They didn't have a lot of homework to do, but it was still nice having so many people working with her to get it done. Not only did Fluttershy feel like she got done faster, but she also felt like she learned a lot more. Turned out Adagio was REALLY good with History, which was good for Fluttershy as that was her worst subject.

All while they were working, Fluttershy couldn't take her eyes off of Rarity. The way she was sitting on the floor before Fluttershy, her profile, the way her legs bent behind her as she elegantly sat, and the way she leaned forward over her book, letting Fluttershy get a good look at her cleavage.

She never said anything, but Fluttershy wondered now if that was Rarity putting on a direct show for her, or if it was Rarity being Rarity.

Once she finished, Adagio went to change into her cat attire and then curled up on the couch. It was so interesting seeing the sexy and seductive siren acting so cute and docile. When she finished her work, Fluttershy walked over to Adagio and looked at her smiling.

“You can pet her, you know?” Sunset said, catching Fluttershy's attention.

“That's okay?” Fluttershy asked.

“She likes the attention,” Sunset explained, “Besides, right now she's not Adagio the siren turned human. She's Adagio the kitten. Go on. Just do what you'd normally do for a cat.”

Fluttershy nodded to Sunset and then held her hand out. She was hesitant at first, but soon began moving her hands on Adagio's back softly. After a second, Adagio opened her eyes and gave Fluttershy a blissful smile before purring.

Oh my God, it's like I'm with a real cat.

“You like that, don't you sweetie?” Fluttershy asked in the same way she'd speak to the animals at the shelter. Adagio gave a cute “meow” before turning over to her back and stretching, presenting her beautiful front to Fluttershy. From a cat's POV, this was a sign of absolute trust, but considering that Adagio was quite top heavy in her own right, this made this so sexy.

Still, she took advantage and began petting Adagio's stomach, every so often brushing against her breasts. With the blissful look on Adagio's face, it was apparent that she was enjoying it.

“She really gets into it, doesn't she?” Rarity asked Sunset, who leaned back a bit to stretch her legs.

“She does. I can't blame her though. To her, being her real self too much is a bit painful,” Sunset explained looking at Adagio somberly, “She gave me permission by the way, so if you want I can tell you what happened to her.”

“I would like to know, actually,” Rarity said, “She's a huge part of our lives now, but she's still a bit of an enigma.”

Sunset sighed hugging her legs, “After we defeated her and the other sirens, the three of them were in a really bad place. Before they were relying on their magic for just about everything. Sustenance, getting houses, money, all of that stuff. Once they lost their magic, they had no way of moving forward really.”

“That's terrible!” Fluttershy exclaimed, “I didn't know that they relied on their voices so much.”

“Even though they were terrible to the school, I had no idea that we were going to hurt them that badly,” Rarity said turning away.

“It's fine,” Sunset said, “Adagio even admitted that she took things too far with the Battle of the Bands. But you see, after that the other two, Sonata and Aria, had a huge falling out with Adagio, blaming her for essentially ruining their lives. The two of them went off by themselves, and Adagio hasn't seen them since.”

“That explains why we never see the other two in school,” Rarity pointed out, “They don't GO to school, at least not here.”

“So… how did Adagio end up here then?” Fluttershy asked, still petting Adagio, this time to comfort her as she did look a little somber herself now.

“Well, Chainmail came through,” Sunset continued, “She found Adagio when she was at her lowest, took her in, and let her stay in this nice apartment so long as she worked at the shop part time. That was around the time I met Adagio again, and she and I sort of hit it off. I mean, I needed a place to stay too since I had gotten evicted from my place, so when she got me a job here I was able to move in with her.”

“How long have you been living with Adagio in secret?” Fluttershy asked.

“Since the Friendship Games, actually,” Sunset explained.

“So I'm guessing we have her to thank for your sudden nicer sense of fashion?” Rarity asked with a coy smile, making Sunset blush.

“She helped, yes,” Sunset covered, making everyone giggle.

“Um… if it's not too personal of a question to ask,” Rarity said slowly, “Just… how did this happen exactly?”

Sunset laughed awkwardly, “Well, I'm not sure who started it really. I mean, Adagio and I were getting really close. We had a lot of interactions that left me feeling sort of… odd though. On one hand she kind of led me on a bit,” Adagio suddenly hissed at Sunset showing her disapproval, “You know you did, so don't even try it.”

Adagio turned her nose to the air and lied back again, a way of asking Fluttershy for more pets on her stomach.

“On the other hand though,” Sunset continued, “I did kinda initiate the first time. See, back then, she would have really bad emotional episodes, and one day when she was going through one I just grabbed her arm to calm her down. The way she looked up at me sent my mind to an odd place, and before I knew it, well… this.”

“So it was YOU who initiated the relationship,” Rarity said clapping her hands, “I must say, I'm impressed.”

“Over time we started getting a little kinkier in the bed, which when you live above a BDSM store that's to be expected,” Sunset said, “I started sort of conditioning Adagio to be my pet, and then the rest, well, is history.”

Fluttershy looked back at Adagio, taking in the peaceful expression on her face. Knowing that she came from a really bad place made her current peaceful mindset that much more prominent. It got Fluttershy wondering though, what exactly caused this change?

“Well, we're all just about finished,” Sunset said closing her books and getting up, “I say we get started with training. Adagio love, you can stay in the cat persona, but I might need your help with this one, okay?”

Adagio sat up, nuzzled Fluttershy, and then got up from the couch and skipped over to Sunset taking her arm. As they walked into the bedroom, Fluttershy walked over to Rarity and sat down before her.

“So… are you ready for this?” Rarity asked.

“Are you?” Fluttershy asked. Rarity sighed and looked away.

“Honestly, I'm a little scared. The level of intensity for this will be…”

“More than you're used to?” Fluttershy asked rubbing Rarity's arm, “We don't have to do this, Rarity.”

“No, I do want this,” Rarity said, “I want to be a good submissive for you, and I have every intention of seeing this through. But… I am rather terrified.”

That said quite a bit. Sure Rarity freaked out during magical issues, but who didn't freak out from that? Beyond that, Rarity was NEVER truly afraid of anything. So for her to admit that, and for Fluttershy to see such vulnerability from Rarity actually meant a lot to her.

“I'll be right there with you,” Fluttershy said comfortingly, “I'm just as nervous too, so we'll be able to support one another.”

Rarity gave Fluttershy a very odd look, and then did something a little shocking. She leaned forward and kissed Fluttershy tenderly on the lips. They had kissed many times before mind you, but this kiss felt different somehow.

“Thank you, Fluttershy,” Rarity said softly, “Let's go.”

For a few seconds Fluttershy couldn't move. She slowly touched a finger to her lips, thinking about that kiss. Why had she done that, and why did it feel different? Something about that actually made her want to see this through even more.

She followed Rarity into Sunset and Adagio's room, where she actually did a double take. Sunset and Adagio were both putting on black leather leotards, fishnet stockings, and high heeled boots. Adagio had already put hers on, and was now putting on the finishing touches on her darker make-up, while Sunset was zipping up her boots.

Holy fuck, this is terrifying.

“Um…!” Fluttershy cried, “W-w-what are you two wearing…?”

Sunset was the first one to look up at them, and gave them her usual friendly smile despite her dark red lipstick.

“I imagine this is shocking,” Sunset said, “This was Adagio's idea.”

“It's to enhance the experience,” Adagio said, turning to them and crossing her legs, “A woman's power is in her sexuality, and these outfits are meant to show that off.”

“What's the safe word that you two use again?” Sunset asked.

“We use a color system,” Rarity explained, “Green is okay, yellow is slow down, and red is stop all together.”

Sunset nodded, “Alright then, for the time being we'll just use that same system. Now, this goes for the both of you,” Sunset walked over to them and folded her arms, “If at any point either of you feel uncomfortable, or get too scared, please say your safe word.”

“Even me…?” Fluttershy asked.

“Remember, you're going to have to experience submission to a degree,” Adagio said, “As of this training, both of you will have to become submissive to us. In your case, Fluttershy, we'll be building you up so that you can awaken to your true dominant nature.”

“Where for you,” Sunset said to Rarity, “We're going to condition you to become a better, more obedient sub.”

This was starting to get really terrifying, and Fluttershy's heart was leaping out of her chest. They hadn't even done anything yet and already this was almost too intense. Yet, something within Fluttershy wanted to stay. She turned to Rarity, who looked nervous, yet there was still a fierce flame in her eyes. She knew what she wanted, and she was going to see this through to get it.

“Do we have any questions before we start?” Adagio asked, “Once we get started, the only way this stops is if you say your safe word.”

“I do,” Fluttershy said, “Um… why exactly do I have to experience being submissive too?”

“That's so you'll understand the headspace of your sub,” Adagio explained, “Don't worry. You won't suddenly lose your dominant nature. Rather, if this is done right, it will temper it.”

“Imagine it like this,” Sunset chimed in, “In order to build a sword, you have to break down the metal and then remold it into a new form. That's you. We're going to break you down and then build you back up.”

“No matter what, don't allow yourself to break down,” Adagio said caressing Fluttershy's cheek, “Even if it hurts, remember who you are.”

That wasn't going to be easy for Fluttershy. She knew that this was going to be intense, and she might crack under the pressure. Would she be able to hold onto herself? Just as she was about to question that, she felt Rarity grasp her hand tightly.

“You can do it,” Rarity whispered, “You're so much stronger than you know.”

Fluttershy turned to Rarity, and gave her a soft reassuring smile squeezing her hand in response before releasing it, “Okay. I'm ready.”

“She's ready, but are you?” Sunset asked Rarity, “You might not ever be the same after this.”

“True,” Rarity said looking down and tightening her fists, “But maybe that's a good thing. I'm so out of control, and I'm afraid that one day I could seriously hurt Fluttershy. If doing this helps me become a better sub, then I want to see this through.”

Sunset and Adagio both breathed out in relief, “Well okay then. Time to get started. I'll take Fluttershy, so Rarity is all yours Adagio.”

“Alright,” Adagio said. Sunset caressed Adagio's cheek lovingly, and then Adagio ushered Rarity off into another room. Sunset then sat down on the bed, crossed her legs, and then motioned with her finger for Fluttershy to come closer. Fluttershy swallowed nervously and then walked over to Sunset, sitting down next to her.

“Now what do you know about being a dom?” Sunset asked.

“I have the basic idea of it,” Fluttershy said, “I um… know that I'm the one with the power, but… sometimes it just seems like I'm acting rough with Rarity.”

“That's definitely a common misconception,” Sunset said with a nod, “So there's a part of you that's always afraid of hurting Rarity. That's why you hold back so much, isn't it?”

“Hold back?” Fluttershy asked, a little shocked by Sunset's sudden probing.

“She talks to me a lot, Fluttershy,” Sunset explained, “I was the first one she confided in concerning this, and she still consults with me on occasion, so I know that you hold yourself back a lot of times.”

That was true. Some part of her still felt ashamed for everything concerning this. While she did enjoy the feeling, she still couldn't ignore that in any other setting she would be technically abusing Rarity.

“I mean, I guess that's the reason,” Fluttershy said sighing, “I don't want to ever hurt Rarity. I mean, we have our safe word, and I'm always checking in, but…”

“You're still afraid,” Sunset said, “I get it. That's why we're here. So we can break you out of that and help you become a better dom. The first thing is for you to experience her side of things. You're going to be my sub for a bit, and I'm going to help you understand what it is that Rarity feels.”

“Um… h-how rough are you going to be…?” Fluttershy asked slowly, “I'm n-not sure that I can, um…”

“I won't go too rough,” Sunset said, caressing Fluttershy's cheek, “All I'm going to do is give you a taste of what it is that Rarity experiences. First, stand right in front of me.”

Fluttershy nodded and slowly stood up, standing in front of Sunset.

“From the outside it seems like the dom's just abusing the sub, but that's not the case at all,” Sunset said adjusting her crossed legs, “The two have a symbiotic relationship. The dom's job is to give pleasure to the sub, who's trusting them to give them the experience that they're striving for. Do you trust me?”

“I do,” Fluttershy said nodding, “I mean, I am scared, but I know you wouldn't actually hurt me.”

“Alright then,” Sunset motioned with her hand, “Strip.”

Fluttershy blanked out for a split second. Did Sunset just ask her to…

“Y-you want me to…”

“Was I not clear?” Sunset said, reaching behind her bed and pulling out a riding crop, “You're new, so you get one strike, which you just used. So I'll say it again, strip.”

Whoa, her entire air changed. She didn't even use her voice any differently. Somehow though, Sunset became the most terrifying person Fluttershy had ever seen. Maybe it was because she still remembered a time when Sunset was a bully, but suddenly Fluttershy was too afraid to not listen.

That, and Sunset was extremely hot right now.

So she did as she was told, first raising her white top over her head, revealing her large D-cup breasts. Sunset smirked, leaning forward, but said nothing, to which Fluttershy took to mean “keep going”. The next things she removed were her boots and socks, both of which she tossed off to the side. She then lowered her skirt, and then slowly, hesitantly, pulled down her green and yellow panties.

Sunset took a deep breath and then rose up, walking around Fluttershy. She was partially brought back to when she was a junior. Sunset did everything in her power to humiliate her back then, making Fluttershy feel so small. Yet here the setting was different. Fluttershy knew that Sunset wasn't actually like this anymore.

Knowing that, Fluttershy couldn't help but feel sort of aroused from this.

“You're remembering, aren't you?” Sunset asked, running the riding crop on Fluttershy's leg, “Back when I was your bully, how I'd talk down to you, and remind you of what a small little bitch you were.”

Oh… dear…

This is REALLY powerful…

“Brings me back, you know?” Sunset continued, running a hand on Fluttershy's leg and letting her fingers get dangerously close to her flower, “Tell me Fluttershy, when you're dominating Rarity, is there anyone you're channeling in particular?”

“It's… you,” Fluttershy said softly, her legs shaking as she tried her hardest to stay in control, “I've… always tried to channel… you…” she gasped as Sunset's finger lightly hit her clit.

“I had a feeling,” Sunset said, “All the more reason for us to have this moment. Before we continue though,” she leaned in close, “Check in.”

“G-green…” Fluttershy stuttered. Satisfied, Sunset slowly stuck a finger into Fluttershy.

“You might be Rarity's dom,” Sunset said as she fingered Fluttershy, “But here, you belong to me, got that?”

“Yes Miss Shimmer!” Fluttershy cried, eyes closed tightly.

“Haven't been called that in a while,” Sunset said, “I like that. You're going to call me that for the rest of your training.” Sunset pushed Fluttershy onto the bed, and then pulled out a bunch of red ropes and what Fluttershy had read was called a “spreader bar”. The resulting tie was somewhat complicated, and Fluttershy was thrown for a loop. By the end, she was lying face first on the bed, her wrists tied tightly behind her back, and another red rope tied tightly around her waist and arms. Her hips and ass were forced up in the air by ropes tied to her knees and then tied to the bars at the head of the bed. Finally, her ankles were tied to the ends of the spreader bar, keeping them apart.

This position was extremely humiliating. Fluttershy would have to remember it for Rarity later.

Sunset walked behind Fluttershy and lightly whacked her rear with the riding crop. It stung, but it wasn't too painful. Still, Fluttershy couldn't help but wince in pain from that.

“This is a good look for you,” Sunset taunted, “Face down, ass up. I wonder what the other students would think if they could see you in this position.”

Fluttershy closed her eyes, trying to move a bit, but stopping immediately. Sunset was an expert at tying apparently, because Fluttershy couldn't move at all. Struggling was pointless, as she'd get nowhere.

Fluttershy felt Sunset run the riding crop on her wet pussy. She then chuckled evilly.

“You're getting wet,” Sunset taunted again, “Could you be enjoying this? I didn't peg you for being a switch.”

“W-what's a switch?” Fluttershy asked, unable to control her trembling.

“A switch is someone who can play both roles,” Sunset explained, sitting down and rubbing Fluttershy's rear, “Not as uncommon as you'd think actually. Adagio and I switch roles every so often.”

Fluttershy was beginning to realize that she enjoyed this. Not as much as she enjoyed being the one on top, but she was definitely having more fun that she thought she would.

Sunset lightly ran a finger across Fluttershy's slit, making the bound teen moan in frustration. She was getting so aroused, but she couldn't do anything about it! She was forced to only go as far as Sunset allowed her to go.

“You have full control as the dom,” Sunset said, now sticking her fingers into Fluttershy's pussy and slowly pleasuring her, “Your job is to give your sub the greatest pleasure you can, but you get to decide when and how they receive that pleasure. In a full time BDSM relationship, this is taken to another level entirely.

“You see, in that case,” Sunset continued, moving up to grope Fluttershy's breast while still fingering her pussy, “the sub is surrendering everything to you. The two of you discuss the terms, and then you assume the roles of dom and sub fulltime. You'd literally own Rarity.”

“Own… Rarity…!” Fluttershy moaned, feeling herself getting wetter from that thought alone.

“That's what you want, isn't it?” Sunset asked, “To own Rarity?”

“I do!” Fluttershy cried, “I want Rarity to be mine and only mine!”

Fluttershy was forced to cum right there, but not necessarily from what Sunset was doing. More so from her own thoughts. When she came down, Sunset untied her and did something shocking. She lied down next to Fluttershy and hugged her.

“Um… Sunset…?” Fluttershy asked.

“Aftercare,” Sunset said, “It's important after an intense scene. Even if you're in a lifetime relationship like Adagio and I, you always have to provide aftercare by cuddling with the sub. It's a way of resetting, and reassuring the sub that they're safe.”

“I see,” Fluttershy said relaxing now, “I guess that makes sense. I was just shocked by the sudden contact, that's all.”

Sunset laughed softly, but then tightened the embrace, “Hey… I wasn't too rough with you, was I?”

“N-no,” Fluttershy said, “Why? Were you nervous?”

“Well, kinda…” Sunset admitted, “I always channel a bit of my old vindictive self when I'm in dom mode, as Adagio calls it. It's fine with her since she's never seen it, but last year… I was horrible to you.”

“But that's not who you are now, Sunset,” Fluttershy said, turning to face her, “You've more than proven to me and the others that you're a better person now. When I said that I trust you, I meant that.”

Sunset smiled gently caressing Fluttershy's cheek, “I can see why Rarity fell in love with you. You really are an angel inside and out. Only makes me feel even worse for how I treated you back then.”

This time, it was Fluttershy who pulled Sunset into a loving embrace. Yes, she was still naked, yes Sunset was still in her dominatrix outfit, but Fluttershy just felt like she needed this.

“After care is important to both the sub and dom, right?” Fluttershy asked sweetly. Sunset smiled and returned the embrace.

“Now you're getting it,” Sunset said. The two of them stayed like that for a bit longer, and while Fluttershy was comforted by this, she did have to wonder about something that Sunset had said before.

Rarity was in love with her?

Author's Note

I've had this chapter for a while, but I wanted to try and write more before I posted it. Alas, I needed to post SOMETHING this month, so I went with it.

Please support my Patreon.