Pear Butter asked "Bright Mac, when did you get back?"

Bright Mac said "Only a couple of minutes ago."

Pear Butter said while scratching her head "Really? Cause I didn't hear your truck drive up. Then again, I was probably in shower when you arrived and didn't hear you since I was listening to music."

Bright Mac asked "How did the competition go? Did you win?"

Pear Butter explained "Sadly, no; we got third place. But on the bright side, we managed to defeat Spoiled Milk's proxy."

Bright Mac said "That's good to know."

Pear Butter said "Anyway, are we still on for movie night tomorrow at my place?"

Bright Mac said "Wouldn't miss it for all Equestria."

Pear Butter said while sniffing something "Great. Bright Mac, are you wearing cologne?"

Bright Mac said "No. I don't use cologne."

Pear Butter said before leaving "You sure? Because you smell really nice. Anyway, see you tomorrow."

As soon as Pear Butter left, Bright Mac smelled his arm to see if he did have a different scent on him; if he did, he was sure that it must have come from Zecora blowing something on him. He didn't smell anything different on him,but decided to go take a shower just in case.

The next day, he got up early in the morning and headed for Hayseed Swamp adjacent to see Zecora and ask her what she did. When he arrived at her address, she wasn't there; the hut had been cleaned out. He looked around to see if she left anything, but found nothing. Before he left, he heard a voice saying "It's not time for us to meet again." He turned around to see if anypony was there, but saw no pony. After finding nothing, Bright Mac headed back home. What he didn't know is Zecora was there but she hid herself with a special camouflage paint.

Back in Ponyville, specifically the Pear family farm, Pear Butter is placing two bowls of popcorn on coffee table; the other popcorn bowl is for Bright Mac since she knows that he'll eat more than her or anypony else. While setting up, she still couldn't get that scent that she smelled from Bright Mac out of her mind.

(Flashback)
Last night, before going to bed, she was getting out of her clothes and putting her night clothes, she accidentally bumped into her dresser and almost knocked over a picture of her and Bright Mac when they to the carnival two months ago; the two of them were sharing a piece of cotton candy and almost kissed. Suddenly, her heart started beating, felt a warm feeling course through her body, and started to sweat. She sat on her bed, put the picture near her, and placed her fingers in her vagina. She moved her finger all around the edges of her pussy and dove her finger in deeper. She let out a huge moan and said "Oh Bright Mac, take me away."
(End Flashback)

She pulled herself together after she heard a ring at her doorbell ring. She went to the door and answered it; its Bright Macintosh.

Pear Butter said "Bright Mac, you made."

Bright Mac said "Told you I wouldn't miss this for all Equestria."

Pear Butter asked "So, what movies did you bring?"

Bright Mac said holding out three films "I brought with me: "The Return of the Shadow Stallion", "A Billion Ways to Die in the Appleoosa", and "The Marvelous 13". What about you?"

Pear Butter said going through a box filled with films "I had trouble deciding which ones I wanted to see tonight, so I'm just going to pick three random films from the film box.

Bright Mac said holding up a film "Happy Birthday Pear Butter"?"

Pear Butter said taking the film away "Ah! That's the film of birth; my aunt Pear Cider recorded it. Trust me, you don't want to see that. I'll mail this to Grand Pear tomorrow; I'm sure he would love to watch this."

Bright Mac asked "How is your dad?"

Pear Butter said "He's fine. The Pear Jam store is doing great; says there is never a day he isn't busy, just the way he likes it. What about your mom?"

Bright Mac said holding up a postcard "I got a postcard from her and Goldie Delicious the other day; they're enjoying the beach a lot."

Pear Butter said "That sounds fun. Chiffon and I have been meaning to go to the beach again; I want to try my new swimsuit I bought."

Before Bright Mac could say anything, he felt a strange presence in the area and turned around and saw nothing. Pear Butter asked him what's wrong but he brushed it off saying that it was just his imagination.

Elsewhere, in a forest, Zecora is stirring a green liquid in her cauldron. While she is stirring it, she sees an image of Pear Butter. However, the liquid changes from green to pink. Zecora said "It seems Bright Macintosh's first mare will not only be a lustful encounter but it will also be filled with love."

Back with Bright Mac and Pear Butter, they are watching one of Pear Butter's favorite films, "Gigantic", the uncut version; it's about two lover ponies who meet each other on a cruise ship and fall in love while aboard. They are at the part where they meet each other again at the masquerade ball on the third floor of the ship.

Pear Butter said "This is my favorite part; it's so romantic."

Bright Mac said "It really is. I've been meaning to ask you, but what's the difference between the uncut version and the original version that was show in theaters? Give me the short version."

Pear Butter explained "They expanded on a few characters that didn't have as much screen time like the should have along with a few "love" scenes" that they didn't want to release in theaters; you see more of this in the middle part of the movie."

Bright Mac said while getting up from the couch "Thanks for the heads up. I'll be right back; need to use the restroom."

As soon as Bright Mac left, Pear Butter started to smell that scent from Bright Mac again. At the same time, while watching the film, she replaces the image of the two dancing ponies with her and Bright Mac. It reminded her of the dance that they both shared during their senior year in high school. As the dance ended, the two ponies kissed and left the ball room for the female pony's room where the two of them are about to make love.

Bright Mac said "I'm back. Did I miss anything?"

Pear Butter said while panting "No. They're about to do the love scene right now."

Bright Mac asked as he sat down "Are you ok?"

Pear Butter said before jumping on top of him "I'm fine."

Bright Mac said "Pear Butter, what are you doing?"

Pear Butter said "Something that I've been meaning to do with you for some time now. For a long time, we were forbidden to love. If it wasn't for our families having to come together to fight against Rich Market from putting our families out of business, we wouldn't be able to act on it like we can now."

Before Bright Mac could say anything else, Pear Butter kissed him passionately. Bright Mac then felt a strong urge coursing through his body which caused his eyes to glow red for only a few seconds and he kissed Pear Butter back. The kiss lasted for five minutes until the two of them broke the kiss; both panting and drooling at the same time.

Bright Mac said while panting "I've wanted to do that for a long time. I want more."

Pear Butter said as she panted "My room, now."

Bright Mac picked up Pear Butter, bridal style, and went upstairs to her room; while walking upstairs, they made out with each other again. Once they arrived in her room, Pear Butter had Bright Mac put her down, had him stand right in front of her, got on her knees, and pulled down his pants to show her his massive cock. As soon as she saw his cock, Pear Butter gazed in awe at the sight of it; she imagined that his cock would be big but never thought that it would be this big. She put his cock on top of her tongue and placed the entire thing in her mouth. She moved her mouth in and out of his cock while making sure to lick every inch of hit. Bright Mac moaned and groaned from her wet and warm tongue on his cock. He said "Oh Pear Butter, your amazing at this; take it deeper. Go for my balls." while placing his hands on her head. Pear Butter did as she asked and started sucking on both of his balls as fast as she could; this made Bright Mac moan even louder. Eventually, Bright Mac cummed in Pear Butter's mouth. Pear Butter swallowed his cum in her mouth and licked the rest off of her mouth.

Pear Butter got up and undid her shirt and bra, revealing her size C breast to Bright Mac.

Pear Butter said seductively "What do you think?"

Bright Mac said "They're beautiful. I've dreamed about seeing these for so long."

Pear Butter said "You can do more than just see; you can touch."

Bright Mac placed his hands on both her breast. As he touched them, he noticed Pear Butter looking at him seductively, begging him to do more with her breast. The two sat down on her bed and he proceeded to kissing her breast. Eventually, he started sucking on her right tit. Pear Butt moaned from his wet tongue on her tit and felt him swirl his tongue; she placed her arms around him to pull Bright Mac deeper into her breast. Bright Mac switched from her right tit to her left tit. Pear Butter felt herself getting wet and had Bright Mac stand up with her so she could take off her shorts and panties; she could tell how wet she really is from how her panties are so wet.

She then had Bright Mac take off his shirt for her so she could see his muscular stomach body. She placed her hands on his six-pack, grabbed her green lipstick on her counter, and started leaving kisses on his six-pack, cock, neck , and cheek. Pear Butter pushed Bright Mac on her bed and got on top of him. She crawled up toward his face, had Bright Mac grab her by the butt, exposed her pussy to him, and had him start licking in. As he started licking her pussy, Pear Butter let our louder moans of pleasure and ecstasy from his tongue inside of her. She could feel him move his tongue in her even further and started to squeeze her breast just to contain the pressure she was feeling; things became more intense as Bright Mac spanked her ass a few times. After a few more licks, Pear Butter orgasms and let her juices all over Bright Mac's face.

Pear Butter said "So, what do you think of my Pear Juice?"

Bright Mac said while licking his face of her juices "It's delicious. I can't believe I've gone my whole life without ever having this."

Pear Butter said "Glad you like it. Now for the main event; hope you're ready."

Bright Mac put Pear Butter down to his level. She got up a bit and prepared to placed her pussy onto his cock. She did this as slowly as she could, but she could still feel the pain from having his cock go inside of her. Eventually, it go to the point where his massive cock popped her cherry. This caused Pear Butter to let out a few tears of pain but Bright Mac wiped them away and gave her a kiss to calm her through the pain. After it became less painful for Pear Butter, she started moving her body up and down on his cock. The two of them moaned and groaned in pleasure and ecstasy of this. Bright Mac loved having her vagina all over his cock and could feel how tight she really is. Pear Butter, even after having her cherry popped, made sure to enjoy every inch of his huge cock inside of her and moved her body even faster after getting use to the pain and the size his cock gave her.

A couple of minutes later, Bright Mac had Pear Butter get on all fours, he got on his knees, and placed his cock inside of her ass; it was just as painful, if not more painful, as having his cock penetrate her pussy. He moved his cock inside and outside of her as slowly for a while until Pear Butter demanded that he go faster. He did what she asked and went faster than ever before. As he went faster, her grabbed hold of her breast and squeezed them tightly which caused Pear Butter to yelp like a dog; she started to yelp even louder as Bright Mac spanked her ass again and again.

Eventually, Bright Mac could feel himself ready to cum again and asked Pear Butter where she would like it; she told him to cum in her ass. Like she wanted and when it was time to release, Bright Mac cummed inside of Pear Butter's ass. He grabbed her up and kissed her passionately before the two of them fall back on the bed.

Elsewhere, Zecora watched as the two rested on the bed. While she is watching, somepony in a hood walks up to her.

The hooded figure said "Well?"

Zecora said "He's already had his first encounter and it went marvelously especially for his first time."

The hooded figure asked "What about the mare; did she enjoy him?"

Zecroa said "She did. From what I can tell, the powder I put on Bright Mac caused it to take full effect on her due to a few factors: She was a virgin, she has feelings for him, and she had the scent of the powder in her for a long period of time.

The hooded figure said "Excellent. Keep me informed on the other mares that he will have sex with."

Zecora said "As you wish."

It's morning. Bright Mac and Pear Butter are fast asleep on Pear Butter's bed; Pear Butter laying beside Bright Mac. However, as soon as the rooster crowed, the two of them started to wake up; but as their eyes opened, they were both shocked to see each other naked.

The two ponies said at the same time while grabbing the sheets"Bright Mac/Pear Butter!"

Pear Butter asked as she covered herself "What are you doing here in my room; why are you naked?"

Bright Mac said "Why are you naked?"

Pear Butter said "This is my house and my room; I can be naked in it."

Bright Mac said "True. That was a stupid question"

Pear Butter said "Weren't we watching "Gigantic"?"

Bright Mac said "We were. I had just come back from the bathroom.........."

Pear Butter said "The love scene began and then........"

They said at the same time "You/I kissed me/you."

Bright Mac said looking around the room and seeing their clothes on the ground "And from what I can tell, we had sex."

Author's Note

Of course I was going to have Pear Butter/Buttercup go first with Bright Mac; I don't think I would forgive myself if that didn't happen along with them losing their virginity together regardless of this story being an AU.

Which mare do you want to see Bright Mac do next?
Chiffon Swirl(Mrs. Cake) or Cherry Jubilee