After Midnight

by Damaged

Pilfered Purple Pony Plots

Previous ChapterNext Chapter

When Midnight felt Derpy slow and finish in her again, she thought the little pegasus was going to launch into another flurry of motion, but the wonderful grinding sensation didn't come. Opening her mouth, she meant to ask Derpy a question, but all that came out was a satisfied groan.

The weight on her back was warm, and she felt Derpy's wings curled around her hips. Midnight tried again with her mouth, and though she let out a little sigh, she managed to speak. "Hey, uh… that was pretty fun…" She looked back at the quiet mare on her back, and saw that Derpy had passed out. "Oh."

Affection overwhelmed all her other feelings, and Midnight used her magic to carefully start to lift Derpy up. Midnight Sparkle's eyes crossed, not unlike Derpy's, when she realized the mare was still hard and deep inside her rear. Cocking her tail to one side, Midnight gently drew Derpy free from her body.

"Wha…?" Derpy woke to the chill sensation of her shaft suddenly outside the warm embrace of Midnight's body. "Uh, hi!" She tucked her wings down and was acutely aware that Midnight was using her magic to grip her smaller body very possessively. "So… uh…" She hadn't heard Midnight's previous comment on fun, and was a little nervous. "Was that fu—" A kiss landed on Derpy's lips, and her brain took nearly two minutes to process that it was a sign that things had been very fun indeed.

Derpy's lips pressed back firmly to Midnight's, and the alicorn felt the gray mare's tongue push sharply into her own mouth. Midnight's eyes fluttered closed as she sank into the kiss.

When her brain caught up, Derpy found herself making out with the alicorn. She reached up with her wings, following through on the warm feelings stirring inside.

The feathery touch of Derpy's wings cupped Midnight's jaw, and she realized that from her laying position, the pegasus was actually standing over her. She opened her eyes and looked into the splayed eyes of her lover.

Despite the absolute lethargy of having spent most of the day servicing Midnight, Derpy felt her body warm for more. But kisses were special. Kisses were important, and she wouldn't give up on the kiss until Midnight was ready to. Gently stroking the other mare's cheeks with her strong wings, Derpy found her mouth working hungrily, desperate for more.

The kiss seemed to start anew, Midnight was overtaken by the desire Derpy showed, the passion she threw into the embrace. Letting herself be ravaged by Derpy's attentions, Midnight tried to keep up as she could. A suck, a counter-poke, nothing discouraged or displaced Derpy's tongue, and Midnight was thrilled by it.

During the lovemaking, Midnight couldn't remember a single moment when Derpy had actually been dominant. She had certainly had fun with just about every naughty word Midnight knew—and even taught Midnight some new ones—but she was aware that there had been no dominance games. At last, questions and thoughts piled up, and Midnight gave a gentle tug of her mouth.

Derpy felt the slight tug, the request for withdrawal. Pulling her tongue back, pushing on Midnight's lips a little firmer until she had fully extracted herself, she smiled against the purple lips. "That is a yes?"

Midnight giggled and nuzzled Derpy's carefree smile. "Yeah. That was really great."

"I heard you finally got through to Princess Twilight." Derpy stretched, arching her spine and spreading her wings. She wiggled her plot a little and pronked once. Landing back on her hooves, Derpy folded her wings back down. "What's she like?"

"She is…" Midnight stopped herself before she went too far. Lifting a hoof, she gently booped Derpy on the nose. "You will have to ask her how she likes it, alicorn-slayer." Derpy's wings shot back up, and her face exploded with a huge grin.

"You think I have a chance?" Derpy stepped back as Midnight stood up, and despite the alicorn's height she wasn't intimidated at all. Her eyes traced over the dark body, particularly Midnight's plot. "Mmm…"

The hungry look in Derpy's eyes fed Midnight's ego in ways she had never felt before. "Like what you see?" The words were just like she remembered girls at CHS saying to their boyfriends, they seemed appropriate. "Want more?" Derpy's wings shot straight up, and she started to prance around behind Midnight with purpose in her stride. "Whoa, hold on. Let's go inside. Spike is out for the rest of the day, we can literally—"

"Map room!" Derpy flapped her wings with excitement. "On the map." Her eyes were spread wide apart, but she didn't care about focusing to correct them.

"If nopony is home, I think we could even try it on Twilight's throne." As soon as Midnight said it, Derpy was bouncing again. "Come on." The energy Derpy displayed almost dismayed Midnight. She was sore in places, and tired, but Derpy looked ready to start all over again. "Wh-What about if we had something to eat first?"

"Muffins?" Derpy stopped bouncing, things had gotten serious. "Ohh, I can see if Spike has all the things!" Spreading her wings, Derpy shot into the sky, showing the skill that had won her so many junior flier gold medals.

Midnight tried to catch Derpy's attention, but the gray pegasus was far too quick. "Well," she started putting one hoof before the rest, "maybe she will calm down a little by the time I get there?"

Walking around the castle, Midnight saw the big doors come into view in the evening light. But that wasn't all that she saw. "Twilight!" She ran forward, tears suddenly in her eyes, desperately needing to touch and hold her fillyfriend. Ignoring the rest of Twilight's friends, Midnight started to wrap her wings around the princess. "I didn't know what to think! And I thought you ran off. And—"

Twilight's head was still ringing from where she had been forced to face down a yak in a headbutt contest. She pushed a hoof against Midnight's snout to silence her. "Please, too loud. This headache…"

Midnight watched Twilight walk past her to the door, open it, and head inside. "What happened?"

"Yaks." Pinkie bounced on her hooves, grinning widely. "Lots of yaks! And they had trouble with a giant adorable snow pony!"

"Abominable." Rarity had to correct her friend, particularly since the snow pony had ruined her new scarf. "There was nothing adorable about them."

"I wouldn't say the snow pony was abominable, although those yaks seemed pretty explosive…" Pinkie tapped her chin. "Anyway. The celebration was huge, and the yaks demanded a traditional yak victory contest."

"You could say they really cracked up our egg-head." Rainbow Dash leaned away from Pinkie, but raised a forehoof into the air aimed towards the pink-maned baker.

"Silly Billy." Pinkie returned the hoof-bump, giggling. "So what did you do all day, Midnight?"

Memories assaulted Midnight Sparkle. She remembered every aspect of the fantastic sex she had had with Derpy Hooves. She ruffled her wings and shook her tail a little. "Things. Ponies. Mostly Derpy."

Pinkie's face fell, and big tears gathered in her eyes. "She… she beat me!" Pinkie was about to continue, when a loud scream came from inside the Castle of Friendship. Twilight's close friends were faster to react than Midnight, and all five rushed inside, racing to the map room. At the doorway, Twilight was standing, staring open-mouthed into the room.

"Twi! What happened? Why'd you yell?" Applejack's legs had brought her to Twilight's side first. She traced Twilight's gaze to its target. "What the buck?"

"You're not Midnight!" Derpy tried to cover up the way her erection was flopped over the map's representation of Canterlot Castle. "What are you doing home early? Midnight said you wouldn't be back for—"

"MIDNIGHT!" Twilight's yell served only to make her headache worse. She kept her eyes locked on Derpy while she awaited her student.

"T-Twilight?" Midnight got to the doorway and could see over the other gathered ponies' heads. "Derpy!"

"Midnight?" Derpy had given up hiding her shaft, instead realizing it as an impossible task. "Twilight, I'm sorry…" Her ears tucked back, and her face wilted. "I was really excited, and had been showing Midnight around, and I just got some muffins in the ove—"

"You are making muffins?" Twilight finally dragged her gaze from Derpy's penis. She looked up the pegasus and stared into her oddly well-focused (for Derpy) gaze. "All we have eaten all day is 'snow sandwiches.' " Twilight closed her eyes and judged her next words carefully. Finding what she wanted to say, Twilight opened her mouth again. "If you make me some tasty muffins for dinner, I will… I will forgive this."

"She looks kinda hot." Pinkie looked up and down Derpy's form, paying particular attention to the displayed dong. "Hey Dash, after you top me later, want to invite Derpy over to pound us both into jelly?"

Pony ears twitched as the brains attached to them attempted to process what Pinkie said. It was ultimately Rainbow Dash that recovered first. "Pinkie! We weren't going to tell everypony until we were ready!"

"Well, I am ready." Pinkie tilted her chin up to Rainbow, and then leaned down and whispered to her domm. "So you get to punish me for being such a bad, bad filly."

The words weren't quiet enough to keep them from anyone but Derpy. Rainbow Dash's wings shot straight up, and the poor mare's brain almost short circuited at how aroused she suddenly was. "Uh… can't sex for muffins, Twisex. I have to go Pinkie sex right now. Totally nothing to sexy about, we are just going to sex and sex." She blinked, her brain not registering what she had said. Turning her gaze on Pinkie, she felt the other part of her—the fiercely dominant part—poke through. "Come on, sex, we have to go have Pinkie."

Twilight, Rarity, Applejack, Fluttershy, and Midnight watched in shock as Rainbow Dash hooked her wing around Pinkie's neck and dragged the bigger earth pony mare away.

Derpy jumped down off the map table, and trotted to the door. Lifting her voice, she called after the two departing mares. "Do you still want me to come around—"

"YES!" Pinkie barely got the word out before the wing closed tighter around her neck. All the blood in her body rushed to her vulva, or so it felt. "Ruv oo." She had to fight just to get the rough words out.

"I'll go get the muffins." Derpy was pleased with herself. From what the pegasus could tell, she was out of hot water with Twilight, and she was going to get some more sex. She froze and turned to look at Midnight. "Uh…"

"It's okay!" Midnight felt a fraction spurned. Closing her eyes, she couldn't stop a smile from returning. "She is really fun. I have never met anypony who just loved life that much."

"Derpy is, um…" Fluttershy blushed a little, remembering when she arrived in Ponyville. "She really likes to make ponies smile." She smiled at the memory.

"Darlings, you have no idea…" Rarity shivered as her own memories unfolded. Absently, she reminded herself that some "special" spa time was definitely in order.

"Ah got no clue what'cha talkin' about." Applejack looked at each mare's dreamy expression, and shook her head. "Ah better go, farm's a farm after all, and it don't wait for nopony."

"I should be going too." Rarity shivered at the memory of a gray pegasus whispering all kinds of naughty things in her ear. A smile pulled at the corner of her mouth, and she admitted to herself she couldn't wait for the spa tomorrow. "Please tell Spike I appreciated the food he packed for me."

"WHAT?!" Twilight spun around as Rarity and Applejack tried to sneak away. "He packed you food, while I ate nothing but snow all day?" Anger flared, but before Twilight could start to shake it off, she was plucked into the air by glowing aqua magic.

"Ahem." Midnight pinned Twilight's snout closed with her magic, holding her mentor and sub firmly. "You must excuse me, I think I will let you escape while I calm Twilight down."

Neither Applejack nor Rarity needed to be told twice, and both actually chuckled at the way Midnight handled their best friend. Rarity turned and trotted for the door, following in Rainbow Dash and Pinkie's hoofsteps, but not before turning and winking to Midnight.

"Um… I'll just be going." Fluttershy started to move for the door, hesitated, and turned back. "This-This weekend I need you to do the thing." She looked at Midnight until the mare she had topped nodded back. "Thank you."

When Fluttershy closed the double doors behind her, Midnight freed Twilight's mouth. "What are you doing?!" Twilight wasn't angry, the restraint actually had her horny, if anything.

"Getting you the best way to calm down." Midnight trotted to the dining room, then through to the kitchen with Princess Twilight Sparkle. "Hey, Derpy?"

Pulling a tray of muffins from the magically-charged oven, Derpy set them on the stove top to cool and turned to Midnight. "What…?" Derpy froze. Midnight was carrying Princess Twilight Sparkle into the kitchen, butt first, and set the Princess of Friendship down on the floor with that sexy plot aimed right at her. Derpy watched as Twilight's tail flicked aside, revealing the perfect plot's treasures.

"Derpy, this is not Princess Twilight. This is my pet. She got worked up over something, and so long as she doesn't say the word 'Red,' you can screw her until she can't walk." Midnight smiled sweetly.

Twilight's ears flattened. "Midnight, I didn't agree to this." She went to turn around, to demand this be stopped, but she hesitated. Derpy had a reputation around town, but whenever anypony mentioned the ever-cheerful pegasus, they usually just smiled off into space for a few moments. Neither Derpy nor Midnight moved, seeming to be waiting for something. "Green."

Midnight leaned down to her pet, and brushed Twilight's mane with her wing. "You are a good girl, and I promise this will feel great. Made me smile, anyway. Say your word and we will stop right away, won't we Der—" Midnight looked back just in time to see the pegasus, flapping her wings, land on Twilight's plot.

"Yay!" Derpy hit her target first go—practice really does make perfect. She sank into the voluminous depths of Twilight's vagina, and almost came right away. "Princess Day!" She grabbed with her wings, and started bucking.

Twilight's legs wobbled. She arched her back and hung her wings low as the huge shape drove into her again and again. "She… she's in me…" The words blurred and melted, and she couldn't help slurring them. "G-G-Green…" Closing her eyes, she felt the well of pleasure filling inside her, but it wasn't just the sex that had her going. Midnight had put her in this position. Her mistress had told her to let another random pony "relieve her mood," and Twilight had "no way to stop it." She didn't care about safe words, they weren't part of the fantasy she and Midnight wove, but Derpy's big dong was something she couldn't ignore.

Twisting and adjusting her hips, Twilight tried to make the shape rub a little less, but each movement only worked Derpy's length onto a new part of her. Panting with her eyes closed, she almost coughed when something hot and sweet shoved into her mouth. The softest, most delicious muffin ever fell onto her palate.

"You're… You're feeding her one of my muffins?" Derpy had let go with her wings and was flapping them to keep up her pace. "Can I have one too?" Obligingly, she opened her snout and closed her eyes.

Midnight fed Twilight with her hoof, and Derpy with her magic. Both mares were eating happily, and still the dance continued. She saw the moment Derpy's thrusts started to become more erratic, and shoved each of the muffins a little more firmly into each mare's mouth.

Twilight felt the hot rush inside, and the tight grip of Derpy's wings around her barrel as the short pegasus unloaded inside her. Twilight groaned around the delicious muffin, and any possible anger she held melted into a gooey puddle, much like her thoughts when the climax suddenly hit.

Derpy's eyes widened. She thought Twilight had already climaxed, but the sudden clamp against her shaft urged her to buck again. Screwing her eyes closed once more, she drove hard, short thrusts into Twilight, feeding her more of the hot seed her body had been gifting to Midnight most of the day.

Each little thrust drove Twilight deeper into her orgasm, and each time she went deeper she found herself surrendering more to the pleasure. She no longer even thought about safe words, games, or anything. She was a mare, she was riding an orgasm while a "stallion" filled her.

"Buuuuuhhhhhhcccckkkk…" Derpy's wings let go and she flopped weakly to Twilight's back. She thought she was ready to buck the Princess for hours, but Midnight had worn her out earlier. She was still deep inside Twilight, still rock hard and ready, like the eager mare she always was, for more. But lethargy threatened.

Midnight lifted another of the hot muffins off the tray and held it before Derpy's snout. "I think she wants another, Derpy."

Derpy's eyes widened, even if they also splayed to the corners of the rooms. Opening her mouth she let Midnight Sparkle feed her the muffin. She knew the pair were playing one of the BDSM games she had heard about. She left the games up to others, she was having too much fun to worry about them.

Twilight drooled a little, a chocolate-stained runnel of spit leaking from the corner of her mouth. When Derpy shoved forward again, she whimpered, but was far enough into her happy submissive place that she could do nothing but respond. Rocking backwards, she felt the friction start to build all over again.

"This is awesome…" Midnight looked at the supply of materials to make more muffins, and started getting to work.

Derpy swallowed the mouthful of muffin. "Stuffing your princess-plot with my mare-smasher." She grinned wide and sped up. "Gonna buck you until you can't walk backwards without whistling!" She giggled, and was already coming up with more sexy—to her—words.

Magic wrapped around Twilight's forequarters. She shivered and moaned as her front legs were encased in magic, and then firm rubber. "M-M-Mistress…" She tilted her head and gaped. Groaning loudly as Derpy seemed to find somewhere deep inside she hadn't poked yet, Twilight realized that with the restraint on she couldn't get away from what the pegasus was doing—not that she wanted to.

"Derpy." Midnight made sure Twilight was stuck fast before turning her attention to the pegasus drilling the trapped alicorn. "Derpy when you are done in there, how about another hole?"

"She'll take me in every hole by the time I'm done…" Derpy bucked again and again, but like a well-practiced dancer, she slipped back and flapped her wings.

Twilight felt the long shaft slip from her body and was instantly whining for its return. She opened her mouth to beg Midnight to invite Derpy back into her, when the pegasus slammed her blunt shaft against Twilight's tight ponut. Twilight's eyes widened and she squealed, but the squeal turned into a deep groan as Derpy breached her body's resistance. Cursing her mistress' use of toys to open her up more back there, Twilight felt Derpy drive deeper into her tight colon.

"Good girls." Midnight fed each of the coupling ponies a little more muffin. Sex, she realized, was fun, but playing with ponies she liked was something else completely. While the two mares grunted and groaned, she mused playing with Rainbow and Pinkie while the pair had sex was probably more fun than actually having sex with either. Another part of her, the scientific part that believed in rigor and testing, started making plans to test the hypothesis.

Again Twilight felt a hot, blush-inducing rush of liquid inside, and this time she squeaked at it. She had no orgasm to accompany the sensation, but part of her adored the feeling nonetheless. Her relaxed happiness collapsed when something thick and hard shoved into her vagina. "MISTRESS!" Twilight's voice was several octaves too high.

"Yeah, plug her like a sink!" Derpy wiggled her rump, giggling like a loon.


Author's Note

So I do this "Ask x" thing, x can be any pony within the story. You can ask them anything and ~~I~~ they will definitely hopefully reply. Keep the questions appropriate to the age-rating of the stories and of course, ~~I~~ they will answer the best question(s) in the author notes of the next chapter. The more votes a comment has the more likely I will get it to the right pony to answer, try and keep it to one answer per post! ~~I~~ They will pick one question per chapter.

Support me on Patreon or fuel my writing on Ko-Fi!

Join me on Discord. Warning, said chat may contain NSFW material and should be considered adult in nature.

Awesome ponies who are already helping to keep me in keyboards and rum:
A.P.O.N.I.
Boulder
Canary in the Coal Mine
Daremo
Dio-Drogynous
Ian
Javarod
Jeffh4
Mary Rowland
Mephia
Nils
Sirion123

And special thanks to the following, for careful eyes and friendly words:
Cross Lament
Jeffh4
Vutava

Next Chapter