Blackmailed

by Haillee

Rating: mature
Tags: Anthro, Dark
Length: 5202

After a picture was taken of her in her home, Fluttershy will no be doing whatever she must to keep those pictures away from the public.

Fluttershy got home and simply took off her clothes. She wanted only to relax in her home. But instead the sound of a click scared her. She looked around only to find somepony running away form her house.
The next day when she put the previous day behind herself she received a text, a picture of her naked body from the looks of her living room window. It also holds an address and actions.
Come alone or this picture will end up on the board in city hall…

"Warning Contians: Bondage, rape, anal rape, cumming, and blackmail.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2017-08-04 03:50:26 UTC

The Price She must pay.

Fluttershy held her phone closely to her face. Making sure she had the right address. She looked at the picture again embarrassed that someone even was able to get a photo like that.

The picture showed Fluttershy completely bare, bending over picking up a book she had dropped. Her genitals exposed and her large pair of breast hanging beneath her. It was clear as day who it was. The cutie mark proved that it was her in the photo. And her being so well known, despite her wishes, everypony in town would know exactly how she looks exposed.
She hated whoever took this. She knocked on the door to find out who ever was blackmailing her into whatever they had planned. The door unlocked and opened revealing a hoof motioning her to come in. She walked in and turned to see a stallion she had never seen before. She stared at his face for a moment and looked at him as her stared at her. It took her a moment to find out he wasn't looking at her face but at her body. She moved her hooves to cover herself and continued inside until the door shut behind her.

The stallion stared at her with a smirk. He had a dark brown mane and a purple body. Fluttershy never seen him in ponyville before. The stallion motioned for her to follow him further into the house. Fluttershy didn't argue and followed into the depths of the house. They walked into the kitchen only to find two other stallions there also. These other stallions looked at her and smiled as their ears perked up. Fluttershy opened her bag and placed a wad of cash on the table, she turned to leave to find one of the stallions blocking her way.

"Hey little lady, calm down their we don't care to much for money here. Though if you like we won't decline if you want us to keep it." The stallion that opened the door said as she looked up into his eyes. Fluttershy finally spoke up. "If you don't want my money why blackmail me with that awful picture you took?" She said staring into his eyes.

At that point the stallion in front of her pointed to one of the stallions behind her, "Murkey get the rope."

'Rope??' Fluttershy thought, she turned her head to see the green stallion with red hair walking into a room off the kitchen to return with the rope. 'What could they want rope for??'

A hoof touched the side of her face turning her head back to the stallion in front of her. The stallion in front took her surprise to is advantage and gave her lips a deep kiss. Fluttershy eyes went wide in fear as she felt his long tounge break through her lips and into her mouth. Shocked she tried to pull back only to find the stallion called Murkey behind her holding her in place and tying her arms behind her back. She stood frozen in fear as she felt the warm tounge going down her throat. She didn't want this so she gave the tounge in her mouth a small bite to get it out.

With a yelp from the stallion in front he pulling out. Fluttershy at first thought she had victory only to receive a hard smack across the face. Fluttershy felt her tied up arm being released from the hooves of Murkey allowing her to fall to the floor.

"That bitch bit me." Said the rather angry stallion.

"Percy lemme see. said the last stallion. The stallion looked into Percy mouth and gave hive a pat on the back. "you will be fine, she didn't even draw blood.

Percy grabbed Fluttershy's arm and pulled her to the room. "Please let me go, I am sorry I hurt you I was scared. please I won't tell anypony take the money just please let me go." Fluttershy begged as the three stallions begun to help each other drag her to room where Murkey got the rope. She got a look of the room to find the wall covered in various tool and objects. Several large didlos and vibrators hung. Along side of these were various wipes and gags. Beads also hung along with other objects she didn't know. She also noticed a large contraption standing in the room. The weird object had two sides made of wood. it also had one metal bar that had foam wrapped around it. On either side of the metal bar was some chains, nailed to the floor. Fluttershy struggled against her captors as they dragged her across the room to the object in the center. The pushed her belly over the metal bar. They untied her arms only to chain them over the wooden bars at her side. Fluttershy began to cry and beg as the chained her legs apart to the wood also. She looked back with the captors once again as they smiled at their work. Her belly hurt like crazy because of the pressure from the bar. Though she thought it was rather nice of them to put to foam to try to give her some comfort.

"Please sir, please don't hurt me. Please all of this can be forgotten nothing has been done. But please don't hurt me. I don't want to do this. Please. She begged as the Percy grabbed something off the wall. Fluttershy turned to find him holding a pair of scissors. She fidgeted against her binding and began to scream. Murkey gave her a smack across the face.

"Murkey please." Percy said as he lowered the scissors to Fluttershy's skirt. He used his hooves and lifted her skirt and began to cut again the underwear revealing a rather dry pussy. Fluttershy let out a yelp as she tightened herself trying to close the view of her privates. Percy gave a chuckle and looked to one the third stallion.
"Mark, get this girl a ring don't need her biting anyone again. Now little Fluttershy as much as I love listening to you plea I am afraid we want what we want. It is hard finding mares in ponyville that fit our liking. We like them a bit tied up and willing to obey orders. However this can be rather hard to come by. So we do what we can. And when Murkey said he spotted the perfect mare for the job, well my lady. We all knew we must get you to be our little pet. Getting you here was easy. Now that we got you, just looking at we you can offer not sure how willing we are to let you go. What do you think boys?" The two stallions nodded and moved to rip off her shirt. Fluttershy cried on hearing this as she let out another cry she felt something forced into her mouth. It tasted like it was metal, making herself leave her mouth wide open. She tried to bit down on the ring only to cause a sharp pain in her jaw. Mark wrapped a strap around her head and tighten it till he saw she was in enough pain in her jaw from trying to force it out. He pulled another strap over her head and attached it to the top of the ring also. He then went back to the wall and grabbed a chain with two clips on either end. He attached one clip to the top of the gag and the other end to the ceiling causing her head to be elevated about 3 feet off the ground.
Murkey grabbed something else off the wall and placed it around her neck. It was some for of collar. She couldn't make out the color but she saw it was now being attached to the chain on the floor. Keeping her head tight and in place.

Her tail hid the privates that were now exposed due to lose of her underwear and skirt. Percy walked over to the wall and grabbed another small ring and clipped it around the start of her tail. Fluttershy yelped again as she felt the metal ring against her anus. She felt her tail began to rise as another chain to the ceiling was chained to the ring on her tail. The stallions looked at their prize. She was nice and fully bare, and now unable to move at all.

"So who wants what first?" Asked Percy.

"Gonna sit out first round, I like to watch, see how she reacts." Mark said as he took a seat in a chair across from her.

"Well I like front if that is cool. Dying to get nice and lubed up." Murkey said as he walked around to her front.

"Mmmmm gonna grab that pussy first. Need some wetness before I can even try the ass." Percy said walking behind her.
Fluttershy stared at the three as they planned on how they were going to violate her. She watched as one made her way into her front line of sight. He held in his hooves a blindfold which he place on her. She now could only wait and listen as they unzipped their pants and removed their clothes. Her tears wet the blindfold and rolled down her checks.

Percy pulled out his member and let it hang. It was large and wasn't even fully erect yet. Fluttershy felt as he rubbed it length up and down her pussy and anus. She yelped in surprise of the warmth of him. Murkey stood in front and sent his member straight down her throat. She moaned as he deep throated her. She had never done anything like that before and gaged as it hit her reflex.

"Hey Percy, I think she never done this before. At least not on this end she is gagging non stop. She feeling new down there?" Murkey said as he moved in and out of her mouth. Fluttershy cried even more at the sheer pain of him entering her so fast.

Percy looked up surprised to hear this and wanted to find out for himself. He shove his cock in hard as he could and rather quickly. He laughed at the feeling. "Yeah, brand new bitch. She saved herself for us. How sweet."

Blood trickled down her clit as he moved in and out. Mark stared in disbelief, she was a full grown mare. How had she stay that innocent this whole time. She was a hot one, surely somepony must have thought about using her.

Fluttershy let out a moan of how fast these stallions were going. She wanted to scream for help from her friends. For anyone that would listen. She felt Percy move in and out of her slowly but making sure he hit the end of her each time. If he had started out like this maybe it wouldn't have been so bad. She wanted him to stop and make him go away and she tried at her hardest to say so. But only mumbles came out.

"Fluttershy you must stop crying, we know you are loving this. I feel you wetting yourself for me, it is getting much easier on my end. Calm down and maybe I let you hold me in you while I cum. That way you can carry around my little baby."
Fluttershy cried even more at this. Why did her body betray her when she was so desperate to get away. She didn't want to carry this monsters child. She didn't want be here. She only wanted her friends. She wanted Rainbow to come through the window and Applejack come through the door, she want her friends to beat the day light out of these stallions and free her. She wanted Rarity to help clean her up and Twilight to tell her it was going to be ok. She wanted Pinkie to come in and make her smile. But what she wanted more than all that, was she wanted to go home, cuddle up next to Angel and forget all this ever happened.

She went into a daze dreaming of her friends and of her home. After a moment however she felt something new on her rear end.

Mark had gotten up and lubed himself. He made his way around and his member fully erect from watching his two friends pound her now rested on her anus. Fluttershy had never heard of seen or dreamed about anything that these stallions are doing to her. So when she felt him push his head of his cock into her rear she screamed straight through the large cock in her mouth. She screamed and bit down on the metal ring in her mouth as her ass felt as if it was ripped apart. Her butt checks grew wider apart as his long thick member was forced into her. After about an inch he began to pull out a bit and then push back in even deeper then last time. Fluttershy screamed and bit down on the ring until she felt her jaw bend the metal ring.

She heard a loud shout from above her head.

'MARK STOP!!" Showed Murkey as he attempted to pull out his cock form her mouth. Mark stopped and pulled out of her. Fluttershy released her jaw from relief. Murkey unstrapped the gag from her head and pulled it out of her mouth. His two friends watched as he pulled his cock out with the bent ring piece stuck on it.

Percy fell out of Fluttershy laughing, leaving her empty.

"Damn bitch bend the ring on me. " Murkey said as he went to grab some pliers. He tried to place the pliers between his cock and the ring and he held down one end of the ring while pulling the ring apart.

Mark and Percy were still on the floor laughing at the sight of ,him stuck in a gag. Fluttershy managed to pull off her blindfold enough. She wanted to laugh at the sight of him struggling but her jaw was killing her. It hurt like crazy and after everything. She puked.

Mark stopped laughing to see what Fluttershy had done to the floor. He got up and walked over the paper towels and begun to wipe it up. Percy still laughed as Murkey finally got the ring off him. He then walked over to his crazy stupid friend and gave him a kick in the chest. Percy quit laughing and rolled over in pain. Fluttershy let out a chuckle at that. She like to see them beat themselves up, Rainbow Dash will have an easier time beating them if they were in bad shape to begin with. Murkey walked around to see her face.

"What's so funny?" He asked removing the blindfold the rest of the way.
Fluttershy was now laughing as hard as she could while she stared at him. My friend, Rainbow Dash, She is going to beat you till your bodies won't move. But it seems you guys are doing the job for her." Fluttershy said through the chuckles.

Murkey looked at Mark. "Finish her ass. I wanna hear this bitch scream.

Fluttershy stared at Mark as he went back around and lined up with her ass. She braced herself for the pain that she knew would come. Only this time, he didn't take it slow. He pushed in full force and broke into her rear. The dry ass cracked under the pressure releasing blood from it. Fluttershy screamed at the top of her lungs, hoping that maybe somepony would hear her. He ripped into her as she begged him to stop. Murkey sat in front of her watching her face as she scream.

Percy picked himself back up and shot a hated look at Murkey as he got back into Fluttershy's now soaked pussy. He pounded along to the rhythm of Mark. Fluttershy begun to be numb to this. She only stand and cried as these ponies did what ever they wanted to her. She felt something. Her body felt a soft vibration. The stallions in her must have felt it too because they stopped moving and shot their load. The looked down at her rear and noticed it glowing. Tiny versions of her cutie mark moved outward of her original cutie mark. Percy and Mark hoped off and questioned what was happening.

"What's going on bitch?" He said pulling at her hair.

"I-I am an element. I am being called to help my friends with a mission." Murkey began to untie her. As Mark went outside.

"They may be able to track her with this, get rid of her. Time we hightail it out of ponyville."

Fluttershy looked at Murkey as he grabbed a needle off the table and stuck it in her neck. She begun to fall asleep. "Don't worry Fluttershy, by the time you wake up. You will be safe and back at home. No one needs to know about what we have done today. And remember there may a day when we come back and ask for this again. But you won't tell a soul, for if you try. We have that picture."
'Click'

"Plus a brand new one. See you again Fluttershy."

The Start of The End

Fluttershy walks into her room. She finally got back from her trip to Manehatten. After everything that has happened before and after. She just wanted to rest. She hadn't gotten a nice night at home since that horrible day.
Angel walks into the room to find Fluttershy crying. She just wanted to cry, get over what happened and forget that it ever happened. Angel being his usual just wants her to get him a nice salad. But right now, she needed him more then he needed a treat. He hops up to the bed and struggles climbing up the comforter. After a moment of him hanging half off the bed Fluttershy realizes he dear pet in need. She helps him up the rest of the way.

Angel goes up to her and snuggles up under her arms. Fluttershy gladly accepts his comfort. She gave him a heart felt hug and then began to cry again. Angel sat there while tears dripped onto his white fur. He was not at all comfortable but he thought that right now, he needed to just be someone to hold. He had no clue why she cried. Nor did he know how he could help her.
After a few minutes of being Fluttershy's tear rag Angel claws her way out and runs off. Fluttershy, now with a few scraps bleeding on her arm, walks toward the bathroom. She starts up the shower and goes out to grab a towel. Still crying, now even more hurt that her precious Angel left while she was getting over an emotional trauma, she begins taking off her clothes and setting them plainly on the floor. Once she finished getting her panties off she moved toward the tub.

"Mmmm, just as beautiful as last time."

Fluttershy jumped in shock and fear. Tripping on her own two feet she slips and hits her head on the tub. Her vision starts going black. Confused ,scared, and worried, she looks for the sound of the voice. Only to find Percy to be standing in the door way. In his hands a very upset and struggling little white wet rabbit. Her sight and body give out on her as she passes out naked on the bathroom floor.

Percy now holding a freaked out bunny and a passed out mare on the floor, is more confused then anything. He put the fidgeting bunny in a nearby cage. The rabbit didn't seem to like that too much, but right now he had other things to focus on. Percy walked into the bathroom and pick up Fluttershy's upper half of her body. Good she has a pulse. Didn't need a dead mare. And since there wasn't any blood on the floor or in the tub he assumed she only scared herself to sleep and that she should wake up soon. He [picked her up and dragged her to the bed. At which point he spread her limbs across the bed. He then rampaged through his bag and grabbed the rope. He tied her legs up to either side of the bed post. The rabbit now made some kind of squealing sound.
That was going to be a huge distraction. he walked over to the cage to find the rabbit trying viciously to bit through the metal bars. Percy gave a chuckle and unlatched the cage. Angel attempted to attack the intruder. Only to get a hard smack of his hoof. The hoof then grabbed the rabbit by his hind leg. Now upside down and his leg hurting him like crazy Angel struggles in this stallions hoof. He tried to bit at the hand that was above him, but he couldn't get himself up that high. Percy walked him over to the sleeping mare and let the rabbit curl up between her arm and chest. Sitting just in the corner of her armpit Angel showed as much love as he could to his caregiver.

"You like this mare huh? Well no worries. When I take her I can bring you too. I am just gonna have a little fun her before we leave."

Angel looked at the man confused. He had no clue what he was saying but it was something about Fluttershy. Angel kept thinking one thing. He should have warned Fluttershy when he heard the front door being unlocked. He tried to get out from her arms and stop the intruder. Thinking it may have been that crazy pink pony. Or maybe the alicorn, Angel thought he would send them away while Fluttershy was upset. Never did he think a strange stallion would pick the lock and come into her home.

Percy grabbed a blindfold out of his bag and placed it on Fluttershy's face. Then went into the bathroom and grabbed a scope of water in a cup. Careful he walked back to the bed and poured the warm water on the sleeping mares face.

"W-W-what happened," Fluttershy wondered trying to look around only to find darkness. She tried to move her legs only to feel the sharp pain in her thighs from pulling. She felt the familiar soft fur rubbing against her under arms. "A-angel? What's going on?"

Percy stood in silence for a moment before he spoke. "Can you talk to that thing?" He asked as he once again picked up the rabbit by the legs.

"Who are you?? Please don't hurt him." She begged as she heard Angel cry from the stallions hooves. "Wait, I know that voice. Percy???"

"Ding ding ding. Give the mare what she won." He said as he tossed the rabbit carelessly back on the bed. Angel landed head first on Fluttershy's chest quickly running back to the corner in her armpits.

"Please no. Not this again, please."

"Relaxed. Murkey found a spell that he casted just after you left. It will make it so no more of those pesky missions of your get in the way of our fun." Percy made his way to Fluttershy's private area. He bent over and stuck his nose straight into her pussy.
Fluttershy yelped in shock. She could only lay as he sniff her pussy. Percy however was planning on getting her nice and close before he had some real fun. He stuck his tounge out and begun licking the walls of her pussy. Making sure to lean out some and give the cilt a small nibble to insure she found some pain in the pleasure.
Fluttershy moaned loudly in agony as he toyed with her. She hated that her body was betraying her once more. But oh how she liked this one. She much preferred it to what they did last time.

Angel however was startled that his loving caretaker was being use as a toy. He wanted to stop this intruder from hurting her. But everything in his body said that if he tried he would be hurt or killed. So he stayed in the warm under arms of Fluttershy.

Fluttershy moaned loudly as Percy hit every right spot on her. Fluttershy begun to tense up and tighten herself.
Percy felt her body tense and stopped licking her. He got over her body and positioned himself over her pussy.
Fluttershy felt both upset and pleased to find him stop lick her. "Thank you Percy. Please let me go noooooooo-"

She was cut off to find that Percy had stuck the head of his shaft into her virginal. He had worked himself watching her undress herself for him and while licking him. Fluttershy let out a large moan as she felt him kindly work his way in her. She felt her walls spread trying to fit him again. She just wanted to be left alone, why was that so hard. She only wanted to be away from this monster.

Angel now saw the panic and tears all over Fluttershy's face. He moved up and sat on her shoulder while he worked on removing the blindfold.
Light slowly made its way into Fluttershy's sight. She looked up to find Angel standing above her. She wanted to give him a kiss, but the pain of Percy pushing himself further in her made her just want to scream.

Percy finally reached his end. Yeah she was a little to shallow for him but he made it in. Nothing was going to stop him from pounding this bitch. He started a nice calming pattern of long strokes in and out of her body.

"Bitch you are going to make me and the boys very happy."

"Wait, please no. I don't want to go back there please. Just put out the picture I don't want to go back." Fluttershy begged through her panting.

"Oh sweet heart don't lie. I know you liked what we did. You were wet as hell. Honestly I would have kept you then if you ass didn't start flashing. But now that we have that controlled we can have you forever."

Fluttershy started crying again as he pounded away. The thought of her doing this for the rest of her life. She wish she could die now. Angel sat by her face and gave her licks to wipe away the tears. Fluttershy returned his love with a small kiss to his forehead.

"You know that rabbit of your is a worrier. He has some real problems, way to clingy to you. But with him being like that, I guess I won't hate having a rabbit with you. " He said as he grunted in and out of her. His pace began to quicken. It was no longer slow and nice. Now it was fast painful and pounding again. Fluttershy cried at the sound of him taking Angel to their twisted place.

With a few more grunts and pushes he released his load into her. He layed on top of her for a moment to catch his breath. He kept his cock inside her letting it gently fall out on it's own. Fluttershy cried as she saw a shadow go past her bedroom window. 'Was that the other two?' She though as she layed there. They must have her exits blocked. There was no way out of this one.

Percy begun to sit up, now sitting on Fluttershy's furry chest. "Now sweet heart, I am gonna untie you but that does not give you permission for you to run off. Got it. Try and I will show you just how strong I am."

Percy begun to untie her and move her into a new position. He then tied her back up but this time leaving her head hanging off the front of the bed. Angel sat on Fluttershy's breast as he watched her head dangle form the bed.
"Bite me bitch and I will rip out all your teeth. Got that?"

Fluttershy nodded as the head of his cock hung in front of her mouth. He slowly stuck himself into her mouth. He loved this end. He enjoyed how a bitches mouth is so warm. He moved himself in slowly. He remembered back how she puked last time. Didn't want a redo of that. No taking it slower will be nice for a change. Besides he like listening to her struggle to take him in piece by piece. He moved at a steady pace bot stopping for her get used tp it. But he wanted her to be happy with this. With her becoming his go to sex toy from here on. She might as well learn to love this.

"So sweet heart, when we get you back to the others want to do a threesome with them again? Of course we will need a stronger ring for you. As funny as it was last time, Murkey wants to keep his dick in one piece."

Muffled words came out of the mares mouth. Percy sighed and removed his cock to hear what she was saying.
"You know it was hypothetical right?"

"What do you mean get back to them? I saw them in my backyard just a moment ago."

Percy looked at her shocked and scared. He looked at the window only to be met by a pain a blue hooves coming through.
CHRASH!!!
In came one very pissed off blue pegasus. Behind her followed a orange and yellow earth pony. The door of Fluttershy's bedroom blasted open with a blue and purple light. In rushed a purple alicorn and white unicorn. Behind them a Pink earth pony came in. She jumped right on top of Percy and tackled him to the ground. Applejack and Rainbow Dash liked that idea and dog piled on the rapist. Crushing him and his member beneath him.

"Fluttershy , Sweetie I am so sorry I came here trying to find you and you didn't answer so I peeked through your window and found you and this BEAST!!" Said Rarity as she kicked him as hard as her lady legs could. "I called the others and they all got here as fast as they could. I am so sorry for not getting you out sooner." She said as Twilight horn lite up and begun untying Fluttershy's limbs.

Fluttershy cried as her friends surrounded her with Percy tied up. "Flutters, what was he saying about others?" Rainbow asked. Fluttershy explained to them what happened as Angel stayed in her arms. Pinkie Pie gave her a hug and Twilight started going through the database to find the other two rapist.

"It's ok sugar cube. They can't hurt ya no more. We got you." Fluttershy said as she held you close.
We got you
We got you
We got you

Fluttershy's eyes opened to find herself in the back seat on a covered wagon. Percy, Murkey, and Mark all were around
her.

Percy turned to look at Fluttershy. "Hey sleeping beauty. Have a nice dream? Don't worry, we got you."