Broken Beyond Repair

by KillerChainsaw

Broken, But In The Best Way

Load Full StoryNext Chapter

Late evening was now slowly settling in as the town of Ponyville was quiet and peaceful, most of the houses only having one or two lights on still as Princess Twilight's castle was pretty much the same, with only a few of the rooms having lights still on however the place being far from empty right now. Twilight having invited all the others round to the castle for a dinner together since lately they had all been quite busy and this dinner was a chance for them all to spend some much needed time together.

As they all sat round the dinner table in the dining hall the mares talked to each other happily about things that had been going on in their lives lately, all enjoying this time that they had been able to have with one another. However as all the others seemed like they were having a good time together and engaging in lively conversations, Rarity seemed to be acting a little on the distant side, as she wasn't talking to any of the others really and was more or less just off in her own world as she pushed her unfinished food around her plate, letting out a deep sigh and now glancing up to look across the table. Seeing Rainbow Dash opposite her as the pegasus was happily talking and laughing with Pinkie, Rarity gazing to the cyan pegasus sitting across from her, and watched as she would chuckle every now and again at what Pinke was saying to her, feeling her heart beating a little faster Rarity let herself get lost in just the mere sight of that carefree pegasus that hadn't seemed to notice her staring just yet.

Fluttetshy was sitting next to Rairty as she had been casually talking to Applejack for most of the evening, but had now stopped for a moment to continue eating her dinner, looking to the unicorn sitting beside her and wondering if she was okay as she hadn't really seen her talking to any of them throughout this whole dinner, plus she did seem like she was awfully distracted at the moment.

Now seeming a little concerned as she looked to Rarity's plate and saw that she had hardly eaten any of her dinner, reaching a hoof over to the unicorn as she caught her attention and spoke to her in a caring tone, "Are you okay Rarity? You haven't eaten much of your dinner," she asked, Rarity now looking back to her having been dragged out of her thoughts, and shook her head as she tried to not focus on what was on her mind right now.

"Oh yes I'm fine Fluttershy, just not all that hungry as all," Rarity stated with a nervous smile, pushing her thoughts to the back of her mind right now as she looked to Fluttershy, but would still look away every now and again to steal another glance at Rainbow Dash, feeling her heart still beating fast as she wondered just how much longer she could last like this.

Fluttershy didn't seem all that convinced as she raised her eyebrow to the way that Rarity was now looking down to her food, and continuing to push it around her plate, clearly seeing that there was something very off with the unicorn tonight, and wondering if she should push her for more of an explanation as to why she wasn't up to eating anything right now.

"You're not sick or anything are you?" the pegasus asked, hoping that not being hungry was all it was, but she could see that Rarity wasn't telling her what she was really feeling right now.

"No, I'm okay really, it's nothing for you to worry yourself about honestly," Rarity tried to convince Fluttershy that she was fine, thinking of now forcing herself to eat more of her dinner so that the pegasus sitting beside her wouldn't be so worried anymore, but truly just not feeling hungry right now as there was something very different bothering her at the moment.

"Rarity if you're not feeling well you really shouldn't push yourself," Twilight now chimed in as she had also noticed that Rairty hadn't eaten much, and was being quite distant tonight, while the other's attention was also drawn onto the pure white unicorn as well now, as they had stopped talking for a moment and were all just staring to Rarity with slightly concerned expressions.

"I know, but really I'm fine Twilight," Rarity stated nervously her eyes now shifting as she had to try and convince all of them that she was doing okay, when it was already pretty obvious to all the others that she wasn't. Trying to search her mind for an excuse, while right now it was more or less just stuck on one thing in particular.

"Are you sure?" Twilight asked as her and all the others didn't seem convinced in the least, in fact Rarity's nervous replies were just causing them to become more suspicious and worried about her right now, clearly knowing that she wasn't telling them how she was really feeling at the moment.

"Yes, yes I'm..." Rarity was going to continue to deny that something was wrong, and say that she was 'Fine' but paused as she looked around at all the others, Rainbow Dash's bright magenta eyes catching her sapphire ones as she could see the cyan pegasus giving her a look of understanding and signally for her to just drop the act,

'You can always see right through me, can't you Dash?' Rarity thought now as she just sighed and looked down to her plate of unfinished food, "You know maybe I'm not feeling all that well after all, I think I'll just head home. Thank you for the lovely meal Twilight, and sorry to cut it short like this," she now nervously stated standing up from her chair and smiling to Twilight, before she then gave Rainbow a secret look, Dash already knowing what the unicorn was silently asking her for right now.

"It's no problem really, are you sure you don't want any of us to walk you home?" Twilight asked, looking worried as she and the others really wondered if Rarity was okay, although she didn't seem all that unwell it was easy to see that there was definitely someting bothering her, and keeping her mind preoccupied at this moment in time.

"Ah no it's fine, I'll be alright- Rarity denied the others help as she turned to start walking away from the table now, but at the same time was giving a signalling look to Rainbow Dash and the pegasus quickly catching on to it as she now cut Rarity off and stood up from her seat as well.

"I'll go with you Rarity," Rainbow stated as the others all looked to her now, while the cyan pegasus just made her way over to Raity and secretly smiled to her for a moment.

"Are you sure Rainbow Dash? I mean you don't have to- Rarity started to protest a little, as she knew Rainbow had caught onto the message she had just given her, but still had to play the stubborn card as to not seem suspicious to the others right now, although she felt like just saying yes right away, and agreeing to the pegasus's offer almost immediately.

"It's not a problem, besides I'm pretty tired from doing weather patrol today anyway, so I think I better head home as well," Rainbow explained as she smiled to Rarity and secretly winked to her, causing the unicorn to blush slightly before the two of them said 'Goodbye' to all the others and soon left out the door to make their way to Rarity's home.

"You think Rarity will be okay?" Fluttershy asked as she was obviously still a little worried for the unicorn that had just left, wondering if maybe she should have gone and taken her home along with Rainbow Dash.

"Don't worry Fluttershy, am sure Rarity's just feeling a little under the weather. She'll be fine after a goodnight's rest," Applejack reassured Fluttershy with a smile as she reached her hoof over and rested it on the pegasus's shoulder in a comforting mannner, while Fluttershy just now nodded slightly, still feeling unsure but tried to not think about it too much.

The others now all falling back into casual conversations, while Twilight seemed to be keeping quiet for some reason, looking back to the direction where she watched Rainbow Dash and Rarity leave and thought for a few moments, something seeming to not be sitting right with her as she went over a couple of things inside her mind.

Noticing her mentor's silence Starlight now looked to the alicorn sitting next to her and wondered if she was okay, looking to her a little concerned, before she spoke up and caught her attention, "Twilight, is there something wrong?" she asked causing Twilight to lift her head a little and look back to her, while the others had heard Starlight's question and were now all looking to Twilight as well, seeing that there was clearly something bothering her now and wondering what it was.

"Ah no...it's just, well doesn't this all seem a little weird?" Twilight asked as she now looked to Starlight and all the others with a slightly nervous expression, referring to what had just happened as she gestured to the door that Rarity and Rainbow Dash had just walked out of.

"Weird how?" Starlight asked as she and the others just all looked to each other for a moment, unsure of what Twilight meant, as they now all looked back to the alicorn again, and waited for her to go into more detail with what she was saying right now.

"Well haven't Rarity and Rainbow Dash been spending a lot of time together lately?" Twilight asked as she noticed that Rarity and Dash were spending more time together than normal a little while ago, not thinking anything of it at first, but now since they seemed to be going off together more regularly, it caused her to become a little sceptical.

"Now that ya mention it, I have seen Rainbow Dash going over to Rarity's a lot lately, especially in the evening," Applejack stated as she thought back and now did realize that she had seen Dash making her way to Rarity's a lot, unsure of what the reason was, and always thinking it was a little strange for the cyan pegasus to be going over there so much.

"Haven't they both been avoiding a lot of our get together's as well?" Fluttershy asked as she remembered the times that she and the others had asked Rainbow Dash or Rarity to come and spend some time with them, and they would either both refuse, or one would refuse and the other would have some sort of almost convenient reason to not come at the last minute as well.

"Yeah I actually wasn't sure if they were both going to be coming to this dinner or not eariler because of that," Twilight agreed with a nod as it seemed like the others had been noticing just how much time Rarity and Rainbow had been spending together as of lately as well. All of them now seeming a little suspicious of just what exactly was going on with the two of their friends.

"Don't forget the other week when we were helping Rarity with a load of orders that she had, once we were all done and going to head home she asked Rainbow Dash if she could stay for a little longer," Pinkie now chimed in as well as she remembered what had happened that evening not too long ago, and never did find out just why Rarity had asked Dash to stay for longer that night, when all the rest of them just went home.

"I thought that was a little strange as well back then," Twilight nodded in agreememt as she thought about that evening as being one of the first times that she started to suspect that something was a little off with both Rarity and Rainbow Dash, only now with all the sneaking around that those two were doing lately it was causing for her suspicions to raise slightly.

"So what are we saying here? Do you think there's something going on between them that they aren't telling us?" Starlight asked looking at all the others as they now all thought for a moment none of them speaking for a little while as silence had fallen on them all now.

"Well that's what it seems like, however I'm not sure what they could be hiding from us, I mean it's not like Rarity and Rainbow Dash have that much in common so the fact that they just might be doing something behind our backs is a little hard to really think about," Twilight thought out loud as it did seem like Rainbow and Rarity were hiding something from all of them, but it was a little bit of a mystery of what that might just be considering the fact that the two mares never really spent much time together until recently.

"Do you think we should ask them about it?" Starlight asked, as all the others now looked back to her again.

"Maybe...I mean maybe this is none of our business, but then again why would they feel the need to keep something from us?" Twilight wondered as she and all the others thought that simply asking Rainbow and Rarity about what might just be going on with them wouldn't be all that harmful after all it definitely did seem like this 'thing', whatever it may be had been going for quite a while now, the only question was what was the reason for it being kept as a sceret from them all?

....

"Well that was reckless of you now wasn't it Rares?" Rainbow asked as she and Rarity had made their way to the Carousel Boutique and were now up in Rarity's bedroom. Rarity laying on her bed as she sighed deeply, while Rainbow stood off to the side of the room smirking slightly to the unicorn.

"You know the whole part of this secret relationship between us is that it's kept as a secret right?" Rainbow went on as Rarity didn't reply, the unicorn just burying her face into her pillow as she felt embarrassed right now for leaving all their friends and cutting their dinner short just so she could spend more time with Rainbow Dash, the pegasus having been the only thing on her mind for what felt like so long now.

"But didn't we talk about telling them all about us soon?" Rarity mumbled out after a long pause, slightly lifting her head up from the pillow as she looked back to Dash now, a slight blush staining her cheeks as she felt foolish for acting the way she had, she should be happy to spend some time with all their friends, and not be focusing on the cyan pegasus that had been sitting across from her all evening.

"Well yeah, but how do you expect us to tell them about us if you keeping cutting the time with have with them all short? Not to mention the many times we've both backed out of hanging out with them because you keep asking me to come round to yours," Rainbow pointed out as she she now raised her eyebrow to Rarity, and came walking up to the bed, sighing to the unicorn slightly, as Rarity just glanced to her out of the corner of her eye.

"You know you could always just say 'no' to me," Rarity stated as she now sat up slowly on her bed, and glanced away from Dash for a moment.

"But that would be cruel of me, and besides..." Dash now paused as she came to stand beside the bed, leaning into Rarity as she rested her forehead against the unicorn's and lowered her voice a little, "...how could I resist such a cute unicorn asking me to come round to her house for the night?" the pegasus asked as she now looked to Rarity with an alluring stare, smiling as she looked deeply into the other mare's eyes. Rarity's eyes widening as she blushed a deep red and could feel her heart beginning to race inside her chest, wanting to just melt against Rainbow but held herself back as she trembled slightly and turned her head away from Dash again.

"Do you think they caught on to anything?" Rarity spoke in a quiet voice as she nervously bit her bottom lip, feeling herself shaking against Dash, 'She's too close right now...I...I'm going to give into her at this point,' she thought trying her best to stop herself from caving but clearly she was fighting an already losing battle, as she couldn't help but look at Rainbow with pleading eyes.

"Nah, I think we're safe for now,"

Rainbow simply stated as she now winked to Rarity, causing the unicorn's blush to deepen as she couldn't stop herself from leaning in, sighing heavily as she now closed her eyes and was clearly asking the other mare to kiss her. Rainbow just smiling as she slowly leaned in a little more and soon closed the tiny gap that was between them, pressing her lips to Rarity's as she almost immediately slipped her tongue in. The unicorn letting a small whimper escape her as she felt like reaching out her hoof and pulling the pegasus on top of her, but instead just sat still and let Rainbow make her head spin with her sweet kisses, moaning every so often, as she let herself melt against Dash, choosing not to fight it any longer.

However their deep kiss didn't last all that long as their lips soon parted and although Rainbow could see that Rarity clearly wanted more, she just stood back and smiled slightly to the unicorn, watching as she opened her sapphire eyes again, and now looked back to her with a begging expression on her face.

"Dash..."

She whsipered out as she now gazed to Dash pleading with her eyes as she couldn't deny how much she wanted this right now, how much she had been wanting it all day, wanting the pegasus to take control and dominate her like she always did, but Dash just continued to stand there, knowing exactly what Rarity wanted, and only stalling because she loved seeing that begging expression of her's.

"What? You know how this goes by now, don't you?" Rainbow asked with a smirk as she took a few more steps back, and just waited for Rarity to do as she pretty much always did and beg her for what she wanted instead.

Rarity knew that Rainbow wasn't going to do anything until she begged her to, and so she just swallowed slowly and now bit her bottom lip again, keeping her pleading eyes on Dash as she now slowly lifted up her rear, raising her waist off the bed and holding it up as high as it would go, her rump shaking in the air a little as she now moved her tail aside as she presented herself to the other mare, already panting heavily as she didn't care how embarrassing this was for her, she was willing to do it if it was for Dash.

"H-hurry...Dash," the trembling unicorn whsipered as she begged for the pegasus to stop stalling and just get on with it, but knew by now that it would take more than just this to get what she really wanted from the other mare.

"Hurry and do what? I won't know unless you tell me Rares,"

Rainbow smiled as she just continued to wait, knowing that she was near enough torturing Rarity at this point, making her beg for exactly what she wanted, but she loved hearing that cute begging voice that only she knew about so much, that she just couldn't help herself, she always loved to hear those slight whimpers as the unicorn would beg her to 'stop this and just take her already'.

"D-Dash...don't make me beg..."

Rarity pleaded as she now had slight tears in her eyes, feeling her desires raging inside her core as she kept her tail out of the way of her sex, showing off her aroused and dripping slit to the other mare, her body desperately wanting attention as this waiting was killing her right now.

But Rainbow didn't reply as she just stood still and didn't look like she was going to make any movements anytime soon, as although she herself wanted to just ravish the unicorn's beautiful body, and cause her to moan and cry out her name, she continued to hold herself back as she was certain that she wasn't going to do anything until Rarity finally begged her for it.

And now it seemed that it had all gotten to Rarity as she soon caved and raised her hips a little higher, looking back to Rainbow with teary, begging eyes and a quivering bottom lip, her heart beating fast inside her chest and her head spinning, "Dash please...lick me..." she now finally pleaded as she hoped that this would be enough for the pegasus.

And luckily for her it was, as Rainbow now licked her lips and slowly walked up to Rarity, looking to the other mare's dripping slit and smiling, taking in the unicorn's sweet scent, before she leaned in and then halted for a moment admiring the sight of her lover's sex, "You sure are soaked, just how long have you been like this?" she asked in a seductive tone, not doing anything until she heard Rarity's reply.

"I...I can't help it..."

Rarity whispered out as even just feeling Dash's warm breath on her sex made her shiver all over, holding back moans as she now buried her head into the bedsheets, the next minute crying out loudly as she now felt the pegasus's hot tongue licking just the outside of her sex, wanting her to do so much more, but knew how much Rainbow loved to tease her.

"You really have become so broken haven't you Rares?"

Rainbow whispered as she stopped for a moment, nuzzling into Rarity's rump, before she went back to lightly licking the unicorn's slit, causing her to moan and cry out over and over again, her face completely red as she couldn't hold her voice back, wanting to just scream out, as she could tell that her body was asking for much more than it was getting right now.

"You really are so cute though,"

Dash now pulled away from Rarity's sex, as she leaned over her instead and whispered into her ear, feeling the unicorn shiver against her, while she gave her ear a long, slow lick and now moved her wing down to Rarity's slit, gently running her feathers over the other mare's sex and coating them in her arousal. Rarity just grinding her hips into Dash's wing as she moaned louder and could feel the feathers of Dash's wing slipping inside her soaked entrance and then slipping back out over and over again, unsure of how much more of this she could take, while Rainbow now licked her horn slowly and caused her head to feel dizzy.

"Dash...quit teasing me already..."

Rarity now begged as she looked to Rainbow Dash with pleading eyes again, feeling the pegasus still stirring her up with her feathers, and asking for her to do more to her. Dash just smiling as she now licked Rarity's horn again, before she pulled away from her and now decided that she had kept the other mare waiting long enough, just simply closing her eyes as she soon leaned into Rarity and started to stir her up with her tongue again.

However not wasting any time now Rainbow began to thrust her tongue deeply inside Rarity's entrance, listening to her low moans and loud cries as they were like music to her ears, loving the way she could easily drive the unicorn into a mess of heavy pants and loud moans.

"D-Dash...if you're that rough with me...I...AHHH!!"

Rarity cried out loudly as she could now already feel pressure building inside her abdomen, knowing that if Dash kept this fast rhythm up for much longer than she no doubt wouldn't be able to hold back at all, and it seemed like Dash wasn't letting up as she continued to thrust her tongue deeply inside the other mare, and was beginning to make her go crazy.

"Dash...your tongue is so deep inside me...it feels...it feels so good!"

Rarity said in-between loud moans and heavy pants as she was so close to just choosing to bite her hoof in order to keep herself relatively quiet, feeling her climax now quickly approaching her and knowing that there was no chance of her being able to hold back, as she already felt so close to bursting.

"Dash...I...I can't...take much more..."

Rarity whispered out as she knew she wouldn't be able to last much longer, feeling herself being so close to being thrown over the edge right now, and then widening her eyes and gasping slightly as she felt Rainbow double her efforts, causing her to scream out loudly as she buried her head into the pillow and rolled her hips into Dash's deep thrusts.

"Dash...I'm cumming...HYAAAHH!!"

Rarity let out a loud scream of release, feeling Dash continuing to thrust her tongue deep inside her, making her ride out her intense orgasm as she screamed out her lover's name over and over again, while wave after wave of endless pleasure rippled through her entire body, shaking all over as she wasn't able to calm down for what seemed like ages.

A feeling of relief now washing over her as she still trembled a little, and could still feel herself cumming, until she finally collapsed onto the bed, not being able to keep her rear in the air anymore as her hind legs gave in, and she now lay panting heavily and recovering from reaching her limit, while Rainbow happily just stood back and licked her lips clean of all Rarity's juices, savouring the bitter-sweet taste it had left on her tongue.

'Dash is right I really am broken...but if it's her than...I guess I don't mind being broken,' Rarity thought as she now lay recovering, feeling her heart wildly beating inside her chest, while she tried to get her breathing back to normal, widening her eyes a moment later as she felt Rainbow leaning over her again, looking to the pegasus before she was flipped over onto her back, and Dash was now laying on top of her, smiling down to her and giving her a gentle peck on the forehead as she waited for the unicorn to recover and come down from her high.

'I love you Dash...I love you so much,' Rarity felt like saying, but just continued to pant, slowly going back to breathing normally again as, she soon sighed deeply and gazed into Dash's eyes, smiling back to her now as her heart was still racing inside her chest, wrapping her forelegs around Dash's neck and holding her close to her, nuzzling into her neck and causing the pegasus to chuckle slightly in response.

"Are you going to stay over tonight?" Rarity asked as she knew that Dash didn't always stay for the whole night, and wanted her to stay with her this time, not wanting to let the pegasus go just yet.

"Well that depends, do you want me to stay?" Rainbow asked with a smile as she already knew what the other mare's answer was going to be.

"Of course I do Dash!"

Rarity smiled brightly as she nodded, and would gladly have Rainbow staying round at her home every night, but knew that that would be asking for a bit too much, and so settling for just tonight for now instead as she hugged Dash tightly, and caused her to chuckle again.

"You tired now, or do you wanna go for round two?"

Rainbow asked with a seductive smile as she now rested her forehead against Rarity's, loving the way that the unicorn blushed deeply in return, before she just replied with a nervous nod, and glanced away from Dash slightly, only for her eyes to go wide as the pegasus brought her into a deep kiss.

The kiss becoming more passionate and then soon ending as their lips parted and Rainbow began to travel down to Rarity's neck, laying light kisses here and there, as she would softly bite but was careful to not leave any marks on the unicorn's body, while Rarity just lay her head back on the pillow and panted heavily, moaning in return as she let herself melt against Dash and sighed a little.

"Dash...mmm...I love you Dash..." Rarity whispered out, being too lost in her own pleasure and not realizing that she had just said that out loud until she felt Rainbow stop what she was doing and looked to her now with a questioning expression.

"What did you just say Rares?" Rainbow asked as she now seemed taken aback, not knowing how to react as she just waited for Rarity's reply.

"I-I...umm..."

Rarity just stuttered a little as all words had left her now, not knowing what to say as she only now just realized that she had said what her true feelings were out loud, knowing she should have stopped herself, and shouldn't have let herself melt so much, nervously looking to Dash as she dreaded how the pegasus would reply to her sudden confession.

"Hey you know I actually need to be up early in the morning, so I best be off now sorry," Rainbow nervously said in a rush as she quickly climbed off Rarity and turned, heading for the door to make a swift escape from this situation.

"Wait Dash!"

Rarity called after Dash and tried to stop her from leaving, but Rainbow had already left out the door, and would now no doubt be heading back to her own home to collect herself and try and get her head around what had just happened and what Rarity had just said to her. While Rarity now sat up in her bed and looked to her wide open door that Rainbow had just left out of, sighing deeply as she cursed herself and hated herself for what she had just done.

"I'm such an idiot,"

She whispered out to her empty bedroom and wanted to go back a few moments in time and take back what she had just said, wishing that she had just kept her mouth shut and not told Dash how she really felt, feeling her heart ache and her chest hurt as she gritted her teeth and felt like crying, laying back down on her bed, burying her head into her pillow and hoping that she could wake up the next morning, thinking of all of this as just a bad dream, even though she knew it was far from that in reality.


Author's Note

Love and relationships don't always run smoothly. :fluttershysad:

Thank you ever so much for reading. :twilightsmile:

KillerChainsaw ;)

Next Chapter