Author's Note

Naughty stuff featured: Kinda tender, if spirited, straight love-making. More emotions and less fetish than previous chapters.

As always, thank you to The Great Derpsby for the help.

Now, I want to announce one thing and ask one question to my readers. First of all, remember how, even though we haven't seen her yet, it was stated that Chrysalis had run afoul of Starlight and been turned into a rubber doll? Yeah I'm blatantly retconning that. I included that because I didn't think I could make future events of the fic adhere well to the show, but now I have an approach that I like. So keep that in mind, I'm going to remove or later the parts where they talk about Chryssie being captured sometime, so she's still out there, and she still plans on capturing the Mane 6 and the princesses. Sounds exciting? I hope so.

Secondly, the question: After reading through the chapter Catered, I wasn't completely happy with it. I realized Celestia didn't talk like herself, and things could've been expanded. Not to mention that I didn't show Luna doing anything with the rest of the Mane 6. So I'm considering editing and expanding that, and this is the question: Do you think it would be best if I just edited the chapter as-is, or if I write a separate chapter expanding on it? I know releasing the same content several times is against the rules, so editing Celestia's speech would have to be just a plain edit, but what about the rest of it?

Reunions, And Unions

Starlight Glimmer opened her eyes, and looked down at her new, naked body. Her form was just as filled and voluptuous as Twilight’s who was standing in front of her with a smile on her face.

“Thank you, princess!” she said, almost sobbed, and hugged Twilight.

“It’s alright, Starlight, I forgive you, and so does everypony else,” Twilight said, returning the hug, feeling Starlight’s soft form through her clothes.

“So you’re fine with what I did to you?” Starlight asked, worry evident in her voice.

“No, none of us are fine with you doing it to us. Not me, not my friends, Shining Armor, the princesses, or all those guards you transformed, but we’re now fine with the results,” Twilight said. “Don’t worry though, you’ve been punished. Water under the bridge.”

Starlight fidgeted nervously. “Well, I’m punished for turning you all into toys, but not for taking advantage of you,” she said. “Want to punish me for that as well? You know what makes me happy, at least what made my old body happy, but I never bothered to learn what makes you happy.”

“Well let me teach you,” Twilight said, and took Starlight by her hand to lead her to the bedroom. “How did you like reaching for a dildo without limbs like you had me do?”

“I learned to like it,” Starlight sighed, but with a sheepish smile. “By the way, what were you doing when you made me lose consciousness?”

“Oh, just experimenting with the transformation,” Twilight said. “I thought you’d like to be the test subject.”

“Well, I can’t argue with that. It was kind of hot,” Starlight said, before putting her hands to her mouth.

Twilight chuckled, and put her arm around Starlight. “I’ve removed the truth-magic from you in general, but you can’t lie to me,” she said.

Starlight blushed, and looked down, smiling.

Sunburst opened his door slightly, not being able to make sense of what he saw.

Firstly, the pony in front of him was the most beautiful mare he had ever seen except Princess Celestia, her form seemingly made to blast its way through his mind, kidnap his sex-drive, and commandeer his brain with it.

Secondly, she looked familiar, which was strange considering he would’ve definitely remembered her. He once caught sight of a good portion of Celestia’s thigh through her dress once, and years later he still dreamed of it.

Thirdly, this impossibly beautiful and sexy mare was looking at him apprehensively, nervously, even a bit scared. A stallion like Sunburst had the social low ground with normal ponies, even more so with beautiful mares, and this one seemed both openly submissive, and eager to see him.

Sunburst was very confused.

“Uuh, hello,” eventually managed to say.

“Hi, Sunburst,” the mare said, shuffling her hooves. “It’s me, Starlight.”

“... Starlight?” Sunburst echoed, and opened the door slightly more, trying to keep his gaze from travelling down across her form, hardly noticing that she didn’t have her unicorn-horn. “Wow, uh, h-hello. What have you been up to?”

“Uhm, quite a few things, actually, and uh… I’d like to… talk to you about some of them and… can we have this conversation indoors?” Starlight asked.

Sunburst glanced behind him nervously. His absolutely gorgeous childhood friend, who managed to look so incredibly sexy despite normal street clothes, was asking to come into his home, which was a mess.

He shook his head. His sex-drive was thinking for him, and he saw himself as above that. No mare had ever been interested in him, and Starlight would be no exception.

“O-of course, come in,” he said, and stepped aside. “S-sorry for the mess.”

Starlight smiled warmly at him, already getting ideas, as she dragged her wheeled luggage in with her. “That’s okay. Do you have time to talk?”

Sunburst’s mouth hung open as Starlight finished her tale.

“... And now I’m here,” Starlight said, and let out a small, nervous giggle.

Sunburst looked at the mare sitting in front of him in silence for a few moments. “Is that… is it all true?” he asked.

Starlight nodded. “Yes. I’m Princess Twilight’s toy, and she’s agreed to lend me to you.”

“But that’s… that’s impossible!” Sunburst protested.

Starlight looked at him in worry for a moment, before standing up, walking over to his couch, and sitting down next to him. “No, Sunburst, it’s just seems impossible.”

“And you’re… here, along with the all the princesses, and the elements of harmony?”

“Yes, and Princess Twilight would like to meet you tomorrow if that’s fine with you, she want me to be a better pony, and she says rekindling a friendship would be a great way to do so.”

“I just– I didn’t think that… Princess Twilight would be the pony to keep an involuntary servant,” Sunburst said.

“No, I’m serious, Sunburst,” Starlight said. “It’s all my fault, and I like being a toy, I want to be your toy.”

Starlight produced a parchment from inside her skirt. “Here, read this.”

Sunburst nervously took the scroll, and unfurled it.

After a moment, his mouth fell open again. “This… is… this really is Princess Celestia’s signature,” he said, amazed, before turning to Starlight again. “So you’re…”

Starlight leaned into Sunburst, and put her arms around him. “Yes, Sunburst, I’m yours,” she said happily. “Assuming you want me.”

“I… I,” Sunburst said, looking out into the distance. “I don’t want a… a slave.”

“Then don’t treat me as one,” Starlight said. “Let me be your friend in that case.”

“A friend that wants me to own her,” Sunburst said.

“Is that so bad?” Starlight asked.

Sunburst paused to consider this. “I… guess not,” he said.

Starlight raised her head to look Starlight in the eyes. “I’m a toy you can be friends with,” she said, happily.

“That sounds... fair,” Sunburst said, and squirmed a bit in his seat. “Although that thing about… uhm, the sexual aspect.”

“If you’re not comfortable with having sex now, let’s get to know each other some more,” Starlight said. “Although if you let me change into my maid-outfit, perhaps we can change your mind.”

Sunburst’s face slowly grew a bashful smile.

“Will you be my owner?” Starlight asked.

“Uhm… yes,” Sunburst said.

Starlight rested against Sunburst’s shoulder, letting out a happy smile. “What do I call you, Sunny? ‘Owner’? ‘Master?’”

Sunburst squirmed a bit. “I’ve uh, read stories about where one pony becomes a sexual servant to another, and I’ve never quite liked how they seem to lose their personalities.”

“Then for now I’m just Starlight. I won’t hide my personality unless you tell me to.”

“So what’s it like, being a toy?” Sunburst asked, looking down at the beautiful mare who almost glowed with happiness just being in his presence.

“It’s wonderful,” Starlight said. “It’s like getting your cutie mark all over again, only better. Just the thought of being played with and making other ponies happy makes me feel like everything is right in the world.”

“What about when you’re… not being played with?”

“If my owner is busy and is happier not playing with me, that makes me happy. Of course, it’s a bit frustrating to go even a short while not being played with, but in a good way. After a day it becomes excruciating, but... also in a good way.”

“So uh, what would you like to do?” Sunburst asked.

“Whatever makes you happy, Sunburst. You are my owner now,” Starlight said, and looked up into Sunburst’s eyes. He was a bit scruffy, and his fashion sense was strange, and he didn’t have a masculine, deep voice, but Sunburst was Sunburst, and not a persona that he hid behind. He was perfect.

“I’ve just,” Sunburst started. “I’ve never been… you know, involved with a pony… very closely before.”

Starlight smiled at her owner. “Then let’s go on a date,” she said. “We’ll ease you into it.”

“I’m not sure I feel comfortable leaving my house like this,” Sunburst said, and squirmed his pelvis.

Starlight looked down at Sunburst’s raging erection, and looked back into his eyes with a soft expression. “Don’t worry, we’ll do here. I’ll cook.”

“Aaw, goochy goochy goo,” Applejack said, and tickled The Baby’s belly.

The Baby giggled, and waved her tiny arms in response.

“She’s so cute,” Pinkie Pie said.

“Isn’t she just?” Cadence said, and smiled warmly down on her child as she cradled her in her arms.

Twilight managed to tear her gaze away from her niece, to look at her brother.

“So, how have you been doing?” she asked.

Shining Armor let out a tired huff, and looked sheepishly at his sister. “I can’t tell you how happy I am to never get tired anymore. I would’ve collapsed long ago if I could.”

“How are things going with Starlight?” Cadence asked.

“I think it’s going well,” Twilight said. “I’m collecting tons of data, and I’ve sent her to see her old friend. His name is Sunburst, and I plan on meeting him tomorrow.”

“Ah, I remember Sunburst,” Celestia said. “He could use a friend I think.”

Their dinner was eaten, and Starlight had noted with delight that no matter what her owner talked about, she loved every second of it. Sunburst hadn’t had a lot of ponies to talk to in his days, and finally got a chance to have somepony listen to him.

Her new special talent in being a toy made her a great listener and conversationalist, and it made her happy too. Sunburst, her owner, was happy, and while Starlight might not have had a heart in a physical sense anymore, she had feelings and desires, and so many of them were being fulfilled by allowing her owner to let things out.

They had talked on the couch, gradually scooting closer to each other. They had casually embraced, and after a conversation had run dry, Starlight had asked Sunburst if he wanted to show her the bedroom.

He did, seeming a bit sheepish over the unmade bed with the books littering it.

She smiled at him, pecked him on the cheek, and started cleaning them off, taking care not to disturb the bookmarks.

Throughout the whole date, and persisting into this moment, Sunburst had clearly been nervous about something, and Starlight was pretty certain she knew what it was; Sunburst’s confidence in himself as a lover. She had decided to take the kind and gentle approach, and try to not draw attention to it, and rather just put on an air encouragement which she was afraid might come across as condescending.

Starlight took Sunburst’s hands in hers, led him over to the bed, and started undressing him.

His erection had been obvious for almost an hour now. She pulled his shirt of him, and appreciatively ran her hands over his chest.

She pulled over own shirt off in one movement, showing her big breasts gently resting in one of Rarity’s most tastefully erotic brassieres. She cupped the undersides of them and jiggled them gently, smiling at Sunburst.

As she did though, he let out a small grunt, and winced.

Starlight’s heartless pulse skipped a beat as she looked down at his pants, and saw a stain forming at the end of his erection.

She looked up with an excited smile on her face, but only saw Sunburst’s horrified expression. He turned away, a pained look on his face.

“Sunburst?” Starlight asked, and gently put a hand on his shoulder.

Sunburst slumped. “I knew it,” he almost sobbed. “I knew it.”

“Knew what?” Starlight asked.

“I’m just, I’m,” Sunburst started, almost choking. “I knew I wasn’t any good at this!”

“Good at what?” Starlight asked. “Pleasing a mare?”

“... Yeah.”

Starlight stepped forward, and hugged Sunburst from behind, locking her hands over his belly. “Sunburst,” she said. “You haven’t done anything wrong.”

“But I just… you know,” he complained. “I’ve never tried being with a mare in my life. I knew this would happen.”

Starlight rested her head on his shoulder, pressing her warm body against his. “Sunburst. You just showed me that just seeing parts of me undressed is so wonderful that you came. I can’t tell you how happy that makes me... how flattering that is.”

“But this is–” Sunburst started, before Starlight cut him off.

“This isn’t the end of the night,” Starlight said, gentle, but firm. “I want you inside me, I want to feel your fluids inside me, and since you just shot some out, I’m going to have to work for the next ones. That excites me.”

Sunburst stopped quivering slightly as he considered this, and turned his head to look Starlight in the eye. “You mean that?” he asked.

“You bet I do,” Starlight said, and pecked him on the cheek. “Go clean yourself off, have a shower and calm down. Let me just prepare some things. I can’t wait for you to get back, but don’t be afraid to leave me to squirm a little.”

A smile was slowly growing on Sunburst’s face. “Alright, I’ll try and be ready again by then.”

Starlight let him go, but before he exited the room, she spoke up.

“Sunburst.”

“Yes?”

“Order me not to pleasure myself while you’re away,” she said, blushing.

Sunburst blushed as well, but they smiled at each other nonetheless. “Starlight… toy, I order you not to pleasure yourself while I’m away.”

“Yes, master,” she said. “I promise. And master? Please don’t get dressed.”

“I won’t, my toy,” Sunburst said, and walked out.

Starlight cleaned up the books from around the bed, changed the sheets, and retrieved a negligee from her luggage, then lay down on the bed, as she listened to Sunburst stepping out of the shower. She gently rubbed her thighs together, and put a hand on her first cutie mark, the one on her outer form.

She lay on her back, her hands snaking across her belly, gently rubbing the silken fabric against her, before her hands started travelling down towards her marehood.

As soon as her fingers just brushed against the soft texture between her legs, it was if she had been struck by lightning. Rainbow had once strapped her down and shot lightning through her, which was readily appreciated by both parties.

This felt like that, but with a tone of shame. Like pain and torture, which she loved, shame was also something she liked if her owner got any pleasure from it, but this was different. She felt like she had been very naughty.

Then she realized what was going on. Her owner had ordered her not to pleasure herself, which she had almost forgotten, and she had almost disobeyed him. It wouldn’t do for a toy to not obey her owner. She was ordered not to pleasure herself, and almost doing otherwise had filled her with so much shame that it was painful.

Of course, her realization of this, and the realization of just how completely she was Sunburst’s property, filled her with so much joy and pleasure that it overwhelmed the negative aspect.

Starlight smiled to herself, and hovered a hand above her marehood, biting her lower lip as she did.

“No,” she said to herself, and smiled. She brought a hand to her breast, resting it on it, before slowly starting to squeeze it.

“No!” she gasped, just before that feeling of shame returned. “No. I’m a good toy.”

She was a toy, but she was also a pony. A thinking, feeling pony. The pony part of her wanted to be free, to roam where she willed and do as she pleased. When she was limited and restrained, that freedom-thirsting part of her worried. It bucked and struggled, and felt tortured, but it could never ever break free from the cage that was her servitude to Sunburst, Sunburst’s ownership of her.

Her free part was restrained in sexy and humiliating garbs, chained thoroughly, gagged, blinded, and deafened. It was then squeezed into a box that was too small for it, which was weighed down, and cast into the deepest parts of the ocean. Even so, it was never broken. Throughout it all, it struggled.

That was only one part of Starlight. The rest of her loved her new fate, and used the energy, the spirit, the friction, and the conflict from her struggling part, and channeled that into pleasure for herself. She needed to touch herself so badly, but she couldn’t. Not until Sunburst allowed her.

All her victims would feel this way. Her curse made it so that they did. It might not be princessily to feel that way, but that’s what the princesses felt, she had made sure of that. She was rightfully shamed and punished for her actions, but she didn’t regret it. Thanks to Twilight outsmarting her and her subsequent defeat, she knew what paradise her curse had turned into.

Starlight put her hands behind her head, and very gently started rubbing her thighs together, longing for Sunburst to return.

Eventually, he did. Starlight looked towards the doorway to see him step in. He was only partially dried off, his mane still clinging to his neck and shoulders.

He walked in with a bit of nervousness, but Starlight still eyed him hungrily, and her eyes lit up when she saw the perfect, blemish-free form of his stallionhood, partially erect.

“Please tell me I get to have you inside me,” Starlight breathed as Sunburst approached the bed.

“Uhm, of course,” Sunburst said, remembering to sound confident in the last second.

“Also, please tell me I’m allowed to pleasure myself,” she said, rubbing her thighs together.

“Uh, yes. You can pleasure yourself, Starlight.”

“Mmm,” Starlight said, as Sunburst sat down on the bed, then she reached up and pulled him towards her. “Since you came earlier from just seeing me, I have an idea on how to make you ready again.”

“Uhm… what’s that?” Sunburst asked.

Starlight reached behind her and pulled out a shiny, black dildo.

“Just watch,” she said, looked Sunburst in the eye, and put the dildo to her mouth, sucking it like it was the most wonderful thing she had tasted, which in some ways it was.

“Mmm,” she moaned, and closed her eyes. “I wish this was you, Sunburst.”

Then she turned over onto her belly, and brought the dildo to her rear, promptly inserted it, and started pumping it in and out. “I so want you to do this to me,” she breathed, and looked at him.

His member was definitely growing, but he was looking at the scene with a bit of hesitation.

Starlight paused her pumping. “Too much?” she asked.

“Uhm, maybe,” Sunburst admitted. “I’ve never seen this before, but it feels a little unreal.”

Starlight stopped, and crawled over to Sunburst, lying on his chest and hugging him. “It is real though,” she said. “I love you, and I want to feel you, but I’ll tone it down if you want to.”

“I don’t mean that I didn’t enjoy it,” Sunburst said.

Starlight, dildo still in her rear, giggled at him, and crawled up a bit, resting her head over his shoulder, and wiggled her behind in the air. “Wanna give it a shot?”

“Uh, sure,” Sunburst said, and slowly reached for the dildo sticking out of his new lover. “I just… pull this in and out?”

“Yes. You normally discover what your lover likes as you go along, but I like everything, so you do whatever you like,” Starlight said.

“A-alright,” Sunburst said, and took it in his hand, as his other arm hugged Starlight’s back.

“Mmm,” Starlight mewled again, as Sunburst gingerly tested to insert the dildo into her, before pulling it out again. “Just like that.”

That gave Sunburst some confidence, and he started pumping the dildo in and out of Starlight faster.

Starlight started kissing Sunburst’s neck, which made him visibly relax. Smiling to herself, she took the hand he held around her back with, and brought to to her bosom. “Here,” she said, between kisses.

“O-okay,” he said, tensing up again, but started relaxing soon after, as he felt her warm, soft form beneath the silken fabric, and how she welcomed his touch.

Sunburst only relaxed in some ways though, as in he was becoming more and more comfortable with what was happening. In other ways he was getting excited, especially from Starlight’s approving moans.

Starlight looked down and saw his length standing at full attention, and put a hand on Sunburst’s cheek and raised herself up. He stopped pumping the dildo, and turned to look at her.

She smiled, bent down and kissed him, before gently breaking away. “I think you’re ready now,” she said, excitement clear in her eyes.

They looked down at Sunburst’s body, and his member twitched in confirmation.

They looked into each other’s eyes again, Sunburst still looking a bit nervous. “Ready?” Starlight asked.

“Uh, yes,” he said, and nodded.

Starlight scooted over so that she was straddling his upper legs with her lower ones, pulled the silken negligee off, and tossed it aside.

Sunburst looked up at her perfect form. Her big breasts, her firm belly, and her healthy exterior. His stallionhood twitched again, and he put his hands on Starlight’s hips.

Starlight took Sunburst’s member in one hand, gently parted her marehood for him, and lowered herself onto him.

Sunburst stayed entirely still throughout the whole thing, and let out a relieved sigh when he had entered Starlight entirely.

Starlight looked down nervously at Sunburst. “How does it feel?” she asked.

“A little scary,” he said. “But now it feels great.”

Starlight let out a sigh of relief, and bent down to gently kiss Sunburst.

“I’m glad,” she said, and took his hands in her’s. One she moved to her back, and the other to her bosom.

“Your turn,” she said, and melted into his embrace.

“Have you, uh, drank anything to come with?” Sunburst asked.

“No. I would’ve emptied it long ago if I had,” Starlight said. “I wanna earn it, so not before you come.”

“Uhm, wanna try drinking some?” Sunburst said.

“Sure, but why?”

“If I…” Sunburst said, and hesitated. “Drink some water, toy,” he said.

“Yes, master,” Starlight said, her insides tickling with anticipation. She reached for a glass of water she had put on the nightstand, and gulped it down.

“Starlight, listen to me,” Sunburst said. “As my toy, I’m ordering you not to come before me.”

Starlight’s eyes lit up. “Oooh, that sounds good.”

Sunburst started wiggling his pelvis, clenching and unclenching his buttocks to bounce Starlight and down himself.

Starlight collapsed against him again, as his hand kept massaging her breast.

“Mmm! Mm, mm, mm, mmm!” Starlight moaned, as she felt Sunburst’s length in her soft insides. “Oh, Sunburst.”

Sunburst started kissing her neck, and caught sight of the dildo still sticking out of Starlight’s behind, and moved reached out for it.

He needed to work a bit to remember it all, but he managed to hit a good stride with pumping Starlight up and down himself and therefore his stallionhood in and out of her, the dildo in and out of her rear, his hand across her breasts, and her lips against her neck

Starlight, for her part, was in a paradisiacal tartarus. Sunburst, the pony she had wanted to own her pretty much as long as she could remember, was turning out to be such a good owner during their first day. He was making him so happy, and she was pleasured in ways she didn’t think was possible, even as a toy.

But she was almost turning into a bad toy.

‘I can’t come!’ she shouted in hear head. ‘I can’t come, but I have to. My owner told me not to, and I’m going to be a good toy! A good toy doesn’t disobey it’s owner!’

Vocally, she just shouted, “Ah! Ah! Ah! Ah!”

“Sunburst!” she eventually managed. “Sunburst please!”

Sunburst, for his part, was in paradise as well. “Huh, huh, huh, yes, Starlight?” he huffed.

“Please help me to not come!”

“You can, huh, you can do it, Starlight,” he said. “I know you can.”

Starlight felt herself tapping into reserves of power she didn’t know she had, and clamped down on her ever-growing desire to shoot the liquid out of herself, sealing her pleasure inside a box where she could nurture it for all eternity. “Th-thank you, Sunburst. You’re, hah, the best, ah, owner a toy could have. Huh, huh! I love you.”

“And I, huh, love you,” Sunburst said, and scrunched up his eyes. “I’m, huh, I’m close.”

“Mm, come inside me,” Starlight said.

Sunburst started thrusting by lifting himself up with his legs, and then stopped as he hilted inside Starlight. He grunted, and Starlight felt him send his liquids inside her.

As he did, Starlight climaxed herself. She felt more fulfilled than she thought possible, every fiber of her applauding and shouting their approval. She sprayed the sheets around Sunburst’s member, staining them.

Then they collapsed, their limbs going limp as they panted, and Starlight felt Sunburst’s length give a few final twitches as it slowly receded.

Starlight tried lifting her up on one arm, but even with her unlimited stamina, she couldn’t focus enough to do so. She did manage to heave her head to the side, and she and Sunburst turned to look at each other.

“Hah… hah. That was amazing,” Sunburst said.

“It, hah…. it sure was,” Starlight said. “You were amazing.”

“So were you.”

All of Starlight’s worries and shames had washed away, at least for the moment. She tried smiling at Sunburst, but couldn’t quite manage it. She saw his eyes start to droop, and lay her head on his chest.

“Wanna sleep?” she asked.

“Hah, yeah,” he said, and managed to stop panting.

“So do I. I love you, Sunburst.”

“I love you too, Starlight.”

Sunburst rested his arms across Starlight’s back, and felt herself falling asleep. The fluids she had came still stained the bed and they didn’t have a cover on, but Starlight’s perfect body heat would take care of that. Her dildo was still sticking out of her behind, but that wouldn’t be a problem now that she was a toy.

And she was a toy. She was Sunburst’s toy, and Twilight’s toy, and she had never been happier.

Twilight turned away from the screen. She had wanted to give Starlight and Sunburst their privacy, and they had gotten some of it, but she had decided that it was for the best to observe. For science.

She rolled her office chair over to the side and spent some time watching the light purple brain floating in the jar of clear liquids, wrapped in a rubber-construction with cables running through it, which connected it to a crystal that pulsated slightly with a faint light, acting as a transmitter.

“How are things going, Twilight?” Princess Celestia asked, as she walked up behind her.

“Good, I think. I’m getting a lot of data,” Twilight said, and gestured to the papers flowing out of a machine to the side, like a seismograph. “Although that means it’s gonna take a lot of time to go through it.”

“It’s going to be worth it. I’m so proud of you, Twilight,” Celestia said, and gently hugged Twilight from behind.

Twilight leaned into the hug, and closed her eyes. “Yeah. It keeps Starlight from trying anything if she relapses, but more importantly, we can find out if there’s anything tangible about what makes a pony good in their brains.”

Starlight’s body, her head filled with a receiver, slept in Sunburst’s embrace. Starlight herself, unknowingly, floated bodiless inside the clear liquid, utterly satisfied with everything in the world.