Octavia, Vinyl, and Lyra are trying to put together a Hearth’s Warming Eve carol for all of Ponyville. Unfortunately, they get themselves into a musical disagreement, and end up turning on each other, each one thinking their style is superior to the others. Not even the town is free from the chaos, as they get in on the argument, and end up feeling upset themselves

Will Hearth's Warming Eve go on without a single carol, or will the three Ponyville musicians find it within themselves to compromise?

Concept for this story was given to me by my good friend, All Art is Quite Useless.

Pre-read by Dustchu.

Edited by Doctor Disco.

Audio Reading by Skijarama.

Art belongs to Brianblackberry.