Their Fluttering Hearts

by Hippogriff Magister

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Human, Other, Romance, Fluttershy
Length: 3450

Samuel confesses his feelings to a certain yellow Pegasus and something magical occurs.

Samuel, an oddity that walks on two legs. Something not even Celestia herself knows about. But, he doesn't mind or care because there is one Pegasus that will always care and accept him. Soon, these two individuals will explore new possibilities and feelings.

Published 2017-01-10 08:00:01 UTC
Last updated 2017-01-10 08:00:01 UTC

Chapter: Awakening Desires

Samuel didn't know how he ended in this world known as Equestria- a land populated by magical talking ponies

But it had been eventful for what it’s worth.

When he had first arrived, he was wondering the Everfree forest for weeks with deaths just a few hours away.

He would've been dead too if wasn't for a benevolent alabaster pony with wings and a long horn that had sensed that something new entered her land. After finding him, she made sure he recovers and survives from his ordeal. He did and in a short span of time as well.

But he didn’t care about that, he was just grateful that someone or “somepony” found him before it was too late. The residents knew this entity as Princess Celestia and she was curious on how he came into her kingdom out of nowhere, considering she had never seen a “human” before.

Samuel really didn’t know either, but he told her everything he knows about his world and in return, she told him abit about hers.

That incident happened a year ago, and from then on, he adapted well in this alien land despite the initial bumps. While he can spend his time roaming Ponyville, a certain event caused the princess to watch over from afar.

A few months ago, a group of ponies tried to kidnap and used him for God knows what, but it wouldn’t be good.

Fortunately, Celestia’s guards heard a struggle in one of the royal bedrooms and managed to thwart the attempt as well as alerting the monarch on what transpired.

The ponynappers were soon thrown in the dungeons for interrogation.

Despite them being put to justice, it was still traumatizing for him. He couldn’t stop shaking from the fear of what might’ve happened if they succeeded or what they could’ve done to him. But what was even more terrifying is that there were probably more of them out there and that scared him for days.

That is until he met her.

The one who help him through it all when nopony else could.

The one that kept him sane.

A shy, timid soul known as Fluttershy. A light-yellow Pegasus with light blue eyes, accompanied with a long pink mane that covered the side of her face as well as long pink tail along with butterfly cutie marks on her flanks.

Although she was frightened and wary of him at first because he was a different species, she still managed to stay with the distraught human and offered him comfort as well as soothing words.

Soon, the fear gradually dissipates every time he talks to her during those days. She was the only pony to be there for him when was feeling scared or is having a hard time adjusting to Ponyville.

Samuel enjoyed her company just as much she did. She was also drawn in by his exotic stature after getting to known him. Plus, she was quite curious about his world- primarily how many species of animal there are.

He avoided the dark and gory details of Earth as well as the animals that are approaching extinction thanks to humans. He didn’t know why, but he just couldn’t say those facts to her. He didn’t want to lose the only friend he had.

Rapidly, days turned to weeks, weeks turned to months, and months turned into a whole year as Samuel and Fluttershys’ bond grew stronger and unbreakable.

They both share some similar traits as many residents soon saw: They were soft-spoken, very kind to those who are in need as well as their immense love for animals.

On some days, he looks at her face and is always happy to see that beautiful smile on her face as well as something else. He didn’t know why, but every time she smiled or grinned at him, his heart did several flips and his cheeks flushed a beet red.

He wondered what’s causing those reactions.

He had never felt that way before. There was just something her that was…appealing to him.

Was it how she cared for animals? Uh-huh.

Her innocent eyes? Most definitely.

Even though she wasn’t the strongest pony around, she always strives to improve and get better? Yep, yep, yep.

It was in that moment he had an epiphany.

He was IN LOVE with Fluttershy.

“But would she hate me for thinking of her that way?”, he thought solemnly.

Samuel knows she is not a bad pony by any stretch of the word. But he couldn't help but think of the worst-case scenarios. Would she reject him outright? Be weirded out by it? Or even…

He shook his head furiously as he got out of the shower, cleaned up and ready for his casual stroll around town.

Thirty minutes had passed since he had freshened up. During his walk, he looked in awe of the scenery. From Sugarcube Corner to Carousel Boutique, it never ceases to take his breath away.

But there was only one place he was looking forward to going to- Fluttershy’s cottage. While not as colorful as Sugarcube Corner or as spacious as the Boutique, it had a homey feel to it and he loved that about her.

He’s been thinking of various ways to say that he has an interest in her since the revelation days ago, but he doesn’t how to do it.

Should he just be blunt and say it to her? Or give her subtle hints?

His questions were answered when he heard somepony singing a calming tune that seemingly washes away all his worries.

He used the tune like a beacon to help him find his destination. Soon, after coming out of a large bush, he was seeing the familiar cottage as well as the mare that stole his heart.

Her long pink mane was dancing in the soft blows of the wind, eyes that sparkles with joy, and fur shining in the morning rays. A smile soon adorns his lips as he saw her perform.

Her beautiful vocals fill the air and he couldn’t but sigh softly as he just melted onto the ground as he marveled at what he was witnessing.

After a few minutes, she soon descends to the grass, twirling her body as unusual birds surrounded her as she is finishing her encore.

“She’s so amazing”, He thought internally as he just stared at her for long seconds.

Yeah, that’s not normal in the slightest. But did he care? Nope.

Then suddenly, her blue orbs locked with his and time seems to stop for the both of them.

A smile soon appeared on her face as she saw Samuel.

Her Samuel.

She blushed furiously as she at the thought as she descends to the ground, finished with her performance.

Samuel got up from the grass, brushing the dirt from his pants from the front to the back.

Fluttershy trotted slowly to him and stopped immediately as her eyes examined his tall lean form.

His long curly blond hair that reached to his shoulders reminded her of the mane of a young manticore. His dark coloration of his skin made her think of hot cocoa that she sips on a cold day. Then his eyes, two completely different colors. His right eye was a grass green while his left was an aqua blue like the clearest water from the streams she usually finds in the Everfree Forest.

Never in her life she thought that a creature like him could be so intimidating, yet so gentle, kind, soothing and…

She didn't realize her mind was trailing off until she looked up and sees Samuel looking at her with a slightly worried look.

“Um, are you okay?”, he said, walking toward her. “You were spacing for a while there’

She shook her head, erasing those thoughts from her head as well as the blush that was riding her cheeks. She then looks up at him with a sheepish smile.

“I-I’m fine Samuel”, she said softly.” Just a little, umm.. “under the weather” as you say it?”

Her answer made him smile as he crouched down to reach her level.

This action made her giggle a bit. Even when he was kneeling, he was still taller than her.

But his size didn't fill her with fear. It made her feel safe and protected from anything outside force that would harm her.

“It’s good to see you Samuel”, she said as she walked over to him and seemingly by instinct, wrapped her forelegs around his neck in an affectionate manner.

He responded in turn by wrapping his arms around her middle, but was careful not to accidentally hurt her. He loved the hugs she gave him as they reminded his mothers’ back home.

Home.

Even though he missed his world, he wanted to live in the now instead of the before. Besides he has friends and potentially, a mare to spend the rest of his life with hopefully.

“You too butterfly”, he replied as he looks at the Pegasus he had an attraction for.

The blush returned with a vengeance as he called her that. This causes her to bury her muzzle in his warm chest, trying to hide her embarrassment which causes him to laugh slightly.

“Hey”, he spoke in a soothing tone “Don’t hide your face Fluttershy, I want to see that beautiful face of yours.”

Saying that made her blush until her face was as red as an apple.

Also, Samuel’s face also turned a bright red as he realized as he had just said.

“Smooth bro. Real smooth”

Fluttershy slowly looked up at his face cheeks still flushed, but a beautiful smile was plastered on her lips and it put him at ease. She likes it when he calls her that, even though it sounds a lot like her name.

They then looked into each other’s eyes for quite a while and no words were said from their maws. Just staring was enough for them.

Both soon realized that were embracing each other a lot longer than they expected and they both slowly but, reluctantly let the other go.

It was hard for Samuel to let go of her.

But little did he know, Fluttershy felt the same way. She didn’t want the hug to end either.

Silence soon follows as the pair just glanced at each other and look away just as quick with red cheeks.

Fluttershy played with her mane absentmindedly with one of her hooves, and Samuel just scratched his neck nervously as he was trying to find a way to break the ice.

The silence quickly gets awkward.

Before he had a chance to speak, she responded.

“How was your day?”

“Uh”, he was numb for a moment. “Oh, right. It was normal I suppose. How was yours?”

Not the response that he was thinking in his head, but he was still tongue tied.

“Oh, it was amazing!”, she replied with a joyous smile, “These new species of bird seem to drawn to singing!”

He then looked at the birds that were flying: they almost look like doves but larger in size, has a grey coloration and had vibrant blue eyes.

He smiles as she talks about the birds. Then one of the smaller ones was seen perched on his shoulder. Surprisingly, their talons didn’t sink into his skin as he had expected.

He scratches its head, eliciting a cooing sound from it. Fluttershy looked at what he was doing and her heart swelled at the sight.

Their eyes met once more and this time, he saw an emotion in her eyes that sent his heart aflutter.

This was it. Time to tell her.

“Hey Fluttershy”

“Hmm?”

He swallowed hard.

“Do you... do you have a boyfriend by any chance?”

“You mean a… a coltfriend?” She replied shyly, half of her face covered from her mane.

He nodded.

“No”, she said “Not many stallions are interested in a mare like me because I’m not like the others.”

She looked down with a depressed look on her face. Samuel didn’t like her looking and that and frowned as he moved a little closer to her.

She kept talking.

“I’m not strong like Applejack, not as beautiful as Rarity, fun like Pinkie, fast like Rainbow Dash or smart like Twilight.” She looked even more dejected than before “I’m just me.”

He couldn’t take it anymore. He got up and when he was close to her, wrapped his arms around her waist.

She gasped breathlessly as she looked at him. She saw an intense emotion in his two beautiful orbs that overwhelmed her.

“S-Samuel what are y- “, her words were cut off as his soft lips landed on hers.

She was initially shocked at his action but gave in faster than anticipated and mewed softly in his mouth. His hands were rummaging around her soft, silky mane with such tenderness that nearly caused her to faint.

The kiss only lasted for a few seconds, but to them, it lasted an eternity as the pair gasped for air.

Their foreheads touched as they gaze at each other, searching for something that only they know the answer of.

Fluttershy licked her lips slowly and his eyes followed the movement with a heated stare.

At that moment, he felt a heat down his groin that was gradually getting hotter by the second. But he knew he had to be gentle with her. There was something innocent about her and didn’t want to overwhelm or hurt her.

That was something he didn’t want at all.

“S-Samuel I -”, She spoke, a bit breathless.

He placed her on the grass gently as he gazed at her with a plethora of emotions.

But the strongest she saw was love.

Love for her.

Only her.

She then looked between his pants and saw a rather large bulge that caused her blush furiously.

“Oh my”, She thought as she looked at it curiously.

He smiled as he spoke to her.

“Fluttershy, you do this to me”, he said point to his slightly twitching erection in his dark brown pants, “I don’t want anyone else but you. Ever since I almost got abducted, I was scared and paranoid that it would happen again and no one would save me. No one comforted me.”

He shut his eyes, seeing that memory surface. He then felt a soft hoof on his left cheek and slight sniffling.

He sighed softly as he placed his hand on her outstretched hoof. He continued talking.

“Then a certain Pegasus saw me in that state and trotted over to me, even though she was terrified of me.”

“Mmhmm”, she whispered as tears fell from her eyes.

“But she helped me anyway. Helped me become the person I am today and I am grateful for that.”

He lowered his and his nose touched her and they began to nuzzle affectionately for long seconds.

“And soon, I fell in love with- “

He didn’t finish as his lips were quickly sealed by her own as she lunged at him making them fall to grass in a heap with Fluttershy on top of his chest.

This kiss was much longer and passionate than the last one but no less gentle.

Their tongues danced as soft moans escaped from their maws. Soon his hands went down to her soft curvy flanks. She moaned and shivered from the sensation of his digits on her.

Then, his rod was now fully prepared to please its mare.

“That looks painful”, she says point to your throbbing digit. “Mind if I... um help you out?”

Seriously? This causes him to moan aloud.

“Oh, fuck all” .

Slowly and cautiously, he takes off his pants revealing his dark skin as well as his sheath to her. She looked on with increased interest.

Soon his hard pole was out of its cage and was presented to her, dripping precum and standing at the ready.

Fluttershy looked at it with lust, curiosity and perhaps a bit of fear.

Samuel senses her trepidation immediately and looks at her with an understanding look.

“You know you don’t have to prove yourself to me, we can wait until you’re ready.”

She shakes her and with a look of determination, made her decision.

“I want you”, she replied her expression not falling in the slightest.

“All right”, he complied “But I have to prepare you.”

She tilted her head adorably.

“What do you- eep!”

One of his hands rested her lower abdomen and squeaked from the odd sensation down there.

But it was a good feeling.

She then fell on her back revealing her wet slit to him. It was too much for him but he held on.

For her sake.

Fluttershy let out a short moan as one of his digits explored her inner walls, feeling her crevice.

Two fingers and then three.

The mare arched her back and bit her forelegs to muffle her pleasure. He can see it in her eyes. She wants him to keep going and that’s exactly what he’ll do. Her pleasure comes first before his own even though he wants to be balls deep inside her right now.

He’ll hold on though. He’ll wait until she comes.

He didn’t have to wait long as he felt her first orgasm and felt her liquids flooded his fingers as he finishes.

She was breathing hard. She never felt anything this good before in her life.

“That was amazing”

He smiled back at his mare. “Don’t worry. I’m not done with pleasuring you yet butterfly.”

His once calm and soothing voice turned to a husky, gruff tone from the lust he feeling.

She shivered in delight as he said that to her.

He then slowly glided the tip toward her marehood. He had to be careful while doing this. From the look in her eyes, this was indeed her first intimate experience with a male. So, he calmed himself as much as he could and caressed the sides of her face with his hands as his face inches from hers.

“Are you ready?”, he whispered his even deeper than before.

She nodded.

“I want to feel you inside of me.” She whispered back, her voice losing that innocent tone and had a sultry edge to it.

Slowly, he thrusted into her. A loud gasp escaped their mouths as her tight honeypot was clamping down on his manhood hard, not letting him go at all. It took every ounce of willpower not the cum right there. He then retracted and thrusted back in, this time a bit faster.

She couldn’t stop the sensual sounds from escaping from her muzzle as she moans and whimper as her senses where heightened to point where she couldn't think. She could only feel.

The thrusts soon became faster as he now got a rhythm and had no plans of stopping anytime soon.

The sounds of their pleasure filled the sky as they panted, moaned, groaned, and whined. Time wasn’t even an issue as they went at it with reckless abandon.

But everyone has a limit.

Soon he lost control and with one final thrust, his seed lathered her insides with its warmth and her marehood tightened around him, wanting every drop of her lovers’ essence. A full minute has passed and his body was entering a state of fulfillment and exhaustion.

Then, his hard steel popped out of her as he watches with a state of pride as he saw his cum flowing out of her slit.

He landed on his back breathing hard as she crawled on top of him not taking her eyes off him.

She shuffles closer to his chest and rested her head underneath his chin, nuzzling him affectionately.

“I love you Sammy”, she said satisfied at their first sexual experience.

He draped one of his arms around her middle and kissed her forehead causing her to coo softly.

“And I you, my beautiful butterfly.”

After their love making, the two soul-mates simply looked at the sky, snuggling affectionately as the birds were flying around them with curious gazes.

They didn't really understand what cause them to feel the way they feel towards the other.

Was it fate?

Or something else entirely?

They didn't have the have the answer nor did they want to find it. All they know is that they are one,

Now and Forever.

Author's Note

Another clop for you guys.
Unlike the other one which was hot and steamy, this one was slightly more tame and cheesy.
Didn't know if I did well on this one but I think I captured Fluttershy's personality well.
Positive criticism is recommended.