Assertive Fluttershy and the Shy Angel Bunny

by Polaris Solarmoon

Rating: everyone
Tags: Comedy, Angel, Fluttershy, Random, Twilight Sparkle, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Alternate Universe, Original Character
Length: 1197

What if Fluttershy and Angel Bunny's personalities were swapped?

Twilight somehow messes up a spell and it changes Fluttershy and Angel Bunny's personalities around and to make thing worse Twilight has company over for a sleepover, this is gonna be interesting.

(will feature a guest appearance by both Glitter Brightstar and Phoenix Firewing.)

Published 2018-03-30 23:40:06 UTC
Last updated 2018-03-30 23:40:06 UTC

The Sleepover.

[Opposite Day]

Fluttershy, normally a kindhearted and shy mare who usually keeps to herself in her cottage with all of her animal friends, right now said mare is heading over to Twilight's home with her pet bunny Angel to see if she can come over for a sleepover.

"I can do this." Fluttershy softly mutters to herself.

She then goes inside and finds Twilight near the room with the cutie map in it.

"Oh hello Fluttershy, glad you can make it. " Twilight says as she walks up to Fluttershy and gives her a hug.

"I'm not alone, I brought Angel with me." Fluttershy whispers, her bunny upon hearing it's name hopped out of the basket she was carrying him in and crossed his arms in a little,"humph" gesture.

"Sorry about that, he's pretty grumpy about being up so late." Fluttershy said.

Angel confirms this by yawning.

"That's ok Fluttershy, I'm just glad your here. I wasn't able to get anypony else because they were busy with their jobs and all." Twilight said.

"Oh okay, I guess it's just us..." Fluttershy says to herself quietly.

"Hey, Fluttershy?" Twilight said.

"Um, yes Twilight?" Fluttershy said.

"Well you and Angel are pretty close right?" Twilight said.

"Of course Twilight, we were together for a long time." Fluttershy says as she pets Angel who simply taps his hind leg in response.

"Ok good, so I heard he's pretty assertive and often treats you poorly, so I've devised a spell that will turn the tables on him." Twilight said.

"What!? Twilight, I will not allow you to use magic on Angel, who knows what could happen to him!" Fluttershy says sternly.

"But Fluttershy haven't you've wondered what it be like to as assertive as him?" Twilight asked.

"No Twilight, I'm not letting you cast magic on him and that's final!" Fluttershy says sternly.

All of a sudden Twilight's voice changed slightly," Aww, your no fun." she says in a totally different voice than before.

"Twilight? What's going on?" Fluttershy asked her.

"It's me Glitter Brightstar, Twilight invited me over for the sleep over and you know I couldn't say no and besides I don't work today!" Glitter Brightstar says as she repoofs up her mane.

Angel curiously hops towards the odd mare and sniffs her, he then hops back to Fluttershy then shrugs.

The real Twilight immediately appears in the room with her teleportation spell and says to Fluttershy," Sorry about that Fluttershy, you remember Glitter Brightstar right? Well she'll be staying over for a little while and she isn't alone she's brought your counterpart Phoenix Firewing as well."

"Oh my..." was Fluttershy's only response.

"Oh, I just remembered! I've got to bring Phoenix here, I'll be back!" Glitter Brightstar says before teleporting away.

"Is she always like that?" Fluttershy asks Twilight.

"Yes, yes she is... I don't know why but she's like a mix of myself and Pinkie." Twilight said.

"Oh okay, um about that spell on Angel..." Fluttershy said.

"Oh that, it was something I wanted to test out, all it will do is make him a little more nicer than he normally is." Twilight said.

"Oh, that makes sense. Glitter tried pretending to be you did she ?" Fluttershy asked Twilight.

"Yes she did, she told me that she was really smart so I told her to prove it so she disguised as myself and well now you know why I acted so strange." Twilight said.

"Alright, can you try that spell on him?" Fluttershy said.

"Okay, set him right by the map and I'll get the spell ready." Twilight said.

"Ok, come on Angel" Fluttershy says as she does what Twilight said.

"Now Twilight, this spell won't hurt him right?" Fluttershy said.

" Don't worry it's harmless." Twilight says as she readies the spell.

"Ok be careful Twilight." Fluttershy said.

"I will don't worry what's the worst thing that can happen? Alright here goes nothing." Twilight says as she casts her spell on Angel.

Fluttershy had closed her eyes and hoped for best.

"Something changed..." Twilight muttered to her once the spell was done.

"Twilight? Is something wrong?" Fluttershy said.

"I'm so sorry Fluttershy i-i messed up really bad, hold on I'll find the reverse spell." Twilight said.

"Twilight? What's going on is Angel alright?" Fluttershy said.

"He is but your not, here see for yourself." Twilight says as she gives Fluttershy a mirror what she sees shocks her...

"What the,Twilight! What did you do to me !?" Fluttershy said, Angel shyly hid behind one of Fluttershy's legs as she said that.

"I don't know, the spell was supposed to make Angel a little more nicer than usual not swap you two." Twilight said.

"Swapped!? What do you mean swapped!? You better explain yourself before I make you!" Fluttershy says completely unaware that she was actually yelling.

"It probably backfired, that usually happens if you use a personality altering spell without any prior knowledge of how to do one properly." Glitter Brightstar explains as she suddenly appears in the room with Phoenix Firewing who looked at Fluttershy in awe.

"But-I- ugh forget it, what she said..." Twilight says as Glitter Brightstar giggles.

"Is that this Fluttershy I've been hearin' about?" Phoenix Firewing said.

"Yes I am, and you are Phoenix Firewing right? It's nice to meet you in person." Fluttershy said.

"Is this what ya normally look like?" Phoenix Firewing asked her.

"No, Twilight messed up a spell that supposedly changed my personality with Angel, which is odd because I don't really feel that different than before." Fluttershy said.

"Maybe it's because your more like Phoenix now." Glitter Brightstar said.

"That's it!" Twilight said.

"What's it?" Glitter Brightstar said.

"Yeah, tell us what's up." Phoenix Firewing said.

"I know how to reverse this now, all I have to do is use the spell on them again but this time think of how Fluttershy normally acts." Twilight says as she readies her spell but it was stopped cold by Glitter Brightstar.

"Wha- hey!" Twilight said.

"Let me handle this, I can get Fluttershy and her bunny back to normal faster and without anymore problems, first Phoenix I need you to move from where your standing." Glitter Brightstar said.

"On it Glitter." Phoenix Firewing says as she moves out the way.

"Next is the spell, Fluttershy I need you be still for this." Glitter Brightstar said.

Fluttershy nodded and stood still.

"Here we go" Glitter Brightstar says as she casts the spell.

When it was finished Fluttershy was back to normal and Angel Bunny was rather peeved that he wasted a lot of sleep on such an endeavor.

"I'm sorry Angel, let's get you home." Fluttershy said.

"Wait, don't you want to join our sleepover party?" Glitter Brightstar asked Fluttershy.

"Sorry girls, maybe next time..." Fluttershy says as she leaves.

"Oh well more cake for me!v Glitter Brightstar says as she pulls a cake from out of nowhere and starts eating it.

"Your so odd Glitter Brightstar..." Phoenix Firewing says to herself.

("What just happened?") Twilight thought to herself.

[The end]

Author's Note

Yet another random story I decided to make.