Twilight trotted merrily just behind Apple Jack. Although she felt a deep bond with all of her new friends in Ponyville, she felt closest to the orange mare. And how could she not? The glistening of her fur after a hard day’s work, the way she fluttered her green eyes when she was feeling playful, the tight ass that the earth mare was currently shaking for her audience’s entertainment, and that accent. Molestia almighty! That accent! Everything about this mare embodied Twilight’s first concrete fetish as a filly. And now that they were fuck buddies…

“See somethin’ ya like, sugar cube?” AJ asked, giving her rump an especially enticing wiggle, flicking her tail in such a way that it only gave the briefest glimpse at what lay beneath.

“Oh you know it,” swooned Twilight. She had to lick up a bit of drool that was falling down her lower lip.

“Thanks again for helpin’ me out. Ah bet Big Mac Ah could get all these apples in the barn by lunch time. If Ah win,” she tittered, “he’s gonna walk through Ponyville with one of Granny’s old vibrators up his ass.” She laughed in that beautiful country drawl that made Twilight just a little-a lot wet.

“No problem, Apple Jack. Plus I’m glad the goal is lunch time.” She licked her lips sensually, trying to develop a sense of x-ray vision to see beneath her fuck buddy’s golden tail. Filing a mental note to look into such a spell for later, she continued, “Seeing such tender, ripe, delicious looking apples is making me hungry.” Despite her attempts to be suave and seductive, a disruptive gurgle from her stomach caused Twilight to blush.

AJ giggled goodnaturedly. “Don’t ya’ll worry none. Ah’m sure we can find somethin’ ta tide ya over.” She gave her rump an especially inviting shake, smirking as she watched Twilight’s mouth water all the more.

“Twilight!” called a distant voice.

“Spike?” Twilight looked in the direction of the barn where her little dragon friend was running as fast as his little legs would take him. “What’s going on?”

“This.” He held out a scroll. Coming to a skidding stop, leaving a light trail of dust in his wake, Spike read aloud from the letter. “Here ye. Here ye. Her grand royal highness, Princess Molestia, is pleased to announce the Grand Galloping Gala to be held in… yada, yada, yada,” he summarized as he skimmed to the important bits. “… cordially extends an invitation to Twilight Sparkle and her fuck buddies.”

The mares inhaled in shock and, as one, cheered their excitement, “The Grand Galloping Gala!”

Spike just rolled his eyes as he watched the mares bounce in place. His gaze inevitably fell upon the way the mares’ movements caused certain parts of them to shake and jiggle, making his mouth water as he watched. The drake’s lewd peeping was cut short with another belch. Green dragon fire flew up and manifested into seven golden tickets that fell into his claws. “Look. Tickets for the… why are there seven?”

Twilight giggled as she rubbed Spike’s cheek, taking six of the tickets in her magic. “Silly. You’re my fuck buddy, too.” She gave his little rump a friendly swat with her tail, causing him to yelp before blushing his embarrassment. “Speaking of which, where were you all morning. I thought you said you were going to help?” she asked, her tone warning.

“I was!” he insisted. “I was organizing the barrels according to type when, uh…” His blush deepened as he rubbed the back of his head.

“It was Apple Bloom, wasn’t it?” AJ asked knowingly.

Spike confirmed with a bashful nod.

“Well, Ah hope ya’ll remembered yer manners an’ at least got her off before skidadlin’ this way.”

Spike blinked once, then twice. “Oh no!” He tore off back towards the barn, leaving a trail of dust behind as he ran.

The mares looked at one another, giggling at the little drake’s shenanigans.

“And this one is yours,” Twilight said cordially as she levitated one of the tickets to AJ, but stopped just before the farm girl could grab it.

“Hey. What gives?”

Twilight’s expression was thoughtful as she hummed. “You know, the scroll said these tickets were for me and my fuck buddies,” she reminded, her lip threatening to turn into a coy smirk. “A pretty ambiguous term, if you ask me.”

“Twilight,” AJ warned. “The Gala’s one o’ the biggest events o’ the year. It’s a prime time fer me ta cozy up ta them frufru unicorns ‘n’ make some new connections.” AJ gave a confident smirk. “Best time ta make is deal is post-sex pillow talk, ya know.”

Twilight didn’t nod, but she agreed with her friend’s reasoning. The Gala was the biggest orgy party in the country. Ponies and non-ponies came from far and wide to sample the debaucheries Molestia had set up for this special night of the year. Naturally, such a concentration of wealthy and well known ponies also made for a prime opportunity to make business connections. Offering sex for favors was, after all, a longstanding Equestrian tradition. It was in the spirit of this very tradition that Twilight remembered her plan.

“Oh, I do know,” the unicorn teased. “I know that, so long as these tickets are in my possession, I’m free to give them out to whoever I want.” She grinned from ear-to-ear and fluttered her eyelashes at her orange friend, making her point clear.

AJ blinked as it finally clicked in her head. “Oh.” It was her turn to flutter her eyelashes playfully. “Ya’ll are gonna make me have ta pay, aren’t ya?”

Twilight nodded.

AJ hung her head low, looking down as her ears drooped. “But Ah ain’t got much money, Ms. Gov’ment Lady,” she said in an exaggeration of her own drawl as she traced her hoof in the dirt. “Ain’t there anythin’ else Ah can do ta get them tickets.” She knew she was laying it on thick, but she also knew of Twilight’s weakness for her countryisms. A slight sheen tricking down the unicorn’s back legs showed her that it was working.

Twilight was breathing heavy now. She was not expecting AJ to play along to this extent. She quickly calmed herself, wanting to play along with the scene as she adopted a look of indifference. “Well I don’t know, little lady. What could such a big, tough, supple,” she licked her lips, “gorgeous mare like you hope to offer the likes of me?”

Her posture still meek and submissive, AJ turned around, bent over, pressing her chest to the dirt while keeping her ass held high, and flipped her tail up.

Twilight swallowed before she could start drooling again. AJ’s tan ass was as beautiful as the first time she’d seen it. Round, firm cheeks that could block out the sun; a pink pussy that winked from the mare’s desire to be filled, glistening with its sweet, fruity juices; and even her perky pucker was quivering in anticipation. There could be no question that this was the ass that belonged to the Element of Arousal. But then there was the last feature, a new addition that most certainly was not there the first time AJ had presented herself like this.

AJ’s balls were large, like apples, well above the average for most stallions Twilight had seen. From experience, she knew that they were firm, supple, and tasted delicious. But below was an even more savory prize. The apple mare’s cock was almost fully unsheathed from her arousal. It’s length, when fully erect, would reach all the way up to AJ’s chest, outclassing even her famously large older brother. Such was the reward granted to her and the other elements for defeating Nightmare Moon.

Twilight felt her own cock emerge from its sheath, fully erect as the flat head poked between her front legs. Since receiving her new equipment, she’d been ‘experimenting’ furiously. Already she had filled out two journals worth of notes and was preparing to write a formal thesis on her transformation. Spike had helped in her ‘research’, of course, doing his duty to help her test the full capabilities of her new tool. Yet only now did it occur to the book pony that she hadn’t actually stuffed her cock into a real pony since the Slutty Sun Celebration.

“That’s a,” she cleared her throat, “a mighty tempting offer. But-” She trailed off when her nostrils flared as AJ’s tail began wafting the scent of her arousal. The odor tickled her taste buds, reminding her of the enchanting combination of sweet and sour green apple; a flavor she knew she could enjoy for years without ever growing bored.

“But?” AJ asked, feigning innocence as she watched her friend’s resolve slowly fail. She gave her rump a quick shake, causing her ass to bounce, her balls to swing, and her cock to flop a little.

“Mine!” Twilight lunged forward with manic eyes and mounted the apple mare. AJ was a fair bit larger, being an earth pony, but the smaller unicorn managed. She thanked Molestia for the blessings of evolution as her hooves found the orange mare’s hips, perfectly designed as grips for mounting. She wedged her cock between AJ’s warm, soft buns, hot-dogging her meat as she listened to the country girl’s moans.

“Whoa nelly, girl! Ya’ll is eager,” AJ moaned, moving her butt in time with Twilight’s movements. The feeling of a warm belly against her back made her pussy start to pour a waterfall of her precum. This was nature, her body reading the signals that had existed for thousands of years, and readying itself to do what was most natural.

“You know it, bitch!” teased Twilight. She felt a pain in her heart at the loss of heat when she pulled away from AJ’s gorgeous flanks, but knew it had to be done. Looking down, Twilight was struck with a peculiar dilemma, one she had never had to deal with when experimenting with Spike. Did she go for the ass or the pussy?

“Mah ass!” AJ answered, sensing the dilemma. “Ah haven’t had a good cock up mah ass in ages!” she whined in want.

Grinning devilishly, Twilight leveled her tip with the apple bottom’s puckered anus, casting a quick spell to lube herself up. She pressed the flare against the puffy anal ring, earning a moan that was like music to Twilight’s ears. “Ease up, a little,” Twilight whispered. She stroked the back of AJ’s mane to calm her down. It worked and the earth mare relaxed, giving Twilight a bit more give to push in further.

AJ sucked in a breath as she felt her anus part, stretching around the intruder. “Molestia’s teats!” she gasped, feeling the tip of Twilight’s cock enter.

“Just breathe,” Twilight advised, as much for herself as AJ as she felt the head slide in. The apple mare’s anus was tight, hot, but the lube did its job in letting her sink deeper.

“Ah know. Ah know,” AJ whimpered, trying to relax. “Ya ain’t the first pony ta stick it up mah poop chute.” Another couple inches of Twilight’s cock slid in. It stung, but in the best possible way. “D-deeper.”

Twilight nodded and again obeyed. Tightening her grip around AJ’s hips, she pulled herself a little deeper, moaning as the anus stretched around her girth. Her medial ring slipped inside and she hissed, thrusting several more inches at the surge of pleasure.

“Th-that’s it,” AJ moaned in relief. “Aw yeah! That’s some good ol’ Apple family fuckin’!”

Both mares gave a coo of delight once Twilight had fully hilted herself inside, their balls tapping together. For a moment they just stood like that, both mares growing used to the feeling of one another’s sexes before they started moving.

“Hey guys!” greeted another familiar mare who came gliding down, an appreciated change from her usual crashed. “What’s up?”

“Oh, hey Rainbow,” Twilight greeted, panting as she adjusted her grip on AJ’s hips. She felt no shame as her rainbow friend’s eyes drank in her form, but she did feel a twinge of irritation at the interruption. “We were just…” Twilight blinked as her mind went hazy. What wasshe doing, you know, besides fucking in the open? The cool breeze on her wet cock just added to her annoyance, so she carefully sank herself down to the hilt. Her dad always did that whenever she walked in on him. He’d said it was less distracting that way.

“‘Sup, RD,” AJ greeted cordially, managing to tip her hat. “Twilight’s blackmailin’ me,” she said matter-of-factly, still wearing a friendly smile.

A sly smirk grew across Rainbow’s face. “Is that so?” She sat down on her rump and moved a hoof down to fondle her teats. “Why? You find out some deep dark secret that she’s afraid of getting out?”

“Nah.” AJ waved her hoof dismissively, not even sounding winded as she conversed, much to Twilight’s interest.

Exactly how much stamina does one get on an apple farm? Twilight filed a mental note to investigate the benefits of manual labor at a later date.

“She’s jus’ holdin’ mah ticket ta the Gala ‘til-”

“The Gala!” RD screamed, flapping her wings in excitement. “Are we talking about the Grand Galloping Gala?”

Twilight giggled. “Is there any other?”

“Yes!” The cyan Pegasus did a loop in midair before coming back down. “The Wonderbolts perform at the Gala every year.” Her eyes went a little glassy and she licked her lips as her imagination went wild. “Twilight. You gotta give me a ticket! I’ve been working on a new routine I know will get me in this year. Please!” she begged.

“Uh, Rainbow…” Twilight began, shuffling her hooves to keep her legs from cramping. “I’m kind of in the middle of a-”

“Oh right. The blackmail! No ticket ‘til you get your rocks off, right?”

“Well…”

“Say no more. I’ve got this.” Rainbow beamed with a sinister glint in her eye. She hovered in the air, maneuvering herself just behind Twilight until she dropped down right over the purple mare’s rump.

“Uh, Rainbow,” Twilight said, sounding a little nervous. “I was just gonna-”

“Quiet, nerd!” Rainbow snapped authoritatively, making Twilight’s jaw close with a snap. “Better.” The speedster quickly found purchase on Twilight’s hips, just as Twilight had done with AJ, although not nearly as tender. Without warning or foreplay, the rainbow mare lined her own cock up with Twilight’s dripping snatch and plunged it in, hilting herself in less than a second.

Twilight’s mouth opened in a silent scream. Her pussy had been stretched far more quickly than what she was used to and a pain lingered. She buried herself in AJ’s mane, inhaling the farm girl’s scent for comfort.

Rainbow grinned sadistically as she took in Twilight’s expression, so beautifully twisted in pain and pleasure. More than any of the others, Rainbow Dash had taken to having a cock like a stallion takes to a mare in heat. She’d stuck her dick in as many pussies, asses, and mouths as she could get her hooves on; her ego assuring her that the only consent she needed was the divine act of being Rainbow Dash.

“Damn it, Rainbow!” snapped AJ. “Now look. Ya’ll went ‘n’ broke her.” She gestured with her hoof at the now motionless Twilight. “Ya’ll ‘ad better fix this ‘efore Ah get Big Mac ta fix you… again.”

Rainbow gulped nervously. Although she could now match the big red stallion for length, his girth was a whole other matter entirely. The last time she’d made AJ this mad, Big Mac had tied her to a hail bail and used her various orifices as his personal cum dump for an entire day. Afterwards, she had trouble flying andleaked for another two days.

“Sorry,” she squeaked. Deciding to make it up to her friend, she readjusted herself behind Twilight and started pulling at the unicorn’s mane with her teeth. Twilight moaned a little at the stimulation, coaxing Rainbow to go further. With a nod to AJ, the cyan mare began bucking her hips in slow, rhythmic movements.

Twilight came out of her stupor quickly enough, moaning as she felt AJ’s anus moving along her cock while Rainbow’s cock thrusted in and out of her pussy. Her breathing evened out as she starting moving her own hips in beat with the others.

Rainbow scowled. As much as she liked sticking her cock in ponies, this slow, gentle thing was not her style at all. Rough and quick. That’s how she liked it. She was the Element of Domination, after all. But as she continued to move, she couldn’t deny that, even though her way was a million zillion times better, this way had its perks; one of them being a ticket to the Wonderbolts. She gave Twilight’s mane another yank with her teeth before grabbing the mare’s evenly trimmed tail and tugging on it, too.

AJ moaned and groaned as she felt the combined weight of two ponies on her back, all while her hips thrust back to meet Twilight’s movements. The added weight made it feel like a challenge, one she had every intention of meeting and surpassing. She grit her teeth as she tightened her anal muscles along Twilight’s length, savoring the feeling of the purple mare’s cock dragging along her insides. Then she heard a familiar jingle as she felt Twilight’s magic grip around her sorely neglected cock and balls, stroking and juggling them.

“You’s mah favorite unicorn,” AJ grunted.

The three mares moaned and swooned together. The air was thick with the smells of sex and the sounds of wet slapping and grunting animals. They were building momentum quickly.

“C-close,” whispered Twilight as she felt a familiar quiver in her balls. “I’m close.”

“Same,” grunted AJ. Twilight’s magical grip was increasing its pace. She was on the edge, now.

“Here it comes!” announced Rainbow as she slammed her hips in Twilight for the last time. Her climax was like a fire hose, gushing out a powerful, steady stream of cum into Twilight’s pussy.

“Fuck yes!” Twilight threw her head back as she felt her womb swell with Rainbow’s load, just in time to shoot her own into AJ’s waiting ass. Her own cunt still ached from the forced stretching, but in a really good way as it sprayed her juices all over Rainbow’s thighs. She made a mental note for a future experiment.

AJ gave an animalistic growl as she felt Twilight’s flare widen, followed by the infusion of hot, syrupy cum into her anal cavity. The moans of her fellow mares were like music to her ears as she felt the first rope of Twilight’s orgasm. It was shorter than she’d expected, her primary frame of reference being her big brother, but she didn’t mind. Her own orgasm was triggered and several long, powerful ropes of clear cum were sprayed onto the ground.

When all mares were spent, it was a somewhat delicate task to untangle themselves from one another. Their bodies were sticky from sweat, causing manes and tails to get caught in places. Twilight nearly fell over once the support of the others had been withdrawn. All three were panting heavily, their expressions pleased and proud as they looked at one another with bedroom eyes.

“Hehe. Check it out,” AJ said as she pointed to the remains of her splooge. It had yet to be fully absorbed into the ground – where it’s magic would flow back into nature, making the land fertile and green – but was still pooled into an impressively sized puddle. “Now that’s how earth ponies do it.” She beamed at her accomplishment.

“Psh. Whatever.” Rainbow waved a dismissive hoof. She hiked her hind leg to check and see exactly how sticky she was. “Oh boy. Gonna need somepony’s mouth to clean this off.” She lowered her leg back down. “But before that,” she extended her foreleg, “the ticket, please.”

“What? Oh right.” Twilight remembered and handed Rainbow the ticket with her magic. “It’s got your name on it, so don’t worry about anypony else trying to take it.”

Rainbow rolled her eyes. “As if any would be dumb enough to try.” And with that final boast, she took off into the air, leaving a rainbow trail in her wake.

“The tickets got our names on ‘em?” AJ deadpanned.

“Oh sure,” confirmed Twilight thoughtlessly. “These are special tickets assigned personally by the princess. I figured, since we’re the new wielders of the Elements of Debauchery and saved Equestria from Nightmare Moon, that we were basically put on the guest list by default.”

AJ’s eyes narrowed dangerously. “So ya’ll put me through all this hullabaloo fer somethin’ that was rightfully mine from the start?”

Twilight grinned and gulped nervously. “Um, well…”

“That was mighty deceitful of ya, Twilight,” said AJ as she began walking toward the purple mare.

Twilight backed away. She’d seen what AJ was capable of and didn’t want to imagine what lay instore if the lovely, luscious apple mare were to use her strength for anything less than neighborly. “Well, the thing is… you enjoyed it, right?” Her voice squeaked on the last word as her rump hit a fence post, caging in the pony who forgot she knew how to teleport. The fierceness in AJ’s eyes was terrifying, but a little arousing at the same time.

“Don’t matter,” growled AJ as she stopped, her snoot less than an inch from Twilight’s, allowing them to smell each other’s breath. “You’s a rotten little cuss, Twilight. Trickin’ me into beggin’ fer somethin’ that was rightfully mine. And we Apples have a way of sortin’ out rotten little cusses like you.”

“… meep.”

***

Spike and Apple Bloom were walking down the road from the barn. Their pace was slow and relaxed, for they knew arrival at their destination would mean the end of their time together. Spike really liked the little filly. Not only was she the first filly his own age to fuck him since leaving Canterlot, she was just really fun to hang out with and talk to. She had no end of stories about the shenanigans she got up to in pursuit of her cutie mark and she seemed to find his draconic physique genuinely appealing; a welcomed relief compared to many of the stuck up unicorns of Canterlot who almost never let their foals play with him. Granted, she was no Rarity, but she was a sweet, savory, and juicy apple.

“So how’d you get tree sap on your butt? You kinda lost me there.”

Bloom shrugged as she walked along beside her cool dragon friend. “Ah don’t know, either. But somehow, no matter what Ah do, no matter where Ah do it, like four outta every five cutie mark attempts ends with me covered in tree sap.” She was so glad to have a friend who didn’t make fun of her for not having a cutie mark. Besides that, he was a dragon. Dragons were cool by default. Everypony knew that. And if the ponies of Canterlot were too busy smelling their own farts to see how cool Spike was, they could all go fuck a toaster. She’d said as much, making the little dragon laugh in a way that made her weak in the knees; or maybe that was the lingering ache of their most recent fucking?

“What kind of tree sap?”

“Oh, all kinds,” she chirped happily. “Maple, pecan, oak, which tastes just like mint fer some reason,” she explained as she listed. “Last time was blue berry, which Granny scraped off and served on pancakes the next day.”

Spike threw back his head and laughed, unknowingly making AB’s knees feel wobbly again. “That’s hilarious.” He wiped a tear from his eye. “I’ll ask Twilight if I can go with you the next time.”

Bloom furrowed her brow quizzically. “But yer a dragon. Do dragons even get cutie marks?”

Spike just shrugged and wrapped an arm over AB’s middle, pulling her against his side as they walked. “Don’t know, don’t care. I just want to see what kind of sap you get in next.” He licked his lips.

Bloom blushed, averting her eyes. No pony had ever talked to her like this before, not even her family. She pressed herself more firmly against Spike, wanting him to know how much she liked him.

“Heeeeeelp!”

Spike’s ear twitched. “Twilight?”

“Someponey help me!”

“I’m coming, Twilight!” He ran down the dirt road to the source of the commotion, Bloom hot on his heels. “Don’t worry, Twilight. I’m here… to…” he trailed off as he took in the sight.

“Say it!” barked AJ. Twilight’s head was locked in a fierce hold while the powerful earth mare used her other hoof to apply merciless noogies to the purple mare’s crotch. “Say it!”

“I’m sorry!” Twilight whined, still struggling against the earth mare’s taut, supple muscles. AJ’s mane was tickling her nose with its scent, rekindling her arousal.

“Sorry fer what?”

“F-for being a rotten little cuss!” Twilight cried as she writhed.

“Huh,” Spike said dispassionately as he watched. He looked to Bloom with questioning eyes.

“Big sis is learnin’ yer friend a lesson,” she explained matter-of-factly. “Don’t know what fer, but Ah’m bettin’ she had it comin’. It’s the Apple family way.”

“Ya don’t say,” Spike deadpanned, looking between the mares and the filly. “About how long does this usually last?”

Bloom beamed a smile and gave her little rump a shake. “Long enough fer another round, if yer ready.”

Author's Note

The original My Little Orgy was one of the earliest stories I found in those first few months after discovering this site. It’s been sitting in one of my libraries for almost as long and I still visit every now and then. However, given the writer’s infrequence to this site, it seems any sort of continuation is out of the question. So, I got to thinking, and it just kind of snowballed from there.

No set schedule for posts. This story is more of a ‘whenever the mood strikes me’ sort of thing, and will not take priority over Horse People. I just really like this variation of Equestria and felt it deserved further exploration.