The authorities of Ponyville began to wonder what had become of Rainbowdash. She was gone for so many years, and the last pony she was seen with was Pinkiepie. The investigation that was performed days after her disappearance led them to nothing. And their only lead, Pinkie, was far too cheery to have done anything, everypony knew that. The case was dropped, and Rainbowdash was lost to all but the memories of her friends and the guards. Now slowly, more ponies are disappearing, and the authorities are ignoring it. Pinkamena has arisen once more, and has put more thought into her acts. Finding her victims from ponies who venture into the Everfree Forest for a solid story of how they disappeared. But what she never expected was to find 2 ponies living in the forest! Now all she needs is to deal with them or risk being uncovered.
This story's main character is not Pinkie, but rather a young filly named Stitches, who Pinkie stumbles upon in the Everfree Forest.