Cheater

by Mythical Witch

Rating: mature
Tags: Romance, Equestria Girls, Sex, Sunset Shimmer, Big Macintosh, Twilight Sparkle
Length: 1399

Twilight gives Sunset an unexpected present.

Twilight gives Sunset an unexpected present.

Warning: Contains mild BDSM, and Female on Female
Sci-Twi, not Princess Twiley.

Published 2016-11-18 06:40:01 UTC
Last updated 2016-11-18 06:40:01 UTC

The present

“Hey there.” Sunset whispered into Twilight’s ear.

Twilight slowly opened her eyes, the bright light of the morning sun assaulting them. Sitting up, Twilight started stretching her arms while stifling a yawn. “Hey there, Sunny.”

Twilight turned to get her glasses off Sunset’s nightstand, when she felt a sting on her butt.

“I’ve always loved how firm you are. It makes things that much more...fun.” Sunset whispered, while running her fingers up and down Twilight’s thigh.

Twilight giggled before turning over to face her lover. “What, didn’t have enough fun last night?”

“You were so tired, we didn’t get to last that long. Now that you’re rested up…”

Sunset leaned over and started kissing Twilight. Moving down, she placed kisses down the purple neck, until reaching her collarbone. Twilight gasped as Sunset licked from her collarbone, back up to her ear. The wet trail caused a coolness, making Twilight shiver.

“You like that?” The fiery haired girl giggled, as she watched Twilight’s face turn bright red. Twilight’s voice cracked, as she attempted to say yes.

Grinning, Sunset reached over Twilight and threw her onto her back. “You remember the safe word?”

“Starswirl?”

Nodding her head, Sunset reached up and forcefully pinched Twilight’s nipples, making the younger girl yelp in pain. “Did you forget something?”

“Sorry. It’s Starswirl, mistress.” Twilight quickly corrected herself, biting her lip to prevent herself from yelling out.

“Good. Now, where to start, where to start?”

Sunset leaned down and started breathing in Twilight’s ear, before nibbling on it. Causing another gasp. Reaching down, Sunset slowly pulled Twilight’s t-shirt off, exposing Twilight’s small, yet perky boobs. Twilight had neglected to put on her clothes after their night of fun, and opted for just her shirt, while Sunset remained naked.

“Close your eyes, and don’t move.” Following Sunset’s directions, Twilight closed her eyes.

Sunset reached under her bed, and pulled out four leather straps, with cuffs on the end. She slowly attached the two straps at the end of the bed to Twilight’s ankles. Noticing this, Twilight instinctively tried moving away, only to find her legs stuck. Shaking her head, Sunset climbed on top of Twilight, pinning her arms under her knees.

“Didn’t I say, don’t move?”

“Yes, I’m sorry mistress. It won’t happen again.” Twilight whispered, trying not to open her eyes.

After a couple seconds, Sunset got off the bed and attached the last two straps to Twilight's wrists. With one final touch, she reached into her dresser drawer and pulled out a blindfold and a feather.

“Since you didn’t listen to me about moving, I’m afraid you have to be punished.” Sunset slid the blindfold over Twilight’s eye, before dimming the lights.

“What are you going to do...mistress?”

Sunset took note of the slight sliver in Twilight’s face, making the fiery haired girl more excited. Sunset could feel the wetness between her thighs growing.

“Let’s see. What should your punishment be?” Taking the feather, Sunset moved towards the foot of her bed and started ticking Twilight’s feet.

“Noooooo, please...please stop!” Twilight laughed, fighting against the restraints.

“I don’t know if I should. Have you learned your lesson?”

Coughing, Twilight nodded her head and Sunset stopped tickling her. She had to be careful, to avoid giving her friend an asthma attack.

“Let’s see, what’s next?”

Getting on top of the bed, Sunset straddled Twilight. Leaning down, she started sucking on Twilight’s erect nipples. Every lick was sending a bolt of energy through the young girl's body. Sunset slowly started moving her hand down, softly moving over the purple skin, until she reached Twilight’s inner thigh.

“Wait, Starswirl!”

Taking note of the shiver that came from Twilight from touching her, Sunset hand planned to move further, but instead let her go.

“I’m sorry Sunny.”

“It’s alright.” Sunset quickly took the blindfold off, and undid the straps. “What happened? It’s not like you to chicken out so quickly.”

“I don’t know…” Twilight watched as Sunset sat on the edge of the bed. Smiling, Twilight reached around and grabbed her lovers boobs. Sunset gritted her teeth from the sudden foreplay. “I thought it would be fun to try something a little different.”

“Cheater.” Reaching behind, Sunset tried to find Twilight’s pussy, but Twilight gave a quick squeeze to the nipples, making Sunset jerk back.

“It’s not cheating, if there’s no rules.”

Twilight started placing soft kisses down Sunset’s neck, until her lovers fighting instincts calmed down. Feeling Sunset start to go limp, and embrace her touch, Twilight reached down and started gently probing at the warm lips.

Sunset jumped slightly from the sudden touch, letting out a low moan.

Twilight started to slide her finger inside Sunset’s slit, and softly pushed around the velvety walls, feeling her prize.

“Mmmm, that...that feels nice.” Sunset whispered, squirming a little in Twilight’s embrace.

“You know, there was a reason I wanted to get to bed early last night. I needed you to go to sleep, so I could go get you present.”

Twilight moved her finger up in a come here motion, doing her best to hit Sunset’s g spot. Sadly, it hadn’t lasted as long as Sunset had hoped for. Twilight licked her fingers, admiring the taste, before starting to rub her lover’s shoulders.

“You trust me...right?”

“Of course, Twilight.”

Reaching over, Twilight grabbed the blindfold from earlier, and slid it over Sunset’s eyes. “Lay down, and I’ll be right back.”

Sunset heard her bedroom door open, and some shuffling in the living room. A moment later, the door clicked closed.

“Ready?” Twilight whispered, waving at Big Macintosh to go to the bed.

Nodding Big Mac climbed over Sunset, who flinched at the sudden weight change. “Wait, what’s going on?”

Sunset started reaching up to take the blindfold off, when she felt a large hand massaging her clit. Letting in a sharp breath, Sunset could feel her pussy getting wet again, waves of pleasure racing through her body.

Twilight leaned down, and started taking Big Mac’s semi-erect cock in her mouth. It had been a lot bigger than anything she had taken before. Twilight had only been able to take half of it, before she started gagging. Pulling away slowly, Twilight cupped her hand around the base of his cock while using her mouth on his tip.

Leaning back a little more, Big Mac started sliding his fingers in and out of Sunset’s winking pussy. Lost in sensation, Sunset could barely let out anything but a moan or squeak.

Big Mac jerked his hips slightly, closing his eyes for a moment.

Twilight took notice of the fully hard member in her hand, and gave it one last lick before pulling away. “Ready Sunset?” Twilight giggled

“What...what are you going to…” Sunset choked, before feeling the tip of Big Mac’s cock push against her opening. “That’s not a toy, is it?’ She asked with a little too much enthusiasm.

“Eenope.” Big Mac said, as Sunset shivered again. He slid down to have a better angle, before lifting Sunset’s legs and wrapping them around his waist.

“Ready?”

Nodding her head, Sunset let out a cry as Big Mac pushed himself in. A small popping sound filled the room. Sunset threw her head back, and her entire body started going numb to all other sensations.

Big Mac started thrusting back and forth slowly, casually picking up the speed, whileTwilight came up behind Sunset, and leaned her against her own body. Hugging Sunset from behind, Twilight braced her lover, while starting to plant more kisses on her neck.

“Oh, oh sweet Celestia…”

It hadn’t taken long before Sunset’s breathing became labored. Closing his eyes, Big Mac just focused on the warmth of Sunset, while letting Twilight take care of everything else.

Sunset shook in Twilight’s embrace, before letting out one last cry. Sunset back bent backwards, while her head was thrown back. All her senses died down to her orgasm, before she softly drifted off to sleep.

Big Mac pulled out, and they laid Sunset on one side of the bed. “That was fast.” He said, a little disappointed.

“Sorry. I guess I worked her too far, before coming to get you.”

“Ya know, mah trucks out back. Don’t want ta wake Sunny here.”

“No we don’t...”

Author's Note

This is my first fanfic, and my first clop story. I hope you enjoyed, and any advice is greatly appreciated.