about how things would go if Dash enjoyed it. Then she’d make Dash an integral part of this little threesome tonight.

Mr. Rubinstein pressed forward, reaching down and pulling her tail up in between them. His grip was gentle, but firm. Her tail stretched up, the dock tugging on her asshole as it was forced upwards. She bit her lip as his cock slid slowly in.

Fluttershy felt the blood rushing through her body, making her turn just as red as Rainbow. Rainbow was transfixed by Fluttershy’s face, and watched with a look of curious concern. Fluttershy forced a smile through her grit teeth. This part was a little painful, but that was part of the fun. She didn’t want Rainbow to think that Ruby was hurting her, or that she wasn’t enjoying it.

Mr. Rubinstein kept sliding further in, and Fluttershy let out a soft grunt as she forced herself open for him. The lube was keeping things feeling nice instead of painful, but she knew she could do better. She grabbed Rainbow’s wrists, signaling to Dash to release her cheeks. Dash let her arms lay awkwardly on the bed, and didn’t look sure what do do next.

Fluttershy almost giggled at the sight. Dash would get the hang of it later. For now, Fluttershy was going to do better. She planted her knees, and pushed herself up and back slightly, getting up into the more familiar doggy style position while simultaneously pressing harder into Mr. Rubinstein. With a satisfying slurp, he slowly slid all the way in.

She closed her eyes and smiled, relishing the sensation of his heavy body on top of her, and her gut filled with his hot length. “Mmmm...” She hummed happily, squeezing his cock slightly, and giving it a gentle massage down the length. It throbbed inside of her, and Ruby was breathing heavy over her shoulder.

“Whoa! What is that?” Mr. Rubinstein stayed pressed tightly into her, and rested on her back.

Fluttershy felt the cool air underneath. She missed the sensation of being surrounded, and briefly considered laying back down on Rainbow, but she wanted to show Mr. Rubinstein everything she could do. She smiled, winking at Dash as she spoke. “I’ve had a little practice, Mr. Rubinstein. Do I feel nice?”

Dash just kept watching, silently blushing as Fluttershy gave Mr. Rubinstein a heavy squeeze with her asshole.

“Uh… Yeah.” He said dumbly, just sitting there on top of her with his cock buried in her body.

Fluttershy kept squeezing him, milking him and gently rocking back. This was nice, she enjoyed it. But it wasn’t what she had planned. She was enjoying making him happy, but she had more pressing needs. She’d milk his cock with her ass another night. Almost regretfully, she pressed him on.

She made sure her voice dripped with need. “Aren’t you going to fuck me, Mr. Rubinstein?”

Like a switch, something changed in his demeanor. Fluttershy braced herself, and grinned wildly at Dash, baring her teeth excitedly as she winked to her friend. She knew how to get what she wanted, and she was showing off for Dash. Fluttershy could be in control and be on the bottom, and she wanted to show that to Dash. She needed to show her that everything would be fine.

“I think I am, Miss Fluttershy.” His voice was determined now, the confusion gone.

Dash glanced curiously at Fluttershy, and Fluttershy winked confidently back once more, this time slowly and obviously as she held back a giggle.

Mr. Rubinstein firmly planted his knees, and put his hands around Fluttershy’s waist. His hands were strong, squeezing her slightly as he started to slowly work his way back and forth inside of her.

Fluttershy gasped and blinked at the sudden pain, but felt herself warming up. She liked that he was fucking her, she liked that his cock was inside her ass, and she liked that Dash was watching her with that wonderfully transfixed expression. But most of all, she liked that she made him do that with her voice.

Mr. Rubinstein grabbed her soft pink hair and gently started to pull it back, forcing her head up. She began to grunt as air was forced out of her from the increasingly violent thrusts. Her ass began to burn pleasantly from the friction, and her pussy started to leak down her legs. He was wide, and strong. Just enough to stretch her and work her muscles, but not enough to hurt her.

Fluttershy couldn’t see Rainbow anymore, she could just see the headboard and the occasional loose strand of hair as he fucked her. A spike of pleasure shot through her as Mr. Rubinstein gave her a reach around with his other hand, thrumming his fingers across her clit. She whimpered, surprised at the pleasant sensation.

Arching her back slightly, she raised up and put her hands on the headboard to provide more resistance when he pushed her forward. He buried himself deep in her gut, slapping his balls into the back of her pussy while his hand roughly squeezed her heated clit, and she shouted in momentary euphoria.

Everything felt amazing. She relished being fucked like this, forced violently against the headboard. Fluttershy spread her legs slightly, and thrust in time with him to press harder against his strong hand. His cock was digging into her, burning her and causing her to shake while his hand was flicking and playing with her pussy, occasionally dipping inside.

Mr. Rubinstein taunted her, talking dirty to fit the mood. “You like that? You like getting it up your ass?”

She squealed, clenching her ass around his cock and her pussy around his finger tips. Fluttershy quivered, momentarily frozen as bliss overtook her. She felt him press hard, pulling on her hair and burying himself tightly into her flesh. Gasping, she tried to catch her breath in between his rough thrusts.

His sudden roughness caught her by surprise, but she still answered. It was only polite, after all. “Yes! Oh… Yes!” She forced her words out between gasps for air. He was still fucking her, still pounding her, and she was leaking like a faucet down her leg. She let out a loud groan and slowly let her arms collapse, keeping her legs up on her knees and spread wide for him.

She was surprised when she found her head resting on Rainbow’s chest. She’d forgotten about her friend in her moment of bliss. Mr. Rubinstein kept pounding into her ass, causing her to wince every time. Her pussy had gone soft and quivery, and his hand felt almost painful in its intensity. He’d let her hair go though, and it was splayed messily across her back and Rainbow’s chest.

Rainbow was watching her with a concerned face, seemingly growing furious. Fluttershy watched in mild curiosity while Mr. Rubinstein fucked her. Rainbow was glancing at Mr. Rubinstein angrily. Fluttershy wasn’t sure what was going on, but she was going to put a stop to it. She forced herself slightly up, and grabbed Rainbow’s head, forcing Dash into a kiss.

If she could control Mr. Rubinstein, she could control Dash.

Surprised at the sudden action, Rainbow’s eyes opened wide. Fluttershy ignored that, and grabbed Dash by the hair, forcing her head back and out of the kiss as she pulled herself slightly up Dash’s body. Mr. Rubinstein was still pounding away at her ass while she positioned her head over Dash’s head, and stared unblinking into her eyes.

Dash froze under her gaze.

()()()()()()()

Dash panicked. She didn’t know what was happening anymore. Shy had looked like she was having fun, and then she’d looked like she was in pain. She’d collapsed on Dash’s chest, and it had looked like Ruby was hurting her, smacking into her over and over while she grunted in agony. Dash had been getting angry. Couldn’t Ruby see he was hurting Shy? She’d been about to do something about it when Shy had pulled her into a kiss, derailing her chain of thought.

And then, Shy had forced her head back and crawled up into her face. Was she angry? Dash blinked, confused about everything as Fluttershy stared into her. All the while Ruby was obliviously pounding away.

Dash shuddered as something inside of her continued panicking. It was that thing that Ruby twisted. Now Shy was grabbing it and twisting it more. It was her eyes. She looked determined. Shy sure didn’t fucking look like she was in pain right then.

Dash wanted to squirm, but felt like she couldn’t move. Shy was on top of her, and her eyes had her pinned. She couldn’t even breathe. Fluttershy blinked, smiled, and the spell was released.

Fear washed through Dash, and then washed out. She caught her breath and blinked away the panic. Rainbow didn’t know what had happened there, but Fluttershy had looked for a brief moment like Ruby had─predatory.

Fluttershy was nice. She had always been nice. She was never dangerous, so that thing that she just did couldn’t have been real. Dash blinked again as Fluttershy lowered her smile into a passionate kiss.

Her lips were hot, and tingly. Dash closed her eyes, forgetting the fear and enjoying her Fluttershy. The kiss lingered, Fluttershy breathed heavily through her nose while Ruby continued to pound into her, causing occasional squeaks and rhythmic jolting through both their bodies. The constant motion of Shy’s writhing was steadied by Dash’s limp body.

Rainbow could do this. She could be their anchor. Rainbow let herself be pulled into the kiss, she let her heart run and beat wildly as she realized that this was going to be… possible. She could make this work.

Shy pulled away, leaving Rainbow breathless. There was a small amount of saliva still connecting their lips, until Fluttershy licked it away with a sly grin. Shy’s eyes fluttered, and she swallowed. She whispered to Dash. “I’m… ah… close again. Can you… oh… hold me this time?”

Dash wrapped her arms around Fluttershy, pulling her down and letting her rest her head in the crook of Dash’s neck. She’d do anything for Shy. She’d told her that already. She held her gently, securing her while Ruby brutalized her rear. She held her in a hug, pressing their chests together and listening to Fluttershy’s pained grunts.

Rainbow glanced at Ruby over Shy’s back, and saw him staring at her with a focused intensity. She glared at him and frowned, holding Shy tight all the same. He grinned, slapping Shy’s ass in response, causing her to squeak in Rainbow’s ear. Ruby danced his hand gently across Shy’s rump as he sneered threateningly at Rainbow.

Rainbow forced her eyes closed and pretended Ruby wasn’t there. She was holding Shy for some other reason. She couldn’t think of one, but she was sure there was one.

Fluttershy’s grunts were becoming loud moans into Rainbow’s neck. Rainbow kissed her neck possessively, and Fluttershy began to lick and suckle on hers. Ruby grunted, and slapped Fluttershy again as he thrust hard.

Rainbow opened her eyes and glared daggers at Ruby as Shy continued to lick her neck. Fluttershy’s warm and constant attention was getting to Dash, but it only made her more protective of her friend. Ruby licked his hand, and reached it back around and under Fluttershy’s body. Fluttershy spread her legs, accidentally putting her knee right up against Dash’s pussy. Shy began to moan hotly into Rainbow’s neck, while Ruby smirked maliciously at Dash as his hand stroked at Shy’s eager core.

Rainbow felt sick and aroused as she tightly held Shy. This whole thing was wrong, twisted and fucked up beyond belief. She shouldn’t be part of it, and yet here she was cuddling and kissing Shy as Ruby abused her. His cock was buried in her asshole, and his fingers were deep inside of her most private place. And Shy fucking loved that he was doing it. Rainbow blinked back her tears. She knew it was wrong, but that didn’t stop Rainbow from grinding against Shy’s leg as Ruby brought her friend closer to orgasm once more.

She felt herself squirming uncomfortably under the mass of writhing flesh. She didn’t know if it was Fluttershy’s attention, or Ruby’s violent aggression, but she’d become wet─horribly, disturbingly, amazingly wet. Worse, she was slightly pressing her wet flesh obscenely up and down Shy’s leg. It was a pathetic, but she didn’t stop.

Ruby kept glaring at her, and she met Ruby’s gaze as Shy grew louder. Shy was going to cum again, and Rainbow was going to hold her this time as Ruby brought her over the edge. Rainbow was shaking. She wished it was her mak…

She wished she wasn’t here.

Fighting back her own arousal and disgust, she grew pissed at herself. She had been so fucking stupid. Why hadn’t she left? Because she thought she could make Shy fall for her? She looked at Shy’s writhing yellow body, and felt her franticly sucking on Dash’s neck. She felt sick. The pounding from Ruby’s assault was causing Shy’s leg to press firmly against Dash’s pussy, mixing Shy’s dripping juice with Rainbow’s.

This debauched hungry animal in her arms wasn’t Shy. It couldn’t be.

Shy was innocent, nice, sweet, loving, always helpful. Shy was amazing. This wet, lewd creature couldn’t be her. But the creature moved fluidly and was holding her back firmly. The creature felt warm and soft, and then Rainbow heard its beautiful voice.

“Ohh… Yes. Yes!” Shy was shouting into her neck, screaming out her euphoria as she went over some invisible line for a second time. It was all too much for Dash. That thing that shouldn’t be Fluttershy was holding her tightly, squeezing her as it ground its leg into Dash’s pussy as it came.

The sound and realization made Rainbow shiver, and she looked dejectedly up at Ruby as he humiliated her again. She ground her pussy firmly into Shy’s leg, reaching her own plateau and letting the debauched sickness overtake her again. It was better if she looked Ruby in the eyes when he beat her, when he made Fluttershy quiver─when he took what she wanted from her. The cold blue eyes anchored her as she floated in her sea of disgusting euphoria.

Rainbow held her friend tight, terrified to lose her forever as they both floated adrift, otherwise quivering uncontrollably.

()()()()()()()

Rubinstein groaned as he emptied himself into the mare. Fluttershy was tight, and seeing her squirm and scream like that had been too much. It didn’t matter that he’d just came an hour ago inside of Dash, Fluttershy’s quivering asshole had milked him for all he was worth. Spurt after burning spurt filled her gut as he caught his breath, watching Dash stare open mouthed at him. He didn’t know if she was horrified or really enjoying herself, but at that moment he couldn’t care less.

His hand was soaked, coated in Shy’s dripping essence, and her pussy was burning hot. The slick skin of her folds felt smooth and soft, her pussy feeling pliable as it wetly quivered under his soft touch. He kept his hand there, relishing the sensation of her quivering flesh around it and feeling her heartbeat from inside her body as the two of them caught their breath together.

The feeling of a mare’s pussy after she came was something he really enjoyed. Right before, it would get tense and hard, then it would suddenly feel like soft wet velvet. That rapid transition to complete relaxation was how you knew you gave a mare a good time. And Fluttershy was absolutely relaxed now, both inside and out.

Sighing, he leaned down on her body, letting her soft frame support some of his weight. He muttered his contentment. “Not what I expected, but fun.”

Fluttershy was still catching her breath, so she didn’t respond. Dash just kept locked on his eyes with a weird, silent stare. She didn’t look like she was breathing.

Rubinstein ignored her, and slowly started pulling himself out of Fluttershy as his dick softened. Dash had been giving him strange signals during the act, and he wasn’t sure what was going on in her mind. He’d talk with her later, but she seemed calm enough now. She didn’t look like she was going to punch him at least. He was worried he’d pissed her off when he was teasing her near the end, but Fluttershy had immensely enjoyed the slapping.

Fluttershy’s signals had been pretty clear. Rubinstein chuckled. That mare was something else all right. Soft and sweet most of the time, she could instantly turn into a devious sex maniac. Not that he minded. It was definitely a fun and novel experience for him. The most forward mares he’d dealt with before had been teases at their core. Fluttershy was anything but a tease. She fully meant what she was offering, and then some more that you hadn’t considered.

And she’d managed to convince Dash to be something like a willing participant, so that was an excellent mark in her favor as well.

With a relieved grunt, he finished pulling his shrinking dick out of Fluttershy’s ass, and looked at it. Her pucker was red and puffy now, with a thin trickle of lube. The room smelled of pungent sex, musk, and more than a little like a pounded asshole. He didn’t mind at all. Relaxing, he fell all the way onto Fluttershy, making a pile of ponies with Dash at the bottom.

He looked at Dash more closely. She was breathing again, but she had her eyes closed and was turned away from him, blushing profusely. She was probably embarrassed about the whole thing. Rubinstein bet she’d never laid under a pony while watching them get ass-fucked before.

He chuckled in amusement.

Fluttershy moaned. “Oh… That was really nice, Mr. Rubinstein. But… Umm… You can be more rough next time.” She sucked in a breath and mumbled, “I um… liked it when you spanked me.”

Rainbow opened her eyes and glanced at Fluttershy in disgust before she muttered, “Damnit, Shy.”

Fluttershy smiled evenly at Dash. “I’m just being honest, Dash. That way I’ll have more fun next time. What about you? Did you enjoy it?”

Dash mumbled something and blushed, while glancing nervously at Ruby.

Ruby chuckled. He was feeling pretty good after all that, and everybody seemed happy enough this time. This is more what he wanted. This is more what everybody wanted. Sighing, he closed his eyes and rested on Fluttershy’s back. Maybe they could all sleep like this, in a pile of naked flesh.

“Oh. I don’t think we’re done Mr. Rubinstein.” Fluttershy spoke up. “Don’t fall asleep yet.”

He opened his eyes, fighting the sudden exhaustion. “I think I’m about done, Fluttershy. That was my second time tonight, and that’s about all I’m about good for.”

Fluttershy gently pushed up, causing him to roll on his side as she got up and stretched. He glanced at the bed. It was soaked, covered in her juice. Even Dash was soaked, her pussy glistening with moisture. Maybe she’d had a little fun, too.

Fluttershy smiled mischievously as she looked down at Dash, who swallowed nervously. “Mr. Rubinstein? What if we have another, smaller, bet?”

He blinked, fighting the exhaustion to sit up cross legged on the bed. He didn’t have to agree, but he was curious. “Oh? And what would we be betting?”

Fluttershy kept looking down at Dash, and her mischievous grin became slightly more deviant. “I was thinking that if Rainbow and I could get you excited again, you could have a bit more fun with us. If not, then you can go to sleep.”

Rainbow looked up at Fluttershy, clearly concerned, but didn’t say anything.

Rubinstein thought about that. He certainly didn’t have anything to lose, the terms were simple enough and there didn’t seem to be any loopholes. It was a no risk bet that could only benefit him. “Well, I don’t see why not.”

Rainbow whimpered.

Author's Note

Oh hey. I wrote most of this a while ago, and never updated it. Whoops. Here's some porn. I also gave it a once over or two, but let me know what you think. Also, if you don't like where the story is going, or if you do like, please let me know!