New guy at CHS: The Mystic Realm

Later that night, the girls planned out their plan to take Cobalt's virginity, "So how are we going to determine who goes first?" Rainbow asked as she looked at her friends waiting for an answer.

They couldn't choose, and they couldn't argue about it or their plan will be heard by Cobalt. They then decided to do a classic. Pull the name out of the hat!

"Alright, all of our names will be put in this hat. We'll draw one tonight, and tomorrow night, we'll do the next one, and so on and so forth," They all nodded as Rainbow shook the hat up. She pulled the first slip of paper for it to reveal something she added in for something fun, "Oh, I'm glad this was the one that was chosen. Fluttershy," Fluttershy smiled, but Rainbow then said, "And myself!"

"Huh?!"

"I forgot I added that in. Fluttershy, we're gonna have a threesome with Cobalt!" Usually, Fluttershy would be embarrassed and mad beyond belief, but instead, she smirked and nodded.

"Very well then, I will enjoy it," This threw Rainbow off guard, but she didn't relent as she agreed.

"Likewise Fluttershy," They shook hands as they went on with the plan.

Later that night, they went over the plan one more time, "Remember, Twilight, you'll use the time lapse spell once we leave the room the next morning."

"Next morning? I don't remember that being part of the plan."

"Do you really think I'd pass up on sleeping with Cobalt? Ha, not a chance," Rainbow smirked as she saw how jealous the others got.

"Need I remind you that Fluttershy will be there as well?"

"Don't worry, she'll sleep on the floor," Fluttershy puffed her cheeks out as Rainbow said this, "Alright, let's get the plan underway!"

Both Fluttershy and Rainbow both waited outside Cobalt's door, both eager to knock, but too nervous to do so, "Well, knock on it Rainbow."

"Me? Why don't you do it?"

"Really? You're going to ask the shy one in the group to do it?"

"Point taken, but I'm too nervous to knock."

"So am I. I mean, I'm nervous around Cobalt all the time, but this is beyond my mental capacity!" The two whispered loudly back and forth, and they hadn't even noticed Cobalt watching them from his bedroom doorway.

"Can I help you two?"

They both stiffened up as they saw Cobalt who was shirtless in front of them, "Uh, we want to... uh..."

"Well?"

"We wanna sleep with you!" Fluttershy yelled at the top of her lungs. Much to the surprise of Cobalt and Rainbow, "I mean... please..."

"Is there a reason for this?"

"Well, we just wanted to apologize by making you feel comfortable while you sleep."

"Well, I did get a little too angry at you girls earlier today. Although, I would've expected something like this from Rarity, and you Rainbow. But you Fluttershy? Are you sure you don't drink?"

"Yes I'm sure, but it's my fault that you crashed through the wall..."

"It's fine. I got too angry. I'll let you girls sleep with me," Cobalt then winked as he walked back inside.

"Fluttershy, did you see that?"

"Yes, and did you see his body? It looks better than it did before!"

"But we saw it at the beach earlier."

"But I never noticed it until now. I thought it still looked the same, but he's more toned."

Rainbow glanced at Cobalt's body, and her eyes widened. He did have better body. His muscles were more defined, and it matched his perfect face. In Rainbow's mind that is. Rainbow couldn't take her eyes of Cobalt's body.

"Rainbow? Aren't you getting in the bed?"

"Oh, sorry..."

"It's a tight squeeze, but we can manage," Fluttershy was in front of Cobalt, and Rainbow was behind him. Fluttershy smirked as she turned around, and scooted back.

No, Fluttershy! Don't scoot back. That nice... ass... is going to... shut up Cobalt! Don't think like that. I know how much you want it, but you can't...

Cobalt soon felt his penis grow larger as Fluttershy started grinding on it. Cobalt shook, trying to hold in his pleasure, but enough was enough.

That's it! I don't care anymore!

Cobalt grabbed Fluttershy fiercely, turned her around, and passionately kissed her. Rainbow looked on in surprise at Cobalt's sudden action.

"Mhmm!" Fluttershy needed to breathe, but she didn't want to break apart.

"Hey! I wanna a turn," Rainbow ripped them apart, and planted her own lips on Cobalt's. Both of their tongues fought for dominance between each other.

Soon afterwards, Fluttershy did what Rainbow did, and ripped them apart, placing her lips on Cobalt's. This continued for at least 5 minutes before Cobalt pushed them away from him, "How about we get to the main event?" Cobalt slowly stuck his hands down the pajamas of both Fluttershy and Rainbow.

"Cobalt?"

"Uh..."

They both knew what was about to happen, and mentally prepared themselves. They soon felt Cobalt's fingers trace across their vaginae, sending them into a state of euphoria.

"Cobalt!"

"Oh man...!"

"Feels good huh? This is only the beginning," Cobalt slowly inserted his fingers as he slided them inside and out, sending them into a higher state of bliss.

With each moment Cobalt fingers them, they moan in complete ecstacy.

"I never knew could feel this great!"

"This is what I've been missing?!"

However, Cobalt soon stopped, confusing the girls. They hadn't even cum yet, and he stopped.

"I need some pleasuring too," Cobalt pulled down his shorty's to reveal his long, erected member. It looked to be at least 9.5 inches long.

"Can that even fit?" Both girls feared as they inched closer to it. They both stared at it intently before looking at each other. They both nodded before going to town on Cobalt's penis.

"Whoa, starting strong I see. Just how I like it...," Cobalt bit his lip as he watched the girls go to town on his erected cock, "Are you girls virgins?" They both nodded, but Cobalt chuckled, "Huh, it's hard to believe with how well you're giving this blowjob you two. Trying to impress me?"

"Oh be quiet, you're lucky we're doing this anyway...," Rainbow retorted, but she went back to doing what she's been enjoying.

Wow, they're really good. I never expected this amount of technique with their fellatio. I'm trying to hold back, but it's just...

"It's pulsating!"

"Come on Fluttershy, he's almost cumming. Do it harder," Rainbow yelled as she sucked with more tenacity.

Fluttershy took a deep breath, and took in Cobalt's entire cock.

She can deep throat too?! Holy shit!

Cobalt held Fluttershy's face down as he shot his warm, thick cum down her throat. Fluttershy eye twitched at the massive amount of cum she was taking in.

"Swallow it all Flutters..."

Rainbow watched on in awe as she saw Fluttershy gulp continuously, "No way..."

"That's it...," Cobalt slowly pulled his cock out as a small trace of saliva followed it, "Open...," Cobalt ordered. She opened her mouth too reveal nothing to be there, "Good girl. Now, on to the dinner," Cobalt pushed both girls on their backs, forcing them down. Cobalt's personality had made a 360 degree turn. Both of them were both scared, yet enticed, "So," Cobalt started, "who wants it first?"

Both of them wanted it, but Cobalt glanced at Rainbow, "You were left out Rainbow for that little bit. How about I start with you," Positioned himself in front of Rainbow. She could feel herself get hornier from this.

"Wait, Cobalt I'm not... Ah!" Before she could finish, Cobalt penetrated her vagina. The amount of pain and pleasure she was feeling was astronomical, "This feels awesome!"

Fluttershy looked on at the amount pleasure Rainbow was in. The pleasure was written as over get face and body. The more Rainbow moaned, the more intense Cobalt got.

"Oh yes... fuck me more Cobalt...," At this point, Rainbow had her tongue sticking out as Consult picked up speed.

"Hehe, I know you like this. Beg for more...," Cobalt demanded. Cobalt was a whole completely different person.

"Please... give me more... give me that succulent cum..."

"Ask, and you shall receive!" Cobalt gave one last fierce thrust. With this thrust, an electric aura surrounded both Cobalt and Rainbow as both of them climaxes at the same time.

Rainbow was now out of it. Her tongue was hanging outside her mouth after cumming. Cobalt then glanced at Fluttershy, "Uh..."

"You ready?" Fluttershy nodded as she seductively sat up to kiss Cobalt. They passionately kissed for another minute, gasping for air afterwards.

"I've been... waiting... for this Cobalt..."

"I know, so let's get on with it. I won't be so rough with you. I was just rough with Rainbow because you know... I knew she would like it."

"Alright..., but you can be rough with me," Fluttershy wrapped her arms around Cobalt's neck, and proceeded to kiss him again.

Once they broke apart, Cobalt chuckled, "It's hard to be rough when you kiss and act like a sweetie. But if you want it rough...," Cobalt paused, and smirked devilishly, "then you'll get what you want," Cobalt lifted her up, and penetrated her fiercely, breaking her hymen, "These aren't suppose to be broken, but you wanted it rough!"

"Cobalt!" Cobalt thrusted up as Fluttershy jumped up from the pain of having her hymen break. She was in pain at first, but she soon started to look more like Rainbow Dash, "Oh... Cobalt... you're big!"

"Don't have to tell me that... guh... I know...," Cobalt then dropped her down on the bed, and continued thrusting, "Beg, just like Rainbow!"

"Oh yes! Please cum in me Cobalt! Fuck me hard!"

"Oh, didn't expect you say that!" Even so, Cobalt did as she please, "And...!" Cobalt gave last good thrust, releasing his semen inside of her causing her to take the same ahegao face as Rainbow, "Whew, I needed that from you girls. I've been wanting to do that for a while...," Cobalt took a look at their bodies just laying there, "It wasn't that good... I think? Oh well, good night you two."

Cobalt cleaned them up, and around them, before setting neatly on the bed. He set down a sleeping bag on the floor, and hopped in it himself.

Now, to play along with the rest of their little plan...