~Anon's Perspective~
You were Anon, the only human in Equestria in fact. You were an average looking white guy with a gray jacket, blue jeans and a black baseball cap (obviously worn backwards). You were also in a herd with two of some of the most well known ponies in Ponyville. The first one was Bon Bon, a cream coloured earth pony who owned a sweet shop in Ponyville. And Lyra who was a minty green unicorn was some of the weirdest fascinations you've ever heard of. When you both first met, she wouldn't stop staring at your hands and fingers. Every time you wiggled them around, her smile would only grow wider and creepier.
After a couple months of living in Ponyville, Lyra finally asked you out for a date. It was long, nice and steamy... much like your dick. Mainly from what she was wearing, she looked proper banging in her dress. However then she asked Bon Bon if she wanted to go out with you, in hopes of all three of you becoming a herd. Bon Bon gave it a try and the next day afterwards you two were rutting each other brainless. You loved both of these mares for their own reasons. However both Lyra and you realized that you were paying more attention to Bon Bon than to Lyra. You rutted Bon Bon multiple times whilst you only went with Lyra once, and that was after she begged you for hours non-stop. You thought that it would have been hot to have a mare begging you for sex, but this was just too much. You also went out with Bon Bon more. You didn't know if it was because you preferred Bon Bon over Lyra, but your priorities always seemed to be on Bon Bon.
It wasn't that you disliked being with Lyra, far from it actually. She was funny, cute as all fuck and she was the one who introduced you to Bon Bon and the whole herd idea in the first place. Maybe it was because Bon Bon seemed to want to be with you more, and you just allow her to get in the way of you getting closer to Lyra. Whenever you would plan a trip with Lyra, Bon Bon always wants to join the bandwagon. Obviously you never say no to her, you were always kind of a softy in that aspect.
But today was the day. Tonight it was only you and Lyra, going out for dinner whilst Bon Bon stayed behind. Both you and Lyra got into a heated argument about you not paying any attention to her compared to her friend, but you tried to settle it with both of them going out for dinner. Throughout the days leading up to tonight, you have been nonstop giving all your attention to Lyra. Making her breakfast in bed, kissing her in public and even helping her run the shop whilst Bon Bon was out. Either way, here you were waiting patiently for her to present herself. You personally didn't really care what she was most likely putting on right now. With or without makeup, you just didn't see any major difference. It also wasn't like you understood makeup anyways. I mean, a guy like you being interested in something meant for girl, can you imagine?!?!
~Lyra's Perspective~
You were currently getting ready in your room. Bon Bon helped you with picking out a dress but you both kept it secret from Anon. You were now putting on make up. Lipstick, blush, eyelash curler and other things, you wanted this night to go perfectly. You knew that he would love what you had in store for him. You giggled at the thought of what this night could hold if it went just as planned. You both already picked out a place where you will be spending your dinner at and have already reserved a table. Anon did worry about it maybe being too expensive, but you told him not to worry about the price and just enjoy the evening.
You were now ready. You double checked yourself in the mirror, checking every inch of your body. Sure you were nervous, but you tried to hide it. You had your eyes on the prize which filled you with determination. Once you were ready, you stepped out of your room and onto the staircase, looking down at Anon whilst he seemed to be deep in thought.
"How do I look?"
You could see his eyes look up at you and his jaw drop. His eyes widened, thank Celestia that he likes it.
"You look amazing!" He complemented
You couldn't help to blush at his complement. You then looked at what he was wearing. He was wearing a white suit with black tie. He looked like a proper gentlecolt. Formal and hot.
"Should we head out then?" he nodded in response "Where's Bon Bon? I haven't seen her all evening"
You started to walk down the stairs, careful not to trip on your dress. It was a rather long dress so you made every hoof step carefully.
"I don't know, I haven't seen her either. I didn't even see her head out anywhere"
At the back of your mind, you knew that Bon Bon must be planning something. Disappearing out of the blue like that, coincidentally at the day where you and Anon are going out for dinner? You just hoped that Anon wouldn't end up letting Bon Bon join you two tonight. You just wanted this night for the two of you. You walked up to him and placed a hoof on his shoulder.
"Just promise me that it will be just you and me. I really want this..."
"I promise, it will be a night that you'll never forget"
Anon then smiled, letting you know that he meant every word he says. You smiled back at him, over joyed inside but you tried to not show it too much. You could then see him leaning in for a kiss. Whilst a kiss would be nice, you decided to hold him off for now. You had bigger and better plans for him. You held up one hoof in front of him face, blocking his face from getting any closer to yours. You smirked as he opened his eyes, you just loved to tease him. Whenever it was kissing or the one time you had sex, it was always fun to see his reaction.
"Oh no, you're gonna have to work to get your reward"
You then walked up to the door, waiting for Anon to compose himself before following you.
"You're such a tease, you know that?"
You giggled, you loved that about him. He wasn't afraid of holding back whatever hes thinking to you. He mostly says the truth, and sometimes a witty insult here and there. They're most for fun though, and even you have your share of witty insults to throw at him. You both then walked out of the door, the night has now officially begun.
~Anon's Perspective~
So you and Lyra finally arrived at the place. It was a high class restaurant in Ponyville called "PretaPony". As you both neared the door, you calmly sped ahead and held the door open for her.
"Mares first" You said whilst bowing
She giggled at your silly antics. You knew that this was a high class restaurant, but you were here to also have fun with Lyra. Who cared what the other ponies might think of you, you were here to enjoy yourself with Lyra, your special somepony... one of them anyways. You two walked up to the counter where there was a pony in a proper black suit and tie serving the drinks.
"Excuse me, we have reserved a seat for tonight" I said whilst Lyra stood back
"Names?" The pony said, placing down the bottle of beer and picking out a piece of paper on a clipboard
"Anon Y Mous" You said, then stepping aside to let Lyra as her name
"And Lyra Heartstrings"
"Ah yes, please follow me" The pony said as he went around the counter and directed us to our seats
Soon enough we got into our seats and we both sat down. The table was beautiful. It had a single candle in the middle, plates and utensils all ready set up and the table was covered in a elegant red cover. The chairs also had a comfy red pillow on them, hopefully the food will be good too.
"You know, I never did get your middle name. Is it really just Y?" Lyra asked, getting comfortable on her chair
"Haha, I wish" You chuckled "My middle name is actually Young. No idea who thought of that, so I keep my middle name to just a Y" You explained
Lyra giggles as a waiter approached our table with two menus being held by his magic.
"Here are the menus, hope you enjoy your time here" He said as he placed them down onto the table, then he walked away without waiting for our response
You immediately took one of the menus and started looking through it, you were starving. You already knew that this place wouldn't have any meat, since this is PONYville after all. Having meat on the menu would be a crime, wouldn't it? As you tried to look through the menu, you could hear Lyra chuckling to herself.
"What has you laughing so much?" you casually asked
"Just keep looking through the menu and you'll find out" Lyra said as she was trying to hold in her laughter
You rolled your eyes, *flips onto the next page* this mare really was crazy someti-
"THEY HAVE FUCKING MEAT HERE?!" You yelled, quickly placing your hands over your mouth and avoiding looking at anypony who may or may not be staring at you
Well, you did hope for fun.. you guess yelling in a high class restaurant will do for now.
~Lyra's Perspective~
You guess that you probably should have told him that the menus here contain meat. After all, this restaurant not only serves ponies but also griffons, bat ponies and other creatures that happen to live in Ponyville. You try to hold in your laughter as you watch your special somepony's reaction to be menu.
"How come you didn't tell me about this?!" He whispers, trying to recover from his sudden outburst
You giggle before responding.
"That would have spoiled one of the surprises that I've got planned for you" You say with a suggestive wink
"One of the surprises? I should have taken you out ages ago if you got that much in store for me"
Oh he has no idea. You grin as you think your plan over in your head. All of the things that tonight will lead to, all of the fun you two will be having. You both carry on looking through the meals on the menu until you two have picked out what you will be having. The waiter comes up to your table, a unicorn with a white top and a fancy mustache.
"Have you two picked out what you will be having tonight?" The waiter asks
"Yes, I will be having Gnocchi alla Trapanese please" You say, reading out the rather complicated words slowly, trying to to mess up on the pronunciation
"And I'll be having a basic steak with baked potatoes on the side please" Anon says
The waiter writes both of your orders on a notepad.
"What about something to drink?" Anon asks you
You think if over in your head. You aren't much of a heavy drinker yourself, so much as well go with something classy.
"Can we ask for some red wine?" You say
The waiter smiles and nods his head
"Anything else?" He asks
"No thank you" You say
The waiter then walks off, leaving you two alone once again.
"This place has some pretty good service, not to mention a GREAT selection of food" Anon jokes
You giggle. This is suppose to be when couples talk about each other, why aren't any sentences coming to mind? Are you nervous? Anon seems to be less nervous than you are, maybe you're just stressing too hard over this. Maybe you should calm down in the bathroom.
"Ummm... please excuse me, I have to use the bathroom" You say, getting off your seat
"Sure, be right back though. If your not back than I'm eating without you"
You smile and walk off into the bathroom, leaving Anon alone at the table. You feel bad about leaving him alone, but you just have to get your mind sorted out. You're feeling too nervous and you just need some time to cool off. You wander around for a bit until you find the mare's toilets. You open the door and walk to the sinks and look at yourself through the mirror.
"Common Lyra. You just have to talk to him, finish your meal, bring him back home and then spend the night together" You tell yourself "You can do this!"
~Anon's Perspective~
You sit at the table, waiting on your marefriend to return. You busy yourself by staring absolutely nowhere. Sometimes you hates Equestria, not having access to your phone in these situations is like hell. Without your phone you're forced to endure what feels like hours by staring into nothing. You slouch on your seat to get come comfortable whilst you wait for Lyra to come back. As you wait you swear that you can feel something on your leg. You look down slightly on your legs but you see nothing there, so you look back up and try to ignore it.
"Hey Anon" A voice whispered
You look around the room, to see where the voice was coming from but you see nopony looking at you nor looking like they're trying to talk to you. You wonder in your mind where that voice came from, it sounded so familiar.
"Anon, over here" The voice whispered again
You quickly turn around, maybe somepony is trying to play a prank on your or something. Once again, you see nopony around you nor staring at you.
"No Anon, down here" The voice whispered again
Then you feel a gentle hoof running down you leg. You ALMOST shriek from the sudden touch, the key word is ALMOST. You try to hold it in as your eyes expand. Is a ghost trying to feel you up? You look down as quickly as you can, only to see a familiar looking pony smiling up at you.
"Bon Bon?! What are you doing here?!" You question in the most quietest voice you can muster
"Well, I heard about your little date with Lyra. And I was going to just let you go... but I couldn't help myself. I want you, I need you, and I'm going to show you how much I love and need you" She says whilst slowly stroking your leg
In an instant you know what she wants from you... in a public restaurant.
"Out of all of the places, here?! Why in a public place?! Why not wait till me and Lyra return home?!" You question
"Because I want it to be secret. I know how much Lyra wants this night to be just for the two of you, but I couldn't stop myself from wanting you"
Oh, how charming.
"Look, I really love you too... but not here and now. I'm spending sometime with my other special somepony and I don't want you to get involved, and I'm sure that Lyra wouldn't like that either"
"I'll be silent. It's only going to be for you, not for me. I want to please you, please let me" Bon Bon begs, giving you puppy eyes
If theres one thing that you hate about ponies, is those darn puppy eyes. Of all the time you spent interacting with ponies, you never got used to them. You try to hold your emotions stable... but to no avail. You quickly find yourself warm up to Bon Bon, what a cheap way for me to do her bidding.
"Ugh, fine. Just be silent, alright?.. and don't make the table shake too much"
Bon Bon then gives you a warm smile and nods before ducks back underneath the table. You have no idea what is this going to lead to, but hopefully nothing bad. You try to relax and loosen up your legs, but you can't help not to be a little bit tense for what is about to happen... in public. You start to feel your belt buckle get taken off and you move yourself closer to the side of the table for a better chance to hide your lower parts from anypony that may be looking. It didn't help that the table was round and it didn't help that the you start becoming more nervous over Bon Bon than the date.
You then hear an audible unzipping sound, clearly shes unzipping your trousers right now and slowly moving onto the boxers underneath.
