Pinkie wriggled her plot under Rainbow. "You are very aggressive, Dashie." When a pegasus had a pony on their back, they could shove them off with their wings. When a unicorn had a pony on their back, they could use magic to displace them. Pinkie Pie loved being an earth pony. "My plot will be sore for a week!"

Rainbow Dash blinked at the absolute glee in Pinkie's voice. "I-I-I hurt you?" She got up off Pinkie to inspect her friend. "I am so sorry Pinkie, I didn't mean t—" Her eyes widened and her mouth stopped at the kiss delivered from the pink party pony.

"Silly." Pinkie pulled back from the kiss. "I love being hurt in the right way." She saw the look of incomprehension on Rainbow's face. "Okay, so it was luck…" She blew a deep breath out and settled back on the floor. "If you lay on top of me again I will explain everything."

"Uh…" Rainbow watched as her friend lay back down and wiggled her plot. The invitation was more than enough to get a smile from her, and Rainbow lowered herself atop Pinkie. Rainbow Dash bucked her hips once to remind her friend what the position really meant.

The buck sealed the deal for Pinkie, and prompted her to arch her back a little for her friend. "Pain is fun when done just right. If a mare… or a stallion… is aroused and feeling really, really happy, a bit of pain in just the right places can make everything better." She looked at Midnight. "With you shoving your magic in, I was fit to burst when she flogged me." Pinkie was squirming around a little, but gave a happy sigh when Rainbow bucked again. "Not all ponies, though." She arched her head back, curving her spine from dock to neck. "But me? When you are playing with me, mistress, I like a little pain with my pleasure."

"Good." Rainbow gave two firm humps against Pinkie's plot. "Because that was just about the best thing I have ever done." Something suddenly rushed up to the fore of Rainbow Dash's mind. "A-A-And you were my first… if this counts that is."

"Oh Dashie, this counts. And you know what it means when you do something this fun for the first time?" Pinkie wiggled in excitement.

Rainbow Dash felt a sense of "overness" with regards to their roleplay, and climbed up. "What—" She didn't get the rest of her question out, Pinkie had fired her cannon into the air, and balloons had suddenly gone everywhere.

"You need a party, silly! A special party, with just your closest friends!" Pinkie laughed, and turned her head sidelong at Midnight. "And I think we have first on the list right here." Her grin spread wide.

Midnight was frozen, like a deer in headlights. "What do you mean?" She looked to Rainbow Dash for support, and maybe some translation of Pinkie-speak.

"She means you are our friend, and I think I can't say no to that." Rainbow Dash lifted a hoof up to Pinkie, and got a firm clop back from her friend. "You weren't pushy, you weren't angry, and you were a lot of fun." She suddenly remembered the alicorn masturbating to the image of her atop Pinkie. "And you were pretty into us, weren't you?"

"Of course she was!" Pinkie rushed up to Midnight and lifted the mare's hoof up. "See," Pinkie sniffed the captured limb, "smells just like her—"

"Alright!" Midnight yanked her hoof back. "Alright, yeah, I was into that. C-Can I watch next time, too?"

Rainbow Dash walked up beside Pinkie and put a hoof quickly in the earth pony's mouth—not that this stopped Pinkie from trying to talk. "You can, but we need to talk about what you can do to help me buck her silly. Maybe over flight lessons tomorrow?" Something odd tickled Rainbow, at the thought of having sex with her friend while somepony else watched.

Midnight nodded excitedly. "Of course! More flight lessons would be awesome, I… I am not so good at it yet." She remembered Rainbow Dash having to save her plot, and looked down.

"You should have seen Twilight when she first learned to fly. I would totally show you the huge holes she made in the ground, but she used magic to hide them." Rainbow Dash spread a wing over Pinkie's back and pulled her into a tight embrace. "You are going to have to excuse us now, I need to learn a few more things from my—"

"Fillyfriend." Pinkie booped Rainbow on the nose. "And I also need to teach Midnight some things too. Isn't it strange how you came here to dominate and now you are taking tips on BDSM play from the fillyfriend-pet of one of the very ponies you thought to take control of?"

"Don't!" Rainbow Dash shook her head at Midnight. "Just let it slide, and don't for a second think of how she knows. She is Pinkie Pie. Twilight tried to find out once, it didn't go too well for science, although I think Twi… I meant Twilight… was a little out of it at the time."

Leaving the new couple to their talk, Midnight felt oddly adrift as she left Pinkie's Party Cave. Once more in the open air, she realized where she should be. "Magic lesson, of course." Keeping her wings tightly furled, Midnight trotted through town towards Twilight's castle.

"There you are!" Twilight Sparkle raced over to Midnight. "Where have you been? I have been worried sick about you!" She looked over Midnight, looking for injuries. "Where were you last night?"

"Uh…" Midnight's eyes looked left and right, a stray thought having told her that Pinkie and Rainbow's union wasn't her secret to tell. "I was uh… sleeping…" Her brain gave up and she rolled her eyes. "It was Pinkie's turn last night."

"Oh…" Twilight stared at her darker twin, and started to blush. "Well… uh… oh!" Twilight searched for a safe topic, and latched on to the first thing she could think of. "Magic lessons are canceled today, we will start again tomorrow afternoon." The look of sadness on Midnight's face stirred not only compassion in Twilight, but also some accomplishment that her oblique friendship lessons were working.

"Rainbow Dash and Pinkie Pie called me their friend." Midnight had no clue why she had said it; the words had just slipped out. "We were just…" she quickly adjusted what she was about to let slip, "just hanging out. It was comfortable, and nice." She blushed a little and looked to the side, only to spot the very image of pony beauty. Yellow fur covered the pegasus, and she was bigger than Rainbow Dash, but not in any way that detracted from her perfection. Fluttershy's pink mane swished as she turned and started to wave to Twilight.

Freezing mid-wave, Fluttershy spotted Midnight Sparkle looking at her. She had seen the look before, had stared it down when it was on a timber wolf. "Hi Twilight!" She smiled, facing the terror that was Midnight in the same way she faced the terror that was interacting with most ponies. "H-Hi Midnight…"

Midnight drank in the mare's meekness, but she could see a little steel behind the plush, velvety exterior of Fluttershy. She smiled as best she could. "Hello Fluttershy."

Twilight was quite chuffed to see Fluttershy so brave in the face of Midnight Sparkle. "I was just telling Midnight that she had the day off from learning about magic." But not friendship Twilight silently added. "Maybe she could help you with your animals for the day?"

Not even a year earlier, Fluttershy's wings would have shot up, she would have swished her mane before her eyes and hidden from Midnight Sparkle. Everything about the alicorn seemed like bad news. The words Midnight had whispered to her came back, and despite her desire to see them play out, she had another plan. "Of course, Twilight." She looked up into the face of the monster, and saw a pony. "Midnight, would you like to learn about all my little friends?"

The moment Fluttershy looked her in the eyes, Midnight knew that this mare was nothing like the schoolgirl from Equestria High. The more she learned of these ponies, the more this kept happening to her—it was a pleasant surprise to find out that there was more depth in each of them. "You know what, I think I would."

The interest surprised Fluttershy, and she found herself smiling despite her fear of Midnight. "I just finished getting everything I needed, we can go back now and start preparing their lunch." Just thinking about taking care of her animals brought Fluttershy's mood higher.

Midnight found her hooves moving on their own, following Fluttershy as the beautiful mare talked on and on about the care of bunnies and otters. Like a sponge, Midnight Sparkle's mind soaked up the information and filed it away. "Do you have any other animals you take care of?"

Fluttershy turned and looked at Midnight, and almost used her stare on the alicorn. "I do, but I don't want to startle you into doing something you would regret." She inspected Midnight with the same focus she did any animal she had seen for the first time. Long legs, like Fluttershy's own, led up to a strong body. Fluttershy paid careful attention to Midnight's wings. Walking closer, she reached out with her own wings to one of the dark-feathered appendages, and gently stretched it out.

"What are…?" Midnight couldn't finish the question with the steely focus Fluttershy was applying to her. The pegasus walked around her, poking and prodding, even lifting her tail—which of course Midnight allowed.

"You will do." Fluttershy trotted off towards her house, leaving Midnight to trot after her. Relegating Midnight to "animal" made it a lot easier to think about her, and think about her body. She didn't even realize that she had mostly ignored what the alicorn was saying while she walked. "Wait out here."

Midnight watched Fluttershy trot up to her house and head inside. Looking around, there were plenty of animals around. She watched a particularly rambunctious bunny hop right up to her and glare directly into her eyes.

"Okay." Fluttershy noticed Midnight was a little lost in a staring battle with Angel, and startled her enough with the word to break her focus. "You really want to do those things to me?" She looked directly in Midnight's eyes. "The things you whispered."

"I do, but only with your consent." Midnight liked the idea of what Rainbow and Pinkie did, but the absolute dominance, and the aching need to control that she had seen in Rainbow was just not in her. "I want to treat you like a pet. I want to play with you. I even want to spend hours brushing your mane."

The words were the only things Fluttershy wanted to hear. If Midnight Sparkle had gone on about some harsher things, she would have sent her away. "Okay, but that is for the end of the week—at the right time." She smiled. "Close your eyes."

Midnight blinked at the command. "What?"

"I have agreed to your fun, now you will close your eyes and let me have mine." Fluttershy didn't use the stare, not for this. She watched the thoughts flicker through the windows to Midnight's mind, watched her eyes start to close. When the lids finally met, Fluttershy struck.

The tightness around Midnight's throat surprised her, and the click feel of a regular animal collar being adjusted made her want to open her eyes and question Fluttershy. Like when she was watching Rainbow and Pinkie, a part of Midnight sympathized with the pony on the bottom, and that part surged at the feel of a collar around her throat. "Is this what I think it is?"

"Oh, you can talk?" Fluttershy put surprise in her voice. "Such a good puppy. Can you speak up for me, come on girl." She smiled into the big, startled eyes that Midnight cast upon her. "No voice?"

Midnight was more than a little confused. "What… I gu—"

"Oh, you can!" Fluttershy spoke right over Midnight, acting the way she saw other ponies did towards their pets. "I wonder if she can shake too?" Fluttershy lifted one hoof, but Midnight still wore a surprised and confused look. "Oh well, I can teach you that later."

Finally, everything sank into place. Midnight realized Fluttershy was feigning not understanding her, and really was treating her just like a pet. The dominant side of Midnight curled up into a tight, warm blanket inside, and let her less-common sibling out. Smiling from cheek to cheek, Midnight sat her rear down and wagged her tail.

"You know how to sit, then?" Fluttershy reached her hoof up to Midnight's mouth, and stealthily pushed a dry, sugary biscuit between the alicorn's lips. "Good girl! Sit! Good, good girl!" After making sure Midnight was chewing on the treat, Fluttershy reached her long leg up to rub Midnight's mane.

The praise almost made Midnight cry. She looked into Fluttershy's eyes, and could see that the mare meant every single word. Her eyes filled with moisture, but before she could break down completely, Fluttershy broke character.

"Are you okay? Did I hurt you?" Fluttershy was looking all over Midnight's mouth, and reaching up to carefully part her mane, inspecting for injuries.

"No. It's just…" Midnight swallowed a lot of pride—pride was what her dominant side clung to, her submissive part was happy to be rid of it—and shook her head. "Please, this is just really nice. I am… I am happy."

"Aww, well aren't you just the most adorable little thing. Fluffy seems like a good name." Fluttershy reached both wings up to each cheek of Midnight's. The first primary of each wing gently touched the alicorn's eyelids, and the feathers wicked up the moisture. "If you can ever learn to say your name, I will pay special attention to you, do you understand me, Fluffy?"

Safeword Midnight thought. She tried to hold back the tears of joy, the wonderful sensation of being told she was a good girl, and being able to believe it.

Author's Note

[7:35 PM] Damaged: Oh dang. I just turned non-sexual BDSM pet play into something that had me crying with the emotions in it...
[7:35 PM] Damaged: THIS WAS MEANT TO BE A CLOPFIC!
[7:35 PM] Damaged: WAT AM AH DOIN?

Okay, I am done crying for Midnight...

~~~~~+++++~~~~~

So I do this "Ask x" thing, x can be any pony within the story. You can ask them anything and ~~I~~ they will definitely hopefully reply. Keep the questions appropriate to the age-rating of the stories and of course, ~~I~~ they will answer the best question(s) in the author notes of the next chapter. The more votes a comment has the more likely I will get it to the right pony to answer, try and keep it to one answer per post! ~~I~~ They will pick one question per chapter.

Support me on Patreon or fuel my writing on Ko-Fi!

Join me on Discord. Warning, said chat may contain NSFW material and should be considered adult in nature.

Awesome ponies who are already helping to keep me in keyboards and rum:
A.P.O.N.I.
Boulder
Canary in the Coal Mine
Daremo
Dio-Drogynous
Ian
Javarod
Jeffh4
Mary Rowland
Mephia
Nils
Sirion123

And special thanks to the following, for careful eyes and friendly words:
Cross Lament
Jeffh4
Vutava