It wasn't supposed to be like this, Caramel thought. It was only supposed to be a one time thing. So, why was Applejack currently sitting on his couch, ramming her cock up his ass?

"C'mon, you little slut!" Applejack grunted, pounding her dick as deep inside of Caramel's anus as she could. "Make your tight, whore ass milk my cock of all its cum!"

That's why, Caramel thought, squeezing his ass cheeks a little tighter around the rod ramming his rectum. She does the things Soarin' would never even think about. It was true. While Caramel loved Soarin' with all his heart, and he was a fantastic, tender lover, he would never even consider doing something as being this rough and rude during their rutting. Caramel loved the way Applejack laid down the law. It offered a nice contrast to the tender love making he did with Soarin'.

Soarin' will be back from his Wonderbolts tour in a few days, Caramel thought, as Applejack's prick prodded his prostate. This will have to be the last time I do this. Tomorrow, I'll tell AJ that we're done.

AJ thrust her cock in harder, Caramel's erection throbbing each time Applejack's orange balls slapped against his own. "Y'like that, don't ya?" Applejack teased, giving the stallion's behind a firm slap. Caramel responded with a soft whimper. "What was that?" Applejack asked, giving Caramel's supple butt another, harder slap. "Couldn't quite hear ya!"

"I love it!" Caramel exclaimed, his cock tingling with his imminent release. "I absolutely love it!"

"Yer damn right, ya do!" Applejack seductively sneered, pulling herself into a sitting position, Caramel bouncing on top of her lap. She reached around and grasped Caramel's cock. She teasingly pumped her hand up and down his pecker, while she continued to thrust in and out of his tight hole. "Now, you ain't gonna cum until I do. 'S that clear?" Caramel nodded. "Good," she purred, increasing the speed of the assault on his ass and cock.

Caramel could hardly hold it. Despite just being told not to, he could feel his orgasm approaching. "A-AJ," he moaned. "I'm about to-"

"Don't you fuckin' dare!" Applejack barked, squeezing Caramel's balls, painfully. Caramel whimpered, and tried his best to refrain from cumming. His cock throbbed and leaked, but he managed to keep his release at bay.

The door knob began to rattle. Oh, shit! thought Caramel. Applejack obviously did not hear it, as she continued to furiously fuck his ass. I am so fucked!

The door swung open, revealing the smiling face of Soarin'. "Honey, I'm ho-" he began, before realizing what was going on. Applejack ceased her thrusting, also noticing that they had been caught.

And Caramel came.

...

Applejack had expected a number of things to happen if she and Caramel had been caught. Soarin' would yell at Caramel, Caramel would cry, Soarin' would yell at Applejack, Caramel would cry, Soarin' would kick them both out of the house, and Caramel would cry. However, she had not expected Soarin' to quietly excuse himself to the kitchen, and return with three cups of coffee, while Caramel and herself sat in and awkward silence, both still naked. Thankfully, they had enough common sense for Applejack to remove herself from Caramel's rectum.

Currently, she was seated between the two stallions, all of them sipping their coffee, mostly in an attempt to avoid talking.

"So, uh," Applejack said, finally breaking the silence. "How was your tour?"

"Fine," Soarin' said, taking another sip of his coffee. "Our show in Baltimare got cancelled, which is why I'm home two days early."

"Y-you could have told me," Caramel whimpered.

"I wanted it to be a surprise," Soarin' replied, a bit more maliciously than he had intended.

"H-how's the rest of the team doing?" Caramel asked.

"Fine," Soarin' replied, curtly. "We were all looking forward to seeing our families and special someponies, again. I'm sure they're all having a wonderful time, right now."

The silence resumed, no one wanting to bring up the issue at hand. The only sounds that could be heard were the ticking of the clock, and the occasional sip of coffee.

After several long minutes, Applejack slammed her mug down onto the table. "Ah've had enough of this!" she snapped. "Why the heck are we ignoring the elephant in the room? Just sittin' here is worse than fightin'!"

"W-well, that's the thing, Applejack," Caramel stammered. "Soarin' and I, well, we don't fight."

"What?" Applejack inquired incredulously. "What in the hell do ya mean ya don't fight? If there was ever a reason to fight, I think walkin' in on yer boyfriend with another pony's cock up his ass is a very good reason to fight!"

"We've avoided fighting our entire relationship," Soarin' said. "There's no reason to ruin a good thing that we've got going."

"So that's it, huh?" Applejack continued. "You boys just ain't gonna fight, or even talk about what happened, even though that can't possibly be healthy?"

"Correct," the pair said in unison, before continuing to sit in silence.

Applejack just stared at them, neither one of them making eye contact with anypony. The awkward silence was infuriating. Somepony needed to say something.

"Ah've had enough of this!" Applejack repeated. She grabbed Caramel's head and pushed it into her crotch. Caramel instinctively opened his mouth, slurping and suckling the appendage. "How do you like this, Soarin'?" she taunted, facefucking the pegasus' coltfriend. "How do you like watching the stallion you love most in this world pleasing somepony else's cock, especially a cock which is magically attached to a mare, no less? How does it feel knowing that while you were gone your boyfriend was my little bitch, suckin' and slurpin' my pecker like a good little slut?"

"I-it makes me..." Soarin' whsipered. "It makes me..."

"Tell me how it makes ya feel!" Applejack shouted, punctuating her demand with a firm spank to Caramel's flank.

"It pisses me the fuck off!" Soarin' roared, slapping Applejack in the face.

"That's more like it!" Applejack said, rubbing the spot where she had been struck with one hand, while her other was still intertwined in Caramel's mane, encouraging him to milk her mighty meat. "And why does it piss you off?"

"It pisses me off because I remained faithful while on the road!" Soarin' exclaimed. "It pisses me off because every night I turned down hot pieces of ass while my own boyfriend couldn't be bothered to do the same! It pisses me off because Caramel seems to enjoy sucking you more than he does me! It pisses me off that your dick is bigger than mine! And it pisses me off that you won't do the same to me!" Soarin' suddenly went silent. His face was tinged with a deep crimson.

Applejack ceased her invasion of of Caramel's tonsils. She noisily pulled her penis out of the timid stallion's mouth, and stared at what she thought was the more dominant one of the couple. "What were those last two?"

Soarin' shut his eyes, tight. "Y-your cock's bigger than mine..." he whimpered.

"And...?" Applejack interrogated.

"And I want the same treatment that you're giving Caramel."

Applejack smirked. She gently pushed Caramel away from herself, and slid closer to his boyfriend. She placed her hand on the blue stallion's crotch, noticing that he was already hard. "So, you liked watching Caramel be my bitch, huh?" Soarin' nodded. "And you want to be my bitch, as well?" Another nod. AJ rubbed along the bulge in his jeans. "Ah think Ah can make that happen. But first, you gotta tell me how long you've had this boner."

"S-since I came in and saw you balls deep in Caramel," Soarin' replied, sheepishly.

Applejack laughed. "You must be achin' quite a bit, right now," she said, unzipping his jeans and reaching in for the treat that lay within. "Seems yer quite a bit bigger than yer boyfriend, here," she chuckled, feeling along his length. "But not as big as mine," she teased, thrusting her own cock in his face.

"Go on, Soarin'," Caramel said, fondling Applejack's balls, caressing her soft scrotum. "It tastes delicious. It still has a bit of my flavor on it."

"Well?" Applejack asked. "Ya did say you wanted to be my bitch."

Soarin' gulped. Was he really about to do this? He took a deep breath before leaning forward and opening his mouth. Slowly, he engulfed the head of Applejack's cock in his maw.

"That's a good slut," Applejack purred, grabbing the back of the pegasus' head, and forcing more of her dick in his mouth. She turned her attention to the other stallion. "Caramel, I do remember telling you earlier that you weren't supposed to cum until after I did. Isn't that right?"

"Y-yes, it is," Caramel whimpered, his eyes instinctively moving to the now cold cum on the floor.

"Now, I think you need t' be punished," Applejack went on, as she continued to force Soarin' to deepthroat her meat. Her eyes were drawn to the spot where Caramel was staring, the chilled jizz grabbing her attention. "Why don't ya lick up that there load and deliver it where it's supposed t' go?" She commanded, lifting her tail out of the way.

"Yes, Applejack!" Caramel eagerly exclaimed, hurrying over to his sperm and collecting it from the wooden floor. After ensuring he had not missed a single drop, he hurried over to her starving snatch. He pressed his lips against Applejack's labia and passionately kissed her hungry opening, his seed spilling into her sopping snatch.

"That's the stuff," AJ moaned as both of her sexes were hungrily assaulted by two submissive studs. She grabbed both bitches by their manes and pushed them as deep as she could into her pecker and pussy. "I-if either of you stop there will be hell t' pay for both of y'all!" she gasped as her orgasm drew near. She fiercely thrust into Soarin's throat and shoved her wet womanhood into Caramel's face when she would pull back, always enuring that whenever one of her assets wasn't being pleasured, the other was. With a growl, she came, pressing both boys into private parts.

Soarin' gagged as Applejack ejaculated down his throat, the taste of her jizz barely washing over his pallet before it slid down into his stomach. The athlete felt a great deal of pride as he successfully swallowed the entire load without spilling a single drop of the salty ambrosia. Meanwhile, Caramel's face became a mess of the orange mare's femcum and his own semen which he had just fed to his mistress' pussy. With a satisfied sigh, Applejack removed her prick from Soarin's mouth, giving him some much need air, and gently pushed Caramel's head away from her snatch, a string of spit, splooge, and pussy juice connecting her wet hole and Caramel's lips, before finally snapping.

Applejack returned to her seat on the sofa and jerked her cock, preventing it from getting soft. "We ain't done, yet, boys," she smirked, her eyes remaining on Caramel. "I don't think you've quite been punished enough for cummin' before I did, earlier, and I think you owe Soarin' an apology for bein' an unfaithful son of a bitch."

Caramel nodded, curtly, before turning around. He bent over and spread his tan ass cheeks, revealing his tight taint. "Do you think this might make up for my misbehavior?" he asked, a blush darkening his face.

Applejack chuckled. "It will do perfectly," she said. She gently pushed Soarin' onto the couch, making him lie on his back, before lifting Caramel on top of his boyfriend. She grabbed onto Soarin's big blue dick and aligned it with Caramel's asshole. "Well, go on!" Applejack commanded. "Get fuckin'!"

Not needing to be told twice, Soarin' pressed the tip of his cock into Caramel's anus, drawing a soft coo from the more submissive stallion. With one firm thrust, Soarin' hilted himself within the tight confines of the other stallion's plot. He grabbed hold of Caramel's supple butt, and began to pump in and out of the warm, tight hole.

"That's what I like t' see," Applejack praised, climbing up onto the couch. She kneeled behind the rutting pair, and aligned her own cock with the already filled hole. She gently teased Caramel's taint with the tip of her prick, causing his eyes to widen in shock and horror.

"N-no! Please!" he whimpered. "I-it won't fit!"

"Oh?" Applejack replied. She put a hand on Soarin's thrusting hips, wordlessly telling him to stop. She leaned over the pair, stopping only to give Caramel's ear a nibble, before she continued. "A good little slut like yerself should be more than capable of takin' two cocks in his ass, at the same time," she whispered, giving his ear another nip. "Surely, you want to apologize to yer coltfriend, and surely you don't want to disappoint your mistress."

"N-no, ma'am," Caramel replied.

"Tell ya what," Applejack continued. "I won't even shove my entire member up there, at first. Only half of it. And I'll be real gentle about it. Does that sound all right?" Caramel nodded. "Good," she whispered, planting a quick kiss on the nape of Caramel's neck, before pressing her cock against his anus, again, and inserting the head inside, while simultaneously rubbing against Soarin's own cock. Once her cock was halfway in, she stopped, and then looked down at her other bitch. "Well?" she inquired. "Now you got two ponies to please with yer dick, so you'd better start movin'!"

Soarin's nodded, and resumed his thrusts, slower, this time. Caramel whimpered and moaned as his ass was stretched to its limits, his cock throbbing every time his prostate got touched.

"That's it!" Applejack gasped, thrusting her hips, slightly. She pulled out an inch, before shoving in an inch and a half of her mare meat. She slowly kept up this rhythm, pulling out when Soarin' would thrust in, and plunging into the warm depths of Caramel's butt when the other stallion would retreat.

Caramel was drooling onto the stallion below him, an insatiable, hungry whore for all of the cock he could fit in his ass. He was in pure bliss. While his ass was stretched, painfully, the feeling of two cocks rubbing along his insides and hammering into his prostate was much, much stronger.

Applejack's heavy tits bounced as she fucked the submissive stallions, beads of sweat running down her chest, before catching her nipples and flying off. She grit her teeth as she felt her second orgasm approaching. "Fuck!" she shouted, slowing her thrusts, but delivering them with more impact.

Soarin' and Caramel were in similar predicaments. Both were barely hanging on, as they held back their own orgasms, both fearing and anticipating whatever punishment their mistress would have in store for them, should they cum before her.

With a roar, Applejack fiercely grabbed Caramel's bouncing buttocks and drove her dick balls deep inside the boy's tight fuckhole, and creamed all along the inside, coating Caramel's colon and Soarin's schlong, much of it spraying out from around the twin dicks and onto the couch and Soarin's thighs. Knowing now that they had AJ's permission, both bitches screamed as they unloaded their own jizz, further adding to the mess on the pegasus and sofa.

With a sigh, Applejack removed her softening cock from Caramel's tight ass, pulling Soarin's out along with it. She stopped to admire the waterfall of cum that leaked out of the well-stretched hole, before leaning down and giving both stallions a quick kiss. "C'mon," she said. "We need t' get cleaned up."

...

After a deep, hot shower, all three ponies were seated around the kitchen table, enjoying a delicious meal of mashed potatoes, corn on the cob, and steamed carrots, with a fresh apple crisp waiting for dessert, all prepared by Applejack.

"Eat up, boys," Applejack said, smiling. "There's plenty to go around."

"Thanks a lot, AJ," Soarin' said with a mouthful of potatoes. "It's amazing."

"Definitely," Caramel agreed. "If you keep feeding me like this, I'm going to have to start exercising more."

"Aw, think nothing of it," Applejack replied, blushing.

"Say, Applejack? There's something I need to ask you," Soarin' said.

"Go ahead," the farmmare responded, leaning forward.

"Earlier, when I caught you... doing things with Caramel that only I should be, you seemed dead set on getting me to respond to it. What did you think would happen when you... shoved your fat cock down his throat?"

Applejack sighed. "I don't rightly know," she said, playing with her food. "I just thought you needed to do something about me fuckin' your man. Have an argument, beat the snot outta me, possibly even break up, just do something about the problem. Ya can't just not fight when the relationship's rough, it ain't healthy. Things coulda gotten even uglier, eventually, if you didn't."

"Well, if it means anything," Soarin' continued, putting his hand on hers and smiling. "I don't think you fucking Caramel like the little slut he is is going to be a problem, anymore."

"Nor would it be a problem if you did the same to Soarin'," Caramel said, repeating Soarin's gesture.

Applejack smiled. "I would love that," she said. "Now, let's hurry up and finish eatin', cuz I ain't plannin' on goin' to bed without somethin' warm and sticky in my holes, and you boys better be prepared to make sure I have plenty of it."

Author's Note

Sorry this took so long to get out. With being in the middle of the ocean for a few months, busy with work, and just needing to get back into writing this was very tough to write. Hopefully, I can build back the momentum I had before I left.