Author's Note

Much like the previous chapter, contains: Hyper Pregnancy/Impregnation, Rape, Mind Break, Hyper Crotchoobs/Ass, Futa, Hyper Balls, light cum inflation, and worst of all shameless fetish fuel plot. (Hopefully that covers all the trigger warnings)

Currently working an an alternate ending for my first fic Experiment in Gluttony. After that I'll take a break from these alternate endings and start working on brand new stories again.

Nightmare Moon's New Toys (Alternate Ending, Semi-Dark/Bad End)

Applejack awoke to a familiar sight. It was one that would bring horror to most mares but was now the natural state of things for her. Looming at-least a couple feet above her head was her swollen belly, so tall she couldn't see her belly button and so heavy it pinned her down to the bed. Her expanded womb was, as usual, filled to the brim with young soldiers for her mistress' army. She was now carrying her seventh brood, and it was far larger than any she had before. She didn't know the exact number of foals growing inside her but guessed there had to be over a dozen at least. The massive dome of her middle shook and wobbled slightly on contact as she began running her hooves over the small parts she could still reach. A heavy shudder of surprise and odd satisfaction ran through her body as she felt a couple of her offspring kick against her womb in response. She once felt fear and anger at what had happened to her, but now felt nothing but motherly pride at her over productive fertility. Escape was no longer on her mind. The constant cycle of pregnancy she was kept in, combined with the increasing brood sizes, left her with periods of mobility that lasted a few weeks at best. The rate at which that window was shrinking meant that trying to run would soon be physically impossible even if she had the willpower. However, a new spell developed by Nightmare Moon which caused Applejack to orgasm with every birth had broken her willpower and left her addicted to the entire process. She still missed her friends, but aside from that had mostly embraced her new life.

Applejack's thoughts were disrupted as the door to her private room opened. In walked her mistress, owner, and sometimes breeder. Nightmare Moon smirked with the usual pride and satisfaction she had for Applejack's ever-expanding womb. After dropping a small bag off near the entrance of the room she approached Applejack's bed from the side, giving her massive orange belly a light pat.

"Good morning, my broodmare. I see the latest batch is coming along nicely."

Applejack nodded, "Yes, mistress. It's a strong group this time."

"I'd expect nothing else. Your offspring have always been powerful and healthy. I made a good choice in my breeding slave. You've come so far in such a short time. To think a few months ago you were so small and toned, but now..." Nightmare's voice drifted off as she ran a hoof over the curved slopes of Applejack's swell. She had to raise up on her hind hooves in order to touch the top of this orange mountain in front of her. She gently brushed over Applejack's navel, which had popped out and swollen to comical size. Applejack was shuddering lightly at each touch, her stretched belly now hyper-sensitive to every sensation. "Truly a marvel of magic and potion making. I wonder how much further we'll be able to stretch your womb as I continue refining the fertility potion..." She allowed that question to hang in the air as her roaming hooves moved back down the slope towards the lower regions of Applejack's body, with Nightmare Moon re-positioning herself for a better view. Sitting below Applejack's mountainous belly were the two smaller slopes of her breasts. She had been giving milk constantly since her first pregnancy and her body had compensated admirably. Each breast exceeded the size of a large melon, and her swollen nipples were continuously leaking small droplets of motherly milk. Nightmare smirked before leaning in and giving the right nipple a teasing lick. Applejack let out a moan with hints of both pain and pleasure, clearly desperate to relieve her overfilled tits. Nightmare obliged her slave by wrapping her lips around the nipple and eagerly sucking out a few thick streams of sweet milk. "Your production of milk is impressive. However, these breasts will need to grow much larger if you are to keep up with demand."

"Y-Yes, mistress." Applejack's submissive response had hints of excitement.

"I see the rest of your figure is coming along as well," Nightmare remarked as she began to grope and squeeze at Applejack's plump flank. Applejack had been forced to eat meals that could feed an entire village in order to sustain her broods, and the leftovers were filling out her hips, thighs, and backside at a rapid pace. Her plot cheeks were nearly as big and round as basketballs, jiggling and wobbling anytime she exercised what little mobility she retained. Her plump thighs squashed together nearly all the way down to her knees. Most impressive, however, was her hips. Her hips stretched almost twice as wide as her shoulders and emphasized her excessive fertility. During the increasingly rare occasions when Applejack was able to walk, she did so with a heavy sway to her gait. "These foals are turning you into such a large, heavy mare. To think this is only the beginning. I can only imagine how fat your flank will be and how wide your hips will get after seven more broods." Upon finishing her sentence Nightmare noticed that Applejack was now rubbing her thighs together and panting lightly. "Oh, does this excite you, broodmare?"

"A-A little."

"Good. My plans for you have just begun, and you've already surpassed all expectations. There is one problem, however..."

Applejack frowned, "Have ah displeased you?"

Nightmare Moon chuckled, "No. It's just that some events are happening that mean I need to accelerate my plans. Even with the exceptional progress I've had with you, one broodmare isn't enough to achieve the numbers I need in time. So I've obtained a gift for both of us. One that'll give me more soldiers, and will cure the loneliness you've felt recently."

"What is it?"

Nightmare Moon returned to the door and called for her guards. A squad of Nightmare Moon's soldiers soon entered the room, and the identity of their prisoners made her jaw drop. She saw all five of her best friends. They were beaten, bruised, and tied up. Their faces contained a mix of shock and horror as they observed Applejack's current state.

"What have you done with her?!" Rainbow Dash cried out.

Nightmare Moon chuckled, "The same process I'm going to do with the rest of you, little one."

The appearance of her friends brought Applejack into a rare moment of clarity. She had long given up hope that they'd be able to rescue her and resigned to her fate. Seeing that they hadn't given up on her inspired a small sense of resolve. What could she possibly do though? She doubted even her full strength would be enough to roll over, and being able to stand up and walk was utterly impossible.

While Applejack was desperately trying to think of any plan, Nightmare Moon was already preparing to put her own into full effect. She used magic to levitate a set of five potions into the air as she spoke. "As you can probably surmise from your friend over there, I've found a new approach to conquering Equestria. I am no longer concerned with destroying the Elements of Harmony or stealing their power. No, I am going to breed the Elements. You five are going to join Applejack as my broodmares. The six of you will be the mothers to a massive army of powerful magic-enchanted soldiers that will easily overrun Equestria."

Twilight Sparkle rolled her eyes, "That's a terrible plan. Even if you kept us here for the entire time we're fertile you'd only be able to produce maybe a hundred soldiers."

"Usually you'd be right. However, thanks to my fertility potions I'm able to bend those pesky biological limits. Just look at your little friend over there. A few doses of this and you'll be able to spawn several foals with every pregnancy. Your wombs will be able to stretch to untold sizes to compensate."

Twilight seemed a bit more nervous now, "W-Well, you'd still have to wait for any offspring to grow up."

"I'm working on a way to mature them to fighting age faster. However, even if I can't a few decades is a short time to wait for total conquest. Enough talk for now. Open up, girls." Nightmare Moon began floating the potions over to her new prisoners. Naturally, all five of them closed their mouths tightly in resistance. "Fine. We'll do this the hard way." She gave one potion to each guard in the room before walking up to Fluttershy, who was the first in the line.

"I'll just force you to drink one by one." Fluttershy let out a frightened gasp as Nightmare Moon's magic forced her mouth to open. Soon after, the guard standing by her opened the potion and began pouring it into her maw. Any resistance she made was in vain as every last drop made its way into her. The effects were remarkably quick. Fluttershy began to blush deeply, her body trembling with quickly building arousal.

"W-What's happening to me?" Fluttershy asked.

"That would be your body going into a state of heat as multiple eggs are released into your womb. It's no normal heat. With your heightened fertility, think of it as a superheat."

"You aren't getting away with this!" Rainbow Dash shouted, "You think we'll sit around and wait to swell up like balloons? We-" Her protests were cut off as one of the potions was shoved into her mouth, its contents easily flowing down her throat.

"Applejack felt the same way," Nightmare retorted, "She attempted multiple to escape many times, but I broke her in time. Just as I will with all of you."

Applejack scowled in rage, feeling a bit of old fire starting to rekindle. She rocked helplessly back and forth on her bed, her massive belly wobbling heavily in response to the movement. She could also feel her foals becoming more active, several of them actively kicking against her womb. These sensations filled her with arousal, and she found herself forced to fight against the very effective brainwashing she had previously submitted to.

Meanwhile, all of Applejack's friends were forced into drinking Nightmare's potion one at a time. They were actively trying to resist the effects, but it was clear the pressure was building. All five were blushing heavily, panting, and fighting against the urge to rub their thighs together. The growing arousal in their eyes was clear as day.

“Now for the fun part,” Nightmare smirked maliciously as her guards spread their legs enough to reveal themselves to their captives. Each soldier had a pair of very large balls, clearly swollen with excessive production of seed. This was accompanied by a large, thick rod throbbing with eagerness to deliver the pent-up payload. After the four guards showed the helpless mares what they were in for they each picked out a prisoner to claim. Twilight appeared notably left out.

“Looks like you’re one rapist short,” Twilight remarked with a scowl.

“Not at all. I just wanted you for myself.” Nightmare let out a slight cackle as she turned her body to reveal her own set of male equipment. She was even more endowed than her guards. Her balls were almost as big as soccer balls and the fluid inside them sloshed with her movement. Her hard shaft was a good foot in length and definitely thick enough to give Twilight a good stretching.

Twilight gulped as Nightmare Moon maneuvered behind her and positioned herself above her. Nightmare’s hooves were now placed to the sides of Twilight’s head, with her stomach directly over her back. Nightmare slowly moved her lower body forward until her cock was pressing against Twilight’s already wet slit. She leaned her head down and whispered tauntingly into Twilight’s ear, “The first time is always the best. I can’t wait to see you break~”

Twilight’s friends weren’t in any better situations. All of them had been mounted and were being penetrated by their respective captors. The room was filled with shouts and whines as each mare tried to resist with little progress.

“You uncouth barbarians. T-This won’t work!” Rarity declared, “With all of us together..we can resist,” the guard mounting her only chuckled in response as he began thrusting in and out of her slick marehood, filling the room with the lewd sound of flesh on flesh.

“Y-Yeah!” Pinkie shouted in agreement, “You think you can use sex as a weapon? That’s just crazy!” Her voice cracked a couple times with hints of moaning. The stallion rutting her gave her flank a hard smack, smiling as it jiggled heavily.

“This one will make a good breeding cow. She’s already halfway there,” Pinkie’s forced partner declared, inciting some laughter from the other guards.

Rainbow Dash struggled violently against the whole process but found her head shoved down to the ground as the guard above her began thrusting more aggressively. Just a few feet away Fluttershy whimpered meekly as a guard who was a bit too big for her mercilessly ravaged her previously tight marehood.

Applejack was incensed. She had to do something. Although it was difficult when she was finding two battles at once. One was against the massive bulk of her body, and the other against her own mind. There was something strangely erotic about watching her friends getting pounded and bred. Her mind was filled with images of her friends slowly growing pregnant. She could picture each of them expanding larger and larger much the way she had. Eventually, they’d all be in this same position. Helplessly pinned down to a bed by an overfilled womb packed to capacity with Nightmare Moon’s future soldiers. The thought of it all made her begin to rub her plump thighs together subconsciously, with a familiar feeling of heat and moisture building between her legs.

“No! Snap out of it!” Applejack chided herself as she began making a final effort to roll herself over. She put forward all her strength, working until she was panting desperately for breath. Despite it all, she was still in the same position as a few moments before. It was at this point that she realized no amount of willpower was going to help. She was simply too large to do anything. The only option was to lay back and watch events unfold.

The level of intensity in the room had only increased. Lewd grunts and groans were emitted from all parties involved. In addition, wet slapping sounds filled the room from all the different sets of hips colliding together. Nightmare Moon and her guards were thrusting into their captives much harder than before, and they seemed to be slowly drawing closer to the big climax.

“Not much longer now, little pet.” Nightmare whispered into Twilight’s ear as she continued rutting her target. Twilight’s marehood clenched tightly around Nightmare’s girthy cock, providing extra stimulation to both of them. All the while Nightmare’s nuts were churning heavily with her corrupted seed.

“We’ll never *pant* give into you. Even if *pant* you do this,” Twilight attempted to protest, but it was becoming difficult to get the words out amidst all of her moanings. Her body was actively betraying her. No matter how much she wanted to hate what was happening, she couldn’t fight the physical pleasure that was rendering her weak and submissive.

“Suit yourself. Breaking you mentally is just a side-goal. Your body will do what I want in either case,” Nightmare bragged with a smirk as she began ramming Twilight’s entrance much harder and faster.

The other four were in no better condition. The lust potions had been slowly overwhelming their resolve. At this stage, most of them were reduced to moaning and thrusting their hips back against their captors. They were like feral mares in heat. All they could do was what came naturally.

Applejack bit her lip as she watched. Now that she’d given up on intervening her mind had flooded with more lustful thoughts. She began to wonder which of her friends would get knocked up first and how many foals would swell out their bellies in the coming months. Their figures would likely suffer the same fate as hers, with fat bouncy flanks and swollen tits. She whimpered, being unable to reach a hoof down and pleasure herself. She settled for grinding her thighs together eagerly while enjoying the show. She soon observed that the stallion thrusting into Rarity was becoming more erratic with his rutting. There was a slight twitch in one of his back legs, and he was thrusting unevenly. It looked like Rarity was next in line on the broodmare-to-be list.

Applejack’s prediction proved correct as within a few moments the stallion she was observing pushed deep into Rarity with a loud groan. A submissive whine emitted from Rarity as her captor began pumping large spurts of virile seed deep inside of her. The potion had definitely done its job on her, as she put up no further signs of resistance as she was thoroughly inseminated. There was a far-away look in her eyes, with the parts of her brain that would resist this being suppressed by overwhelming pleasure and desire.

The whole process was repeated with Pinkie Pie just a few moments later. The stallion rutting her gave her plump flank a final hard smack before tightly gripping onto her hips and lodging his cock as deep into her as it would go. Pinkie moaned and babbled with pleasure as she was rapidly pumped full of baby batter, “Ooh, you guys sure do make a lot of yummy cum.” She giggled loudly as a few final waves of seed were released into her waiting womb.

“Two down, three to go.” Nightmare Moon bragged as she quickened her pace. Nightmare’s cock was throbbing heavily now, the pressure inside continuing to build. It was obvious to everyone that this was going to be a big load.

The two Pegasi were next to be bred. The two stallions rutting them smirked at each other as they thrust in unison. It looked like they planned to impregnate their targets at the same time.

“I bet this one with the pink mane will make a great broodmare. She gave in real easy,” Fluttershy’s guard taunted. Fluttershy was too lost in the lust of it all to respond properly, any meek retort she made was lost in all the moaning.

“Please *Moan* d-don’t, I’m not ready *pant* to be a mom,” Rainbow Dash made a slightly larger attempt at protest, but it was equally in vain.

“You look ready to me. So shut up and just take it,” her guard gave her a hard slap on the rump to emphasize his point.

The two guards bumped hooves before giving out a few final thrusts and releasing into their respective mares. The sounds of their groans were quickly drowned out by the receiving mares moaning with pleasure. Any final complaints Fluttershy or Rainbow may have had were lost as intense satisfaction washed over them. It was yet another manipulative effect of Nightmare’s potion, causing mares to orgasm just from cum reaching their womb.

“Just one left,” Nightmare Moon laughed sadistically as she continued whispering taunts into Twilight’s ear. “I hope you’ve enjoyed watching your friends get claimed one by one because now it’s your turn.” Sounds of their sex intensified as Nightmare assaulted Twilight with deep and heavy thrusts. Her member was throbbing harder than ever, with her balls churning and sloshing with the massive load she was about to release. “You should be honored to get impregnated by me. You’ll get to carry the largest and strongest brood out of all your friends. I’m sure you’ll catch up with even Applejack after just a few pregnancies.”

Thrust Thrust

Twilight grunted and whined as she struggled against Nightmare’s grasp. She could feel the same haze that broke her friends starting to fog up her mind as well. She could know tell that if Nightmare was allowed even this one victory it could have irreversible effects. There was no escape, though. Her focus was clouded and her muscles weak. Her own body had defeated her, shutting down her resistance to fulfill its desire for Nightmare Moon’s potent seed.

Thrust Thrust

“S-So close. This is glorious. I wish Princess Celestia could see her prized pupil become my pet,” Nightmare panted as her heavy balls began tightening up closer to her shaft. She was only a few more thrusts away from completing her conquest of the Elements of Harmony.

Thrust Thrust

“Ready yourself, Twilight Sparkle. It’s time for your new life...n-now!”

With one final thrust Nightmare Moon pushed her member right up to Twilight’s cervix and begin spurting a torrential wave of seed into the mare’s womb. She soon began thrusting once more, releasing a new wave of cum every time she embedded herself into Twilight. She pumped wave after wave of potent semen into her new broodmare. The onslaught she released was so large that Twilight’s belly began to bulge out slightly and gave her a very pudgy look.

Twilight tried to resist at first. However, as her womb began to fill she was overwhelmed with the same sensations that the others experienced. By the time it was done she was moaning and panting shamelessly. All of her previous anger and worry seemed distant as the fog of lust claimed her mind.

Nightmare took a few moments to savor the victory before pulling out. There was a lewd slick sound as she withdrew her cock. It slapped against Twilight’s rear and let out a final few drops of cum. The empress took a few moments to look at the other captured mares. They all were in the same condition as Twilight, rendered into a state of lustful haze by the potion.

“Well done. Now, move each of these prisoners to their own cell. We need to make sure they’re all properly broken before we can trust leaving them together.”

As the guards began dragging the others away Nightmare strolled over to her heavily pregnant first broodmare. Applejack’s face was deep red with a mixture of lust and embarrassment.

“I take it you enjoyed the show?”

Applejack was too ashamed of herself to speak, but it was clear the answer was yes. She shuddered as Nightmare began rubbing a hoof over her swollen belly once more.

“Soon, you won’t have to be lonely when I’m away. You’ll have your friends to talk to. You’ll all be broodmares together. For now, though, I’ll leave you with your thoughts.”

“B-But…” Applejack bit her lip, still rubbing her thighs together. The arousal that had built up from watching earlier events was driving her crazy. Her marehood was hot and drenched, but she had no way to relieve it.

“Oh. I see. I’m afraid I won’t be helping you with that tonight. Consider it punishment for those displays of attempted resistance you made earlier,” Nightmare cackled evilly as she began walking away.

“See you in the morning, broodmare.”

Applejack gently rubbed the sides of her belly as the door slammed coldly. This was a rough life sometimes. She had hoped her friends would rescue her and take her away, but at least they’d be here with her now.

Six broodmares were happier than one, after-all.