Twilight Sparkle, Pinkie Pie, Rainbow Dash, Applejack, and Fluttershy walked into Twilight’s old room in Canterlot Castle, not rousing any suspicion from anyone despite being rubber sex toys in disguise.

In a sense they were now more than they used to be. All of their magic, capabilities, and functions were restored; they could eat, drink, sleep, rest, sweat, and just about everything else that a flesh and blood pony could, even though they didn’t need to unless they chose to.

Underneath their fully restored bodies, they were fused to the same bodies they had gotten at Starlight’s village, with all those capabilities as well: Infinite stamina, no need for sustenance or air, the ability to restore grievous injuries within minutes, and of course, the ability to enjoy sex in indescribable ways, to get heavenly pleasures out of something so simple as giving a pecking kiss to somepony’s marehood, enjoying just about any sexual activity including domination, humiliation, romantic love-making, and pretend-abuse of any level of harshness.

“Aren’t we going to see the princesses?” Fluttershy asked.

“Yes, but I think it’s best if we unpack Rarity here rather than where the guards keep track of who’s going in and out,” Twilight said.

“Oh, right,” Fluttershy said, and walked over to the wheeled luggage.

She unzipped the luggage, and gently undid the straps that held the limbless form of Rarity inside it, lifting her up onto Twilight’s bed.

Rarity tried looking around in worry, but to no avail, being blindfolded, gagged, and deafened by black plugs.

Fluttershy bent down and gave Rarity a soft kiss on her nose, before opening another pocket on the luggage, picking out Rarity’s limbed, naked body, folded neatly to take up as little space as possible.

It unfolded methodically, standing up on its legs and probing around on confusion. Fluttershy took one of its hands, and let it over to Rarity. When she removed the ear-plugs and the gag deep inside Rarity’s throat, Rarity coughed and gasped instinctively. “Where are we?” she asked.

“We’re in my old apartment in the castle,” Twilight said.

“Nopony saw me then?”

“No.”

“You know,” Applejack said. “If you’re so worried about being seen, why do you do this?”

Rarity turned towards Applejack’s voice, and gave a coy smile. “The excitement, darling! Imagine the scandal if this was to become known.”

“Hey I got a scandal for you,” Rainbow said, and grabbed the dildo in Rarity’s marehood, pumping it in and out and turning it around.

“Ah! Aaah! Rainbow!” Rarity squeaked and arched her back.

“Is this classy behavior?” Rainbow Dash asked.

“Aaahn! Huh! Huh! Huh!” Rarity said.

“I’ll stop when you say please,” Rainbow said, with a smirk.

“Puh- puh- please!” Rarity eventually managed. Rainbow stopped pumping her, leaving Rarity panting on the bed. “Hah! Haaaah… I’ll get you for that, Rainbow darling.”

“Oh yeah? How?” Rainbow Dash asked confidently, only to suddenly have a naked body grab her from behind and force her face to contact with Rarity.

Rarity immediately arched up and planted a big kiss on Rainbow’s mouth, hanging onto her lips for a good five seconds.

They disconnected with a loud ‘smack’, and Rainbow managed to stand back up.

Rarity smirked as her body instead undid the last straps on her, and removed the blindfold. “I win, dear,” she said.

“Fine,” Rainbow grumbled, but smiled to herself as she turned away.

The rest of the girls laughed at the exchange. As soon as Rarity had a body that looked like a real pony again, and had dressed herself, they gathered around Twilight, who teleported them to the conference room.

When they arrived in the conference room, they found themselves in the company of Princess Celestia, Luna, Cadence, and Shining Armor, who all rose up to greet the new arrivals.

“Shiny! Cadence!” Twilight said, and shared a hug with her brother and sister-in-law.

“Hey, Twily. How are you?” Shining asked.

“I’m great!” she said. “Everything’s back to normal, and Starlight Glimmer is captured. How are you, Cadence?”

“We’re good too,” she said, smiling at Twilight. “She gave us a run for our bits, but she couldn’t run forever.”

“Indeed,” Celestia said, and gestured to the table. “Are we ready?”

“We’re ready,” Twilight said.

“What’s in the bag?” Pinkie Pie asked, referring to the duffle bag lying on the table next to Shining Armor and Cadence.

“Something tangentially connected,” Cadence said, and smiled.

“Let us proceed,” Luna said, and magicked up the rubbery form of Starlight Glimmer from underneath the table, and roughly dropping her in the middle.

Like Rarity had been until recently, Starlight Glimmer had no limbs, no horn, and a ‘TOY’-cutie mark adorned her rubbery body. She was also gagged, blindfolded, and had her ears plugged.

She let out as scared huff as she tried futilely looking around from being dropped on the table, her naked breasts pressed against the surface.

The plugs in her ears were removed roughly, and she tried looking around with renewed vigor as she let out another scared huff.

“Starlight Glimmer,” Luna announced. “You are accused of kidnapping, abuse, illegal transformation, gross intimidation, carnal violation, assault, treason, and high treason. How do you plead?”

“Guilty!” she shouted in a panic as soon as the ballgag left her mouth, and the six ponies newly arrived in the room immediately understood that Starlight was under the same truth-magic as they had been. “Guilty of all charges! And theft... and assault! And poison!”

Despite their interviewee being blindfolded, the gathered ponies had been looking at the limbless rubber-pony with a look of utter coldness, but now all of their expressions made way to mild surprise at how readily the confessions came.

Luna took a moment to get back her stern demeanor. “Are you then saying that you knew your actions were deplorable, immoral, and illegal?”

“Yes! All the time from start to end,” Starlight immediately said.

“Then why perform them?”

“Because I hate cutie marks,” Starlight said, gaining some fire in contrast to her scared demeanor just before, and grit her teeth. “They force ponies into a vocation and change their lives, no matter the consequences.”

She then slumped her head, the fire in her dying down again. “And because I’m a twisted, perverse pony, who wants other ponies to suffer, and enjoy it.”

Luna snorted. “The academic question of whether one can enjoy suffering notwithstanding, you recognise the cruelty of your actions then, and admit to them?”

“Yes,” Starlight said into the table.

“Then let us move on. How is your transformations reversed?” Celestia asked.

“With the Staff of Sameness,” Starlight said.

“And where is the staff?” Celestia asked.

“I destroyed it,” Starlight said, making everypony around the table recoil, and Fluttershy letting out a small gasp.

Starlight inclined her head to the noise, but Luna spoke up immediately. “If a transformation was incomplete, would it be possible to reverse or complete it without the staff?”

“Yes,” Starlight said. “It can be completed.”

The duffle bag squirmed in response. Twilight and her friends looked at it in confusion, but Cadence put a hand on it, stilling it.

“And with the staff destroyed, the transformations cannot be reversed?” Celestia asked.

Starlight shook her head. “No.”

Luna and Celestia looked at each other, and Luna unceremoniously gagged Starlight and re-attached the plugs in her ears. Starlight let out a small, surprised moan, and was left looking around in confusion.

“Well, at least things are mostly back to normal,” Shining Armor offered.

“Indeed,” Celestia said. “Have you all learned to live in your new states?”

“Sure have, Princess,” Rainbow Dash said, and poked herself in her arm. “I mean, these things are so awesome and realistic. I need to exercise, I sweat, I can eat, and all that stuff.”

“How about you, Fluttershy?” Applejack asked. “You seemed a little worried there.”

“Oh, I’m fine,” Fluttershy asked. “I just… thought about how it would be like to be like this forever.”

“Indeed, darling,” Rarity said, and put her arm around Fluttershy’s shoulders. “Never fear, we’ll be with you to make it all better, kissing you, loving you.”

Fluttershy looked down into her lap as she smiled and blushed.

“And you are all alright?” Twilight asked the other princesses and her brother.

“As an immortal alicorn, one learns to live with many injuries,” Luna said confidently. “This is nothing compared to the past.”

“And things are practically better now,” Shining said, putting an arm around his wife. “We have more leisure time now than before. Before we had, uhm…”

Cadence smiled and kissed her husband’s thinking face. “Nine hour work per day, Nine hour sleeping, two hours making love on average, and four for other things. Now we have six hours for making love on average, and no need for sleep.”

“How did she get you all anyway?” Pinkie asked.

Starlight Glimmer woke up from the chiming sound of magic being cast, and within a second was out of the bed of the family whose house she had broken into and locked in the basement.

She grabbed the Staff of Sameness and cast a spell towards the assailant in the room, sprinting out into the hallway, naked. She didn’t have time to teleport away before another figure in the hallway shot a ray of magic at her. She threw herself into another room, and jumped out of the open window into the warm summer night.

Before she was able to teleport, a pink aura grabbed her horn, and she looked up at it in panic.

“Second time’s the charm it seems,” Princess Cadenza said, and stepped out of the darkness towards Starlight.

“You forget that I have more than my horn, majesty!” Starlight shouted, and used the staff to shoot a ray of magic at the princess.

The ray was blocked by a pink magical shield. “So does she,” Shining Armor noted, and stepped in from the other side.

“Indeed,” Princess Luna said, as she too stepped out of the darkness beside her sister.

“Come with us, Starlight Glimmer,” Celestia said in a voice that only just hinted at sadness.

“Oh you think just because you’ve grabbed my horn and have a shield, you have me,” Starlight sneered. “Unlike your precious little Twilight Sparkle, I’m not so easily defeated!”

Celestia scowled ever so slightly, but before anypony could react, the staff in Starlight’s hands pulsed with magic, and sent out a shimmering shockwave that knocked the princesses and the prince to the ground, but not before Shining Armor readied another shield.

Shining’s shield did not stop the wave of magic, but it did reflect some of it back at Starlight, and knocked her over as well.

Everypony sat up in the grass, shaking their heads.

Starlight let out a gasp, and flexed her fingers experimentally, before grabbing the staff and teleporting away before anypony could stop her.

Celestia let out a sigh and raised herself up on her hooves. “We did plan ahead,” she said, as she helped Luna up. “Good thing we let the family out and took them to Canterlot first.”

“Indeed,” Luna said, and looked down at her hand. “I think it’s time we head there as well.”

In a flash, the four royal ponies were gone.

Starlight however, landed with a thud in a dark cave.

“That… that… that… hunk!” she shouted, slamming her hands into the cavern floor.

A quick spell later the pool of water in the otherwise dry cavern lit up as a magical source of light, Starlight sat up and began desperately casting spells on her own naked body.

“No,” she said to herself, and cast another one. She didn’t bother with the staff– it was little more than a wand in any case, despite what she had always claimed in front of others.

“No… no… no,” she kept going as she tried spell after spell, and let out a sigh, looking up into the cavern ceiling, hugging her knees to herself.

She could only do so for a few second, before her hands vanished. “Ah!” she shouted in panic, feeling her hips and breasts expand slightly as her grip on her knees vanished.

She looked down on her empty wrists and empty lower legs, before she scowled at them, tears building in the corners of her eyes.

She took some of the glowing water from the pool in her magic, and started writing a message with it on the cave wall.

Her heart raced as she went through what it should say, and as she added a caveat, she felt her lower arms and legs vanish halfway up the elbows and knees.

Starlight looked at them for a second, panting in panic, before turning back to work.

Once she was satisfied, she lay down and tried calming down for the most sophisticated memory-spell she had ever heard about. It wasn’t just about implanting or burying, it was complete and utter removal. Many things could go wrong here, and she had very little time to prepare it.

She did her best to ignore the sensation of her growing breasts and buttocks as she concentrated on what needed to be done, and by the time her limbs ended halfway up the elbows and knees, she lit up her horn again.

…

Starlight suddenly woke up in a dark cave, and tried sitting up, but her limbs didn’t work properly.

She looked at her right arm, and let out a horrified shriek at what she saw.

She looked at the rest of her limbs, saw that there were only inches left of them. “No! No, nonononono!” she chanted in panic to herself, before noticing a glowing message on the wall.

‘They’ve gotten to you,’ it said. ‘You don’t have much time, so listen up. The staff beside you is the only thing that can reverse the transformation, but you don’t have time to find out how. As soon as you’ve read that you’ll try and figure out how to make it work, but don’t bother. If it falls into the wrong hands however, they will have time to figure out how to reverse the transformation. You can’t let them do that; it will undo everything you’ve worked for. Destroy it, they won’t transform you back anyway. At least like this some ponies will remain saved from their cutie marks.

‘Remember Sunburst.’

That last part was proof enough for Starlight. It was written by her, and she meant what she had written.

She heaved herself up and tried looking past her by now enormous breasts.

She looked at her cutie mark as it was attached to her flank one last time, and then used the staff to remove it. It floated in the air for a few moments, before it settled on the floor.

Starlight painted another cutie mark on her flank, the same ‘TOY’ mark as she had given the princess and her friend. At least like this she might eventually get some joy out of life.

She looked at the staff in her magical grasp for a moment, before the last parts of her limbs vanished into her, swelling her breasts and buttocks one last time, before looking up at the message again.

The staff was suddenly ablaze, and burned away into ash that scattered in the cave in just a few seconds.

Then she felt the sensation she had wondered about so many times spreading from her crotch.

Celestia, Luna, Cadence, and Shining Armor appeared in Celestia’s private quarters.

They looked at each other, and then slumped.

“Please tell me that was you reversing the spell back at her,” Cadence said.

Shining let out a sigh. “... Yep.”

“Oh!” Luna said, letting out a gasp of relief. “Joyous news. Defeat in battle I can handle, but gloating from that unsufferable foal one more time would be beyond my capability.”

“I think it’s best we sit down,” Celestia said, and magicked up four great cushions.

They did so happily.

“So what now?” Cadence asked.

“Now, we wait until we fit into the new bodies we prepared for ourselves,” Celestia said. “Then we go and apprehend Starlight Glimmer. Judging from her reaction at being hit by the spell, I doubt there will be much of a challenge this time.”

Armor let out a sigh. “A rubber doll,” he said. “Some warrior-prince I’ll be.”

“Oh I don’t know,” Celestia said. “Your sister and her friends are fully restored, their main difference is their great capacity for carnal joys.”

“Besides,” Cadence said, and rolled onto her husband with a smile on her face. “It’s not like anypony will be able to tell the difference, hunky as you are already.”

Armor let out a chuckle, and pulled his wife in for a kiss.

“One thing I must bring to our attention,” Luna said. “Judging from the element bearers’ new style of life… I will be blunt, will you bed me if I need it?”

“Yes,” Celestia and Cadence said at the same time.

They turned to Shining Armor, and Cadence giggled at him. “It’s sweet of you to pretend otherwise, but be honest.”

Shining Armor nodded with a small smile. “Yes, I’ll love up all of you,” he said.

Cadence leaned down for a kiss, and halfway through it, she pulled back as her hands vanished, and her bosom expanded slightly.

“We better get out of our clothes before we rip them,” Cadence said, and lit up her horn.

She was stopped by Shining grabbing her horn with his wrists. “Let’s try and make it interesting,” he said, and leaned forward to bite down on Cadence’s dress.

“And that’s it,” Shining Armor said.

“Starlight Glimmer is captured, and you’re all even sexier than before,” Rainbow Dash said. “I consider that a victory.”

“By the way, what’s in the bag?” Applejack asked.

“Everypony, meet Queen Chrysalis,” Cadence said, and the bag started squirming angrily. “She had a run-in with Starlight as well. Poor dear didn’t take to her new talent so well. We’ve kept her fed, but she doesn’t enjoy it as much as we do these days.”

“On that note, we thank you again, Twilight,” Luna said. “For providing the basis for our new talents. They have brought us much pleasure.”

“Happy to,” Twilight said.

“Now, I have a punishment set up for Starlight here,” Luna said. “If you could please come with me, and share what you think.”

A teleport later, and they all found themselves in Luna’s private quarters.

Luna walked over to a large tapestry magically attached to the wall, and pulled it away. Behind that was a large glass container inside the wall, the bottom a body length in breadth and width, and one and a half body lengths in depth.

“What’s this?” Applejack asked.

“Starlight’s new home,” Luna said casually.

In the bottom was a slight padding, and at the top was an opening with a hatch. Luna magicked the confusedly struggling Starlight Glimmer to the top of the container, and in through the hatch, putting her down on her belly at the bottom.

She removed the gag, the blindfold, and the ear-plug, and swiftly floated them out of the hatch before silently closing it.

The inside was left absolutely featureless except for the padding in the bottom, and a dildo hanging from a rope from the top, about thigh-height of a pony standing inside the container.

Starlight looked around in confusion and fear, but didn’t seem to register the ten ponies standing just outside her little container.

“Hello?” she asked. “Is anypony there?”

“Can she hear us?” Pinkie Pie asked.

“No. Nor can she see us,” Luna said. “The interior is illuminated enough, but there is nothing to see, except for one thing.”

“Uh! Huh!” Starlight huffed as she struggled to turn around and looked behind her, but saw nothing but blank surfaces.

“Anypony!?” she called, and waited for a response that would not come.

Then she turned around to look above her, and as she saw the dildo in her periphery, her eyes widened.

She clearly wasn’t as adept as Twilight and her friends at moving around without her limbs, and she made several tries to turn around before shuffling over to a wall and propping herself up against it in order to turn around.

She fell over on her back, unknowingly exposing herself to the ponies outside, but only having her eyes on the dildo.

Starlight heaved herself up towards it, but didn’t even come close. She tried three more times, starting with smacking the bottom with her pelvis to try and gain some more height, which helped, but not enough.

“Somepony!? I can’t… please! Anypony!” she called. “The… the dildo! I can’t reach it!”

She struggled and heaved herself a few more times, pausing to gasp for breath. “I… I need it!”

“You certainly do,” Luna said, smilingly, and turned to the other. “What do you think?”

“It’ll do, for a start,” Rarity said, watching Starlight struggle with a content look on her face.

“Agreed,” Shining Armor said. “What do you think, Twilight?”

Twilight just smiled, mostly to herself. “I think it’s fair. Very fair.”

“I’m glad you think so,” Luna said, and magicked cushions next to her bed and put covers on it to accommodate ten ponies. “Now, is everypony in the mood? I know I am.”

“Indeed. As much as I love you all, my little ponies,” Celestia said to Twilight and her friends. “Having a stallion with us will be a nice addition.”

Shining Armor smiled a bit sheepishly, and Cadence clung to him with a mischievous smile on her face as her hand snaked its way down to the front of his pants.

Luna closed the curtains to Starlight’s little habitat, silencing her desperate moans.

In the corner, Queen Chrysalis lay forgotten in her duffle bag for now.

Author's Note

That's it for now. I guess from now on it might be more of an anthology of fun scenarios involving the Mane 6, the princesses and Shining Armor, and other ponies who might've been transformed, and what they get up to. I'm thinking that perhaps Daring Do was sent to capture Starlight and ended up transformed, and perhaps Shadow Spade being an actual pony who is now also transformed. And the two captains and their teams that were sent to the village; are they all rubber ponies underneath their normal exterior? Imagine what the barracks will look like at night.

I wanna thank The Great Derpsby again. I have linked to them in the story's long description, but it bears repeating. A very diligent, very fast, and very pleasant proofreader who gives a lot of kind and clever insight and feedback. Thank you again.