Date Night

by GhoulDash97

Rating: mature
Tags: Starlight Glimmer, Romance, Trixie, Comedy, Bon-Bon, Sex, Anthro, Lyra, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic
Length: 2189

Since their secret three-year anniversary is coming, two ponies have no idea how to celebrate? Just what can they do to spice things up?

After coming back from solving a friendship problem, Starlight looked around and saw that Twilight and the others weren't in the castle. Having figured out that they're trying to solve their own friendship problem, Starlight decided to spend some time with herself help. Until Trixie decided to show up. While the two were having their way with each other, they came up with this idea for their three-year anniversary. They have decided to invite Lyra and Bonbon for a double-date. Starlight decides to ask the two out while Trixie tries to find the restaurant for themselves. Just what can go wrong?

Published 2017-08-28 18:50:06 UTC
Last updated 2017-09-06 02:53:14 UTC

Nopony's home

"Well, looks like another problem has been solved." Starlight said as she wiped the sweat off her forehead.

After having solved another Friendship problem for another day, Starlight Glimmer was finally finished and ready to head back to Twilight's castle. She had to solve a rift that was going on between Lyra and Bonbon because they were arguing about their work schedules and the free time that they have to spend with each other. After listening to their problems for strenuous mounts of time and solving it, Starlight was more than ready to call in quits.

"I wonder if Twilight's back at the castle? She always has these anxiety problems that goes on and on about everyday." she thought as she was walking through Ponyville.

Just then, she spotted the ice-cream shop.

"Hmm... I do need to keep up my energy... Eh, what the heck."

After grabbing her favorite flavor of vanilla ice-cream, she headed straight towards the castle.

"Hey Twilight! I'm back!" Starlight shouted as she entered the castle.

She didn't hear a word.

"Twilight?"

She looked around the entire castle and still couldn't find her.

"She better not be at the Psycho Ward."

Just then, she found a piece of paper on the table. Starlight picked it up and saw that it was a letter of some sort. She unfolded it and it read

Dear Starlight,

If you're wondering where I am, I'm at Los Pegasus right now. There's a friendship problem that I have to solve and it looks to be more difficult than I had anticipated. But hey, this is nothing new to me. Anyway, everypony else has their own friendship problems to solve, and Spike is visiting Canterlot right now. Dinner's in the freezer. I'll be back in a week.

Yours Truly,

Twilight Sparkle

"Woop-de-doo. What other songs do you have while you're away?" Starlight said sarcastically as she sighed.

After reading the letter, she decided to head up to her room to get into her pajamas. Heading down in the corridor, she got lost along the way in the castle. After spending a half-hour wandering around the castle, she finally found her room, which the door was opened up.

"I can never get used to this castle..." Starlight said, breathing out a sigh of relief while feeling stressed out.

After entering her room, she went into her drawers and found her clean pair of pajamas. Before she could undress however, she noticed that the door to her room was open. Feeling that it was suspicious, Starlight put her pajamas down and decided to find the person who open her door. After searching for forty-five minutes around the castle, she headed back to her room to figure out where the assailant went off.

"Well, he didn't take anything in my room..."

Just then, she heard her closet door creak as it opened. She immediately turned around and saw that nopony was there.

"Okay Rainbow Dash, this isn't funny!" she shouted as she went towards the open closet.

She saw that nopony was there and she started to feel more than angry.

"Pinkie Pie! You better come over here right now!!!!" Starlight yelled.

Suddenly, she started hearing hoofsteps. She turned around and saw that nopony was there, much to her annoyance.

"I swear. If I ever get my hands on them, they're gonna wish their pranks were harmless..." Starlight said, fuming.

"Me too~." a voice called out.

"Huh?" Starlight asked.

She turned and saw that it was Trixie, whom quickly gave her french kiss as she pushed her on the bed.

"Trixie?" Starlight asked.

"Happy two days before our anniversary, Starly~." Trixie said as she gave her a quick peck on the lips as she pulled down her tube-top shirt and started kissing her breasts.

"When did you-?"

"Oh. The door was unlocked. Besides, breaking would've been a lot more fun with your friends in sight." Trixie said sensuously.

"Hmm. So how was one of your magic tours?"

"They were fine. Not one of my greatest, but fun nonetheless. How was your friendship problem?" Trixie said as she put her face in Starlight's breasts as she groped and sucked on them.

"It was alright. Had to solve one between Lyra and Bonbon." Starlight said as she moaned a little.

"Oh? Were they having a fall-out on their relationship~?"

"Well... yes and no."

"What do you mean?" Trixie asked as she continued to rub her face everywhere and kiss Starlight's body.

"They were arguing about financial problems and were going on and on about their anniversary as a couple."

"Okay. Keep going..." Trixie said as she pulled down Starlight's panties with her teeth.

"They told me that they one wanted to spend money by going out to dinner while the other wanted to spend time at home doing what we were doing."

"Were they?" Trixie said as she licked and ate out on Starlight's pussy while moaning erotically.

"So I told them-. Hey, are you even listening to what I'm saying right now?" Starlight asked as she grabbed Trixie's hair.

"Holding onto every word, Starlight~." Trixie said as she smile and gave a small kiss to Starlight's pussy.

"Fine then. Since you're totally ignoring me, I'm gonna get on top of you." Starlight said with a suggestive smile on her face.

"Oh momma~." Trixie exclaimed as Starlight pushed her off and stripping her of her clothes.

After becoming fully naked, Starlight got on top while Trixie laid on the bottom in a sixty-nine position.

"What do you think we should do for our anniversary?" Trixie asked as she licked Starlight's pussy.

"Well, I was thinking that we could invite Lyra and Bonbon on a double-date since they're gonna be going out for their anniversary." Starlight suggested as she licked Trixie's pussy while fingering her butt.

"Wouldn't be a bad idea. I mean, I never really went on a double-date before. Besides, the only way that I can get off is if I'm with Snails and he barely puts in much effort, despite his pros when it came to dating at the time."

"Great. I'll go and speak to them while you figure out which restaurant we'll eat at."

"Fair game Starlight. Fair game..." Trixie responded as she continued to lick Starlight's pussy before shoving her fingers into her butt.

"Ahn~. You pervert~!" Starlight shouted erotically as she shoved her face into Trixie's pussy.

Invitation

After getting dressed from their sexual activity, Starlight and Trixie tried figuring where to eat and how they should invite Lyra and Bonbon.

"So where should we eat?" Trixie asked.

"I could ask you the same question. Ponyville has so many restaurants. It's so hard to pick and choose."

"Well, there has to be a good one. It can't just be some random restaurant where all there is is hayburgers or anything that feels like fast food."

"I didn't know you had taste Starly~. Maybe you should pick out the restaurant~."

"Uh... given your past transgressions and your misdeeds, I would have to be the one to invite Lyra and Bonbon."

"Really? You had to bring up Twilight Sparkle and her annoying friends?"

"Hey. You bring my past all the time. It should only be fair."

"Right. Right. Double standards..."

"That's right. There can't be a double standard, no matter what reason you have."

"You always have to remind me?"

"Well yeah. You tend to go overboard whenever you have any sort of idea."

"That's not true. I had some good ideas while I was away from Ponyville."

"Like what?"

"Well... I... C'mon, just trust me. I can talk to them. Besides, I get picky when I choose a restaurant."

"I'll speak to them. You find the restaurant."

"Fine. But next time, you're choosing."

"Alright. Just see what you think would be good okay? And one more thing..."

"What's that?"

"WOULD YOU QUIT GRABBING MY BREASTS?!!!!"

"What~? They're so big and fluffy~."

Feeling annoyed, Starlight swatted Trixie's hand, got behind her and grabbed her left breast along with going into her tight pants to finger her pussy.

"Listen. We will do this on anniversary night, but until then, you will not touch me until after our dinner with those two." Starlight said as she kissed Trixie's neck.

"Ah... And when... will that... be?" Trixie asked as she panted.

"After our anniversary dinner. Now be a good girl and keep your hands to yourself."

"F-Fine..."

After complying with her demands, Starlight let Trixie go and she fell to the ground.

"See? Even someone as mischevious as you can behave yourself." Starlight said as she licked Trixie's pre-cum off her hands.

"You really need to show restraint. It really hurt when you grabbed me like that." Trixie complained.

"You'll live. Now go find a restaurant. We need to be ready for our double-date with those two."

"Yes mistress. Hey, when are they gonna be back" Trixie said as she got up while Starlight was preparing to leave.

"Few days. It could be long though. It's a friendship problem."

"Surprise, surprise. It's goody-goody two horseshoes to the rescue."

"Yeah well, at least we don't have to hear any of their songs."

"Right..."

After finishing up, Starlight left the castle to go look for Lyra and Bonbon while Trixie went off to search for a restaurant.

***

Meanwhile, Lyra and Bonbon were at home. Kissing and hugging each other, passion was the only thing that took existence as they were wrapping each other in their arms while in bed, naked with each other.

"Oh, you naughty girl~." Bonbon teased as she grabbed Lyra's butt.

"As naughty as you want, sweetie~." Lyra said as she licked Bonbon on the neck.

"You really know how to show a pony a good time~."

"Just like high school and middle school when we did it in the gym closets."

"Ah, PE class. Back when we were cheerleaders..."

"Well, I was a cheerleader. You played volleyball."

"It was a fun game. Plus, I were always there in that outfit you loved~..."

"I know. Every guy on the team was hitting on you and trying take you out on a date."

"And I turned them down..."

"They were jocks. Plus, I was already dating somepony while they wallowed in sorrow."

"Oh~? And who was it~?" Bonbon asked as she giggled.

"Guess, girlie~." Lyra said as she kissed Bonbon's navel.

"I will~." Bonbon replied as she moaned erotically.

Before they could go any further, they suddenly heard a knock on the door.

"Huh?" Lyra said.

"Now what?" Bonbon asked annoyed.

The knocking grew louder as they were still entangled in their embrace.

"Might as well go see who it is..." Lyra said as she got out of bed.

"Fine. Just hurry up." Bonbon said.

After getting a shirt and some shorts on, Lyra made her way to the door. Upon opening it, she saw that it was Starlight Glimmer.

"Oh, Starlight Glimmer! What a pleasant surprise!" Lyra exclaimed, feeling enthused.

"Hey. Are you two busy right now?" Starlight asked, feeling a tad nervous.

"Not at all. What can I do you for?"

"Well... is it okay if I come in? It's a secret."

Grumbling a little, Lyra reluctantly responded,

"Alright."

Lyra let her inside and took her to the living room to speak to her.

"Okay. Could you please hurry up? Bonbon's getting impatient." Lyra warned.

"I'll be quick. I was hoping that I..." Starlight asked before stopping herself.

"Huh?"

"Me and Trixie were..."

"Were what? C'mon, Starlight! Spit it out! What is it?"

"Uh..."

"Starlight Glimmer, it's me. Lyra Heartstrings. You can trust me. Just tell me what's on your mind."

"We were hoping we could go on a double-date." Starlight said really fast.

"What?"

"Yeah..."

"A double-date?"

Starlight solemnly nodded at her response.

"Sure." Lyra replied.

"Huh?" Starlight asked, feeling confused.

"Yeah! What didn't you say so? I would've said yes. What was wrong?"

"Well, I was afraid you would say no because you-"

"Geez, Starlight. It's natural to hide your sexual orientation. But do you remember when you solved your friendship problem yesterday?"

"Yeah...?"

"We were all over each other. Plus, we have been in this type of relationship since middle school. We don't care what other ponies think of us, but we just camouflage it as our friendship between me and Bonbon. But when ponies like you are with us, you can talk about it anytime you want. Okay?"

After breathing a deep sigh, Starlight said,

"Okay."

"So what do you and Trixie have in mind~?" Lyra lightly flirted.

"We're trying to find a restaurant, but Trixie's being picky right now, so bear with her?"

"Oh. Anything else~?"

"You'll see~."

Lyra giggled and said,

"We'll get ready. Just make sure it's extra spicy~."

"Okay then. Just tell Bonbon to wear her finest dress."

"Will do, my friend~." Lyra said before giving Starlight a light spank on her butt.

Starlight yelped and replied,

"Save that stuff for after dinner."

"Okay~." Lyra said as Starlight left the house.

After leaving Lyra's house, Starlight just has to help Trixie pick the best restaurant while choosing a good dress.