Timidthy had come to Ponyville, with his mother's permission. As a relaxing day to calm his frequently stressed nerves. He had come to Sugar Cube corner not to eat any sweets of course. But mostly because he knew the only thing that could stress him was the crowd's. But to his surprise the place was empty; Mr and Mrs. Cake werent even in the bakery.
"Hello Timidthy!" A cheerful voice said and Timidthy jumped almost wetting himself,
"Oh.....hi Pinkie." He said shyly greatful that he hadn't drank anything that day. Pinkie bounced in front of him with a chocolate cupcakes,
"I just made a new desert! Want it?" Pinkie said and Timidthy smiled as his magic wrapped around the cupcake.
"Tha-Thanks." He said before taking a few bites from his cupcake resisting the urge to stuff it into his mouth,
"Your Welcome!" Pinkie said as she watched the prince eat the last remains of his desert. "I'm glad you like my sweets Tim! When I first met you I was worried they had scared you for life!" Timidthy yawned as his eye's drooped,
"Um.....I...think.....I.....need....to....go....home." He said feeling fatigued. Pinkie's smile became unsettling as she said,
"Naw just take a little nap and everything will be fine." Timidthy passed out as he swore he could hear Pinkie giggling.
Timidthy woke up with a sharp pain in his forehead he groaned as his eye's tried to adjust to the dim light. He tried to move until he realized he couldn't. He tried to look down but realized his forehead was also strapped down. He moved his eye's and saw all on his hooves we're strapped down as well, Timidthy's breath quickened. He looked around the room and saw that pony intestines. And skulls we're scattered all over the place including a few hides. Timidthy started to cry as his body shook,
"Are you sure about this? If he's crying now then what is he going to do when we start?" A voice said and the prince's eye's snapped to see Derpy. Inkie, Minke, Blinkie, Pinkie, Apple Bloom, Babs, and Derpy walk down the basement stairs. Apple Bloom was carrying what looked to be a bucket of peanuts. Babs closed the door as they walked in front of Timidthy,
"Don't worry that just makes him more fun. He's been so sheltered and protected that there will be more of a reaction." Blinkie said calmly.
"I told you taking his horn would get him to wake up." Minke said and that sentence immediately registered in Timidthy's mind,
"M-My horn? Wha-What did you do to my horn?" He asked and he was sickened by how everypony started laughing. Finally they stopped and Babs said,
"We cut it off." Timidthy's eye's welled up with tears once more as his eye's we're also wide in disbelief. Apple Bloom giggled as she held out a broken green horn. Finally the flood gate's opebed for Timidthy and he started sobbing.
"My horn!!" He bellowed and Minkie snarled as she took the bucket, and said.
"Stop that! We havent even taken your cutiemarks and your already acting like it's the end of Eqestria!" Timidthy stopped as tears we're still pouring from his eye's. Everypony was surprised they couldn't believe that actually worked. The ex-alicorn's eye's flickered to Pinkie,
"Pinkie what's going on? Why'd you take my horn? What does she mean taken my marks? And why are you allowing this Pinkie? I thought you we're my friend." He said and everypony waited for Pinkie's response.
"Well Tiny Tim to answer your questions. Your gonna help us make cupcakes we took your horn so you wouldn't use magic to escape. I'm allowing this cause this is needed to be done and of course I'm your friend silly! This is why I'm doing this! You see I put a special ingredient in my cupcakes! Ponies! And I feed them to everypony in Ponyville! In fact the cupcake you ate was made in here just an hour ago!" She said and with each sentence Timidthy's face paled until it looked like he wanted to throw up. The group backed away not even getting a bucket for the prince. He vomited onto the ground as some of it landed on his stomach and in between his legs.
"Gross! For a member of royalty you certainly don't give ponies much warning!" Inkie exclaimed once Timidthy had run out of vial,
"I-I'm....sorry." He muttered. Timidthy looked at Apple Bloom his eye's filled with despair, "I-I....I just don't know how to handle this."
"Well don't worry Timidthy we'll make sure to give your cupcakes to Sweet Dreams! She'll love that you gave baking a chance." Derpy said, causing the ex-alicorn to cry.
"Let's get started!" Pinkie said as she went off to grab a scalpel,
"Please Pinkie don't do this. Think of mother, my brother, my fillyfriend and my friend's! When they realise I'm missing they'll worry!" Timidthy said. And everypony again laughed,
"Oh Timidthy! You're a riot! What so you think they're gonna do without evidence to your disappearance?" Apple Bloom said. Just as Pinkie came back with the scalpel and started to cut a circle around his left flank. Timidthy groaned in pain as he bit his lip and tried not to scream. Babs came over and started to cut a circle around his other flank soon after. Except she was much ruffer causing Timidthy to scream in pain.
"STOP SCREAMING! IF YOU WANT TO DO ANYTHING CRY! BUT YOUR VOICE MAKES YOUR SCREAMS INTOLERABLE! YOU LITTLE RAT!" Minke said, and Timidthy clamped his mouth shut, "In fact as punishment you get this." She said as she stuffed a hoof-full of peanuts in his mouth, Timidthy cried in alarm.
"Swallow it." Blinkie said, and the prince shook his head no his eye's having tears fall from his face.
"SWALLOW IT!" Minkie said and Timidthy did as he was told with a trembling tail. Finally Babs and Pinkie took the marks off him and he had to chock back a scream.
"That's better." Babs said, Timidthy groaned as he stomach started to gurgle. His face turned red,
"Did you guy's already feed him the nuts?" Pinkie said taking a gander at the prince.
"Yeah he wouldn't stop screaming so we gave him some." Derpy said before another gurgle came from Timidthy's stomach,
"Well then he's going to have an accident soon." Pinkie said with a giggle as Apple Bloom went to grab the hacksaw. Timidthy blushed a deep crimson,
"Please let me use the coltsroom." He wined he definitely didn't want to wet himself in front of girls. The group laughed again as Apple Bloom came back with the saw.
"Now it's time to cut your wing's off." She said and Timidthy started sobbing,
"Please don't! Please let me go!" He said and Apple Bloom chuckled as she stretched on of Timidthy's wings open. And placed the saw blade on it,
"No." She said calmly as she started to saw the wing off. Before Timidthy could stop himself. He screamed and Inkie stuffed a hoof-full of peanuts in his mouth again. He knew he had to swallow it so he did regretting every moment of it. Timidthy gritted his teeth as Apple Bloom cut through the bone and flesh.
"How can you do this?" He asked and Blinkie rolled her eye's and smirked,
"It's because we don't care about your life." She said. And Timidthy's stomach gurgled louder he winced wishing he had his horn to stop the pain. Apple Bloom came in front of him holding his left-wing and he started crying harder.
"Pinkie please! I can help you! I can make you all see why you're doing this! And we can put a stop to this!" Timidthy screamed he knew it would get him more peanuts but he didn't want to die. Pinkie looked into Timidthy's eye's. He looked into his former friend's eye's and his face paled when he saw what was inside.
"You can't fix what's broken!" Pinkie said as Timidthy began to shake, his mind was trying not to accept it but it knew he was going to die here.
"Pinkie-" The prince said before he felt his bladder release. He blushed like mad as he heard everypony laugh at him,
"Wow you're a bigger baby then I thought!" Babs said.
"Just kill me already." Timidthy whispered,
"Awww, but you still have your right-wing!" Pinkie cooed.
"Plus we have one more surprise for our little prince." Minkie said as Apple Bloom grabbed the hacksaw and moved to his right-wing. She has no problem cutting through it. As Timidthy clenched his teeth and closed his eyes again trying not to scream as tears of pain fell from his eye's. During this Inkie was pulling out a huge crate and pushed it in front of Timidthy. As the floor around him had a puddle of urine as Timidthy's right-wing came off. And the poor ex-alicorn was beginning to pass out from the pain and the emotional distress. Minkie ran over and grabbed two syringes. She injected Timidthy with the first one and he woke up immediately. She then injected the other one in a vain near the prince's stomach.
"What was that?" Timidthy said weakly,
"Just some numbing stuff so that when we do the harvest you'll stay awake. I have to admit you did much better than expected!" Pinkie said. And the ground waited for the numbing cream to take affect. It only took a few minutes as Apple Bloom grabbed an empty bucket and placed it beside the crate.
"Alright ready to see your surprise?" Babs said and Timidthy only stared broken-heartedly at the killers,
"Just show it me already. It can't be anything worse than what you've done to me." He said almost unemotionally. Pinkie giggled as she opened the crate and Timidthy felt his world shatter when he saw what was inside. It was a stuffed version of Sweet Dreams that was too perfectly crafted to be fake. Timidthy broke down crying and wailing,
"Yeah we lied. We had ended killing her and putting her ingredients in the cupcake. That. You. Ate." Babs said making sure the word's sank into Timidthy's brain,
"Please stop." He said just as Pinkie started to cut his stomach open. Timidthy would've asked Pinkie to stop to beg, and plead but he was I shock. He could hear Sweet Dreams's voice begging to be let go wondering where he was to protect her. Timidthy didn't even come back to reality when Pinkie was pulling out his organs.
"I think we broke him." Apple Bloom said, but she spoke too soon. As Timidthy whispered before his life flashed before his eyes.
"Please don't hurt anypony else. Let my death convince you all that this is wrong." And he went silent as his hearing started to sound as if he was underwater. But he swore he could hear as clear as day a voice say.
"Don't worry Timidthy you won't be hurting anymore." That sounded distinctly like Sweet Dreams and that was it. Timidthy's head went slack as his heart was removed and he was dead. Pinkie dropped the heart in the bucket along with the other organs,
"Come on everypony time to make some cupcakes!" She said as her and her group left the prince's corpse.