The Deepest Darkest Secrets

by Silver Inkwell

Rating: teen
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Alternate Universe, Rainbow Dash, Romance, Fluttershy, Random, Slice of Life, Twilight Sparkle
Length: 4492

Twilight tries out a new spell on Fluttershy, it does not go/ turn out very well.

Twilight tries out a new spell on Fluttershy, it does not go/ turn out very well.

Rated Teen Because it Features: Seductiveness, Cuddling, Hugging, Some Slight Kissing, and Suggestive Materials and Some Very Slight Mild Swearing

WARNING: Contains Flutterdash shipping

Published 2017-02-28 15:00:01 UTC
Last updated 2017-03-02 15:43:42 UTC

One

Twilight slowly examined her very new book that she had been recently given to, one that was from Princess Celestia herself, and as such she treated this one with even more tender loving gentle care than she normally did on a very regular basis. She skimmed through and glanced at the pages very quickly trying to absorb every detail and spell in. Then with a very bright big huge smile on her face she took in a big huge whiff of the book. Oh, that smelled so good…

There was a whole lot in this book, but one very particular spell stood out from the rest, “Darkonius Fathomonia Secextras, this spell reveals and masks any living creature’s true real side. Warning: This usually causes the subject to always tell the truth no matter what it is, how cold, cruel, or blunt. However, it also can bring about something that the caster of the spell has never seen from the subject ever before, any and all behaviors and actions of such can and shall, and will only be held responsible to the caster of the spell instead of this book, it’s writers, editors, of chief ponies for any and all part(s) that are of this book.”

She rolled her eyes and sighed, she was fine with legality matters, but did they have to do it with every spell? It was becoming very annoying at this point, so much quite so that Twilight wanted to write a letter to them and complain.

She didn’t of course, because she was just too nice, kind, and generous of them and any and all of their mistakes. The spell looked very interesting and left a whole lot to the imagination, and now all that she needed was a willing test subject, but who could she find on such notice? Twilight sat down and then put one hoof on her chin and folded back her wings as she thought. Rarity would surely be too busy working on her clothes, Rainbow Dash would probably just be too lazy to do it unless she tricked her into doing it instead, Applejack would be hard at work on the farm, and Pinkie Pie… well… she was just herself.

She could go over and double check that they weren’t busy, but she knew that they would be since they all already had plans for today, plans that Twilight knew very well, her other friends however, they could work out, right?

“Nope, sorry, I can’t today, too busy with the shop.”

“Nope, sorry, I can’t today, I have to take my mom’s sick gold-turtle to the hospital and have it get a massage- I mean its shots for its health of course.”

On and on these answers of no went, each time the answer did seem remotely plausible except for a very small select few. Finally, she had no other choice.

“Spike, will you come here for a moment?”

Here was no answer and she suddenly knew exactly why. Spike was out doing something boy related with Big Mac and Discord of course.

He wouldn’t be back until later on this evening.

That left only one last final choice.

Sighing she slowly went over to Fluttershy’s cottage and knocked.

She waited for a very long moment until the door finally opened up very slowly.

“Oh, well hi there, Twilight,” Fluttershy said very nervously now then.

“Hey Fluttershy, I was wondering if you would be willing and able to do something for me? It’s nothing really, it’s just very small, tiny, and little.”

Fluttershy considered this for one moment as her lips quivered and then she finally sighed. “Yeah, I guess so, I don’t really have anything planned today anyhow,” she said. “Great, let’s get started right away then, shall we?”

“Yeah, I guess so,” Fluttershy said scooting very nervously out of the way.

“Okay then, so I found out this new spell in this new book given to me by Princess Celestia, there’s only one small slight tiny problem, I have no idea what it does yet exactly and I was wondering if you’d like to be my very first test subject.”

“Uh, well yeah, sure, so long as it doesn’t hurt me…”

“Oh no, it doesn’t, not from what I’ve read at least, it only changes you and makes you tell the truth apparently, so it’s nothing too bad that much really.”

“Oh, well then, fine, I don’t even really mind at all.”

“Well then that’s just great, fine then, let’s get started now, shall we?”

And with that said Twilight lit up her horn and said the magic words to the spell.

“Well? Do you feel anything at all? Anything strange, out of place, unusual, or very highly much odd instead?” Twilight said now then.

“No, I don’t feel anything yet, nothing at all,” she said.

“Well the spell should be working since it said the effects were instantaneous.”

“Well I don’t know about the spell, but I think that it’s time that you should probably go and leave me now, right?” she said very gently Twilight towards the doorway. “Well I guess so only if you want me to leave you first though.”

“Well guess what, I do, so yeah, please just go away for now!!!”

And with that said suddenly the door was slammed shut right in front of Twilight’s face. Wow, she had never seen Fluttershy act so rude or out of place either before, it was almost as if… no… it couldn’t be the spell, right? But it just had to be since there was nothing else that Twilight could possibly ever think of to explain her very recent behavior and actions that she just took.

Twilight sighed, she should have known better than to just test out a random spell without any kind of hypothesis or knowing what it did either exactly.

She didn’t know what to expect now since she had cast the spell, but whatever was to come next, she was sure that she would be very surprised and shocked.

She decided to go back on to her own home and hoped that whatever happened it would turn out well enough for her instead of going very bad.

Later that evening Spike did indeed come home and was very curious if anything interesting, odd, strange, or out of place had happened since he had left.

“Well I did try out this new spell from this new book that princess Celestia gave me on Fluttershy, but I’m still afraid since I have no idea how it works out yet exactly though,” she said. “Oh, well then, I hope that everything works out well enough, but who’s the author or spell maker of the book though exactly?”

“Star Swirl of course, who else? I mean he did practically invent every spell.”

“Yeah, all except for one, the levitation spell,” Spike grumbled under his breath.

“Well how was everything with Discord and Big Mac?”

“Just perfectly excellent and wonderful, we reenacted Lord of the Rings,”

“Huh, well that’s good enough I guess, well, good night for now then.”

“Yep, good night,” he said going into his own bed trying to get comfortable just as Twilight did since her wings kept getting all stiff and straight on her.

And with that said all was silent in the castle.

Two

The next morning came and then Twilight slowly opened her eyes to see that Fluttershy was sitting on top of her bed in a very seductive sexy position.

“Well hello there, Twilight, you look very lovely and wonderful this fine morning.”

Twilight tried not to scream and resisted the very strong urge and instead forced herself to take a very deep calming breath before she finally replied to her.

“Good morning, Fluttershy, may I ask why you are in my bed though exactly?”

“Oh, Twilight, I thought that you already knew one of my darkest deepest secrets,” she said giggling with a very slight blush as she tilted her chin towards twilight and licked her lips very seductively, “But I guess not, I guess that I was wrong, but let me tell you it anyways, secretly I really like other mares,”

The full realization and implications of this slowly sunk in.

“Wait, you’re a lesbian?” Twilight said.

Fluttershy giggled, “Yep, I surely am indeed, what are you going to do about it, you naughty, dirty, little girl?” she said as she bent over and showed Twilight her- “Fluttershy!!! How could you?” Twilight said turning away from the sight.

Fluttershy giggled, “What? Body parts are nothing to be ashamed of since we’re all just naked around here anyways, what’s so wrong with showing off just a tiny little small bit to some pony who’s your very best friend after all?”

“Fluttershy, you can’t just go around showing your-… body parts to some pony else even if they are your very best friend!!! It’s just not right, okay then?”

Fluttershy giggled as she seductively walked around Twilight very slowly.

“Well, if you say so then okay, alright, fine, but I’m starting to wonder if you’re just saying that because you’re nervous about admitting your true real feelings about how you feel about dating mares, especially ones like me, or if you’re saying that just because you’ll always be that smart nerdy lonely pony in the corner always studying for her next test, quiz, and exam never making any friends, honestly Twilight, I was surprised and very shocked to learn that you had any friends before you ever found us, it really truly is amazing that you had any life before you found us, I think that we completed you instead, Twilight.”

“Oh my gosh Fluttershy, I can’t believe that you would actually say something like that, I mean this behavior is not like you and I think that I might know why.”

“Oh Twilight, these thoughts have always been part of me, I’ve just never been brave enough to express them out loud, but now I can, because I don’t want to hold back any of my deepest darkest secrets, I’m going to let my true real side of me shine through, my sexy side, my romantic and adventure side, because guess what, I can be whatever you want me to be anytime that you want, Twilight.”

“Oh,” Twilight suddenly said, “I think that I’m starting to understand what the spell did to you, it makes you tell your deepest darkest secrets while also revealing something that he subject hasn’t ever shown before, like you being sexy and mean, which both totally go against your normal regular personality.”

“You guessed it, but I’m not lying about any of these things at all you know.”

“Yeah, the notes did mention that the spell might force you to tell the truth,”

Fluttershy giggled, “Well then, if you don’t mind I’m going to go seduce my favorite mare because while you’re pretty cute you’re not the one that I love.”

“Alright, fine then, go, I’ll be here trying to figure a way out to reverse the spell.”

And with that said Fluttershy smiled as she left.

Later on, Twilight finally computed just exactly what Fluttershy had said.

“SHE’S GOING TO DO WHAT?” she shouted running outside the castle and then trying to find and figure out where she had just gone exactly though.

Three

Twilight rushed out of the house desperate to find Fluttershy first before she did whatever she was planning in her head had mind to whatever pony she loved.

She stopped for a moment, she didn’t know who she loved though.

Well that’s just great because now she had no idea where to go.

Well… she might just have one way that could work out for her…

But she still didn’t know if it would work or not this time.

She too a very deep heavy sigh and gave in, it was probably the only way left for her now. Slowly she managed up the will to do what she needed to do right then.

“Discord!!!” she shouted hoping and praying that this would work out.

“Yes, Twilight?” Discord said stepping out of a random various dimensional doorway. “Discord, could you please tell me where Fluttershy is right now exactly?” she said. “Let me think about that, um, no, I won’t, sorry.”

“Why not?” she said. “Well, why should I? What’s in it for me exactly dearie?”

Twilight took in another very deep sigh. “What do you want though exactly?”

Discord slowly smiled, “Finally some pony asks the right question, well Twilight, to answer your question I want attention and love, I want money, I want power, I want wealth, I want fame, I want to grasp the whole entire world in the palm of my claw, I want anything and everything that I ask for of course.”

“Uh, but don’t you sort of kind of already have that already?” she said.

“Look, I feel like I’m not getting enough attention from you or your friends.”

“So, what do you want then though exactly?”

“I want to be featured in the newspaper with you of course, and more time with you and your friends, how about Fridays, will that work out for you?”

“Yeah, sure thing, whatever, fine, alright, just tell me where Fluttershy is!!!”

“Well alright, fine then, but you’re a bit picky and impatient today now, aren’t we?” he said closing his eyes, “Yes, well it looks like she’s over at Rainbow’s house, and it looks like she’s… doing something I won’t say for you right now.”

“Wait, what is it exactly?” she said very curiously now then.

“Sorry, you’re just going to have to go up there and figure it out by yourself.”

“Well alright, fine then, I will,” she said leaving him all alone now then.

And with that said she flapped her wings very powerfully and slowly flew up into the clouds over to Rainbow Dash’s house. She quickly knocked on the door.

“Rainbow Dash? Are you here right now? I’m sorry if I’m disturbing you but-,”

“I’m kind of and sort of busy right now at the moment!!!”

“-I was wondering if I could just have a moment if you let me in.”

“Uh sorry, I can’t let you in, but you can come in if you want to because honestly I’m having a very hard time figuring out what Fluttershy is doing to me here right now,” she said. Twilight took the invitation to come in and was very shocked and surprised at what she saw. Fluttershy was wearing lingerie and was licking and nibbling the ears of Rainbow Dash who was tied down to the chair while Fluttershy sat in front of her on her lap in a very seductive sexual position.

“Oh my,” Twilight said blushing at the sight as she closed the door.

“Yeah, that’s exactly what I thought too at first as well!!!” Rainbow Dash said.

“Uh, Fluttershy? Do you mind getting off of Rainbow Dash?”

She giggled, “Why should I? We’re going to have so much fun together.”

“Yeah, thanks for the help Twilight, but I’ve tried everything that I can think of short of bucking her in the head, and nothing is working on her yet.”

“Well don’t worry, I’ll think of something to fix this spell.”

Rainbow Dash groaned, “Let me guess, new book, new spell, it went wrong?”

“Well yeah, that pretty much sums it up.”

“Well that figures out to be right, well anyhow just deal with her and then untie me from this chair, but do it quickly before she gets any more ideas!!!”

“Alright, fine then, let’s see here,” Twilight said flipping through her spell books including the newest and latest one, “Nope, that’s not it, still not it just yet…”

“Uh, Twilight, mind hurrying that up?” Rainbow Dash said very nervously as Fluttershy suddenly found a whip and smiled very deviously and seductively.

“I’m trying!!! Just don’t rush me, okay then, please,” she said.

“She has a whip Twilight, and I’m very worried with what she plans to do with it,” Rainbow Dash said. “Before I start what’s your safe word Dashie?” Fluttershy said still smiling. “TWILIGHT!!! PLEASE HELP ME OUT RIGHT NOW!!!”

“Well, that’s a very odd and rather strange safe pass code, but I’ll accept it-,”

Twilight put down her book as this was said and decided to screw finding a solution and instead opted for the very easy way out to help her friend, casting a sleeping spell. She lit up and flared her horn quickly casting the spell at her. The spell hit Fluttershy and then she instantly fell to the floor fast asleep.

“Oh thank goodness, I was starting to get worried there for a second, I’m just glad that you got here before she decided to play with any more of her toys, or even worse, actually have sex with me instead,” she said.

“Wait, what toys exactly?” Twilight said. “Oh, those toys, in the corner of the room,” Rainbow Dash said pointing to the right proper corner where sex toys lay.

“I didn’t know that you had those here.”

“I don’t Twilight, she brought them over from her house.”

“Oh, well who would have ever thought, right?”

“Yeah, well how long will she be out for then exactly?”

“Long enough hopefully, but not too long that we’ll have to drag her either too as well, but while she’s out I think I’d better explain what’s going on first,” she said going over and quickly untied the ropes with her magic. “Thanks a lot.”

“You’re welcome, anyhow I cast a spell on her, and apparently, it reveals and unmasks something that the subject has always hidden before, and in this case, it would seem to make Fluttershy a badass sex crazy obsessed pony.”

“Huh, well do you have any ideas on how to make her regular, normal, and ordinary again? Because I really don’t like sexy Fluttershy at all that much.”

“No, not yet, but I will be working on it, but until I do I think that we should keep Fluttershy somewhere safe, sound and secure so that way she doesn’t bother you or any pony else, including our friends too as well,” Twilight said.

“Oh, well then, good luck with that, but do you have any ideas where we might keep her? Because I don’t think that any pony would want a crazy sex obsessed pony,” she said. “Well we could keep her in one of the castle rooms I guess…”

“Yeah, I think that will be best, I mean after all, you have all those rooms, tons of them are unused each and every day,” she said now then.

“Yeah, that’s a very fair fine point, well I guess that you’re right Rainbow Dash.”

“Of course I’m right!!! And that’s because I am the very best pony that there is!!!”

Twilight sighed, “Rainbow Dash, you are not best pony, no pony is because we’re all equal, but if there was even such a thing as a best pony then it would have to be Star Swirl,” she said now then trying to reason with her.

“Oh come on, you’re only saying that because he was great and powerful, because he totally couldn’t possibly ever match my moves

that I have.”

“I’m pretty sure that he could,” Twilight said.

“Well he doesn’t have any wings-,”

“He doesn’t need any wings,”

“-So I’m pretty sure that I could beat him very easily enough.”

“Well, I’d like to see him try me one of these days.”

Twilight sighed, “Enough, let’s just take Fluttershy to one of the rooms in the castle until she wakes up and we can question her without any interruptions of any sort or kind?” she said. “Gladly,” Rainbow Dash said picking up one half of the body, “I’m just glad that she only nibbled my ear off and not anything else more, because if it had gotten any worse I don’t think that I would be quite the same,” she said. “Rainbow, you do not need to describe any of the details to me.”

“Don’t worry, I won’t,” she said. And with that they slowly carried Fluttershy over to the castle and then into one of the many various random rooms that were there. “You really need to get a map of this place sometime very soon.”

“Why though? Can’t you get around easily enough yet?”

“Nope, it’s still very much a maze and very confusing to me.”

“Well your suggestion is very noted, now then I’ll go to the library and try looking up ways to cure her, but come to me and alert me when she wakes up.”

“Okay then, fine alright captain,” Rainbow Dash said now then.

Twilight sighed and went into her very big huge library looking for a book.

She searched high and low, but there was still nothing that could help her out.

She even tried the new book out until Rainbow Dash eventually did finally come back to her. “She’s awake, but this time I tied her down to a chair instead.”

“I applaud your creative ingenuity,” Twilight said slowly followed her back to the room, “But I still haven’t quite found anything to fix her up just yet.”

“Well you’d better figure it out fast because she’s only getting more edgy by the minute,” she said slowly opening the door as Fluttershy smiled. “Oh, well hello there you two, did you bring a friend along to have some fun with me Dashie? That’s so thoughtful if you did, but I just want to have some fun with you all alone… if you know what I mean of course…” she said. “See what I mean?

Even I’m starting to get just a tiny little bit scared about her behavior and actions, I mean if this keeps up what are we even going to do with her anymore?”

“Yes, I do see it very clearly, and we should keep trying to help her out as best as we possibly can, but I think there just has to be something in this spell book that can help us out, I know that there is because there’s always a reverse spell.”

“Except for when there isn’t,” Rainbow said. “Yeah, well that is a very fine fair point, but that was for the one and only time,” she said rapidly flipping through the book until she found something. “Finally, I’ve got it, okay, so there’s no exact spell to reverse it, but there is something that we can do to undo it instead.”

“Well, what is it exactly? Please tell me,” Rainbow Dash said.

“Well the book says that with whomever she shares her secrets with must also likewise share something that they’ve never told to any pony else.”

“Wait, what?” Rainbow Dash shouted out very loudly.

“Well that’s what it says, and well yeah, I guess that would mean us since we’re the only ones that she’s shared her secrets with so far,”

“Well I don’t want to share any deep dark secrets of the past!!!”

“You’ll have to do it if you ever want Fluttershy back again.”

“Alright, fine then, very well, I’ll try to do my very best at this then… Fluttershy… You may like me… but I’ve always kind of… sort of… liked you too as well.”

“I once got a B+ on an assignment… and I also peed in the pool, I also am not really that interested in dating mares or any pony else either.”

Suddenly a look of calmness seemed to wash over Fluttershy.

“Oh my, I never knew that before, but can you please tell me why I’m tied up to a chair wearing lingerie?” she said. “Wait, don’t you remember anything that you did at all?” Rainbow said. “No, one moment I just remember being at my own home and then the next thing that I know I’m here tied up in this chair, why though exactly? Did something happen? Was it that spell that Twilight cast on me? Did it make me act differently or strange or unusual or odd in some sort of way?” she said. “Yeah, kind of, you were putting the moves on me.”

“Oh, well yeah, I kind of might have a crush on you just a tiny small little bit Dashie,” she said. “Hey that’s fine, that’s totally cool, and it’s really amazing and awesome that I finally know because now we can work out our relationship.”

“Wait, are you serious about this, about us?” she said. “Yeah, sure thing, why not? After all, you’re a pretty cute looking mare, especially in that lingerie.”

“Oh my, can you please untie me now so that I can change into something less exposing?” she said. “Fluttershy, we’re ponies, we go around to places naked the whole entire day, you literally have nothing to hide, not anymore at least.”

And with that said they untied Fluttershy and she changed out of her lingerie.

“Thanks a lot, but do you mind telling me what I did though exactly?”

Rainbow Dash smiled, “Later, we’ll tell you later, right Twilight?”

“Yeah, sure thing, but why don’t you go on home, I want to have a talk with Fluttershy alone before she goes anywhere else,” she said.

“Alright, fine then, very well, see you later, Fluttershy.”

And with that said she suddenly flew off and away into the distance while Twilight glared at Fluttershy. “Nothing in any of my books says anything about forgetting memories or the experience after this spell wears off.”

“Look, just don’t tell Rainbow Dash that I remember, it’s just so embarrassing.”

“Don’t worry, I won’t, I promise, stick a cupcake in my eye and hope to fly.”

Fluttershy sighed, “Thanks a lot for that, now I feel safe.”

“So, what do you think will happen between you and Rainbow Dash then?”

“Honestly, I don’t know, I just hope that it goes really well and slow too as well.”

“Yeah, I know you, slow and easy, well I wish the best of you two the most luck.”

“Thanks a lot, see you later then, bye for now.”

“Yeah, see you later.”

And with that said Fluttershy gently flew off while Twilight remained behind contemplating the book and what she should do with it, she considered locking it up and making it secure, safe, and sound, but then she remembered who gave it to her, princess Celestia did, but why? Celestia, despite all the time she spent with her, still remained a complete mystery, even to Twilight herself.

She looked at the book, and then the spell, thought, and then considered her choices and options, after all, it would be nice if it were safe, sound, and secure, so that way no secret of any pony else could be revealed, but then again, what was Princess Celestia’s deepest darkest secret? What was she hiding?