I Won't Accept No For An Answer

by Rarityfan87

Rating: everyone
Tags: Slice of Life, Alternate Universe, Twilight Sparkle, Sad, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Spike, Rarity
Length: 2655

Spike finally gets the courage to ask Rarity out. How will she respond?

Spike finally gets the courage to ask Rarity out. How will she respond?
This story takes place after season 2 and before season 3.

Published 2017-04-29 15:10:01 UTC
Last updated 2017-05-06 16:06:54 UTC

Spike's Big Day

Written by Rarityfan87 (Smithpat989)

The morning sun was rising over Ponyville brightening up the town. Ponies were getting out of bed, about to start their daily routines. That is except for one dragon. Spike didn’t want to get up, he was having a ‘fun’ dream. Unfortunately for him, he lived with Twilight Sparkle. The pony who kept to her schedule, without a second to spare. Noticing Spike had not woken up, Twilight went over to his bed.

“Spike, wake up!” Twilight lightly shook him to wake him up.

“Five more minutes…” Spike responded, still half asleep.

“NOW SPIKE! We need to get the chores list done early. Have you forgotten you promised Rarity, that you would help her today?” Twilight spoke, knowing that would get him out of bed. Spike instantly woke up, and got out of bed.

“You’re right, I completely forgot. Thank you Twilight.” Spike yelled as he ran (almost to Rainbow Dash speeds) to the bathroom to get cleaned up. Twilight shook her head, giggling slightly. She made her way downstairs to her desk, checking the task list for the day.

“Let’s see… Dust off the shelves, make sure books are in alphabetical order, sweep the floors…” Twilight was interrupted by the sound of Spike turning off the shower.

“Nice and clean for Rarity. Gotta make sure I look perfect today. Today’s finally the day I will ask Rarity to be my special pony.” Using the mirror, Spike checked to make he brushed and flossed every single tooth. When he was satisfied, he went downstairs to start his chores.

“Alright Spike, I want you to dust the shelves to start.” Twilight pointed as she spoke.

“I can’t do that Twilight.” Spike gave her a ‘you should know’ look.

“Why is that?” Expecting Spike to give her a terrible excuse.

“I just got cleaned up, and I can’t go to Rarity’s dirty from all the dust.” Spike said, causing Twilight to giggle.

"My apologies Romeo. Could you reorganize the book alphabetically?”

“That I can do!” Spike getting started right away, not wasting a moment. Halfway through, Spike stopped.

“I’ll get breakfast started Twilight.” Spike said, running to the kitchen. Twilight didn’t respond, she was too busy finishing dusting the books. A few moments later she finished, noticing Spike was gone.

Probably making breakfast. I should check to make sure he actually placed the books in proper order. Twilight made her way to the first book shelf. Taking a look, right away she noticed they weren’t.

“Breakfast is ready Twi.” Spike shouted.

“Coming.” Twilight made her way to the dining room. The usual breakfast was waiting for them. Gems for Spike and a bunch of dandelions for Twilight. She sat beside Spike. Spike noticed she had ‘that’ facial expression again. He knew she was about to lecture him on something.

“Spike, how many times do I have to tell you? It has to be placed in this order, subject, author, title and year of publication!” Twilight spoke with an annoyed tone in her voice.

“Like I’m going to look at every book to see how many pages there are. It would be so much easier if you just went author then title. Then you might have some actual free time sometimes, but then you wouldn’t know what to do.” Spike couldn’t hold back his laugh.

“Oh yeah? Just for that, you have to read a nature book to me tonight before bed. What do you think about that smart guy?” Twilight teased.

“That’s every book in this library.” Spike teased back.

“You just have to look, there’s so many great books out there, and I plan on reading them all!”

“Earth to Twilight. Come back to reality.” Spike waved his claw in front of her face. Twilight snapped out of it.

“Sorry Spike, I got carried away.” Twilight cheeks were turning red.

“Yeah, well let’s finish our breakfast so we can finish our chores.” They both finished their breakfast quickly. Getting back to the library, Spike continued alphabetizing all the books, doing it his way. Once he finished, he checked the time.

“Eleven o’clock! I need to get my stuff!” Spike ran upstairs to grab the cash he saved up for this moment. He quickly ran back downstairs yelling a quick “goodbye” to Twilight, as he quickly left for the flower stand. He arrived there in the nick of time, there was only one dozen of roses left! And in Rarity’s favourite colour.

“Hello sir, how can I help you today?” The earth pony running the stand asked.

“I would like to buy your last dozen roses, and I could I get them put in a nice vase please.”

“Sure thing, I will go get a vase in the back.” The earth pony walked off. After what felt like forever for Spike, he saw her coming back, with the flowers and vase.

“Here you go sir, what do you think?” Spike stared in awe.

“It’s perfect!” Spike said placing his money on the table.

“Keep the change.” Spike said grabbing the flowers and running off.

“Why thank you for your generosity sir.” The pony waved him goodbye.

Alright, now to get some chocolates, and the best there is. I know Rarity loves her dark chocolate. I guess that’s the type ‘high society’ eats.

Spike arrived, no line up. Thank Celestia, he thought to himself.

“Hello sir how can I help you?”

“A box of your finest dark chocolates please.”

“Right away sir.” The pony went into the back to grab the chocolates. Spike knew Rarity would love these chocolates, he has been here with her before. She absolutely loves these. She feels the ones from Sugar Cube Corner are not ‘high quality’ enough for her standards. Spike noticed the pony came back.

“Here you are sir, the finest I have.”

“Thank you.” Spike placed the money on the table. He grabbed the chocolates and ran off, hoping he wasn’t late for his appointment with Rarity. Spike was standing in front of Carousel Boutique. His heart was racing, he was short of breath, nerves taking over. He put the flowers and chocolates on the side and took a few deep breaths. He made he still looked ok, and checked to see if he had enough money for the date. After he got his confidence, he grabbed the flowers and chocolate. He knocked on the door, his nerves were taking over again. The door opened, with his crush on the other side, Rarity. All of his confidence left, he wanted to just turn around and not come back. He was interrupted by Rarity.

“Hello Spike, you just arrived on time. Please come in.” Rarity noticed the dragon was nervous about something.

“Are you alright Spike?” Rarity asked with concern. Spike snapped out of it, slightly gaining confidence.

“I am fine Rarity.” Spike remembered he had gifts for Rarity.

“These are for you Rarity.” Handing over the flowers and chocolate.

“I just love these flowers, and my favourite chocolates! Spike you shouldn’t have!” Rarity said wearing the biggest smile. She quickly put the flowers on her work table. Unable to resist, she opened the box of chocolates and ate one.

“Rarity I wanted to ask you a question.” That’s when it hit Rarity, he was going to ask her to be his special pony. She couldn’t believe she didn’t notice since he brought her, her favourite chocolates and flowers. She didn’t like him like that. Why did he have to ask now? She started looking for an excuse when she was interrupted.

“Rarity, will you be my special pony?” Using all his courage to ask her that question.

“You’re very kind Spike, but I cannot accept.” Rarity responded.

Author's Note

Hello everyone, I decided to completely rewrite this story. I had deleted it from my page longggg ago. I hated the original version, and have decided to finally start on the re write. If you would like to see the original, private message me, and I'll send you the google doc.

Thank you for reading and let me know what you think of it so far compared to the original.

If you liked it, please give it a thumbs up.

Rarity's Response

“I’m sorry Spike, but it just wouldn’t work out. I mean darling we are both different species, I am quite a bit older, you would live much longer than me, seeing as you are a dragon. I’m sorry Spike, I just can’t.” Rarity hoped she didn’t sound too harsh. Spike took a few deep breaths and broke eye contact with Rarity. It took all of his strength to not yell at her and hold back his tears. It took him a few minutes before he could speak.

“Why does this not surprise me?” His voice was calm, earily calm, causing Rarity to be concerned.

“Spike I didn’t mean to…”

“No, you’ve said enough. I don’t want to hear your excuses, you made your point clear. You go after ponies like Blueblood, high culture, connections to ponies in high positions. They don’t care about you like I do, however you keep going after them anyway. All because of their title. It hasn’t brought you much success, a little sure, but not what you expected I’m sure. You go after the ponies that date you just to get access to your marehood." Spike could feel his anger continiously building, he just wanted to slap Rarity, but he held back, knowing it would only make things worse.

"Let me just say this. I am not like that. I am not just after your marehood, I am not going to just use you. I have, HAD genuine love, I loved you for you. Sure I’m not ‘high culture’, not in high positions, but I here for you, not just myself. I would love you to the very end, through thick and thin. You could lose everything, and I would still be there for you. Why don't you understand that?” Spike did his best to not show he was crushed, he didn’t want Rarity to feel sorry for him.

“Spikey…” Something clicked in Spike, he now understood.

“Enough, you spoke, and I heard enough. Thank you for showing me how shallow you really are and how much of a manipulator you are. I understand now. You were manipulating me. Speaking in a soft tone, acting a little flirty, prettending to be sad or hurt so I would do what you wanted me to. In this case I am glad you said no, I wouldn't want to be stuck with a manipulator. Please don't talk to me, ever again! I've seen the truth, and I don't want to part of this anymore. Goodbye, Rarity." Spike came back to his senses. He could see the shock in Rarity's face. Before she could speak, he ran home, not wanting to deal with what just happened. Rarity wanted to stop him, but she was still in shock, not believing what just occured.

I can’t believe what Spike just said. I am not a manipulator! I am a great pony to be with. Her conscience began to talk to her.

You are a manipulator Rarity! How many times have you talked to Spike in that tone? Also what makes you think those are valid excuses? You may be afraid, but without trying, you'll never know how great of a dragon he could be. You already know he's a great friend, he could also be a great boyfriend.

You’re right, I am afraid. What if it doesn’t work out, then I will have lost a great friend.

That's always a possibility, but I believe it will work out, and if it doesn't, I'm sure you two could still be friends.

You’re right, I must try. Besides I do have feelings for him, and I do believe he would make a great boyfriend. I will talk to him tomorrow, I’ll give him time to think about what happened today. Rarity hoped it wouldn’t be too late.

(Back at the Library)

Spike ran in and went to his room, causing Twilight to be concerned. She walked up to the door to their room. She put her ear against the door, and heard crying.

*Knock, knock.*

No response.

“Can I come in Spike?” She asked, worried. No response. Twilight opened the door, to see him crying in his bed. Twilight sat beside him, hugging him, to which he returned.

“She told you no Spike?”

“Not just no, but also gave me every reason why it wouldn’t work, not even giving me a chance.”

“I’m sorry Spike.” Twilight couldn’t stand seeing her best friend like this.

“I gave her a speech I don’t think she’ll ever forget however.” Spike told Twilight what he told Rarity.

“Good for you Spike, you stood up for yourself. I’m proud of you.” Twilight gave him a smile of approval.

“Thank you Twi. I didn't see until then how much she was manipulating me.” He started to remember the times Rarity did that.

"Of course, you’re my best friend, I’m here for you. Besides, I have been through something similar.” Twilight started to remember that moment.

“What happened Twi?” Spike put his arm around her for comfort.

“It was back in Canterlot, there was a colt in my class that I had a crush on. He was smart, talented in science, and good looking. Every day I would talk to him, get to know him. We became school friends. We did partner projects together, studied at school together, spent lunch together. Well one day I decided to ask him. I took many deep breaths, had a good half hour convincing myself to go through with it. The bell rang, as every other pony left, I asked him if I could ask him a question. He listened, and that’s when I asked him the question, feeling so nervous. He looked at me, and told me, “I’m sorry Twi, but I like you as a friend.”. I started tearing up, I ran out of the class to my locker. He followed soon after and joined me at my locker, I looked at him and told him “I need to be alone, please just leave me alone.”. Everyday after in class he would talk to me, trying to get me to talk to him. I stayed silent, ignoring him, until eventually he started to leave me alone. I never did talk to him since that day.” This time Spike gave Twilight a hug, to which she returned.

“I’m sorry to hear that Twi. You’ll find somepony perfect for you.”

“Thank you Spike, and I know you’ll find somepony or dragon perfect for you as well.”

“Thank you Twi. If you don’t mind me asking, how come I didn’t hear about any of this?”

“You were very young at the time, I didn’t feel like it was a good time to tell you. I wanted to wait until you were at that stage. I hope you’re not angry.”

“I understand Twi, I’m just glad you’re ok.”

“You will be too Spike. It will take some time, but you’ll be back to the fun Spike I know.” They both smiled.

“Actually Twi, could you do me a favour?”

“Anything Spike.”

“If Rarity comes by wanting to talk to me, please tell her I’m not interested, I don’t want to talk to her.”

“Sure thing Spike I understand." Spike gave her a smile.

"How about we get some supper, something to help get your mind off of Rarity."

"Sounds good Twi." They both walked down the stairs, feeling better after sharing what happened.

Author's Note

Hey guys, thanks for reading! :)
Please let me know what you thought and if so far you like this version or the older version better.
If you liked it, please give it a thumbs up.