Blackmailing a Blushing Beauty

by Rarity225

Rating: mature
Tags: Equestria Girls, Porn, Trixie, Sex, Fetish, Rarity (EqG)
Length: 3866

Rarity gets blackmailed by Trixie

After accidentally running into Trixie. Rarity ends up having to make a choice, have her secret exposed to the whole school or doing everything Trixie say which may just leave her in some interesting and nasty situations.

Hello Everypony, here's another requested story. I want to give a huge thanks to the requester for basically coming up with the whole idea for this story. Anyway, Hope you all enjoy!
/)

Fetish Warning Humiliation, Swirlies, scat, (more will be added as new chapters are added.)

Published 2018-02-23 00:50:07 UTC
Last updated 2018-04-29 02:57:34 UTC

Chapter 1

It was a very rainy morning at CHS, almost everyone were hurrying about trying to stay dry. Rarity was one of these students. Normally she would have her umbrella, except the fact it was probably half way across town after it blew out of her hand. The rain pelted her face as she ran as fast as she could into the school.

She ran quickly towards her locker. Hoping no one would see her and she was rather successful, that was until..

"Tada!" A huge puff a blue smoke appeared in front of her. "Behold! It is I, the great and powerfu... Wa- oof."

Rarity hadn't been paying attention to where she was going and ran right into Trixie, knocking both girls to the ground.

"Hey! What's the big idea!?" Trixie hollered. Rarity, on the other hand, didn't say anything. She just got up, and headed off to her locker once again.

"Trixie demands an apology! Get back here!" Trixie yelled after her. "Ugh, so rude." She said.

Then she looked around, people were staring at her. Some laughing, some even had their phones out. "What? What is so funny?" She asked angrily.

She looked down. When Rarity had ran into her, she had been flung into one of the trash cans. She had a banana peel on her head, and unfinished smoothies all over her skirt.

"Wha.. No.. Stop laughing! It's not funny!" She yelled. But the other kids didn't listen and kept taking pictures.

"The Great and Powerful Trixie demands you to stop laughing!"

"Nice trick, Trixie!" One guy yelled.

"Yeah! Is your next trick going to be turning into a juicer!?" Another girl asked.

"Look! She wet herself!"

"What!? No.. I didn't." Trixie stuttered as she looked down and noticed that an unfinished bottle of apple cider was not seeping through her skirt. Everyone present laughed harder..

Trixie was very angry. "I'll get you for this Rarity." She quickly got up and ran off to the bathroom with smoothie dripping off her and other students laughing and still taking pictures.

The school day passed by quickly and when the bell rang, Rarity ran excitedly out of class and all the way home. When she reached her house she walked in, flung her backpack on the couch and made her way to her backdoor. There she stripped out of her wet clothes and made her way into the backyard. The rain was cold but felt great as it splashed against her naked body. She walked over to where her dirt pit was waiting. Rarity stuck her hand in the mud. It sank up to the wrist in the sticky, thick goo that the rain had turned it into with a squelch that sent a shiver up Rarity's spine. Filthy...

"Perfect." she mumbled as she chewed on her lip, biting back a huge, silly grin and gleeful squeal.

Fingers clenched to bring a handful of it with her, she brought her hand out of the mud with another squelch, the drizzling rain making spots of her white skin appear under the glove of brown she now wore. She brought her hand to her chest and with a splat, smeared the handful of muck into the top of her cleavage, letting it drip and trickle down between her breasts as her fingertips traced lines of brown across them, seeking and teasing her nipples. She cooed and giggled with every touch of the cold, sticky mud as it ran down her soft skin, staining it as her rapidly heating body warmed it up.... Finally she couldn't handle it any longer and let herself fall forwards, hands leaving her chest and splayed outwards so she could embrace the mud she loved so much like a lover as she belly-flopped with a splash and squelch! She giggled harder as she felt her body sink into the mud pit just a bit, embraced by the dirt, and rolled onto her back so she could get an even coating on both sides, staring up at the cloud filled sky through a haze of lusty delirium.

"Oh..This is.. so wonderful!" She squealed as she rolled around getting filthier and filthier by the second.

Rarity's hands began to make their way down to her pussy and began massaging herself. Rarity was enjoying herself so much she didn't even notice she had an unwelcomed visitor.

"Haha, this is just too perfect." Said Trixie as she peeked between the holes in the fence around Rarity's backyard.

"This will teach her not to mess with The Great and.. quiet Trixie." She said as she ended her recording, placed her phone back into her pocket and ran away. Rarity had no idea she had been watched. She was to busy enjoying herself.

"Oh god, yes!" Rarity moaned as she reached her climax and flopped back into the mud, catching her breath.

The next morning, the rain had stopped so Rarity wasn't running about. As she was making her way to her locker, she was grabbed and yanked into a dark hallway.

"Wha..what the.." Rarity was caught of guard. "Let me go."

"Oh, I'll let you go. We just need to have a little talk first."

"Trixie." Rarity said as she figured out who was there. "What do you want?"

"Well, first, i've got something rather interesting to show you." Trixie said slyly as she pulled her phone out of her pocket.

"I don't really want to see your circus tricks, I have other things to do." Rarity said impatiently.

"Oh, no. You'll want to see this." Trixie replied holding her phone up to Rarity and played the video she had recorded the day before. Rarity went pale when she saw it.

"Whe.. Where did you get this?!" Rarity shouted.

"I have my ways." Trixie replied smugly, her smile so infuriating Rarity would have wanted to slap her regardless of what she held in her hand

"Delete that... that slander at once!"

"Hmmm....." Trixie seemed to consider it for a moment, tapping the edge of her phone against her lips. Then she smirked. "Nah, I actually think it would be better if I sent it to the whole school."

"Why? What did I do to you!?" Rarity asked angrily, fists trembling as her flush from humiliation mixed with one of anger.

"You humiliated the great and powerful Trixie just yesterday!"

"Humiliated you? Darling, you do that yourself every day." Rarity laughed, smirking despite her flushed face, waving a dismissive hand. Trixie didn't blink at the insult.

"Unless you want me to send that video to everyone in the school. You'll do what I say." Trixie said. Rarity's heart sank, and she swallowed as she considered her options.

"Fine..Fine. Just... tell me what you want me to do..." Rarity said, dropping her eyes in defeat and staring at Trixie's boots, half expecting to have to kiss or lick them, or something.... Trixie's smug grin became wider, more predatory

"You're going to see how it feels to be embarrassed." She replied.

"What?" Rarity asked, very confused.

"You're going to do everything I say.. No matter how strange." Trixie smirked.

"So, if I do what you want.. You won't share that video..."

"That's what I said." Trixie giggled.

Rarity thought for a second. She didn't want her secret fetish plastered all over the school. But she was nervous of what Trixie was going to make her do.

"Fine.. I'll do it." Rarity sighed. "What do you want me to do?"

"Haha, this'll be fun." Trixie giggled again. "Let's go to the bathroom why don't we?"

Rarity rolled her eyes.

"Why?"

"You'll see." Trixie responded and ran down the hall, pulling Rarity with her. They burst into the bathroom. No one else was there. Trixie shoved Rarity into the room and locked the door behind them.

"Okay, you've brought me into the bathroom. What? Are you going to take my kidney now?" Rarity joked.

"No, third stall down, go in." Trixie commanded.

"Uh..okay." Rarity replied and towards the stall. As she did, she peered into the toilet. Someone had obviously used it. The water was brown and smelled awful.

"Ugh, gross." Rarity shrieked. "You brought me in here.. To look at a filthy toilet?"

"Not just look at it. Use it!" Trixie told her. "Let everything out."

"Uh.. Alright. Good thing I had to go anyway." Rarity giggled slightly.

"Tell me when you're done. But before you do the "paper work."

"Whatever." Rarity replied and shut the door.

A little while passed and Rarity had emptied her body of her waste.

"Alright Trixie, I'm done. What do you want now." Rarity asked, slightly worried what Trixie was going to say now.

"Pull up your panties and come out here." Trixie said.

"Okay, but I haven't cleaned up."

"Oh, I know. Now come out here." Trixie commanded.

Rarity did as she was told. She pulled up her panties very carefully as to not get them dirty and walked out of the stall. But Trixie wasn't there.
"Trixie? Where did she g- oh!"
Trixie snuck up behind Rarity and yanked her panties up, letting them slip in between her crack.
"Trixie! What the.. Stop that." Rarity screamed.

"Alright!" Trixie replied and let go of Rarity's panties. They slid back into place.

"What.. How is that supposed to embarrass me?" Rarity said. But Trixie was laughing hard.

"You.. You may wanna look at your butt. Haha!" Trixie said holding her side.
Rarity could feel something wet against her butt, she ran across the bathroom and looked in the mirror. She was horrified at what she saw. Running down the middle of her panties, was a large brown stain.

"Oh my god! That's disgusting!! Oh no.. This is my only pair of panties with me." Rarity shrieked as she began to freak out. Trixie, on the other hand just burst out laughing.

Rarity blushed as she stepped away from the mirror, feeling the sticky stain on her panties rubbing against her skin with every step. The thought of what that sensation was, what that stain looked like, disgusted her!

"Are you happy now!?" Rarity yelled. "Are you done!?"

"Oh no, I'm just getting started." Trixie laughed. At last, she finally was able to calm down. But Rarity was beyond angry.

"Alright, Trixie. You've had your fun. Can I leave now. I've got to try and get this stain out before any one sees."
Rarity yelled.

"Oh, you're going to sit in those the way they are all day." Trixie replied.

"WHAT!"

"Oh and I want you to go stick your head in the toilet you just used." Trixie continued.

"No! Nonono! That is disgusting. I am NOT doing that." Rarity yelled.

"Oh, so you don't mind if I go ahead and release this video all over school, huh?" Trixie taunted. Rarity stopped in her tracks and took a deep breath.

"Fine."

"That's a good girl." Trixie teased.

Rarity walked back into the stall, the water was still left unflushed and smelt terrible.

"Well, I haven't got all day." Trixie taunted.

"Shut up." Rarity snapped back.
She leaned down towards the toilet. Trying her best not to throw up right then and there.

"I just have to do this quickly and it'll all be over." Rarity sighed.

*snap*

"What the, Trixie!" Rarity yelled.

"Just getting a picture of those wonderful panties." Trixie giggled. "Now, what are you waiting for? Get dunking."

Rarity rolled her eyes and turned back to the toilet.

"I can't believe i have to do this." She said to herself, she took a deep breath, the stink hit her nostrils full on, wrinkling her nose and she gaged, as she was forced to breathe in and look directly at the mess she made. Quickly, She forced her head into the filthy toilet.

Trixie couldn't help laughing and taking another picture. Rarity began to lift her head out of the toilet. Dirty water and small chunks of shit dripped off her hair.

"I didn't say come up!" Trixie commanded. "Get back in there." And she forced Rarity's head back down under the water. Rarity was caught off guard, her head went farther then it did the first time and she hear squelches as she was pushed harder into the mess.

At last, Rarity felt Trixie let go of her and she quickly pulled her head out of the water, gasping for air while try to avoid the water and chunks from getting in her mouth. Trixie couldn't stop laughing.

"Are.. We.. Done now?" Rarity asked, catching her breath.

"For now. I'll leave you to clean your self up. But there will be more." Trixie replied. "Meet me behind the school after class."

Trixie began to walk towards the door.

"Oh, and one more thing, you can get the shit out of your hair, but don't change your shirt." Trixie chuckled. "Ta ta!"

With that, Trixie walked out of the bathroom. Leave a very angry and very smelly Rarity alone to dry off.

Chapter 2

The last bell rang and everyone headed out of the school. Wether it was to home or to the the various after school activities. Rarity did as she was told to and was waiting for Trixie at the back of the school. She had spent the day trying to hide her stained panties which she was able to do rather well. The smell from her dunk was harder to get rid of. Luckily, she had plenty of perfume to cover it.

"So, how was your day of being the laughing stock of CHS?" Asked a familiar voice. Rarity looked up just as Trixie walked up.

"Actually, no one really noticed. A couple people asked about a strange smell but other then tha.."

"WHAT! ARE YOU KIDDING ME!?" Trixie screamed.

"Nope.. Face it Trixie. Your "revenge" isn't working." Rarity replied smugly.

"Oh, that was just the beginning. Come on.." Trixie said and yanked Rarity's arm as she hurried back into the school.

"Trixie, come on.. I did what you told me to do. Can we stop this now?"

"No, not until you know what it feels like to be humiliated!" Trixie said and shoved Rarity into the bathroom, making her stumble as the door slammed open and she skidded on slick tiles.

"Wait a minute.." Rarity said as she suddenly realized where she was. "We're in the boy's room!"

The smell had been different, more... musky and pungent, there was a distinct scent of sweat, the acrid tang of piss, and the thick, stifling smell of what was undeniably shit. The girls bathroom could sometimes stink, certainly, quite badly when someone like Rainbow Dash was dropping dumps or just letting out farts without regard... but this was on a whole other level! Rarity gagged and felt her stomach churn at the whirlwind of scents Trixie had stirred up by shoving her so violently through the door.

"That's right. Now, Get in that stall." Trixie grinned, hands grabbing Rarity's shoulders as the girl tried to fan away the smell from her nose and keep her balance at the same time. She shoved her into the stall, Rarity, still off balance, felt her booted foot slip from under her as Trixie spun her. She landed on her backside with an unladylike grunt of pain inside the stall, almost bashing her head on the toilet behind her. She also landed with... a splash.

Rarity shivered as the cold, stinking liquid splashed around her, what must have been a fairly fresh puddle of pee splashing over her hands and easily soaking through her thin skirt and already stained panties. She could feel... IT on her skin! Not just her hands, but her thighs, her backside, even her chest from where it splashed and stained her pristine white shirt!

"Oh my god! Gross!!" Rarity screamed as the urine began to soak into her. The smell was even worse so close to the ground, and she dared not turn around in case the toilet behind her was the source of the more earthy, shitty stenches...

"This is more like it." Trixie laughed, snapping another picture with her phone. She was having trouble deciding which would be the best contact picture for Rarity, and they were far from done... "Now, get on your knees."

"What?"

"You heard me.. Get on your knees." Trixie repeated. Rarity decided it was best not argue with her anymore and slowly pushed herself up on to her knees, feeling the wet, sticky floor soak into her bared skin directly and making her shiver in disgust once again. It was dripping from her skirt!

Trixie laughed and started taking more pictures.

"This is just too perfect." She giggled. "You in your proper position, instead of pretending to be sooooo much better than the rest of us."

"Now, you just wait there." Trixie said as she turned away thumbs tapping furiously on her phone as Rarity just blushed and fumed indignantly. In her proper position? She was kneeling in the boys lavatory in a puddle of urine which had splashed all across her, with a skidmark on her underwear... just how could this get any worse? What did Trixie have in mind?

She didn't have long to find out. After a few minutes of Rarity shifting and splashing in her puddle, and Trixie snickering to herself as she listened and continued to type and take pictures, the door opened again. Rarity, who'd been trying to breathe through her mouth as shallowly as possible, gasped and squeaked, feeling her face burn brightly. They were going to get caught! S-She couldn't be seen like this by boys!

"Holy shit! You weren't lying! You're actually here!" a boy's voice said with an astonished laugh. Trixie grinned as she turned to face the newcomer, motioning with one hand to present Rarity, who was trying to shrink back against the toilet behind her without actually touching it or making a sound.

"Nope! The grrrrrrreat and poweeeerful Trixie has persuaded the stuck up and pompus Rarity that she needs to be humbled, taken down a peg, and make amends for her past misdeeds. She's starting to learn humility, but I thought you boys could help me with that." she said with a grin as the boy stepped up to the stall doorway. Rarity had no idea who he was, but he looked slovenly, shirt rumpled and hair greasy, a little overweight and clearly not giving any thought to his appearance. That someone like HIM saw her in such a state... she blushed more furiously as he looked down at her, grinned, and then laughed.

"Bwhahahaha! Holy shit this is too good!" he said, wiping a tear from his eye as he stepped forwards and let his companions, similarly disgusting males who Rarity was sure she could smell the BO of even through the stink of the bathroom, see the girl kneeling before them.

"Well, Trixie gave me her orders, and it's not like I've got any problem with them...." he said as he began to turn, and to Rarity's horror, undo and start to drop his trousers....

"Good, I'll just sit here and watch. Do your thing. She's all yours." Trixie giggled and sat up on the sink counter to get a good view..

The first guy pulled down his pants down and walked closer to Rarity, exposing his bare rear to her full view.

"Oh my god! What is that revolting smell?" Rarity asked in disgust.

"That's me." The guy responded. "Haven't cleaned in weeks. Have a look." And stepped closer to to Rarity, spreading his checks for her to get a good look. Rarity tried not to look, but since he was only a few inches away from her face, she had no choice.

"Hope you like what you see." He laughed, shaking his ass in her face. Rarity couldn't help but notice he had dried brown spots in his crack. He clearly didn't clean up enough.

Trixie was enjoying this, she was taking pictures and laughing away.

"So, Rarity. Do you recognize this guy at all?" She asked slyly. Rarity thought for a second while also trying to look away from the dirty ass infront of her.

"N-not really. No." Rarity replied, holding back the urge to throw up.

"We dated for a couple of days. I took you to dinner on the last night, leaned in for a kiss and you told me that girls like you don't kiss disgusting people like me." He explained. "Pucker up, bitch. Because you're about to kiss something." And shook his ass infront on her again.

"What? No! I'm not going to-"
"Ah-hm."
Rarity looked up to see Trixie tapping her phone on her lips with the video up. Rarity sighed.

"Fine.. Whatever you say." Rarity forced out and reluctantly leaned closer to his ass, puckering her lips. But just as they were about to make contact...
"pffttttt."

"Oh my god.."

"Ahaha." The guy laughed. Trixie couldn't help but laugh as well. Rarity was speechless.

"I can't believe it! You.. You farted in my face!! That's just disgusting!!"

"Whatever bitch, just get kissing."

"Ewww.." Rarity winced to herself as he pushed his ass closer to her. Rarity leaned in again and quickly gave his rear cheeks a quick kiss and pulled her head away.

"There, done. You can leave now." She blurted out quickly.

"Oh hell no. That wasn't good enough. You're going to make out with it! Like it was a boyfriend."
He laughed at her.

"Ugh. Fine." Rarity rolled her eyes and slowly leaned in once again and began to make out with his ass.

"That's a good girl." He chuckled as Rarity made audible, sloppy kisses on his ass. Suddenly, in one quick move, he moved his ass over and Rarity's face was shoved straight into his filty crack.
"Mmmwhatmmletmmmeemmmgo!" Rarity tried to yell. But wasn't able to get the words out.
"You seemed to be enjoying the cheeks so I think you'll like this more." He said laughing harder as he began to shake his ass up and down with her face still smushed against it.
This went on for a good five minutes until Rarity's face was released from his ass. But not before letting forceing another large fart right into Rarity's face.

"Haha, that's a nice look for you." He laughed hard as he pulled his pants back up. Rarity was confused.

"Nice look? What do you mean." She asked.

"Look for yourself." He laughed again and walked away. Rarity quickly grabbed her hand mirror from her piss soaked pocket and looked at her reflection.

"OH MY GOD!!" She screamed. She had a large, brown skidmark on her face.

"BWAHAHAHA!" Trixie burst out laughing.

"Alright ALRIGHT TRIXIE!" Rarity yelled "I've done what you wanted. I feel humiliated. I'm done!"

"Done? Oh nonono. You're no where close to being done." Trixie chuckled. "You are going to give the guys everything they want. Or else...." She shook her phone in a teasing way.

Rarity sighed. "Well, I suppose it couldn't get any worse." She thought to herself. "Who's next?"

"That's what I want to hear." Trixie smirked and she walked over to the door.