Dusk was both angry and scared at the moment. He was mad at himself because he made a promise to help out around Ponyville and at Starlight for being right. She had a point when she said that he can’t lock himself up for fourteen days. He was scared because of the potion. The only things they knew about the potion is that it affect ponies who get physically close to him and it cause them to get aroused. They don’t know anything else and Dusk didn’t want to find out what anal sex feel like with him as the catcher. “Woowee, when Dash said you’d look different, I didn’t expect this.” Dusk was snapped out of his thoughts and, after criticizing himself for getting distracted, looked around. He was at Sweet Apple Acres, his first stop for today.

“Did she say anything else?” asked Dusk as he thought about slapping Rainbow for not be clearer.

“Just something about needin’ to be careful ‘round ya,” Applejack said with a shrug. Dusk couldn’t stop his palm from meeting his face.

“Yes, the potion that did this also had an interesting side effect. If someone gets close to me, they get extremely aroused,” said Dusk as a blush came across his face.

“There’s something else botherin’ you, ain’t there, sugarcube,” said Applejack with a concern expression on her face. Dusk sighed as he knew she wouldn’t leave this alone until he told her.

“Rainbow and Starlight both kissed me,” said Dusk. When Applejack didn’t say anything, he continued, “And I enjoyed it.”

“So the problem ain’t the kiss. It’s how you felt about it. Am I right?”

“Yeah. First, they only did it because of the potion. Second, they don’t feel that way about me. Third, I can’t date multiple ponies at the same time,” said Dusk as tears came to his eyes

“Well, I can’t say anything ‘bout the potion, but how do you know that they don’t have any feeling toward you?”

“They never showed any interest in me,”

“’kay, you’re wrong,” Dusk was about to say something, but Applejack held up her hand. “Let me finish. Tell me, have you heard Dash call anypony else, ‘Egghead’”

“well, no, but,”

“Don’t you find that weird? I mean, you aren’t the only smart pony that enjoy reading, but she only calls you that,” Applejack continued without giving Dusk a chance to say his opinion.

“Friends give each others nicknames all the times,” pointed out Dusk.

“Yes,” agreed Applejack, “but when she came here to tell me about the change, she was happier than a school filly on a summer day.”

“What about...”

“And Starlight should be obvious. I’m surprised you haven’t noticed yet,” Applejack said with a shrug.

“If they feel this way, why haven’t they done anything?” asked Dusk.

“Because they’re scared,” said Applejack.

“Scared of what?”

“Rejection, not being good enough, and a couple other things.”

“I wouldn’t reject them. Yes, it would be surprising, but I would at least give them a chance,” said Dusk. “What do you mean not good enough?”

“Even if you deny it, you’re a special pony,” said Applejack. “I mean you were the personal student of Princess Celestia, friend to Princess Luna, sister-in-law to Princess Cadance, Element of Magic, Princess of Friendship, and arguably the most powerful pony alive.

“But what about the other problem? I can’t date multiple ponies at the same time.”

“Is there a law against dating more than one pony at a time?”

“Well, no, but it wouldn’t be fair to them,” said Dusk.

“It wouldn’t be fair to not give them a chance because you’re afraid you’ll hurt one of them.”

“What should I do?”

“Give them a chance,” said Applejack before she turned around. “Now, come on, these trees aren’t goin’ to buck themselves.”

Dusk had faced evil tyrants, the embodiment of chaos, a changeling queen, a magic-absorbing centaur, going through time, and so much more, but nothing compared to the danger he now faced. His own friend, Pinkie Pie. Pinkie was already an affectionate pony that didn’t know the meaning of personal space, but who know what will happen with the potion? Unknown to him, Pinkie had snuck up on him while he was panicking. “Are you having a staring contest with Sugarcube Corner?” This caused Dusk to jump in shock. “Good luck. I still haven’t beat it.”

“Uh, no, I’m not having a staring contest with a building.” said Dusk after he got over his confusion. “I’m guessing that you already been told about the potion, right?”

“What potion?”

“Pinkie, do you notice anything different about me?”

“Dear Celestia, you’re right,” Pinkie said with gasp. “You’re a couple inches taller”

“No, well, yes, but I’m male now”

“No, that’s not it,” said Pinkie, clearly thinking about what was different about her friend.

“I need you to do something for me, Pinkie,” said Dusk after he decided to give up trying to explain things to Pinkie.

“Sure, anything. Well, not anything. I mean anything that is realistic and not mean. Like...” The rest of Pinkie’s statement was cut off when Dusk, without thinking, covered her mouth with his hand. Immediately after realizing his mistake, he pushed Pinkie into the bakery and didn’t stop until they were in the kitchen out of sight.

“Pinkie, are you feeling alright?” said Dusk while preparing to push his friend off of him if necessary.

“No,” said Pinkie with a straight face, “I’m hungry”

“You’re hungry? Hungry for what?” said Dusk a little confused.

“For something long, thick, and filled with delicious cream,” Pinkie whispered into Dusk’s ear.

‘She’s not talking about that, is she?’ thought Dusk with a gulp.

“Like a Twinkie,” said Pinkie, now using her normal tone of voice.

“What?”

“A Twinkie is a...” Dusk interrupted Pinkie.

“I know what a Twinkie is, but you don’t feel anything else?”

“Nope,” Pinkie said with a shake of her head. Dusk shook his head and decided that nothing goes how you expect them to when it involves Pinkie.

“So, other than making Twinkies for you, What are we doing today?” asked Dusk. Pinkie gave him a list of desserts that they need to bake for today. There were muffins, cupcakes, brownies, cakes, pies, and more. It took them around four hours to bake all of the food. It would have been shorter, but Dusk had to stop Pinkie from taste-testing some of the desserts.

“Hey, Dusk,” Pinkie said. Dusk was a little confused because he never told Pinkie his temporary name. He quickly got over it and turned to his friend.

“What is it, Pinkie?”

“You got some cream on your cheek,” Pinkie said pointing at the cheek in question. Dusk was about to wipe it off when Pinkie spoke up again. “Here, let me get it,” Pinkie then proceeded to lick Dusk’s cheek, causing his cheeks to turn bright red.

“What was that?” he asked as he tried to get over the shock of having his friend lick his cheek.

“Oh, sorry,” Pinkie said, “Did you want some?” Pinkie grabbed Dusk’s head and started kissing him, tongue and all. Dusk manage to get her off of him and, before Pinkie could recover, ran all the way back to the castle.

Author's Note

hey, sorry it took so long, but i recently started college again. I also had to stop at the twinkie part because i couldn't stop laughing. if you couldn't tell, i'm doing the main characters' reactions to the change first. next chapter is Rarity and Fluttershy. I'm planning on doing the first major sex scene around chapter 5, so sorry to anyone that is reading this just for the smut. anyone who say that Rainbow doesn't only call Twilight 'egghead', i want to point out that this is a fanfiction. I used to write for fanfiction.net and i had someone complain that my story wasn't following canon. hopefully there's no idiots here, but if there is, i will not talk to you.
i wish you a good day/week/month/year/life. (choose the one that fits)