A girl’s secret

You made your way toward the school as questions started to run through your brain about a text you got on your phone this morning, it said:

Hey there, would you please come to Canterlot High?
I want to tell you something before I keep to my promise to you.
You won’t regret it, see you there?
Love, Sunset Shimmer.

You didn’t have questions about what her “promise” to you was, but more about how she got a hold of your number or what she wants to tell you. But you’ll learn the answers to those questions soon enough as you came up to the building and saw the girl in question standing in front of it, waving toward you with a bright smile on her face.

You waved back, only to stop mid-wave as Sunset motioned for you to follow her and started to walk toward the back of the school.

You brought your hand back down and followed her, thinking that, whatever she wants to tell you, isn’t for anyone else to hear. Sunset already behind the school long before you.

But as you did, however, were you greeted with a partially naked girl, already taking off her undergarments to make it compete. Once undone of her clothing, did Sunset walk up to you and pressed her body onto yours, her beautiful light orange marmaris being squished against your chest as she briefly kissed you lovingly on the lips.

You opened your mouth to speak when she released, but Sunset’s finger put a stop to that by pressing it against your lips and lowered herself toward your crotch, unzipping your pants when she got to her knees and taking your still hardening member out for some fresh air, not wasting any time as she already put it in her mouth before it could get erect to full length and started suckling it like if it’s a lollypop.

You shuddered and moaned softly as you felt her tongue going all over your erect mast, coating it in her saliva and started to slowly bob up and down.

Sunset started to moan as well every time she took it all in, the vibrations of her vocals going through your tip and making you roll your eyes to the back of your head with the amount of pleasure she provided.

With the way Sunset was giving you her best attention, didn’t it take long before your girth swelled and shot its seed down into her stomach, all the while she kept sucking and licking as to get every last drop your balls were willing to produce, gulping down everything.

‘Wow,’ You breathed as Sunset softly and lovingly slid your softened manhood back into its place, zipping your pants back up after, ‘what did I do to deserve that?’

Sunset got back on her feet and smiled, ‘Because the girls told me how nice you were to them, even how you helped Twilight with her insecurities,’ she hung her head as she got a sad expression, ‘she first told us what happened and asked if she wasn’t pretty enough. We all told her that she was beautiful,’ she looked back up to you, a slight smile forming on her face again, ‘but it seems she needed an answer from a boy. Luckily, you were there to provide it for her.’

You rubbed the back of your head with a hand, ‘Well, it just felt like something that I had to do, it was nothing.’

‘It was totally something!’ Sunset exclaimed, then cleared her throat before continuing on a softer tone as a slight rose tint made its way on her cheeks, ‘I mean, you made my friends feel wanted in so many ways without asking anything in return, making them trust you to no end.’ Sunset looked away as rubbed her arm with a hand and biting her lower lip, ‘which is why I want to ask you: can you keep a secret?’ the latter being said as if not really sure it should be asked of you.

You were taken aback by the question, ‘You trust me enough with a secret? Even though you don’t know me that well?’

‘It's because,’ Sunset said as she slowly made her way toward you and placed her hands on your chest, wrinkling the fabric of your shirt when she closed them and looked up at you with her big shimmering blue eyes, ‘I believe enough in you to trust you with this.’

You gulped as you watched the girl pres herself against you, ‘well.. sure, I’m able to keep a secret, but that still doesn’t-’

You were cut off by Sunset’s lips pressing against yours, ‘You’re as sweet as I knew you would be, but I think you should know this before we go.. at it.’

You raised an eyebrow as Sunset took a few steps back and got an insecure look on her face, you would’ve called it cute on her if you weren’t really confused at the moment. Sunset seems to steel herself as she took a deep breath, releasing it in one go as she said, ‘I’m actually a pony from another word.’

You just got more confused, ‘Huh?’

‘I’m actually a pony from another world,’ Sunset said a bit slower, her eyes filled with interpretation as to what you would do or say.

You just stared blankly at her. Sure, there had been some crazy things happening on the school, heck, even at Camp Everfree. You knew of another world that was filled with ponies as the dominant species due to that other Twilight who was supposed to have come from there, and from this world’s Twilight when she opened all those portals to the pony one. But still, it was hard for you to think that Sunset was actually a pony too, so you said the most intelligible thing you could as your brain thought of how to process this, ‘Uh-huh.’

‘It’s okay if you don’t believe me,’ Sunset said with a slight smile, she then grabbed you by the hand and pulled you along, ‘that’s why I also wanted to show you.’

‘W-wait,’ you started, shocked at the sudden movement, ‘w-what about your clothes?’

‘Clothes?’ She asked with a smirk, ‘Where we are going, you don’t need.. clothes.’

You watched wide-eyed as sunset moved to the pedestal of the old Canterlot High mascot that used to stand on top of it with no sign of stopping, even able to drag you along while trying to stop. You braced for impact as the girl reached the slab on the back, only to see that the girl passed right through and taking you with her.

You screamed (very manly) as you went through a, what you would call, rainbow tunnel, the colors and the intensity of the trip was too much for you and lost consciousness.

☆☆☆☆☆☆☆

‘Hey, are you okay?’ You softly heard the voice of Sunset call out to you as you came too.

Once you were able to open your eyes, you sat up from your position on the floor and were greeted by an orange pony with the same kind of hairstyle as Sunset, even the pony’s eye color is the same, ‘Are you alright?’ heck, even the pony’s voice was the same as Sunset’s, wait...WHAT?

‘D-did you just t-talked?’ You asked as you pointed toward the Sunset sounding pony, only to notice that your hand and fingers have turned into a hoof.

You were about to freak out, but the Sunset pony look-a-like put a hoof over your mouth, ‘Sst,’ she shushed, ‘relax, it’s me, Sunset. Only, I’m a pony now.’

You calmed down slightly, though you’re still unsure of what happened as you looked yourself over, seeing that you’re a pony too and aren’t indeed wearing any clothes, ‘W-what.. is all this?’ you asked as Sunset pulled her hoof away and you tentatively put your own on your pony nose.

Sunset stepped back and smiled sheepishly as rubbed her foreleg with the other, ‘I-it’s my… home. Equestria.’

It’s now that you noticed the horn on her head, but before you could ask about it, did a ray of sunlight came from a nearby window and shone on the unicorn, the distorted morning sun making her a beautiful sight to see for some reason.

‘What's wrong?’ Sunset asked as she saw your slack-jawed expression.

‘You’re.. beautiful,’ You breathed, though you didn’t really know why you did, though it had a great impact on the orange unicorn mare as her cheeks started to light bright red.

‘T-thank you,’ She said softly and moved toward you, giving you a passionate kiss before she nuzzled into the side of your neck, thanks due to her close proximity and her loving sent, you felt something shift were your lower region should be and saw something of a flat head crawling out of a sheath. It took you a moment to realize that it must be a horse cock.

Sunset stopped nuzzling you and looked at what you were gazing at, her eyes widening at the revealed shaft, a sly smile forming on her lips as she gazed hungrily at it, ‘It’s been a while since I’ve seen one of those,’ she said lustfully, her horn suddenly emitting a reddish aura, enveloping your body with the same color and you felt a force come upon you that guided you onto your back.

You gulped audibly as Sunset crawled over your body, ‘What are you-’ you tried to ask, but was silenced by a somewhat forceful kiss, her tongue shooting into your opened mouth and started exploring your confines, moaning softly as her appendage ran over your teeth.

Though surprised by the sudden affection of the pony girl, you melted into the kiss as well, wrapping a front leg around her neck and making your tongue dance around with that of hers until she broke it, ‘So, going by your.. friend here,’ she said with a smirk as she rubbed her sex over yours, ‘you don’t mind fucking a pony?’

With your brain out of commission because of all the things running through it, your libido took over and twitched profusely as a form of answer.

Sunset felt the movements against her pony pussy pedals and grinned, ‘I’ll take that as a yes,’ her horn lit up again and you felt your member move towards her opening, the girl moaning lustfully as it slid into her confines, her smooth inner walls lovingly massaging your shaft as it entered her warm depths.

All your thoughts screeched to a halt as the mare pierced herself with your ponyfied penis, your thoughts making way for the pleasure she was giving you as she took the member in all the way to the base.

Sunset hummed lovingly as she gyrated her hips in a circling motion whilst having her front hooves on your chest, making you groan in delight as you felt your dick being swished around within her confines.

‘You ready for the main event?’ Sunset asked in a hushed tone as she lowered her head toward yours until they were only inches apart.

You could only nod due to the big blue hypnotizing orbs looking at you.

Sunset brought her lips on yours before starting to slowly move her hips up and down while still maintaining the kiss, her tongue poking your teeth, asking you permission to enter.

When you allowed it entrance, she immediately shot inside and wrapped her wet appendage around yours, dancing around it as if prompting it to do the same.

You just felt like you were in heaven, your tongue swirling around hers as if in an integrate dance while your pony penis was being groped by her velvety walls as it went in and out her, both feelings sending you into a wave of bliss.

Sunset let go of the kiss to moan lustfully into the air and started to move her hips faster, wet slapping sounds echoing around the room you were in, but you didn’t really notice where you were as Sunset was all you could focus on, watching her sweat glistening body move as she slammed on to you, feeling her heat enveloping your dick, only for cold air to grasp it as she lifted herself off, making you groan when her warmth returned.

Before long, Sunset’s speed started to decline, gasping for breath as she tried to lift herself off of you with shaky legs and struggling keep it up. Not willing to see her tire herself out more, you placed your front hooves on her thighs and though you were still unfamiliar with your changed limbs, were you able to stabilize her and use your strength to help her move.

Sunset gave you a grateful smile as she was able to speed up her movements again thanks to your efforts.

Not wanting her to do all the work, you started to move your hips up when she came down and was able to match her speed, the both of you letting out sounds of pleasure every time your bodies met with a wet slap.

Even though you couldn’t hold this pace up for long, you could feel your girth swell up and noticing a familiar pressure building inside of you, ‘S-Sunset, I-I’m about to cum!’

The mare on top of you grinned as she found the energy to go even faster and she made her inner walls clamp around your shaft as if telling it to let go of its load.

Not able to hold it in much longer, you bring your body up to hers one last time before you release your load, getting Sunset hum in delight as you filled her with your essence, her inner muscles making sure you’re giving her every drop.

Once emptied, you drop to the floor with Sunset following soot, only to drape herself over you as you both panted from the exhausting endeavor.

Having caught your breath, you turn to look at Sunset with a smile, ‘Did you cum too?’

Your smile faltered as she shook her head, ‘No,’ she said before quickly adding, ‘but that's okay, it was your gift and I enjoyed every moment with you.’ she leaned in and gave you a kiss on your cheek.

You smiled slightly, but still felt she was left out. Sunset noticed that and started to slowly and lovingly stroke the hair on your head, ‘Hey, don’t worry, I really did love every moment of it and I don’t think any less of you for what happened.’

You wrapped a front leg around the back of her head and brought her in for a small kiss, ‘Thanks.’

Sunset snuggled up to you and yawned before she said ‘No problem.’ falling asleep shortly after.

You placed your head back on the floor, looking at the crystal ceiling before sleep got a hold on you as well.

☆☆☆☆☆☆☆

The both of you walked back out of the portal and you were back fully clothed again, but Sunset… wasn’t. So you quickly made your way to the back of the school where Sunset’s clothing should be.

Luckily, they were still there and Sunset walked over to the pile, bending over to retrieve them and giving you the full view of her labia in the process.

A grin formed on your face as an idea got into your head, your hardening dick twitching in agreement and you walked up to Sunset, taking your now full mast out in the process and grabbing a hold on the girl’s backside once close enough. Sunset let out a yelp and looked back, a wide grin forming on her face as she saw what you were doing and dropped her clothing before placing her hands on the ground while opening her legs up a bit more for a better entry.

Not waiting for a second longer, you brought your tip to her opening and pushed your cock all the way in one go, making her yelp, ‘Wow, you’re really antsy to go again, huh?’

You answered the only way you could think of, that was by starting to fuck her. First by pulling out really slow, enjoying the feeling of her walls clamping down on you in an attempt to keep you from leaving, then slamming back in with force, to which she let out a cry of pleasure.

You kept this pace up for a while longer, feeling the slight differences between her human innards to her pony’s, though it felt great either way.

Done with your warm-up and coating you manhood with Sunset’s natural lubricant, you started to move faster, pumping in and out of her like a piston, already panting heavily as you moved through the girl’s tunnel, while Sunset moaned and cried in pleasure every time you slammed into her.

Sunset’s panting grew more erratic as you went on, feeling your rod being squeezed harder with every second, closing your eyes and thinking of something else, hoping that you could at least hold on until you were able to get her off first.

You didn’t have to wait long as Sunset’s body became rigid and she let out a wail of pleasure, her inner muscles pulling on your member as her cum splashed all over it, giving you the signal to cum as well.

But before you could, did the girl suddenly flop to the ground, taking your dick out in the process and lay there while small spasms ran through her being as well as fluids seeping into the earth from her convulsing snatch.

As your man meat sprang free, did the cold breeze send you over the edge and made you spray your content over the now prone girl on the ground.

After you caught your breath, you realize what happened, ‘O shit, Sunset,’ you exclaimed as you bend over to her with a worried expression on your face, ‘are you okay? You didn’t get hurt, did you?’

Sunset just smiled as she shook her head, running a finger over a glob of cum that landed on her cheek and placed it in her mouth, humming in delight as she licked her finger clean.

Though the sight of a girl licking up your cum was hot as hell, you were more relieved that she was alright and let out a grateful sigh before offering your hand to her for her to take.

She accepted the gesture and you pulled her back on her feet, to which she thanked you by placing a kiss on your cheek, ‘Well, I think it’s time to go home,’ Sunset said as she picked up her clothing again and walked up to you, ‘thanks for a great time,’ she said, giving you one last kiss on your cheek before running off with a wave, ‘see you later!’

You watch her go as you gave her a light wave back in bafflement until she was out of sight.

Blinking a couple of time, you just shook your head, put your softened member back in its place and started to walk back to your home with a smile on your face.

To be continued

Author's Note

, A movie reference!

thought in canon, every pony would seem to get a new set of clothes as they go through the mirror, in this story, I decided to "switch" it off, it was for the best in my opinion.

Don't you think so?