Her Vampire Secret

by Oldtakufanboy

Rating: mature
Tags: Equestria Girls, Sex, Slice of Life, Alternate Universe, Human, Fluttershy (EqG), Original Character, Romance
Length: 2221

Fluttershy has something to tell me privately. What I hear and see, is unbelievable

It's a cold night, as I wait in front of a cottage for my girlfriend Fluttershy to talk to me about something private and was too nervous to say to her friends. As we met, she showed and explained me what I never expected.

(OC is 19 years old, Fluttershy is 18 years old)

Published 2017-03-10 22:40:01 UTC
Last updated 2017-03-10 22:40:01 UTC

Her Vampire Secret

I stand in front of Fluttershy's cottage, waiting for her to show up, as the sun disappears behind the Canterlot city from afar. Fluttershy wanted to tell me about something that sounds very private and wanted to talk to me about it and not her friends. I guess whatever it is, can't be handles by the girls. My name is Randy, a nineteen-year-old at Canterlot High. I have blonde hair, blue eyes, and scar on my lower lip from five years ago when I was running through a forest with some old friend, which it got cut from a branch and it bled for quite a while, until the wound closed.

"Come on, Flutters," I said, as I pull out my phone. "It's gonna get cold soon if I wait out here any longer."

I began to feel a small chill, making my teeth chatter. Suddenly, a yellow car drives in the parkway and there she was, Fluttershy coming out with a grocery bag in her right hand. She closes the door and locks it, before walking up to me with a shy face; in fact, more than before.

"Let's get in before it happens," said Fluttershy, as she walks past me and opens the door.

"What's wrong, Fluttershy?" I asked, as I walk in with her and shut the door behind us. "Why did you want to talk to me privately about this? Is there someone at school bullying you? If so, I'll make sure he doesn't."

"It's not that," said Fluttershy, as she places the grocery bag on the coffee table. "You see, I've had this secret and... I want to confess it to you."

"Then tell me," I said, as I stand beside the coffee table, noticing a lot of red apples within the grocery bag. "Why do you have so many apples?"

"That's part of it. You told me before why I can't see you during night, well, you're going to witness this here and now."

The sky goes darker, as the room becomes dimly lit with only a few candles that are nearly melting to the bottom. Fluttershy closes her eyes, then opens them slowly, revealing red eyes with slit pupils. I gasp, as her ears grow long and a little furry. Her nails go sharp, along with two fangs pointing downward. A tear goes down her eye, before giving out a sniffle.

"I'm... I'm a monster," she said, as more tears burst forth. "The apples are for whenever I get hungry."

I'm shocked, but I'm not afraid of her. I give her a serious look before walking up to her and placing my hands on her shoulders.

"Fluttershy," I said calmly. "I am not afraid of you."

"Y-you aren't?"

"I wouldn't care if you were a lamia, a large spider, or anything mythological. You are you. I'd still love you, even if you are a vampire that craves on apples instead of blood."

"You mean it?"

I take my right hand and wipe the tears away from under her red eyes. Before I could pull my hand away, she grabs ahold of it and presses it against her cheek.

"I love you, Randy," she said with a blush.

"I love you, my sweet apple," I replied, making her giggle.

"Want an apple? I'm getting hungry."

"I'd love one," I said, as we sit together on the couch.

Fluttershy reaches for the bag and pulls out a clean and perfectly red apple. She brings the apple to me, allowing me to take a bite into it. The taste was sweeter than the ones I get from school or the store; she must've got them from one of those outdoor markets. She brings it towards her, as she opens up her mouth and chomps onto it with her two pointed teeth sink deep. As she slowly brings her upper jaw down, her two pointed teeth made a little of the apples' juices go down, as though she were biting down on a human's neck.

"Mm," she said, as she munches on the apple. "Delicious, huh?"

"As sweet as you are," I said, making her blush again, as she swallows.

Her red eyes glow, showing off a different look that Fluttershy wouldn't usually show. She puts the apple down on the coffee table and crawls on the couch toward me, licking her fangs (also out of character).

"The vampire in me wants something sweeter than apples," she said with a sultry tone.

"W-what is it you want?" I asked, as I pull my head away from hers.

"I want to taste your sweet nectar," she whispers, as she rubs a hand between my legs.

"You mean that nectar?" I asked, making her reply with a nod.

"Let's make some sweet juices," she said, as she grabs the middle of her shirt and rips it off, showing her white bra.

"Whoa! Fluttershy!"

"The vampire in me find you sexy. Just relax and enjoy what this vampire has in store for you."

Her bra pops off, as the strings from the back break from two large wings popping up.

"Whoa! You got wings?!"

"Sure do, stud-muffin," said Fluttershy, as she grabs her bare breasts and gives them squeezes.

"I'm actually liking this vampire side of you. You're quite sexier."

"D'aww, thank you. I'd like to give you a kissy-kiss."

She puckers her lips, before our lips touch. She pushes her lips upon mine, as her tongue slips into my mouth, sending in an apple flavor taste into my mouth, which I don't mind. I start doing the same, but her tongue pushes mine away from the entrance, as though her tongue has a mind of its own. I do my best, but to no avail. We pull our lips apart, making her give out a chuckle.

"I love teasing your tongue," she said, as she takes a claw and rips my shirt downward.

"Hey!" I said, as I look down at my now ripped shirt. "What the hell?!"

"Don't worry about it," she said, as she pulls off my shirt, showing off my abs. "Oh wow, you have an awesome body."

"I do a lot of working out," I said, as she continues to stare at my chest.

"I'm glad Fluttershy found a guy like you."

She proceeds, as she pulls down the zipper of my pants before I help pulling them down with her. As both my pants and boxers are to my ankles, she looks down at my not-so-hard member.

"Thank you for the food," she said before taking the head into her mouth, sending a pleasure zap all over my body.

Her tongue swirls around the head, before she brings her head further down the length, making my member grow hard with each five seconds.

"Oh G-God," I said, as Fluttershy bobs her head up and down. "F-Fluttershy, y-your tongue."

Her tongue coils around my member like a snake, as she pulls it up and down with each bob, making the pleasure double. As she continues, I couldn't help but grab her right breast, feeling its texture and softness. I love feeling her nipple in the palm of my hand that I decided to give it a slight pinch, making her give out a muffled gasp. She then giggles before bobbing her head up and down, but this time, she picks up the pace, making me feel the buildup of cum ready to come forth.

"F-Fluttershy," I moaned, as I let go of her breast. "I'm g-gonna cum!"

I tilt my head back, as my sperm enters her mouth, feeling her mouth become nearly filled with my cum. She brings her mouth away from my member and sits up, swallowing my seed. Once finished, she opens up her mouth, showing me that she gulped it all down.

"Your nectar tastes better than I thought," she said with a lick of her tongue. "Also, I'd like your cock inside me."

She gets up from the couch and pulls her green skirt down, showing pink, yet soaked panties. She then slips her fingers under the strings, pulling them down as they reveal her drench pussy. She kicks the panties aside, before sticking a finger in there, making herself give out a moan.

"Oh, God," she said, as she takes her finger away from her slit. "Taste this."

She brings the finger into my mouth, making me taste its essence, nearly clouding my mind. All that matters is that Fluttershy wants me more than ever. She takes the finger away from my mouth with a pop, before lying back on the couch, and using two of her fingers to stretch out her throbbing pussy.

"Come here, Randy," she says with a purr. "I want you inside me."

"Man, Flutters," I said, as I go onto my knees and grab my member. "You're quite frisky when you're a vampire."

"The vampire in me like you," giggled Fluttershy, as she licks her teeth. "Now fuck me."

"And you use quite a lot of foul language."

"Just shut up and fuck me," said Fluttershy, as she brings her legs behind my back and push me towards her, making my member slip within her lower lips.

The two of us moan, as I began thrusting deep within her, feeling her muscles around my member.

"Damn, Flutters," I moan, as I go at an average pace. "Your pussy feels wonderful."

"And your cock feels wonderful too," she replied, as she grips onto her breasts, breathing heavier.

With each thrust, a moan escapes her lips, knowing that she is enjoying this far more than I am. I pick up the pace, as Fluttershy looks up to me with her glowing red eyes.

"Y-you are great at this," she said.

"This is my first time, actually."

"You are doing fine, now go on and cum. Empty those balls inside this vampiric pussy."

And so it shall, as I felt the buildup of cum ready to shoot my load. As I give in one more thrust, I let out a gasp, as my seed enters within her. We hold position for about ten seconds, before I pull out and rest my body onto hers. The two of us breathe heavily, as she takes a hand onto my head and pats it softly.

"You are quite fabulous at sex, Randy," she said, before giving my head a kiss.

"Thanks, Flutters. I actually like this side of you."

"You actually do?"

"Like I said earlier, I don't care if you were some mythological creature. The point is, I'd love you no matter what you are, even if you're a vampire."

"You're such a sweetie," she said before giving out a yawn. "I need to sleep. Was planning on eating a lot of apples, but I lost my appetite."

"Let's cuddle," I said, as I move up to her side. "You're quite sexy tonight."

"Aw, come here," she said before the two of us give each other a soft kiss.

"Good night, my vampire," I said, as I rest my head close to hers.

"Good night, my stud-muffin," she replied before the two of us shut our eyes.

Morning comes, as I wake up with a yawn. I look around the living room to see Fluttershy gone, along with the bag of apples. I get up and pull up both my boxers and pants. As for my shirt, kinda sucks that I'm gonna have to walk around shirtless; hope Fluttershy doesn't mind. My nose catches the scent of something sweet coming from the kitchen, as I walk past the hall and into the dining room to look to my left and see Fluttershy pulling out what appears to be pie. She looks over to me and gasps with a blush.

"G-good m-morning, R-randy," she said with a shy voice, looking away from me.

"Good morning, Flutters," I said with an awkward chuckle. "Sorry about being shirtless. Your vampire self from last night made you rather... frisky."

Her face goes redder, as she places the pie on the counter and covers her face out of shame.

"S-sorry you had t-to see me like that, R-randy," she said. "I can't control the way I act when I become a vampire."

"It's okay, Flutters," I said, as I walk into the kitchen and give her a hug. "Nothing went wrong. It's not like you bit me and made me bleed."

"Oh, o-okay," she said, as I break the hug. "If you're okay, then I feel a whole lot b-better."

"I also see you made some pie," I said, looking over to the steaming freshly-baked pie. "Is that for breakfast?"

"Yes. I made it for this lovely Saturday morning."

"How about later, let's go hang out with Twi and the others. I want you girls to have a girls day and I'm willing to go along."

"You'd actually like to hang out with me and my friends? I thought you'd didn't want to because it's gonna be pretty girly."

"I can withstand it, like that time I saw the second Twilight film with my cousin."

She hugs me tight, kissing my lips repeatedly.

"I love you, Randy!" she shouts, as she let's go of me with a giggle. "Let's have some pie. It's apple flavor."

"Anytime, my little fruit bat."