Equestria Girls: The One That Got Away

by TheWhoovian1099

Rating: everyone
Tags: Drama, Mystery, Equestria Girls
Length: 1298

One of the students at Canterlot High is causing a ruckus and getting into trouble. So now, it's up to Sunset Shimmer to figure out what she can do to help him out, but not before she faces with her worst nightmare.

Even though the Town of Canterlot is a sweet and happy place, one of the students in Canterlot High is getting himself into a lot of trouble, and this causes Sunset Shimmer to be suspicious. As soon as she tries to help out the destructive student, she comes face to face with her biggest fear.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2017-05-25 02:09:25 UTC

From the Top

A bright and sunny day in the town of Canterlot as the calm, soothing wind blows across the sky. The portal sits in its place, reflecting the school in front of it. You here a voice speaking over, but no being nearby.

It's easy to think that everything that transpired over the years happened because of this one little thing. In case if you don't know, this is the portal that binds two worlds together, this world, and another 'magical' world called Equestria. Since then, it was the very thing that opened the book for all of us to read and laugh, but sadly, it's the very thing that closed this book. How about I take you back to about three days ago, see why this book is closed.

OK so, today's date right now is September 25, 2018, one day away from the annual Fall Formal pageant. Back then, Sunset and her friends helped out all around the school, solving problems not only in CHS, but all around town, and people adored them for it. See what I did here? Ha! Anyways, on *THIS** day, maybe, things are about to get messy. Just wait and see for yourself, I'll go through everything later on.*

Twilight and the others are walking around the hallways, checking to see if there are any problems that the students need to fix. "So, it looks like we got everything under control. We managed to fix the AC in the Science Lab, and got rid of that wasp situation at the soccer field."

"Those wasps were causing nothing but trouble the moment they arrived. I mean, three of our best athletes were sent to the Health Office due to wasp related injuries. Thank goodness we got rid of them in time."

"I know, if they were to make it to the gym, we'd have to cancel the Fall Formal, and that would be really, REALLY bad. Luckily we let Fluttershy handle the situation."

Twilight gets a message from Sunset on her phone. "That was Sunset. She needs us at the Gymnasium as soon as possible. Looks like something urgent."

They head to the Gym, and spot Sunset dangling from the top of the stage.

"Oh my gosh! Sunset what happened to you?"

"I have no idea. I was just trying to help Micro Chips fix the stage lights for the pageant, and all of a sudden the floor completely gave up."

Micro Chips, standing next to the hole of the truss, feels frustrated. "I told you, the truss you were standing on was rusted up and weak. It wouldn't be able to support one person."

"Well thank you for reminding me so soon!"

Rainbow Dash feels confident about this type of situation. "Don't worry, I got this."

Rainbow Dash climbs up to untangle Sunset's foot from the truss.

"Ready?"

Sunset becomes frightened. "No!"

"Works for me."

Rainbow Dash untangles Sunset's foot, and she starts falling. Luckily, Applejack managed to catch Sunset before she hit the ground.

"Thanks Applejack."

"Don't sweat it."

Applejack puts Sunset down, but she starts limping. Sunset stumbles, yet her friends were there to pick her back up.

"Goodness gracious. Sunset, your leg!"

"It's OK Rarity. I'll be fine. I just need to get to the nurse."

"Oh how I LOVE the nurse! He gives me a cookie for every time I get a fever of 103."

Pinkie winks, and the girls look at her with a weird look in their faces.

"OK, we're just gonna let that one slide. Come on, let's go."

The girls escort Sunset to the Health Office. The man is standing near the broken truss.

Yikes! I might be going Applejack right now, but I did *NOT** expect that to happen to Sunset! GOSH DARN IT, you caught be red-handed. (sigh) Come with me, I'll tell you more about what I've done. Speaking of which, go put on some Linkin Park while you're at it. They make pretty good songs by the way."*

The Jig is Up

The man walks down the hallways, heading towards the Health Office.

So, let me bring you up to speed, I was the one that caused what happened back at the gym because...well...she literally made my job a living nightmare! Ever since this whole 'magic in this world' incident back in 2013, when she tormented the students at CHS, and causing a ruckus by putting the crown on turning herself into a demon lady with no sense of respect, I had to fix every single issue that she brought up. Including the big gigantic crater that was created! In short terms, I return the favor. You see, I tend to do what we know as "The Karma Effect" here at the town of Canterlot. Every time someone does a good thing, I give them a good thing in return like a coupon for a free latte at Sugar Cube Corner, but if someone were to do a bad thing, like put some random spice in a cup of water, well...

*Flashback*

Sunset is talking to Fluttershy at the Cafeteria. The man walks by and slips a little capsule in Sunset's drink. As soon as Sunset took a sip of her drink, her mouth started to foam up and hyperventilates.

"I need some assistance over here."

*End Flashback*

...things don't go as they seem to be for *THOSE** people. Anyways, there's a perfectly, rational explanation for why I did this, Sunset, ever since she was a complete migraine, did some things that got other students in trouble for the things she did. Like when she destroyed the gym and almost blamed it on Twilight, speaking of which I must remind myself about that. But none of that matters know, let's see what's happening right now.*

Nurse Redheart checks Sunset's ankle to see if any bones are broken. She appears to be observant, but not serious.

"So, is my ankle broken or anything?"

Nurse Redheart finishes her observations, and feels relieved. "Well, it's only twisted, but the good things is there's no signs of any fractured bones."

"(sighs) Thank goodness."

"Now, I do advise you don't walk with that leg for at least until the end of the school day, but at the mean time I'll put a cast on the ankle and provide you with crutches just to be safe. Once the day is done, come here and I'll check the ankle once more."

"Thank you Nurse Redheart."

The nurse smiles. "No problem."

The nurse heads over to grab the crutches and bandages.

"Phew, that was a relief. For a moment there I thought..."

Rarity is interrupted by a commotion outside the office. An unfamiliar student and the Diamond Dogs are having a major argument, but the anonymous student of them goes berserk.

"I thought I told you to put the wasps nest in the gym like I asked you!"

Oh boy, here we go.

"I'm sorry, but when we last checked the nest wasn't there anymore. Maybe we can..."

"You know as well as I am that I'm not apologizing for any faults. Now please, get out of my sight!"

"But sir, if you can just give us another chance..."

[color=cccccc]"I SAID GET OUT!"

The Diamond Dogs run in a scurry. Sunset and the others witness the events that transpired.

"What was that all about?

"It looks like they were having an argument about that wasp situation Fluttershy resolved. It's very uncommon to know such a thing."

Vice Principle Luna speaks over the PA System. "Sunset Shimmer please report to the Principle's Office immediately.

Uh oh, something big is about to happen. I wonder what it could be? I guess we'll just have to see for ourselves then, won't we. To the Principle's Office!