Fear Of The Light

Theodore pulled away from her lips, smiling warmly at Lunalla. He storked her cheek, caressing her perfect body. “You’re so beautiful…” He whispered, nuzzling his face into her mane.

Lunalla blushed, cooing softly at the feeling of his hands sliding over her fur, pressing into her soft form. “Theodore… you make me feel so beautiful… b-but I know I’m nothing next to Celestia..” She whispered.

“Don’t put yourself down.” Theodore pleaded quietly, “You two are far, far too different to ever compare. In my eyes you are both perfect, and nothing anypony can say or do will change that.” He squeezed her hands, “Lunalla… I want you to know, whenever I tell you something… I mean it, with all of my heart.” He stated.

“You… Theodore…” Lunalla said, “You really do mean it, don’t you?”

“Yes, I do.” Theodore nodded. “You and your sister deserve the world… but all I can truly give you both is myself.” He cupped her cheek, “I only hope I’ll always be enough for the two of you.” He smiled, kissing her forehead.

Lunalla hugged him tightly, nuzzling against his cheek. “You always will be, Theodore... you’re more than we could’ve ever asked for.” She said.

Theodore smiled, his eyes sparkling as he squeezed her back. “Now… I do have something I want to give you…” He whispered.

“Oh? What is it?” Lunalla asked, leaning back to look into his eyes.

Theodore didn’t speak, only staring down into her eyes for several seconds. His hands cupped behind her back, but she could still feel the flow of magic all around her.

She shivered at the feeling of it… it was hot, like her sister’s but… more primal. More… an inside heat, rather than the feeling of the sun shining upon her. “Oooh… your magic feels so strange, Theodore, but rather nice…”

“I’m glad you like it.” He smiled, nuzzling her nose. “As much as I love seeing those amazing cyan eyes of yours… I want this to be a surprise.” He kissed her on the lips.

Lunalla giggled, before closing her eyes, pushing back into the kiss. “Surprise me, then!” She said after pulling away.

Theodore grabbed her hands for a few moments, but then she felt something slip onto the ring finger of her left hand. “It looks so beautiful on you…” He breathed, kissing the top of her hand, “Why don’t you see it for yourself?” He suggested softly.

Lunalla slowly opened her eyes, looking down at the ring- she knew it was a ring once he’d put it on her- and gasped. It looked just like Celestia’s in form… but so different in color. The band was… magic? It surely shimmered like it was, lightly sparkling in a way no metal could, and atop it was an inset gem of… “T-Tanzanite?!” Lunalla gasped, bringing her free hand to her mouth. “But… we thought it had all been mined out… sold to the Diamond Dogs, o-or eaten by dragons…”

“I have my ways.” Theodore chuckled, “You and your sister deserve only the rarest and greatest things I can give you.” He cupped her cheek, “Now, all that’s left is for you to flaunt it to the world.” He nuzzled her cheek. “And flaunt your husband to anypony you desire.” He kissed her again, “The band is probably the hardest thing for me to get… it takes a little of my magic to make it. Something I can never take back.” He said, taking her hand in his. “And, the sparkling and color… that’s because of your magic. It’s only ever going to be that color for you.”

“R-really? You… you did all this for me? A-and Celestia too, I’m assuming, but still!” Lunalla said, growing excited. “It… it’s so amazing! It’s so beautiful, I… I don’t know what to…” She trailed off, one word finally hitting her. “H-Husband?”

“Yes, it is a wedding ring… Celestia and I were married in secret, and so too shall you and I.” Theodore nodded. “A permanent symbol of our union, and our love.” He smiled.

Lunalla’s smile grew so wide, it hurt. Just as well, her eyes welled up with tears. “Theodore… I… there are no words for h-how...how much I love you right now…” She whispered, her body shaking in joy.

Theodore’s own smile grew to match hers, he leaned in and kissed Lunalla with all the passion and love the moment needed. His muscular arms wrapping around her entire body, pressing her against his chest. His tail wrapping around her waist as well, completely surrounding her as his wings joined the full bodied hug.

Her tears leaked out onto Theodore’s cheeks, tracking down into their kiss and making it a salty show of love.

He pulled back from her lips, wiping away the tears and cupping her cheek. “I love you so much, Lunalla…” He cooed, his smile never wavering. “What a way to begin a night.” He chuckled, “But… I guess this makes tonight our honeymoon.” He teased, nuzzling her cheek, further making her tears vanish.

“D-did you plan this?” Lunalla asked, giggling as she leaned into his hands.

“No… I didn’t.” Theodore shook his head, “I… just felt it’d be wonderful to give you the ring now… Make it amazing, and show you how much I love you.”

“Theodore… every moment with you is amazing, and… and I hope every moment that ever follows is, too…” Lunalla said. “You’ve made me so happy…”

“I’ll continue to do whatever it takes to make you happy. I love seeing you smile.” Theodore grinned, tapping the end of her nose. “Now, my little Lunalla… we’re here all alone, and I’m all yours. Just tell me what you want me to do, and it’ll be done.”

His final comment broke the mood, making it charge with a light overtone of sexual tension as Lunalla’s blush returned, and she said, “Er… w-well, you… you’re my first, Theodore. So… I don’t… know what I want?”

Theodore laughed quietly, “Right… Um, why don’t we start then with what you know? At least from there I can help make things a bit easier.” He suggested. “I mean… you do know somethings about sex at least, right?” He joked.

Lunalla nodded. “Well… there’s vaginal sex, and oral sex, a-and anal sex if you’re adventurous… and I’ve heard of… of ‘handjobs’ and ‘titjobs’, I believe they were called.” She explained.

Theodore’s hand shot to his mouth and she saw his eyes beginning to water as he held back laughter. “O… oh my, that’s… um…” He choked back tears, “Yo… you’re just too adorable…” He then burst out laughing, “Oooh, anal being ‘adventerous’… HAH! You should really tell Celestia that one…” He leaned backwards, covering his face completely as he laughed at her innocence on the matter.

“H-hey! Don’t laugh at me, Theodore! I just… it… It’s not my fault!” Lunalla said, pouting.

“I know… I know, it’s just too funny for me…” Theodore’s laughter came to a stop, “It’s just… I never expected you to know so little, it’s like all you were told about was in a textbook.” He shook his head. He smiled at her, “And just remember who exactly you’re talking to.” He added.

“Well, Father did say after the, er, Talk, that I could borrow the book he had on it if I really wanted to…”

“Right… the talk.” He sighed, shaking his head. “Please… just tell me you do know what a stallionhood looks like. And that won’t be a huge shock to you…”

“I-I most certainly do!” Lunalla said indignantly, glancing away after a few moments. “I… do own a few… dildos.”

“Yes… um, Celestia did tell me you’ve masturbated in the past.” Theodore nodded, “So, why don’t we begin in familiar territory?” He suggested, “Except instead of you touching yourself, it’d be me.”

Lunalla bit her lip, her blush returning. “Y-you… would do that, for me? Start off so slowly?” She asked.

“Of course, I’ll go as slow as you want.” Theodore nodded. “I don’t want to push you too fast, or far… I don’t want to risk you hating me for hurting you.” He stood them up, and motioned for her to turn around. “Of course… who strips you is your choice. Just know, if I do, I’ll take my time…”

She shivered at the low tone Theodore’s voice took, then, and nodded, before voicing her agreement, “P-Please… strip me, Theodore... l-look at me again like you did when you saw me in the bathroom…”

Theodore’s heart fluttered and he took her in his arms. His lips touched hers and she felt his hands slide slowly down her body, gently feeling and groping every inch of her still clothed body as he made his way to her waist. He stopped for a few long moments to tease her breasts, feeling the soft marshmallows that’d soon be in his hands. After his hands touched her waist he removed his lips, his fingers slipping under her shirt. “I still think you’d look wonderful in a dress.” He teased, gently removing her shirt. “It’d bring out your curves more…” He slowly caressed her sides, feeling her fur and her soft stomach with nothing left to block out his hands. He continued down her body, his snout nuzzling her back and wings as he slid down to his knees, bringing her pants with him, leaving her in just her bra and panties. “And please… do remind me to get you some lingerie…” He added, nuzzling into her huge, soft flank, now being able to touch and feel it as he pleased.

Lunalla moaned, groaned with need, and cooed throughout, relishing each and every soft touch of Theodore’s hands and lips upon her, shuddering at the light surges of pleasure when he just barely squeezed her breasts. She gave a gasp when she felt his head pressing against her plot cheeks, nuzzling against them. “Th-Theodore… you… you make me feel so amazing…. Please….” She begged, her legs weak under her.

Theodore slid up her body, and instead of wasting time in sliding her panties off, he tore them in two, letting the tattered remains fall to the floor. His hands dug into her flesh as he teethed on her neck. After nearly a minute of groping her plot, his hands moved to her bra, unhooking and letting it fall away. His hands now shamelessly groping her titflesh as he nuzzled her neck. “There we go…” He whispered, “Now… it’s time for me to see my work…” He pulled back, slowly twirling her around, his hands now on hers, holding her out at arm's length as his eyes slid over her body, seeming to judge her nude body. Though his smile showed his absolute joy at being able to see it. She was sure if his cock had been out, that -if it wasn’t always hard- he’d be rock solid.

She blushed brightly as Theodore’s eyes slid up and down her body, looking away, and eventually moving her arms to cover her breasts and marehood, the latter of which was dripping down her leg and making her so much more nervous. “Theodore… you… s-stop staring… it makes me feel so embarrassed.” Lunalla mumbled.

“Why? You’re absolutely beautiful…” Theodore stepped forward, cupping her cheeks as his body pressed against hers. “Every single part of you… you’re perfect, so damned perfect.” His one hand gently guiding the arm over her breasts to his shoulder. “Including your marehood, and plot...” He gently circled a finger around her nipples. “It only makes every second I spend with you that much better… no matter if we’re clothed or naked. I love seeing you, Lunalla. Just as much as I love seeing Celly.”

Lunalla stared up into his eyes, searching for any hint of lying or just saying things… but she could see that Theodore meant every word he said. He really, truly thought she was perfect., just like her sister. “I… I love you, Theodore…” She whispered, her arms around his neck. “Please… m-make me feel like I’m perfect… let me feel your love…”

Theodore wrapped his arms around her, leaning down just enough to touch her lips, “I'll never let you feel anything less.” He whispered, now kissing her. Only after a few moments did he begin to guide her back into the bed, nestling her in his lap, his lips never leaving hers. He slowly pulled back from her lips, leaving them both feeling a little colder.

“N-no… don’t stop…” Lunalla begged, trying to lean up and resume the kiss.

Theodore’s finger touched her lips -one on each set, sending a tiny spark of electricity through her.

She gasped at the feeling of his finger upon her puffy, lower pair, lightly shivering from just the touch alone.

He softly rubbed her marehood, making sure to always touch her clit. He kissed her horn just as his finger finally parted her labia and slipped into her.

“A-ahhh!” Lunalla gasped, arching her back against his arm. True, it was just a finger… but it felt like so much more than that.

Theodore smiled softly, “It's a wholly different beast when someone else is doing it, isn't it?” He mused, kissing the tip of her horn again.

She was about to answer, and then Theodore’s lips touched her horn. She cried out in a sudden surge of ecstasy, her marehood squeezing around his finger, trying to milk it.

He continued to work on her horn, surprising her further by licking it. He closed his eyes and pushed another of his fingers into her, spreading her open just a bit more.

Lunalla’s moans and gasps were so cute, each one egging him on to get to the next one, to hear her voice whimper out his name again.

It didn't take long for him to begin his true work, her horn vanishing into his mouth. She could feel his tongue swirl around it as he gingerly suckled. At the same time, his fingers pressed deeper, now grinding and prodding her walls, never for a moment letting up. It was clear he was enjoying this just as much as she was.

Her hips lightly bucked against Theodore’s fingers, and Lunalla’s face was in a constant ahegao, her eyes rolling up to her forehead when he slid her horn fully into his mouth.

He continued to fully pleasure her, only to pull completely off of her as she neared her peak.

Lunalla blinked, confused. “Th-Theodore? Why… why did you stop? It f-felt and so good…”

Theodore had plans to make it feel even better and he slipped down her body. “Oh, I know it did…” He breathed, taking in the heavy scent of her dripping marehood.

She saw where his face was, and gasped, instinctively spreading her legs. “Y-you… you want to… give me oral s-sex?” She whispered.

He chuckled, “Yes. Yes I do.” He smiled, softly nuzzling her honeypot. He closed his eyes and gently slipped his tongue in, the appendage filling her even more than his fingers. It was only for a moment, and he loved her taste. “And… it's more of eating you out. While when you do it to me, it's called a blowjob.” He said.

“Nnn… s-such strange terms… Father’s book never said anything about either of those.” Lunalla said, shivering as Theodore’s long, thick tongue licked up her labia.

“You still have quite a bit to learn.” He breathed, now burying his face in her marehood, licking at her like a thirsty animal. He pushed his tongue in deep, lapping her interior with a skill that would make any mare shudder and not giving her any sort of warning.

“Haaah!” She wheezed, her hands grabbing onto Theodore’s head for support as her body rocked with the sensations emanating from her pussy. “O-oh, gods! I-I never… I never thought…. It c-could feel this amazing!”

He could only smile inwardly, his mouth far too busy pleasuring her to pull back, or even stop. His hands gripped her legs, tugging on them to get her to wrap them around his head.

Lunalla eagerly obeyed, wrapping her thick, soft thighs around Theodore’s head and squeezing him in closer.

Theodore pushed his snout roughly against her lips, his tongue teasing right up against her cervix. He wanted to lick and tease as much of her as he could, and get her ready for when he was truly inside her.

She shivered heartily when the tip of his tongue brushed her deepest barrier, before getting an idea. “Theodore… f-find my, ah, m-my G-spot! I n-never could with my toys…”

He pulled back from her cervix, probing and pressing into her walls, now searching out her g-spot, determined to find it so he could give her the most pleasure possible. It didn’t take him long, almost as if he just knew where to find that special spongy spot. His tongue delicately tickled and pressed it, sending shocks of pleasure through her body.

“O-oh, Theodoooore!” Lunalla cried out, throwing her head back as she shouted her ecstasy to the heavens. Her pussy squeezed and clenched around his tongue, coating it and his face in her juices as he ravaged her with it.

Theodore only doubled his efforts to get her off. His tongue twisting and turning massaging as much of her marehood as he could manage, at the same time his tail had slid up, wrapping around her breasts, roughly massaging them.

Her screams got even higher and louder as she finally came, pressing his head as much against her crotch as she could, her marehood’s juices pouring out in an a small flood that would likely leave the bed stained.

His tongue wiped back as he attempted to drink down her juices. Though he didn’t even wait very long, pushing out of her grip and stumbling back, licking the juices from his face and snout. He panted, breathing heavily as he stared down at her quivering form. Without a word he let his cock begin to slide out, letting it come to full mast before he even approached her again. Though he wasn’t heading for her marehood.

“Th-Theodore…?” She whispered, panting and gasping for breath, her eyes locked on his length.

“Yes, Lunalla?” He asked, standing on the side of the bed, his monster shaft just in range of her hands. “Am… I rushing a bit?” He asked honestly.

“I… I do not think so…” She said, still staring at his stallionhood. “I just… I never expected it to be so large…”

“I did say you’d be getting my full size.” He laughed, “And right now it’s all yours. Just, tell me where to move, and what you want me to do. If you want any ideas… I can explain a few things to you.”

“Tell me… what you would like to do to me.” Lunalla said, looking up into his eyes. “A-and… what you want me to do to you.”

Theodore smiled, sitting down on the bed, he motioned for her to move to his side. “First, why don’t we try a handjob? It’s pretty simple.” He suggested.

“But… I cannot fit my hand around you.” Lunalla said, after she’d scooted next to him. “I… I don’t even think I could with both…”

Theodore wrapped an arm around her, chuckling. “Don’t worry about not being able to fit it all. That’s not the point... so long as your hands are on it, then you’ll be giving me a hand job.” He said, nuzzling her.

She leaned against him, biting her lip as she slowly set her hand atop his hard, throbbing length, gasping a little at the sheer heat of it. “Is… is it always this hot, Theodore?” Lunalla asked, rubbing the veined skin of it.

“Yes it is… is it unpleasant? I can make it cooler for you.” He offered, shivering lightly at her touch.

“No! It is… I like it. You know that, like Celestia, I… exude a feeling. Though unlike hers, it is coolness, instead of warmth… I like hot things, much as she enjoys colder ones.” Lunalla said.

“Well… just you wait, it gets hotter.” He laughed, kissing her cheek. His cock throbbed pleasantly, egging her to touch it more. Then she saw the cloudy white liquid leaking out of it, the dollop of it remaining perfect on his tip, almost beckoning her to run her finger through it.

So… she did. Lunalla slowly swiped her finger through the glob of… precum, she realized, and lifted it up to her face, getting a better look at it. “It… it’s so thick! The book said precum was thin and clear, but… this… it looks more like semen.” She said, marvelling at it.

“Maybe that’s for ponies. But… usually, it’s just as potent as my cum would be.” Theodore explained. “And… well, it only comes off when it’s rubbed against a pony. Water does nothing to it.” He added, “Why don’t you taste it?” He suggested.

She glanced at him. “T-taste it? But… w-well… you did with mine, so I suppose… it’s only fair.” Lunalla said, before bringing her finger to her mouth and sucking the seed off, her eyes widening. When she gulped the glob down, she turned back to Theodore, “So salty, a-and… slightly sweet! How does it taste so good, Theodore?”

Theodore for once seemed reluctant to answer. “It’s… uuh… meant to be addictive. My cum adjusts in taste magically… but um, drinking it straight down… yeah, just ask Celestia what comes from that.” He sighed. “She… wanted to bottle it up.” He joked.

“Oh… that makes sense, then. It seems that really wasn’t a bottle of cream, all those years ago…\” Lunalla said, giggling.

Theodore remained quiet, raising an eyebrow. “E-excuse me?” He questioned.

“It seems she snuck some past you.” Lunalla said, giggling a little harder.

“I… I don’t…” He trailed off an idea clicking in his mind. “Oooh, that’s brilliant.” He muttered. “I… I wonder how much she had stored up…” He shook his head.

“I don’t think she had much.” She offered, easing his thoughts a tad.

“Oh gods…” He mumbled. “Uh… i-if I vanish for a long time… just know… I’m probably with Celestia.” Theodore choked out, only wondering when Celestia had run out.

Lunalla tilted her head, before thinking a bit deeper. “I… I suppose that, as an incubus, you have nearly if not infinite ‘production’, yes?”

“Mmhmm… and it’s Celestia we’re talking about here…” Theodore muttered, “She’ll take it all… even if she has me locked up there for days.”

“I may just join her, if it proves to be as good as it sounds…”

Theodore visibly shivered at that thought. “O-one… one of you… m...” He couldn’t even finish his thought. His cock once again violently twitched, almost like it had a mind of it’s own and it was sick of being neglected.

Lunalla’s attention shifted back to it, and she bit her lip, before slipping off of the bed and in front of his shaft, down under it on her knees. “I think this position may prove easier for me to stroke you from… and it means I may study your testicles as well.” She said, before leaning in and hefting said swollen orbs of seed. “So large… and full. I can feel your seed inside, sloshing about with each movement…”

“Nnn… glad you like them…” Theodore groaned, “Just… uh be careful down there… my musk’s a little strong.” He paused. “Well… incredibly strong. Be glad I contain it… I am…” He shivered, the thought of the one time he didn’t fully control it at Celestia’s behest. “Oh gods… she was a demon… it still scares me…” He mumbled.

Lunalla leaned her face in closer to Theodore’s balls, her face blushing heavily as she took a deep breath of his musk, letting it fill her lungs. “Ooooh… I can certainly see why she likes it…”

He shivered as her snout touched his sack, “It’s all yours.” He smiled, running a hand through her mane.

“One, at least…” Lunalla said, before dragging her tongue up the sweaty skin. “Ahhh… it tastes so… so good…”

Theodore let out a cute moan, closing his eyes as he let her do whatever she desired to him. “Your tongue feels amazing…”

Finally, Lunalla turned her attention to the spire of flesh above her, really taking in how large it was from her position under it. She scooted back some, until she had it pointed at her face, and then slowly began to slide her hands up and down Theodore’s long, thick shaft.

His cock quaked and quivered at her touch, pre leaking out in glorious amounts, only coming off when her hands touched it.

Lunalla leaned her head closer, before sliding over his entire wide, flat tip, swiping his pre up into her mouth and eagerly swallowing it, licking her lips once it had gone.

Immediately more formed at the tip, showing his truly never-ending virility. “Oooh, keep that up.” He shivered, moaning softly.

She did as he said, and continued to slurp up any and all precum that leaked from his shaft, her tongue teasing his whole tip with each pass.

She noticed it start to get thicker, almost like his cum was truly mixing in with it. “Yes… s.. Stroke it a bit more…” He murmured.

“Mmm… you like this…” She said, her hands speeding up.

“I love it!” Theodore moaned, “Aaah…” His cock twitched a few times. “I… If you want me to cum at all… j-just tell me when…” He mumbled, closing his eyes again as he basked in the pleasure he was receiving.

“Theodore…” Lunalla purred, looking up at him, “I want your seed in two places… my marehood… and… and my plot.” She said. “Because I am feeling adventurous.”

“Oooh… I’ll give you that and more…” He panted, “When I’m done… you’ll look nine months pregnant… cum dripping out of every hole.” His breathing grew heavier, and his eyes narrowed. “You’ll be breathing in my cum for days… never able to get rid of the taste of it.” She realized she struck a chord deep in his mind. “Lunalla… I want you to ride me right now…” His cock twitched and seemed to grow harder.

She blushed, and Lunalla realized she had been out-done. “A… already?” She asked. “The… the book always said it was important to wait… mmm, b-but I do want to…”

“J… j-just do it in whatever order you desire… I just need you to ride me at some point…” Theodore nearly whined, shivering a little more with desire. “Nnnn, i… if you do decide to skip foreplay… n-never go straight to anal… it’ll be an absolute disaster…” He added quickly.

“You mean you… h-have to prepare me for it?” Lunalla asked, glancing back at her rear.

“Yes… stretch it out, and lube my cock up.” Theodore nodded, “Did… you want me to get you ready for when you want to try anal?” He asked.

“I-I do! I’m… I realize, now… all the times you looked at my plot… you love it.” She said, smiling up at him. “And… I’m curious, too.”

Theodore licked his lips, smiling widely. “Come, lay back down… this time on your stomach.” He said, motioning to a spot beside him.

Lunalla did as he said, laying on her front… letting him get a glorious view of her large, amazing ass. He instantly dove at her, burying his face in her plot, nuzzling both her cheeks and planting kisses all over them.

She began to assume that’s all he’d do, until she felt him slip a finger into her plot.

“Ah!” She yelped, in pain for a moment before it shifted to a strange sort of pleasure. “Ah… Theodore, warn me!” She scolded, looking back at him.

Theodore responded with a playful nibble to her plot, slowly swirling his finger around, beginning his slow process of properly spreading her hole.

“Nnn… it feels strange… good, but a different good than when you were eating me out.” Lunalla said, lightly swaying her plot jiggling from when she pulled it away from Theodore’s nipping.

“Just wait until I’m buried in you…” Theodore breathed, “Every inch… stretching you wider than you’ve ever been stretched before…” He slipped a second finger into her plot, spreading his fingers apart as he slid them in deep.

“Oooh!” She squealed, her body shuddering both from the imagery and the sensation of her large, puffy asshole being spread by Theodore’s fingers. “Theodore… t-tell me… how you’ll ravage me.”

“Ooh… you want me to tell you what I’ll do?” Theodore licked his lips, “Mmm… first I’m going to pull that nice… full ass of yours up, slamming my cock right into your pussy… I’ll take your first time doggy… pounding you deep and hard as I bend over you, biting into your neck.” He licked up her back. “Then… just as I’m about to cum, I’ll pull out to just my tip… let my flare lock all my cum inside you so you can feel every ounce… every pulse…” He breathed out.

“K-Keep going… “ Lunalla begged, bucking her hips back against his hand, desperately wanting more.

“Then, just as I feel the last spurt coming, I’ll push my flare into your virgin ass… letting my cum be the lube… then once I can fit my flare in you… I’ll start fucking you harder than you could ever imagine.” He whispered into her ear. “You’ll be left unable to even stand…” He then nipped her ear. “But that won’t be where I finish with you… I’m going to soak your body in cum… your coat will be stained white until I clean you off… But I might just leave you soaked in cum for a while… let the castle know how much you enjoyed being ravaged…”

Lunalla arched her back in pleasure as Theodore stuffed a third finger into her ass, moaning her assent out to the heavens. Theodore was now completely over top of her, there was no mistaking what he was going to do. She could only wait with bated breath as he slowly pulled his fingers out.

He gave no word of warning, only kissing her neck as he grabbed her hips and positioned her against his cock. She felt his dripping maw open, just as he sunk his hot shaft into her, he bit down, fully claiming her from both sides. He did just as he said, slamming into the hilt, battering through her cervix and taking her womb as his own.

As much as everything she knew said it should hurt, that what Theodore had just done should be impossible… it didn’t, and it wasn’t. She cried out in pleasure and pain- the bite did hurt- as he shoved himself fully into her, and Lunalla could feel her belly bulge out in the area where his length was in her womb. He ripped his teeth from her neck, lapping at the wounds, a heat now spreading rapidly though her body as they instantly healed.

“So… damn TIGHT!” He growled, hammering hard into her marehood. His pre leaked in massive amounts into her, making his rough thrusts go even faster because of the smooth slide in. Lunalla’s marehood felt like heaven itself… hot, tight, and both smooth and ridged, it teased Theodore’s shaft with each and every thrust, squeezing and pulsing around him.

“Th-Theodore!” Lunalla said, her voice hoarse from the amount of concentration it took just to speak, “S-stretching me… so m-muuuuch!”

She was taken by surprise when his hand came down on her flank, a loud SMACK echoing through the room. “You’re fucking perfect…” He moaned, groping the ass cheek he just slapped. “I might not let you go… make you into a cum dump… How does that sound?”

“Haaahn!” Lunalla moaned, shuddering beneath him as her ass jiggled from the slap. “Ahhh… t-take me… make me y-yours!”

Theodore let out a roar, pulling nearly all the way out, and she felt his tip flare brilliantly within her. Though it did nothing to stop his pounding, only making him thrust harder. His seed flooded her marehood, if she thought his cock was hot, this was pure fire. It clung everywhere and slathered her womb in pure white.

Each spurt of his hot, glue-like cum poured down into her deepest reaches, soon enough filling it before starting to make her stretch out. Lunalla’s eyes sprang open as soon as it started and from her mouth erupted a cry of ecstasy as she came from the sheer depravity inherent in knowing Theodore was filling her so full her womb was actually bloating with seed, making her stomach distend.

As Theodore had promised he yanked his flare from her, managing to hold back the last spurt long enough to press his cock slightly into her plot, now spraying his seed even deeper in her. The heat quickly filling her to the core.

Her cries got even louder as she felt the lewd load spilling forth into her guts, filling them all full for a good few feet like a pure cum enema.

His flare shrunk back down and with a mighty thrust, he sunk all the way into her tight plot. Now he rested inside of her, letting her body adjust to his cock.

After about ten solid seconds of screaming in agonizing pleasure, Lunalla came down from her second orgasm, feeling oh-so strangely wonderful with Theodore’s length fully into her plot. “G-guh… it… it feels so d-different… a-and… and so right…” She panted, squeezing her plot around him.

“Nnn I’m glad you like it…” Theodore panted, grinding himself around in her plot. “I abs… absolutely love your body…”

“Theodore?”

“Yes, Lunalla?”

“P-pound me… into the bed!” She demanded, pushing her fat ass back against his body.

Theodore grabbed her ass tightly, digging his fingers deep into her flesh before he began to violently rut her, taking her like a mare in heat, and showing no more mercy for the tight ass he had fallen in love with.

Every thrust was like soft punch outward from inside of her, bulging her already-swollen belly with the thick form of Theodore’s cock. He mercilessly trained his shaft in and out of her asshole, forcing it to stretch over his medial ring with each pass, plunging it deep into her intestines every time he hilted.

He grunted and groaned with every thrust, railing her hard into the bed, the frame shaking violently with every movement. She could hear his balls churning loudly, signaling her impending filling.

Each thrust made his enormous sack slap up against her drenched, cum-dripping marehood, making her give a small cry from the shock of pleasure it gave her every time.

Theodore wrapped his arms around her stomach, pressing her further into the bed. “Yeeesss!” He hissed, his cock throbbing violently. “P...prepare yourself… it… it goes all the way…” He grunted into Lunalla’s ear. She had no time to guess at his meaning as he hilted himself, letting his flare lock him in her plot. The thick shots of cum nearly broiling her intestines as it descended through her, soon beginning to fill her stomach.

“A-all the… wyyggg…” Lunalla started, only to be cut off as something locked her throat. Her eyes wide, she tried to swallow whatever it was, but it forced itself further up, until- “Glrrk!” a waterfall of thick, sticky cum drooled from her mouth, pooling on the bed. Her eyes rolled up from the insanely lewd feeling of being completely filled with Theodore’s love, and she came again on the spot, her ass tightening against his length, milking him for all he had.

He groaned, accidentally resting his full weight atop her back, forcing a good amount of the cum out of her stomach and womb with a loud splrrrt. “Nnnaah…” He muttered, his magic flaring up, preventing Lunalla from experiencing the mind breaking feeling, though unlike Celestia’s cum removal spell, his just dropped it all on the floor. The thick, musky scent of his cum threatening to permeate the whole castle. Though he really didn't care, content to rest atop Lunalla, his throbbing and still steel hard cock in her plot, that he now wanted to worship.

“Lunalla?” He panted, lightly nuzzling right behind her ear.

She responded with a gurgle, her mouth still dripping his seed, before swallowing most of it and saying, “Theodore.... that... w-was amazing…”

“I'm happy you like it so much.” Theodore nuzzled her mane, now snuggling against her. “Is there anything else you wanted to try, or should I go run us a bath?”

“Mnnn… let’s take a sh-shower, Theodore…” Lunalla said, clenching her ass around him. “Perhaps… we’ll think of something in there.”

Theodore slipped about halfway out before rolling Lunalla onto her back and pushing back in. The two were now chest to chest. “I’m sure we will.” He smiled at her, slowly lifting her up. He kissed her, slowly walking towards the bathroom.

“Oooh… having you up my plot… i-it feels so good, Theodore…” She murmured, shivering as each step made his shaft push a bit deeper into her, and made the cum still trapped inside slosh about.

“Your plot is divine.” He nuzzled her. “It seems I’ll have to make love to it whenever I get the chance.” He teased, his tail turning on the shower. “Sadly… I can’t just carry you around the castle like this…” He let out a sigh, grinning a little.

“True… but we can sleep like this.” Lunalla said, nuzzling his neck. “And if either of us should awaken with the urge to continue, well… I am sure your stallionhood will be up for the task.”

Theodore laughed, “Yes… yes it will.” He slowly, and reluctantly removed himself from her plot, letting Lunalla rest up against his body as the shower was turned on. “For n…” He trailed off as he looked over her body once more, his eyes falling directly on her breasts. “Ooh…” He mumbled, taking them both into his hands, groping and tracing his fingers all around, focusing on her nipples. “That’s new.” He commented, poking a finger gently against her inverted nipples.

“Hmm? My nipples?” Lunalla asked, blushing at his gentle touch. “They are… inverted, I believe is the correct term.”

“It’s a rare trait…” Theodore said, leaning down giving one a light suckle, his mind now kicking on in full as he thought about all the fun they could have with them. “They’re very beautiful.” He added, smiling at her, his cock now getting soaked with water as it rode up her body.

Her blush progressed further, at both his compliment and the feeling of his shaft sliding up her form. “Y-you really think so?” Lunalla asked, her smile wide.

“Yes, I do.” Theodore nodded, lightly kissing her. “Everything about you is beautiful, Lunalla.” He nuzzled into her mane, drawing her head into his neck.

“I… thank you, Theodore…” She said, hugging him tightly, “My heart continues to flutter every time you say that…”

“I love just saying it.” He hugged her back. “Heh… I’m wondering something.”

“What is it?”

“Well… seeing as your nipples are inverted… it would be possible to penetrate them… with some smaller objects, that is.” Theodore started.

“Penetrate… my nipples?” Lunalla repeated, a little shocked. “R-really?”

“Yeah…” He nodded slowly. “Of course… it’d have to be kinda slow… Unlike the ‘slow’ of… um plowing you into the bed.” He joked, biting down on his lip. “Like, take our time to stretch it out…” He paused, gently rubbing one of her nipples. “If you’d want to that is.”

“There’s no harm in testing it… right? So… we can try, and if I like it, we can keep doing it.” Lunalla said, her hands shifting to his back and pressing herself further against him. Theodore leaned down and pulled her into a deep kiss, caressing her own back for a few moments.

“Alright!” He slowly stepped out of her arms, turning her around to press his chest against her back. Her wings were now rubbing against his muscles as his arms draped around her stomach. “Here… this should make it all a bit easier.”

“Make what a bit easier?” Lunalla asked, trying to tilt her head back enough to look into his eyes.

Theodore traced a finger up her body, gently rubbing it against her nipple. “This.” He whispered, his finger gently pushing into her, his finger spreading her nipple out as it slipped in deep. “How does that feel?” He asked, genuinely concerned she might not enjoy it.

“O-ooooh!” Lunalla gasped, her voice cracking in the middle of it. “Theodore… it… it feels so different from anything else… so… dirty… b-but right….”

Theodore smiled widely, now thrusting his finger in and out. “It must feel really good…” He breathed, grinding a little against her. “Mmm, I can image how big they’d both be… stuffed up with my seed.” He whispered teasingly.

Lunalla groaned, pushing herself back against him. “Y-you… you’d never fit yourself in them, though… r-right?”

“I’d sure as hell try.” Theodore whispered, kissing her horn. He pulled his first finger back, gently pushing a second one into her nipple, stretching it even wider. “Celly’s going to be jealous of you… she’d never be able to experience this…”

“Ahhh!” Lunalla gasped again, her eyes shooting wide open. “Th-Theodore!”

His grin grew devious as he did something she never could have expected, his tail slithered up her body, the tip of the large prehensile object pressing into her other nipple. It was a good thing the spaded tip was soft, and not sharp… it curled into a small cylinder as it pressed against her breast, wiggling slightly as it slowly slid inside.

“Theodore, I’m… nnn… I-I’m going to cum a-again!” Lunalla warned, her legs shaky underneath her, forcing her to lean back against the incubus.

Theodore grinned, his free arm wrapping around her waist to add support. “Don't hold back.” He nibbled on her ear, twisting his fingers and tail.

Lunalla’s scream of pleasure echoed off of the walls of the bathroom, and her marehood clenched and squeezed on naught but air as its juices ran down her thighs, her smell clear and heavy in the shower as it intermingled with Theodore’s musk. Her nipples tightened around him as well, in a startling similarity to how her marehood and plot had.

He shivered and felt his cock throb, wanting to be buried back in the alicorn. He was half tempted to ram back into her marehood as he fingered her nipples. Though a stronger part of his mind wanted to set her down and try to get his now aching cock into her nipples. In truth he didn't know if it'd actually fit… but he’d love to try.

“Ahhh… Theodore…” Lunalla whispered, bringing him back to the moment. “I-I think… I’m tapped out, for now…”

Theodore bit his lip for a moment, his erection beginning to die down, “Well… I won't force you to go over your limit.” He assured, removing his finger and tail from her nipples.

She brought a hand to her still-swelled stomach, groaning happily. “Oooh… Theodore… remember, this… it was my first time. It was amazing… and exhausting. But soon my stamina will build up, and then,” She clenched her thighs around his shaft, letting him feel her arousal on top of him, “We’ll go all night… and perhaps all day, too.”

“I can’t wait… I'll show you no mercy when that comes…” He breathed, grinding against her. “Maybe by then you and Celestia will be together as well… you two might even drain me.”

“Mmm…” She hummed, biting her lip at the feeling of his length passing between her legs. “So eager to see us like that, aren’t you?”

“Yes! It'd be so hot…” He was nearly drooling at the thought.

“Pressing our bodies together… begging you to take us…”

Theodore bit down hard on his lip, “Mmm…” He mumbled, thinking of all the things he’d do to them.

“Our marehoods sopping wet… tongues hanging from our mouths as we pant in need… our cocks throbbing in lust…” Lunalla continued, throwing in the last bit just to tease him.

“Ooooh…” Theodore shivered, quaking against her. “T-that’d be amazing…” He mumbled.

She burst out in giggles. “Oh my, Theodore… you really would love to see that, wouldn’t you?” Lunalla purred, turning around in his hold.

“There's so much about it I'd love to see…” He nuzzled her.

“You know we’d return the favor, correct?” She said. “Leaving you all bloated and exhausted like you leave me and Celestia…”

“I hope so! I wouldn't let you two stop until that happened.” He licked his lips. “It does make me sooo sad that I’d have to take turns with you two though…” He sighed.

“Why would you? You have a mouth and a firm, tight plot…” She said, reaching around him to pinch it. “We would merely trade places every so often… filling you to the brim from both sides.”

For a moment Theodore’s grin turned mischievous, “You are far too innocent…” He laughed, wiggling his butt. “My… I can't wait till your mind is as dirtied as Celly’s, I just hope you don't ever stop talking like you do now though…”

“Hmmm? What do you mean?” Lunalla asked. “Do I speak a certain way? Twilight tried to help me before, but… I suppose it didn’t work… b-but you like it?” She looked back up at him, her blush returning.

“It's such a turn on! I love it!” Theodore nodded vigorously. “It's the exact opposite of the way Celly talks in bed.” He mused, “Where you’re so innocent in what you call everything… so hesitant… she just… um, you’ll eventually see.”

“Is she overly vulgar?”

“Mmmhm.” Theodore nodded, “But, just like what you do… it manages to push all the right buttons.”

Lunalla smiled. “Then I shall keep talking as I do now. But, er… you know I’ll stop being so hesitant soon.”

“Oh, I know…” He smiled back, nuzzling and hugging her. “I’m just going to enjoy that part while it lasts… it’s nice being able to guide somepony again… just taking it a bit slower, and watching somepony enjoy it for the first time.” He mused, his smile growing a little more. “Your sister was like this the first time…”

“Really? Celestia… doesn’t seem like the type to want to go slow- or, well, slow-ish, considering. But still, knowing her… she really acted like I did, so long ago?” Lunalla asked.

“Yeah… and back then I was a lot more timid, surprisingly… She did a lot to change me.” Theodore chuckled. “We were both nervous the first time, heh… I was nervous during the first few times honestly. It was just… so strange for me.” He sighed. “You should ask her about it sometime… She used to find it funny. And it took us months to work up the courage to even attempt anal, but uuh… It was a one-time thing back then… she had a slight limp for a few hours… and it was long enough for your father to notice.” He laughed.

“What did Father do?”

“I had… a stern talking to.” Theodore started. “Oooh, if only he knew what went on after we developed that silencing spell… I’d have been obliterated for what I showed her.” His grin widened, “It wouldn’t have taken her all that long to bring me back… but still. That was around the time I found out she was a sub… it’s really a good thing none of you heard her calling me ‘Master’ or screaming that out. Or even when I spanked her… the way she screams always makes me shiver… Yours is just absolutely breathtaking… I love it just as much.” He added, nuzzling her mane. “I can’t imagine what both of you screaming will do to me…”

“We’ll just have to find out, then, won’t we?” Lunalla said. “And… perhaps one day soon, you and I can dom her together.”

“All in good time… for now, just like I always will, I’m going to enjoy all the time I spend with you two, whether we’re having sex or not.” Theodore smiled, squeezing her close. “I love you, Lunalla.”

“I love you too, Theodore…” She replied, kissing his nose. “But don’t think I didn’t notice the happiness in your eyes when I mentioned domming. I”ll have you and Sister calling me Mistress before the month is out!”