Twin Trouble!

by Poppy8

Rating: teen
Tags: Drama, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Alternate Universe, Romance, Original Character, Slice of Life
Length: 4691

What happens when four twins fall in love? Let's find out!

Crepe and Binkey have always thought they'd never fall in love; after all they we're the only ones who hadn't fallen for the trap. But they get snared when two new twins come to their boarding school and it causes drama and school rumors to spread like wildfire.

Published 2017-04-22 16:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2017-05-16 21:59:25 UTC

Two New Student's

Crepe and Binkey we're in cooking class. As the room was filled with pleasant smell of all different kinds of foods and treats. The floor was a shimmering pale orange while the walls were a light cream. The place was filled with kitchen supplies and appliances. Surrounding tables and the colts and fillies working. Especially from the table of Crepe and Binkey. Binkey was simply baking cupcakes. While Crepe was in full motion making a strawberry and ice cream crepe cake.

"Crepe?" Binkey said as he put his cupcakes in the stove,

"Yeah?" Crepe responded as he put the fifth layer of ice cream and strawberries on.

"Do you think we should start date or something?" Binkey said as his face burned red, Crepe raised an eyebrow.

"Sorry bro but I don't like you that way." Crepe teased and Binkey blushed redder,

"Not funny, I mean should we start dating fillies." Binkey said with a cold and slightly annoyed voice. Crepe smiled,

"Naw none of the fillies here really pop out to me anyway. Plus they'd probably not wanna date a guy who can cook better than them and a guy who still likes you-know-what." Crepe said lowering his volume slightly. Binkey blushed redder,

"I know but I just wonder maybe there is a special somepony out there for us." Binkey said as he checked his cupcakes and Crepe poured on another layer of the crêpe mixture. The teacher got up from her desk and walked towards Crepe and Binkey. Just as Binkey pulled out his finished cupcakes and Crepe finished cooking the last layer of the crêpe batter. The teacher was a unicorn with pink hair and green stripes in it. Her coat was sliver and her cutiemark was a chief hat, her eye's we're a peppermint red. Binkey and Crepe put their confections on the table as they turned to face the teacher.

"Nice work Binkey. And Crepe once again you go passed my expectations. With your knowledge and creativity on French backed goods!" The teacher said,

"But I need you two to go pick up two new student's they are very delicate so you two need to be careful. Can you do that?" The teacher asked. Binkey nodded as Crepe said,

"Of course Mrs.Palimac!" Mrs.Palimac smiled.

"Good they're down at the office and remember be careful." Mrs.Palimac said as Crepe and Binkey opened the door and they left the room,

"What do you think she ment by "delicate"?" Binkey asked his brother,

"I don't know but she probably means their shy or something or maybe their crippled." Crepe said. Binkey glared at him,

"Crepe the nice way to say it is physically disabled." Binkey said.

"Yes but the appropriate term is crippled." Crepe said glaring back. Binkey rolled his eye's as they stopped by the school office door. Crepe opened it and let his brother walk through. Crepe then walked through himself and Crepe was shocked when he saw his brother. Binkey's ears we're down as his eye lids lazily covered half of his eye's. His face was flushed red and he had a small yet goofy smile on his face,

"Bro! You okay!?" Crepe said but his brother gave no response he followed his brother's gaze. And Crepe felt as if his heart had been hit by Cupid's arrow. For what stood, or should I say flew, in front of them we're two breezies. The first breezie had a short but a hot sauce red mane whole her tail was long and flowing. Her body was cinnamon and her antenna we're stubby and short just barely poking out of her hair. Her wings we're long and pointed as they had blended stripes of green and orange. Her eye's shimmered gold as she wore an apprehensive look. The second breezie had a short mane as well with a greenish-yellow slightly puffy mane and tail. Her tail as well was long and had a small curl at the end. Her anttene we're long as they twitched independently of each other. Her body was a relaxing turquoise and her eye's we're a bright pacific blue. Her wing's we're giant (for a breezie) as it shimmered through every shade of known green. The cinnamon one came over and slapped Crepe and Binkey,

"Are you bozos gonna keep staring or are you gonna escort us to class!?" The cinnamon one spoke as her voice betrayed a German accent. Crepe looked shocked and was about to retort back but, surprisingly, enough Binkey spoke up.

"So-Sorry and yeah we're talking you to Culturally Cooking! Mrs....." Binkey said and the cinnamon breezie rolled her eye's,

"I'm Spice and my sister Serenity." Spice said as Serenity waved shyly. Both Crepe and Binkey smiled again,

"Such a beautiful name for a majestic creature." Crepe muttered,

"What was that!?" Spice demanded.

"N-Nothing." Crepe said as he tried to look at Spice rather then Serenity. Serenity pulled at her sister's tail,

"I apologize for her behavior she just is a bit on edge being around you giant's." Serenity said with a hint of Swedish in her voice.

"No I'm not just get us to class and stop looking in our direction!" Spice ordered and Binkey and Crepe nodded as they opened the door. And let Spice and Serenity fly through the door. As Crepe and Binkey walked down the halls they couldn't help but stare at Spice and Serenity.

"They are so cute." Binkey whispered,

"I know right?" Crepe said as him and his brother shared goo-goo eyed stares.

Landed One

Serenity and Spice we're now in cooking class as they tried to make a stuffed shell (for those who don't know what a stuffed shell is it's a huge pasta noodle wrapped up in a shell-like shape stuffed with cheese and has spaghetti sauce in or on it.) Crepe tried to focus on idea's that involved Crepe's but he couldn't stop staring at Serenity. Binkey half-heartedly frosted his cupcakes while quickly glanced at Spice from time to time; not wanting to get caught by Spice. Mrs. Palimac watched with both curiosity and concern this was not something she had ever seen before. Serenity looked back at Crepe and giggled softly, she waved and smiled bigger as Crepe became flustered. Spice pulled Serenity's attention back to their project and glared at Binkey and Crepe. Crepe glared back while Binkey blushed and gave a sheepish smile. Spice's glare softened a bit and she turned back to her work. Finally the bell rang and the kid's turned in what they had done and left the classroom. Binkey and Crepe walked dreamly to the colts dorm they had never felt this way before. They felt like they we're floating on air and had a fuzzy warm feeling in their chest.

"There so amazing." Crepe said,

"I know" Binkey said.

"There adorable." Crepe said as a his eye's shimmered,

"I know." Binkey said as his blush reddened even more.

"There way out of our league." Crepe said as his ears flattened and he felt shame, Binkey sighed as he bowed his head.

"I know." Binkey said as they walked down the halls of the colts dorm, they then turned to their room door and walked through. Binkey and Crepe sat on their shared bunk beds and pulled their chatties out. They lightly tapped the screen and went to their group chat with their friend's.

Bi: Hi guy's

C: Hey

FP: Hey! There are the two brother's joined at the hip!

B: You seem to be in a good mood.

SD: Come on spill B.F.F! What's up?

FP: Yep! My teacher showed the other teachers the hairstyle I had done on her and now everyone at school is booking me and paying me for new looks for them!:pinkiehappy:

T: Great! Oh and Bumper how's that chattie for Citrus coming?

B: You go my sexy stylist! And yeah I'm almost done! But.....what's her mark again?

BB: It's three music notes surrounded by small heart's.

M: So how's school life going for everypony?

BB: Well my brother's ego has rised to new levels! And I've never been prouder!

SD: My Timidthy has confidence!?:pinkiegasp:

FP: Somepony call Pinkie we need to celebrate!

B: Awesome!

T: Guy's it's no bid deal plus I'm still below average so let's not get carried away.:twilightblush:

FP: Wait.......Binkey, Crepe why have you guy's been so quiet?

Bi:......no reason.......

C: Yeah......

M: Sure and I'm a breezie.

T: What you guy's not telling us?

Bi: ......Nothing.

C: .....Nothing.

T: Why say nothing when there's something?

C: Because it's nothing!

Bi: Yeah!

T: Is it a student?

C: Um....no?

Bi:.........

T: Aha!

SD: Oooooh! Is it a girl?

Bi:.....maybe......

B: Oh boy somepony get out the popcorn here comes drama!:rainbowkiss:

BB: What species?

Bi: Uh.....gotta go, bye!

C: Seeya!

The two then quickly turned their chatties off and put them away, Crepe and Binkey both had extreme blush on their faces. How was Timidthy so talented at making ponies admit stuff that they didn't want to talk about? Binkey sighed and jumped off his top bunk onto the floor,

"I'm gonna go clear my head." Binkey said and Crepe numbly nodded. As Binkey left the room, Binkey walked down the dorm halls. Out of the dorm and around the campus he needed to figure out what he was going to do. Binkey stopped as he saw underneath a blossom tree, he sighed again.

"What's up with you and your brother?" said a familiar voice, Binkey blushed and looked up to see Spice was in tree.

"What am I speaking Spanish? Why are you and your brother acting so weird?" Spice repeated clearly agitated, Binkey blushed redder as he lowered his gaze to his front hooves.

"It's just we find you.........attractive! I-I mean.........my brother finds your sister attractive! I-I mean........sweet Celestia what's wrong with me!" Binkey said as his face grew redder. Spice laughed, Binkey blushed redder,

"Y-Your a doof!" Spice said through laughs. Binkey wanted to bury his face into the ground, Spice flew down and landed on Binkey's nose.

"And I like that in a colt. Listen I trust ya seventy-five percent and that's saying a lot for me. How about you meet me here tomorrow and we can chat a bit?" Spice said as Binkey blushed redder,

"Su-Su-Sure." Binkey said. Spice smiled and flew off Binkey's nose and kissed him on the tip of his nose.

"Seeya." Spice said as she flew off, Binkey smiled and cheered as he jumped up and down. He had gotten himself a date. Spice smiled as she flew off she didn't want to admit it be she had found Binkey cute when they first met. But she didn't like that Crepe was in love with her sister she wanted to protect her sister at all cost. No matter what got in her way. Meanwhile Serenity sat in her and her sister's dorm room, she sat on the top matress of her bed. Her face was flushed red, why was just the mere image of Crepe making her act do silly?

A Wonderfully Awful Idea

Crepe berried his face into a pillow he felt so ashamed for even hoping that Serenity would be interested in him. Not to mention he hated Spice and her attitude, 'What makes that girl think she can act so crummy. She calls us morons, orders us not to look at her and her beautiful sister. And what makes it worse is that my brother has a crush on her! What's Spice's reaction gonna be when he finds out about my brother's mark and his obsession? Laugh? Snort? And mock him? Not only would he be heartbroken but he might give up on his obsession and destiny forever!' Crepe thought just before the door opened and his brother came in sporting the biggest smile he'd ever seen. Binkey pulled out one of his blankies and hugged it, Crepe shut the door hoping nopony saw his brother.

"Dude! What's up?" Crepe asked, 'He's never this careless.' Binkey blushed slightly but he just couldn't stop smiling.

"I got a date! Spice asked me out! After she called me a doof but I'll take it!" Binkey said with unnatural amounts of enthusiasm in his voice at least for him, Crepe looked dumbfounded Spice seemed so.......aggressive before.

"Great brother! Make sure you aim to impress!" Crepe said but he didn't mean it call him crazy but he had a bad feeling in his chest. 'Spice has to be up to something.' Crepe thought as his brother started going through all of his formal attire, meanwhile Spice had just entered her shared dorm room with her sister. Serenity looked at her sister who was sporting a victorious yet intimidating smile.

"I got Binkey to take me on a date." Spice said simply, Serenity's eye's widened and her mouth gaped open.

"Y-You asked him!? That's great! Your finally breaking out of your shell and-" Serenity said but she was cut off as her sister started laughing,

"No way! You believe I would date that colt for real! Have you see his cutiemak? And his name is ridiculous! And his brother is just as worse! I'm only dating him to get information off of him and his low life of a brother! I don't trust him or Crepe! And once I've run Binkey dry I'll dump him and use the secrets to my advantage!" Spice said getting over her laughing fit, Serenity was shocked how could her sister be so cold-hearted by messing with somepony's emotions that way.

"B......But he loves you! You can't!" Serenity said,

"I can if it mean protecting you from those creeps then I'll do anything." Spice said with a surprisingly sweet tone. Serenity blushed and smiled slightly she knew her sister could get over-protective.

"Now come on sis let's go get some ice cream." Spice said as she flew out of their dorm window, for a moment Serenity hesitated maybe she should go tell Binkey or maybe even Crepe of her sister's plan. But as she shook the idea out of her head as she decided maybe not engage until it was necessary.
Binkey was nervous as he sat under the blossom tree yesterday he wanted more than anything to date Spice now he was thinking of running away and berring himself in a hole forever. He was actually got get up and do exactly that until Spice's voice made his crumple under him.

"Hey Bink are you ready for our date?" Spice said as she flew through the blossoms,

"Y-Y-Yeah! M-More then anything!" Binkey said before he could stop himself. He covered his mouth as he face turned red, Spice snorted as she landed on Binkey's flank and slapped it. Causing Binkey to flinch and blush redder,

"Now tell me how did you get your mark?" Spice said and Binkey blushed even redder. As his mouth trembled and he felt the word's tumbling out faster then his mind could keep up. Once Spice was done listening to Binkey's story she kissed him and said she had to leave. Binkey numbly nodded as she flew away and she made her way back to her and her sister's dorm. She then shut the door and started laughing.

"A colt obsessed with baby stuff! I hit gold and I just started!" Spice said as she realized her sister wasn't in the room, she then saw a note on the desk that read:

Hey Spice. I went to visit Crepe, I know you don't want me too but I at least want to be friendly. Don't worry I won't tell Crepe about your plan as long as you don't take it too far . I'll seeya later.

XOXO,

Serenity

Spice then smiled her sister's note had given her an idea, she smiled evilly as she grabbed a camera and flew back out the window......towards Crepe and Binkey's dorm window. Meanwhile Crepe and Serenity had left the brother's dorm room and headed their own separate ways. Leaving Binkey alone in his extremely ecstatic state. Binkey locked him and his brother's shared dorm door and pulled out one of his silk diapers. He slipped it on and pulled out one of his pacifiers. Binkey was so happy and his baby stuff only made his even more joyous, and as Binkey cheered happily from the pacifier in his mouth, Spice was by the window snapping pictures. Spice held back her laughter as she found it both hilarious and adorable. For some reason Spice felt a pang of guilt, she wasn't supposed to be seeing this. But she shook it off she had to stick to her plan. Spice then flew off back to her dorm ready to secretly admire the pictures some more and to engage step two.

A Secret Blown

Spice had waited until midnight to get step two of her plan started. As she flew to the newsroom in the school to submit the pictures. The room an inky black and it was filled with papers and pictures for the school paper. And a small blue tray layed on the only desk in the room. Spice sat on the rim of the tray and stared at the photos as her face heated up again. She found Binkey adorable already. And this picture was making him look like the cutest creature in the world. She looked back to the tray as she felt another pain of guilt; why was she feeling like this. Spice then heard hoof steps coming towards her. And before she could turn around she felt something hit her side and she slammed into the wall. Spice's vision swam as she saw Crepe with a furious expression; holding a fly swatter.

"What? Are? You? Doing? HERE!?" Crepe said through closed teeth, as his eye's landed on the pictures that had fallen. His eye's widened in disgust and horror; then his eye's narrowed,

"I knew you we're using him just to humiliate him in the end. You are a sick, sick creäture." Crepe said his voice barely a whisper.

"I....I...." Spice said as she struggled to speak,

"I......I....WHAT? What can you possibly say that's gonna change what ya did! You snuck into our room, took incriminating pictures of Binkey. And you we're going to put them in the tray and offer them to the school paper." Crepe said his anger growing,

"But.....I love him!" Spice said. Crepe laughed,

"If you loved him you wouldn't be doing this! If you loved him you wouldn't have invaded his privacy! If you loved him you would feel some sort of guilt for what your about to commit! But you don't! Y-You know what you are? Y-Your a narcissist!" Crepe screamed. Spice paled,

"No I'm not! I did it to protect my sister! You giants don't know what it's like to be small! I did it to make sure no one would mess with us!" Spice said. And Crepe and Spice stared at each other. Both huffing from their screaming and aggravation.

"Okay fine I won't tell him but you have to promise not to try anything like this again." Crepe said as he resisted the urge to grind his teeth,

"I-I promise. But just know I do love him." Spice said; he voice quivering as she flew away. Crepe sighed as his anger disappeared, strangely enough he somewhat believed her. And Crepe walked off. The next morning the school was buzzing. As it was the weekend and colts and fillies alike we're exploring the campus. But that wasn't the reason, Serenity and Spice we're sleeping soundly. But we're woken up with loud banging at their dorm door. Serenity fell out of bed while Spice groaned. As the door suddenly burst open with a frantic looking Crepe at the door.

"Oh Celestia you won't believe this!" Creep said,

"What I don't believe is you waking us up before eight a.m.!" Spice snapped at him. Serenity sighed,

"What is it?" She said getting herself up. Crepe pulled out a newspaper and threw it on the floor. And what the two sisters saw made their blood run cold, the newspaper dead line read:

DIAPER LOVER ON CAMPUS!

And it had a picture of Binkey on the cover wearing on of his silk diapers. Serenity's face turned red at she let out a weak gasp. Spice looked ready to pass out,

"How!? You stopped me! I left! I didn't submit them or write an article!" Spice said. Crepe blushed and smiled sheepishly,

"I may have forgotten to take the pictures with me." Crepe said as guilt and shame was written all over his face. Spice smacked her forehead while Serenity flew up and hugged Crepe,

"It's okay. I mean how many ponies read the school paper?" Serenity said and Crepe pointed out the door as every filly had a newspaper and was talking about it.

"My bro is ruined and when he finds out he's gonna explode." Crepe said,

"You mean he doesn't know?" Spice said slightly amazed.

"No he's sleeping. I always wake up earlier than him." Crepe said,

"Then shouldn't we be the one's to deliver the news?" Serenity said and Spice and Crepe nodded. They knew it was for the best. They walked through the campus and made their way into Binkey and Crepe's dorm room just in time to see Binkey wake up.

"Oh hey guy's what's up?" Binkey said just before he yawned, Spice flew over to him and held his left hoof in her own. Crepe bit his lip as Serenity landed on his head and gave him a reassuring smile. Binkey began to feel nervous something was off he could feel it.

"Dude, I need you to know your life isn't over because of this. In fact you can share this experience with Timidthy! But......something leaked out.....and.....well.....this happened." Crepe said as he pulled out the newspaper, Binkey's mouth gapped open as he paled. His eye's began to water as his cheeks turned red. Everypony covered their ears as he burst into tears and screamed.

"NOOOOOOOOOO!" After Binkey finished screaming he hid himself under the covers. Spice patted him on the back feeling extreme guilt. And Crepe hugged his brother for comfort while Serenity stroked his mane. Knowing he needed some sort of comfort.

Running From Yourself

Author's Note

Sorry for not updating lately but life really gets in the way sometimes but I'd like to point out this chapter gets a little emotional.

Running From Yourself

Binkey was sucking on one of his pacifiers as his mind was in panic, how!? How could his secret obsession get out!? He'd have to move in order to escape the torment! As Binkey was trying (and failing) to calm himself. Spice stroked the left side of his cutiemark.

Remembering this flustered but calmed him. Crepe was investigating outside to see if this really was as bad as they all thought. While Serenity sat on Crepe's bed waiting anxiously for his return. Binkey finally took the pacifier out of his mouth as he steadied his breathing.

"You okay?" Spice said,

"I-I think so." Binkey said.

"Your sure?" Spice said as she saw Binkey's lip was trembling,

"NO! I've never felt more violated and humiliated!" Binkey said as tears fell from his eye's. Spice kissed Binkey and he hugged her gently. Finally the door opened and a red blur ran in making sure to slam the door behind him. Crepe was taking in deep breaths as he slid against the door.

"Well!?" Everypony said at once,

"Brother I'm only saying this because I would hate to lie to you and I love you. But......everypony is making jokes, giggling, snickering. Planning pranks and insulting yet witty comebacks to throw at you when you leave this room. So......basically your reputation is in....shambles." Crepe said bluntly as he walked over to his brother and took Spice away from him. Expecting the incoming flood. Binkey's body turned red as he burst into tears, Spice slapped Crepe.

"You couldn't have sugar-coated it a little?" Crepe shook his head,

"It's for the best." Serenity landed on his forehead staring sympathetically at Binkey. Thing's we're going to get a little more difficult.

For the next few day's Binkey never left his room, didn't eat or drink, nor did he sleep. The who school knew about his secret, to him his life was as good as done. Crepe would often come in to hug Binkey tightly, he would do his homework and try to get him to eat something.

But.....nothing worked.

Spice would kiss him every chance she got to get some emotion other than shame and despair to light up in him. And Serenity would try to coax him to leave the room.

But he never left.

It was putting all three of them into bad moods. Crepe was worried about his brother. Spice was almost as depressed as Binkey. Feeling guilt for inadvertently making this happen. And Serenity felt so much stress and weight on her trying to figure out how to cheer up her sister and Crepe.

Finally on the sixth day Crepe grabbed his chattie and walked to Serenity and Spice's room. He shut the door and turned on his chattie, he noticed he'd gotten a friend request from Citrus and accepted. Along with adding her to his contacts. He then set up a video chat with all of them no sooner the screen split up into seven, each of his friends (and Citrus) in a box. Spice and Serenity got the message and flew down onto Crepe's head. Everypony immediately noticed the sorrow in Crepe (and the new guest's) eye's.

"What's wrong?" Timidthy asked with concern lining his voice. He sighed and told everypony the whole story. After they all heard the story they we're stunned. Finally Bumper spoke,

"Dude. Get Binkey out of your school. He's gonna be ripped to shreds."

"And send him here. He's gonna need some series therapy." Timidthy added,

"Yeah! He could use some hugs and some calming music too." Citrus said her voice surprisingly soft.

"We'll fill in the holes later in our chat. And Bumper get a microscope and your tools out theses two need one." Blood Bones said and Bumper nodded, they then said their good byes and signed off. The three smiled slightly, Crepe grabbed his chattie and trotted to his room and Binkey's room. But as they got there and opened the door the room seemed to be a bit empty. Spice, Serenity and Crepe then looked around for any sign of intruder. But.....as they all looked around they noticed all of Binkey's baby supplies and toys we're missing. They all then tore away the bunched up blankets on Binkey's bed. And to their horror the broken colt wasn't there instead was a rolled up scroll, looked to be stained with tears. Spice landed on the letter and read it out loud. By the time she had finished, Crepe was in tears, Serenity had fainted, her heart had shattered.

And it was all her fault.

Dear whoever this may concern,

It's Binkey.

And I'm very sorry for doing this but I can't take it anymore! I had to escape from this prison I once loved! If I stepped on hoof out of my room the last remaining bits of my dignity would've evaporated into thin air. Crepe if you're all reading this just know that wherever I end up so will always be in your heart. Spice, I love you more than the world and thank you for being there for me. And.....Serenity we may not be joined at the hip but even your silence could speak volumes. And....finally tell my parents you raised my well.

From (as you should have known),

Binkey

Meanwhile as the sun set all over Eqestria. From miles away from the school you could see a blue figure carrying a makeshift bag. With tears in his eye's he kept looking forward and didn't look back. As his cutiemark shined as bright as the sun. And the moon rose over his young head.