Author's Note

Fair warning, I wrote this because of all the fics of Sunset Shimmer getting railed by a horse and decided to make it even worse.

Never let it be said I let a bad idea go unwritten.

Her First Time

Applejack knew something was going on with her horses. She’d found the barn door unlocked twice now, and even though nothing seemed to have been stolen, things got moved around, and she was sure someone had been getting into Lonestar’s stable. The mare had been acting a little strange, too. Stranger than usual for this time of year.

Almost as strange as Rarity, if Applejack was being honest. The girl had been acting all coy and annoying for two weeks now.

Lunch, at Canterlot High on Turkey Thursday. Which was just every other Thursday - they tried to make it more exciting but Taco Tuesday was definitely still the winner of the food popularity contest. For some reason most of the school really loved tacos. Especially the girls.

Applejack ate slowly and watched Rarity. The girl had been sighing and blushing and looking at her phone all lunch, barely paying attention to anyone at the table.

“Alright, it’s been fifteen minutes an’ nobody else has asked,” Applejack said. “What’s his name, sugarcube.”

“Hm?” Rarity glanced up from her phone.

“You got a new boyfriend,” Applejack said.

Rarity blushed and turned her phone over, putting it screen-down on the table so no one could look at it. “I’m certain I don’t know what you mean.”

Applejack sighed and started counting on her fingers. “Big Mac. Soarin. Gilda. Double Diamond…”

“Oh please,” Rarity huffed. “Most of those were just little flings. I mean, I wasn’t even dating Double Diamond! We just hit it off at the sky lodge and, well, it was rather nice getting some attention from a rather attractive young man.”

“What was that third name?” Dash asked. "It sounded like you said-"

“All of them were little flings,” Applejack pointed out, cutting Dash off. “You and Big Mac, y’all didn’t even last two weeks. An’ I had to deal with the fallout on both sides from that mess!”

“It was unfortunate,” Rarity sighed. “I was attracted to him, but he isn’t much of a talker. I can’t be with a man who refuses to discuss his dreams, his problems, he couldn’t even tell me that he loved me!”

Applejack sighed. “He gets tongue-tied around girls, Rarity. You know that.”

“It was rather cute at first. It simply got… less cute over time.”

“So who’s the new boyfriend?” Pinkie asked, reaching for Rarity’s phone. Rarity slapped her hand away.

“I’ll tell you when I’m ready,” Rarity said. “I don’t want to discuss it until all parties are ready.”

“You should respect her privacy,” Fluttershy said. “I just hope whoever it is makes Rarity happy. That’s what’s really important.”

Rarity smiled at her friend. “Thank you, Fluttershy. I’m glad you understand.”

“I’m sure whoever it is, we’ll approve,” Sunset said, tapping on her own phone before slipping it into her pocket. She had an odd smirk. “Rarity has great taste in boyfriends. Better than Dash, that’s for sure.”

“Jeeze, I keep telling you guys, I never dated Zephyr! He photoshopped those pictures! Badly!” Dash huffed, blushing.

“I know. I’m pretty good at photoshop myself,” Sunset said. “I’m just teasing you, Dash.”

“Maybe Applejack is just jealous,” Rarity said. “I could set you up with someone, if you ask nicely.”

“If I wanted to date someone I’d go up an’ ask them,” Applejack said.

“Mm-hmm. If you say so, darling,” Rarity replied. She gave Applejack a look, and AJ couldn’t meet her gaze.

Dealing with an intruder in the barn was a lot easier than trying to deal with Rarity. Rarity was as twisty as a grease-covered snake and as beautiful as a greased-up snake wasn’t. All that talk about her having a new boyfriend had kept AJ up well into the early hours of the morning, and that meant she was awake to see the faint light from inside the barn.

She could have woken up Big Mac and Granny, but they’d just tell her to go back to bed and she wouldn’t have been able to work out any of her frustration. She could handle this herself - last time something like this had happened, it had ended up being Scootaloo running away from home again.

Applejack swore one of these days she’d report the girl to child services. Probably she’d wait until after the farm wasn’t using mostly unpaid, underage labor to keep running, just in case questions got asked.

She quietly snuck up to the sliding door, the light within casting a thin line out into the night. Just in case it was something dangerous, she had a baseball bat and the element of surprise-

“Oh yeah, just like that,” moaned a voice from within. A girl’s voice.

AJ looked inside and dropped the bat. She’d been wrong about having surprise on her side - nothing could have shocked her more than what she was looking at right now.

Sunset Shimmer stood on a stool behind Lonestar, the horse pressing back as she slowly fucked it, her hips meeting the horse’s ass with a wet slap every time she thrust forward. Thick drops fell from their joining to splatter against the ground.

Applejack’s cheeks burned red, and she froze, watching, unable to look away. It explained everything. Nothing had been taken because the intruder had been getting exactly what she wanted, and Lonestar had been acting strange because someone had been fucking her so hard she couldn’t walk in a straight line the next morning.

Lonestar nickered, and Sunset started to look to the side. Applejack ducked back behind the door.

She wasn’t sure why she was hiding. It was her horse. Her barn. She wasn’t the one in the wrong. She should have gone in there and demanded Sunset stop, then banned her from the farm forever.

Instead, her clothing felt too tight and hot. She tried to breathe, but all she could smell was the musk from inside.

Lonestar whinnied, and though it shouldn’t have been possible, it somehow sounded… husky. Had her horse just…?

Applejack bit her lip and looked inside again.

“You like that, don’t you?” Sunset asked. “You’re such a dirty little mare~” She kept pumping into the horse, and this time Applejack could see it. Sunset Shimmer’s cock. It was massive - no wonder Lonestar was enjoying herself, the girl might as well have been a horse herself!

Applejack hadn’t seen a lot of cocks herself. In person. The internet didn’t count, otherwise she’d have seen hundreds. Even those didn’t compare to what Sunset was packing. She could break a woman with that thing, and the fruit hanging below it were big enough to ensure that anyone she spent time with was going to walk away sloshing.

The farmer felt someone’s hand slide into her pants and it took her a moment of shock to realize it was her own.

She fought back a moan as she touched her wet lips, her panties soaked through, sticking to her tender flesh.

It was so wrong, especially after what she’d seen. Her finger slid inside, her lower lips gripping it tightly.

Applejack whimpered and shivered, imagining being speared on something much thicker.

The hot breath on her neck wasn’t her imagination.

Someone grabbed her wrist, keeping her from pulling her hand out of her panties.

“Applejack, what are you doing out here?” Sunset asked.

“I was- I was-” Applejack gasped as Sunset’s hand slid down her wrist, sliding into her pants and forcing Applejack’s own fingers deeper inside.

“I don’t need to read your mind to know what you’re thinking about.”

“Y-you were- you got a-” Applejack stammered.

Sunset pressed her body against Applejack’s back, and the farmgirl could feel the stiff rod throbbing against her, only a thin layer of clothing separating her from the thick, virile manhood.

“I was really embarrassed about it at first,” Sunset whispered. “But someone’s been helping me learn to love it.”

“A-and Lonestar?”

“The poor girl is in heat and needed some relief. I couldn’t just say no. I know what it’s like.” Sunset moved her hand, Applejack not resisting as Sunset started stroking her friend’s lips, flicking a finger against her clit.

“I-I promise I won’t tell anyone-”

Sunset kissed her ear, and Applejack shut up.

“I know you won’t. You liked watching it too much.”

Applejack couldn’t say no.

“Come on,” Sunset said, pulling her hand out of Applejack’s pants and tugging on her arm. Applejack followed her into the barn.

Applejack tried to look anywhere but Sunset’s crotch, and ended up staring at Lonestar, the mare looking tired, breathing heavily while thick white seed slowly dripped from her stretched, used hole.

“She’s very thankful for the help,” Sunset said.

Lonestar looked back at her, and Applejack could have sworn the horse was blushing.

“Don’t be ashamed to look,” Sunset said. She put a hand on Applejack’s cheek and guided her gaze to just where she wanted it. Applejack’s own cheeks started glowing apple-red as she got a good front-row look at Sunset’s member, the thick half-hard mast slick with mare juices and the girl’s cum.

“How did you even get that thing?” Applejack whispered.

“Magic,” Sunset shrugged. “Maybe it’s the magic of friendship with benefits?” She giggled. “Sorry. Repeating a joke from someone else.”

“Who?” Applejack asked.

“I don’t kiss and tell,” Sunset said, taking a step closer, the head of her monster rubbing against Applejack, so close the girl could smell beyond the sweat and sex to the lavender body wash she used. “Which is good for you.”

“Huh?” Applejack asked, looking up from Sunset’s dick just in time to catch the kiss. Sunset’s lips were as warm as a summer’s day, pressing hard against her, Sunset pushing her against the wooden wall and holding her there.

It was the best kiss she’d ever had.

Sunset’s tongue slipped into her mouth, touching hers, just a feather-light touch of flesh to flesh. Applejack held onto her for support, her legs weak.

“Lonestar doesn’t really care about these, but maybe you’ll like them more,” Sunset suggested, taking Applejack’s hesitant hands and guiding them under her shirt, helping her strong, rough palms find her breasts.

Applejack squeezed them, tensing up as Sunset kissed her again. She felt her friend unbuttoning her shirt, exposing her own bust to the night air, her breasts the size of apples and almost as firm, nipples rock-hard with arousal and the sudden exposure to the cooler air of the night.

“Do you want the same thing she got?” Sunset glanced at Lonestar.

Applejack nodded, unable to actually say it herself.

“If you want it, then the first thing you have to do is clean it off,” Sunset said.

Applejack looked at her, confused, before Sunset guided her to her knees on the straw-covered floor, right at eye-level with the dripping, messy cock she wanted.

“B-but that’s-”

“Take a taste,” Sunset said, pressing the tip of her stiffening member against Applejack’s lips, a string of mixed fluids connecting them when she pulled away.

Applejack licked her lips instinctively, the mix of salt and sweet and musk a fleeting, not unpleasant presence on her tongue.

“Not bad, right?” Sunset asked.

Applejack blushed again, shaking her head, and leaned closer, licking the blunt head of Sunset’s dick. It was ten times stronger, here at the source, the taste and smell like a physical force, making her slit tremble and drip in time with the pulse she could feel in the cock in her mouth.

“Take it deeper…” Sunset begged, pushing another inch into Applejack’s mouth.

It was almost too big for her, even taking part of it meant the tip was starting to push into the back of her throat, filling all her senses at once.

Applejack did her best, licking around the thick shaft, swallowing the heady mix. Sunset put an encouraging hand on the back of her head, helping her bob up and down, easing it deeper. A thick drop of semen fell onto Applejack’s tongue, meaty and strong.

“Just a little more,” Sunset gasped, pressing harder.

Applejack felt the cock in her mouth throb, pulsing with the beat of Sunset’s heart. She looked up, Sunset’s breast’s bouncing as she fucked the farm-girl’s mouth, using her like a toy. Applejack stopped fighting it, letting the cock slide deeper, struggling not to choke on the meat she was being force-fed.

Sunset moaned and shoved her rod as deep as she could, AJ’s nose almost pressing into her crotch, the tip sliding what felt like most of the way to her stomach. Her nails dug into Applejack’s scalp as she came, jets of thick seed painting her throat. Applejack swallowed, trying not to drown, her stomach filling with hot cum.

She held her there for almost a minute, Applejack struggling, unable to breathe until Sunset finally let up, letting go. Applejack gasped for breath as she slid off of the girl’s thick shaft, coughing and feeling her stomach. It felt like she’d chugged almost a gallon of the white stuff, but that was impossible, right?

“Not bad,” Sunset said, sliding down to the floor next to where Applejack was kneeling. “You earned yourself a reward.”

“A reward?” Applejack asked, between deep breaths.

“Mm… first, let’s get you in the right position.” Sunset smiled.

Applejack bent over the hay bale as Sunset pulled her pants down, exposing her quivering lower lips to the air, having to peel her panties off, the thin material soaked all the way through. She hadn’t shaved down there in a while, a patch of blonde proving that it was her natural hair color.

“You look good bent over like that,” Sunset said, grabbing Applejack’s hips and giving her slit a long lick. Applejack gasped at the unfamiliar sensation, pushing back on Sunset’s face.

“Ya can’t do that to a girl with no warnin’!” Applejack said, her voice weak, trying to keep control as Sunset tasted her, the girl’s tongue sliding deep inside.

“Delicious,” Sunset said, pulling away and wiping her lips on the back of her arm. “Your farm really does make the sweetest apples~”

“Don’t you dare make no apple puns at me.”

“I’ve got something better than puns to give you,” Sunset assured her. She rubbed the head of her cock against Applejack before letting it slide past, rubbing her shaft up and down against the dripping snatch in front of her.

“That feels real nice,” Applejack said, gripping the hay bale tight as Sunset teased her, pushing back against the rock-hard erection, grinding against the thick shaft and painting every inch of the once-clean flesh with her own juices.

“It’s gonna feel better in a minute,” Sunset said, pulling back her hips and pressing the tip against Applejack’s vulnerable hole, the farm-girl crying out as she was violated.

“Yer gonna tear me apart!” Applejack gasped.

“Don’t worry, I know how to treat a girl,” Sunset assured her. “You’re going to love this.” It sounded almost more like an order than anything else.

“It’s too big!” Applejack’s voice came out as little more than a whisper, her body feeling like all the strength was being sucked out of it as her entire world centered around the hot flesh driving itself into her core.

“It’s just right for a slutty little mare like you~”

Applejack would have protested the name, but she was too busy being fucked like an animal, bent over in the barn and taken bareback like she was being studded by a stallion.

And the thought of that made Applejack realize the danger she was in, even as she was feeling heady and drunk on the pleasure of being rutted.

“Y-ya gotta pull out before ya cum!”

“Don’t you want to be filled up just like Lonestar?” Sunset teased, rolling her hips and giving Applejack a thrust that pressed the tip of her huge cock right against the end of Applejack’s passage, the sensation of having something touch the entrance of her womb making the girl shudder.

“I-I can’t-” Applejack gasped.

“I’ll let you decide,” Sunset whispered. “I’ll tell you when I’m getting close.”

Applejack nodded quickly. She was getting too close to her own peak, pushing back hard on Sunset, her body practically moving on its own, her instincts overriding her brain.

She knew even this was stupid, that the tiny bit leaking out of Sunset and dripping into her passage - making everything feel so wet and smooth and warm and right - even that was a risk. It didn’t matter. She could justify it to herself. It wasn’t a big risk. She could handle it. It would be fine as long as Sunset pulled out before she really finished.

A shiver of pending orgasm wracked her body, her inner walls clenching around the wonderful shaft inside her, trying to draw it deeper inside.

“I’m getting close~” Sunset warned.

“J-just a few more,” Applejack gasped. “Ah’m about to- I’m gonna-”

“I don’t know if I can hold it,” Sunset said. “You have to tell me to stop, Applejack~”

“D-don’t you dare!” Applejack yelled, pushing back when she felt Sunset start to pull out. She just needed one more thrust to finish, to feel that cock filling her to the brim just one more time.

Sunset’s cock slammed into her, and Applejack came, shivering and pressing her hips back against Sunset, not letting her escape even as the girl fucking her cried out. Jets of thick, hot cream sprayed into her, invading every part of her, so deep and pressed so tightly against her back wall that there was no way it didn’t invade her womb.

Applejack didn’t care. She pushed back a few more times, riding out her own orgasm on Sunset’s twitching cock before nearly collapsing, Sunset helping her lie down and spooning her from behind.

She sighed happily, feeling totally content as she fell asleep.