Horrors of Sugar Cube Corner, Vol.1

by spiderpony

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Other, Romance, Scootaloo, Adventure, Pinkie Pie, Gore, Dark, Alternate Universe
Length: 4115

Watch as Pinkamina and Scootaloo go on daring adventures

Pinkamina Diane Pie is not your nomral pony. She bakes cupcakes and other kinds of treats. But her secret to her tasty goods is a dash of pony flesh into every bite. She is a killer and a damn good one at that. What happens when a new killer is introduced into the lives of our to blood soaked maidens of death? Well, you'll have to read to find out.

Note: The events that follow in this series spin out from the Pinkamina Diane Pie comic.

Published 2012-07-01 21:14:02 UTC
Last updated 2012-07-03 20:03:53 UTC

Ch.1 and 2

Horrors of Sugar Cube Corner

-Vol. 1-

Ch.1-Ingredient Shopping

The sun slowly glided through the night sky, as another day in Celestia’s kingdom came to a close. Night soon descended on the humble land of Equestria. In the quaint town of Ponyville, ponies have eaten their supper and enjoyed the company of their loving families. Soon after, sleep came and the houses in the small town all extinguished their lights and headed off to slumber. Well…all except one house.

Sugar Cube Corner, the town’s bakery, was still bustling with life. The large store loomed over the adjacent street, casting a mysterious and gloomy shadow. The shop did not resemble what it once was. The wood of the porch was old and riddled with creaky floorboards. The paint, once bright and inviting, had become chipped and faded. Inside, the lights were still on, as work at the bakery has just begun. Light hoofsteps banged about the empty store as a pink pony emerged from a dark basement doorway. Her straight, hot pink mane swished around as she examined her personal effects. She began going through a mental checklist, “Let’s see: rope, check; chloroform, check; sack, check; knife, check; rags, check…Ok, I think that’s everything”, she muttered to herself.

“Scoot’s! I’m leaving,ok? I’ll be back in an hour or so. Take care of everything while I’m gone”, she yelled to the dark passage which led to a basement area.

“Kay, bye Pinkie! Don’t worry, I’ll be good. Love you”, the pony from the basement shouted. After saying her farewells, the pink pony exited the Sugar Cube through the back door and greeted the warm night air.

Pinkamina Diane Pie trotted down the dimly lit streets of Ponyville, making her way to her intended target of the night. It was hard to believe that this pink pony used to be ‘Pinkie Pie’, the bubbly party animal that loved to laugh and smile. Sadly, those who would remember Pinkamina’s former self are all either dead or gone, off doing their own adventures and living their own lives. Now, all she is to the colorful folks of Ponyville is a humble baker that makes delicious confectionary treats for all the hungry townsponies. Pinkie could bake anything, especially sweets. Cakes, donuts, muffins, cinnamon twists; you name it and she could bake it. Her specialty, however, was her famous cupcake recipe. Ponies for miles around would flock to the bakery to have one, and she would often be flooded with orders for two or even three baker’s dozen. She chalks that up to the dash of special ingredient that she puts in all of her recipes.

Shelly (Number 4638) and Salamander (Number 4637), the herpetologist couple who moved in from Trottingham a scant three months ago, slept silently in their bed. They were tired of the city and wanted a quiet place to settle down and have a foal of their own. The door slowly creaks open. A sinisterly soft giggle is uttered…

Pinkinmina made her way to the side window of the house, making sure not to make any noise. The Scales were fresh to the town, and were in the silly mentality that no pony could ever possibly hurt them. It almost made Pinkie laugh on how clueless some ponies can be these days. She cracked open the window and slinked into the den of the small two story house. The den had what most normal ponies had in their homes: a couch, a television, some house plants, and several disgustingly cute pictures of the happy couple scattered about the room. A pile of cardboard boxes filled one corner of the room. The couple still had some unpacking to do and had decided to put that off until tomorrow morning.

Gently, the pink haired devil ascended the stairs to the second floor. From the blueprints of the house that she had memorized, their bedroom was the second one down the hall on the right. An air of caution was exerted as she stealthily made her way to the sleeping couple’s bedroom. Her Pinkie sense didn’t alert of anything, though there was still a strange unease about her…like something about this particular grocery run was different than several ones previous. Silent as a cat, she moved down the hall and made her way to the bedroom. As she reached the door, she gave a small sigh and opened it. To her shock, her victims were already dead. They lie motionless on bloodstained silk sheets, their throats slit open and their bodies cut to ribbons. A bloodstained male unicorn stood over the now dead couple, sporting a pleased grin.

Chapter Two-Invasion of Territory

Pokey Pierce (Number 111) was standing over the two, now lifeless, herpetologists.

“Ah, so good of you to join us Pinkamina! For a moment, the good doctors and I thought you weren’t going to show. Would you like a spot of tea? Some cookies perhaps”, Pokey spoke enthusiastically.

Out of all the ponies in Ponyville, Pinkamina would never have guessed that Pokey Pierce would be a murderous psychopath like her. She hated to admit it, but she was not prepared for this type of situation. Sure, she could fight a normal pony or two, but she was not up to fight a monster. And from the looks of Pokey Pierce, he was a terrifying one at that.

“Oh cute, you’ve killed the new couple from down the street. Forgive me if I’m not impressed. Now, please be so kind as to leave before I lose what little civility I have and turn you into a throw rug”, she coldly demanded. Pokey gave a small grin and hopped down off of the bed.

Pokey said, “Fine, I’ll leave. But only because I have other plans this evening”, and went to exit the room. As he exited, he gave a quick flick of his tail, lightly hitting Pinkie in the face. Letting out a small growl she entered the room and got to work on stuffing the two inside the large burlap sack that she had brought with her.

Scootaloo, an orange filly Pegasus, was playing with their family “pet” Chrysalis, as Pinkinmina grouchily entered their basement lair with her lumpy burlap sack in tow. Scoots merrily trotted over to her friend and greeted her with a big hug.

“Glad you’re back Miss Pinkamina”, Scoots said as Pinkie walked over to a large surgical table. She quickly slammed the table with a hoof and letting out a loud “Fuck”. The sudden noise gave Chrysalis a start and caused her to release a high pitched yelp.

“That asshole! I can’t believe he had the-the gall to step in on my territory. On my targets! How did he find out where’d I be”, the pink pony lamented. She looked down at her assistant, concerned about her caretaker. Before the she could speak, Pinkamina comforted her with a small hug.

“Don’t worry little one, it’s not an issue. Now…who wants to help me make some cupcakes”, asked Pinkamina. Scootaloo responded with an excited “I do! I do”. The two ponies took the first of the two carcasses and put it inside a large bathtub. Wearing surgical masks, rubber gloves, and aprons, the two began their process of dissecting the body.

Scootaloo began, by fulfilling her role and draining the blood (or rather what blood was left) from the body. Though the corpse of Shelly Scales had already sustained a fair amount of bruises and lacerations, she still had to make a few primary incisions and hoist the body upside-down. Pokey Pierce’s work at least made Scootaloo’s job much easier. Once the Shelly’s fluids were drained from her, she was lowered back into the tub. Scoots then took a pair of rusty pliers and removed the teeth. She whistled a merry tune as Shelly’s teeth were forcibly extracted from her mouth. The next step in the cute pegasus’ work was to disfigure the face. Looking at Shelly’s face, which seemed to resemble tenderized hamburger, Scootaloo frowned. Disfiguring the face so the body could not be identified was one of her favorite parts of the job. She tried not to let Pokey’s work take all of the fun out of it and sliced up the face an adequate bit with a small kitchen knife. Scootaloo, now an adorably bloody mess, trotted over to Pinkamina so the dissection stage of their work to begin. The body was placed on a large metal table. Scootaloo gleefully wheeled a cart carrying several medical implements. Dissection was Scootaloo’s favorite part of the baking process. Seeing the flesh peeled away revealing organs and bone and muscle tissue filled her with delight. Pinkamina wrapped her long flowing mane behind her, as so it wouldn’t get in her way. She approached the table and began to examine the body.

“Such sloppy work”, she said in disgust, “if you’re going to kill a pony, at least show a little professionalism. These two probably only lived for five, maybe ten minutes. And they certainly didn’t experience much pain. It’s a shame really”. Scootaloo watched as her mistress went over the corpse. It was truly a spectacle to behold. Almost every inch of the body was examined, looked over with such artistic grace. This was truly Miss Pinkamina at her best. She picked a scalpel and made a vertical incision along Sally’s sternum. She then used a chest separator and split the ribcage open. What she found inside was somewhat strange. Shelly had all of her organs (lungs, spleen, liver, heart, etc.), but something else was there. Behind her heart lie, what appeared to be, a small plastic sandwich bag. After a little tugging she quickly extracted the baggie. Inside the blood covered bag was a small cell phone and a note.

“It appears he isn’t as sloppy as I thought”, Pinkie thought aloud as she opened the zip locked bag. Unfolding the note, it read:

Dear Miss Pinkamina,

I would like to cordially invite you for dinner tomorrow evening. Wait for my phone call on the phone provided for the when and where. Do try looking your best.

Your dear admirer,

Pokey Pierce

P.S. If you do not accept the invitation, you will have a nasty surprise in the form of two of strapping police officers at your door the following morning.

Ch.3 and 4

Horrors of Sugar Cube Corner

-Vol. 1-

Ch.3- Dinner for Two

The Galloping Green is one of the classier restaurants in Ponyville. The restaurant certainly threw around its title as the premiere place to eat, serving extravagant meals to only the wealthiest of ponies that could afford it. On special occasions (and for a staggering price), the restaurant will clear the whole place out and allow a few ponies to dine by themselves and will cook whatever they want.

Pinkamina Diane Pie was once again in uncharted waters. She had never been to such an upscale restaurant before and felt uncomfortable wearing her fancy black dress. She would much rather wear her Berry Punch sweatshirt over the slim number that acquired from Rarity a scant few hours ago. Unfortunately “rules are rules” as Pokey Pierce said in regard to her dress code. With a begrudging sigh she crossed the threshold into the restaurant and was greeted by an overly perky hostess, Bright Eyes (Number 56). She was a simple looking pony, with a white coat and a brown mane dressed in a formal evening gown. Her blue eyes sparkled, even within the dim lighting of the restaurant. If it wasn’t for the existing circumstances, Pinkie would have popped those eyes out of her skull and started ripping out teeth.

“Hi there! You must be Mr. Pierce’s dinner guest for the evening. If you’ll follow me, I’ll take you to your table”, said the perky hostess with an overly jubilant smile. The restaurant’s décor was certainly impressive. The walls were lined with exquisite marble pillars that supported a fresco painted ceiling. The fresco featured Celestia and Luna as they oversee Equestria.Beneath her hoves lie the softest carpet she had ever walked upon. Tying the room together was a small string band playing soft music. If Pinkie were a more emotional pony, she might’ve felt such awe in the display around her. A single table was in the center of the large dining room, with a dark blue unicorn with a white mane seated at it.

“Oh good you came”, Pokey exclaimed, “I was afraid for a second that you wouldn’t show”.

“Like I was given any choice”, the Pinkamina retorted, moving her hair out of her eye as she sat down across the table from Pokey. With a motion of his hoof, Pokey signaled for a waiter to come over and take their orders.

“Good evening monsieur and mademoiselle, what are we having for tonight”, inquired the stuck up waiter in an obviously fake French accent.

Pokey responded quickly, “Yes, to drink, a fine Château la philtre d'amour. To eat, the lovely lady will have the seared pony flank, topped with bacon and sautéed vegetable. As for myself, I will have the liver, cooked medium, with a light peppercorn sauce. Also, a small plate of pegasus wings to split between the two of us. And for dessert, I think we’d both enjoy a slice of Angel Bunny cake”. With a “Very good sir”, the waiter trotted off to the kitchen with their order. A few moments later, the waiter returned with a chilled bottle of the wine Pokey requested. “

As the wine was being poured, Pokey stated boldly,“You’re going to just love this vintage. It’s a ’72 Chardonnay with a touch of A-positive; very playful with one’s palette”. Pinkamina didn’t touch her wine. From her own experience, the best way to capture a pony was to slip them something in their food or drink. The last thing she wanted was to have here night end with a very intense one time session of role reversal. After a few minutes of silence, Pokey Pierce spoke.

“The wine isn’t drugged by the way”, he said swirling his glass. She hesitantly brought the glass up to her lips and poured the dark red liquid down her throat. To her surprise, it was actually quite good. The blood mixed in with the wine really did bring out its flavor.

“See? I’m not that bad of a guy after all”, remarked the blue stallion. Food was swiftly delivered to their table. The spread looked heavenly. Each morsel of food seemed to be bursting with flavor, giving off an intoxicating aroma. With all the plates set on the table, the two ponies anxiously dug into their meal. The cooks did not disappoint. Pinkamina’s first bite was spectacular, as her cut of meat practically melted in her mouth. The two released a simultaneous “mmmm” as they took consumed their first bites.

“So…are you going to tell me why you’ve decided to bring me out here with you”, Pinkie inquired in between bites of her food.

“Simple”, Pokey Pierce said calmly, “We are not like the other ponies Pinkamina. We are more evolved. We eat meat, we cannibalize our own kind. We enjoy murder, because we understand in those sweet few minutes between excruciating pain and death, there is pure bliss--”. As Pokey blathers on, Pinkie slowly moves her hoof down from the table and onto her lap. She slowly pulls her dress up and places her hoof on the knife that was secretly strapped to her leg. Her mind was running scenarios on her best course of action. The most logical would be to slip Pokie’s annoying throat, use the two dinner knives and quickly assassinate the wait staff, eviscerate the band, move on to the kitchen and massacre all inside, and then finally torch the place to destroy any traces of evidence. Suddenly she felt another hoof on her leg. Pokey Pierce rubbed it gently and gave an evil grin.

“I apologize for boring you. I’ve been told that I tend to ramble. Anyway, what I seem to be getting at is…I think you’re a nice pony and I thought I’d take you on a date to get better acquainted with you”, said Pierce innocently. Pinkamina brushed his hoof of quickly and gave a sharp, “This is not a date”, to here malevolent dinner companion. She was about to add a string of colorful insults to her dialogue with Pokey Pierce, but was interrupted by the dessert cart’s arrival. Though the cake was just as delicious as the other food that was served, Pinkie paid no attention to it. All she could do was watch her enemy eat and hope he didn’t try anything before their time was up. After what seemed like hours, Pokey Pierce effortlessly used his unicorn magic to levitate his napkin and gently dab his lips.

“Oh no, it seems you have barely touched your cake. Well, I suppose with a fine meal like that no pony would really have room for such treats in the first place. Shall I have the waiter wrap it up for you”, inquired Pokey. Pinkie merely grunted. Her tolerance for his presence was reaching its maximum. With a small giggle Pokey motioned for a to-go box as he removed himself from his chair.

After giving a small bow he said, “Thank you for the lovely evening Miss Pinkamina. I had a lovely time and do so hope we can meet again. I’ll be seeing you”. He turned and slowly made his way towards the restaurant’s exit. This was Pinkamina’s only chance to end this silliness. Lightning fast, she made for her knife.

Panic sets in. What should be the familiar touch of cold steel was replaced with the soft, tender touch of her own flank. Pokey released a loud burst of laughter and waved her knife behind his back with his magic.

“Don’t worry, I won’t make this one count against you dear”, he yelled, half laughing as he left the restaurant.

Ch.4-Stress Relief
Deep within the confines of Ponyville’s bakery, a wet splat echoed throughout Sugar Cube’s basement followed by an unbearable scream. Bright Eyes, the hostess of The Galloping Green, was being used as a living target for Pinkie’s throwing knife collection. She was in a great deal of pain as three knives were embedded in her abdomen, and two were in her arms and legs respectively. She attempted to release a word and reason with the pink pony, but was cut off by another knife, this time to her left flank. Another shriek erupted from her throat. Pinkamina, now bored with the knives, slowly trotted over to the bleeding pony. Tears streamed down Bright Eyes’. She tried to be brave and show her captor that the pain meant nothing to her and that she was a tough pony. Unfortunately, her trembling didn’t help her cause. Pinkamina rubbed her face with a hoof, wiping away Bright’s present tears.

“Shhh”, she said softly, “You’re much too pretty to cry…Why don’t we fix that”. Pinkamina started to deliver blow after blow to Bright’s face. Each punch felt like an oncoming train. The beating continued for almost five minutes. Bright Eyes’ face now resembled something akin to hamburger meat. Out of breath, Pinkie signaled for Scootaloo to finish the job.

“Golly you sure do look tired. Want something to help”, asked the orange pony. Bright Eyes didn’t say anything. With an inquisitive ear, Scootaloo leaned in to listen for a heartbeat or any other sign of life. A very faint heart beat was heard after an anxious little amount of waiting. Scootaloo produced a taser from behind her back and delivered a quick zap to the captive pony. Bright Eyes responded with a shriek and then labored breathing.

“Oh good you’re still alive. For a second I thought Miss Pinkamina was too rough on you”, said Scootaloo with a big grin. As Pinkie watched on, she realized she had been rather too rough with some of her more recent patients. Ever since her dinner with Pokey Pierce, she’s been a little on edge as of late. In fact, after that night, Pokey was the only thing she could think about. When she drew Bright Eyes’ number, she had hoped for at least some information about her admiring pony.

“Scoots, I’m going to go up and get some fresh air. You can finish up our play time with our guest”, said Pinkie. With an “Okie dokie loki” Scootaloo then produced a hack saw and began cutting off one of Bright Eyes’ legs.

“It’s for our dog”, Scoots said. “She really likes leg bones”. Bright Eyes’ screams filled the room as Pinkie exited the torture chamber. Upstairs Pinkie went to the kitchen and washed the caked blood off of her hooves. She had always enjoyed her work in the past, but lately something has felt missing. “All of this is that damn unicorn’s doing,” she thought angrily. With a small yawn and a glance at one of the clocks in the kitchen, she figured it was time to go to bed. After a quick shower and brushing her long pink mane, she made her way to her bedroom. To her surprise, the little pegasus was already under the covers sleeping. Though Scootaloo was good at what she did, she was never that fast. Suspiciously Pinkie flipped over the covers. Under them were a dozen roses with a card that read “With love From: Pokey”. She tossed the flowers out of the room angrily, muttering curses under her breath. She hopped into bed and prayed that that bastard’s number came up next.

***

The day was finally upon her, as another number drawing was at hand. She quickly jumped out of bed and rushed to her computer, waking up Scootaloo in the process. Scootaloo was always happy to have a new pony to kill, but seeing Miss Pinkamina act in such a way has worried the little filly. For weeks Pinkie has been springing up every number drawing day like a child on Hearth’s Warming Day, gleefully started up the number generator program.

Numbers sporadically flashed on the screen. She twitched whenever a digit in Pokey’s number would pop up. The numbers began to slow down. Pinkie began to sweat and nervously rubbed her hooves together. The numbers fell into place, one after the other, followed by an electronic beep. The screen displayed “Number 111” in big bold font.

“yes…YES”, she shouted triumphantly, cackling with laughter. She picked up Scootaloo and gave her a big, spine crushing hug. Scoots embraced her mentor, glad that the craziness would soon be over and things would be back to normal.

Several hours later nightfall came, and with it Pinkamina’s bloodlust. Taking nothing to chance she put on her old sneaky suit that was hanging in the closet and equipped over a dozen of her sharpest knives. She quickly exited the bakery and made for Pokey Pierce’s house. She trotted hastily down the winding cobblestone streets, looking over her shoulder every few seconds to make sure no ponies were following her. After several tense minutes, she finally reached Pokey Pierce’s residence. To her concern, the door was wide open. She knew that several ponies in town were dumb enough to leave their doors and windows unlocked, but Pokey would certainly never be so careless.

The interior to the house was surprisingly normal. Not much furniture besides a small couch and a television set, but otherwise the home of a law abiding citizen. The house was small, having only a few rooms in the one story dwelling. Nothing registered on her Pinkie sense. Like a shadow, she stealthily crawled through the dark living area towards the bedroom. Shallow breathing could be heard down the small hallway connecting the two areas. Pinkamina gently taps Pokey’s bedroom door with a hoof, lightly pushing it open.

Curled up in soft bed sheets lay Pokey Pierce, her nemesis, sleeping comfortably. She silently draws a knife from her sneaky suit and slowly approaches her sleeping victim. One quick swipe and all of Pinkie’s troubles will disappear. Her hoof shakes. She hesitates. Why is this so difficult for her? Gazing on his face through the soft moonlight, she feels strange. She hovers over him for another few minutes. A feeling similar to what she’s experiencing now is when she is with Scootaloo. It’s similar but somehow…more uncontrollable. Time was of the essence and she had to make an important decision: kill him or leave empty hooved.

She blends back into the night and disappears from the quiet house. To her chagrin, she leaves without a body.