A Goddess or a Demon

by Copycat the Alicorn

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, Princess Celestia, Human, Sad, Main 6, Nightmare Moon, Thriller, Gore, Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Romance
Length: 8875

A human joins Nightmare Moon on the moon a few years before she comes back to Equestria. Will his involvement cause ripples in the timeline that was suppose to be?

A human joins Nightmare Moon on the moon a few years before she comes back to Equestria. Will his involvement cause ripples in the timeline that was suppose to be?
Nate is a young man that was a soldier. After being injured he prayed one day to his Goddess and she responded before bringing him to her world. He will soon fight against others he has never seen before.

Published 2017-02-18 06:10:01 UTC
Last updated 2017-02-20 20:09:11 UTC

Prayers

A goddess or a demon?

"Now the hour has come at last

The soft and fading light

Has crossed the west horizon

And has bidden us goodnight

And what a lovely night it is

To walk a moonlit field

To see the softer shades

That are by starlight now revealed

So why is it that now,

When all is quiet and at rest

When candles glow and all the world

Is at its very best

The ponies of Equestria

Should lock themselves away

To shun the moon and wait instead

For Sister's sunny day?

(In umbra Luna est)

Am I so wrong to wish that they

Would see things like I do?

And am I so wrong to think

That they might love me too?

Why shouldn't they adore me?

Is it not within my right?

I'll not be overshadowed!

Mine is not the lesser light!

I've waited long enough now

For them all to come around

And though the Sun may plead and threaten,

The Moon will stand her ground

It comes to this at last:

I will no longer yield the sky

If they cannot love

But one princess alone

See, the Moon is rising

She has come to claim the heavens for her own

And all will know the wonder

Of my dark and jeweled sky

When all the world is wrapped

In an eternal lullaby

So say goodnight to this,

The final setting of the sun,

Tomorrow dawns in darkness;

The nighttime has begun!"

Nightmare Moon repeated these words as she looks out of her prison upon the moon down upon Equestria with eyes of hatred. She had gone through this same routine for nearly one thousand years now having her only need to be getting back and killing Princess Celestia.

Nightmare turns away from the window that looks down at Equestria as she trots towards her throne room once more to sit and wait until she was tired once more. Her mind was a void filled only with ideas of death and torture for those who would oppose her return next year.

Luna lifted a hoof and tapped it lightly on the window which showed a rainbow colored wave of color to show around the outside of it. This rainbow wave had sealed her here for so long and had kept her here life air in a bubble that would not pop.

She glared down at her kingdom and states to herself, "Soon I shall be home and you shall fall before me, Sister."

As she looks to her left where a mirror sits she sees her glorious and celestial body that any pony would wish for. Her royal coat was a dark blue almost on the verge of being pure black with her mane being a black moving mass with glittering stars inside it. Her crown, regalia, and armor were made of black metals that were thin yet had been through many battles before. Her eyes were oddly like a dragons with how they looked slated and greenish

She turns and sits back on her throne to wait once more hoping for something to occur before she went insane. She felt so alone.

G.O.D.

Celestia looked up at the moon where her sister had been trapped under the control of the demon that had taken over because of her fear. Soon her mistake would be fixed and Equestria would once again have its two princesses together once again keeping Equestria strong.

Celestia walked along as she saw guards looking at her as she passed them by. She knew her pure white coat shined and glistened like the finest jewelry, her regalia were flawless and enhanced her appearance, and her eyes were blue like the sky in the mornings

As night turned to day she began to use her powers as a song she was used to began to come out of her voice.

Fate has been cruel and order unkind

How can I have sent you away?

The blame was my own; the punishment, yours

The harmony's silent today

But into the stillness I'll bring you a song

And I will your company keep

Till your tired eyes and my lullabies

Have carried you softly to sleep

Once did a pony who shone like the sun

Look out on her kingdom and sigh

She smiled and said, "Surely, there is no pony

So lovely and so well beloved as I"

So great was her reign and so brilliant her glory

That long was the shadow she cast

Which fell dark upon the young sister she loved

And grew only darker as days and nights passed

Lullay moon princess, goodnight sister mine

And rest now in moonlight's embrace

Bear up my lullaby, winds of the earth

Through cloud, and through sky, and through space

Carry the peace and the coolness of night

And carry my sorrow in kind

Luna, you're loved so much more than you know

Forgive me for being so blind

Soon did that pony take notice that others

Did not give her sister her due

And neither had she loved her as she deserved

She watched as her sister's unhappiness grew

But such is the way of the limelight, it sweetly

Takes hold of the mind of its host

And that foolish pony did nothing to stop

The destruction of one who had needed her most

Lullay moon princess, goodnight sister mine

And rest now in moonlight's embrace

Bear up my lullaby, winds of the earth

Through cloud, and through sky, and through space

Carry the peace and the coolness of night

And carry my sorrow in kind

Luna, you're loved so much more than you know

May troubles be far from your mind

And forgive me for being so blind

(Instruments play slowly)

The years now before us

Fearful and unknown

I never imagined

I'd face them on my own

May these thousand winters

Swiftly pass, I pray

I love you; I miss you

All these miles away

May all your dreams be sweet tonight

Safe upon your bed of moonlight

And know not of sadness, pain, or care

And when I dream, I'll fly away and meet you there

She looked once more at the moon setting and says to herself, "Soon sister, you will be back home and you will be made yourself again by my student."

G.O.D.

What the princesses didn't know was that in the human world a human male was on the edge of death. This man was an everyday man who was just trying to get by after a life full of pain and lose throughout his life. Today he was planning to end it all with only a note and a prayer before he ended it. He looked in the mirror and saw his useless self.

He was a 6 foot 1 inch male with short brown hair, his skin was a light tan-white with light freckles over his skin, his bluish green eyes looked tired with the bags under them. He was wearing a forest camouflage shirt, a pair of green camouflage pants, and a pair of tan steel toe boots. His hands looked to be worn from heavy labor  with a few scars on his arms that looked like knife wounds. He had a pair of thin glasses over his eyes that seemed to be quite worn and slightly dirty.

With a sigh, he turns and limps over to a chair by his kitchen table where he grits his teeth as he slowly sits down. He reaches under his shirt and grabs a pair of necklaces which he lightly lifts over his head and sets down on the table before him. One is a set of dog tags from his time in the army where he had gotten his injuries from while the other was a necklace with two symbols on it. The first symbol had a part of his religion which was Wiccan while the other was for his goddess, Selene the goddess of water and of the moon.

He smiled fondly as he touched the dog tags and the symbols with fondness like people pet their dogs and cats. He sighed before standing up slowly and walking to the kitchen where he opens the fridge to find it almost empty except for a jug of milk, a bag of shredded cheddar cheese, and some mild Italian sausage. He smiles lightly as he pulls them all out and begins to make a breakfast for himself after a long ten hour work day at Arby's. He loved to cook but with how life was right now...he just felt so tired of existing right now. As he cooked he looked at his phone to see a message from his dad and another message from his friends

'Hey Son, I wanted to say that I will be coming to visit you with your stepmother in two months. Want to hear how you are doing and when you can call me back.'

'Yo Nate it's been a bit. Wanted to know if you really told that cute chick that you were not interested in dating. You sure you're not gay cause you really need to get laid man.'

He sighs as he tosses his phone to the side and says to himself, "Everyone gets to do what they want but I can't. To damn smart but to damn responsible to even think about missing bills. Tonight should be the full moon...can't wait to pray and let my last feelings go so that I can finally end this suffering. I hurt so much. I just want the pain to end."

He finishes up cooking and puts it on a plate before going to the table and eating it slowly while thinking of the good days. He had been top of the recruits at Fort Jackson and Fort Lee before heading off to Iraq where he had been stationed with the 43rd army infantry. He was under Commander Stafford who had ordered him and his men to go on a convoy to join up with some tanks on the border to Afghanistan. The problem was that in route the convoy was attacked and he had gotten a piece of shrapnel through his left knee cap. Only two years in the military and already he was sent home with barely enough money to help him pay his bills. After that money ran out he had tried to get a good job but... he had no luck. Finally he got hired as a full time employee at Arby's where he hated it. He had been trained to be a soldier and part time leader of his men and now he was serving fried food to civilians.

He put his plate in the sink and washed it one last time before putting it in the rack to dry as he headed into his room to grab his colt 32 cal pistol which he brought with him to his small shrine as he grabbed his dog tags and his necklace with his religious symbols before kneeling in front of the alter. The alter was peculiar for sure as it sat under a window in the living room where moonlight shone down upon it from the full moon over head. On the shrine was four small vials filled with different things, a picture of a woman, a couple of sticks of incense, and a small pentacle on the table made from chalk.

He kneeled there as he says, "The elements before me are to appease the gods and goddesses above. The spirit of the point is the picture of Selene to show my devotion, for earth I have sacred dirt purified of all toxins to show my purity of my body, for air I have a bottle with pure oxygen to show the air around me is without sin, for water I have a bottle of mineral water from a natural spring to show my mind is pure, and fire is the incense before me is lit to show my heart is pure for all to see."

He breathes in as a small shiver goes through him as his next words feel as if they are speaking deep to the world, "Selene I pray to you today to help me. I have been your loyal follower for these last 15 years and wish to ask one request of you before I pass on. I ask that as the soldier I am and the useless person I am that you may help me find a better place for myself and rid me of this pain that hurts so much every day. I invoke your true name Luna the lady of the moon, to help your follower so that with my death I will find a new life beside you until the day you do not need me anymore. I invoke the elemental of water and your moon to allow this so that with your answer I can finally have peace and live as the true follower I have always been to you."

G.O.D.

What the man didn't know was that his request entered into a nexus of magic that had opened upon the moon raising to its highest point and went out to be heard by two Princesses.

The voice spoke in chipped tones as it said in a muscular voice, ""Selene I pray to you .... help me. I have been your loyal follower ... wish to ask one request of you... I ask that as the soldier I ... that you may help me find a better place for myself... I invoke your true name Luna the lady of the moon, to help your follower.... find a new life beside ...  I invoke the elements of water and your moon to allow this so that with your answer ... live as the true follower I have always been to you."

Celestia upon hearing this voice speaking in such a strange and yet spell like nature caused her head to raise in alarm but also surprise. These words had not been heard in such ages that even Celestia was still young when her parents had heard them as well. This meant only one thing that she knew of and that was that the ancient laws were still around in the other worlds out there...the legacy of her family still existed in other worlds like her father had predicted.

Tears went down Celestia's cheeks as she says, "One of the followers still exist and they call to my sister. I can only hope a part of her still exists to help this follower or dare I hope she doesn't and whomever calls for her is not turned into a weapon against Equestria. I must at least try and stop it from reaching her if possible."

Celestia began to use her magic to try and muffle or silence the voice from reaching her sister.

She looks up at the moon not knowing her sister heard it as well but before her.

Nightmare Moon was walking back towards her bed when the words came to her ears and she raises her head and looks towards the open window with surprise and hope.

"Could it be true? Could there still be followers left of mine after so long without a prayer? I...I feel Luna smiling and wanting to reach out but dare I do so? They say they are a warrior but dare I trust them to actually help?" asks Nightmare Moon to herself as she looks to think a little.

She seems to contemplate this for a bit before saying to herself, "I will take this chance and maybe this warrior will be able to assist me when it is time to go back to Equestria to take back my throne. I shall answer this one's heed and shall bring them here to assist me while we wait for the time to pass to invade my homeland once more."

Her magic gathers as she says in her Royal Canterlot voice, "Mortal, I have heard your invoking and shall allow it. You will come and be in my arms once more and I shall guide you to your true destiny under my care. None shall harm you so long as you stay true to what you have said and My protection shall stay upon you until the day that I parish where you shall as well."

With declaration she casts her magic to open a portal before her which would open near the one who asked her of this request.

In Equestria Princess Celestia felt the magic gather and heard Nightmare Moons voice with dread in her heart as she says to herself, "It looks like I must push my student Twilight Sparkle along a little so she is prepared for what is to come. It seems Nightmare Moon has gotten another to join her to fight and we must be prepared for what is to come with this change of future events."

G.O.D.

Nate sighed as he felt that he would receive no response for his prayers. Taking his hands off the alter he grabs each vial of the elements and puts them in his pockets along with Luna's picture of her pure spirit when he hears what he wished to hear after so long.

A voice ... a feminine voice called out to him in such a sweet and yet motherly voice like a whisper through the air, "Mortal, I have heard your invoking and shall allow it. You will come and be in my arms once more and I shall guide you to your true destiny under my care. None shall harm you so long as you stay true to what you have said and My protection shall stay upon you until the day that I parish where you shall as well."

Nate's eyes open wide as tears go down his cheeks as if someone had just grabbed his hand to stop him from jumping off a cliff and smiles. His prayers had been answered and he would be with his goddess like he had always wished. He stumbles his way to his room and grabs a pair of 9mm pistols which he puts in their holsters which he clips to his hips. He then goes to his closet and opens it to grab a pair of swords. The first was a black katana that was about three feet long and the other was a knight's sword that was engraved with dragons on it. He finally grabs his assassin's dagger which he slides into his boot sheath.

As he heads back into the living room to answer his Goddesses call he sees the air before him ripple before it seems to open and reveal a multicolored interior which shifts about in color and shape. As he looks as if he feels a small tug on his heart telling him that he should go in.

With a true smile he limps to the portal and enters it after saying, "I am coming my lady. I am yours and shall never leave you."

Nate closed his eyes and walked through the portal without even knowing if he would live through it. Upon stepping in, he feels a kind of sucking sensation as he keeps moving like he is in a straw or a tube and is being pulled back into his world as he fights forward. With each step the sensation gets stronger until with the sound of shattering glass he falls over as the sensation stops. He pants on his hands and knees before he slowly opens his eyes to look down upon a smooth black floor made of some kind of rock.

His vision seems off for a second as it seems to go hazy and back to normal a few times as he begins to stand up. With a slight trouble with standing, he finally is at his full height as he looks about to find that he is in some kind of medieval castle that is made of this black stone all around speckled with shapes that are made of what looks to be silver or maybe pearl but he can't seem to tell.

His eyes wonder about until they come upon a chest high.... pony? He would call it a pony if not for its horn and wings. Is it some kinda Pegasus or unicorn? Pagacorn or Unisus? He wasn't for sure.

He blinks a few times as he tilts his head in confusions looking at it before the pony opened its mouth and says in a familiar feminine voice, "Hello, my faithful follower. I am very happy to see that you have to come to me after all and you didn't even change from your original shape."

Nate's eyebrows raised up as he asks, "Are you Luna?"

'Luna' nods and says in a soothing voice, "I am Luna, your goddess of water and the moon. I can understand if you are concerned about my looks but this is my form in my home realm. You have come here and I hope that everything you spoke was truth all these years."

Nate quickly snaps out of his funk before saluting her and saying quickly, "Of course, my ...lady? I have never went wrong as your truest follower and have would never lie to you."

'Luna' seems to smile as she says, "I do hope your fighting skills have not gotten rusty since I last looked upon you during your last time in a fight."

Nate looks slightly offended but says, "Of course not, my lady. I am still a great fighter even if I am slightly crippled."

'Luna' smile gets slightly wider as she says, "Let me use some of my powers to remove your pain so that when the time comes you can join me in a battle against a foe worthy of your skills."

Nate blushes a little at the compliment before he nods and let's her get to work on his injury.

G.O.D.

Nightmare Moon grins happily at how easy it was to manipulate this warrior to let her use her magic to make her bound to her in body and soul.

Her horn began to glow a dark blue as her magic seeps into the warrior before her and begins to fix him and change him somewhat. She first notices that some metal was lodged in his leg causing him pain and decided to vanish those before fixing the muscles with a simple regeneration spell before putting some her magic on his brain to make him more susceptible to her orders and to not question them. She than help him by adding a little more muscle and fixing his eyes. With that she smiles as she also goes through his memories to see how much she would have to change to her liking.

What she came upon was quite unlike what she expected. His life was always lonely or with so few and yet the one thing he seemed to always do was pray to Luna... to her. Memories go past her in a blur as voices seep through to be heard.

"Your a smart kid, Nate. Use it wisely."

"What's wrong with you? Why do you dress like a gangster? I didn't raise you like this."

"Dude, like why have you never dated? Something wrong with you."

"Come on, man. The Army is the best place for you man."

"You maggots better be ready for hell."

"The Sergeant is dead! We need to call in support."

"We're under fire. Keep your heads down."

"Nate! Stay with me private."

"Back luck bro. Wish you were still around."

"Murderer."

"Baby Killer."

"We don't need you."

"Get lost."

"Why don't you go die."

" Mortal, I have heard your invoking and shall allow it."

She stopped as she heard that one and looked at the memory. The memory radiated with such... love and devotion?

'Was his life so full of pain and suffering that my words made him come to me? If so... should I really do this to him?' Nightmare Moon asked herself.

'Help him. He is like me, lost and needing a reason to live. Guide him and maybe we can have a friend or even someone we can trust.' replied Luna.

'I am Nightmare Moon, I do not need friends or trust. I need only servants and followers.' replied Nightmare Moon with a growl.

'You are all alone here without him. He is smart and has not had the love or right motivation to guide him. Show him the right way and maybe you and he can live happily these next few years.' replies Luna.

Nightmare Moon seems to think on it before leaving Nate's mind and saying to him, "You should be better now, Nate Rowenoak."

Nate's eyes open as he stands up and takes his glasses off before noticing he felt stronger. He looks at her before kneeling and saying, "I thank you, my lady, for this. I will do anything you ask until the day you do not need me anymore."

Nightmare Moon smiles, 'happily' ,at him before stating, "We shall first test your body and skills to find out if you are up to par with the opponents that you will face later on. Today will be the start of your training."

Nate nods and follows her into a training room which looks like a torture chamber with the amount of sharp objects. He gulps as one thing goes through his mind and out his mouth.

"Well....fuck me with a cactus...I'm gonna be in a world of hurt." he states

Arrival

Hear, Goddess queen, diffusing silver light, bull-horn'd and wand'ring thro' the gloom of Night.

With stars surrounded, and with circuit wide Night's torch extending, thro' the heav'ns you ride:

Female and Male with borrow'd rays you shine, and now full-orb'd, now tending to decline.

Mother of ages, fruit-producing Moon [Mene], whose amber orb makes Night's reflected noon:

Lover of horses, splendid, queen of Night, all-seeing pow'r bedeck'd with starry light.

Lover of vigilance, the foe of strife, in peace rejoicing, and a prudent life:

Fair lamp of Night, its ornament and friend, who giv'st to Nature's works their destin'd end.

Queen of the stars, all-wife Diana hail! Deck'd with a graceful robe and shining veil;

Come, blessed Goddess, prudent, starry, bright, come moony-lamp with chaste and splendid light,

Shine on these sacred rites with prosp'rous rays, and pleas'd accept thy suppliant's mystic praise.”

(by Orphilios)

G.O.D.

Nate groaned as he slowly stands up after his latest workout against the water horses that his lady, Luna or as she liked to be called Nightmare Moon, had summoned to fight against him. He was dead tired with how much fighting he had done for the last hour against multiple water horses that had swords, spears, and magic. He fought using only his speed and swords to take them out until he began to slow and finally tire out and get his ass handed to him by the water horses.

Nightmare Moon stood to the side wearing a kind and happy smile as she complimented him by saying, "You did even better than last time but I do hope you are ready for tonight. Tonight we shall be free from this prison I was placed in and we shall take back my kingdom once more from that insufferable pony who dared to take my place."

Nate says kindly to her as he walks over and puts an arm around her, "Just remember what we talked about. I want to make sure you don't do something that will hurt you or me. I don't want to lose you because of this pony and I will protect you with my life."

Nightmare Moon smiles before turning away and saying, "Stop getting so sappy with me or I'll take away my gifts from you."

Nate smiles and says, "Oh really? Than that would mean I shouldn't make you that nice mint chocolate shake?"

She gasps and goes wide eyed as she says, "Anything but that. Please!"

Nate chuckles and replies as he pokes her nose, "Your fault for getting addicted to my milk shakes."

She pouts a little before stating, "Not my fault you're a better cook than any other I have had."

He looks at her and says with some sass, "At least I can cook. What do you call that black mass you make."

"Are you implying that a Goddess such as myself cannot do something?" she states with narrowed eyes.

"Oh I would NEVER do that my lady." he replies with a smirk as he ducks under a book thrown at him.

"I will make you pay for that later... after we take my kingdom back." she states with a huff.

"Yes my lady." he states with a chuckle.

He head towards the kitchen to prepare the final meal of the day in the castle before they were going to head to her true kingdom. As he entered the kitchen he began to search and grab each item of food necessary for the last dish of the day.

He grabbed a couple of eggs which were preserved quite well, as if fresh, as well as some potatoes, and cheese. He began to slowly cook the potatoes and eggs before adding in some cheese, and finally setting them on plates where his last pieces of daisies where. He plucks them and puts them on one plate as he walks towards the table where his goddess would be waiting for him. He had taken it upon himself these last couple of years to help by cooking, cleaning, and caring for his goddess.

He sighed knowing that even with his short life span, he wished that she wouldn't do this. Yes, it was her kingdom but this adversary of hers sounded like someone close to her from how sad but angry she sounded when talking about them. She also never used a name for this adversary which made him feel unsure about this endeavored but never the less he had sworn to help her and he would even if it cost him his life in doing so.

He smiles brightly at Nightmare Moon as he says, "My lady, dinner is served. Today we are having a country breakfast with daisies and your favorite Mint and honey Tea today."

Nightmare Moon smiles warmly at him as he sets the food down on the table and brings out the drinks to set down it front of them both before saying, "I am very thankful for this good food you have brought me, Sir Nate. Let us toast to our return to my kingdom."

Nate smiles as he says while raising his glass of milk, "To a happy day for you, my lady and let there be a happy future for both of us."

Nightmare Moon smiles at him and nods before clinking their glasses and they begin to dine.

'I do wish you would allow me out every once in a while to speak with him. He seems like such a refined gentlecolt." comments Luna mentally to Nightmare Moon.

'I dare not let you out because it would either cause him confusion or you might turn him on me. I would rather be able to trust in him.' replies Nightmare Moon to Luna

'You do know that my sister has prepared for our return and will have the elements secured to fight you back. He stands no chance against Equestria with only you as help. You will lose and he will die trying to help you.' states Luna sadly.

'HE SHALL NOT PERISH. WE SHALL NOT ALLOW HIM TO PERISH UNTIL HE HAS SERVED HIS PURPOSE TO US. WE WILL RULE ALL OF EQUESTRIA WITH HIM BY OUR SIDE AND IF WE SO WISH, HE SHALL BE OUR CONSOURT OR SLAVE TILL WE HAVE NO NEED OF HIM. DO NOT MAKE US ANGRY LUNA OR WE WILL NEED TO PUNISH YOU FOR IT AGAIN.' states Nightmare Moon in the canterlot voice at Luna in her mind.

Luna quiets down and watches as Nightmare Moon continues her talk to Nate without pause, "...and I believe that our return will be met with confusion and hate by our little ponies meaning we will need to work fast to reach the weapon used against me to send me here."

Nate seems to contemplate this for a bit before asking, "This weapon needs to be wielded by someone right? If we knew who this opponent of yours trusted most or trained for it...we could figure out how to stop it from being used."

Nightmare Moon's eyes go wide as she says, "I can't believe I never did think of this. We could make it impossible for them to send me away again and at the same time cause the resistance to fail so that my existence can once more exist and rule my kingdom peacefully."

Nate smiles and says, "It's like a saying my father said, ' the only reason a weapon is dangerous is if you give it to someone to use it. If it sits there it ain't worth the scrap it's made of.'"

Nightmare Moon nods and replies, "Your father is a smart man to have such ideas. I am proud he passed that on to you so that you could assist me in helping my ponies see the right way once again."

Nate blushes a little at the praise and says, "It ain't nothing too much. Outside of ideas and fighting, I really ain't that good at much. I'm kinda just a jack of all trades when not using a weapon or my head."

Nightmare Moon Looks out the window and says, "It looks like it is almost time for our return to my Kingdom. Let us prepare."

Nate nods as he cleans the table, dishes, and food up one last time before heading to his room. In his room he gets dressed and armed for the fight ahead. . He first makes sure his sheathes are in place on his left leg for his assassin's dagger and for his two swords on his back. He then makes sure his belt is on tight with his holsters with the twin 9mm pistols with extra ammo in each. He finally makes sure that the black leather armor that Nightmare Moon had enchanted was in its right places over his chest arms and legs to ensure he was not hurt. He smiles as he then takes a black wool cloak and clasps it on over himself to hide his visage from others.

He slowly walks out with each step sounding loud in the hallway as his steel toed boots land with each step on the black stone floor. He runs a hand through his now short hair as he feels excitement and dread at fighting once more after his last fight back at his old home.

He pushes the doors open at the end of the hall and says, "My lady, I am ready for our journey to return your kingdom back to you."

Nightmare Moon smiles evilly before she says, "Let us be off than and great my old enemy."

With that said, Nightmare Moon gathers her powers about her and Nate before in a cloud of mist, they disappear from the Moon's Castle to Equestria where a battle would soon start again.

G.O.D.

Celestia sat on her throne listening to the last of the nobles talking about stuff that only made them richer and the poor even poorer.

"...and raising taxes would allow the treasury to keep up with the demand of exports from other countries like the Zebra and Dragon Kingdoms. I believe that raising taxes for those on lower paying jobs would help in this matter." stated a prissy dressed noble to Celestia.

"My little pony, I can see you have been thinking this matter through a lot but we cannot raise the taxes on those of lower paying jobs or we will be forced to lower prices of goods and housing as well to the point where our trade economy will go into a vast decline until the kingdom falls apart. I think if you can find another way to help with the treasury than we can talk more on this." states Celestia in a kind and motherly voice to the noble who looks shocked.

The noble nods and walks with head held high out of the throne room. With the massive doors closed, Celestia sighs and says to her guards, "Please lead me to the carriage so that we may get to Ponyville in time for the Summer Sun Celebration. It will be better than last year because my student Twilight Sparkle will be taking charge of it."

The guards nod as they form at her sides and lead her to the carriage when a mist forms in front of the carriage making the guards stand ready with their spears.

"HELLO CELESTIA. IT HAS BEEN A LONG TIME SINCE WE LAST SAW EACH OTHER." states a voice in the mist as it begins to form into two beings before Celestia.

Celestia knew the voice well and says in an angry tone, "Nightmare Moon! You have returned it seems from your prison. It looks like it is time to send you back there."

"WE THINK NOT. IT IS TIME FOR US TO RULE OVER EQUESTRIA ONCE MORE. YOU HAVE RULED OUR KINGDOM LONG ENOUGH AND SPREAD TO MANY LIES ABOUT US." yells Nightmare Moon as she stands tall beside the cloaked figure beside her.

Celestia narrows her eyes as she shoots a beam of magic at Nightmare Moon when the figure steps in front of her and holds a sword ready to block it. The magic hits the sword and seems to be absorbed into it as the figure swings the sword twice to knock the spears of the guards aside. The figure than kicks both guards sending them skidding into the walls and thus knocking them out of the fight.

Celestia looks shocked at the figure between her and Nightmare Moon before asking, "Who are you? Why are you letting Nightmare Moon manipulate you into being a pawn in her game to take over Equestria?"

A rough male voice answers under the cloak, "I serve my goddess because I am her follower. You shall not tempt me with your silver tongue to go against my lady. Her kingdom will not be under your control any longer betrayer."

Celestia's eyes go wide as she knew that voice from not that long ago. It was the voice of the follower from another realm of reality that had asked for help not even two years ago.

"You must not do this! You must not let her lead you astray and cause the doom of Equestria. She wishes to make night eternal and destroy everything." Begs Celestia to the cloaked figure.

The cloaked figure looks at Nightmare Moon and shakes his head as he says, "My lady does not wish to ruin the world as you think. She wishes to be seen as a true ruler and not as an enemy like you did to her after killing her sister. It is time for you to feel what she feels having been trapped on the moon and watching the world be changed against you."

Nightmare Moon using this moment fires a spell at Celestia. Celestia notices the spell but is too late to protect herself as it hits her and she disappears. In her place is a small globe made of glass and fake snow along with a miniature Celestia who looked frightened. The figure grabs the globe and puts it in a pocket in his cloak before saying to Nightmare Moon, "It is done my lady but I feel that this weapon you seek to get rid of is not here."

Nightmare Moon thinks for a second as she rubs a hoof on her muzzle before heading to one of the knocked out guards and looking into their mind. Her eyes go wide as she smiles before saying, "She has an apprentice that she has been training for this day. She sent the young unicorn over to a town called Ponyville where a celebration is going on. I believe the elements are there and that her apprentice is searching for them as we speak."

"We must make haste then, my lady or we may be too late. I believe scaring this unicorn may help in gathering an information as to where they may be." states Nate as he gets close to Nightmare Moon.

Nightmare smiles and laughs evilly as she says, "Let us go make a grand entrance then to show Equestria that we are back."

With a cloak of smoke once more heading out, Celestia hears all this and says to herself in the snow globe, "Please, let my training have worked to help get Twilight ready for this challenge. This follower is stranger than I had expected and it may have turned the tide in favor of Nightmare Moon. Please let us succeed."

G.O.D.

Excited whisper and chatter happened among many of the towns members. After a good deal of fanfare Mayor Mare took to the center stage. She grabbed the microphone and began to speak. “Ponies of Ponyville, it is with my own pride and a grand honor to introduce to you her highness. Princess Celestia!” With a sweeping shift he cast his gaze up to the balcony, were Rarity in that moment reached out and pulled at the cord that held the drapes closed.

And standing in behind them? Not the Sun goddess who had for thousands of years ruled over their kind and protected them from the dangers that filled the world. Instead it was the form of Nightmare Moon, now armed with  thin cyan armor chest mail and armor head piece with crafted with arcane designs carved into every inch of the surface with the twinkling images of the stars themselves visible in her mane. Beside her was a black cloaked figure who had a sword in its black gloved hands standing ready beside her “Greetings mine subjects. At long last thy one true queen has returned.”

"Oh, my beloved subjects. It's been so long since I've seen your precious, little sun-loving faces."  Nightmare Moon announced as she was looking at the audience of ponies.

"What did you do with our Princess?!" Rainbow Dash yelled out as she tried to charge at Nightmare Moon but she was stopped by Applejack.

"Whoa there, Nelly..."  Applejack as she grabbed Rainbow by the shoulder and forced her down Nightmare Moon than began a cold and cruel chuckle.

"Tell us, whom among you know who I am?”  Nightmare Moon prompted as her demonic eyes skimmed over the ponies. “

"...Yes," Twilight said. "You're... Nightmare Moon."

"Well well well, somepony who remembers me. Then you also know why I'm here." replies Nightmare Moon with a smile on her muzzle

"You're here to... too..." Twilight Sparkle began to stammer. Having lost the confidence she had for that moment.

A malignant smile graces the lips of the dark goddess. "Remember this day, little ponies, for today is the last day the sun will ever rise. From this moment forth, eternal night has begun!" Nightmare Moon said as lightning starts to fill the air.

With that sentence, the guard charge at her on foot and by wing to attack Nightmare Moon when the figure steps forward and begins to kill each guard by either cutting off their head of just impaling them on the sword. The blood coats some ponies who seem to panic or go into shock at this bloodshed.

Nightmare Moon laughs as she says, Prepare my subjects for soon all will be mine and you will all forget about Celestia!"

In a cloud of smoke, Nightmare Moon and the figure disappear causing the town to go into a panic as Twilight ran to the library to grab what she needed in order to defeat Nightmare Moon and the cloaked figure.

Twilight panicked as she tried to find the book she needed as she called to Spike, "Spike! I need your help and we have to hurry!"

"What you looking for? You trying to do other stuff to us spy!" states Rainbow Dash at Twilight.

A tug on her tail from Applejack stops her from hurting Twilight as she says, "Simmer Down Sally. She ain't no spy but she does know what's going on. Don't you Twilight?"

What none of the ponies inside knew was that they were being watched from a window by Nightmare Moon and Nate. They listened closely to the ponies as they talked about 'The Elements of Harmony' and that the elements were located in...

"...Every free Forest!" states the ponies as they look into the forest.

Nate looks at Nightmare Moon and says, "My lady. I shall fight them here so you may locate the elements and destroy them. I wish to either slow them down or destroy these ponies before they hurt you."

"Do what you must my friend but be with haste for if they escape your grasp I will need you with me to fight them again." states Nightmare Moon as she lets him out of her magic.

He falls to the ground and lands with a loud bang in front of the six ponies  who had just stepped into the forest.

"I cannot let you six go any farther. My lady needs time and you must not do this or I will be forced to kill you." He states as he draws his swords to wield in each hand.

Twilight looks wide eyed at him and asks, "Who and what are you? Why must you do this to us?"

"My goddess demands that none enter here and it must be done. I am her loyal follower and devoted warrior." he states as she takes off his cloak to show himself to the ponies. "And I am the one you must face if you are stupid enough to keep going."

Twilight gasps having seen his kind before in ancient legends, "You are a human!"

The others gasp at having such a being before them. Humans had once been legends of warriors that served as special guards to the princesses before one day they just died or disappeared. No one knew if it was true or not until now.

"Why are ya helping that no good varmint that's a tryin to take over Equestria?" asks Applejack with concern. She felt that this creature was good and yet it worked for someone so evil.

"I swore service to her upon her saving my life. With my death in sight I swore that I would protect her and serve her till the day I died and I still wish that even if she wishes to end it all." he states as he takes a stance at seeing the rainbow colored Pegasus coming around his side as the others spread out.

"Well to bad! We are not gonna let that happen." states Rainbow as she speeds towards him with a hoof out to punch him.

With reflexes attuned to fighting fast opponents he easily steps aside and brings a boot around to hit her in the side sending her crashing into a tree hard, leaving an imprint. As he gets ready for the next attack a rope lassoes around his arms to make him unable to use his swords. Using his legs he easily flips and lets the rope fall onto the ground as his sword buzzes past the mane of Rarity making her run off to check her mane.

Twilight shoots a few beams of magic at him only for him to use his sword to block them or absorb them. He ducks as Pinkie Pie fires her cannon which hits Twilight instead and kicks Pinkie Pie to put her head first into a tree's hole. With most of the ponies done with he turns and sees.... a very scary looking pony before him. The yellow pony named Fluttershy was glaring at him and it was giving him the chills as he tried to stand his ground against her as she yells at him.

"How dare you hurt my friends! How dare you hurt others who are trying to save Equestria! HOW DARE YOU TRY AND THREATEN US WITH WEAPONS! YOU SHOULD BE ASHAMED OF YOURSELF FOR DOING THIS TO HELPLESS PONIES! DO YOU HAVE NO HONOR OR KINDNESS, YOU ... YOU... YOU MONSTER!" She screams into his face.

Most of the first stuff she said made him back up until the said the last two sentences which hurt him deeply. He looked down as he says in a sad voice, "I... I am ashamed of my actions and I do have kindness and honor but if I do not stop you... my lady would die. The Elements of Harmony are only suppose to be used once on someone before it kills them. If you use it again my lady will die and I will have to die with her."

The others are starting to get back up and gather around as she kneels in pain and sorrow as he keeps talking, "I do not like my job but someone has to do it or else who will help make the world better. I have been a soldier for most of my life and have fought countless fights and yet... I am always seen as a horrible person even though if me and others didn't do it... the world would be lost to death and ruin."

He is openly sobbing as he holds the necklace in his hand and letting tears fall while the ponies around him look either sad or depressed at his speech.

Fluttershy goes up to him and hugs him as she says in a soft and caring voice, "I know how hard it is to be a soldier and how some ponies treat you badly. My mother is a soldier and cries herself to sleep at times because of how ponies see her at times. I am sorry for calling you a monster but I had to make you see that this is not right and that you are doing the wrong thing. I know you can't take back your oath to her but you must at least try to not kill or hurt others like you used to. That is the difference between a fighter and a soldier."

He nods and stands up slowly before saying, "It seems that I must go now. I will let you enter but we will face each other on the other side at the castle. I will not be able to stop, my lady, from hurting you but I must follow my oath and keep you from harming her. I...If it comes down to it... you must kill me or else I will be forced to kill you if she so wishes it."

He nods to them before turning and running deep into the forest towards Nightmare Moon as the ponies watch him disappear.

"Why did you guys let him go? We could have taken him!" yells Rainbow Dash at them.

Applejack shakes her head and says, "He is way too strong for us to defeat without a plan of action, Sugarcube. Worse is that he is actually a kind stallion."

Fluttershy nods and states in her low voice, "He is to kind even for his own good. He is willing to die to let us win it seems."

Twilight looks confused at Fluttershy as she asks, "What do you mean by that?"

"He told us to kill him if need be. He means that when we get the Elements of Harmony and face off against Nightmare Moon... He wants us to kill him so we can win and save Equestria."

"You can't seriously mean he wishes to die, darling." asks a shocked Rarity with wide eyes.

Fluttershy nods and says, "We wants to die so that he can keep with his oath and still be a good... person. It's his last wish for us to complete. I will do so if it comes down to it."

The other ponies gasp in shock as they look at the sad Fluttershy who stated she would willingly kill somepony as there last wish.

"You can't mean that Flutters. You're like way to cool to do something like that." states Rainbow.

"I must if need be. I am a kind pony but even death is sometimes a kindness when there is so other way. Some animals can't be saved even by me and I have had to end their lives just so they can smile or be happy at the end." states Fluttershy as she slowly walks forward with her head down.

Twilight looks at the others who look sadly as well before they trot after Fluttershy. Twilight thinks to herself, 'Is there no way to save him? I know that death is natural but... There has to be a way to save him and defeat Nightmare Moon as well. There must be...'