Stranger As Fiction

by Unicop

Rating: mature
Tags: Slice of Life, Sex, Twilight Sparkle, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Starlight Glimmer, Random
Length: 1738

Starlight Glimmer has a secret, she likes writing self insert erotica involving her friends, including her mentor Twilight Sparkle. It would be a tragedy if anypony ever found out about it, specially Twilight!

Starlight Glimmer has a secret, she likes writing self insert erotica involving her friends, including her mentor Twilight Sparkle. It would be a tragedy if anypony ever found out about it, specially Twilight!

Published 2016-11-07 06:20:01 UTC
Last updated 2016-11-07 06:20:01 UTC

Chapter 1

Starlight lay in bed staring into nothing. Her friendship lessons for the day already ended, and both Twilight and Spike had left for the day leaving Starlight once again alone in the castle.

She didn't mind much really. She was used to spending many a happy hour in solitude back at her old town, either studying magic or writing bizarre works of fiction never meant for publication, or any ponies eyes other then her own. Starlight had found writing a relaxing vocation, it was nice to create characters and put them in the dumbest or most horrific situations and see how her vast imagination would plot out their fate. Sometimes she would even write stories based off of ponies she knew, these would mostly be romance or erotic works of fiction.

As of recently most of her writing comprised of self insert erotica involving her newly formed friends in Ponyville, though mostly she seemed to write about herself and Twilight. Ever since their first meeting Starlight found herself drawn to Twilight. Her vast intelligence matching her own, her long flowing locks of mane, and for a pony who's main form of exercise is speed reading the latest Daring Doo novels she didn't have a bad figure.

Lighting her horn, she summoned an old notepad and pencil from under her bed and began to write.

(Twilight entered the room and leaned against the door frame with lidded eyes. “Like what you see Starlet?”

I nod, words unable to form as I take in her succulent figure bathed in the light of the full moon shining through the open window. Twilight sombered toward me waiting on the bed, swaying her hips from side to side playfully as she went. As soon as she reached the bed she reared like a lion about to go in for the kill, and pounced pinning me against the silk sheets on the bed.

“Now who's your little mistress?” She asked in a sing song voice.

“I am.” I mutter weakly staring bashfully back into her violet eyes.

“I'm sorry, didn't quite catch that!” Twilight bite me neck gently as I suppressed a moan of both pain and pleasure.

“I AM!” I screamed between clenched teeth.

“That's right my young apprentice, and don't you EVER forget it!” Twilight then kissed me on the lips, my mouth opened slightly allowing her tongue to slip inside and fight furiously with my own. Then she began kissing down my neck, stomach and finally teasingly around my waist as I felt a warm tingling sensation begin to form between my legs.)

Back in reality Starlight slowly began to feel the same burning sensation. She quickly repositioned herself so she was lying on her stomach, her notepad propped up against a pillow and a fore hoof slowly snaked its way between her thighs.

(Twilight then turned her attention to my most sensitive area, I gave a load yelp as her tongue parted my lips and began expertly exploring my moist walls. My own tongue lolled out of my mouth as I panted and moaned in ecstasy. “T-Twilight…Ah..S-Slow down a bit…Ahhhn. I T-Think I'm gonna…” I strained to get the words out but Twilight either didn't hear, or choose to ignore them. Instead she amped up her pace, occasionally stopping to suckle a bit on my moist clit.)

Starlight stifled a moan herself as she strained her ear for any hint of activity outside. Twilight and Spike shouldn't be back for at least another three hours, but it never hurt to be cautious.

(Twilight decided it was time to pickup the pace. She quickly repositioned herself so her own wet mound was dripping her own excitement into my face. I quickly took the hint and dug in greedily lapping up her juices as they began flowing more freely down my chin. Soon the entire room was filled with moans and the smell of filly love making as we continued to eat each other out.

Twilight then decided to move in for the coupe don resistance, and began focusing her attention on my clitoris. I screamed loudly as each lick brought me closer and closer to climax. I immediately copied Twilight earning the same muffled reaction as she moaned heavily from inside my slit. With each lick I grew wetter and wetter, until at last with one final push of Twilight's tongue I reached my climax. Twilight was not far behind me as her waist lurch forward screaming “OH STARLIGHT GLIMMER!” As we both spilled a decent amount of fluid onto the bed.)

Back in reality Starlight herself had begun peaking. Unable to take any more she threw the notepad aside and began pleasuring herself furiously with both hooves until at last with one final scream, her waist pushed upward and she spewed so much fluid it completely soaked her sheets. She then collapsed in a puddle of her own excitement panting heavily.

After recovering she quickly gathered her pencil and notepad, and snuck it back underneath the bed. Once sure it was safely hidden away, she stepped out of her room to freshen up with a nice hot shower before Twilight and Spike returned.

Later that evening Starlight was happily applying overzealous amounts of butter onto a jumbo sized bag of popcorn. Once sure she had dumped the entire pot into the bag, she picked it up with her magic and turned to leave, only to find herself face to face with Twilight, sporting her brand new reading glasses and a coy little smile.
“Starlight, can I see you in the library for a minute?”

“Um sure!” Starlight nervously gulped down a mouthful of popcorn and followed her mentor out of the kitchen. Upon arrival Twilight walked over to her desk and picked up a notepad levitating it in front of Starlight. Her entire body went cold as she saw it was her personal notepad which she had been writing all her secret ship fics in.

“I didn’t know you were into writing!” Twilight stated in a slightly smug voice “Nor did I realize you were into erotica, never would have pegged a pony who spends all day hiding in a castle to be so romantically deviant!” Her lips cracked into a toothy grin “Then again, i’m not one to talk!”

“Wait……. What?”

Twilight levitated another larger notepad from one of the drawers in her desk, and gave it to Starlight who after a moment’s hesitation began leafing through it. Her eyes widening to the size of dinner plates as she read.

“As you can see I also like to write stories from every genre, including romance and erotica!” Twilight giggled as Starlight began blushing bright red “Though while you tend to stick to tamer Erotica I sometimes like to dwell into the more Vore and Bondage genre’s. “

Starlight began to feel an all too familiar burning sensation between the thighs, and quickly tossed the book back onto Twilight’s desk. “Soooo, you’re not upset or disgusted with me then?” she asked timidly.

“Of course no, that would be kind of hypocritical would it not?” Twilight giggled.

“Aaand, how in Equestria did you get a hold of my *ahem* stories anyway?” Starlight circled the floor with her hoof nervously “I thought I had hidden it away where nopony would find it...”

“You mean under your bed?” Twilight rolled her eyes “Oh Puh-leeze Starlight that’s like the most OBVIOUS spot ever! Only a foal would think nopony would ever look under there!”

Starlight blushed furiously, this time from sheer embarrassment. “And WHY may I ask where you looking through my private belongings?”

“Oh I wasn’t, I was just seeing if you had taken my copy of fifty shades of eyeliner Rarity sent me last week, although it turns out it was under Spike’s bed…. Not sure I want to know what he was planning to do with it.” Twilight added rolling her eyes again.

Starlight said nothing for a while, her mind racing. On one hoof it at least seemed she was not in trouble or about to be dragged out onto the street tarred and feathered. However, she still couldn’t help the feeling Twilight was up to something. “Soooo…. What now?”

“Whatever do you mean?” Twilight asked playing the innocent.

“Oh knock It off, I doubt you called me out here just for a confession!”

Twilight broke into another mischievous grin, and Starlight began regretting opening her big mouth. “Well now that you mention it!” Twilight teleported back behind her desk, her eyes half lidded still fixed on Starlight “As I mentioned I too am into writing stories of the erotic persuasion. However, it’s not as much fun on my own as it is with another pony. Back in Canterlot as a young teen I used to write them with Moondancer, but ever since moving to Ponyville I’ve been stuck writing mostly by myself. Occasionally Rarity helps with my less raunchy Romance fiction, but I’ve not had another pony to collaborate with on my more erotic works.” She placed Starlight’s notepad next to her’s on the desk, and waved a fore hoof above them gesturing “That is until now!”

Twilight then teleported inches in front of Starlight’s face, fixing her with her most seductive look “What do you say? We can even re-enact a few of our stories when Spike’s not around sometimes, something I also used to do with Moondancer. Heck maybe since we are both old enough we can publish a few of our stories! Under secret pen names of course!”

Starlight considered this for a few moments “Er, this is all rather sudden Twilight…But.”

Twilight then leaned forward and kissed Starlight fully on the lips silencing her. When they finally broke off Starlight’s face was flustered while Twilight gave her another seductive smile. “I’ll take that as a yes!” Twilight then walked past Starlight, flicking her tail playfully under her nose as she passed. She stopped by the doorway and looked back at Starlight “My room in ten minutes?” before blowing her a kiss, winking, and departing from the library.

Starlight just stood there frozen, still processing everything that had just took place. When her brain had finally caught up with her she gathered up her notepad from Twilight’s diary and left the library, knowing nothing she had read in any erotic book could ever prepare her for whatever awaited her in Twilight’s personal quarters.