Twilight asks ponies if they have seen Caring or where did they last see Caring. They would've either seen him in his house or at the market. Twilight goes to Caring's house and knocks on the door but no answer. She knocks on his door again. "Hey Caring! You home!?" She says. She knocks one more time but still no answer. She looks through the windows to see if he's in the house somewhere. She didn't see him until she finds him come out of the hallway into the kitchen to wash his hooves. "Hey Caring!" She says. Caring notices and comes to the door.
"Hey Twilight." He says.
"Where have you been? I haven't seen you in town for 3 months." She says.
"Oh. I've been busy these past few months." He says putting a smile on his face.
"Busy with what?" She asks curious.
"Busy with some new spells. I've been testing some new spells." He says. "Why are you here?" He asks.
"I've noticed you've been gone and I decided to look for you so I went to your house." She says.
"Well, I've been here all the time." He says.
"May I come in?" She asks.
"Of course." He says and lets her in.
"Can I see the spells you've learned?" She asks with a smile.
"I wish I could but I'm tired." He says and wipes his head like he has sweat on it.
"Aww. Can you try at least one?" She asks.
"Twilight, I've been busy all day with the spells that they tired me out." He says.
"Oh. Okay." She says and her smile goes away.
"Maybe tomorrow." He says and comes up to her then hugs her.
She hugs back. "Alright. I'll be here tomorrow." She says and smiles again.
"Let's chat. I'll get you something to drink." He says and goes into the kitchen.
"Thank you." She says. She sits down and notices that a book on his shelf is pulled out too far. She looks at it then walks up to it then pushes it in which causes a ladder to show up which leads down to somewhere. She becomes interested and climbs down the ladder and when she reached the bottom it was pitch black. A horrible smell hits her nostrils. "Oh Celestia. What's that smell?" She says. She walks forward, trying to find a light source, and she finds a lantern. She lights the lantern and her eyes widen at what she sees. Blood all over the floor, dead ponies in the corners, a stash of organs in a box, and a whole bunch of sharp objects. Old, rusty, and bloody.
Twilight looks around the room in horror. She finds a knife with blood on it and the blood is fresh. She walks up to a piece of paper on a table, it's a list of various ponies. Most of the names have been marked and some have not. The names were: Vinyl, Octavia, Ms. Cheerliee, Big Mac, Filthy Rich, Lyra and Bon-Bon, Twilight Sparkle, Rarity, and the list goes on. Twilight sees her name hasn't been marked yet. Meaning she might be next. Everypony accept her and the rest of the list hasn't been marked. She turns around and runs to the ladder but Caring was in front of the ladder.
"What are you doing down here? Your not suppose to be down here." He says looking pretty furious.
"What is this Caring? What have you been doing?" She says terrified.
"You've found out where and what I have been all these months. I kill ponies and feed off there organs. I keep the ponies as a doll for my collection. Do you like it?" He points to the collection of ponies.
"No. This isn't right." She says and tries to use her magic to get out of here.
Caring immediately casts a spell on her that causes her magic to stop working.
Twilight notices. "What did you cast on me!?"
"You ain't going nowhere Ms. Sparkle." He says. "I see you also found my list." He says.
"Yeah. What's the list for?" She asks scared.
"The ponies I'm after. I get them at night while they are asleep and I take them down here and kill them and I eat there organs then they will stay down here so they can never be found. Since I am a quiet pony, nopony will ever expect me to do this. I live off of killing innocent ponies." He says. "And guess what Twilight?" He asks.
"What?" She says.
"Your next!" He uses his magic and throws her onto a surgery table with a powerful force.
She groans in pain.
Caring nails her hooves into the table and then nails her wings into the table as well. Blood spurts from her hooves.
She screams in pain. "Ah! Let me go!" Caring puts some tape over her mouth.
He grabs a fresh knife from a table nearby and looks at Twilight.
"Now, let's get started. Shall we?" Caring says.
Twilight tries to break free but it was useless. She was trapped and Caring was going to show no mercy.
Caring stabs Twilight in the chest and cuts open a big hole then pulls her skin off and her organs were visible.
Twilight screams in pain and the sight of her organs makes her sick.
"What organs should I grab? Oh, all of them of course. Your going to die anyways." Caring laughs and starts to rip her organs out.
"Stop! Stop!" Twilight screamed under the tape but it was hard to understand her.
Caring doesn't respond and continues to get her organs out. "And last but not least. Your heart will be most precious gem. I collect ponies hearts and store them down here." He says and presses a button and reveals small jars with other ponies hearts in them. Caring rips the tape off of Twilight's mouth. "Any last words princess before you die?" He says.
Twilight looks at Caring. She was in so much pain. But says. "I hope you get found out and killed for what you have done...You've become a monster Caring." Twilight says.
Caring looks at Twilight and laughs at her. "Oh Princess Twilight. Your so funny. It will take forever for them to find out what I am doing and besides, when they do find out and when I am put to death....." Caring gets really close to Twilight's face. ".....I will just smile." Caring says then yanks her heart out. Twilight screams and dies instantly. "I will always smile." Caring says and puts Twilight's heart in a jar. He removes the nails from Twilight's hooves and fixes her up and puts her with the other dead bodies. "There. Another pony done." Caring marks Twilight off his list and waits for night to hit so he can get his next victim. But who? He got everypony on the list. Time to make a new list.
