Rarity was at Applejack’s, bound so she was stuck on all fours with her ass in the air as Applejack stood in front of her stroking her horse cock to get it hard. When she was fully erect, she grabbed Rarity’s hair and pulled her head up off the bed before ramming her cock down her slut’s throat.

Rarity lay there and took it. This was her life now.

“Do you want more, slut?” demanded Applejack.

No, I don’t want any of this, thought Rarity but her voice disagreed. “Yes Mistress.”

As Applejack continued fucking her throat, Rarity felt pressure on her ass and pussy as two cocks pushed their way inside her. In her head she was screaming at them to leave her alone but she heard her own voice moaning in pleasure and begging for more. As all her holes were pounded mercilessly she was in agony, begging to be left alone but her voice just begged for more. Granting her pleas, another two cocks pushed their way into each hole, threatening to rip her apart.

The entire school was watching this, she was in the middle of the hall and everyone was lining up to have their turn on the school slut. A sign next to her read ‘Free For Anyone’s Use’. The cocks behind her spent their loads insider her and were immediately replaced by another four, pounding her to breaking point.

Please stop! I don’t want this! This is rape! she tried to say but again she heard her voice saying something different. “Thank you Masters. Thank you for letting me be your cum dump.”

She felt someone grab her shoulders and the world went dark. They wouldn’t have her again. She lashed out into the darkness and made contact with a chin which produced a yelp from the figure she couldn’t see. She kept fighting against the darkness but the figure must have retreated.

“Rarity, it’s OK, please calm down,” said a concerned voice from the darkness.

Who was it? Why was she lying in something soft? They were worried about her. Sunset. Rarity’s thoughts finally caught up with her, she was in bed and she had just punched her new roommate.

“Oh my goodness! Sunset I’m so sorry. Are you alright?”

“Mmm, yes,” said Sunset, clutching her lip. “Are you?”

“No,” said Rarity quietly as she felt the tears rolling down her cheeks. There was no point in hiding it anymore.

“I’m going to put the light on, cover your eyes.” The searing light struck out from Rarity’s bedside lamp and dazzled both girls.

Sunset sat down next to Rarity on her bed, noticing the glistening streaks on her cheeks but didn’t bring it up. “You were talking in your sleep,” she said gently, “I didn’t know if I should wake you up or not but then you said something about being raped and I had to.”

Rarity’s tears started flowing swiftly as the nightmare came back to her. Sunset took Rarity’s hand in both of hers and held tightly as Rarity tried to stifle her tears.

“Do you want to talk about it?” asked Sunset after a minute.

Rarity broke down in a howl of tears, throwing herself on Sunset and burying her face in Sunsets chest. All Sunset could think to do was hold her and stroke her hair.

It took a few minutes for Rarity to compose herself and explain her nightmare to Sunset who could only stare in horror. Rarity couldn’t look at her as she was saying these awful things and stared at her own knees the entire time, subconsciously grabbing the hem of her nightdress. When she was finished explaining she still couldn’t look at Sunset, she felt she was a dreadful person for having these thoughts.

“How long have you been having these nightmares?” asked Sunset, placing a hand on Rarity’s arm.

This contact brought a wave of silent tears from Rarity. “Months,” she whispered, “about a couple of times a week.”

Sunset was already having trouble holding her emotions back but hearing her friend had suffered these horrors for months was almost too much. She fought back her tears the best she could, she needed to be strong for Rarity. “You know Applejack would never do that?” she asked, her voice slightly shaky.

Rarity sat motionless, her tears running down her cheeks and into her lap. She couldn’t bring herself to say what she thought.

“You can’t think she would do that?” asked Sunset, shocked Rarity could even consider it.

There was still no response from Rarity. Sunset grabbed her shoulders and forced her to turn and look at her. Rarity’s eyes were red, her tears still flowing and her lip was trembling as she held back the sobs. Sunset blinked away the tears in her own eyes.

“Tomorrow we’re going to speak to Applejack, is that ok?”

“Ok,” whispered Rarity. “Would you stay with me tonight?”

“Of course,” said Sunset instantly, a few tears now flowing freely down her cheeks.

The two girls got into Rarity’s bed, Sunset lay on her back as Rarity’s cuddled into her and cried herself to sleep against her roommate's shoulder as Sunset tried and failed to be strong for her friend.

The next day the girls caught Applejack alone and Sunset acted as mediator as Rarity again relived her nightmare as she told it to Applejack. She was as appalled as Sunset that Rarity could even consider she would do such a thing. She reiterated that she had only ever done what she thought Rarity had liked and would never have brought others into their game.

Sunset had hoped talking things through with Applejack would calm Rarity’s mind and stop her nightmares but that night she was again woken by shouts of fear from the other side of their shared bedroom. Having learned from the previous night, she woke Rarity up by pinning her arms down as she tossed in her sleep. She knew this was maybe not the best thing to do to someone dreaming they were being raped but she didn’t want to get punched in the face again. As Rarity struggled into consciousness, there was a couple of seconds of panic before she recognized Sunset’s voice

“It’s OK Rarity, you’re alright, it’s just the two of us.”

Rarity stared up into the darkness with tears rolling down her cheeks. “I’m never going to be free of it,” she said, resigned to her torment.

“Do you want me to stay with you again?” asked Sunset.

“Yes please.”

The two of them spend another night together, with Rarity again cuddled into Sunset, silently crying herself to sleep.

The next morning, Sunset was awake before the alarm and discovered Rarity still clinging to her, lying with her head on her shoulder, one arm across her stomach and their legs were entwined. She looked too peaceful to disturb so Sunset lay awake and wondered if there was some other way to help her friend.

By the time the alarm went off half an hour later, she had came up with a solution. She had read up on various aspect of psychology when she had first arrived in this dimension and she thought of something that might help. The problem was suggesting it to Rarity.

As Rarity woke up to the alarm she held Sunset tighter as she fought against the blare. Sunset decided to just come out with it. “You need to have sex with Applejack again.”

This snapped Rarity out of her sleepy state and into full alertness. “That’s what caused the nightmares, how is doing it again and risking that slut stealing my body going to help?”

“Because I believe you’re having trouble with your sexuality,” said Sunset, running through her reasoning, how accurate it was she didn’t know. “Your experience with Applejack has scarred you and you’ve avoided the subject anytime I brought up our time together. I think you need to prove to yourself that you are not the slut you fear you are and accept you like girls.”

“But I can’t have sex with Applejack. What if it goes wrong again?”

Sunset had thought of that. She took a deep breath before revealing her plan. “But what if I was there as well? I’d keep an eye on you and make sure you don’t go foggy. That way you’ll know you can trust yourself even around the one that caused it.”

“Are you suggesting a threesome?” asked Rarity after a long, awkward pause

“Well, I wouldn’t, necessarily, be involved. I’d just be there to.... watch.” Now she said aloud it was beginning to sound a little pervy. “Your fear is losing control and becoming the slut that controlled you, the only way to conquer that is to prove you can stay in control.”

“That does make some sense I suppose,” said Rarity, still rather unsure.

“Will you think about?” asked Sunset as she disentangled herself from Rarity and slid out of bed to go for her shower.

“I will.”

It was Friday before Rarity brought up Sunset's suggestion. She had been thinking hard about it and had decided anything was worth a try to rid herself of her nightmares. When she and Sunset arrived home after school they went to their room to dump their bags and Rarity took the plunge.

“We should do it,” she said.

“Do what?” asked Sunset.

“The threesome thing.”

“You mean the test to see if you can stay in control with me there to keep an eye on you.”

“That too, Darling.” Sunset’s insistence that it wasn’t a threesome was cute. “So what if we ask Applejack to come over on Sunday when I’m not working?”

“Right, but this isn’t to be anything seductive so none of your sexy underwear I accidentally saw in a drawer,” said Sunset, immediately planning every aspect of it. “You need to stay in power during this and if you’ve gone in trying to impress like you did when, you know, then it’ll be harder to stay in control.”

Sunset started going through everything they should do, should not do, signals in case the slut tried to take over and a myriad of other thing. Rarity struggled to keep up but greatly appreciated all that Sunset was doing to help her.

Come Sunday morning, Sunset and Rarity were waiting in their bedroom for Applejack. Sunset was trying to keep Rarity calm as she was beginning to panic about what would happen if the slut took over her again. After failing to verbally calm her down she had to step in and physically stop her talking when she started babbling about how Applejack would order her to restrain Sunset and then they would rape her and then she would be Applejack’s slut too.

After being literally shaken back to her senses, Rarity managed to calm down and they went over the plan again. Applejack hadn’t been informed about what exactly was going to happen as Sunset thought she wouldn’t do it, she thought it was just to help Rarity talk through her problems.

When Applejack arrived she knew the door would be open and headed in and up to Rarity’s room. When she entered she found the two of them sitting on the bed, both looked slightly nervous. “What’s going on?”

“We may not have been completely honest about what we had planned. It is to help Rarity make peace with herself but its a little more hands on,” said Sunset as she and Rarity stood up.

Applejack watched as Sunset placed her hands on Rarity’s waist and the two began to kiss, passionately. Applejack just stood and stared, she had never suspected those two were anything more than friends.

She continued staring as her friends became more immersed in their kiss there was a little moan from Rarity. Sunset then slid her hands up and began unbuttoning Rarity’s blouse as Rarity extended her arms out behind her and it slid to the floor revealing a normal, non-provocative white bra. Sunset’s hands then moved down and unzipped Rarity’s skirt which fell to the floor leaving her in just her bra and panties.

Applejack just stood there as Rarity broke off from her kiss with Sunset, strutted over to her with a sexy walk, placed her hands on her shoulders and kissed her. She wasn’t too sure about this but she saw Sunset out of the corner of her eye who nodded towards Rarity, indicating she should go with it.

With this push, Applejack let herself loosen up and returned Rarity’s affection. The warmth from Rarity’s lips was something she hadn’t experienced for a while, they had barley kissed since their first couple of encounters. After what felt like several minutes of this enjoyable warmth, Applejack let her hands reach out and touch Rarity’s smooth, porcelain waist before running her hands up and unhooking her bra.

Knowing Applejack was now into it, Rarity began undressing her, taking off her shirt, skirt and bra. She then stepped backwards towards her bed taking Applejack with her, making sure to pivot round as they approached and let Applejack fall backwards onto it. She took off her own panties and then Applejack’s before kneeling down between her legs.

Sunset sat down against the headboard of Rarity’s bed so she could keep an eye on her. Looking at Applejack lying naked on the bed, Sunset logically knew that she was hot, a toned, tanned blonde is always going to be hot, but there was just no sexual attraction for her. Rarity on the other hand, there was a reason the old Sunset had destroyed her so completely at the previous year’s Fall Formal. Looking at her naked body now, Sunset could feel herself getting hot.

This was the bit Rarity was most scared of, the part where the slut might take over. She looked over at Sunset to make sure she was in position to keep an eye on her and make sure her inner slut doesn’t take over. Sunset smiled and nodded as encouragement. Rarity took a deep breath to steady herself and placed a finger against Applejacks clit.

Applejack was astonished that this simple action caused a tingle throughout her body. As Rarity’s finger stroked along the length of her slit, she felt her warm breath against her clit and then another tingle as her tongue made contact. This was nothing like what she remembered. As Rarity worked her finger and tongue, alternating between licking and probing her pussy and pleasuring her clit, Applejack felt her breathing quickening as small moans started appearing from within her.

As Applejack was groaning, Sunset was watching closely for any sign of Rarity losing control. Unfortunately this meant she was watching someone she has a physical interest in, completely naked, pleasuring one of their friends. As a result, she was starting to feel a considerable warmth between her legs and knew she wasn’t going to be able to remain an impartial observer for long so, honestly, there was no point in trying. She got off the bed and stripped off before kneeling down behind Rarity and pressing herself in close as she reached around and started caressing Rarity’s breasts.

“Sorry, I couldn’t resist. How’s your head?” she whispered.

“It’s just me here,” she said as she reached behind her and ran her hand up Sunsets leg. She still couldn’t face up to her feelings herself let alone tell Sunset, all she could do was lust for her privately and take any chance that came along. “Could you get the vibrator?” she asked.

“Sure,” said Sunset, kissing Rarity on the shoulder as she got up and went over the bedside drawer where they had put it beforehand. She passed it to Rarity and knelt down behind her again, caressing Rarity’s breasts, toying with her nipples and kissing her neck.

Rarity took a few moments to enjoy the attention from the girl she unknowingly loved before going back to pleasuring the girl who traumatized her. She licked the tip of the vibrator before placing at between Applejacks wet lips. She kept her finger working on Applejack’s clit as she slowly began pushing in the vibe and then thrusting it in a little further with each stroke. As she was fucking Applejack with the vibe, she felt sunset’s hands reach down and between her legs.

“Could you stand up?” asked Sunset.

Rarity smiled as she stood up so she was still leaning on the bed, continuing to work the vibe in Applejack’s wet pussy, drawing out more soft moans. With her ass in the air she spread her legs to allow Sunset to kneel behind her and shivered as she felt Sunsets’ tongue run the length of her pussy. As the tongue teased along her lips, Rarity felt her hands run up her legs to squeeze her ass.

She tried to turn her focus back to Applejack and discovered that the full length if the vibe was already inside her and Applejack’s hips were grinding gently against it. She gave her a few full length strokes and then pushed the switch on the base turning the vibe on.

“Oh sweet heeee-Ahhh,” was all Applejack could say. “Yes, do that, do that!”

Rarity smiled to herself and kept up her smooth motions as the vibrations sent Applejack over the edge. As her shouts of pleasure and joy got louder, Rarity noticed that she was now toying with her own chest so she started fucking her faster with the vibe, deeply enjoying both being in control of herself and Sunset’s tongue pushing its way into her pussy.

As Applejack started to come down from her orgasmic high, Rarity kissed her pussy and then climbed up onto the bed, regretfully leaving Sunset behind. While on all fours straddling Applejack, she kissed her deeply, their tongues dancing as Applejack got a taste of her own juices. After a few seconds she continued crawling up the tanned, toned body below her and sat up on her knees so that her pussy was ready for Applejack’s mouth.

As Applejack picked up where Sunset had been forced to leave off, Rarity closed her eyes and let herself relax and enjoy her friend's tongue. She was in control, there was no foggy headed slut making her do anything. As Applejack’s tongue separated her lips and dived in, Rarity felt the mattress move and open her eyes to see Sunset in front of her with a huge smile on her face.

Sunset reached out a hand and placed it on Rarity’s cheek before gently pulling her in for a kiss. As their lips touched, Rarity felt like a shock had gone though her. The pleasure from the kiss was somehow greater than Applejack's tongue in her pussy, she felt like she was going to melt and collapse into a pool of orgasmic bliss from Sunset’s lips alone. She wrapped her arms around her to support herself causing her chest to crush against Sunset’s. The warmth was unbelievable, so much so, she nearly forgot about Applejack beneath her.

Using all her mental strength, Rarity pulled herself out of the kiss and leaned down to pick up the vibe she had dropped next to Applejack. She straightened up and licked the top while looking into Sunset’s eyes. Sunset smiled and nodded. Rarity positioned the vibe at Sunsets pussy, letting out a loud moan as Applejack grazed her clit with her teeth to reminder her she was still there. Composing herself, she slid the vibe into Sunset’s pussy. There was a lot of resistance even though Sunset was very wet, this was her first penetration. Rarity took a few thrusts until the whole length was inside a moaning Sunset and as she pushed in the full length, she hit the button.

It felt like an explosion to Sunset, the vibrations echoing throughout her body. It took her a while to acclimatise to the new sensations before she could even hold herself upright. Her voice was working by its own accord and there was nothing she could do to stop the joyful moans.

The sight of Sunset lost in pleasure-driven moans and Applejack’s tongue in her pussy was sending Rarity over the edge. Her hips were rocking on their own accord and, as Sunset saw when she was able to sit up straight and look into Rarity’s eyes, she was unable to focus on anything.

“Kiss me,” begged Rarity.

Sunset immediately did as requested and the instant their lips touched a spark ran through and Rarity climaxed. She threw her head back and let out a deep, primal moan of pleasure as she continued rocking her hips on Applejacks face.

Her hand was no longer able to work the vibe in Sunset’s pussy so Sunset reached down and placed her hand on top of Rarity’s to help her. This simple touch seemed to bring Rarity even more pleasure as she slumped forward, her free arm clutching onto Sunset as she moaned in sheer bliss.

After a minute of heavenly bliss, she began to calm down and resumed her kiss with Sunset that had been interrupted by her orgasm. All she knew was that she wanted her.

With Rarity’s orgasm ending, Applejack slid out from underneath her and sat up, looking at her two friends, realising that wasn’t just an act they put on when she had arrived, they were both eager for it. As she watched, Sunset was now struggling to control her body as she started moaning in her kiss and pushing Rarity’s hand to thrust the vibe into her hard and fast and it wasn’t long before she was unable to continue the kiss as she started gasping as her orgasm took hold of her.

To Applejack, she seemed to be clinging to Rarity as if she feared she was about to be dragged away never to return, the attachment between the two was clear to see. And now they lived together. Was the single bed against the opposite wall ever used? She decided she shouldn’t pursue that topic, not today, certainly.

As Sunset’s exclamations of pleasure stopped, she let Rarity slip the vibe out of her pussy who immediately brought it up to her own lips and licked the tip clean, making a point of showing Sunset this. She then tilted her head back and used a skill Applejack had forced her to learn. She slid the entire 6” vibe into her mouth and into her throat, wrapping her lips tightly around its base before pulling it out, sucking the entire length clean.

“That’s pretty impressive,” said Sunset as she got her breath back.

“A friend taught it to me,” said Rarity, looking over at Applejack. “I guess some things might be useful.”

“But are you still yourself?” asked Applejack.

“I am,” said Rarity happily, “It’s just me in my own head.”

“So, now you know you’re not a slave to the slut in your head, you think the nightmares’ll stop?” asked Applejack. “This was fun and all but I don’t think we should make a habit of it.”

“Probably a good idea,” said Sunset before turning to Rarity. “I think the extreme nature of your encounters may be a factor in this. When you get a boyfriend or girlfriend you should maybe keep it simple, one on one, nothing too kinky.”

Sunset didn’t notice the smile Rarity gave her at the mention of ‘girlfriend’ but Applejack saw it. She got off the bed and started getting dressed, this prompted Sunset to do the same much to Rarity’s disappointment. She had secretly been hoping they could just hang around naked together so she could try it on with Sunset again.

“So, what are you planning for the rest of the day?” asked Applejack when she was fully dressed.

“I don’t think we had anything,” said Rarity looking at Sunset for confirmation.

“How about a film?” she suggested.

“’Fraid I ain’t got time for a movie, I need to get back before lunch to help Apple Bloom with.... somethin’,” said Applejack, she felt so confident going into that excuse. “I’ll be best just heading back now.”

As Sunset was still getting dressed Applejack went over to the still naked Rarity and put her arm around her shoulder. “Just tell her,” she whispered.

“Tell her what?” Rarity whispered back.

Applejack looked Rarity square on. She seemed genuinely confused about what Applejack was talking about. “It’ll come to you eventually. See you both at school tomorrow.”

As Applejack left, Rarity wondered what it was she had meant. Unfortunately she was still very much in denial and couldn’t quite hear her subconscious saying she loved Sunset.

Author's Note

Apologies to those who were hoping for the Nightmare Rarity, the title was just to obvious to pass up.