Sunset pulled up in front of my house to pick me up for Pinkie Pie's Valentine's Day party.

"Got you a present," she said while holding her hands behind her back.

"Really? What is it?" I asked excitedly.

She move her arms in front of her body to display a beautiful purple chrome motorcycle helmet.

"It's beautiful! I love it! Thank you so much!" I told her with a huge grin on my face. "I got you a present too, but you have to wait until we get to the party."

Sunset begged me to let her have it right then because she already gave me the helmet, but I refused. I had a plan to not only embarrass her at the party, but set her up so we could hopefully have some more fun at her house after the party.

I had been looking forward to the motorcycle ride to Pinkie’s house. The feeling of my arms being wrapped around her slim waist and the vibrations from the engine were enough to get me excited. Unfortunately, the ride only lasted a couple of minutes.

***

"Sunset! Twilight!"

That's the sound we heard when we got to Pinkie's house, just seconds before we were knocked over by a pink blur.

"Hi... Pinkie," I managed to say, gasping for air.

"How was your date the other night?" asked Pinkie before ending the hug and letting us breathe.

"It was..." Sunset started before looking at me and turning red.

"Relaxing," I finished as I felt myself turning red as well.

I just grinned as Pinkie stood there with a confused look on her face.

"Hey, did you guys bring presents to trade with your Valentine? Because if not I got some presents you can have to give to your Valentine! That way they don't feel left out when everyone else gets presents from their Valentine!" Pinkie rambled before gasping for air.

"Yeah we brought presents for each other," I said. "Thanks for thinking ahead of time for us though."

"That's ok because you guys still get the presents anyhow. Now. Let’s PAAARTY!"

We all headed inside where I noticed Rainbow and Applejack playing video games, Rarity was with her date, Fluttershy was holding Angel and Cheese Sandwich was mixing up some more punch.

Wait, I thought. Cheese Sandwich? What the hell was he doing here?

"Um, Pinkie? What's Cheese Sandwich doing here? I thought you two hated each other?" Sunset asked before I could get the same question out of my mouth.

"Oh. He's my date," she said with a smile. "We talked it out and decided that if we planned parties together they can be twice as good as before so now he's my date for all the rest of our parties so they can be bitchin'!"

Sunset and I could only laugh at her comment.

***

The party went better than I expected. Probably because of the two awesome party planners. But the time finally came for the gift exchange. Pinkie gave everyone chocolate-strawberry cupcakes, Rarity got a beautiful diamond broach and her date got a custom made tie by Rarity. Rainbow and Applejack got each other lingerie. And then it was Sunset’s and my turn.

I opened the bag that Sunset gave me expecting something erotic, but ended up being a set of pink and purple silk pajamas. I guess she decided to play it safe after her little speech few days ago. And finally it was my turn.

"I'd like to say a few things before I give Sunset my present," I started. "Since Sunset decided to reveal her feelings towards me earlier this week, I thought I might as well do the same tonight.” I took a deep breath. “Until Camp Everfree, I had not thought about having anyone special in my life. But after Timber started hitting on me, I began to wonder who that special someone would be. And then the answer was revealed to me: Sunset Shimmer. I thought about her day and night for months, not knowing if she felt the same way, until I enlisted the help of Pinkie Pie."

As I looked over to Pinkie to thank her, I saw that her cheeks were slightly flushed.

"Sunset, I give you this present in hopes that it can be used not just in the near future, but for years to come." I handed her the box wrapped in red paper with silver hearts and a pink ribbon. "I love you, Sunset."

That speech was followed by a the whole group going "Awwww!"

A feeling of excitement rushed through me as Sunset tore off the wrapping paper, my gift consisted of two separate boxes, a large one and small one. "Our date must have been better than I thought if I get two gifts," she said. "Thank you, Twilight."

"Don't thank me just yet," I said, stifling a giggle.

The look on Sunset's face was priceless as she looked inside the larger box and quickly closed it. The anticipation of everyone seeing what she got was driving me insane.

"What is it?" asked Fluttershy in her usual quiet voice.

"Yes, darling, please show us what you got," Rarity added.

"C'mon Sunset," said Rainbow, "it can't be that bad."

After a minute or two, Sunset regained her ability to talk.

"Oh, it's... uh... it's nothing," she said quickly.

"Ooooh! It's a surprise gift," said Pinkie. "Let's see the other box then."

I almost lost it when she looked inside the small box and her face turned beat red.

And that's when Applejack spoke up.

"Sunset, y'all ain't makin' this fair by hidin' what Twilight got ya. Let's see."

With an audible groan, she reached in the smaller box and pulled out a bottle of lubricant. Everyone started laughing at the sight.

"Seriously?" she asked, clearly annoyed.

"Read... the... label..." I managed to say as I laughed. "It doubles as massage oil."

She shot a frown my way and reopened the large box, emptying its contents. A bright red, nine inch dildo fell out into her lap, bounced off her leg and landed right in front of Fluttershy, who then fainted at the sight of it, which made us laugh even harder.

"Ok, Twilight," said Sunset. "Nice prank. Now, where's the real gift at?"

"That... that... that was the... the real gift…”I laughed.

"What?!" she yelled. "Are you serious?!"

"Yes. That's what I meant when I said I hope it can be used for years to come."

Sunset sat there with a look to kill for a minute. I got ready to haul ass because I saw that look in Shining Armor's face many times growing up. And sure enough, she jumped to her feet, hollering "I'll get your ass for this!", and began chasing me around Pinkie's house for about ten minutes. Everyone kept laughing harder at me and Sunset, acting like a couple of kids. We all got settled back down and then Pinkie had to be Pinkie.

"When do you want me to throw your 'Congratulations On Getting Your First Dildo' party?"

We all bursted out laughing at the question until we were crying and our sides were hurting.

Anyway, the party wrapped up a little bit after that and everybody went home. Before me and Sunset left, she asked Pinkie if she was serious about a "dildo" party, to which Pinkie replied yes. As I got on the back of Sunset's motorcycle, she vowed revenge for what I did to her. It was with that comment that I knew it was going to be a long night…

Not that I wasn’t expecting it.

Author's Note

Big thanks to Hakuno for helping me improve my writing skills and offering suggestions.

There's one or two more chapters to go. Hopefully the next one will be up by Friday.