Spiking the Punch

“Hmmm, something’s not right here,” Starlight tapped her chin as she looked at Applejack.

Applejack lay on her back with legs splayed, ready to be a wishbone in a non-incestuous sense for once. One leg was okay while the other was bent back at the knee. The break swelled and discolored around the bone shards that poked free, agitated by Applejack putting weight on it.

“One of mah legs is broked,” Applejack explained.

“Oh!” Starlight nodded. “I thought something looked off.”

“Wow, our brains are like soup at this point!” giggled Pinkie. “It’s okay though! We’ll break the other and jar it around to be fair!”

Pinkie grabbed the other leg and twisted it at the knee, pulling it back. Applejack bit her lip to anticipate the surge of pain though it took Pinkie longer than she’d like before Applejack’s ankle snapped. When it did, and Pinkie jarred it around at random, Applejack rolled back her eyes and shivered.

“Hmm, I don’t know if that’s the same,” pointed out Starlight. “I think now you’re has more because the swelling on this one is keeping it somewhat stable. Here.”

Starlight grabbed the first leg, turning the knee about and jarring it a few times.

“That should do it,” Starlight smiled.

“But ya broke a different joint,” pointed out Applejack. “Easy mistake ta make ah guess.”

“Wow, am I dumber than an earth pony now?” Starlight blinked. “Excellent! That’s the humiliation a genius like me deserves!” She wanted all the suffering she could, and emotional suffering was still suffering. She’d take it.

Pinkie grabbed the leg on her side at the knee while Starlight grabbed her leg at the ankle. A few moments later, Applejack spasmed again in delight at the new joints breaking. As the breaks were twisted, shattered bones ground together, she came, cock shooting off a geyser of spunk as her pussy blasted a shower to join. Pinkie and Starlight both opened wide to catch what they could.

“Here, let me get that under control for you!” Pinkie offered. She grabbed another knife from the drawer and slammed it into the floor, impaling Applejack’s balls to keep them still. That just caused her to orgasm again though this time blood and cum poured out of the torn ball sack.

“Good enough,” said Starlight. “Ready?” She grabbed Applejack’s hind leg with her magic and got ready to pull.

“Ready!” Pinkie grinned, grasping the other leg with her hooves. “Go!”

The leg breaking wasn’t needed since they both pulled apart at the upper leg, but it had been fun anyway so that was okay. It took a few minutes of tugging before it gave. Applejack’s hips cracked as both legs came off at once, tearing out by the root and leaving only her bloody broken pelvis.

Applejack groaned and creamed again, more blood spurting out. As she did so, Starlight and Pinkie held the two severed legs together. They were even.

“Hmm that won’t do,” said Starlight. “Oh well, let’s go for the front legs I guess!”

Pinkie and Starlight took the time to break Applejack’s front legs, even if such a kind act wasn’t needed. Applejack held them out, drooling as each leg snapped at the knee and ankle, twisted around at each break.

Applejack rolled her eyes back as her legs pulled apart from one another, soaking up the bliss of the twisted limbs before they came free. The legless pony could only watch now as they compared the two new legs, which were also the same length.

“Well, I’m out of good ideas for this,” shrugged Starlight.

“I got one!” Pinkie suggested. “Give us super-long dicks, we fuck her cunt and ass, impale her all the way out the muzzle, then pull apart to rip her in two long-ways! If it still looks even then, we’ll just ask Twilight to judge.”

Both the mares lacked bits at the moment, but Starlight solved that. After all, they’d been through, neither flinched as their body molded the new piece, but it felt great all the same. Initially their dicks were normal sized to enter, so they sat on their haunches facing one another as Applejack was pulled between them.

Applejack squeaked as her balls, still pinned to the floor, tore off and stayed where they were. Starlight grasped Applejack’s throbbing erection with her magic, grasping the base before twisting it off, making more room for their current task. She kept the cock hard, squeezing the base to keep it full like a blood balloon.

As Applejack’s fuck-pillow of a body floated between them, Starlight pressed her tip against the earth pony’s sopping pussy, while Pinkie nestled against her tight little asshole. They forced Applejack’s body downward, both invading futa mares moaning at the feel of warm flesh twitching in constant agony around them. Applejack moaned too, but Starlight cut hers short by shoving Applejack’s own cock into her muzzle, ramming it down her throat until she gagged.

Soon the three cocks were pumping in and out, gradually lengthening. Starlight’s pushed deeper into Applejack’s fuck tunnel with each thrust, until it rammed through her cervix and into her womb, soon poking at the back. The stretch became tighter and tighter still until it broke right through the tender flesh and into her gut.

Pinkie’s cock did the same, lengthening until it jarred the edge of Applejack’s intestines and forced its way through her. The warmth of Applejack’s shivering guts felt amazing as Pinkie pushed up through them and into her guts as Starlight had. Pumping in and out, the two could feel their cocks sliding against one another as Applejack’s body bulged in unnatural manners.

Applejack convulsed as they impaled her deeper still. Unlike Twilight, Starlight could still magic an x-ray view of Applejack’s insides. Instead of using that to make sure they went up through her neatly though, Starlight used it to make sure each cock punctured a different lung. Applejack vomited blood around the disembodied cock still ramming her throat, splattering like a fountain onto Pinkie and Starlight.

Starlight’s magic or not, Applejack wouldn’t survive long now, but she didn’t need to live much longer. The cocks impaled her lungs, then pulled close to push up through her neck. Her neck bloated, the cock in her throat pushed out to make way for the double bloody tips that exited her muzzle.

After exiting, both futa cocks exploded into a fountain of cum. It shot upwards, splattering against the ceiling and raining down on them. It left both with spunk pouring down their body, swirls and blobs of white joining the puddles of blood on the floor until the whole thing swirled together into a pinkish slime.

As they pulled apart, Applejack convulsed in excitement, knowing her life would soon end forever. It took a long time to rip, even with Starlight augmenting the shafts and pulling both apart with her magic, but it gave after a few more minutes of fun. With a loud grotesque sound, Applejack’s body gave at her thighs and tore up the middle

Blood and guts poured into a heap on the floor as her body came apart. The meaty flesh tore off either side, ripping away from her rib cage, left on its own for a moment before collapsing to the floor. Her head, spine, and gory ribs fell in the middle while much of her meat came off on either side, equal amounts falling at the hooves of both futas.

“Well that was pointless,” Starlight sighed

“Not at all!” offered Pinkie. “We gave our good friend a brutal end!”

“Wow, I guess so,” said Starlight. “We are learning so much about friendship as we die!” She turned to Twilight. “Twilight? Could you judge which is bigger?”

“Huh?” Twilight looked away from Gummy and to the mass of parts that was once Applejack. “Oh, I can’t tell, but let’s kill Pinkie first, we need Starlight’s magic to drag out the last two deaths.”

“That makes sense!” nodded Pinkie.

“Say Pinkie,” said Twilight. “Did you know about Gummy’s eye socket fetish? Cause he came in Rarity’s and now he’s fucking Rainbow’s.”

“Oh yeah,” Pinkie nodded. “He did that to Nana Pinkie at her funeral. It was a little awkward! He couldn’t fly though!”

“I think that’s because I gave him Twilight’s cutie mark,” said Starlight.

“Makes sense!” Pinkie nodded. “You know it’s hard for Gummy having no teeth; he’s been trying to murder me for years but hasn’t been able to. Hey! He should help!”

“Hear me mortals!” Gummy’s voice echoed in their heads. “The slaying of the pink one is nigh! Use me as a condom as you fuck her to death!”

“Hey, I have an idea,” said Starlight. “I’ll use Gummy as a condom to fuck Pinkie!”

“How creative!” nodded Pinkie.

“Okay, you enjoy that,” said Twilight. “I’ll join, but I promised Spike I’d fuck his corpse, so I’ll ride his corpse-cocks first.

Twilight’s legs were stiff, swollen and baked. Any movement at all created agony, which made her enjoy her walk to get Spike even more. She limped over to him, placing him on her back before going back. She collapsed several times along the way, but got back into the kitchen to continue watching.

Rather than shortening her shaft with magic again, Starlight sliced it off at about the length she wanted. She brought Gummy around in front of her and put his asshole to her dick. She pressed hard, but the tiny gater’s hole was tighter than any fuck-hole she’d ever impaled.

“This will kill him quicker than I’d like,” said Starlight, but Gummy didn’t seem fazed. He hanged on her cock and blinked from time to time, his own stiff mini-shafts hanging beneath him, covered in blood and pus from fucking all those eye sockets.

Pinkie took a more unique approach to removing her own cock. Instead of cutting it off, she retrieved a cheese slicer from the drawer, made to slice a small chunk of cheese into slices all at once. Putting it to the tip of her cock, she sawed, clenching her teeth as her tip tore into slides and drooled blood down its long throbbing length.

“Your failure is absolute mortal,” Gummy’s voice boomed. “Allow me to intervene to stave off your incompetence.”

“This is so fucking ridiculous,” laughed Starlight.

“Welcome to my life!” giggled Pinkie. “Um, I mean death. Welcome to my death!” She continued to saw through her cock, blood bubbling out as she continued to cut it into slices longways, shivering as she worked her way down the length

Gummy’s eyes glowed, and Starlight popped into his asshole. His new magic allowed him to stretch without tearing in half, but it crushed his organs against his ribs, so it was only a matter of time for him. His gut bulged, but remained calm as Starlight pushed deeper.

Even with the magic preventing his injury, it was excruciating, but he was okay with that even without having drank the punch. He’d watched these mares murder one another for hours and now he wanted in, literally. He would endure and enjoy any amount of pain to do it.

As she watched, Twilight lay Spike’s corpse out on the floor. She purred as she pulled herself up upon his cold body. She slid his double cocks within her, having to force them in, cunt and ass dry and swollen from being baked. It felt like daggers sliding into her flesh, making her moan as she bounced.

“I guess we’re the only three left,” Twilight mused as she watched her friends. “It’s good to see you die, Pinkie. I have to admit, I’ve wished you’d die more than once.”

“Aw, Twilight,” Pinkie smiled. “You should never keep your friends from the joy of being murdered!” She was half-way through her cock now, falling onto her back and spreading her legs wide for Starlight as she did so. Pinkie continued to saw even as she grabbed the sliced tip in her muzzle and ate the delicious bloody flesh.

“I think this worked out better,” said Starlight, pulling herself close to Pinkie and pushing Gummy’s nose to Pinkie’s slit. “I don’t imagine you’d been so creative with your murder back then.”

Starlight shoved her hips, pushing Gummy into Pinkie’s body. The slut’s cunt stretched over him, Pinkie groaning as the ridges on his scales agitated her sensitive flesh. Starlight took long hard strokes, leaning forward to help Pinkie devour the sliced and diced cock.

One of the first things Gummy did when he got magic was give himself teeth. His lack of teeth prevented him from murdering Pinkie Pie and others before, but not anymore. Being fucked to death was a small price to pay to get to aid with Pinkie’s murder.

He opened wide as Starlight forced him through Pinkie’s cervix and into her womb. It was no easy task, but he kept snapping until he grabbed the wall of her womb in his teeth, crushing the tender flesh between his teeth. As Starlight yanked back, he pulled a chunk of Pinkie’s womb into her fuck tunnel.

The motion helped loosen her up inside though it didn’t take a lot since Pinkie’s reproductive system had taken plenty of beatings already over the years. With his current condition, he couldn’t swallow a lot, but it was enough to taste the delicious meat and tear her apart. He gnawed the flesh he grabbed to a pulp, crushing one of her ovaries like delicious fuck-fruit.

“Oh!” Pinkie groaned. “He’s eating me from the inside! Cool!” Her body bloated with the shape of gummy and discolored beneath her fur from the internal bleeding. He finished her womb and grabbed for whatever other organs he could reach.

Pinkie finished slicing her cock to the base, so she and Starlight engorged themselves on the tender flesh left hanging. Starlight lengthened her cock, not yet impaling Gummy fully, but pushing him deeper so he could continue to fist. Gummy had the time of his life, hind legs jacking off his little gator cocks as he came all over the bloody minced guts inside his owner.

Pinkie’s belly burst open and Gummy’s bloody head popped out. Starlight moaned, creaming a torrent of seed which shot through Gummy and out his muzzle, raining down upon Pinkie’s upper body and face. Pinkie opened her muzzle and lay back to enjoy her demise.

As she watched, Twilight fulfilled her promise to Spike, laying him back on the floor and pulling his hard shafts upward. She moaned as she slid down onto them, her dry, cooked cunt and ass a fountain of pain upon being penetrated. She continued to roll her hips, sliding her well done pussy and ass down onto his corpse. She felt her fragile insides peel apart from the friction.

When she came, it unleashed a river of blood onto the floor from her cunt and ass together. She shook, dizzy now from blood loss but still held on to life. She regained her composure enough to see Starlight blowing her load through Pinkie’s chest, her tip exiting Gummy’s muzzle as the alligator died happy. He’d made good use of Twilight’s cutie mark to survive so long.

But as Starlight withdrew once more, she sealed up Pinkie’s chest again with her magic, taking none of the pain but keeping her from spilling out further. She turned back to Twilight and motioned for her to come closer.

“Come, Twilight,” Starlight panted. “I want to see if I can get Pinkie to explode from cum overfilling, not just burst open like Trixie did.”

“Sure!” Twilight smiled. “Anything to make my good friend’s murder more brutal!”

Twilight’s body reshaped from Starlight’s magic, giving her a new functional dick. The process hurt even more than it would have since it was burned flesh reshaping. Even after it reshaped, there were nasty burns all over the throbbing shaft. It would be agonizing to push that into anypony, and Twilight couldn’t wait.

Pinkie moaned and fell limp as Starlight picked her up and Twilight pulled up behind her, pressing her new-new futa cock against Pinkie’s rear entry. Starlight’s magic tightened up the dual entries so they wouldn’t overflow and even sealed off the back of Pinkie’s throat to prevent leakage from there. Pinkie only remained alive because of Starlight’s magic.

Starlight and Twilight thrust into Pinkie together. They pushed into the shredded flesh pit where many of her organs had been chewed up by the dead alligator still hanging on Starlight’s cock. Murdering her last best friend and the torment of ramming her charred cock into the tight flesh sent Twilight to her peak. Starlight wasn’t any different, getting to complete her revenge, even if she hadn’t wanted it anymore until this started.

When the two came together, Starlight’s magic continued to hold Pinkie together as her body bloated grotesquely. The magicocks didn’t stop pouring bloody seed into Pinkie’s body and it expanded all the more, making her look like a pony balloon. Starlight only released the spell holding Pinkie together when she was certain that there was enough pressure.

Pinkie exploded cum and gore all over the kitchen when she came apart. Only her plot remained between Starlight and Twilight, and the two continued fucking into the gutted pony part even after she came apart. Her head rolled to a stop nearby, glimpsing of the two mares ramming what remained of her bottom half and dying with a big smile on her face.

“Yes! They’re all dead!” Twilight moaned.

“Mmm, not all of them,” Starlight grinned. “Ready to kill one another?”

“Am I?” grinned Twilight. “Where should we die?”

“Let’s die at the punch bowl,” said Starlight. “Since that’s what Spike and Trixie used to trick us into murdering each other.”

“Great idea!” Twilight smiled as she attempted to stagger back there. “I still can’t believe they pulled that off. I trusted Spike more than anypony else, so him betraying me to a gruesome death like this is so arousing!”

Starlight repaired Twilight’s body enough so she wouldn’t die too quickly, but did nothing for the pain. They both moved back onto the table with the punch on it, kicking Fluttershy’s torso onto the floor as they climbed onto it.

“So, I guess we fry each other with electrocution?” asked Twilight. “It’s pretty much the only thing I can do with my horn broken.”

“That should work!” Starlight grinned. “I can’t wait for you to die, Twilight.”

“Aw,” Twilight smiled. “I can’t wait for you to die either, Starlight.”

The two ponies kissed while charging. Starlight envied how much agony Twilight would feel with her horn in that condition, but needed her own magic to make certain they survived a long time.

They shocked one another, a jolt of energy that set the bloody, cummy table cloth aflame from the energy. Starlight put that out, lest all their bodies burn and whoever found them didn’t get to see the full horror of how they murdered one another.

As the power charged up, so did the agony, both mares rolling their eyes back at the sensation of cooking from the inside. The torment increased exponentially as their body heated, and soon their fur was smoldering. Their blood boiled, eyes popping and oozing down their faces, tongue and gums coming apart and sizzling, and even their futa cocks swelled before bursting all over the table.

Soon their blood was boiling out of their bodies. Starlight’s magic keeping them alive shattered though as her horn cracked, and they both felt their lives fading. They locked lips into one last kiss during their last moments.

“Twilight!” Celestia burst into the room. “I sensed something amiss and…“

Celestia’s mouth dropped open. Twilight grinned at her with her gory muzzle, teeth popping out like popcorn due to the heat, before she and Starlight collapsed together onto the table.

“Bye! Please murder our families and yourself!” Twilight gargled before she faded from life.

Celestia looked around the room, eyes wide as she beheld the gore and stench of fresh well-fucked bodies.

“Fuck this is hot…” Celestia panted, moving her front hooves between her thighs.