Sweetie, Applebloom, and Scootaloo sat down on the couch in the living room.

Though it was far too small for Bard to join them, Scootaloo was about to get up so at least one of them would sit with him, but Diamond sat him down in a huge chair that was in sight of not only the three mares who came in with him but Diamond as well who laid across the empty couch.

Scootaloo scoffed quietly. Of course she’d want an entire couch to herself.

“So, what made you want to bring him here?” Diamond mused, giving the three mares a casual glance before going back to eyeing up Bard like a hungry succubus.

“We thought it’d be a great idea for you to get more friends. Plus…” Sweetie began.

“He’s our stallion.” Scootaloo finished.

“Oh? A herd?” Diamond chuckled. “My… to think you three share everything with each other, a stallion wouldn’t be any different would it?” She didn’t sound accusatory, she wasn’t about to ruin her chances of getting close to Bard. She whistled loudly and immediately the butler from earlier rushed in.

“Yes, Ma’am?” He bowed.

“You three… ask for whatever you want.” Diamond said, motioning to the CMC.

The three mares look to each other, eyeing Diamond suspiciously.

“I may make fun of you three, but you’re now guests in my home. I’m not going to treat you terribly here.” She sighed before pausing for a moment, “And… I want to make up for what I’ve done in the past.”

The three mares shared a silent conversation.

“Alright. We’ll give yah a second chance.” Applebloom said.

Diamond smiled, this one a bit more genuine than she would have liked, “Great! Now, go ahead and ask for whatever you want.” She slowly sat up.

Soon the three mares were quick to ask for food and various drinks, some normal, and one or two wines that they’d share with Diamond and Bard.

They were giggly and quietly talking amongst themselves, their attention on Bard slipping.

Diamond slowly stood up, walking over to Bard, she sat down on the armrest of the chair. She cared little for the fact that his arm was there and now his hand was just beside her flank. “So, what brought you to Ponyville?” She asked softly.

The butler was quick to come back, bringing in some sandwiches, and the drinks the CMC had asked for. Their attention was still consumed with the food and drink, none of them having eaten yet.

“Well… I was abandoned on a bench by somepony who called me his friend.” Bard said.

“Oh? Who’d be so cruel as to do that?” She asked, slowly sliding her butt back so it was right against his hand.

“Thunderlane.” Bard said, though he took the hint and ran a few fingers over her luscious plot.

“Mmm…” Diamond muttered, glancing momentarily to the CMC before dismounting the chair and walking over to them. “Enjoying yourselves?” She asked with a smile.

“Yes! This is amazing!” Scootaloo smiled widely.

“I’m glad.” Diamond laughed.

Bard let out a small sigh.

“Oh… I’m so sorry. Did you want something too?” Diamond quickly asked, walking back over to Bard.

“Just something to snack on.” Bard said.

“Mmph!” Sweetie teleported a sandwich onto his lap. “There you go!”

“Thank you.” Bard laughed quietly, picking the sandwich up and slowly eating it.

“I’ll be back shortly.” Diamond said, slowly walking out of the room.

Sweetie, Scootaloo, and Applebloom shared a glance. “You saw her making moves on him, right?” Scootaloo quickly asked.

“Yeah…” Sweetie nodded slowly.

“Should we… call her out on it?” Scootaloo asked quietly. “The whorse is g-”

“Ah think we should let her.” Applebloom suddenly spoke up, confusing the hell out of her friends.

“What? If we do, she’ll try to lead him somewhere to fu-” Sweetie stopped herself. “Oh… Oooooh… Yeah, we should let her… Look. He isn’t going to abandon us over her. You two saw how dominant he can become… just think about if he dominated her. His… his cock is too damn big for me to feel any other stallion ever again…” She shivered, squeezing her thighs together. “If he takes her… well, we can just use it as an excuse for her to join us. Look, we’ve made it clear he’s with us. And… well a herd does mean open. But only if we accept the mares.” She rationalized.

“So… if we don’t like somepony… and they sleep with Bard…”

“They’re a slut.” Applebloom finished.

“Wait, wait… What about Pinkie, Rarity, Applejack, and Rainbow Dash?” Scootaloo asked.

“Well… of course they can decide to bring others in. But, if we have a choice in saying whether or not somepony like say… Diamond Tiara, Babs, Gabby, or Lilymoon can sleep with him.” Sweetie said.

“I think we should take a vote.” Scootaloo stated.

“I think we should let it happen if Bard decides to.” Applebloom said.

“I agree. Besides, he’s not a one-pump chump… he’ll be more than ready to go if we decide later to do something with him.” Sweetie nodded.

Scootaloo glanced to Bard for a moment. “Alright. If he decides to…”

“Look… if even one of us doesn’t want him to. We can go over and ask him not to take any more of her advances. Something tells me he’ll listen to us.” Sweetie assured.

“Mmm… I just…”

“He’s well hung… and you saw the way she was eyeing him up. If she sees his pride… well, she’ll have no more reason to make fun of us, right?” Sweetie offered.

“Fine… fine if he decides to fuck her senseless, I won’t get involved.” Scootaloo sighed, closing her eyes.

“Scoots… why don’t you come stay over with me tonight?” Sweetie offered. “The spare bed’s open… and well, Rarity said he mine all day… you could always come join us in bed.”

“Hmph…” Scootaloo huffed. “I dunno…”

“What about me?”

“All three of us can have a sleep over! It’ll be an orgy!” Sweetie said giddily.

“Mmmm… I like that idea.” Scootaloo giggled, the three of them immediately relaxing now. “Hey… why don’t we subtly make it known that we saw her?”

The other two mares paused.

“We should…” Sweetie nodded. “Try to convince her to join us fully.”

“That’s a great idea! If she doesn’t want to truly be our friend… well, we’ll leave with Bard. Or one of us can make it deathly clear he’s ours and she isn’t to touch him.” Applebloom nodded.

“It’s settled then.” Scootaloo grinned mischievously. The three went back to giggling amongst themselves.

Diamond Tiara walked back into the room, smiling sultrily for a moment over at Bard.

“Hey, Diamond…” Scootaloo began as she entered.

“We’ve been harsh on you too in the past… and well…” Sweetie continued.

“We’d love it if you joined us.” Applebloom finished.

Diamond paused and turned to them, a small blush flaring up on her cheeks. “W-what?”

“We’d like if you became a Cutie Mark Crusader.” The three other mares offered.

“I already have my Cutie Mark.” Diamond began.

“Pssh. That doesn’t matter, we just want you to be our friend.” Applebloom smiled.

Diamond’s face immediately fell as she suddenly felt bad. She regretted the anti-pregnancy potion she just took, she regretted making moves on Bard, and she didn’t know why!

“I… I…”

“If you don’t want to that’s fine… but at least we can be friends right?” Scootaloo offered.

“Gods damn it all…” Diamond sighed loudly. “What’s this about?”

“What do you mean?” Sweetie asked innocently.

“We’re giving you a second chance… and what better way to make it the last chance you’ll ever need by being our friend?” Scootaloo tilted her head.

“Like yah said, we share everything with each other… so, if yer gonna make moves on Bard, yah might as well take the full step and just join us.” Applebloom finished.

Diamond’s blush grew.

“Well… if you weren’t and we were reading you wrong… then don’t worry.” Sweetie said.

Diamond let out a long sigh. “Alright… fine. I’ll give it a try.” She muttered.

“Great!” The three mares grinned up at her.

“Um…” Bard began, now sporting a full erection that was made completely visible by his sitting position.

Diamond’s blush grew brighter, as did the three mares. They had completely forgotten he was sitting there.

“Your call now.” Scootaloo choked out, not able to take her eyes off his bulging crotch.

“Mmm… nnnnmmm…” Diamond muttered, rubbing her legs together. She looked back to them pleadingly. The three shrugged.

“I wouldn’t blue ball him after making it clear you wanted some… he’s a bit… dominant.” Sweetie said quietly.

“Well… c-couldn’t one of you relieve him? I mean you four are a herd!” Diamond retorted, not taking her eyes off the bulge.

“Sweetie’s the only one who’s slept with him so far.” Applebloom stated.

“It’s huge.” Was all Sweetie said.

“I want it.” Scootaloo muttered to herself.

Diamond let out a long sigh she wasn’t about to back down from a stallion. She was Diamond Tiara, daughter of the rich and powerful Filthy Rich. Some… dominant, massive stud wasn’t going to scare her.

“R-Rumble wasn’t that big…” She eeped out.

“It doesn’t hurt… i-if that’s what you’re scared of.” Sweetie assured. “It’s amazing once he’s in you… just if you can get beyond his need to dominate.”

“I can just go to the bathroom and relieve myself.” Bard offered.

“No!” The four mares said simultaneously. Bard shrunk back for a moment.

“Well… why don’t we all go somewhere private and… well you could each take a turn with me?” He suggested, trying to find something that’d work for all of them.

Now the four mares glanced to each other. “Well… I could dismiss the servants… send them on an elongated break… we’d have my room, or whatever other rooms we needed… or wanted… to use. Nopony to interrupt us.” Diamond began. “W-what do you girls think?”

“I need him in me at some point… t-the sooner the better.” Scootaloo muttered, her eyes falling half lidded as she made no real attempt to hide her arousal unlike the others.

“Well she’s decided.” Diamond joked, glancing nervously to the other two mares.

She saw Sweetie was eyeing up Bard hungrily, and Applebloom was squirming a little.

“Just… wait a bit, I’ll go tell the servants they’re free to go on break now.” Diamond sighed, leaving the room for a few moments. After two minutes she returned. “They’re gone now.” She said. “One of you grab him… we’ll start in my room.” She sighed.

Scootaloo shot up and latched onto Bard, kissing him deeply. The other three mares were quick to scramble up, and pulled Bard and Scootaloo with them to Diamond’s Bedroom.

Scootaloo refused to detach from Bard and was steadily feeling up his chest as they fell onto the bed.

“Wow… she’s really getting into it.” Diamond muttered.

“Hey, Scootaloo…” Applebloom began.

“NO!” Scootaloo ripped back from Bard’s lips. “He’s mine!”

She quickly was peeling off her clothes, falling off his chest as she struggled to strip. Bard was likewise quickly pulling his clothes off, throwing his shirt away and giving Applebloom and Diamond Tiara the first glimpse of his fully body. They didn’t start drooling until he had his pants off and his massive thick cock flopped out into the air.

“Holy shit.” The said at the same time.

The scent that flooded the room was intoxicating for them, Sweetie had already teleported her clothes off, helping Scootaloo with hers before the two started making out quite loudly so Bard would know what was going on.

Bard was aptly stroking his cock, making a show of it for whoever was still watching.

Applebloom and Diamond Tiara looked at each other and approached the bed, along the way they too were stripping, throwing their clothes to the ground. Now naked they got on their knees, and started nuzzling his stallionhood and balls, worshiping them eagerly.

“Oh gods… he smells amazing.” Diamond muttered, kissing his balls leaving lipstick marks all over the two glorious orbs.

“One of you, up here on my mouth now.” Bard’s command caused them both to quiver.

“Yah deal with his shaft… Ah’m gonna go ride his face.” Applebloom said, quickly mounting the bed she got down in a doggy position with her marehood over his face. The wet dripping alerted him to her arrival and he pulled her cunt down to his mouth, his tongue shooting out and sliding all around her wet passage. Applebloom moaned loudly, squirming atop his face, her tongue lolled out as he groped her flank and swirled his tongue around her depths.

Meanwhile Diamond hungrily suckled on his leaking shaft, her hands working to massage the two overflowing orbs that were producing a scent that’d have any mare acting like she was in heat.

Sweetie and Scootaloo watched in awe as Applebloom and Diamond serviced Bard like a god before they decided to join in.

“Diamond… do you want his shaft or balls?” Sweetie panted out, moving over to add her own licks and kisses to his throbbing meat.

“Mmnnn, they’re both amazing…” Diamond whimpered.

“We’ll switch!” Sweetie pleaded, licking the sensitive underside of his flare.

Scootaloo didn’t care, she was already rubbing her clit and marehood as she buried her face in his sack, taking one of his pristine breeding receptacle into her mouth.

“Hey… I-I have an idea… Let’s let Scootaloo service him… and maybe…” Diamond began to murmur. Sweetie leaned over top of his cock and kissed Diamond, the earth pony moaning loudly into her mouth as she climbed over Bard. For a moment he felt a drop fall onto his cock and his innate reaction was to thrust roughly up to sink into something. Diamond gasped as she was sure his cock would leave a bruise on her stomach, but it didn’t hurt and just caused her to shiver.

As Sweetie moved to kiss and lick her bruise Diamond moaned happily, falling back onto her bed beside Bard. Soon a puffy pink marehood was presented to her and she eagerly started to eat it.

Bard continued desperately licking and teasing Applebloom before pulling her off. “Go… help Scootaloo.” He ordered in a soft whisper. Applebloom giggled drunkenly, sliding off his chest. Now her scent was permeating the room.

With two mares working hard to pleasure his shaft he turned his attention to the two moaning mares beside him. He reached over and squeezed Sweetie’s rump before pulling her and Diamond closer. He bit and licked her flank, slowly moving to add his tongue right along side Diamond’s. Both mares moans grew louder as Diamond and Bard performed a strange hybrid of making out and eating out Sweetie.

Soon Scootaloo climbed on his chest, receiving an slightly angered growl from the horny stallion before he felt wet lips collide with his shaft, slowly sliding up and down it, slathering it in love.

He turned his attention to Scootaloo, pulling her head closer.

“I’m going to fuck you. And when I’m done you’ll be mine forever. All of you will.” He stated as though it were the truest fact ever spoken. The four lust drunk mares took it as such too. “Applebloom. You’ll be the one to make sure Scootaloo becomes mine.” He growled at the farm mare.

Applebloom pulled back from his sack which she’d been worshiping feverently. She was covered in his scent and sweat. She grabbed his shaft as Scootaloo was hauled up his chest for a few moments.

Scootaloo’s eyes were hearts and her wings flapped happily. “Please… please…” She panted out. He kissed her breasts, though they weren’t much bigger then a D cup. He still loved them, he loved everything about these mares.

Scootaloo tensed for a moment as she felt the godly flare spread her lips and Bard’s hands slide to her hips.

“Slow… or fast…” He whispered, nuzzling her neck lovingly.

“Fast… I n-need you in me!” She begged, shaking her hips to move his flare around and smear his pre against her needy cunt. The foal maker poised and ready to make her a real mare was ominous for the other mares watching, doubly so for Applebloom who could decide if it actually went in. They held their breath and were blown away as he forced Scootaloo down his entire cock. Her eyes bulged out and her tongue shot out of her mouth, juices instantly splattered across Applebloom’s face, causing her to stumble back onto her ass.

Scootaloo truly seemed to need it as she quivered and shook violently like some full-sized flesh vibrator. Bard patiently waited for her to ride the high down, his cock already was stuck in heaven within her, and he had all the time with them that he needed…

After nearly a good minute Scootaloo’s first orgasm ended and she panted and nuzzled his chest in the most loving and adorable way. “S-so full… I-I can’t be empty again…” She shook her head. Her whimper when he slowly pulled her back to his tip was heart wrenching. “W-why are yAH!” She came again as she was forced down to his hilt.

“I said I was going to fuck you… make you mine… and until I cum… I won’t stop.” He whispered, nipping her ear as he slowly sat up, resting her on his lap. “But… if this is what you’re like…” He nuzzled her. “I guess leaving you with my load in you will have to wait…” He kissed her neck a few times.

By now all the other mares were down at his feet, his balls consumed by three eager worshippers who were getting covered in Scootaloo’s juices.

“M-master…” Scootaloo whimpered into his ear.

Bard didn’t reply with words, quickly causing her to screech pleasurably as he thrust up into her. His balls smeared across the other mares faces and they fell back, looking up as their new god slowly stood, bracing Scootaloo in his arms.

“Right now… you all only exist to please me.” He growled, giving another harsh thrust into the quivering pegasus in his arms. Scootaloo clawed at his back and was slowly growing used to the feeling of her womb being stretched by cock.

The three other mares were in awe.

“This.” He pulled out of Scootaloo until just his tip remained in her. “Will happen to all of you.” He growled biting her neck in a show of primal dominance as he slammed her back to his base.

“MASTER!” Scootaloo repeated louder this time. “USE ME!”

Now she wasn’t cumming with every thrust and Bard was keeping a steady and rough rhythm, nibbling and licking her neck in a manner that spoke to Scootaloo’s deepest instincts. She felt needed in his arms, and that flooded her heart with a steady warmth that flooded through everything.

Diamond got up and rushed to her dresser, pulling out a drawer and grabbing three bottles. She handed one to both Applebloom and Sweetie.

“Anti-pregnancy… strong enough to void heat. Trust me on that last part.” Diamond said quickly. Both mares quickly drank.

“B-Bard… c-can I…” Diamond began to say, for a moment Bard stopped his thrusts, and Scootaloo’s head fell limp, giving Diamond ample time to have her ingest the potion. Scootaloo whimpered as the liquid slid down her throat.

“N-nooooo…” Scootaloo squeaked. “G-get me pregnant…”

“Not now…” Bard whispered, dropping his dominant act and taking up an affectionate tone. He guided Scootaloo’s head to his neck. “You’re far too precious… all of you are… to spoil with foals right now…” He kissed her head.

It made their hearts soar that he’d swap his role in a matter of moments. If they weren’t desiring him before, now their bodies were just as needy as Scootaloo’s.

“I’ll cherish you all… and when they day comes that we’re all ready for foals… I won’t stop until you’re all pregnant… and we’ve made one giant family.” He whispered soothingly.

“Mmm… I love you, Bard…” Scootaloo whimpered softly, kissing his neck.

Bard picked up thrusting again, though they were small and caring, giving her more pleasure. “I love you too… all of you.” He smiled widely. Scootaloo panted and moaned happily with every thrust, she was happy that somepony loved her like this. She cupped his cheeks and kissed him over and over again, her walls rippling and massaging his cock with every hilt.

The three remaining mares watched in awe as his balls now throbbed with seed. The sane and rational side of their minds was thankful they’d taken the anti-pregnancy potions. But the primal part that his scent and dominance was drawing out made them regret it… it wanted to be filled with foals, turned into nothing but broodmares for the healthy and large stud.

“Here it comes… your first filling…” Bard whispered, hilting himself inside of Scootaloo. “Are you ready?”

“Yes! Yes!” Scootaloo nodded quickly. He grinned and dislodged from her. “Wh-what?” She was forcefully turned around to face her friends. They were watching her with an intense curiosity. “B-bAAARD!” She screamed as he bit her neck and slammed into her marehood again. His flare extending and making a very visible bulge for them to see. Her eyes widened as she felt the first shot of seed enter her. She then let out a long moan and the other mares gasped as they saw her stomach slowly expand.

“H-holy…”

“Nnnaaaah… f-fffiiiiillllll meeeeeeeee!” Scootaloo slurred, her legs kicking uselessly as he emptied what seemed like gallons of seed into the once virgin pegasus.

He let go of her neck and licked the spot he bit, shivering as his balls churned audibly. “After I’m done with her… who wants to clean my cock and take it next?” He nuzzled Scootaloo’s neck, letting his new cumdumpster smile widely as she felt so full.

The three of them sat in silence watching Scootaloo’s stomach balloon until it looked like she’d been pregnant for a full term.

They shivered and thought about ending up like that, and it just made their marehoods ache even more.

“Oh? Silence? Mmmm… Well, I’ll choose then.” Bard growled.

Scootaloo was in an utter haze as she was left feeling blissful and warm. He slowly dislodged his cock from her letting the last spurt of his cum shoot out and hit the three waiting mares.

He set Scootaloo down behind himself, just at the foot of the bed. His cum soaked rod dangled dripping Scootaloo’s juices onto the floor.

“Open your mouths… I’ll decide who I take next.” Bard ordered, the three mares obeying.

Author's Note

Ready for a four parter? I hope you're ready! First up to getting made into a cumdumpster is Scootaloo!

Who's next? Who do you guys want to be next? And what else would you like to see in the next chapter?