Binding Sunset: Whips and Chains part 1

by PlagueDoctorPwny

Of Truth and Dare

Previous ChapterNext Chapter

“Pizza’s here!” Pinkie yelled as she kicked in the door to her room, startling everyone present in the process. She toddled into the room balancing six large pies on her head and toting four two liter bottles of assorted sodas under her arms. “So that’s two supremes, two meat lovers, one pineapple and olive for me, and a veggie delight for Sunset and Fluttershy to split!” she said, while spinning. In one fluid motion, everyone’s pizza accurately landed in front of them.

The group began to dig in as idle chatter filled the room like a happy crescendo. It was times like this when the Rainbooms felt their best. Good food, great company, and a happy atmosphere is what often brought their group together and was one of their favorite past times. Sadly these times were getting fewer and farther between as life and relationships began to take precedence over their formally weekly gatherings.

They all felt it. Soon the crunch time of senior year would be upon them; one final scramble to finish high school and to top it all off, going out with a bang. Pinkie had already promised the part to end all parties at the end of the school year. This turned chat to what everyone planned to do for their senior year. Everyone had different ideas of what they’d like to accomplish or what colleges they’d like to attend.

“I’m hoping I do well enough to get into a good sports program,” Rainbow said between bites of her meat lovers. “Several good schools are supposed to be sending recruiters this year. Both me and Lightning Dust are up for top spots on several teams.”

“Ah just wanna get into a good agriculture school, and follow that up with a business degree,” Applejack added. “Ah know Ah’m gonna be running the farm. Big Mac’s already said all he wants to do is manual labor. T’aint to interested in the running o’ things.”

Rarity sat up from where she was leaned against Twilight to reach for a piece of supreme. “I’m hoping to find a good design program somewhere near enough that I can still run the boutique. Fashion design may be my dream, but my boutique is still my love,” she said, to which Twilight gave her a pointed look. Rarity smiled sheepishly. “Next to you, of course. You know what I meant Darling,” she added.

Twilight smiled and blushed slightly. “I want to get a science fellowship at Canterlot University,” she said. “Maybe something in either theoretical or applied physics.”

“Looking at the next Bill Neigh?” Rainbow dash asked jokingly.

Twilight made a dismissive noise. “Please…That quack is hardly a real scientist. He just got lucky with his kids show and managed to polish up is celebrity a bit. He’s duped the uneducated masses into thinking he’s a real scientist.”

Rarity hugged her sideways while looking at Rainbow Dash. “That man is a bit of a sore spot to her,” she said admonishingly.

“So what about you Pinkie?” Twilight asked.

“Business management,” she said simply with eating her pizza from the outside in. She looked up and noticed that everyone was giving her a blank stare. “Whaaaaaat?”

“T-That’s…just surprising. I don’t think we were expecting you go to for something so…serious?” Sunset questioned while looking around at the other girls.

“Oooooh…” Pinkie said. “Well see as much as I like parties and planning them; there really isn’t that much of a future in it unless you get into big massive event planning. That’s just way to much trouble so I’m just going to run a catering business or maybe my own bakery.”

Again, everyone was giving her a blank stare. “Whaaaaaaat?” she asked.

It was Fluttershy’s turn to give an answer. “That’s…just surprisingly well thought out.”

“I’ll have you know that I take my future beyond the next five minutes very seriously,” Pinkie said turning her nose up at the group, cheese still hanging from her chin. This caused a loud round of laughter from the rest of the group.

“So what about you Fluttershy,” Twilight asked between giggles.

Fluttershy smiled and said “Veterinary School,” quietly. “I figured if I can do that, maybe I can take over the shelter one day, or even maybe open my own practice.”

Sunset hugged her and kissed her cheek. “I know you can do it.”

“What about you Sunny,” she asked, hugging her back.

Sunset shrugged. “I really don’t know. I haven’t thought about it; maybe something in science or computers.”

Rainbow Dash barked a laugh. “I guess I’d have a hard time deciding too if I was good at every damn thing!”

The rainbow haired menace’s laughing was cut off by a pillow to the face thrown by Fluttershy. “Do not make fun of my Sunny,” she said with a hint of playful malice.

Sunset laughed hard as she kissed Fluttershy. “Thank you for defending my honor, Sweetness.”

Fluttershy smiled and snuggled into Sunset’s arms. “By the way, everyone; Lyra and Bonbon put together a group of students from school who are…well…they have alternative sexualties. Anyways she invited Sunset and I to attend one of their meetings. I thought I’d bring it up here in case any of you’d like to go as well.”

“I-is it like a support group?” Twilight asked tentatively. “Alternative sexuality is a bit vague. I don’t want to go in thinking it’s meant for us to discuss how this affects our lives, and it turns out to be some fort of pseudo political function.”

Sunset blinked at her friend’s reaction. “You really hate politics don’t you, Twi?” she asked seriously.

Twilight gave something that almost passed for a sneer and responded, “Politics are the bane of free thinkers and true intellectuals.”

“Ok, steering clear of this topic now,” Sunset said. “It seemed like it was a support group. I doubt it’ll be political at all; just a place for us to safely discuss our relationships and maybe how to make them better.”

Rarity seemed to consider it. “It may be helpful to have ideas from outside our own circle,” she said then looked towards Twilight. “What do you think, love? Try it out once to see if we like it?”

“I…don’t suppose it could hurt to go just once,” she said, still sounding slightly uncertain. “Lyra and Bonbon are nice people. Who else is in it?”

“Octavia and Vinyl, and a few others from school,” Sunset answered while swiping the last piece of veggie delight. “CHS has a surprising number of people in same sex relationships it seems.”

“Heck, Ah’d be down to go if they don’t mind havin’ me,” Applejack responded, somewhat surprising everyone. “What? Ah may not be a lesbian, but Ah can be supportive.”

Pinkie just grinned. “And that is why we love you AJ.”

Applejack just tipped her hat.

“So should I tell Lyra to expect all of us?” Fluttershy asked as she pulled her cellphone out to send a text.

Rainbow Dash looked pensive as she sent a sideways and wanton look towards Pinkie Pie. If she was being honest with herself, and she was being just that more and more often lately; much to her chagrin, she was developing a crush on the pink party girl. It wasn’t just because Pinkie had helped her open the gateway of understanding to her own sexual nature. She had been kind, comforting, always willing to lend an ear, and always cheerful.

She had seen the true nature of Pinkie Pie; the girl beneath the surface of randomness, frosting, and confetti. That was the girl she desired a relationship with now. Rainbow was not as shallow as she used to be and it was this girl who opened her eyes to it. Now if she only had a way to put her thoughts and feelings into words.

“So uhh…” she false started. “Hey Pinks. You wanna go to Lyra’s thing?”

Pinkie looked at her. “Oh absolutletootly! Of course I’m going to be there for all my friends.” she said excitedly then going back to type on her phone. She missed the slightly dejected look on Rainbow’s face.

Applejack, however, did not. She stood and stretched. “Ah’m gon’ ta walk around for a bit to get my blood flowin’ back ta mah legs. Ya wanna come with me Rainbow?”

“Huh?” Rainbow asked, suddenly coming back from the boarders of distraction. “Oh…Yeah sure,” she said while getting up to follow Applejack out.

They got as far as the kitchen before Applejack put a hand on Rainbow’s should. “What’s bothering you, Sugarcube?”

Rainbow’s eyes went slightly wide. “N-nothing!” she said before she regained her composure. “I’m great; perfectly fine.”

Applejack titled her head sideways and gave her the panted ‘Y’all can’t hide nuthin’ from me.’ Look. “Come on, Sugarcube. Tell me what’s going on in that head o’ yers.”

Rainbow Dash let out the sigh of the long suffering and sat down at the kitchen table. She waited for Applejack to join her before she started. “I think…” she false started before correcting herself. “I KNOW I have a crush on Pinkie. She’s…helped me figure some things out about myself lately. Because of that help, she’s let me see the Pinkie that’s beneath the surface. She…I don’t know. I’m no good at feelings and stuff. She…I guess captivates me?” she asked as if looking for the right words.

Applejack just nodded while she listened. “Sounds like ya understand ya feelings better than ya can articulate. Ah’m no Princess Twilight or anythin’, but Ah think she’d tell ya to be honest with both yerself and Pinkie.”

“I know,” Rainbow said in a dramatic way that could rival Rarity and then let her forehead bang against the table. “Trust me…I know. I just don’t know how to tell her. How would you do it?”

“Ah’d just tell her.” Applejack said. “Element of honesty an’ all that.” she continued, waving a hand dismissively.

That was the answer Rainbow Dash expected. “I’ll…I’ll talk to her about it at some point.”

“Hey girls!” Sunset called from upstairs. “We’re about to start truth or dare!”

“Coming!” They both called back and headed up.

They entered the room to see everyone had changed into their pajamas, sitting in a circle on the floor. They set about changing their own clothes and joined them.

“So as host, I call right to go first!” Pinkie exclaimed. “Fluttershy! Truth or dare!”

Fluttershy looked nervously around the room before hiding behind her own hair. Sunset was about to speak up with the slightest sound came from her mistress. “Dare.”

Everyone looked surprised. “D-did you just pick dare?” Pinkie asked. “I had a question all lined up, but now…umm…” she paused for a few moments before she got a wicked grin. “I dare you to take your top off and let Sunset suck on them until it’s her turn.”

Fluttershy blushed for half a second before the realization that she was getting to indulge in her exhibitionist side set in. She smiled sexily at Sunset, who's mouth went suddenly dry. Slowly, Fluttershy lifted her top and let her large tits fall free with a bounce. “Come here, Sunnybunny,” she said with a beckoning finger. “Lay your head in my lap.”

“Yes, Miss Fluttershy,” Sunset said and did as she was told and Fluttershy lowered a nipple to her mouth. Sunset began to suck happily and in earnest, making Fluttershy trill.

The rest of the girls watched the display with various reactions ranging from humor to arousal.

“MMmmm…” Fluttershy moaned from Sunset’s attention. “Twilight, truth or dare.”

“D-dare,” she said nervously while adjusting her glasses and preparing herself for the worst. Granted this was Fluttershy asking. How bad could it be?

“I know Rarity has some sexy lingerie with her. Why don’t you dress up for us?” Fluttershy asked with a wicked smirk.

That bad. Twilight blushed hard. “I-I…umm…I don’t know. Heh.” She sputtered nervously before Rarity stepped in.

Rarity ran a finger along Twilight’s collar bone. “I think that’s a great idea, my little doll. Why don’t you play dress up for us? I have the perfect outfit,” she said seductively while leaning towards her, giving Twilight and enticing view of pale cleavage.

Twilight’s eyes glazed over like they usually did when she entered her subspace. “Yes, Seamstress,” she said quietly and stood in the middle of the circle.

Rarity stood up next to her and slowly began to undress her. “Doesn’t my doll have such perfect skin, girls?” she asked. She knew Twilight would be a little nervous with this, but chose to have some fun with it anyway.

Twilight felt goosebumps rise up on her skin as Rarity undressed her. Normally the fact that everyone was watching would cause her some mild panic, but right now she was just too horny to care. She wanted them all to look at her. She wanted to bare all to them.

Finally she was completely naked before all her friends. She could feel how wet she was. She was so close already. It would only take the slightest touch, but she couldn’t do it. Rarity wasn’t done dressing her yet.

Rarity came back with some articles and got to work. She dressed Twilight excruciatingly slow. She carefully slid the stockings into their proper places and hooked them to the garter belt. She decided to forgo the panties. Next came a sheer bra that hid practically nothing. Her work done, Rarity stood back to admire the fruits of her labor. She saw how wound up Twilight was and smiled. “You can cum now,” she whispered in Twilight’s ear.

Twilight’s whole body shuddered in a spontaneous orgasm as she sunk to her knees. “oooooohhh…fuck me sideways.”

Everyone laughed at Twilight’s choice in profanities. She looked up and blushed while giving her trademark sideway smile. “Sunset!” she said loudly. “Truth or dare!”

“Mmmph!” Sunset said without taking her mouth away from Fluttershy’s tit.

Fluttershy lifted the tit from her mouth. “Would you care to try that again, Sunnybunny?” she asked with a smile.

Sunset looked put out that she had her treat taken away. “Truth! Now hurry up and ask. I was enjoying myself.”

Twilight laughed at her friend and asked, “What’s the most erotic fantasy you’ve had?”

Sunset blinked for a moment before sighing. “All of you were there, including Princess Twilight. I had to pole dance for all of you.”

Fluttershy lowered her tit back to Sunset’s mouth. “Mmm…I wouldn’t mind seeing that,” she said happily.

“Me neither,” Twilight joined in with the rest of the girls giving their agreed affirmations. Sunset just shook her head and kept sucking happily.

Twilight got an idea and whispered it to Rarity. Rarity got a wide grin and ran over to the stereo and queued up a song. Twilight took off her glasses and shook her hair loose from his pony tail. She looked the very spitting image of the Princess of Friendship. “Sunset,” she said to get her friend’s attention.

Sunset looked over and suddenly went wide eyed. Twilight smirked. She knew her ploy was working. “Would you please dance for us, Sunset?”

Sunset sighed and sat up. “You know it’s scary how well you do that, right?” she asked as she got to her feet and moved to center of the room. She looked at Rarity who was standing next to the stereo and motioned for the girls to give her some space. “Ok Rarity. Hit my music.”

A deep bass began to thump and Sunset felt it. ‘Oh yeah, that’s the shit right there,’ she thought to herself as she began to move her body. True enough that she lacked a poll, but that didn’t mean she couldn’t shake her ass with the best of them. She spun, hands above her head and rolling her hips like a belly dancer before lowering her hands and hooking them into the waist band of her pants. She swayed her hips side to side as she lowered her pants, underwear along with them, to the floor.

She bent at the waist, giving all the girls a view of her slick quim. On her way back up, she grabbed the hem of her shirt and lifted it over her head in one fluid motion. Now completely bereft of clothing, she proceeded to dance to her hearts content. After a bit, she moved towards Fluttershy with an exaggerated hip sway that would’ve made Adagio Dazzle envious.

She stepped in front of Fluttershy with her legs spread and knees bent. She began to make grinding motions to Fluttershy’s face. Fluttershy surprised Sunset by grabbing the girl’s hips and forcing her tongue into the wet folds she was presented with. Sunset moaned as Fluttershy began to eat her out with gusto.

The other girls watched with marvel and wonder in their eyes at the erotic sight before them. Even Applejack would later admit she was turned on by this. Pinkie bit her bottom lip as she dribbled off her shorts to rub herself. Rainbow Dash saw and opportunity and climbed between Pinkie’s legs and started licking her slit.

The others, for their part, just watched and enjoyed the show that was being put on for them. Between Fluttershy and Rainbow’s oral efforts, there was a wave of lust that permeated the room that soon had all of them engaging in a bit of autoeroticism. Soon enough, one and all had achieved their orgasms and were sitting back enjoying a collective afterglow.


The party tapered off soon after that and everyone settled down to sleep…everyone except for Rainbow Dash. She was laid on the floor next to Pinkie’s bed, wide eyed, and counting the dots on the ceiling. She growled under her breath in frustration. ‘This isn’t solving anything,’ she thought to herself and sat up. She ran a hand through her rainbow locks and pulled her knees to her chest.

She peaked up over the edge of Pinkie’s bed to watch the sleeping girl. How Pinkie slept was just as chaotic as how she lived her life. Her limbs were splayed in every direction. Her hair was a mess of pink curls that seemed to argue with itself on what direction it wanted to lay. ‘She is chaos. She is a force of nature. She lives by her own rules. She…she practically bends reality to her will,’ Rainbow thought as she watched on with rapt attention. ‘I-I want that chaos. I want to live that to.’

She stood, clad only in her panties and a tank top, and walked from the room while completely unaware of the blue eyes watching her. She walked down to the kitchen and retrieved a bottle of water from the refrigerator at sat at the kitchen island, her thoughts still lying with the girl upstairs. Rainbow was so lost in her thoughts that she never realized she wasn’t alone anymore until the light from the fridge door being opened jerked her back to reality.

In front of her stood Maud Pie, along with her pet rock Boulder. “Boulder was hungry,” she said in her monotone voice while taking a seat across from Rainbow Dash. “So you have a crush on my sister.” Maud said, more stating a fact than asking a question.

Rainbow winced at what the elder Pie sister said. She just brought it out as easily as discussing the weather. “I-I…I do,” Rainbow said, wondering where Maud was going with this discussion.

Maud gave Rainbow a blank look, which was about as much emotion as she ever showed. “I like you Rainbow. I think you’d be good for my sister. That is…” Maud said, pausing.

“That is what?” Rainbow asked, suddenly nervous. I mean she had the approval of the normally unflappable Maud. Surely that much count for something.

“Pinkie has…trouble with relationships,” she said. “I’m sure you noticed that she’s never had a real romantic interest. Sure she’s had friends with benefits, but the occasional fuck buddy a true lover does not make.”

Rainbow thought back and realized that Maud was right. She had never known Pinkie to ever have a true significant other. “D-do you think…that means she won’t return my feelings?”

“Most likely not,” Maud deadpanned. “But you have a better chance than anyone. Pinkie has a skewed idea of what love is. I blame our parents for that. I don’t know if you noticed, but Pinkie is kind of the odd duck of this family.”

“I wouldn’t say she’s odd,” Rainbow said. “Eccentric sure, but that just adds to her charm to me. It’s hard to explain I suppose.”

Maud nodded and stood, walking to the door before she turned a fixed Rainbow dash with a hard glare and a furrowed brow. “Take your shot Rainbow Dash, but you better not hurt her,” she said and left the room.

Rainbow Dash felt, in that instant, that her life was truly in danger.


Pinkie sat up in her bed shortly after Rainbow had left the room. She had been getting and odd vibe from her lately, but was hard pressed to put her finger on it. It wasn’t anything bad, just odd. She stood up and made her way to the door and out into the hall. She saw Maud coming up stairs as she reached the landing.

“Your friend is in the kitchen,” Maud said as she passed, carrying Boulder on her shoulder and entered her bedroom.

Pinkie padded down stairs quietly and peaked into the kitchen to see Rainbow Dash with a slightly scared look on her face. “Everything ok, Dashie?” she asked.

Rainbow looked at her as her inner terror at Maud died down. “Y-yeh. I was just talking with your sister.

Pinkie sat down across from her and propped her head on her hand. “No, that’s not what I meant. You’ve been different the last few days. Do you want to talk about it?”

Rainbow’s nervousness increased greatly. “I-I…umm…well...” she false started. “It’s nothing really.”

Pinkie gave her a critical eye and leaned closer, presenting an enticing view of her cleavage. “Are you sure?” she asked in a quiet sing song voice.

Rainbow just sighed. How could she be so god damn cute? “Pinkie…I…oh fuck it. I have a crush on you and I want us to be a real couple, not just friends with benefits,” she said, feeling relief then a stomach tightening terror as Pinkie just blinked and sat back, her hair going slightly limp.

Pinkie just shook her head and slightly frowned. “I was worried about this,” she said quietly. She looked up at Rainbow with sad eyes. “I’m sorry Rainbow. I just don’t have those types of feelings.”

Rainbow felt her stomach sank. She felt herself go slightly limp in her chair as heavy emotions crashed down on her. Her eyes started to sting as she searched for words to say.

“It’s not just you,” Pinkie continued. “I really have no desire to have a romantic relationship with anyone. Don’t get me wrong Dashie. I love you, just like I love all you girls.”

Rainbow fought back her tears. At least she knew where she stood now. She got up and walked around the table and pulled Pinkie into a hug. “This…changes nothing.”

Pinkie hugged her back and kissed her cheek. “I’m glad to hear you say that. I don’t want to lose you as a friend,” she said, pushing back her own tears. “Thank you for being honest with me, Rainbow.”

Rainbow just pulled back and gave her a sad smile. “That’s my line.”


Sunset woke up when she felt Fluttershy shift next to her. They had decided to zip there sleeping bags together to make one large bag. She rolled over to watch her girlfriend sleep for a bit. She was surprised to see Fluttershy awake herself. “Shy, baby. Everything ok?” she asked.

“Hmm? Oh yes. I was just watching you sleep. That’s not weird is it?” she asked nervously, giving Sunset a meek look.

Sunset chuckled and kissed her forehead. “If it were anyone else, yes. From you, it’s just sweet.”

Fluttershy blushed sweetly and nestled her face against Sunset’s shoulder. “I love you, Sunset,” she whispered.

Sunset gasped when she heard those words and looked down at Fluttershy. She smiled widely and felt her heart beat quicken. “I love you too, my Fluttershy.”


Author's Note

Sorry this took longer than usual, and that its shorter than usual. I started at work and its been a hard transition. I went from pretty much sitting around all day doing not much to being on my feet walking for almost 8 hours straight. Pain doesn't describe it.

Only a couple of more chapters left and I can call my first story to a close. I have plans for at least 2 sequels in the works that will focus on other couples. So stay tuned for more.

If you like this sort of thing, then consider joining Sanctum Dominatum. Its a new group that is focused on stories that contain similar themes and growing the community. Just remember 18+ please.

Next Chapter