Calling All the Monsters

by Michael Hudson

Rating: mature
Tags: Alternate Universe, Other, Rarity, Fluttershy, Random, Sex, Human, Anthro, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Second Person
Length: 3905

You own a boarding house for beautiful mare monsters. This couldn't end badly, or sexy, at all, could it?

Ever since monster/mare hybrids have been coming out into the public eye, you've been fascinated by them. There are so many, all with their individual quirks. So, why not make a place where they can live, and you can live with them? What's the worst that could happen?

Written as a gift for my patrons, who inspired what monsters I would/will write about for this.

Contains:
Chapter 1: Titfuck Present tense Blowjob Romance
Chapter 2: Past Tense, Nibbling, and Vaginal Sex Comedy
Chapter Three: Comfort

Published 2016-11-19 18:10:01 UTC
Last updated 2017-05-03 22:33:44 UTC

Wolfenshy

You smile as the door to your room opens. It’s a full moon tonight, and you were already warned that one of your tenants might come to curl up with you or something. Of course, when they warned about possibly violent possibilities, you had merely chuckled.

Of course, the government idiots were always like that. Ever since you had made this nice, little boarding house, they had warned against it. Monsters were supposed to be dangerous, deadly, and avoided. Not that they could say that that was the reason they told him to avoid them, not with how people were supposed to be living with them.

For you, you found them fascinating. All of these myths and legends that were coming true, and so you had begun to think. There had to be some way to interact with them while showing them that you were friendly. And so, after much thought, and running your bank accounts dry, you had a boarding house that only took them.

And tonight, Fluttershy was supposed to be visiting. A smile crosses your lips as her image appears in your mind. To say she was cute was an understatement. Always shy, always wearing sweaters, she was adorable, despite being just as tall as you, and with a rack that most girls would kill for.

With how kind and innocent the wolfenkin was though, you couldn’t even think about things like…

Suddenly, you were all too able to think about bending her over and taking her doggy style, as in your doorway, in nothing except her fur, was Fluttershy. She blushed, sure, but she also didn’t bother to cover herself. Instead, those large, soft breasts were on full display, brown fur even framing them.

She stepped in, even without you prompting her to, and you could now hear her heavy breathing. She sounded like something was wrong, or like she had been teased for about an hour. Glancing to her claws, you saw no sort of toy or anything, and she didn’t let her brown fur grow long enough to cover her hands.

No, she had just, for some reason, come to your room completely naked. You didn’t dare move though, afraid of either scaring her off, or of the dream ending. Fluttershy hadn’t noticed your open eyes yet, so she crawled onto the bed, her short tail swishing behind her. It only helped to remind you that she also had a great ass, and make the fantasy in your mind grow larger.

Fluttershy slowly pulled at your blanket, letting more of yourself show. For a moment, you cursed yourself for normally sleeping naked, before realizing that she could probably tear anything you were wearing off with ease. Besides, it also let you smile when she gasped.

Then, she replaced one of your fantasies with a whole different one. Soft, squishy mounds pressed themselves against your cock. It was obvious what they were, and you didn’t dare breathe in fear of them moving away. Not that you lower half got the memo, causing the wolf to squeak as your cock slowly got harder between her breasts.

From there, it got… cuter. Not sexier, not too quickly at least, but as your member got primed, Fluttershy seemed to want to respond in kind. However, her pushing down on her chest just squished her breasts more. As you get fully hard, and it seems that her current attempt isn’t working, she does try to move more. And by more, you mean about a centimeter every few seconds.

After watching her failed attempts for a little bit, you lean back and decide to help. With your first thrust, you get a delightful scream terror out of her that is cut off by a loud slap. While you hope she didn’t cut herself with her claws, she comes back to your cock, sliding it between her bosom again.

This time, when you thrust up, there’s only a squeak, but she keeps her bosom there. The next one brings with it panting, just like when she had first entered. And the fourth, comes with a lick on the tip of your member that sends shivers down your spine. Her tongue is what you might have expected; large, wide, and somewhat rough, but it by no means makes it any worse.

You continue thrusting into those soft breasts, enjoying all that is happening. You no longer care about the why, only the what, and that is amazing. Tits you had always known you wanted, a tongue that lapped at you like you were water for a desert wanderer, and moans that told you the girl’s enjoyment.

Soon enough though, licks were apparently not enough for the wolf girl, as she pulled away her breasts. For a moment, it’s a little sad, what with you thrusting into air. What pushed you back down is a growl, along with the girl taking every inch of you.

It’s bliss. Her canines gently rub against the side of your cock, teasing it as it is bombarded by heat, saliva, and that large tongue. As it goes past all of that, it’s treated by the tightness of Fluttershy’s throat as it closes around you. And then, the vibrations. The glorious vibrations that tease every inch of your rod as she moans.

Finally, you move, putting your hand onto her head without thinking, and groaning as you force her to stay at your balls. Your body shakes in time with her, her muffled shout of surprise quickly changing to another moan. It only grows louder as you feel your excitement flow out of you in thick, salty strands down her throat.

And then, just as quickly, you let go of her head, and she rises back up, sitting on her heels as she pants. Her body is now covered in sweat, slicking down her fur wherever it lays against her.body. You reach over, gently stroking her thighs, and whisper, “That was amazing,”

Fluttershy’s eyes almost pop out of her skull at the words, realizing that you’re awake probably. You can feel her stiffening, getting ready to run, before she… relaxes, and blushes brightly. “S-so you… you liked it?”

You nod, smiling at her as you beckon her to lie down. She eagerly does so, snuggling into your chest while her large, bare bosom presses against you. “Of course I did, how couldn’t I? I’m just surprised you could do all of this.”

Fluttershy blushes at your compliment, before looking away. “I… I may have been wanting to for a while, and when the full moon comes out… Well, yeah, we can become more dangerous when we give into our animal side. For me though, it made my want…” She turned bright red and covered her face as she whimpered.

You smile at the gesture, before pulling her in closer and whispering, “Well, know that I would love to be with you like this more often.”

A small giggle escaped Fluttershy before she wraps her arms around you, and snuggles into your neck. “I… I would like that too.”

You both share a smile as your arms come around her, before the night slowly faded away to the two of you sharing one dream. A very pleasant one at that.

Raripire

Ah, the dishes. When you can only rent out to about five or six mares at a time, the dynamic becomes a bit different than a normal landlord and their tenants. If you were completely honest, you ran more of what might be considered a bed and breakfast, or rented rooms of your house, rather than apartments.

And that meant that after the mares left for their jobs, you had cleaning to do. Not that it was bad. In fact, it could even be therapeutic. A moment of silence amongst all the chaos.

At least, on the days when they all had work, which was not often. As for today, two hands slipped around your neck, before a set of fanged teeth scratched your neck. The plate in your hand almost dropped back into the warm water as your body froze up, before you stammered out, “N-now Rarity, you know you’re not allowed to drink my blood.”

The blood red eyes of your residential vampire came into your peripherals. She wore her normal, coy smile, as if she were doing nothing wrong. She leaned back in, pecking your neck again before she whispered, “And what if I was just looking for some tenderness? Some… fun?”

Your eyes lowered with your shoulders. This made the… seventh time? Calling her out on what her fun usually led to was pointless, as she would get huffy until you let her do as she pleased, so the only real course was to allow for her to do what she wanted. On the other hand, for once you were truly in the middle of something. “I have dishes to finish.”

A cloud of purple smoke flashed in front of you, clearing to reveal your tenant in a rather regular state for her when she knew you two were the only ones in the house. A black, satin robe loosely hung from her shoulders and arms, hiding nothing. Her large, perky bosom was on full display, as well as her hourglass hips, reminding you of how she didn’t really need her vampire magic to hypnotize you.

Rarity let out a long coo as her finger slid along her slit, an action you couldn’t help but watch. She then let her arms rest on your arms, smiling as she leaned back against the counter. “From what I can see, I’m completely at your mercy, even though your hands continue their task. All you need is your hips.”

You bite your lip for a moment. On the one hand, she is correct, and you know from experience how tight those folds are. On the other hand, if she gets too close, you wear scarfs for a reason.

Not that Rarity was going to give you the a real choice, not as her eyes glowed and your pants quickly undid themselves. You could run of course, but last time you did that, you ended up with a bat on your face, before a hot cootch to lick. The time before that, hypnotism.

It was one of the reasons why you didn’t plan to have vampires as tenants after this time. They always wanted their food fresh, instead of the plasma pills that were common for their kind to eat. Still, as her magic ran along your shaft, you couldn’t deny the benefits of that craving.

Her hands landed on your hips, pulling you in a little closer. You instinctively leaned back, keeping your neck back as far as you could, even while the tip of your rock hard member pressed against her lower lips. They were already wet, and Rarity gave you the best part of her cravings. Despite her confidence, or how she treated you, when it came to time for their ‘fun’, she looked away with a bright blush.

It was adorable, and you knew it wouldn’t last long, not unless you acted quickly. For a moment, you let the dishes be alone in the sink, pressing your hands on the wall of the sink so you could pull yourself closer. The effect was immediate as you moved forward, pushing half of your throbbing shaft inside of her.

No matter how many times you did this with the naughty mare, it made you shudder. Despite being dead as a doornail, Rarity was as hot as any mare you’d been with, and her folds clung hungrily to you. If that wasn’t enough, her angelic moans were plenty to make the fang marks on your neck worth it.

Now that you’d begun though, you let your hips do the work while your hands fumbled in the sink. As much as you’d like to focus on how good it felt to plunge deep inside Rarity and have her screaming in your ear, you know where that led as well, and you were at least going to try to stop it. Not that it was easy.

Rarity soon joined in with you, her own hips slamming against the sink as she moved and howled. Her body had turned into a trembling mess, her weight mostly against the counter as cried out in euphoria. You never understood how you had this effect on her, but it was definitely an ego boost. Or, would be if, you know, the biting didn’t always come with it.

Rarity’s arms clung close to you as her moans became whimpers, an attempt on her part to regain some of her composure. It was a poor attempt though, as you could feel her large bosom grinding against your chest. They almost were as big as Fluttershy’s, and were pleasantly soft despite how they didn’t sag. Not only that, but like Fluttershy, they were sensitive and her moans doubled in strength as they were grinded against your shirt.

She clung to you all the tighter, her folds becoming like a vice around your cock as her inhuman strength brought every inch of you into her. Her nethers messaged your cock as her hot breath beat against your ear. She was trying to say something, but her whines made it unintelligible. It was probably her trying to let you know she was cumming, something you were just about to-

Shink.

And, for the eighth time now, your eyes went wide, your resistance broke, and your cum flooded her system, as well as your blood. Her body became like a coil around you, threatening to crush you as she moaned into your neck. Of course, as much as you should love this, it’s pretty hard when two needles dug into your neck.

And, just like the seven times before, you don’t really remember when you fell asleep. All you know was that Rarity put you in her room, with another note saying sorry.

Yep. When she moved out, no more vampires. They were simply too much of a pain in the neck.

Author's Note

I'm not apologizing.

Lamia Dash

You frown as you walk into the yard. It’s not an especially cold day out today, no rain, no snow, even clear skies. That’s of course part of the problem, especially when its been that way for a week now.

A few steps take you to a set of wooden doors set into the ground. For most places, it would be a wine cellar, or an extra way out of the basement. Instead, it’s just another room for one of the types of girls you can keep, whether they be bats, spiders, or…

Snakes. A lamia to be specific. She was fun to be around, sure, but also a handful, though that does have its perks… You shake your head rapidly, trying not to focus on such things before you knock onto the doors. “Rainbow? Are you in there?”

After about five minutes, and two more knocks, you open the doors with a sigh. You know she’s fine down here, sure, but she’ll normally respond at least. Not just take her food from the kitchen when no one’s there. It just wasn’t like her.

Nor was to be curled up at the back of the large cave that was down here. The workers had complained a lot when it was installed, as it required going down almost two stories worth of stairs, and then building a wide central area and four adjoining rooms. Since Rainbow was the only one here though, she liked to lounge in the central area, usually sprawled out in the central area, or getting ready to wrap you in her coils when she heard you coming down.

But now she had her coils wrapped around herself, hiding everything other than her tail, which you usually wished she’d do, but this was the one time where some of her habits were acceptable.

You step closer, the crease in your brow growing with each step. He’d walked in on her sleeping many times before, having to wake her up for one thing or another when she’d overslept. Then her vibrant, multicolored tail would stay still, never moving, and the prism-like scales would keep to whatever rainbow they were set as. They gave her away though, as she shifted her tail, fidgeting from your presence and changing the colors slightly each time. “Rainbow, are you okay?”

Whatever response you get is too muffled to make out, and for perhaps the first time since she came three months ago, you have to sit down next to her, instead of being forced to. You lay a hand on her scales, whispering to the center of her mass, “Hey, it’s just me. What’s wrong?”

A head poked up out of the coils, her bright rainbow hair now in view as she looks at you. You give her a smile, but she just ducks her head back down. “Rainbow, it’s safe. You can tell me anything.”

The eye came back up before she finally pushed herself out of her own body. Just as always, you can’t help but take in a sharp breath, otherwise you might lose it. The rest of your tenants are voluptuous girls with tits at least the size of tangerines, if not larger, but Rainbow… she was different. Her torso matched her tail, almost entirely flat, smooth, and glistening with its blue beauty.

And then the most preposterous thing came out of the confident, one of a kind snake. “Why do you bother with me?”

You reach out, shaking your head as you try to wrap your arms around her, but it’s brought with a hard push as she shakes her head. “No! I know what you’ll say, but I want the truth!” Her fangs were bared now, even as her body shook. “I’m a failure. I can’t keep a job. I barely get by in my classes, if I am, and even if I did pass them, what am I supposed to do with this?”

Her tail came up, before slamming into the ground, shaking the underground home with its force. To be fair, you always knew that Rainbow’s anatomy did cause her problems. The others were mostly humanoid, with legs and arms, but the lamia form meant that they faced a lot more problems than the average monster.

It wasn’t a reason for this though. “We will find you something, Rainbow. It’ll just take time to figure out something that works with your body. I promise.”

Rainbow glanced down, as if unable to meet your eyes while she stayed stubborn, as you knew this wouldn’t be the end of it. It never was.

But then, her tail curls around your foot as she sighs. “Look, I… I know you probably have agreements with the government, and you even said you weren’t going to ever take advantage of one of us, but…” Rainbow Dash looked down, but the red on her cheeks were impossible to miss.

When she looked back up, her hair blocking parts of her eyes as she whispered, “Would you please sleep with me? I could really use someone I can… I can say I’m as close as family or… or maybe more right now.”

First, a wave of shame runs through you, before you dismiss it. What happened with the others was their choice, and your say in it had been… limited. You hadn’t taken advantage of them. They were seeking fun to show how close they were to you, or to have fun with a part of their life.

Rainbow on the other hand was wrong in doing this, and while her sleek, petite body would be amazing… “No. I don’t need to sleep with you to be that.”

Rainbow Dash of course didn’t take well to this, but again, you were used to this sort of thing out of the bratty snake. “First you’ll yell at me how I’m being an idiot, and how wonderful whatever it was you were offering or wanted is. I’ll rebuttal with all of the cons, like the emotional scarring that sleeping with someone just because you hope they’ll make you happy that way will do. You’ll deny reason, probably even try to use your habitual nudity to your advantage,” you stop long enough to grab the tip of her tail, which had been making its way towards your leg, “but I’ll do something outlandish to make it obvious I don’t care.”

“And then, after I figure out whatever stupid thing to do, you’ll laugh at me, mock me, and move on, happy that you at least got a laugh. Now, wait while I think of something stupid to do.”

You got maybe half the way up before her tail swept underneath your feet, bringing you crashing down onto the ground. This was of course where she ruled, and before you could even try to get up, her long coils were already around you. She even managed to stop you from yelling about what she was doing by.. Kissing you.

Her lips are warm and thin against yours as her heat presses down upon your whole body. You’ve never been trapped like this, with every way just leading to more of her soft, smooth scales. She’d grabbed you, but for a full coil like this… It was nice, just like the kiss, both things you wish you could admit otherwise.

As Rainbow pulled away, she sniffled, burying her face into your chest as she began to sob. It didn’t take long that your speech on how she acted had done the trick of your normally stupid action, but instead of making her laugh, it cracked her shell. You get to hear about how her family is so far away, how she can’t send letters to them until she does something right, and above all else;

How important you are, proven in better way than the t-shirt she wore to the kitchen the next morning, and the ‘tease’ for later in his ear as she said, “I’d get started working out now, if I were you, because when I have a job, I’m dragging you down there and showing you the five hour mating period for us lamias, and I don't plan to hold back, not when I'll have a lot of thanks pent up just for you.”

As she slunk away from you, your eyes can’t help but look at the hot oil on the pan of bacon you’re making at the moment. One flick and… No, it just meant that you needed to go to the gym starting tomorrow. Besides, Rarity would kill you if you burned your face, and she doesn’t need to promise you to promise to know that for a fact.

Silver lining: Rainbow was wearing a shirt now, and didn’t know about-

“You did what?”

You glance towards Rainbow’s yell, before correcting the silver lining to the one point.

Author's Note

I've been doing a Monster Girl Original Story recently (as in at least 15k in the past four days) and thought it'd just be mean if I didn't do at least a chapter of this. Hope you enjoyed the cute little chapter, and you can click this link to see a teaser for the Original Story I'm doing.