“T-that b-bow would look really c-cute on you Spring.” Star said with her usual stutter, referencing the deep blue bow that Spring was looking at. Star walked towards her friend, blue eyes shimmering with a friendly light. “You should g-get it.” Spring smiled back at her friend.

“It’s so expensive though. I don’t have a very big allowance you know.” Spring grinned up at the shops pony, “Thank you, but I don’t think I’ll be buying anything today. Come on Star.” She was most of the way out of the shop before she noticed Star wasn’t following her. “Hey Star, you coming?”

“In a bit, I just w-want to look around a b-bit more!” Star yelled back. Shrugging, Spring closed the shop door, and leaned against the brick wall. The bustle of Canterlot was in full afternoon swing. The loud clatter of hoofs on cobblestone and the smell of the sweat of hundreds of ponies on a hot day pervaded the air. Spring frequently found herself getting lost in the buzz of the city, especially the upper districts like this.

“Excuse me. Miss?” Turning her eyes towards the voice, Spring saw a large white stallion smiling at her. “Hey, do you know where I might Grand Accessories?” Spring laughed, and pointed to the sign over her head. The stallion’s face turned red in embarrassment. “Ha ha, I guess I found it, thank you miss….”

“Spring.” Came her curt reply.

“Miss Spring.” He finished as he walked inside. The stallion had to quickly move to the side as Star came running out in a flash of red. She threw back an apology, but didn’t even bother turning around. Spring chuckled at her friend’s enthusiasm, as they began to walk away from the store, but her face grew more serious when she noticed why Star was so excited.

“T-Tada!” She was beaming as she presented Spring with the bow.

“Showing off your family’s money again I see.” Spring replied in a cold tone that was desperately masking how elated she was. Star’s face became concerned.

“I-I wasn’t trying t-to sh-show off. I just wanted to d-do something to make you happy. To, you kn-know, return the favor for once.” She replied, then her smile returned. “N-Now let me help you put it on.” Unable to hid her excitement anymore, Spring squealed joyously as she felt Star’s magic fit the bow onto her tail. She looked back at the blue fabric with an unhidden grin, and when she looked back up she noticed a similar pink bow by Star’s right ear. “I bought us a m-matching p-pair.” Spring grinned up at her friend.

“You really didn’t need to do this, but, thanks.” They walked for a while in relative quiet, the path to Spring’s house went through a relatively quiet part of town. Because it wasn’t a very reputable part of town, Spring liked to keep her eyes open. Which is how she noticed that the white stallion from earlier walking some distance behind them. “Hey Star, do you recognize that guy?”

“Hm?” Turning to look to where Spring was pointing, she saw the stallion. “I don’t think so. W-Why?” Spring just shrugged it off. Maybe he’d just moved in nearby. Pushing it out of her head, she resumed talking to Star about school.

It was raining that morning. Even though Spring had on a raincoat, the pegasus was still getting pretty soaked. Star was trying to use her magic to keep the umbrella over both of them, but kept unconsciously moving it to just over her own head. The sun hadn’t even been raised yet, Spring thought miserably.

“Do we really need to be out in this?” Hearing the irritation in her friend’s voice, Star shrunk slightly. Spring winced as she realized that she probably spoke to harshly for the timid filly.

“Tr-trust me, you’ll think this place is r-really nice. Mommy took m-me there w….”

“Help….” A very faint whimper echoed out from the nearby alleyway. Spring heard it immediately, and stopped dead to listen. Star opened her mouth to ask what was wrong, but then, “Please, Somepony?” Star looked to Spring with a pleading expression.

“Woah, hey, Star. Maybe we shouldn’t just run into the dark alley. We don’t know what’s going on, we should grab an adult first.” Despite Spring’s insistence, Star was clearly worried.

“B-but, there’s no pony around. We need to at l-least see what’s wrong.” Another croaked call for help echoed from the alley, and Star’s eyes glistened with worry. “P-Please Spring?” The green filly groaned. Star was probably right.

“Ok, but stay behind me.” Spring probably didn’t really need to say that, as Star shadowed her as she moved forward. The two slowly walked into the alley, rain muffling the sounds of the city as they went. Curled up among some garbage bags was a black pegasus, he seemed to be clutching at his side. As the fillies got close, Spring stopped Star. She was skittish about approaching a strange pony, and she called out to him from a few strides away. “Hello? Are you…what’s wrong.” The stallion looked up at the two of them, and grinned. Sensing something wrong, Spring made to turn around, but was greeted by the white stallion from the previous day. A sudden fear building up in her gut, she tried to grab Star and run out of the alley, but her mouth was quickly covered in a strong-smelling rag.

“Sp-Spring?!” Star stared in horror, too scared to move. The black stallion was able to walk right up to her, as her friend’s eyes glossed over in unconsciousness, and Star just looked up at him fearfully, her hooves anchored in place. “P-please d-don’t humph.” A rag was shoved over her mouth, as the stallion pinned her hooves to her side.

“Will you just shut up and finish securing that hoof?” Star wasn’t sure whose voice she was hearing. She wasn’t really sure what was happening at all, her head was too hazy to focus much. She felt something fit over her left hoof, and her eyes drifted open to see what it was. The white stallion from before was wrapping some kind of cuff around her leg. Sensing movement, he looked up at her. “No, seriously hurry. She’s waking up.” It was like somepony had flipped a switch in her head. Suddenly she was lucid, and keenly aware that she was being tied up. With as much force as she could muster, Star started pulling at the still loosely secured restraints.

“S-stop, let me g-go. What are you doing?” Moving quickly, the white stallion and a brown one to her left finished tightening the straps holding her down. Star continued to ineffectually pull at them, her eyes beginning to tear up in fear. “Mommy, help me! Spring, please hel…nnnn!” She was interrupted by a bit being pulled into her mouth, and secured tightly around her head. Tears were beginning to fall down Star’s cheeks as she looked up at her captors, fear very evident in her eyes.

“You sure you don’t want to have a go at her? She is a real cutie.” The white stallion said as he placed a hoof gently on her shoulder. Star whimpered nervously at the contact. The brown unicorn responded nonchalantly.

“Eh, she is, but I want to try out the other filly first. You have your fun.” He winked as he turned to leave. The other stallion shrugged, and then began messing with the bit gag in Star’s mouth. Once he was sure it was tight, he turned her teary face to look at him.

“It’s ok, don’t cry. I’m just going to get what I want, and then I’m going to leave you alone for now. Do you understand what’s happening to you?” Star shook her head as the tears finally broke and rolled slowly down her cheek. “Oh, well then I’m sorry that you have to learn like this.” He had moved until he was standing behind her, and Star yelped in surprise when she felt his hooves rest on her butt. “Of course, I can’t be too sorry. After all, I do love breaking in new guests.” Star felt an alien sensation as something began pushing up towards her slit. Before she could wonder what Tinker was doing, she got her answer.

Although Tinker moved slow and tried to be gentle, it still sent a sharp pain through Star. As the cock slid in and out of her Tinker rubbed his hooves along her thin legs and around her body to her skinny stomach. Whining into her bit gag, and crying pitifully, Star let out muffled pleas for Spring to come save her, to protect like she always did.

In another room of the building, Spring woke up from a quick slap. The sting fresh on her cheek, her eyes drifted open to see a form standing over her. She tried to speak, but the ring gag in her mouth made that impossible. As her memory came back, a sick feeling overtook her. She fought to keep herself from crying, as she met her captor’s gaze with what she hoped was a fierce look. Umber just laughed down at her.

“Aw, look at you. You think you’re scary.” His hooves stroked her mane, going down the middle and along her pigtails. “I like what you did with your hair.” He said with a dark inflection in his voice. “Pigtails make wonderful little handles.” Spring was unsure of what he meant until, she began to push his erection towards her mouth. She tried to shake her head, move it aside so that she could avoid the inevitable. Umber just gripped her pigtails with his magic, and pulled her head towards him. The ring prevented Spring from biting down as he shoved his way into her throat. The long erection slid along her tongue and down her throat as Spring retched slightly. She fought angrily to pull herself free, only succeeding in hurting her head as Umber yanked back into position her by her blue hair.
As was his tendency, Umber got straight to business and was soon furiously fucking the little fillies face. Tears were flowing from her eyes as Spring lost her fight for composure. Trying to put what was happening to her out of her mind, Spring’s thoughts turned to the comfort of Star, and then darkened horribly. ‘Oh Celestia, they have Star too.’ Her crying worsened as she realized that her best friend was probably going to go through this too.

“Ah, your throat is so good; I’m going to cum soon. Make sure to drink it all, it’s your first meal here and you shouldn’t waste any of it.” Umber kept pushing, his balls repeatedly brushing against her saliva covered chin. The slowly building feeling reaching a fever pitch, as he finally hilted in her mouth. His magic pulled her down firmly, and she retched as he shot his cum into her mouth. She coughed up as much as she could, but the gag made it difficult. Smiling down at his victim, Umber shot her a quick comment before he left. “I enjoyed that quite a bit. I hope you did too, because you’re going to be doing it again tomorrow.”
He began to untie her, and after he got her first hoof free she tried to hit him. Ducking out of the way, Umber responded with a more accurate slap. When he was sure she wasn’t going to fight back again, he finished untying her. Once she was free, he gestured towards the door and led her out into the hall. Umber opened the door right next to the one she had woken up in. Immediately, the sound of broken sobbing filtered out.

“Star!” Spring tried to rush in to help her friend, but Umber held her back. Star looked up at her friend with a pleading look. She tried to beg for help through her gag, with little success. Tinker ignored the two of them at first, his eyes shut as he humped the crying filly. After a few minutes, with Spring fighting to get free the entire time, Tinker gasped. Star whimpered as she felt something warm shoot into her body. The stallion pulled himself out to her relief. Then he patted her head apologetically, and nodded to Umber. Understanding, Umber finally let Spring go. The green filly ran to Star’s side, ignoring the sound of the door closing behind her. Working quickly, she pulled the bit out of Star’s mouth. She was immediately greeted by Star’s tear filled voice.

“Spring, thank you. I…I knew you’d come. Please, p…please t…tell me you know how to get us out of here. H…He d…did t….” Spring interrupted her with a hug, holding Star close.

“I will. I’m not sure how yet, but I will find a way to get us both home. I promise Star.”

“FUCK!” Onyx looked up from his newspaper in mild surprise at the sharp yell. He could hear Umber yelling something, followed by the familiar sound of Spring yelping as he slapped her. Soon Umber stormed into the living room, blood oozing from his right forehoof. Marched into the kitchen and returned with a towel pressed to the bite wound. Glaring at Onyx, he pointed in the direction of the room they kept Spring in. “Two weeks. Two fucking weeks and she’s still unreasonable. Why haven’t you done anything about this, mister expert?”

“Well, for one thing, it’s pretty damn hilarious how you never seem to learn a fucking thing. How many times has she bitten you so far?” Onyx laughed as Umber’s face flashed red in rage. “Ok, calm down. I’m just joking. Don’t worry, I have the perfect idea in mind for how to control our little pet. Go into the basement and blindfold the littler one. Don’t bring her up until I say though.” Umber grumbled a bit, but did as he was told.

Spring was carried into Onyx’s room. She’d been taken here a few times before, as Onyx used some of his toys on her. She was expecting something similar today, and despite her inner dread, would have taunted the stallion for his unoriginality if it weren’t for the tape over her mouth. To her surprise though, Onyx didn’t carry her to the bed, but instead plopped her down in the closet. Once she was down, he began tying her hooves to notches on the floor, and then curled up behind her.

“You’ve been an undisciplined little filly. As fun as it’s been watching you fuck with Umber, eventually I’m going to need you to behave. Since you still won’t do as you’re told, I have a special little punishment in mind.” He briefly stepped out of the closet, and Spring noticed a slight shimmer as he did. The closet had the same sound proof field around it as the rooms downstairs. Onyx seemed to motion to somepony outside the room, and then he stepped back in behind Spring with an excited grin. He looked down at her. “Don’t worry, the sound proofing here only works one way. We’ll be able to hear everything.”

On the third day, Tinker had been nice enough to return the backpack that Star had been wearing, allowing her to enjoy her favorite hobby again. Since she barely ever saw Spring, her art had become her biggest source of comfort. The drawing she was sketching now was elegant, and certainly a bit of wish fulfillment. It was her and Spring, back in Canterlot, eating dinner with Spring’s family. She sincerely hoped that Spring would get to go home to her family again. Her parents were likely just as worried as Star’s. Umber stepped into the room with a grin on his face. Star’s eyes welled up as she wondered what he had in mind for her this time.

“Come along little one, I need to put this on you.” He said, holding up a blindfold. Knowing better than to refuse Umber of all stallions, Star nodded, and her vision became blackness. The stallion led her silently down the halls and up the stairs to the main floor. They paused briefly, but after a minute or so he continued to lead her. “Ok, climb up.” Reaching out, Star could feel the bed in front of her. The first few tears that fell were absorbed into the blindfold as she climbed up, and waited for the inevitable. Umber tied her forehooves to the front of the bed, and then latched a spreader bar onto her back hooves. ‘That’s weird, they haven’t used one of those in a while.

“W…What a…are you going to d…do this time?” She asked, beginning to become nervous. Umber just laughed, and she heard him pick up something. Star whimpered fearfully, but that turned into a yelp as she felt something thwack into her backside. “What w…was that?” She didn’t get an answer, Umber just brought the paddle down harder as Star shouted. “Ow! W…What, what is this?” This time, Umber truly spanked the filly. She screamed, and he swung again.

Sping’s eyes were screwed shut, as she tried to shut out her friend’s desperate screams. The deep feelings of horror rising up in her throat worsened along with Star’s sobbing. Any attempt to put what was happening out of her mind failed soon after.

“Why? W…Why are y…you doing this? I was good, I d…didn’t do anything wr…wrong. Help! Please S…Spring, help me!” Star’s frantic yelling did little, as her ass began to turn a bright red. Spring began to cry, and Onyx grabbed her head and turned it towards him.

“This is what happens when you misbehave. Tell you what, if you agree to be good in the future, I’ll tell Umber to stop spanking her. He’ll still have sex with her of course, but that’ll hurt a lot less.” Spring nodded furiously.

“Ok, ok. You’ve made your point. Just please, stop him.” Victorious, Onyx exited the closet, and when Umber turned to him, he gave a quick nod. The other stallion put the paddle down, and rubbed Star’s red butt cheeks while the filly whined in pain. Giving her no time to recover, he entered her as she cried softly.

The sore sensation in Star’s backside sent sharp jabs of pain through her body every time Umber pumped into her. At least he had stopped spanking her, this was far worse. To her embarrassment, the spanking had actually caused her to get slightly wet. At least that made this less unpleasant than some of the other times she had been used. A small wisp of pleasure began to shoot through her body as the stallion pushed into her. Umber had his hooves on her pained backside as he worked.

Star was only sniffling now. The cock moving through her body was getting quite the reaction out of her body, and she was beginning to breathe heavily. Umber seemed proud that he was pleasing the filly as much as he was, and his pace quickened. He was getting close, and he leaned down to position himself more in line with her body. The slapping of their hips, each accompanied by a squeak from Star, became more rapid. With a squeal, Star felt herself cum. A deep sense of shame washing over her as she felt her juices gush out onto the bed. Only moments after, she felt the stallion’s warm cum coat her insides. Star sobbed quietly, and unknown to her, so did Spring. It was quiet aside from the girls’ sobbing for a few moments, until Tinker entered the room looking furious. Star looked up at him.

“Why? What d..did I do? You said you w…wouldn’t hurt me if I was good.” Tinker was red with fury, but he spoke calmly.

“You didn’t do anything wrong, but your friend has been misbehaving. Somepony here thought it was a good idea to undermine me, and hurt you to get at her.” He stomped over to the closet, and to Star’s shock he pulled out a tied-up Spring. He untied her, and then did the same for Star. “I’m going to let you two talk for a bit. Don’t let how this room looks deceive you, it is just as secured as your rooms. If I find either of you tried to escape, I’ll do far worse to you than what you just experienced. Now, I am going to go have a word with my so-called boss.” The door slammed shut as Tinker stormed out. Star was huddled in a ball when Spring pulled her into a warm hug.

“When are we going to get o…out of here?” Star pleaded as her friend held onto her. Spring squeezed her shoulders in sympathy.

“Star…I don’t think we are.” Spring could feel the smaller filly stiffen under her hooves at the words. Star looked up at Spring in horror.

“But we have to. You said you would th…think of something. You p…promised me.” Spring just looked at the floor, not meeting Star’s eyes as it dawned on Star what this meant. Star hugged her lower hooves to her body. “I’m g…going home. I am.”

The two fillies stood next to each other. They had been instructed not to talk to one another, and after three weeks they had both learned better than to argue. Onyx approached them with a calm smile on his face. He looked them over briefly before he began to speak.

“It has been wonderful to have you girls over, but it is getting close to time for you to leave us.” He noticed the confused looks on their faces, but he kept speaking before they could ask questions, “So, I have been exchanging a few letters over the last few weeks. A good friend of mine in Baltimare is looking to buy a new filly. She recently bought a little pegasus from me, and was pleased enough with her purchase to want more from me.” The two fillies deflated as he spoke, but he wasn’t done. “However, I’ve contacted your families as well, and they have actually done something I didn’t think could be done. They gathered enough money that I would be willing to give one of you back for it.” A demented grin formed on his face. “One of you.”

Spring’s mouth dried up as the implication of Onyx’s words hit her. ‘The other one has to stay here, has to do this forever.’ Home was so close. All she had to do was speak up, but…. Next to her, Star was shaking. She kept looking between Spring and Onyx, clearly weighing her choices. Spring couldn’t do it. She couldn’t just leave Star here, but…at the same time, she couldn’t stand the thought of this being the rest her life.

“Me!” Star yelled, making Spring look up at her in surprise. “P…please, please just let me go home.” Spring was about to let out a sigh of relief at Star resolving the issue for her, when a dark thought crossed her mind. This thought wasn’t lost on Onyx either as he grinned down at her.

“Are you sure? You know this means your friend will have to stay with us, until she gets sold. She’ll never get to see you, or her family again.”

“I…I d…don’t care. Just let m…me go home.” Star refused to look over at Spring. Her shoulders shook, and guilt nearly overwhelmed her, but she looked straight at Onyx. Her mind was made up, she was going home…even if it meant going alone. Spring was looking at Star in confusion, betrayal. She had been glad that Star would be the one going home, but Star didn’t seem to care about what would happen to her.
“Star, I….” Spring’s face went red and tears of anger welled up in her eyes. She kept her mouth shut though, she could never force another filly to take her place in this hell hole. As hurt as she felt, as furious as she was, Star didn’t deserve to have to stay here. Onyx was enjoying watching this, but he was more excited about what was going to come next. So, he decided to move things along.
“Ok Star, the cart is waiting outside. Follow me.” Star began to step forward, but turned to Spring.

“S….Spring, I’m sorry. I just….”

“I was going to offer to stay.” Spring said coldly. Star could hear the hate in her voice, and she looked to the ground as she stepped past Spring in shame. Despite this, she still made no move to change her mind. Before she made it out of the room though, Spring called out to her, "Star! You forgot something." Star turned around, and felt a softly wadded piece of blue cloth hit her face. It was the bow she had given Spring the day they were kidnapped. Star picked it up, and her lip quivered. Clutching it close, she ran out of the room before she could change her mind. Onyx led her through the building, and farther away from the pony Star knew no longer considered her a friend. The door to the outside opened and Star burst ahead of Onyx in excitement. She was greeted by a mare standing next to a large carriage. It looked a bit big, and she looked back at Onyx in confusion. The stallion grabbed her, and held her as the mare attached a set of chains to her hooves.

“W…What? What is t…this?” Star screamed, and the mare looked at her in confusion. Onyx however was laughing.

“I lied little filly. I never even talked to your family. Why would I ever let you go? You’d just tell ponies what happened to you, and what I look like.” He leaned towards the now screaming filly, “Your friend will never know this of course. She’ll always believe you sold her out, and are living comfortably back with your family. I still can’t believe how quick you were to throw her to the sharks, so to speak. I’m proud.” He looked away from her as she began to sob hysterically. The mare met his gaze as he commented to her, “Take care of this little one will you. She’s been fun.” The mare nodded, and pulled the struggling girl towards the cart, and the rest of her life.

Author's Note

A companion chapter to Scootaloo's New Life. The characters belong to my friend Skyflys. I needed a couple of ponies for a chapter, and he had a couple he wanted to see get horribly raped.
https://derpibooru.org/1382840?q=artist%3Askyflys
What they look like if you're interested.