New Fluttershy's Wrath

by StormLuna

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Rarity, Fluttershy, Sex, Non-consensual, Violence, Pinkie Pie, Death, Alternate Universe, Twilight Sparkle, Anthro, Gore
Length: 13789

After taking Iron Will's assertiveness class, Fluttershy goes from being assertive to aggressive. When ponies confront her over her assertive behavior, she decides that they must be punished in the most unorthodox ways possible.

After taking Iron Will's assertiveness class, Fluttershy goes from being assertive to aggressive. When ponies confront her over her assertive behavior, she decides that they must be punished in the most unorthodox ways possible. She decided that nopony would ever treat her like a doormat again.

Trigger warnings: Cannibalism, bedroom violence and murder

Published 2018-01-07 18:30:06 UTC
Last updated 2018-01-07 18:30:06 UTC

Prelude: Putting Her Hoof Down

Prelude: Putting Her Hoof Down

A couple of days ago, Fluttershy was a doormat, nothing more than a doormat who let everypony trample all over her. Ponies could cut in line, mock her, laugh at her and belittle her all the time. That would change however after she took an assertiveness course from Iron Will. After that, she held her head up high and she had plenty of confidence, she had changed so much that she began calling herself "New Fluttershy." It would not be long after that though that her assertiveness became aggressive when she had to deal with ponies who tried treating her like a pushover. Eventually any little thing would set her off and unfortunately for her friends, they were not exempt from her increasingly volatile temper.

Fluttershy wound up dropping a letter in a puddle after giving a pony directions on how to find the Ponyville Tower. This caused her to go into a rage, such a rage that she threw him in the direction of the tower and was spotted by two of her friends, Pinkie and Rarity. Neither of the two were thrilled with what she did and thought she should know that she has gone too far.

This will for the most part be like Fluttershy's confrontation with Pinkie and Rarity in "Putting Your Hoof Down"

Rarity saw this and said, "Fluttershy darling, that's no way to behave!"

Fluttershy was not one bit thrilled by her friend's statement. She yelled, "Didn't you see what he did to New Fluttershy? He thought that New Fluttershy was a pushover!"

Rarity countered, "No he didn't, we saw the whole thing. I think you've taken this a little too far. You've gone from being assertive to aggressive."

Fluttershy yelled, "What? You just want New Fluttershy to be like Old Fluttershy!" She got up in Rarity's face and shouted, "Well that's not happening!"

It was becoming a bit more difficult for Rarity to keep her composure as she tried to keep herself from either yelling like Fluttershy or breaking down in tears. She said, "We want nice Fluttershy back, that is the Fluttershy we want back."

Fluttershy only became more agitated, "What? No, you want wimp Fluttershy back, you want pushover Fluttershy back, you want you can do anything to her and she won't complain Fluttershy back!"

Pinkie Pie, who had remained silent said, "Too many Fluttershys to keep track of, make it stop!"

Fluttershy couldn't help but think that Pinkie's statement was idiotic and was perhaps a sign of how truly stupid she was. She slammed her fist on her head and laughed, "What's the matter, is all this too complicated for your simple little brain Pinkie Pie?"

Tears began to run down Pinkie's face as she had never imagined that her friend would throw such an insult her way. This did not sit well with Rarity as she yelled, "Stop right now with the petty insults......."

Fluttershy was quickly growing tired of the conversation that she was having with her friends. Rarity was angering her further and further the more they talked and given the type of day she had, she needed to unleash some frustration and knew exactly who she wanted to unleash her anger upon. She slugged Rarity so hard that she knocked her out cold. Pinkie saw this and was in a state of shock. She gasped, "Fluttershy, how could you?"

Fluttershy gave her an evil grin and laughed, "New Fluttershy was getting sick of Rarity's whining."

She made a fist and aimed it at Pinkie, readying herself to strike. Pinkie saw this, cowered and begged, "Please don't hit me!"

Despite her pleas, Fluttershy knocked her unconscious and began dragging both of them towards her cottage. She had put up with quite a bit of stress that day and she figured that her two friends would be perfect for her to release all that stress upon.

A Horrific Wrath

After an hour of being knocked out, Pinkie and Rarity began to come to but something didn't seem right, they discovered that they were bound. Rarity discovered that she was tied to a chair and Pinkie was chained to a bed. Besides that, they also discovered that they had been stripped down to their undergarments and were in a dimly lit room. This bothered and scared them a lot but Rarity became even more scared when she discovered that she had a horn cap on.

The two screamed when they heard the crack of a whip and a sinister laugh. Despite being chained to a bed, Pinkie looked up to see a figure headed into the room. What would terrify them the most was when they saw who it was. This pony, like them, was wearing nothing but her undergarments and as she took a look at the two, she licked her lips and laughed, "New Fluttershy sees you two are awake."

They both were nervous but Rarity tried to remain calm, "Fluttershy darling, why are you doing this? Why are we tied up, why are we only in our undergarments and why do I have a horn cap on?"

Fluttershy was not overly thrilled with her question but did not wish to release any anger yet. She cracked her whip and growled, "Because you two want wimp Fluttershy back, because you two don't like New Fluttershy!"

Rarity countered, "We never said we don't like you, we just said we want the old Fluttershy back."

Pinkie added, "Yeah, we just said we want the nice Fluttershy back."

Fluttershy was not thrilled with either one of them but was beginning to get a bit aroused with the two mares she was holding captive. She wasn't sure about Rarity but she was pretty sure that Pinkie had never even been kissed, much less been involved in anything else. She walked over to the bed, glared down at Pinkie and asked, "So, you want the old Fluttershy back huh?"

Pinkie was a bit unnerved by her glare but remained strong. She replied, "Yes, I want the old Fluttershy back."

As she stared down at Pinkie, she couldn't help but stare intently at her enormous breasts and her large hips. She licked her lips and snarled, "Is that so?" She began to lean down and continued, "New Fluttershy is sorry but the old Fluttershy is gone forever."

She pressed her face down against Pinkie's and began to kiss her passionately. Leaning over like that wasn't overly comfortable so she decided to mount Pinkie and continue to kiss her. She wrapped herself around Pinkie tightly and began to moan in pleasure. Pinkie wasn't sure what to think about it but it did feel good yet she was scared at the same time.

Once Fluttershy broke the kiss she glared down at Pinkie and asked, "So, did you like that?"

Pinkie wasn't quite sure how to respond to this. She did like it a bit but her fear of Fluttershy was much worse. She replied, "Well uh....."

Fluttershy smacked her and yelled, "So, you didn't like New Fluttershy kissing you?" She got up, headed over to a shelf and grabbed a knife. She gave Pinkie a sadistic look and laughed, "Maybe you'll like this more!"

Pinkie shrieked in terror when she saw Fluttershy heading towards her. She began to please, "No, please don't kill me! I liked it, I really did!"

Fluttershy gave her a warm smile and giggled, "Oh I'm not going to kill you." She again mounted Pinkie and continued, "But since you are laying down, getting your bra off will not be so easy." She placed the knife under her bra and cut it off. She wanted her more exposed so she also slashed the straps in half. When she pulled the bra back, staring right at her were Pinkie's breasts and despite her being scared, her hard nipples.

Fluttershy licked her lips and laughed, "My my Pinkie, you sure are aroused for being so scared." She began to lean down and continued, "Maybe you do find New Fluttershy sexy!"

Shortly after she said this she began to suck on Pinkie's breasts and flicked her tongue on her nipples. This felt so good for Pinkie that for the moment she completely forgot the situation she was in and began to moan in pleasure. Fluttershy continued to suck harder and Pinkie's moans became louder. This brought out a lot of joy from Fluttershy but she was not about to make this a wonderful moment for her. She bit down on her nipple which brought out a loud, painful scream from her.

Fluttershy continued to bite harder until she finally bit part of her nipple off and could taste her blood. Pinkie was in a great amount of pain and tried to struggle. She yelled, "Fluttershy, stop! It hurts so bad."

Fluttershy broke her hold on her and raised up. She saw the look of pain on Pinkie and sneered, "Oh, so you don't like New Fluttershy sucking on you, do you?"

Pinkie screamed, "No, I do not like it!"

Fluttershy smacked her and yelled, "Well then, perhaps you'll like what New Fluttershy will do next!"

Pinkie knew what she would do next would likely be painful. She yelled, "I will not."

Fluttershy again smacked her before moving down. She took her knife to her underwear and began to cut them off of her, leaving her vagina exposed. Fluttershy licked her lips and said, "Oh my, your vagina is calling out to New Fluttershy!" She began to massage it and continued, "Oh don't worry, New Fluttershy is coming!"

Pinkie watched in fear as Fluttershy leaned down and began to suck on her. She forced her face in and grabbed a hold of Pinkie's hips. She began to moan in pleasure as she tasted Pinkie for the first time. Fluttershy wanted a whole lot more than mere sucking though. She grabbed her flanks and began to massage Pinkie, right where her cutie marks were. This brought about a great amount of pleasure to Pinkie and again, she began to moan and forget her situation entirely.

Fluttershy began to massage her flanks with more force causing Pinkie began to go into sensory overload and she started shaking. Her moaning became louder and Fluttershy began to probe her vagina with her tongue. At this point Pinkie was feeling nothing but pure pleasure and Fluttershy was anticipating the moment when Pinkie would give her a nice, tasty treat. Soon she began shaking harder and Pinkie screamed, "I'm gonna, I'm gonna, I'm gonna!!"

At that moment Pinkie flooded Fluttershy's mouth full of her nectar. Fluttershy intensified her sucking and tightened the seal around her so that not a single drop of cum would be wasted, Fluttershy wanted it all. Once she had drank every last drop, she pulled her head up and laughed, "My my Pinkie, you certainly taste good." She began to stroke her vagina and giggle, "And now New Fluttershy shall reward you!"

Fluttershy leaned down to her vagina and clamped down on her clit hard. Pinkie began to scream in pain and tried to struggle out of the chains that she was bound in, hoping that she could get loose but to no avail. This angered Fluttershy, a lot. She got up and yelled, "Oh, so you don't like New Fluttershy sucking on you huh?" She began spanking Pinkie and yelled, "Well since you don't like it you ungrateful brat, New Fluttershy has decided that you must be punished!"

Fluttershy took her knife to Pinkie's flanks and began to cut her cutie marks off of her. Pinkie began to cry out in agony, begging and pleading for her to stop. Rarity, who had been watching in shock and horror finally realized that this could not continue. Despite being bound to a chair, she lunged forward in an attempt to get Fluttershy to stop and this did not sit well with her. She stopped cutting on Pinkie and snapped, "Look Rarity, New Fluttershy knows you don't like what she is doing but...."

Rarity interrupted, "Stop it Fluttershy, stop it!"

Fluttershy immediately got off of Pinkie and stormed towards the same shelf where she got the scissors and grabbed a hack saw. She stomped on the chair so hard that it broke and Rarity wound up on her stomach. Fluttershy pounced on her and yelled, "Oh, so you're going to cause New Fluttershy problems huh?" She began slamming her face into the floor and yelled, "Well, New Fluttershy is going to solve this problem right now."

She again slammed Rarity's head into the floor, leaving her disoriented. Fluttershy took the saw to the base of her horn and began to saw it off, causing Rarity to scream in agony and go into convulsions. She threw Fluttershy off of her and began to cry out in agony. It would not take Fluttershy long to get back on Rarity and resume cutting her horn off. Once she got her horn completely cut off, Rarity blacked out and this did not please Fluttershy one bit.

She got up, began to stomp on Rarity and yelled, "So, you don't want to spend time with New Fluttershy, huh?"

Pinkie again began to struggle and shouted, "Who would want to hang out with you when you're mean like this?"

Fluttershy picked Rarity's horn off the floor and headed back to the bed. Pinkie knew that Fluttershy did not have good plans for her. She again began to struggle and begged, "Please Fluttershy, please don't hurt me any more."

Fluttershy gave her a sadistic laugh and began to ram Rarity's horn up into her vagina. She began screaming in horror as Fluttershy was ramming it up in her, pulling it out and then ramming it up in her again. Fluttershy couldn't help but laugh as the pain got worse and worse for Pinkie. It was not long until the blood began to flow out of her vagina and Fluttershy looked at it with a great amount of desire. Without saying anything, she pounced on her and began to suck on her vagina, drinking the blood as it flowed out.

Fluttershy began to moan in pleasure as she consumed the warm liquid. Soon though her thoughts turned elsewhere. She pulled the horn out of her and got up on her knees. She glared down at Pinkie who was crying in agony, which did not sit well with Fluttershy. She finally decided that she wanted to mark Pinkie as her property so she took the horn to her stomach and carved the words "NEW FLUTTERSHY'S SLUT" right into her.

Fluttershy couldn't help but laugh as Pinkie's crying had become more intense and the look in her eyes were full of more fear than they were earlier. She finally decided that she wanted to feel some pleasure rather than merely providing it. She took her undergarments off and mounted Pinkie. She leaned down and began to kiss Pinkie. Pinkie again began to struggle but Fluttershy would not allow this. She leaned Pinkie's neck up, wrapped her bra around it and snarled, "Lay still and maybe New Fluttershy will let you live!"

Pinkie froze when she heard this as she finally realized that Fluttershy may actually kill her. She did as ordered and Fluttershy began to grind her violently. She began to moan in pleasure and again started kissing Pinkie. She wrapped her arms around her neck and held her head in place so that she could be in complete and total control of her. Fluttershy's moaning became louder as the grinding brought her more and more pleasure until she was readying to climax.

When she got that close to climax, she quickly stopped grinding on her, turned around and slammed her vagina right on top of Pinkie's mouth. She began to spank her violently and yelled, "Eat New Fluttershy little filly, eat New Fluttershy!"

Pinkie did as ordered and Fluttershy began to moan in ecstasy, "Yes Pinkie yes! Eat New Fluttershy, eat her! Yes, yes, yes!"

After ten minutes of being sucked on Fluttershy finally climaxed and caused a flood of nectar to go flowing into Pinkie's mouth. It would not be long until Pinkie began to choke and struggled to get up. Fluttershy was angry that she would struggle so she pressed herself down on Pinkie further. Finally Pinkie couldn't take it anymore so she did the one thing that would get her abuser off of her, she clamped down on her clit hard enough that she drew blood.

Fluttershy quickly jumped off of her but went into a furious rage. She again mounted Pinkie and yelled, "How dare you bite New Fluttershy!" She took Pinkie's bra and wrapped it around her neck. She pulled it tightly around her and yelled, "Nopony bites New Fluttershy, nopony!"

She pulled the bra tighter and tighter around her neck. Pinkie began to gag and choke as she struggled harder and harder which only made Fluttershy angrier. The struggle continued for several more minutes until Pinkie finally fell limp. Pinkie began smacking her violently yelling and screaming at her. Finally she realized that Pinkie was dead. She smacked her and yelled, "This is what you get for yelling at New Fluttershy!"

She got off of her and then looked down at Rarity, who was coming to. When she got up and saw the blood that was not only covering Fluttershy, but had stained her sheets, she was horrified. She broke down crying, "How could you! How could you kill Pinkie!"

Initially Fluttershy had wanted to do to Rarity what she did to Pinkie but at that point she was far too angry to either give or receive any sexual pleasure. She headed back to the bed, removed the bra from Pinkie's neck and began to go after Rarity. Rarity knew what her plans were and would have none of it. She ran towards the door and yelled, "No, you will not kill me!"

Rarity began trying to open the door but it was locked. She continued to try and get it open but would be caught by Fluttershy. She threw Rarity to the ground, pounced on her and wrapped the bra around her neck. She yelled, "You want to turn New Fluttershy in, don't you? You want guards to make New Fluttershy a pushover, don't you?"

She turned Rarity over on her back so she could see the fear in her eyes. Fluttershy tightened the bra around her neck and began to slam her head on the floor violently. Rarity continued to scream in terror as she realized that she may not survive. As Rarity was nearing death, her eyes first were full of terror before finally giving a look of despair as she stared straight into Fluttershy's wrathful eyes. With one final slam into the floor, Rarity's skull cracked and she perished.

Fluttershy leaned down and listened for a pulse but heard none. At first she felt a great sense of satisfaction until she realized something. She realized that she was not only going to have to dispose of the bodies, but she would also have to dispose of the blood stained bedding and have to get washed up.

She yelled, "Damn it New Fluttershy, how could you not have thought about this. How could you not think about how you'd get rid of them!" She looked around with a scowl on her face and growled, "Well New Fluttershy, once it gets dark we'll have to take them into the forest and bury them."

Disposing of the Evidence

After having her way with a couple of ponies who she thought still wanted her to be a doormat, Fluttershy felt a sense of satisfaction yet disgust at the same time. She was satisfied that she was able to have a little bit of fun with them, was able to abuse them and was able to watch the life leave their eyes. What disgusted her was what was going to be more difficult, disposing of not just them, but the bloodied sheets on her bed without being caught.

While Fluttershy was waiting for the sun to set, she took a long, hot shower to cleanse herself of the blood that she had got not only in her fur, but in her mane and tail as well. She breathed a sigh of relief as the dried up blood washed off of her and down the drain but knew that she had a long night ahead of her, a long taxing night. Once she finished her shower, she got dressed before heading downstairs to where she had had her fun.

When she headed in, the first thing she saw was the lifeless body of Pinkie Pie, laying face up with her eyes still open. This brought out a smirk from her as she laughed, "Oh hey Pinkie, you comfortable?"

There was no response so she smacked the remains and yelled, "Figures, New Fluttershy shows you a wonderful time and you won't even talk to her?" She then walked over to Rarity's remains and nudged them with her foot. She asked, "So Rarity, are you going to ignore New Fluttershy too?"

Again there was nothing but silence so she began to stomp the remains and yelled, "Figures with you too. All New Fluttershy wanted to do was hang out with her friends and you two treat her like this!"

She then sighed to herself, "Well I suppose I better get this mess cleaned up." She then saw Pinkie's cutie marks laying on the bed and the knife she used to cut them off. At that moment she decided that she wanted to keep a part from each victim so she grabbed the knife and began to cut Rarity's cutie marks off as well. Once they were removed, she grabbed them and threw them in her freezer.

She returned to them and laughed, "Well girls, now part of you will always be with your closest friend, New Fluttershy."

Fluttershy then realized that she had better get to work so she dragged the two along with the bloodied bedding up to her front room and looked outside. Outside of a bit of moonlight, she saw nothing but darkness and heard nothing but silence. She grabbed her victims and laughed, "Well girls, let's get going! New Fluttershy needs to get this done before dawn."

She began to drag her victims outside and headed into the forest. Right before she got to where trees started, she dropped them and sighed, "How could you forget you'd need a shovel!"

Fluttershy headed to her shed and grabbed a shovel before returning to taking care of business. After dragging them for a couple of miles, Fluttershy figured that she had went far enough in that she could bury them and the bodies would never be found so she began to dig furiously as she knew that a deep hole would be needed since she was not going to dig them separate graves.

Despite digging at a furious rate, it still took her three hours to dig a deep enough hole that they would both fit in comfortably. She then proceeded to throw them in and couldn't help but smile as she looked down at them. She snickered, "So girls, comfy down there?"

She leaned down and asked, "What's that Pinkie, are you cold?" She stood up and laughed, "Don't worry, New Fluttershy can take care of that."

She grabbed the bloodied bedding and tossed it in before beginning to fill the hole back up. Filling the hole did not take nearly as long as digging it had so she was able to grab her shovel and fly back to her cottage well before dawn. When she got back to her cottage she couldn't help but feel a sense of relief. She was able to properly punish two ponies who she felt disrespected her, she was able to have some fun with them, spill their blood and was able to dispose of them properly.

When she got back downstairs she was not thrilled with what she saw. She had forgot to bury their clothes with them. She grunted, "Oh great New Fluttershy, how could you have forgot to dispose of everything?"

Fluttershy took a deep breath and continued, "Don't worry New Fluttershy, its not like anypony will be coming in here anyway and you do want to keep part of them around, right?"

Fluttershy laughed to herself, "That's right." She proceeded to kick the clothes under her bed before putting new linens on it and laying down to get some sleep.

An Unexpected Visitor

After getting a few hours of sleep, Fluttershy woke up. She felt drained from the energy that she had put into digging a deep enough hole for two bodies but at the same time she felt excited to start a new day. Her stomach growled and she said, "Well New Fluttershy, let's get some food in our system!"

Fluttershy headed to the kitchen to fix herself some food. That morning she had decided on eggs and waffles, which meant she would have to get into the freezer where she was storing the cutie marks of her victims. When she saw them she couldn't help but chuckle, "Oh hi girls! New Fluttershy is so excited to see you!" She had to move them to get to the waffles and she continued, "New Fluttershy would invite you out for breakfast but she only has a couple waffles left!"

She grabbed her waffles and put them in the toaster to cook while she was preparing her eggs. Once her food was finished, she sat down and began to eat. Her meal would be interrupted by a knock on the door. Fluttershy was not overly thrilled to be having company, especially during a meal. The knocking continued but Fluttershy was not about to answer the door until she had finished her eggs.

Once she finished her eggs, she answered the door and was greeted by Twilight, "Oh hi Fluttershy, can I come in?"

Fluttershy gave Twilight an odd look and replied, "Sure."

Twilight headed in and sat at the table. Something didn't seem quite right to her but she couldn't figure out what. After sitting for a moment in silence Twilight brought up what she initially planned on doing, "Fluttershy, have you seen Pinkie or Rarity today? I haven't seen them since yesterday."

The very mention of their names made Fluttershy nervous but she knew that she couldn't show any signs of weakness around Twilight. She asked in return, "No, New Fluttershy has not. Why do you ask?"

Twilight gave Fluttershy a curious look and asked, "New Fluttershy?"

Fluttershy replied, "Yes, New Fluttershy." Her voice became more confident as she continued, "Well, as you know for a long time Fluttershy was a doormat and would let other ponies push her around and she wouldn't complain."

Twilight had a nervous look on her face as she sighed, "Uh...."

Fluttershy continued, "Well no longer! Old Fluttershy was a doormat but nopony will push New Fluttershy around, nopony!"

Twilight asked, "Ok but what prompted this change? Why all of a sudden are you going with this 'New Fluttershy' thing?"

Fluttershy stared at Twilight and noticed something about her that she had not paid attention to before. She looked at her intently and realized that she found her friend hot, very hot. Fluttershy replied, "Oh it's nothing serious. Just come with New Fluttershy and she will show you."

Fluttershy led Twilight downstairs which confused her quite a bit. She looked around and asked, "Why are you bringing me down here and why is there a bed down here? I always thought your bedroom was upstairs."

Fluttershy replied, "Well this is New Fluttershy's guest room." She saw Twilight staring at some of her shelving with various objects on it and continued, "Oh and those shelves are where New Fluttershy stores some of her stuff."

Twilight looked down and saw what appeared to be a white horn that had been cut off. She used her magic to pick it up and asked, "What is this?" Her eyes grew wide as she began to realize what it was. She gasped, "Is this a horn?"

Fluttershy knew that Twilight would likely figure out that it was Rarity's horn and knew that she had to do something about it. As Twilight was analyzing it, Fluttershy began to make plans as to what she would do if Twilight was to figure out what it really was

After staring intently at the horn for a couple of minutes Twilight's eyes grew wide and she gasped, "Is this Rarity's........."

Before she could finish her sentence, Fluttershy smacked Twilight and yelled, "Yes it is Rarity's horn and now New Fluttershy must make sure that you don't let anypony know what happened!"

Twilight was horrified when she heard this. She shrieked, "Did you kill....."

Fluttershy grabbed Twilight and slammed her head on the floor hard enough that it knocked her unconscious. This made Fluttershy very happy because not only would she have a chance to at least hide everything that she had taken from her victims but perhaps it would even cause her to forget everything she had seen earlier. What made Fluttershy the happiest though was the fact that she would be able to fulfill her raunchiest fantasies, ones that she was certain that Twilight would like.

A Second Horrific Wrath

Roughly two hours after being knocked unconscious, Twilight finally came to. She was still a bit disoriented so she sat up and asked, "Ugh, what happened?"

Fluttershy approached her, sat down next to her and replied, "Twilight, you wound up fainting so New Fluttershy decided to get you laid down."

Twilight's memory was a bit hazy from what happened earlier but there was one thing that she knew was different and she spotted it right away. She noticed that Fluttershy was no longer wearing a larger shirt and pants, she was wearing a short skirt and a tight fitting tank top. She asked, "Fluttershy, what's up with the change in clothes, I wouldn't think you'd even own clothes like that, much less wear them!"

Fluttershy put her wing around her and replied, "Twilight, let's not worry about what I'm wearing. I want to make sure that you are ok."

When she slammed her head into the floor, Fluttershy had left quite a gash on Twilight's forehead. She leaned closer to her and began to analyze her. She was looking close and everything seemed to be ok. She said, "Well this cut on your forehead looks fine." Fluttershy then decided to move on to what she truly wanted. She shoved Twilight down onto the bed and pinned her down. She wrapped her legs around Twilight's and continued, "Almost everything looks fine, New Fluttershy just has to do one little thing!"

When Fluttershy pinned her down, Twilight couldn't help but blush. She saw Fluttershy giving her a seductive look and asked, "Oh and what is that?"

Fluttershy giggled, "Oh you'll see!"

Fluttershy leaned down and began to kiss Twilight passionately. She released her hands allowing Twilight to wrap her arms around her while Fluttershy began to yank on her mane, hard. The sexual tension between the two quickly began to build the longer they kissed and it wouldn't be long until they got up and began to remove their clothes. Once they were completely nude Twilight laid down and begged, "Take me Flutters, take me!"

Fluttershy was thrilled, very thrilled. She replied, "Don't worry Twily, New Fluttershy will. She pounced on Twilight and quickly wrapped herself around her.

Again they began to kiss but soon that wouldn't be nearly enough for either one of them. Twilight broke the kiss and ordered, "Take me Flutters, dominate me, own me!"

Fluttershy got off of her and giggled, "Oh you want New Fluttershy to own you huh?" She gave her a more intense look and asked, "So basically New Fluttershy can do anything she wants to you and you won't complain or object?"

Ever since the day she met her, Twilight had wanted to be in a situation like this and had fantasies about Fluttershy dominating her and treating her like she was her property. She excitedly replied, "Yes Fluttershy, you can do anything to me, own me, dominate me, I'm begging you!"

Fluttershy snickered, "Good, very good. New Fluttershy likes that idea!

She ordered Twilight to stand up and she got on her knees. She began to suck on her ankles before slowly moving up. As she continued to progress higher and higher, Twilight's breathing became more intense. When she reached her inner thighs, Fluttershy could smell something sweet, very sweet. She stopped sucking and giggled, "Oooh, you must really want New Fluttershy to dominate you, mustn't you?"

Twilight moaned, "Yes Flutters, dominate me please!"

Fluttershy gave her a seductive yet sadistic smile and began to nibble on her inner thighs, causing Twilight to giggle. Fluttershy was enjoying this and couldn't wait until she began the next process of dominating her. Once she reached her vagina, she began to suck hard and probe it with her tongue, causing Twilight to gasp loudly, "Flutters, yes baby yes! Oh Flutters!"

This was exactly what Fluttershy wanted to hear so she decided that since Twilight had been begging her to dominate her, that she would do exactly that. She moved her hands to her butt and moved her fingers to her crack. As her fingers made contact with her opening, Twilight begged, "Yes, do it Flutters, do it! Ram me, dominate me!"

Despite Twilight begging her to ram her, Fluttershy wanted to take this slow. She slowly began to insert her fingers into her opening and began to glide them in and out, going back a bit further each time. Twilight began to breathe harder the further back she went but she wanted to be punished. She begged, "Please Flutters, dominate me, punish me!"

Fluttershy decided that if she wanted to be punished so much she would beg for it, that she would fulfill her fantasy. She began to ram Twilight violently, causing Twilight to moan in pain but beg for more. While she was ramming her violently and going deep, Fluttershy's fingers were long enough that she could go back deeper and be even more violent. Eventually she was doing it to where her whole fingers were going up into Twilight and was thrusting so hard that Twilight began to shake. The pain was becoming unbearable for Twilight. She screamed, "Stop, please stop! It hurts so bad!"

Fluttershy pulled her face out long enough to yell, "You said for New Fluttershy to punish you and that is what she is going to do!"

Twilight pleaded, "Please stop! I said for you to dominate me, not abuse me!" Her pleading became a yell, "If you keep abusing me, I'm leaving and telling Princess Celestia about this."

Fluttershy gave her a scowl and headed towards the shelf where she kept horn caps like those she used on Rarity and grabbed a horn cap. She would not be thrilled when she saw Twilight light her horn up, attempting to teleport out of there. Fluttershy tackled her, held her down and forced the cap on her horn. She pulled Twilight up and laughed, "Better, much better! Now New Fluttershy can dominate you again."

Twilight knew that since she couldn't teleport out of there, that she could maybe get out of the door. She rushed to the door and tried to open it but like it was with Rarity, Fluttershy had locked it and would once again find herself on the floor. Fluttershy grabbed her by the ankles and drug her back to the center of the room. She got up, grabbed the knife that she had used on Rarity and Pinkie and ordered, "You said you wanted New Fluttershy to dominate you and she will dominate you, using any means necessary!"

Twilight froze when she saw Fluttershy holding that knife. She figured that she had better do what Fluttershy wanted if she did not want to wind up dead. She thought that maybe if she played a much more subservient role, that perhaps Fluttershy would start going easy on her. She asked, "I'm sorry master, what is it you want me to do."

Fluttershy gave her an evil grin and giggled, "Master, New Fluttershy likes that!" She realized that with Twilight suddenly behaving like this, that perhaps she could be even more brutal. She pulled Twilight up and ordered, "Now spread your legs wide little slave, Master was not done yet."

Twilight complied and Fluttershy resumed to what she was doing earlier. She was sucking on her and ramming her fingers violently into her. Twilight again began pleading with Fluttershy to stop but given that Twilight had tried to escape earlier, Fluttershy no longer wanted to dominate her, she wanted to punish her severely so she clamped down on her clit causing Twilight to cry out in agony.

Her cries caused Fluttershy to stop, but not out of mercy. She instead decided that the next phase of Twilight's punishment was due. She pulled her fingers out and released her hold on her clit and in a caring voice asked, "So little slave, you really want Master to stop?"

Twilight had tears running down her face as she begged, "Yes master, it hurts so bad."

Fluttershy got up, shoved Twilight down on the bed and growled, "Very well little slave, Master shall stop."

Fluttershy grabbed her knife, mounted Fluttershy and began to kiss her passionately. Twilight was terrified yet at the same time she was enjoying the kissing. After a couple of minutes, Fluttershy broke the kiss and ordered, "Spread you legs wide little slave, spread them wide for Master."

Twilight was not thrilled with the term "little slave" but given the situation she was in, she figured that it would be in her best interests to not object to it. Twilight did as ordered and immediately Fluttershy began to grind her. She began to moan, "Yes little slave yes! Master likes this, she really likes this."

Fluttershy continued to grind her harder and despite seeing Fluttershy holding a knife in one hand, she too began to moan in ecstasy, "Oh yes Master! Grind me harder, grind your little slave harder!"

Fluttershy continued to grind her harder and had started to kiss her again. Fluttershy was hoping that she could maybe get Twilight to enjoy their situation again instead of being either defiant or terrified so she sat the knife down and wrapped her arms around Twilight so that she could hold her down again.

When Twilight noticed that Fluttershy had set the knife down again, she wrapped her arms around her and pulled her deeper into the kiss. She did not do this because she was enjoying it, she did it so that she could perhaps lull her master into a false sense of security.

After another thirty minutes of kissing, Fluttershy broke the kiss and began staring intently at Twilight's horn. She grabbed her knife again, sat back, spread her legs wide and ordered, "Now little slave, give Master horn sex or else."

The very thought of inserting her horn into another pony's vagina really grossed out Twilight but she knew that she had better obey. She leaned forward and inserted her horn into Fluttershy's vagina. As soon as she had got it in, Fluttershy locked her legs around her head, tightening her vaginal muscles. She grabbed a hold of Twilight's mane, yanked on it and yelled, "Thrust Master little slave, thrust her!"

Twilight began to thrust her, bringing out squeals of delight. Fluttershy noticed that despite her horn not being overly long, that she had yet to insert it completely into her. She yanked her mane again and yelled, "Put the whole thing in little slave. Thrust Master harder, give her the pleasure she deserves!"

Twilight began to thrust her harder but it still was not enough for Fluttershy. She began to yank on her mane violently, pulling her in deeper and deeper and causing the thrusting to become harder and harder. As Twilight continued to thrust her harder, Fluttershy began to squeal in ecstasy, "Yes, oh yes little slave! Give Master what she deserves, give her what she demands!"

Twilight continued to thrust her and given that unicorn horns are very sensitive, she too was squealing loudly and was going into sensory overload. Despite her being terrified and not liking the idea of horn sex, she was very soon enjoying this as much as her master was. This brought a great amount of joy to Fluttershy, knowing that her little slave was enjoying this as much as she was. Fluttershy had done a great job at holding back her orgasm but after an hour she couldn't take it anymore. She squealed, "I gotta, I gotta, I gotta cuuuum!"

As she said this, a flood of cum flooded out of her and onto Twilight's head, soaking not just her, but her horn. She pulled Twilight out of her and forced her head to her mouth. She wrapped her arms around Twilight and giggled, "And now Master shall see how she tastes!"

She began to suck on Twilight's horn, causing her to begin to shake. Twilight moaned, "Yes, oh yes Master! Suck harder, suck harder!"

Fluttershy happily complied and continued to suck on her harder. Once she was done with her horn, she moved down to her head and began to smear the cum all over her face. She then leaned down to Twilight and ordered, "Lick it clean little slave, lick Master's face clean."

Twilight began to lick her face and Fluttershy continued, "You better swallow every last bit of it or Master will punish you severely!"

Twilight did as ordered and once she was done, Fluttershy threw her back down on her back again, began to eyeball her flanks and licked her chops. She giggled, "You know, Master sees something she wants, really wants!"

She crawled down further the bed, leaned down and began to suck on Twilight's cutie mark. Again Twilight began to moan in pleasure as cutie marks are almost as sensitive as horns. Twilight grabbed her mane and moaned, "Yes Master yes! Suck on your little slave, punish your little slave!"

When Fluttershy heard this, she decided she would do a lot more than merely suck on it, she decided she was going to eat her mark right off of her flank. She clamped down on her and began to rip the meat right off of her. Twilight began screaming in agony and started thrashing about. She was thrashing about hard enough that she wound up throwing Fluttershy off of her. She was able to rush towards the door but again would be tackled. Fluttershy locked her legs around hers and yelled, "No little slave, Master will not be denied. She wants your cutie marks and she is taking them whether you like it or not!"

Fluttershy got off of her, grabbed her by the ankles, drug her to the center of the room again and yelled, "You know what, Master is going to take them just like she took Pinkie and Rarity's!" She grabbed her knife, took it to her left flank and began to cut her mark off.

Twilight again began to struggle and this did not sit well with Fluttershy. She threw Twilight to the ground, sat on her and proceeded to finish cutting her cutie marks off. Fluttershy then threw them in front of Twilight and laughed, "And now Master must put these in the freezer after she does one more thing!"

Twilight knew that it would likely be killing her but she still had plenty of fight left in her. Using every ounce of strength she had, she was able to kick Fluttershy off of her and realized that perhaps the only way out of this was to use Fluttershy's weapon against her. She quickly got up, threw a punch at Fluttershy and caused her to drop her knife. Twilight was quickly able to grab it and when Fluttershy reached her, she was able to stab her in the side.

Fluttershy fell to the floor screaming in agony and when Twilight saw this, she knew that she had better get going. Again she tried to get the door open but still couldn't. She figured that if she couldn't open it, that she would kick it down. She began kicking the door but would freeze when she saw Fluttershy had pulled the knife out of her side and was charging at her.

Fluttershy again tackled her and yelled, "How dare you stab Master little slave." She grabbed Twilight by the head and again began to slam her face into the floor. Twilight continued to struggle so Fluttershy realized that she had only one option, she would have to kill Twilight. She grabbed her knife and held it to the struggling Twilight's throat. She slammed her head into the floor again and demanded, "Any last words little slave?"

Twilight tried to kick Fluttershy off of her but this time she had been weakened by the head trauma. She yelled, "I am not your little......"

At that moment Fluttershy slashed her throat to ensure that Twilight would not tell anypony about what she did. After sitting for a moment over Twilight's body Fluttershy knew that she would have to get that stab wound taken care of. Luckily for her, the wound wasn't too deep so she figured that she would be able to handle it herself.

She looked outside and noticed that it was still fairly light outside. She sighed, "Well New Fluttershy supposes that this will give her time to get this taken care of." She then kicked Twilight's remains before sneering, "And get New Fluttershy's disobedient little slave disposed of!"

A Disposal and a Confrontation

Several hours had passed and Fluttershy had not only showered, but got her wound cleaned up as good as she could. She looked out her window and noticed that the sun had set and that there was nopony out and about that she could see of. She knew that transporting and disposing of Twilight's corpse would be much more difficult given the pain she was feeling from her stab wound.

After a few more minutes of looking for other ponies, she kicked Twilight's remains and yelled, "Come on little slave, Master needs to take care of something."

She grabbed her shovel, grabbed Twilight by the ankles and began to drag her out of her cottage and into the forest. She noticed that like it was with Rarity and Pinkie, that she was leaving a trail and that was something that could not be. She began flapping her wings as hard as she could to lift Twilight off the ground but the pain was horrible for her. She began screaming loudly at first but then quieted down some so she would not be detected.

As she was carrying her victim's corpse into the forest she passed the site where she had buried Pinkie and Rarity. One part of her wanted to just bury Twilight in the same area but then she thought to herself, "Come on New Fluttershy, we know it hurts to carry her but we can't bury her in the same place! We must bury her further in."

The next hour would be filled with excruciating pain as Fluttershy continued carrying Twilight but once she got her over five miles into the forest, Twilight dropped her on the ground and sighed, "Well now little slave, time to get you buried!"

Fluttershy began to dig the grave but with the pain was horrible for her. The pressure on her side from digging was simply too much to take so she began to think about what else could be done. Her ears perked up and she said to herself, "We've got it New Fluttershy, let's throw her in that gorge by Celestia's old castle!"

Fluttershy knew it was still a great distance but figured that disposing of her that far away would be worth it. She also knew that she could simply grab the shovel on the way back so she threw her shovel down and continued to carry Twilight further into the forest. Despite it seeming to take forever because of the pain, Fluttershy finally got Twilight's remains to where she wanted them. She looked around and sighed, "This is at least a good twenty miles in so this will be perfect!"

Fluttershy lifted Twilight's corpse and set it to right where it was under the bridge and least likely to be seen. She snickered, "This is perfect New Fluttershy! Hopefully she won't be found and you can get away with wiping them out!"

Fluttershy had wore herself out quite a bit in carrying Twilight's remains so far so she looked at the castle and continued, "Well New Fluttershy, how about we spend the night in the castle?"

Fluttershy flew into the castle and began looking for a place that was not exposed to the elements in the event a sudden storm was to move into the area. As she continued to fly around the castle, she just couldn't find an area where Nightmare Moon hadn't at least somewhat taken the ceiling out so she had to settle for a place where just a small part of the ceiling had been damaged.

When morning arrived, Fluttershy woke up refreshed. While her side still hurt, she knew that she needed to get home and get some breakfast in her system so she took flight and headed home. As she saw the edge of the forest approaching, she felt a sense of relief but that would soon vanish when she saw Applejack, Rainbow Dash and Spike headed towards her cottage.

She sighed, "Oh isn't this just dandy. Now they'll probably find out what New Fluttershy did and then try to make her a pushover!"

When she arrived at her cottage she tried to head into her cottage but would be stopped when Applejack grabbed her. She asked, "Fluttershy, what are y'all doing coming out of the forest in the morning?"

Rainbow added, "And what's up with the shovel?"

Fluttershy became nervous wondering how she was going to answer this since normally she wouldn't be coming out of the forest in the morning, much less coming out of it with a shovel. She replied, "Uhh...."

Spike interrupted, "Fluttershy, have you seen Twilight. I know she headed over to see you yesterday but she's never gone for the whole night."

Fluttershy again struggled for an answer which prompted the three to think that something just wasn't right. Rainbow blocked Fluttershy's path to her door and asked, "Fluttershy, is Twilight ill and you decided to keep her with you."

Fluttershy grabbed Rainbow by the wing, threw her out of the way and yelled, "No, New Fluttershy did not keep Twilight with her! Why would she do that?"

The fact that Fluttershy would literally throw somepony out of her way caused the three of them to become more suspicious of their friend. Fluttershy turned to the three and yelled, "Now if you will excuse her, New Fluttershy just wants to get into her cottage and be left alone!"

As she unlocked her door and began to go in, she was grabbed by Applejack. She said, "No Fluttershy, something here doesn't seem right, it seems like you're hiding something." She tried to pull her back and continued, "And what is with this whole New Fluttershy thing?"

Fluttershy broke loose from her hold, slugged her and yelled, "New Fluttershy isn't hiding anything! Now if you will excuse her, just let her into her cottage or you'll be sorry!"

This caused the two to know something was up. Rainbow believed that she could perhaps restrain her better so she grabbed her and said, "Look Fluttershy, just let us in, see what is up with you and then we'll leave you alone."

Fluttershy knew that both Rainbow and Applejack were stronger than her but knew that if she did things just right, she could take one of them out and then maybe escape so when she opened her door, she pulled Rainbow in and slammed it shut on Applejack and Spike before they could get in. She locked it and had a look of pure rage on her face when she cast her gaze at Rainbow.

When she was looking around, it was not Fluttershy's facial expression she noticed, it was the trail of blood that led downstairs. She looked at Fluttershy in shock and gasped, "Fluttershy, did you kill Twilight?"

Fluttershy did not answer her. Instead she kicked her in the face and threw her down into her "guest room." Rainbow laid at the bottom of the stairs, disoriented. Fluttershy saw this as her chance to take a pony who not only knew too much, but who she believed would turn her in and make her a doormat.

Before Rainbow could come to her senses, Fluttershy pounced on her and began slamming her head into the floor until well after she had rendered her unconscious. Fluttershy did not want there to be even the slightest chance that her newest victim could escape. She then threw her up onto her bed and got her chained to it. She laughed, "Well New Fluttershy, now we just wait for her to come to and then you can fulfill another one of your fantasies, your darkest fantasy!"

Tasting the Rainbow

Fluttershy had grabbed her knife and was standing impatiently over Rainbow. She knew that Applejack and Spike were either going to contact Celestia via scroll or head up to Canterlot to snitch on her. She sighed, "Well New Fluttershy, if you're going to take care of this one, you can't wait for her to come to, you have to do it now!"

Like she had with Twilight, she stripped Rainbow down to where she was nude but she remained in her clothes. She did not find Rainbow attractive and had no desires to do anything sexual with her. She was however, still going to fulfill her darkest fantasy. She laughed to herself, "Well New Fluttershy, let's hope this one tastes good and hope she isn't taking steroids. Those would probably make her taste nasty!"

Fluttershy looked down at Rainbow's flanks and figured that like she had with the others, that she would cut off her cutie marks. The moment she began to cut into her right flank, Rainbow shook a fair amount and yelled loudly. This did not sit well with her so she smacked her and yelled, "Would you shut up? If you don't want New Fluttershy to fulfill her darkest fantasies, you'll keep quiet and do what you're told!"

Being cut had caused Rainbow to come to completely and she immediately began trying to flap her wings but could not get out of the chains, much less get airborne. Despite this, she had plenty of fight in her. She yelled, "Just you wait! I don't know why you're doing this but when Princess Celestia comes, you'll be sorry!"

Fluttershy smacked her and laughed, "Oh New Fluttershy doubts that!"

Fluttershy walked further down the bed and decided that it would be easier for her to remove her marks by simply standing over her rather than sitting on her since she was struggling. As Fluttershy resumed removing her mark from her right flank, Rainbow again began to yell but wanted to know something. She screamed, "Why are you doing this and what is it with this New Fluttershy thing?"

Rainbow walked up to her, slammed her fist down on her face and broke her nose. Fluttershy then got up in her face and yelled, "Well, for so long everypony always treated Old Fluttershy like a pushover." She smacked her again and continued, "Thanks to Iron Will, Old Fluttershy realized that can no longer be and New Fluttershy will punish anypony who treats her like that, anypony!"

Rainbow had heard a bit about how Rarity and Pinkie had confronted Fluttershy over her behavior. She asked, "Wait a minute, did you kill Pinkie and Rarity?"

Fluttershy growled, "Yes, them and Twilight. They thought New Fluttershy was a pushover so they had to be punished!"

Rainbow yelled, "I know you're mad but that's no reason to kill somepony, especially your friends!"

Fluttershy knew that if she kept on talking with her captive that she may not have time to do what she wanted to do and then head off into exile. She resumed cutting her cutie marks off and within a few minutes, she had a couple new prizes. She grabbed the marks and gave Rainbow a deep scowl, "Now don't go anywhere Rainbow Crash, New Fluttershy has to put these away."

Rainbow Crash, the same nickname that the bullies in flight camp had given her. Despite her having always put forth a tough attitude and truly needing to remain strong in this situation, tears began to run out of her eyes. When Fluttershy returned, she saw that Rainbow had tears streaming down her face. She punched her a few times and yelled, "Oh you poor little baby! New Fluttershy would think that you'd have tougher skin than that!"

Rainbow countered, "Well look at you, you cried all the time when they would bully you!"

Fluttershy punched her in the face and decided to move on to the next phase. She had her knife and couldn't help but stare at Rainbow's vagina. She couldn't help but laugh, "New Fluttershy bets a dumb jock like you is still a virgin, aren't you?"

Rainbow gasped, "Oh, and you're not this innocent little thing? You've seriously been with....."

Fluttershy laughed, "Twilight, yes!"

Rainbow asked, "Twilight, how could she pene....."

Fluttershy smacked her and laughed, "Horn sex you idiot and she is, or should New Fluttershy say was so good!"

Rainbow began to say something but would begin screaming in agony as Fluttershy began ramming her knife up her vagina. Fluttershy was getting a great amount of joy hearing her scream in agony and watching the blood flood out of her. While one part of Fluttershy wanted to have a taste, the other part of her had no desire to suck on Rainbow down south, no matter how tasty the blood looked, she thought sucking on a tomboy like Rainbow would be uncouth and disgusting.

After five minutes of non-stop stabbing her vagina, Fluttershy decided the time had come to not only make sure Rainbow never said a word about this to anypony, but to fulfill her darkest desires, ones she suddenly developed once she became assertive. She mounted Rainbow and gave her a sadistic look. Rainbow wanted to try and shake her off but all the stabbing she had endured so far had weakened her considerably. Despite being weakened by her ordeal, Rainbow was still defiant. She yelled, "You'll be sorry when Princess Celestia finds out about this! She'll banish you....."

Fluttershy punched her a few times and yelled, "Just shut up already! New Fluttershy is sick of your whining!"

Fluttershy decided that enough was enough and that if she wanted to get this done, that she had better do it before Celestia would arrive. She gave Rainbow a sadistic look and lowered her knife, ready to start cutting. Despite being unable to do so earlier, Rainbow tried to struggle hoping that maybe she could throw Fluttershy off but it was all for naught. She was far too weak to even cause her to lose her balance, much less throw her off of her.

Rainbow began to cry out in agony as Fluttershy began to dissect her like one would a frog. As the blood began to flood up through the wounds, Fluttershy began to lick her chops. It took her around twenty minutes to get the skin cut off that would be necessary for her to do what she desired. She then began to bite the flesh off of her rib cage, causing Rainbow to scream out in further agony. The loudness of her screams was hurting Fluttershy's ears but she decided to just deal with it and get the job done.

Fluttershy was devouring the flesh off of her rib cage and when she got her ribs cleaned off for the most part, she began the most difficult process, breaking the rib cage open. As she was trying to do this, she was grunting in frustration and Rainbow was crying out in agony, begging for Fluttershy to stop. Fluttershy couldn't help but laugh over the request, "What does it matter now anyway, you're as good as dead."

Rainbow continued to look into the sadistic look in Fluttershy's eyes and finally a feeling that she had never experienced before set in, despair. When Fluttershy saw this she smacked Rainbow and sneered, "Pathetic, absolutely pathetic!" She smacked her again and continued, "I wouldn't think some Blunderwolt wannabe would fall into despair like this! I thought they were tough no matter what!"

Rainbow screamed, "It's Wonderbol.....AAAHHH!"

Rainbow screamed louder than she ever had before when Fluttershy broke her rib cage open. Fluttershy watched in amazement at Rainbow's inner workings. She gasped, "Wow, the inner workings of a pony are amazing!" She smacked Rainbow and continued, "You know, you should take a look for yourself!" She broke down laughing, "Oh wait, you're too weak and injured to sit up so forget that!"

Fluttershy cast her gaze at the one thing she wanted most, the heart. She licked her chops and laughed, "Finally, New Fluttershy can satisfy her darkest desire" her laugh became more manic as she continued, "and there isn't anything anypony can do about it!"

She reached in and pulled Rainbow's heart out of her body cavity, slowly moving her face closer and closer to it. Rainbow had again began to plead with Fluttershy to spare her but she would have none of it. Rainbow let out one final scream as Fluttershy bit into her heart, causing her to perish. Fluttershy began to drink the blood before feasting on the flesh.

Once she had eaten the heart she began to look at her other organs. She knew that many of them would kill her if she ate them. At that moment she decided to focus on the lungs since they didn't contain any fluids like the stomach, kidneys or the liver did.

She gave Rainbow a smile and giggled, "New Fluttershy is pleased, this rainbow tasted a lot better than that nasty one up in Cloudsdale!" Her giggle became more manic as she continued, "What a shame Pinkie weren't here, New Fluttershy knows she would have loved this!"

Alerting Celestia

After rushing out of Fluttershy's cottage, Applejack and Spike knew that they had to get help. The first place they headed was over to Sweet Apple Acres to discuss things. Applejack asked, "Spike, what do you think is going to happen? Do you think Rainbow can handle her?"

Spike knew that Rainbow was tough but also knew that if Fluttershy was able to sneak up on her or distract her, that she could use her knife on her. He replied, "I don't know but I think that we better try and get in touch with Celestia."

Applejack said, "Good thinking Spike."

The two rushed over to the library where they could easily find some paper and a quill. When they headed in, Spike immediately grabbed some paper and a quill. He then headed to Twilight's ink well and discovered something that would make this more difficult, the ink had dried out completely. He gasped, "Applejack, the ink is dry!"

Applejack asked, "Does she have any more somewhere else?"

Spike replied, "I'm not sure, let me look."

Spike began checking in ever cupboard and corner trying to find some. When he couldn't, he began to tear the whole library apart. After fifteen minutes he said, "Applejack, I can't find any! We're going to have to go to Canterlot and tell her about this."

Applejack threw her hands up in the air and yelled, "Spike, that could take us a couple of hours at least and if Fluttershy took her weapon to Rainbow, she's as good as dead."

Spike yelled back, "Well we're just going to have to hope Rainbow got the best of her." He began to head towards the train station and continued, "Come on, let's get going."

Applejack nodded and followed him. Much to their dismay, as they arrived at the station, the train to Canterlot was just pulling out. Both of them were frustrated as the next train would not arrive and depart for another hour, which would make the time that it took to do this increase greatly. Both of them sighed in disgust over this. Applejack asked, "Spike, instead of doing this, do you think we should try to go and save Rainbow or just wait?"

Spike replied, "I honestly think we should just go and try to contact Celestia. Maybe she can talk some sense into her."

Applejack sighed, "Well for Rainbow's sake, let's hope so."

After an hour, the train to Canterlot finally arrived and the two boarded it. The trip seemed to take forever and to make matters worse, the train had to stop for an hour when the engine overheated. What was normally a forty minute trip wound up taking nearly two hours and by the time they reached Canterlot, both of them were frantic.

As soon as the train stopped entirely the two disembarked and rushed to the castle as quickly as they could. Much to their dismay, they were greeted by two guards at the castle gate.

One guard asked, "Halt, who goes there?"

The other guard added, "State your business."

Applejack replied, "Listen, we have to speak to Princess Celestia. We have news regarding her protege, Twilight Sparkle, that we must discuss with her."

The guard replied, "Very well, follow me to the throne room."

The guard's leisurely pace was irritating the two but they knew that it would likely not be in their best interests to either shove him or urge him to move along quicker. When they reached the throne room, both of them rushed up to Celestia. Applejack exclaimed, "Princess Celestia, we have an emergency!"

Celestia cast her gaze towards them and asked, "Where are the rest of your friends?"

Spike said, "This involves them! Here recently Fluttershy took an assertiveness course and suddenly she became mean!"

Applejack added, "And Pinkie, Rarity and Twilight have vanished! When Rainbow and I went to visit her this morning she was coming out of the forest with a shovel!"

Spike continued, "And she yelled at us and threw Rainbow into her cottage!" He became more frantic and continued, "What if Fluttershy killed them because she made them mad!"

At first Celestia found their claims to be far fetched, especially given Fluttershy's sweet nature. She then realized that out of all the element bearers, that Applejack would never lie like that. She knew that she would never make anything up like that. She sighed, "Well lets get going. If Fluttershy did manage to do something to Rainbow and your other friends, I fear that they may be in grave danger, or perhaps worse."

As they headed out of the throne room, Applejack and Spike were concerned as to how they were going to get back to Ponyville. They knew that Celestia never traveled on a passenger train and they also knew that her chariot was likely not big enough to accommodate all three of them. Spike asked, "Your Majesty, how are we going to get back. I don't think....."

Celestia grabbed them in her aura and replied, "This might make the two of you sick but I think it would be best if I simply carry you two down there."

Applejack said, "Well if we can save our friends, it will be worth it."

Celestia nodded and they took off. Celestia did a good job holding them to where they would not tumble and get dizzy but it still made them a bit woozy. Once they arrived in Ponyville, neither one of the two were able to keep their balance so they had to lay on the ground for a few minutes so if they had to handle an aggressive Fluttershy, that they would be able to do so.

A Fatal Confrontation

In her cottage, it had been an hour since Fluttershy killed Rainbow and ate her heart. After she killed her, she decided to gut her entirely just for the fun of it before feasting on her lungs. She looked down at the bloody mess that was once her friend and laughed, "Well Crash, still think you can treat New Fluttershy like she is a pushover?"

She put her ear down close to Rainbow's face and heard nothing. She smacked her remains and yelled, "You're just as bad as our other friends. New Fluttershy invites you in to talk and you won't say a word."

She grabbed her knife and cut out her lungs before she began to feast on them. While they had cooled down and did not provide Fluttershy the same warm meal as her heart had, she still devoured them. Fluttershy said, "Wow Crash, your lungs are almost as tasty as your heart!" She then smacked her remains a few times and yelled, "Almost, just almost!"

After a few minutes of laying on the ground, Applejack and Spike were finally able to stand up straight so they headed towards Fluttershy's cottage. Applejack looked up towards Celestia and suggested, "Your Majesty, I'd advise you be careful. If she has her knife and thinks you would treat her like a doormat, she'll likely attack you."

Celestia lit up her horn and replied, "I'm not worried Applejack. If she comes after me I'll just grab her in my aura so she shouldn't be a threat."

Spike said, "I certainly hope she won't be."

When they arrived at her cottage, Celestia knocked on the door and said, "Fluttershy, we need to talk."

They stood there for a minute with no response. Celestia asked, "Do you think she may not be at home?"

Applejack replied, "If she heard your voice, she'll know that you're probably here over what has happened."

Spike suggested, "Well you could always use your magic to unlock her door."

Celestia replied, "Well doing that is against the law but if your suspicions are correct, I think it would be warranted."

Celestia unlocked the door and the three headed in. Once they got inside they noticed that every single light was off and that it was deadly silent. Spike threw his hands up in the air and sighed, "Huh, maybe she isn't home."

Applejack looked down and saw a trail of blood leading down stairs. She pointed at it and said, "Princess Celestia, do you see that? Something is up because the Fluttershy I know would never have a trail of blood leading anywhere!"

Celestia whispered, "Keep it down in case she is down there, we want to catch her off guard."

They headed down the stairs and figured that like it was with her front door, that it would be locked. Celestia used her magic to unlock the door. When they entered the downstairs room, they would be horrified by what they saw. They saw that Rainbow had been gutted entirely, they saw numerous organs laying on the floor and found Fluttershy leisurely snacking on one of her lungs. Applejack gasped, "Fluttershy!"

Immediately Fluttershy grabbed her knife and charged towards the three. She knew that out of all of them, that Celestia would be the biggest threat. Celestia saw her charging for her and lit up her horn, readying herself to grab Fluttershy in her aura but Fluttershy would be much quicker than anticipated as she reached Celestia and plowed her knife straight into her gut.

This caused Celestia to fall over to the floor, screaming in agony. Fluttershy had pounced on Celestia and continued to stab her but Applejack was not about to let her kill the princess. She grabbed a hold of Fluttershy and pulled her off of her victim. Fluttershy screamed, "Let go of New Fluttershy now!" She broke free of her hold and slugged her. She yelled, "You're just like everypony else, you want New Fluttershy to be a pushover!"

Fluttershy was able to break free from her hold and again pounced on Celestia. Celestia was crying out in pain and begged for Fluttershy not to hold her. Fluttershy was able to stab Celestia in the gut a couple more times before Applejack pounced on her again. This time she was able to wrestle the knife away from Fluttershy, hoping that without her knife, that Fluttershy would stop with her aggression.

Applejack realized that Fluttershy's aggression was not the only thing that they had to worry about, she also knew that Celestia needed medical attention. She ordered, "Spike, go to the hospital and get help, Princess Celestia needs it!"

Spike headed out the door and replied, "Yes ma'am!"

While Applejack thought that without her knife that Fluttershy would calm down, that was not the case. When Fluttershy saw Applejack with her knife, she charged at her, bound and determined to get her knife back. She tackled her and pinned her to the floor. Despite having more strength because of the fury she was in, Applejack was able to get Fluttershy onto her back and was pointing the knife directly at her. Celestia continued to cry in pain and this angered Applejack further. She gave Fluttershy a scowl and ordered, "Listen to me Fluttershy, I don't want to kill you but if you try to hurt any of us, I'll have no other choice."

For Fluttershy this was not an option. She was able to headbutt Applejack, knock her off of her and in the process caused her to lose her grip on the knife. Fluttershy rushed to grab her knife but Applejack would pounce on her and in the fight for the knife, she was able to grab it. Fluttershy began to try and kick Applejack off of her. She knew that if Fluttershy was able to do that, that she may either try and hurt her or do more to Celestia, even without her knife so she felt she had only one option, she held the knife to Fluttershy's throat.

Applejack warned, "Fluttershy, I don't want to do it but I will if I have to."

Fluttershy continued to try and kick her off of her. She yelled, "You'll never get the chance! When New Fluttershy gets free, she'll kill both of you!"

Applejack continued to hold the knife to her throat and at that moment Fluttershy knew that she was serious. This did not deter her though, she realized that maybe if she calmed down and promised not to hurt anypony, that Applejack would let her go and she could do something to get her weapon back. She faked some tears and sighed, "I'm sorry Applejack, I'm sorry. Please don't kill me."

Applejack was unsure as to whether she could believe or trust her for a moment but she decided she would trust her. She got off of her and helped her up. She still remained leery and kept a firm hold onto the knife, pointing it at Fluttershy. Fluttershy saw this and sneered, "Oh, so you don't trust New Fluttershy do you? You're scared of New Fluttershy aren't you?"

Applejack replied, "Yes, I am and I'm not putting this knife down until......."

Before Applejack could reply further, Fluttershy charged towards her and knocked her to the floor, causing her to lose her grip on the knife. Fluttershy did not notice this as she had clamped down on Applejack's throat. She knew that this was now truly a kill or be killed moment. In the struggle Applejack was able to grab the knife again. She was screaming in pain as Fluttershy's bite became harder and harder. Finally she bit down hard enough that she bit Applejack's throat open but in her final moment, Applejack's arm slammed down and caused the knife to sink deep into the back of Fluttershy's neck.

Fluttershy screamed in agony as her neck was cut. She rolled off of Applejack and was screaming out in pain. She knew that with the way she was cut, that she likely would not last for long and decided that there was one more pony she had to take care of, one more pony who she thought wanted her to be a doormat that she must take out. She ripped the knife out of Applejack's hand and began to head towards Princess Celestia. Despite being severely injured, she saw Fluttershy lunge towards her and was able to get out of the way. When Fluttershy lunged towards her, she wound up falling flat and let out one final sigh.

Before Celestia could go to check on her, several medic ponies along with Spike came barging into the cottage. The first pony they rushed to was Celestia. One of them said, "Your Majesty, we've got to get you to the hospital at once!"

Celestia pointed at Applejack and Fluttershy. She replied, "I know but you have to check on them as well."

One of the medics, one that was a unicorn levitated the princess onto a gurney and began to take her out of the cottage and to the hospital. The three other medics that showed up went to check on them and discovered that both of them had passed. They also noticed Rainbow's corpse and one of them sighed, "Well, we better get the coroner over here to handle these bodies."

Another added, "Agreed but for now, we need to get Princess Celestia to the hospital."

Spike offered, "If it could help, I could notify the coroner about this."

The medic replied, "We would really appreciate that, we can't just let these bodies rot."

Spike headed off to notify the coroner over the situation and the medics proceeded to transport Celestia to the hospital. As they were transporting her, none of them could believe what they saw. They had seen ponies with multiple stab wounds before but never had they encountered multiple bodies. He sighed to himself, "What could have caused that to happen?"

Epilogue: Moving Forward

Epilogue: Moving Forward

Word of Princess Celestia's stabbing spread quickly as it was not even two hours after her admission to the hospital that she was visited by her sister. When Princess Luna saw her sister laying in a hospital bed, bandaged and looking rather weak, she rushed to her, hugged her and asked, "Sister, are you ok?"

Princess Celestia opened her eyes and replied, "Yes Luna, I'm ok."

Luna had not heard a whole lot about this whole situation except for what Spike had sent in what appeared to be a hastily written scroll. She asked, "Who did this to you? Who stabbed you like this?"

Celestia replied, "It was Fluttershy. I don't know what happened to her but she became rude, violent and arrogant. She kept referring to herself as New Fluttershy and spoke in the third pony. When Applejack and I went to confront her over her behavior, she attacked us."

Luna developed a fury in her eyes. She was enraged that anypony, especially somepony that her sister trusted would do such a thing. She slammed a fist into her other hand and snapped, "When I get my hands on Fluttershy she will......."

Celestia interrupted, "Luna, there is no need. She wound up dying in a fight that she had with Applejack."

Luna had always been fond of not just Applejack, but the Apple Family in general because of their work ethic, that and her love of their fritters. She asked, "What about Applejack, what happened to her?"

Celestia held her head low and replied, "During their fight, Fluttershy bit her throat open and they pretty much killed each other at the same time."

Luna shed a few tears and asked, "What about the others?"

Celestia replied, "Well Rainbow Dash was chained to a bed and every single one of her organs were removed and regarding the other three, I have this feeling that they are probably buried somewhere, most likely in the Everfree Forest."

Luna put her hand up to her face and stood there in shock. She just couldn't fathom that something like that would happen in Equestria, especially among those six. She held her head low and asked, "So sister, what are we going to do? Is there any sort of investigation that needs to take place or since they're all dead, is this it?"

Celestia replied, "All we can do now is move forward. With all of them being gone, there is nothing to investigate. We'll just have to send ponies into the forest to try and find the other three if they were buried there and we have to do something more difficult, retake control of the Elements."

Luna's eyes grew wide as she heard this. She asked, "Sister, how are we going to do that? Up until now, it was those six who were the ones they were connected to and with five of them, they are no longer in their original shape. They are in a shape that tied them to those five."

Celestia replied, "Perhaps with them no longer being alive, the connection between them has been broken and their energies will be tied to us again."

Luna gave her a concerned look and said, "Let's hope so or Equestria may be in grave danger."

Celestia was becoming tired so she nodded and yawned, "All we can do now is hope little sister. For now though, I am tired and I need to get some sleep."

Luna replied, "Very well big sister but I'm staying here by your side."

Celestia gave her sister a smile before closing her eyes and trying to get back to sleep. As Luna watched her sister slumber, she still couldn't help but wonder what would cause Fluttershy, the sweetest one of the Element bearers, to snap the way she did and spill so much blood. She did know that her sister was right though, that they would have to retake control of the Elements in the event of future crises.

The End