Flutters, Would You Go On A Date?

by PixelMoon

Rating: everyone
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance, Fluttershy, Pinkie Pie, Slice of Life, Drama
Length: 2822

Pinkie Pie has been having weird feelings. And they point to a certain yellow Pegasus.

Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy have been great friends for a while now. When they are alone, it gets awkward. Pinkie Pie realizes that she may like Fluttershy. She has to find a way to win her heart.

She manages to convince Fluttershy to go on a date with her. But will she realize that she may like Pinkie Pie too?

Published 2017-06-28 06:00:06 UTC
Last updated 2017-06-28 06:00:06 UTC

The First Date

Flutters, Would You Go On A Date? written by Pinkie_Pie_

This is just for fun.

*Written from Pinkie Pie's perspective*

I looked at my best friend. Her yellow coat, pink mane, teal irises, everything about this pony was beautiful. We were hanging out at a party and I 'somehow' snatched her away and to my room above where the party was held, Sugarcube Corner.

"Uh, Pinkie? Where are we going?" Fluttershy whispered in a scared tone.

"Don't ya worry ya little head Flutters, I'm just taking you and me to my room silly!" I replied in my usual tone.

"But wh- wha- what about t- the party?" She stammered.

"Oh I have much bigger plans for us!!!!" I said hopping into my room.

Fluttershy opened her eyes to Gummy staring at her with an expression that said 'what up Flutters'. I just knew it. Nopony else knew, but maybe Fluttershy did.

"Do ya know what he's saying?" I asked. "Do ya, do ya, do ya????"

"Um.... Did he say 'what up Fluttershy'?" She whispered in a tone that should be MUCH louder.

"Close enough!"

"Um, what?"

"Do you want to know why I brought you up here?" I randomly asked.

"Uh, yes I kind of do."

"Well, I brought you up here to ask if you wanted to go on a date." I causally said.

"Um... I'm more into stallions...... No offense Pinkie, but I don't think so....."

As soon as that was said my ears dropped. I started crying and screaming.

"SHE DOESN'T LIKE ME!" I cried.

Fluttershy, who was still up there for some reason, looked sad. She.... Seemed to have been thinking. I only knew that because of what was said next.

"Um never mind! I will. For you if it makes you happy." Flutters whispered.

My mane popped back up. Oh, did I forget to tell you that it straightened? Oops! Silly me. I'll replay it for you and add it! Okay, out of my train of thought......

"Really????!!!!!!" I gasped, my eyes twinkling. At least I think. I can't see myself through Flutters. Unless......

"Hey Fluttershy, can I look into your eyes?" I casually asked like it was nothing. Which it wasn't.

"Um, why?"

"'Cause I wanna look to see if my eyes are twinkling of course!"

"Um... Go ahead?" She shrugged.

I looked at my eyes through her eyes. They. Were. SPARKLEY!!!!!

"So where do you do you want to go for our date?" I asked.

"Um, how about we go to my house?"

"Okie Dokie Lokie!"

"Day?" I asked.

"Um, the day after tomorrow please?"

"Okie dokie lokie!"

"Time?" I asked.

"Sunset?"

"Ooh! Perfect choice Flutters!"

"I guess I'll see you then Pinkie." Fluttershy said as she walked out of my room.

I hopped down the streets of Ponyville. I was careful to not ruin my gift I made for my Flutter bear. Hehe, that sounds funny.

I got to her house at exactly sunset, which would make her so happy. I knocked on her door, then she answered it.

"Hi ya Flutters! I got this gift for you!" I said right away, shoving her gift in her house.

"Um, thank you Pinkie. Would you like to come in?" She offered.

I nodded and walked into her house. It had a small table in the middle with candles on it. Her animals were helping with everything and making the food.

"Wowie! You sure got everything ready!" I exclaimed, making her blush.

"T-thank you Pinkie."

Her bunny, Angel hopped into the room and stomped his paw on the floor. Fluttershy leaned down and Angel made a whole bunch of motions.

"Oh! Um, of course."

She sat up when Angel hopped away. "Um, Pinkie, he said that he would like us to take our seats." She explained.

"Of course!!" I said, hopping to the table. "Oopsie! I almost forgot to do something!"

I went over to Fluttershy's chair and pulled it out. I bowed goofily. "There you go, Princess Fluttershy!"

She blushed and sat down. "Thank you, Pinkie."

I beamed my regular smile. She smiled shyly, as usual.

I couldn't help but notice what she was wearing. She had a beautiful light green dress on. It wasn't very heavy, just one layer. But it was clearly made by Rarity.

Her mane was in a light bun. Some of Fluttershy's front locks of hair were out of the bun. Around the bun was a braid.

"Um Pinkie?"

"Wha? Oh hi! Sorry, I was, you know, staring at your outfit. I couldn't help but notice." I said, snapping from my daze.

"Oh, it's okay. You weren't moving so I was worrying. And I was totally about to, um, panic." She whispered.

"Classic Flutters." I giggled.

There was an awkward silence. I hate it when that happens. I just didn't know what to say! And that NEVER happens!

Angel hopped in. Thank goodness he broke the silence! Well, kind of. We were focused on him.

"Oh! Um, Pinkie? Dinner is ready." Fluttershy interpreted from the motions Angel was giving her.

"Okie dokie lokie!"

Trays of food were brought out from the kitchen. My eyes widened, I mean like, HOW IN EQUESTRIA DO ANIMALS MAKE THAT?! It's crazy!

The main course, or at least that was what I was told it was called, was spaghetti.

"Yum!" I said when I got my plate.

Fluttershy blushed. "I hope you like it."

We sat in silence for awhile. Curse you silence!

"Pinkie?"

My ears perked up. "Yes?" I said through a mouthful of spaghetti.

"You know when you first asked me on a date how I said no?" I nodded. "Well, a part of the reason I changed my mind is because I decided you could make it interesting. I, um, don't really feel like that is happening, if you don't mind me saying, that is." She said.

My eyes got watery. I realized she was right. We needed some confetti! Balloons! Streamers! Good thing I always bring something.....

"You're right! Good thing I always bring.... MY PARTY CANNON!!!!" I shouted, pulling my cannon out of nowhere.

Confetti, streamers and balloons sprayed everywhere. Tons of confetti and streamers landed on my date. My date. I am on a date with Fluttershy!

Wait. I've seen that look before. Her eyes showed disappointment. I need to do something bigger. And I don't even know what. Oh no, oh no, oh no!!! I can't fail! I want her! I need her!

"I'm sorry Fluttershy. I can clean it up!" I said, pressing a button on my cannon. All of the party supplies that came out of the cannon got sucked back in it.

"I.... I didn't even know that could clean up too." Fluttershy deadpanned. She was wide eyed.

"Yeah..! Now, I need to give you a better first date. How about we go somewhere else?" I asked.

"Oh dear... It's just that my animals worked very hard on all of this. I don~"

"Don't worry! I'm sure we can eat their food later! Besides, now they have breakfast, lunch, and dinner for three days!" I interrupted.

She giggled. I made her giggle! Yay!!

"Now come on!" I said, dragging her out of her house.

We trotted to the spa. What better way to restart a date than going to a relaxing place!?

"Oh dear! Are you sure that this is a good idea?" Fluttershy worried.

"Trust me! I know what I am doing!" I insured her. Hopefully.

We walked through the door. Aloe looked up and gasped.

"Two late comers? This has never happened!" She exclaimed. "Oh. Are you on a, uh, date?" She added when Aloe saw our formal wear.

I nodded. Aloe rushed us into her 'best treatment'.

A few minutes later, we were getting our hooves done.

Then we had a million other treatments.

When we were in the hot tub, Fluttershy spoke up again.

"Uh Pinkie? I just want to apologize for earlier. I guess I can't always expect ponies to do things. This has been a great, relaxing date so far. Thank you very much."

"Aww it was nothing. And we aren't done yet! I have more planned for us two!" I beamed from ear to ear.

"Oh okay. I hope it is has great as this."

"And Fluttershy, I know this is a weird place to go for a date." I said, rubbing the back of my mane.

"It's quite alright. We are unusual friends after all." She whispered giggled.

We finished our trip to the spa and headed to the next place. We trotted to the Ponyville restuarunt. Ponyville only has one romantic restaurant, which was the one we were heading to.

"Oh my! This is a wonderful place! I can't believe you're taking me here!" Fluttershy shouted at a whisper level.

"It is the only good one in Ponyville." I said.

We walked inside. I was surprised they were still open. It was a little after 8:30. Not a lot of places are still open. Or are they?

"Hello, misses. May I take you to your seats?" A waiter asked.

"Oh, um of course! If you don't mind, that is." Fluttershy whispered.

The waiter nodded and began walked to a special looking area.

"This is the area for those on, ahem, dates." He faked a cough to look between the two of us. Why is two mares on a date so weird?

"Thank you, waiter!" I said as politely as a pony like me could.

He nodded and left. We took our seats in the two chairs across from each other.

A mare waiter came a few minutes later. "Hello, my name is Cherry Spices, and I will be your waiter tonight. Are you ready to order?" Cherry grinned, holding a notepad in her magic.

"Oh yes! I would like your best spaghetti!" I answered immediately.

"Okay miss! And what would you like to drink?"

"Um... How about a punch?" I asked.

"Sure!"

"Okie dokie lokie!"

"And what would you like miss?" Cherry asked Fluttershy.

"Oh um. I would like spaghetti too, if it isn't too much trouble." She whispered, hiding behind what was still down of her mane.

"Okay. And your drink?"

"Tea please. Extra sugar." She said, a bit louder.

"Okay. Thank you misses! Your food should be done in fifteen minutes. Care to have some bread and butter? Or blueberry muffins, if we have some. I am not sure if miss Derpy has ate them all yet." Cherry offered.

"Some bread and butter would be nice. Right Pinkie?" Fluttershy asked.

"Absolutely!" I agreed.

Cherry left, and came back a minute later. "Here is your bread and butter, misses!" She said, levitating the basket over.

"Thank you!" I exclaimed before grabbing three slices of bread and butter and shoving them in my mouth.

Fluttershy giggled at me. "Oh Pinkie Pie. I love y~" she gasped and covered her mouth with her hoof.

"What?"

"Oh um, nothing. Please don't make me say it." She pleaded.

"Okay.... Here! Have a slice!" I offered, hoofing a slice of bread over to her hoof.

"Thank you, Pinkie."

We chewed our bread for a few minutes. I caught Flutters sneaking a peek at me. I don't know why, but I would rather not ask.

"So, what do you like doing? You know, besides taking care of animals." I asked, scaring the silence off .

"Hm?"

"What else do you do that's not animal related?"

"Oh! Um, I enjoy sketching a little." Fluttershy blushed.

"Cool! Can I see?" I asked.

"Um..."

"Please!" I pleaded.

"Okay, fine. If you really want me to." She gave in.

"Yay! Okay, how about this pose?" I asked, sitting on my hunches and making a face.

My hooves were up to my face, framing it. I had a huge smile on.

Fluttershy giggled. "Perfect.

She sketched me for a few minutes. Every now and then she would take a bite of her bread.

"And..... Done!" Fluttershy announced after thirteen minutes. She put down her quill and lifted her sketch book up to show me.

It had a almost perfect me on it. There was a few mishaps, but otherwise was perfect.

I noticed another pony in her sketch. She had a flowing mane, beautiful wings, and was next to me. She had a angelic smile on her face.

"Did you add yourself into the sketch?" I questioned.

"Yes. I felt like it needed it. I hope you don't mind that I changed your position though." She replied.

"I don't mind. This looks hundred times better." I said.

She blushed. I think she was going to say something else, but was interrupted.

"Here is your food, misses." Cherry came out of nowhere.

She laid a tea and punch on the table. Then she lifted up one plate of spaghetti.

"Um, excuse me, there is only one plate of spaghetti." Fluttershy pointed out.

"I'm sorry, it's just that when couples are on dates and order the same thing we like to let them share." Cherry explained.

"Oh, um, okay then." Fluttershy blushed.

Cherry left us on our own. I took a fork and started eating. Fluttershy did too a little after I did.

Eventually we each grabbed a noodle and put it our mouths. Flutters closed her eyes so I did the same. The next thing I know my lips are pressed against something.

My eyes shot open to see Fluttershy open hers too. We realized we were kissing. But for some reason, neither of us wanted to let go.

My tongue went into her mouth. I heard her gasp, but relaxed. She hooked her tongue onto mine.

Eventually, we let go of each other to breath. Fluttershy stared at me.

"Pinkie Pie." She said.

"Uh yeah?" I hoped for the best.

"I love you."

"What?"

"I said I love you. This night has been wonderful. I'm glad I agreed to go on this date. I realize you are the pony I want to be with." Fluttershy admitted.

I squeed. "Oh my gosh! Really?!"

"Yes Pinkie. Will you be my marefriend?" She asked.

"Yes!! Yes! Yes! Yes!!!!!" I shouted.

She giggled at my silliness.

We finished our dinner and headed out to a hill.

"Where are we going Pinkie?" Fluttershy asked for the thousandth time.

"I told you! You will know when you will know!" I said for the thousandth time.

"But I want to know now." She grumbled.

"Then luckily for you, we're here."

She looked up in time to see a shooting star. Her eyes lit up in amazement.

"How did you know this was tonight?" She asked, still looking up.

"I just knew, Flutters." I said.

Fluttershy wrapped her wings around me and laid back, tugging at me to fall back too. I landed on her, due to being in her wings' grasp. We stared up, just watching the stars and shooting stars. This was certainly the best. Night. Ever.

Afterwards

I trotted along side my marefriend. We were heading to Sugarcube Corner to tell our friends about our unexpected love story and how we were dating.

Our first date was a couple days ago. We had a second date last night, in which we decided to tell our friends.

"Pinkie Pie? Fluttershy? Darlings! What is the big announcement? And why do you look clos~ oh dear Celestia!" Rarity gasped.

"What is it now, Rares? Are you freaking out about Fluttershy's mane or something?" Rainbow asked, rolling her eyes at Rares.

I had the feeling that Rarity already knew what we were going to say. I didn't like the look on her face.

"What is is Rarity?" Twilight asked, trotting into my home.

"I.. I would rather not say." She put a fake smile on.

"If ya say so." Applejack said.

My friends all sat down at a table. Me and Flutters sat down a few seconds after.

"Now, girls, please don't hate us, or ~" I interrupted my marefriend.

"Or make a big deal." I added and then let her continue.

"About this. We are, well, Pinkie? A little help?" She asked.

"Oh yes! Well, we ~"

"Are dating." We finished together.

"I knew it!!!!" Rarity burst out.

"Well, that was, unexpected." Rainbow deadpanned.

"Indeed." Twilight agreed.

"But what do you think?" Fluttershy asked.

"Well," They gathered around in a group. "We all think it's marvelous." Rarity said, everypony nodding.

"Thank you! Thank you so much!" I said, hugging them.

"Why would you think we would hate you?" Twilight questioned.

"Classical Twily." Fluttershy said.

"I think I'm rubbing off on you!" I giggled.

"Maybe you are. Hey! Maybe you will make me louder!" Flutters exclaimed in her shy way.

We all laughed. Imagining a Pinkiefied Fluttershy was impossible.

"Who wants to get a treat and hang out?" Rainbow asked.

"Sure!"

"Of course!"

"Yeppie!"

"Okay."

We all headed to the kitchen to find the cupcakes.

The End