Choking Out of the Closet

by headless_rainbow

Rating: mature
Tags: Porn, Fetish, Tragedy, Profanity, Non-consensual, Big Macintosh, Violence, Sex, Applejack, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Death, Alternate Universe, Rainbow Dash
Length: 3046

Applejack and Big Macintosh perform corrective rape on Rainbow Dash for her own good. They then justly murder her because she won't stop being gay. If you take this fic seriously, you deserve to. If you get off on it, you deserve to too.

(Stop annoying the mods with reporting this story. Most of them aren't in my fan club and don't want to have to read my stuff to confirm that your complaint is invalid.)

Rainbow Dash confesses her love for tries to force her deviant views on Applejack without knowing the Apple family are homophobic assholes good, upright ponies that will not tolerate her sins. The Apples decide to punish her for being different protect Ponyville’s foals from corruption. Correctional rape and snuff Righteous justice ensues.

Based on image >>620294 on Derpibooru (explicit obviously)

Contains: asphyxiation, bondage, bone breakage, correctional rape, gagging, homophobia, if the horseshoe fits wear it, incest, necrophilia, out-of-character characters, rationalized hatred, snuff, straight, vaginal, violence

May or may not be followed up at some point if my fans scream loud enough. I haven't decided.

See my subscribestar for early access to fics and to help pay my bills so I can write more. Commission info here.

Published 2018-08-03 12:50:01 UTC
Last updated 2018-08-03 12:50:01 UTC

1. Rainbow is Justly Punished for her Crimes against Nature

Rainbow Dash was acting strange around her as of late, and even more now. She had told Applejack she wanted to talk, but now that she was at the Apple farm, all she was doing was blushing and shifting her hooves where she stood. It was unlike her.

“So what'd you wanna talk about?” Applejack asked.

“Well,” Rainbow chuckled awkwardly. “We’ve spent a lot of time together the last few years and… well I guess I should just say it. I don’t know what you’re into, but if you like mares, maybe we could go out sometime? Like on a date?”

Rainbow’s sudden sinful words stunned Applejack. Was Rainbow saying what it sounded like?

“On a date,” Applejack was incredulous still. “Like as a lesbian couple?”

“Well, yeah!” Rainbow grinned, pushing down her previous reluctance now that she’d said it, and seeming to expect an affirmative answer.

Was this a joke? Surely it was just a prank, but Applejack knew just how to call he on it.

“Why wait fer a date?” Applejack gave Rainbow fake bedroom eyes. “If you wanna be mah marefriend, why don’tcha show me yer tongue work?”

Applejack turned herself around to face her plot towards Rainbow. Hah! That’ll show her to joke around about perverse things.

“R-really?” Rainbow sounded surprised. “You're sure it's okay already?”

“Yeah munch away,” Applejack smirked. Soon Rainbow's joke would be-

Rainbow wasn’t joking. She approached slowly and pushed Applejack’s tail out of the way, grasped Applejack’s flanks in both front hooves, and dove for her. She pressed her muzzle against Applejack’s slit and gave it a long deep lick.

Applejack couldn’t believe it! Dash had been serious? Disgusted by the actions of her now-former friend, Applejack did the thing any decent member of society would do. She clocked Rainbow hard in the head with one hind hoof. Dash cried out in surprise as she tumbled backwards, dizzy from the somehow unexpected attack.

“What the buck, Dash?” Applejack demanded. “How dare you put yer tongue on me like that!”

“W-what?” Dash stammered. “You offered!”

“Ah thought ya was jokin’ and ah was callin’ ya on it!” Applejack shouted. “Ah didn’t think you were actually a lesbian!” She felt her rage built. Rainbow thought she’d be into this? “Why you…”

Rainbow was too dumbfounded to reply, but barely dodged Applejack’s next kick. But the kick was only to get Dash into the position AJ wanted. As soon as Rainbow turned and spread her wings to take off, Applejack grabbed the pegaslut’s right wing and twisted it. It gave under Applejack’s strength, snapping with a sickening crack and eliciting another cry of pain.

“My wing!” Rainbow shrieked. “Applejack why?”

“Ya won’t need yer wings in Hell, slut!” Applejack growled. “And you might go there before the day is up!”

“W-what?” stammered Rainbow like an idiot, but AJ wasn’t surprised a lezbo’s brain was too weak to comprehend her situation.

Applejack continued her assault, not wanting the freak to get away before they dealt with her properly. She slammed her weight down upon Rainbow’s back to push her to the ground. Pushing a hoof to the back of Rainbow’s head, she slammed her face-down into the ground to keep her dizzy, then grasped her good wing. She twisted and bent it at the middle, not stopping until shards of bone jutted free of the bloody wound.

“If ya want yer wings fixed,” said Applejack. “You’ll just have to see reason before they’re beyond repair!”

“Help me!” Rainbow cried out as the well-deserved pain wrecked her body. That she thought anypony on the Apple farm would help her was an even graver insult. She’d soon pay for her cruelty to Applejack.

“Uh,” Big Mac’s voice came from behind them, having heard the ruckus and come outside.

Applejack turned to see her brother staring at them in confusion.

“This dyke slut just tried ta tongue-rape me!” Applejack gave a completely accurate explanation. “Came outta nowhere and tried to pin me down to buckin’ lick my snatch!”

“I didn’t!” Rainbow shrieked, trying to lie her way out of it “That’s not what… I asked and you offered!”

Big Mac’s eyes widened, then his face twisted in anger at the news that a filthy dyke attempted to rape his sister. Then blamed it on her! Somepony they trusted no less!

“Get some ropes, brother,” Applejack said, twisting Rainbow’s broken wings more to silence her wicked attempt at deceit. “We’re gonna show this trodger-dodger what her foal factory is for! Ain’t a mare in the world that’d prefer pussy after gettin’ plowed by your meat.”

“Eyup!” Big Mac nodded, knowing the only moral thing to do now was to execute their sinful ex-friend. He turned and galloped to get the ropes.

“Applejack, why?” Rainbow just wouldn’t shut her filthy muzzle.

“It’s for yer own good, Dash,” Applejack explained. “After corrective action, maybe you’ll be normal again and we won’t have to put ya down.”

“B-but I love you!” Rainbow shrieked.

“Shut up!” Applejack couldn’t believe the depths of depravity Dash had sunk to. Had she always been this fiendish? “Yer gonna make me sick! How many other ponies have you already tried to corrupt? How many foals?”

“Foals?! I would never…” Rainbow started, but stopped when Applejack dragged the writhing mare towards a nearby fence.

“Don’t give me that!” Applejack wasn’t falling for Rainbow’s deception. “Ah know what you snatch-slurpin freaks are like. How many innocent foals have you molested, ya filly fooler? You disgust me!”

“Eyup,” said Mac from behind them.

“And not just that,” said Applejack. “It's because of faggots and dykes like you that ponies are losing faith in Celestia.”

Rainbow was too stunned by Applejack's clearly flawless logic to reply.

Applejack turned to see Big Mac carrying both a rope and the ball gag from their toy box. He was eager to teach the degenerate pegasus a lesson in the proper purpose of pony pussy; his sheath swelled, shaft slowly emerging.

“Ah good, ya brought the gag,” said Applejack. “Probably shoulda thought of that mahself, but ah’m just so angry. Anyway put it on her. This insufferable cunt’s been spewin lies the whole time.”

Rainbow’s struggles increased as more tears rolled down her face, but Applejack held on to her. She wasn’t about to let the deviant escape correction, or justice if she refused that. She shoved Rainbow’s head between the two rails of the fence, securing each of her front legs against the top rail to hold her there. She tied a second rope around Rainbow’s midsection to hold down her shattered wings. Applejack pulled it tightly, making certain the abnormal mare suffered more for her sinful behavior.

Big Mac latched the gag against Rainbow’s muzzle despite her head thrashing, and soon the perverse lesbian was restrained. The once-proud pegasus sobbed outright, kicking her hind legs. For a moment the Apples backed off and let Dash wear herself out.

“Fer cryin out loud,” Applejack rolled her eyes as Rainbow thrashed. “It’s disgustin. She knows good and well that that she deserves worse. We should just be snuffin’ the bitch, but because we care, we’re givin’ her a chance to try dick before we resort to that. What an ungrateful slut.”

“Eeyup,” Big Mac agreed.

The poor stallion was impatient, shaft now hard and throbbing beneath him. Applejack stroked a hoof along the pulsating flesh and admired the instrument that would hopefully bring Rainbow back to them.

“Go on, big brother,” Applejack smiled to him, then turned to Rainbow. “Come on Rainbow, this is fer yer own good. Trust me, a few minutes of this and you’ll never lust for mares again.”

As Big Mac approached Rainbow from behind, she got a few kicks in, but the strikes glanced off of Mac’s powerful chest. He moved up between her hind legs where they could no longer get a good kick in and pulled himself up atop her. He grasped at her flanks, letting his pulsating instrument lay against her plot for a moment, ready to return Rainbow to sanity.

Applejack stepped closer, grabbing hold of Rainbow’s tucked tail to pull it out of the way. Rainbow writhed and shook her head, but Big Mac was undeterred. The righteous stallion pushed his tip against the pegasus pussy, prying it open. She was tight, labia stretching around his tip, then snapping over him to let him sink in more.

Mac strained as he forced himself deep. His appreciative moan was drowned out though by Rainbow’s scream even through her gag. He showed no mercy to the sinner, pushing as deep as he could on the first thrust. He only stopped when his tip impacted her cervix. As tempting as it was to let Dash adjust, Mac immediately pulled back and began powerful thrusts. The barely moist cunny squished hotly around his shaft as a small layer of blood coated his length.

To show Mac encouragement, Applejack moved behind them. She leaned in, giving his swinging balls a sisterly slurp. She coated them in her saliva before lapping at the penetration point. It remained surprisingly dry still, more blood than cunt honey.

“Talk about a dry well,” scoffed Applejack. “It’s yer own fault it hurts Dash. Ya ain’t even a little wet with that cock plungin ya? Well, you’ll get into it soon enough, or you’ll die, yer choice.”

Rainbow arched her back, squealing from behind the gag, jaw clenched and pain etched all over her face. Applejack rolled her eyes, not fooled by the act. Applejack lost her virginity at half Dash’s age and it didn’t hurt that much.

“Yer bein more of a drama queen than Rarity,” Applejack called Rainbow on her deception. “Why don’t you quit the act? I’ll ungag you if yer ready to admit how good my brother’s cock feels.”

Rainbow shook her head violently, continuing to sob. Applejack knew she was stubborn, but this was absurd. Did she think they wouldn’t kill her? Rainbow thinking Applejack was a liar enraged her all the more. As much as Applejack was trying to help Rainbow, the pegasus insisted on trying her patience.

Applejack looked away from Rainbow’s face to the other end, which looked far more pleasant. She ran her hooves over Mac’s flanks, enjoying how his muscles flexed with every thrust, his fur growing damp with sweat.

Despite Rainbow’s pretend agony, her pussy betrayed her true feelings. Her love tunnel had grown juicy, drooling cunt honey down Mac’s balls. Applejack licked her lips as she enjoyed the sight of her brother’s thick shaft glistening with natural lubrication each time he withdrew. Applejack was certain she saw Rainbow’s hips twitch, but the bitch of a mare was straining to keep still to hide how much she loved it.

Finally, he sank all the way inside, belly smacking against Rainbow’s behind. Rainbow’s cervix had given way, allowing him to push right up into her the womb she’d selfishly forbade stallions access to. The lesbian slut’s wickedness wouldn’t keep Mac from fueling her foal factory. If Rainbow came to her senses, maybe Applejack would get a niece or nephew out of this.

“Ready to admit it?” asked Applejack. “Come on, girl, don’t let yer ego get ya killed.”

Rainbow shook her head again, squalling like a foal through the gag. Applejack rolled her eyes; that fake crying wasn’t fooling anypony.

Big Mac huffed, grasping her flanks harder, muscles tightening as Rainbow’s juice poured down both their thighs. Applejack could tell he was getting close.

“Well ah assume a dick dodger like you ain’t on foal control,” said Applejack. “Maybe getting one put in ya will do ya good.”

Applejack expected Rainbow to give up the act and get excited about being bred, but she only resisted more. As she realized Mac was going to cum inside, she redoubled her efforts to fake discomfort, looking like an idiot as she flailed and moaned. How pathetic.

Big Mac arched his back, ridiculously sexy as he blew his fertile load into Rainbow’s cum catcher, proving to her once and for all what her pussy was for. He trembled in bliss as he painted her insides white, her belly swelling with his load as sticky goodness overflowed and drooled down their thighs.

“Okay, Dash, one more chance now that yer knocked up,” Applejack pried her eyes away from her hot brother’s rape stick long enough to speak to Rainbow again. “Ya got a choice. Either give up yer sinful ways and become part of the family or refuse and go right to hell.”

To make sure Rainbow knew how serious she was, Applejack tied the remaining rope in a lasso and looped it around Rainbow’s neck. She pulled, tugging Rainbow’s head back and cutting off her air. Despite how understanding they’d been though, Rainbow refused, shaking her head furiously.

That was it. Not only was Rainbow refusing to admit the truth, but wanted to murder the new life Big Mac planted inside her by making them kill her in self-defense. Not to mention in defense of all the others she would corrupt if allowed to live!

“Have it yer way,” Applejack growled. “If ya don’t wanna live straight, you kin die a dyke.”

Applejack pulled the rope tight, cutting off Rainbow’s breath. Rainbow rattled the fence in her struggle, gaging for air. Panic filled her eyes as more tears rolled down her face.

Wet squishes joined her choking as Big Mac resumed thrusting. Applejack knew he loved to feel a mare’s pussy spasm as she died, and it wasn’t often enough they committed holy murder. Soon he was grunting and grasping her struggling body once again.

“One we put this one down,” Applejack said around the rope to Big Mac, since Rainbow was no longer worthy of being addressed. “We gotta find out what foals she’s been molestin’ so they kin get treatment. No tellin how many foals this filly fooler has abused.”

“Eeyup,” Mac grunted as he enjoyed the spasms now dancing over his shaft.

Rainbow shook her head violently, denying things even now as she died. The Apples weren’t fooled, knowing all gay ponies, without exception, molest every foal they could get their hooves on. Applejack yanked harder, Rainbow’s neck bruising from the strain, chest heaving in a futile effort to breathe.

Applejack had to admit, seeing a sinner get their well-deserved death made her own pussy wet. She hoped this bitch hadn’t worn Big Mac out too much for him to plow Applejack afterward. But then…

“Fuck,” Applejack realized. “This muncher spent all that time with Scootaloo, she’s tainted fer sure. That little lezbo-in-training better not have touched Apple Bloom. We gotta deal with her later.”

“Eeyup,” Mac grunted as he rammed harder.

Rainbow tried to renew her struggles as she heard Applejack talking about her fuck-toy Scootaloo. She was far too weak though, her movements limited to shivers, though her insides convulsed delightfully around Big Mac, making him roll his eyes back. The rope cut deep into her neck, and soon her death throes were upon her, ridding Equestria of one more wicked deviant.

Her body fell limp, save for the rocking caused by Big Mac’s pounding hips. He moaned at Rainbow’s final spasms, feeling the warmth of her death piss roll over his shaft and drool down his balls and legs.

Applejack released the rope as Mac continued to pound the sinner’s corpse, leaving her head to hang limp. She moved around the fence, taking a moment to run her tongue up the side of Rainbow’s face. She tasted her tears, tongue gliding over her wide-open eye.

“Enjoy Hell, you insufferable cunt,” Applejack purred as she pulled away.

Big Mac arched his back and groaned again, unleashing a second blast of seed into Rainbow’s undeserving womb. It overflowed more quickly this time now that her muscles had loosened up, and even more so when Mac withdrew.

Applejack moved back to his side of the fence, leaning down to push her head beneath him. Soon her skillful tongue was removing cum and piss from his cock, giving him a good cleaning. His stamina was impressive, still rock hard, which was good, because Applejack wanted this beauty in her next.

“Oh my Celestia!” a voice called to them. “What is going on?”

Applejack turned to see Twilight, who was landing in front of Rainbow’s executed body.

“Oh hay Twilight,” Applejack said. “Sorry. But Rainbow tried to come onto me, so we killed her for bein’ a dirty dyke.”

“Oh goodness,” Twilight calmed as she learned that Rainbow brought this on herself. “Are you okay? She didn’t hurt you did she?”

“Nah, ah’ll be okay,” smiled Applejack. “Tried ta get her to admit being wrong, but she wouldn’t even after Big Mac came inside her. Too bad.” She sighed.

“It’s not your fault,” Twilight assured. “You showed true friendship by giving her a chance to cease her deviance and you also shown your strength of character to do what needed to be done to a former friend.”

Twilight sighed and looked at Rainbow’s corpse, bound to the fence, gag still in her muzzle and rope still digging into her neck. The remnants of her piss and Big Mac’s cum still drooled down her hind legs. Twilight had no trouble seeing that Applejack had done this in self-defense. Twilight felt a little responsible, knowing Rainbow so long without realizing what a monstrous deviant she was.

“You’ve helped me decide, Applejack,” Twilight decided. “We’ve been too lenient with ponies we suspect might have the same incurable disease. It’s time for a crack-down on dykes and faggots for the good of Equestria.”

“We’ll be glad to help,” Applejack assured. “I'm gonna fuck mah brother now atop this lesbo's corpse. Anything else ah kin help you with?”

“Oh no, that's okay,” Twilight nodded. “You two have fun with your non-deviant straight sex.”

As Twilight flew away, Applejack felt good about herself. Not only had Applejack performed her sacred duty, but encouraged others to do the same. Heaven smiled upon her righteous behavior, and she couldn’t wait to share what she did with all her friends to encourage them too.

Life was good. Now to fuck her brother.