Mare Do Well in Pony Asylum

by Himan1385

Rating: teen
Tags: Crossover, Dark, Adventure
Length: 1099

My Little Pony and Batman Arkham Asylum

WARNING: Contains some scenes and flashbacks from Cupcakes, but it will be toned down.

Jason, is a Pony that is the friend of Mane 6. But when the random murders start happening, he takes the suit of Mare Do Well, Jason and Spike try to solve it. But when he finds out whats happening, he will have the LONGEST Night of his life!

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2012-07-20 23:28:55 UTC

Lets start the madness!

The sky was a dark purple color, and the clouds were grey. Rain was pouring down on Ponyville. Jason walked to the SugarCube Corner. He opened the door that made a little bell ring whenever you open the door. His coat was drenching with water. Jason took a look around the place. It was almost empty, but there was 3 groups of people at different tables. The smell of cakes was in the air. He looked around again to only see Mr. and Mrs. Cake.

Where were Pinkie Pie and Dizzy Music? He thought to himself.

He then walked to the door leading to the basement. He put his left ear to the door to hear a slight scream. It was like a scream of pain.  He then opened the door and closed it. He went down a dark hallway to hear laughter and screaming.

Jason dashed to cover, hitting his arm in a pile of wood. He started taking off his coat and jeans.  He put down his normal clothing, and took out a golden belt from his bag . He was wearing the Mare Do Well suit, but only the part  below his neck. He then reached his hoofs behind his head and pulled down his mask with his hat on it.

Jason lifted his head over the wood pile. The room was dark, and there was rope hanging from the roof. Jason could make out which look like horse mannequins...with horse skin on it, diffrent ones too, like one that had a rainbow mane...wait a rainbow mane! And a one that looked like Applebloom....and a Griffion skull! Everything made sense now!

He looked over more to see only one light in the room. A Pink pony with pink mane, and a strapped down pony in lots of pain.

The Pink Pony turned her head to grab a blade to show her face. It was Pinkie Pie! Everything made sense now to Jason. Pinkie Pie was the murder! But why?

Jason only knew one thing, he had to stop Pinkie Pie!

He dashed to cover, to cover. Then, when he was close enough, he put his hoof under a part of his belt. A sharp metal blade shaped as a 'M' came into his hoof. The 'M' shaped blade had light reflecting off of it. This caught Pinkie Pie's attention. Pinkie Pie turned around and looked into Mare Do Wells eyes.

Both, Mare Do Well and Pinkie Pie had anger in there eyes.

Pinkie Pie face was horrible, eyes of fire, and she was gritting her teeth. Mare Do Well then chucked the 'M' Blade at her. The blade went so fast that Pinkie Pie had no time to move. The blade cut through her flesh in her left shoulder. The blade then stuck into the wall beside the strapped down pony. Pinkie Pie screamed as she dropped her knife on the ground and grabbed her shoulder. She looked up, anger in her eyes.

"Stop right now, Pinkie Pie!" He screamed at her. Pinkie Pie then chuckled.

Pinkie Pie picked up a rusted steak knife from the tools table.  She held it in her mouth as she charged at Mare Do Well. Mare Do Well also charged at Pinkie Pie unarmed.

Got to think fast. He thought to himself.

Pinkie Pie swung the knife at Mare Do Wells head, But  Mare Do Well slid under her legs and flipped on his hind legs behind her, seeing the strapped down pony. The pony was Dizzy Music! She worked at the SugarCube Corner, she was the only pony that really cared for him. She had her Cutie Marks cut off and her Unicorn Horn ripped out.

Jason, was mad. Pinkie Pie turned around and charged at him. But all the anger In Mare Do Well was released.

Mare Do Well kicked Pinkie Pie in the face. The power of the kick made her hit a wall and throw the knife in the air. Pinkie Pie lifted her head as the knife came down and put a cut down her face. Pinkie Pie's vision was blurry, she could hardly see, but she could see Mare Do Well's dark purple suit, and the mask's white eyes.

Pinkie Pie laughed her head off.

Mare Do Well grabbed her by the neck and lifted her up.

"You monster! You murdered your BEST FRIEND! And a pony without her Cutie Mark!" Mare Do Well threw her into a crates.

Mare Do Well picked her up and tied rope from the roof around her legs and arms. He picked her up and went up the stairs.

Pinkie Pie started laughing, harder and harder.

Mare Do Well busted open the basement door and threw Pinkie Pie into a table. All the ponies got up and backed away.

"I have found the murder!" Mare Do Well then said as he pointed at Pinkie Pie.

Mr. and Mrs. Cake ran out and gasped at the sight of Pinkie Pie.

Mare Do Well walked toward them.

"Mr. and Mrs. Cake, Pinkie Pie was the murder, look in the basement." He said to them. "I will take her to the Pony Asylum"

Mr. And Mrs. Cake ran downstairs into the basement with 5 other ponies who were medics.

Pinkie Pie was still laughing her head off. Mare Do Well then walked to her and picked her up.

"Call  Applejack, Rarity and Twilight to get here NOW." He said to them.

"Ok" The ponies replied as one ran to the phone to call them.

Mare Do Well then walked out into the cold, night rain and walked toward the Pony Asylum.

They walked on and on.

Pinkie Pie stopped laughing as she could see the sign 'Pony Asylum' through the 2 lights on the side, lighting the words on the huge gate.

Mare Do Wells suit was ruined with mud and dirt on the leg part of the suit. Mare Do Well opened the gates up and walked into the yard. Guards moved out of the way as he walked to the door.

"It now ends here for you Pinkie Pie." He said to her.

He then opened the door and walked into the warm prison.

He saw ponies being transported into cells and lots of guards.

The wall had pictures of the Mayor on it.

"So Pinkie Pie was the one behind this,I would have never known. She was always so kind to us." Aaron Dollars said to Mare Do Well as they entered into the elevator.

"I know, me too." Mare Do Well said back.

Halfway down the elevator stopped......