Author's Note

WARNING! WARNING!
TWO MOMENTS OF CLOP!
enjoy and make sure to comment!

Chapter 3: Futa is Magic (Yes I Went There): Part 2

Alright, tonight was the moment of truth, the Tweetles were ready, it was nearing time for the celebration, and the moon looked ominous.

“Okay… game face, Fluttershy…” I said to myself, aware of what was impending.

I decided to skip the massive amount of suspense and get straight to Nightmare Moon’s arrival, since I knew the payoff already and going through that again was more boring than I liked to admit.

Anyways, it was time for Nightmare Moon to come into the picture, and begin her big important speech… buuut I was planning to put my two bits into the ring this time, instead of being silent like the original.

“Oh, my beloved subjects.” she began. “It’s been so long since I’ve seen your precious, sun-loving faces.”

“What did you do with our princess?!” Rainbow demanded before she was held back by Applejack.

NM gave a chuckle and spoke in a more mocking tone to the pegasus. “Oh, am I not royal enough for you? Don’t you know who I am?”

As the room was filled with confused faces, and Pinkie proceeding to make bad guesses to her name, I believed now was cue Fluttershy.

“Are. you. Kidding me?!” I cried out, since this part did in fact make me genuinely annoyed how all of ponyville had no idea who Nightmare Moon was, Celestia didn’t brainwash these idiots! How the Buck did everypony in Ponyville forget one of the greatest tragedies in Equestrian history!?

Funnily enough this had the unintentional effect of killing the mood Nightmare was making, as even she was shocked that someone was more annoyed about her being forgotten than she was, but I was on a roll so I didn’t think long on it. “I’m sorry but I might get a few ponies not remembering but all of you?! For Celestia’s sake this mare has her own holiday!!”

“I do?” she asked, her earlier malice drained by the fact that she was actually having her own day.

“Yes, it’s called Nightmare Night, every year Ponies stay up during the night to gather up a big candy offering to you and wear monster costumes to disguise themselves as your minions.”

“Disguises? Offerings?” she said with a bit of excitement. “I guess they know to fear my power, so what is it that drives such terror?”

“Well it… was mainly about the old ponish legend of how you snatched away foals to create the first Thestrals but…” she seemed to be unamused at the ‘but’. “Mistranslations had it dumbed down to the point where it says you eat foals.”

“... excuse me.” the now green Nightmare said as she ran off.

“Wow Fluttershy, how do you know so much about Nightmare Night?” Rainbow Asked.

“Yeah! Normally you hide in your cottage and don’t want to go near the holiday!”

“Well, after the celebration last year I wanted to know why Nightmare Night had to be so scary, maybe I could’ve made a nice, not-spooky little party for my animal friends, no sense in them being left out of the fun because I was too scared.” they all seemed to nod at that. “But when I started reading the original legends, it was really interesting to hear of the tales of the first Nightmare Night… it’s… part of why I’ve been working to build confidence.”

“Wow, little Fluttershy working to be braver, I couldn’t be more proud!” my prismatic pal exclaimed.

After that little revelation, we watched as Nightmare Moon returned, looking rather nauseous before shaking it off to glare at the crowd. “I can’t believe Celestia allowed such a wretched lie to besmirch my name! Despite my intent I make no move to kill, let alone devour, any of you ponies, it seems I will have to take my recompense, I was merely going to cage her and bring about Eternal Night! But now... once I am done with my plans, After the next few generations I will drag her name into the mud and see how she likes being seen as a pony eating monster… better yet, I’ll have her remembered as a Foal-Fondler!”

The crowd gasped in terror as she laughed maniacally, disappearing into the mist and off into the Everfree.

“Great! If Night Forever wasn’t bad enough, now she’s going to have our grandfoals think Celestia was a pedophile!” Rainbow cried out as Applejack lost her grip from the sheer shock of such a plan.

“Sorry everypony… if I hadn’t opened my mouth she-”

“Oh come now Fluttershy,” not horny enough maybe later, wait… no! Bad brain! BAD! “There’s no way you could’ve known, you shouldn’t feel sorry for anything.”

“Thanks… say, where’d Twilight go?”

They all blinked and looked around for her. “She must be heading back to the Library.” Applejack said.

“Yeah… she seems to know a lot more than she lets on!” Rainbow added.

With a resolved group mentality, we rushed off to the Golden Oak to interrogate Twilight on the matter.

We arrived a few seconds later to see Rainbow accusing Twilight of being a spy, and my brain decided to go anime for a moment. I don’t know why I did it, but I regret it and don’t regret it at the same time…

I just drop-kicked her. “Sorry for that, Twilight, we shouldn’t be accusing you like this, I’m guessing you were preparing for this when Celestia sent you here?”

“Ow… nice form…” Rainbow groaned as she got up. “How’d you get so strong?”

“I have to wrestle a bear so he lies still for his massage.” I say, having them all be quiet. “...what? Harry’s a nice bear, but he’s very stubborn when it comes to his spine.”

“Right…” Twilight said. “Anyways, I can’t talk long, I need to find the book on the Elements of Harmony but I can’t find them!”

“‘Elements of Harmony: A Reference Guide’.” Pinkie read aloud, causing Twilight to ask, Pinkie to have a weird answer, and everyone just understanding Pinkie is random… in other news grass is green, the sky is blue and this joke is overused.

Knowing our path, we stopped outside the border of the Everfree, and let’s just say.

Despite my cottage being so close, being this close was terrifying, it had an aura about it that was never shown in the cartoon, the simple malevolent energy pouring out of it was like we were marching into the jaws of a hungry predator with a taste for Equines.

Nevertheless we marched in, facing the first peril of Nightmare Moon, the cliff… yet it was different than expected.

As the rocks fell away, I found myself on a perfect circle of earth that remained despite all logic. I would’ve questioned the circumstances of why NM did that but then Rainbow reminded me of our non-winged comrades.

It was easy for us to catch everypony and for AJ to succeed in the challenge of Honesty… yet my thoughts went back to that rock.

Next up was my test, the test of Kindness.

In all honesty, I doubt I’d qualify for that title much, I will readily admit that I have on occasion been a bit of a mischievous ass and that I think that would’ve disqualified me but… my friends were depending on me, I’d push through that doubt as we marched onward, and the Manticore appeared, and I was ready to translate.

“[RRRRAAAAAAAAGH!!!]”

Okay… he just roared, but thankfully I could still see the issue.

Before the group moved to attack, I called out.

“WAIT!” I winced as everypony else did, and I walked up to the Manticore, still roaring in pain, confusion and anger. “It’s okay, I want to help.” I said sweetly, motioning to his paw.

As he showed it to me, it looked deep in there, so it must seriously be hitting a nerve. “Oh you poor thing, don’t worry, this will only hurt for a second, ready?”

The beast nodded as I gripped the thorn in my mouth and pulled.

*pop* *roar* *licks of thanks* you get the idea, right?

Well here’s where it differs, before we all left I grabbed the Thorn in my hoof “um, excuse me, but I need to… use the little mare’s room.” and with that I sped off into the bushes.

And as I entered my face instead sported a lecherous grin as I looked down upon the ‘lifeless, inanimate thorn’ I knew in truth to be a shapeshifted Nightmare.

Knowing she didn’t know that I knew, I walked up to my prey. “Oh it’s so hard being around all those animals, and little innocent Fluttershy couldn’t possibly buy something to aid her~.” I said in a sultry tone that would turn cooked spaghetti hard. “You’re a little blunt on the end, so I hope you’re gentle enough~.”

I could feel the panic and confusion in my captive, if she reverted back now, she’d be caught before her power was fully restored, especially since shapeshifting magic is very taxing for non-changelings, but if she didn’t revert back…

Well it was too late for her to make a decision now, the mood had indeed got me horny, and I wanted to try my new marehood out~. I lowered down… letting out a tiny squeak as I feel the smooth pointed object rubbed against my pink gates, before I applied more gravity and let it slip in.

With luck, even if it was sharp before, the tip was rounded down now, leaving me safe from danger, but holy fuck did that curve feel good all up inside me~.

“Mm~, that’s a very lovely shape you have~!” I cooed as I pushed deeper and deeper, until I found myself sitting on the ground, my thorn playmate all the way in, and when I stood up, no amount of lubrication could help her escape the clutches of my hungry lips. “Ooh~! I must be more pent up than I thought~.”

I smirk as I gave a little sway back and forth, letting it shift around inside me.

*throb* *throb*

“Nnh~... *giggle* okay, you get to come out and play too~.” I say as I slipped off my cock-covering and sat down again, pushing the inch that slid out back up in there. “Ooh~! Eager little thorn-dick~...” I say as I wrapped my forehoof around my hungry length. “I have just the pussy to imagine you taking~.” I say as I stroked and moaned, my pussy convulsing with every touch of my shaft, causing Nightmare to stimulate me more.

“Ahh~ oh buck~, such a tight marehole.” I muttered in my imagination, my hoof going further along my length, faster and faster. “Oooh you’re such a dirty slut, aren’t you~? Letting me take you like this!” I cried, and my motions went faster and faster, my vision starting to go white as my cock throbbed in readiness.

“Oh! You’re making me cum a big load!” I cried into my other hoof, desperate to ensure the others didn’t here, but I was already so close, I leaned forward, about to spray a puddle into the ground in front of me as I declared the name of who I fantasized plowing.

“Oh buck~!! Luuunaaaa!! nnNNGH~!!” I cried out, muffled by my hoof as I let loose stream after stream, my convulsions more frantic that they forced my makeshift dildo out of my cunt, but I didn’t care, I simply stayed there in bliss, panting as I let my cock shrink enough to re-cover it.

As I smiled and looked back to the thorn, drenched in my mare-juices, I leaned forward and gave it a slight kiss. “Maybe I’ll get to take it for real sometime, right Nightie~?” I giggled and trotted back to the group before she could do anything.

Next was the test of laughter… actually that didn’t really change at all and I’m not transcribing the song so fuck off.

Now the test of Generosity didn’t change much either, only that I made it apparent to Rarity that with her tail so short we could see everything.

Happily that meant she grabbed some of the foliage for a basic prosthetic to retain her dignity, so she now had a leafy green tail to cover-up.

Now the test of Loyalty, that changed quite a bit, because instead of a broken bridge it was something I could never expect. The test involved me…

As I was snatched up by Nightmare and pulled off deep into the forest!

“AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHH!” I screamed.

“FLUTTERSHY!” the group screamed back as I got further and further away.

As I was now out of sight I was thrown unceremoniously onto my back behind a bush, yet as I moved to get up I was stopped and pinned down by my foalnapper.

“I’m afraid it will be some while before your friends come to rescue you, perverted pegasus, in the meantime, I will relish having some payback against one who saw fit to use me as a common sex-toy!”

Oh shit, what’s she going to do to me?! My brain rushed into fear as I thought of all the possible punishments a pissed-off princess of the night could do to me.

Chop me up.

Throw me to space.

Freeze me alive into a pegasicle.

Grow a massive horseco-wait, what??

Indeed, in my fear and panic, I was only snapped out of it by the sight of the shining black tower that stood tall before me, a practically glistening regal length built to ream and reduce the common mare into a moaning puddle.

“Let’s see how fun it is to have me penetrate you now!!” she declared, lining herself up to me. “Ah, I see you’re already wet with terror and wish to beg me for your-wait… that’s not urine.”

She looked back up to my blushing, half-lidded face as I looked back, my eyes shining with a burning need that had erupted the moment I saw what she was about to do to me, the fantasies from before only fueling the new-found arousal.

...okay, it may also help that I might have a bit of a rape fetish.

“P-please be gentle… i-it’s my first time.” I squeaked out as I stared up at her, trying to spread my hind-legs a little wider.

I felt a sense of pride as I stared up at a shocked and blushing Nightmare Moon who was seconds ago prepared to ravage me, even more so when a trickle a blood began flowing down from her left nostril.

Though as expected she shook herself out of it and seemed angrier. “You think this is a game?!” she declares as she thrusts into me, and I cried out as I felt her enter past my cervix, yet only reaching the medial ring. “I’ll teach you to treat me with the proper respect!” she growled and thrusted in, she was hard, fast, slamming into me over and over as she fucked my pussy raw for the sheer thrill.

Yet with every thrust of her massive length, and every squeak of pleasure she forced out of me, I saw a hint of actual affection in the act, the way she pounded into me and felt my pussy milk her for the white treat it craved.

This was NOT hatefucking or revenge-rape, she was doing this because she wanted me.

And I was all too happy to be wanted like this. “Oh Nightie~!! Come on, force it deeper! I wanna bulge!”

“Be silent! This is your consequence for disrespecting me! I am your Princess, and you will serve! Be it as a slave or a slut~!!”

“Yes Mistress~!” I purred out between thrusts, causing her blush to come back full force.

“S-stop that!!”

“Please Mistress, use me like the worthless little cumdump I am, fill me with your seed~, it is my purpose to take your baby batter~!”

Her resolve wavered at the sub-play, as with her dominatrix mindset, this was seriously getting her off. “Enough~!! I’m your Princess! Your ruler! I am the one who shall bathe the land in eternal night! You are nothing to me~!!”

“I’m your biiiitch~...” I moaned loudly, and it seems that was enough to get her to crack as she dropped her weight on me, forcing herself balls deep!

“You cunning little mare-slut~!! Look what you’ve done to me! I’m going to make you regret making me lose it.”

“Please… don’t stop~!!” I declared as she thrusted in again and again, her balls slapping against my flanks in this kinky forest fuck. “I’m so close, Mistress~!! I’m… I’M CUMMING~!!”

“No, you’re not cumming before me~!!” she thrusted harder. “Yes! Yes! AAAAHHH~~!!”

I felt a bit upset when she forced her orgasm out first, but immediately forgave her as she proceeded to get me over the edge with a few extra thrusts, it was bliss, absolute Elysium, it was-

“Fluttershy! Are you there?!”

“Buck! I thought the Shadowbolts would’ve held her up long enough for a second round!” she said before she poofed into mist and disappeared, leaving me alone, suffering aftershocks of climax, panting, and dripping Alicorn jizz out of my gaping marehood.

“Fluttershy! Where are-OH SWEET CELESTIA!” my friend Rainbow screamed when she found me in my current state.

“Oh… h-hey Rainbow… took… your time… didn’t you~?” I gasped out as she helped me back onto my jelly legs… which when she realized I wasn’t gonna be able to even stand any time soon, she apologized for and carried me back to the others who had similar reactions, even Pinkie.

“Oh my goodness! That must’ve been horrible!” Twilight said as Rarity got her fainting couch.

“That low-down dirty snake!” Applejack declared angrily.

“...was she any good?” Pinkie asked.

“PINKIE!” the others yelled.

“Very~...” I said in my little prolonged afterglow, causing everyone to go silent until I eventually sobered up and blushed redder than Big Macintosh. “W-wait! I didn’t mean-!”

“It’s alright, Fluttershy! We understand you weren’t in your right mind after that, we’ll have to rest here, you’re in no condition to go anywhere and we can’t leave you alone.”

“O...okay, thanks Twilight.” I replied as I collapsed into the soft dirt.

When I managed to recover feeling in my legs… and everything around my pelvis… I rushed with the others to the castle.

I went through many of the motions when I got there and saw Twilight focusing on how to spark the five elements.

I wasn’t really thinking when I heard Twilight scream, I just acted and rushed to help her like the friend I was, including when it came to follow Applejack to the next structure.

However, I think everyone caught the flinch I made when I saw Nightmare Moon again… and she licked her lips at me.

Why does being a protagonist have to be so good yet so bad at the same time?!

I didn’t even realize I got my element until after we had made Nightmare ‘Taste The Rainbow’.

And I didn’t become fully aware of what was going until we were at the big celebration and I looked at Luna…

...she seemed to blush when we made eye contact, but she didn’t look upset, in fact she smiled a little.

This day was almost perfect.

“Come on, come on…” I said as I stared at the little item in my hoof.

It was only natural after a thorough rutting that I should’ve used a pregnancy test.

I waited… and waited… and waited…

*ding* [-]

“MOTHERBUCKER!”

...WHAT?! What mare, or woman for that matter, wouldn’t want Luna’s foal??