Trixie Hits the Jack Pot

by RetiredAccount

Rating: mature
Tags: Starlight Glimmer, Jack Pot, Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance, Trixie, Comedy
Length: 14310

Trixie and Starlight are out on a romantic Las Pegasus getaway, and they go out looking for someone to join them in bed. Enter Jack Pot, a charming stallion ready for a long night of fun. Strange, he looks exactly like Trixie... What are the odds?

While on a romantic getaway in Las Pegasus, Starlight has an idea. An awful idea. She has a wonderful, awful idea: she and Trixie are going to have a threesome with a stranger.

What could possibly go wrong?

This story contains: accidental incest, lesbian horses doing lesbian things, role-play incest, impregnation, and incestuous incest.

As always, a big thank you to anon26182 for his excellent proofreading, and for kicking me in the ass when I was taking way too long to get back into writing. Cheers mate!

Published 2018-06-09 18:20:07 UTC
Last updated 2018-06-09 18:20:07 UTC

Out of all the ponies in Equestria...

“How about that mare?”

“Too small.”

“Of course she is… What about that pegasus over there?”

“Too tall.”

“Oh come on… Fine, how about him?”

“Too skinny.”

“But… he’s so handsome, look at his cute flanks… no? Alright alright, sheesh.”

Starlight gave a silent farewell to the attractive stallion, his firm, athletic flanks seeming to taunt her as he trotted away, oblivious to the attention he was getting. He was swallowed by the crowd, lost amongst the throngs of ponies milling around the Las Pegasus food-court. Starlight’s disappointment was soon forgotten as she spied another potential candidate, a burly earth pony with a rugged look and a muscled barrel. She shifted on her seat to get a better look at him, her tail swishing with interest.

“Well hello there gorgeous,” she cooed, a hungry smile on her lips, “Trixie, check out that stud over there!”

Trixie threw a distracted glance towards the stallion, barely looking at him before she raised her nose in the air. “Too big.”

Starlight groaned out loud, exasperated. She let her head bang against their table, their cutlery rattling between them. She should have known… She should have known better than to hope Trixie wouldn’t be too difficult.

The plan was simple: take Trixie on a romantic getaway in Las Pegasus, treat her girlfriend like a princess, and then have the naughtiest and most debauched sex, every single night. It had been three days since they had arrived, and everything had gone off without a hitch. Trixie was happy, Starlight’s bank account was screaming for mercy, and they had wrecked two bed frames thus far. Three, if you counted the hole Trixie’s horn had punched through their current headboard.

So why… WHY, in the wide, wide world of Equestria had Starlight tried to spice things up? Why had she proposed they bring a third pony to their nightly activities? Trixie had instantly agreed, but at this point Starlight almost wished her girlfriend had just said no.

They had been stuck for hours now, sitting in this crowded food-court, Starlight desperately trying to find a suitable partner while Trixie shot them down without a second glance. It was a good thing she loved the showmare so very, very much, or Starlight might just have acted on her urge to strangle her marefriend a few dozen candidates ago.

“Hey, why are you getting angry?” Trixie accused, her hooves crossed over her chest with a stubborn pout. “The Great and Generous Trixie agreed to your threesome idea, but she will not let just any other pony in her bed!”

“Shhhh!” Starlight desperately shushed her lover, her head whipping around the open-air restaurant. She gulped when she found more than a few ponies looking back at her, their eyes wide and staring. “Keep your voice down!”

“Humph”. Trixie pretended to be angry for a few more seconds, then she smirked. “That’s not what you said last night. You know, when you were pounding into Trixie with that giant strap-on dil—”

“Trixie!”

Trixie snickered, her eyes twinkling with mischief. “Relaaax, this is Las Pegasus!” She leaned over the table, running her hoof over Starlight’s blushing cheeks, unconcerned by the eavesdropping ponies around them. “No one cares what ponies do here. What happens in Las Pegasus…”

“Stays in Las Pegasus.” Starlight completed with a grumble. She had become very familiar with the saying since they had arrived, it was Trixie’s favorite excuse when she did something crazy. “Fine, but will you please just choose already?”

“Trixie won’t jump into bed with just anypony.” Trixie snorted, seeming offended by the very idea.

“Then just tell me if you don’t want to do it, and we’ll think of something else!” Starlight groaned. “We’ve been here for hours!”

“No. It sounds like fun.” Trixie shook her head. “We just have to find the right pony!”

“Well either you pick someone,” Starlight put on a cheeky smile, “or I swear I’ll invite Twilight to our bed when we get back.”

Trixie stared at her marefriend with a shocked expression. “You wouldn’t…”

“Are you sure about that?” Starlight reclined on her chair, holding her confident grin. “Do you want to risk it?”

Truthfully, Starlight would never have the nerve to present such an indecent proposal to her friend and teacher. Not that she didn’t find Twilight very pretty and adorkably cute, but she was convinced the mare would faint outright if she was invited to a casual threesome. The alicorn was so innocent, Starlight suspected she had never even held hooves with anypony before.

“Alright, alright.” Trixie grumbled. She looked at the ponies walking all around, her ears perked and eyes focused. “Trixie will find somepony.”

Never fails. Starlight thought smugly, chuckling to herself. “So, stallion or mare?”

“Trixie thinks a stallion will be more fun.” The showmare mumbled offhandedly, her eyes roaming the crowd. “He has to be perfect, he has to be handsome, he has to be strong and worthy of Trixie...”

“Hey, we’re looking for a one-night-stand, we’re not going to start a herd with him.” Starlight reminded teasingly.

“He has to have a gorgeous coat and a beautiful mane…” Trixie went on with her mumbling, ignoring her lover. “He has to be… him!”

Starlight blinked in surprise. That was fast. She followed Trixie’s hoof, looking for the stallion she had set her sights on… and she quickly spotted him; her eyes rolled so hard she almost felt dizzy. Of course. Of course, of all the stallions in Las Pegasus, Trixie would choose the one that looked exactly like herself.

“Really?” Starlight sighed, shooting an unimpressed glance at her lover.

“What?” Trixie blinked, apparently genuinely confused by Starlight’s reaction. “You don’t like him?”

“I do, but…” She searched her marefriend’s eyes, wondering if Trixie really was so narcissistic she didn’t realize she had basically chosen a stallion version of herself. She quickly decided to just shrug it off, in the name of her deep love for the mare. And, to be honest, that stallion did look very handsome. “Alright, let’s do this.”

Starlight quickly paid the bill and they hurried out of the restaurant’s fenced area, afraid to lose the stallion from view. She found it somewhat amusing that Trixie now seemed even more eager than herself, the blue unicorn almost cantering in her haste to reach the stallion. Not a few instants before Trixie was dragging her hooves to choose someone, and now she looked like a filly on Hearth’s Warming’s Eve rushing to open a present.

“Uh…” Starlight tilted her head as they came close enough to see the finer details of the stallion’s muzzle. “He’s older than I thought.”

“Even better.” Trixie smiled naughtily. “A stallion with experience!”

“I’d say, he’s old enough to be your… father… wait…” Starlight looked from the blue stallion to the equally blue mare trotting at her side. She eyed their identical coats, their identical manes, and most disturbingly their very similar muzzles. She quirked an eyebrow, a nagging thought coming to her. It was unlikely, astronomically so, but she still had to make sure. “Say, Trixie… What happened to your dad again?”

“How could you forget? Trixie’s father was a hero, a royal guard who died in a great battle before she was born.” Trixie said proudly, reciting the story her mother had told her. “Why?”

“Oh, no reason.” Starlight smiled, glad to put that worry to rest.

They were now close enough to hear his voice, the stallion surrounded by a bunch of foals, his strong voice easily carrying over the ambient noise. Starlight perked her ears in interest, wondering what kind of pony he was.

“… And that is how I, Jack Pot, vanquished the dreaded Shadow Pony and sent him back to Tartarus!” Jack declared grandiosely, rearing back for greater effect. The foals around him gasped in awe, their mouths open in adoration.

“So cool…” One filly mumbled.

“Please, I am but a humble magician.” Jack said with fake modesty. “But, what’s this behind your ear?” He reached around the filly’s head, and produced a bundle of tickets he had hidden in his sleeves. “Why, these are free entries for my midday show tomorrow!”

“Ooooh!” The foals crowded around him, their eyes fixed on the tickets.

“Now, what should I do with these, hmmm?” He rubbed his chin, pretending to think about it.

A little colt shyly tugged at his jacket, his puppy dog eyes shining with hope. “Can… can we have them, pwease?”

“Why, that’s a great idea!” Jack ruffled the colt’s mane, and to the delight of his audience he started to hand out one ticket to each foal. “Here you go kids!”

The herd of young admirers thanked him, and they scattered everywhere, each one running to their watching parents with a ticket in their mouths. Jack chuckled good naturally as the last ticket was given away, a little filly scampering off. It warmed his heart to see his little fans so happy.

He watched the cheering foals to make sure each returned to their family, waving back at his little admirers, and he noticed two mares making their way to him. Two very pretty mares, he was quick to notice. Jack resisted the urge to smile, for he knew the look on their faces; he was about to get some company for the night, if he wasn’t mistaken.

“That was very generous of you.” One of the mares said as they stopped before him. She had a beautiful pale pink coat that matched her purple mane, gorgeous eyes that twinkled with intelligence, and a pair of full-bodied lips currently stretched into a knowing grin.

“Only the best for my fans.” Jack tipped them his hat, putting on his most charming smile. The second mare looked up at him with stars in her eyes, completely awestruck, but the first only smirked wider.

“And it doesn’t hurt that their parents will have to buy full-price tickets to accompany them, does it?” She teased.

Ah, she’s smart. He thought, considering the pink mare with new interest. “Why yes, it’s a fortunate turn of events.” He smiled roguishly, cranking up his charm to eleven. The mare’s cheeky expression crumbled a little, a deep blush decorating her muzzle. He chuckled to himself: he knew full well he was a dashing fellow, and he had a lot of experience when it came to seducing younger mares.

After a few moments the pink mare gathered her wits, her blush softening. She cleared her throat, and spoke with renewed confidence. “I’m Starlight Glimmer.” She offered him her hoof. “Pleasure to meet you.”

“Jack Pot, the pleasure is all mine.” He took her hoof, but instead of shaking it he carefully kissed the tip, bowing like a gentlestallion. He looked up, and was somewhat chagrined to find that his chivalrous act had little effect on the mare: she was smirking at him again, unimpressed. This one is going to be difficult… good, I enjoy a challenge. He held Starlight’s gaze for a few moments, then turned to the second unicorn. “And who might this pretty lady be?”

The petite blue mare was startled out of her dazzled state, a few strands of drool decorating her chin. “Trixie is Trixie!” She blurted, her blue cheeks reddening quite fetchingly. “Trixie is trixy to treex you!” She eagerly thrust her hoof at him, her tail wagging frantically.

And this one is going to be wonderfully easy to tease. He thought as he took her hoof, the mare mewling happily as their matching fur made contact. Instead of kissing her hoof he brushed his lips against her fetlock, a very intimate gesture one usually reserved for a lover. He said nothing, and only looked up at her, holding on to her hoof. She seemed to melt under his smoldering gaze, and Starlight had to support her friend to keep Trixie from literally falling head over heels. He chuckled and finally released the flustered mare, lest she faint outright.

“Always nice to meet a fan.” He stood back up, and gently ran a hoof through Trixie’s mane. He felt a strange tingle as he touched her brow, his heart beating with an unfamiliar warmth, a strange feeling of deep longing filling his chest; he assumed it was the effect of some sort of illusion spell. “What kind of magic did you use to change your colors to mine? You’re the most accurate impersonator I’ve ever seen.”

Starlight quirked an eyebrow. “She isn’t your f—”

“Trixie is your biggest fan, yes!” Trixie interrupted. She elbowed her friend in the ribs, Starlight grunting in surprise. “Right Starlight?”

“Fine, fine, she is.” Starlight rolled her eyes. She looked back at Jack, and her bravado seemed to falter somewhat. She coughed, rubbed her mane, and generally seemed uncomfortable with the obvious question on her lips. “Say…” She began. “I was wondering… If you want… later today…”

“I’m staying at the Golden Stables hotel.” Jack Pot interrupted, his magic gently closing Starlight’s flapping mouth. “Ask for my room number at the reception, I’ll warn them I’ll be expecting company. I’ll be there after my show tonight, and you’re both welcome to drop by.”

Starlight flushed deeper, but she managed to give him a confident smile in return. “We’ll be there.”

“Great!” Jack Pot smiled. “I’ll bring the refreshments, you gals bring the other... necessities, deal?”

Trixie nodded, her eyes wide and obedient. “We will!”

“Very well. But for now, I’m afraid I must bid you adieu, I have a show coming up.” He tipped them his hat again. “Until tonight ladies.” He gave them a wink, and turned to leave without another word. He heard them mumble their farewell, and he could practically feel their eyes on his flanks as he walked away.

Tonight was going to be fun, he could already tell.

... you chose...

“Starlight, wait up! You’re leaving Trixie behind!”

Starlight grunted, and she made a conscious effort to slow down; she studiously ignored Trixie’s snickering as the mare caught up. The two of them trotted side by side through the Golden Stables hotel, straight towards one of the Royal Suites. Jack Pot’s Royal Suite. They were almost there… so close...

“Someone’s impatient, hmm?” Trixie leaned against her, breathing into her ear. “You really liked him, didn’t you?”

“You’re one to talk.” Starlight shot back playfully, hip-checking Trixie’s flank. “You were drooling over him like a filly with her first crush.”

“It’s not Trixie’s fault!” Trixie pouted. “There’s something about that stallion… Something that made Trixie feel… safe.”

“And horny.” Starlight added. “You practically left a trail when we left him.”

“Humph.” Trixie thrust her nose in the air, her damp tail flicking against Starlight’s rump. “Lies and slander.”

Starlight chuckled, but she soon quieted down: the door to Jack’s room was just at the end of the hallway. She licked her lips, then turned to Trixie. “Are you sure you brought everything?”

“For the last time, yes!” Trixie popped her saddlebag open, rummaging inside with her magic. “Trixie brought lube, vibrators, a strap-on dildo in case he’s into that kind of stuff, butt-plugs—”

“Why don’t you speak a little louder, half the hotel hasn’t heard you yet.”

“— a ball gag, ropes, a riding crop, and some lotions for the aftermath.” Trixie finished with a huff. “Everything’s there!”

Starlight chewed on her lips, looking at the bag with a frown. “I swear we’re forgetting something… something important…”

“Well, it’s too late now.” Trixie interrupted with an eager squeal. “We’re here!”

The two of them stood before the door, fidgeting on their hooves. Trixie wore a carefree smile, but Starlight knew her well enough to recognize the signs of nervousness under the mare’s confident façade. Trixie hadn’t had much experience before starting her relationship with Starlight, so this was probably her first time with multiple partners. Starlight on the other hand was very familiar with the concept, as most ponies in her old village could attest.

“… Aren’t you going to knock?” Trixie whispered after a few moments.

“I’m just thinking about what I’m going to tell him.” Starlight answered softly, going through her list of naughty one-liners.

“Just ask him: ‘Hey handsome, which one do you want to bang first?’ See, easy!” Trixie muttered.

“You say it’s easy, but you’re the one shaking like a leaf.”

“Trixie isn’t shaking!” Trixie hissed, her shivering hoof poking at Starlight’s belly.

Before Starlight count answer, the door started to glow, startling them both. Jack Pot opened the door wide, smiling confidently, looking just as handsome as Starlight remembered. She gulped heavily as she noticed he was now naked, his magician jacket and top hat discarded. From his unkempt mane she could tell he had just stepped out of a shower, his coat shining brightly.

“Ladies.” Jack greeted them, his charming smile making Starlight’s belly flutter. “How nice of you to drop by. Please, come in.”

He stepped to the side and waved them in, his eyes twinkling with confidence. Trixie rushed to obey, the mare practically tripping over herself to enter. Starlight followed in a more subdued pace, but with just as much anticipation. She felt the stallion’s hungry gaze on her flanks as she passed by him, her heart hammering in her chest as she heard him growl in appreciation.

His apartment’s lobby was bigger than Starlight’s and Trixie’s entire hotel-room, the furniture ridiculously extravagant and dainty; hopefully the bed was made of sturdier stuff than gold or crystal.

“Welcome to my humble abode.” Jack Pot said theatrically. “Please make yourselves at home.”

Starlight whistled, suitably impressed. “This place must cost a fortune.”

“It would… if the owner wasn’t such a big fan of mine.” Jack chuckled. “I can always count on him to lend me a room when I’m expecting… company.” His tail gently brushed against Starlight’s leg as he went past, making her coat tingle.

He repeated the teasing gesture with Trixie, the showmare barely stifling an eager moan, her tail flagging higher and higher. Starlight now had a clear view of her marefriend’s slit, trickles of syrupy arousal already dripping on the plush carpet, her heated scent making Starlight’s mouth water.

“So, now that you are both here.” Jack turned to them, a roguish smile on his lips. He gestured to one side of the entrance hall, and spoke like a performer on a stage. “This door leads to the dining room, where we could spend some time getting to know each other.” He then pointed to the opposite door. “And through here is the bedroom.” He waggled his eyebrows. “In case you two want to skip the formalities and go straight to the fun part— mfft!”

Jack stumbled backwards as Trixie pounced on him, her tail wagging erratically as she latched-on to his lips. Her kiss was fierce and almost desperate, her hooves hooking around his neck as if her life depended on it. The bedroom doors banged open as Jack half-staggered, half-fell through the opening, the stallion clearly unprepared for Trixie’s clumsy enthusiasm. Starlight rolled her eyes, reminded of the first time she and Trixie had spent the night together, and she followed them into the plush bedroom.

Trixie and Jack were rolling on the floor, the contents of her saddlebag spilling out as she shrugged the straps off. Their identical coats seemed to blend together as their bodies writhed in a passionate embrace, their lips never parting. Starlight licked her own lips, her breath shortening as she watched the lustful display. Her horn flared to life, and she bit her lips while her magic flowed over her drenched pussy, teasing her puffy slit. It was like looking at two Trixies making out, and for Starlight the spectacle was unbearably hot.

Soon enough Jack started to take control of the kiss, his expert lips quickly overwhelming the much younger mare. Trixie didn’t oppose any resistance, the showmare happily yielding to him, her hooves folding against her chest as he pushed her to the ground. He slowly stood over her, Jack’s dominant kissing turning Trixie into a mewling pile of mush. She remained on her back as he finally broke the kiss, whimpering submissively as he loomed over her limp form. He raised his head, a strand of saliva linking their lips, and he took a moment to admire the beautiful mare beneath him.

Starlight engaged in her own gawking, her eyes roaming all over the older stallion’s body. He had the athletic musculature of a pony who worked out regularly, but with a slight pudge on his belly from a life of excesses and indulging. The lines on his muzzle betrayed his age, but to Starlight it only made him look sexier, more masculine… as did his large sheath and his big, fat pair of swinging balls. She could see his cock stirring inside its hiding place, the tip peeking from his folds, ready to flop out.

“You’re a naughty little filly.” Jack scolded playfully, smiling down at his doppleganger.

Trixie nodded eagerly, the scent of her arousal spreading through the room. Jack inhaled deeply, and Starlight held her breath as his dark blue cock slowly emerged from its sheath, his blunt tip already flaring slightly. Her magic flowed faster and faster on her slit, the ethereal tendrils sinking just a little deeper with each new inch of exposed stallion flesh. Her eyes widened as Jack’s length just kept slithering out of his sheath, his medial ring nowhere in sight; just how big was he?

“See something you like?” Jack called, startling Starlight out of her cock-induced trance. “Why don’t you come take a closer look?”

Her gaze flicked to his arrogant expression, his smug smile incredibly similar to Trixie’s. Starlight was walking to him before she even realized she was moving, lost in his oh-so-familiar eyes. Those dark violet pupils, the exact same shade as her marefriend’s, the eyes she just loved to gaze into for hours, the same mischievous twinkle as she stepped closer and closer… Even his lips were as soft as Trixie’s.

Their kiss was slow, sensual, erotic. Jack wasted no time in trying to deepen the kiss, but Starlight played at biting his lips whenever he tried to take control. He might have been a fantastic kisser, but she was not ready to surrender to him that easily. Their tongues wrestled for dominance, never breaking contact even when their lips parted, their hot breaths mingling together. Starlight could taste Trixie on his lips, mixing with his own flavor… it was simply delicious.

Jack leaned forward, trying to push her back, but she held her ground, their chests pressing together. He nickered deeply, and Starlight answered with a heated snort, two dominant ponies trying to impose their authority. Their kissing became more aggressive, their lips sliding off as they traded playful bites along their necks, before going back to kissing, and then biting again. They lost themselves in their combative mating dance, like the feral ponies of old, neither willing to back down.

Suddenly everything changed as one of them, Starlight wasn’t sure who, dragged the other to the ground, their bodies locking together. They grappled fiercely, trying to be the first to stand up, to be the one to win this torrid wrestling match. Starlight had to use all her considerable strength to keep Jack from pinning her to the floor, and in return the stallion squirmed like a snake whenever she managed to get on top of him. Between grunts of effort and moans of pleasure they kissed, deeply, passionately, drunk on a cocktail of lust and pride.

All the while Starlight could feel his limp shaft brushing against her fur, his pulsing cock slithering on her belly, her flanks, her back, her everything. He was even starting to leave a trail of sticky arousal all over her body, his tip leaking precum like a broken faucet. She could tell he was trying to keep himself from becoming completely hard, and she decided to do everything in her power to make it an impossible feat.

Her horn twinkled to life, and he grunted as she gave his balls a gentle squeeze. His floppy stallionhood throbbed in response, inexorably hardening under her careful fondling. Little by little he stopped fighting her, his hips humping into her soft fur instead of trying to hold her down. With a heave she managed to straddle him, using her tail to tease his sensitive flare. She trapped his cock between her thighs, and started to grind her plump teats against his length.

She was rewarded by a large spurt of precum right on her tits, helping her slide his meat between the slender mounds. She heard him groan under his breath, his stallionhood giving a mighty kick, the semi-soft flesh twitching against her belly. He faltered in his kissing, his hooves going slack as he started to surrender to pure pleasure. Just a little push and Starlight would make him yield. She had him, she had him now…

Starlight gasped out loud as a second pair of impossibly soft lips pressed into the crook of her jaw, making her shiver in delight. Trixie nibbled on her lover’s coat, her teeth biting just in that special spot she had found, the one that made Starlight’s legs turn into jelly. Starlight whined in protest, her strength leaving her as both Trixie and Jack kissed her all over, the stallion quickly finding the same spot on her neck; this wasn’t fair! She was dragged down, her limbs going limp, lost in a sea of blue lips.

Starlight couldn’t tell who was who, she couldn’t tell which one of her lovers was currently nibbling on her ear, and which one was licking her neck. Everywhere she looked she could only see azure fur and silver mane, the two magicians embracing her as they writhed on the soft carpet. Trixie’s scent now permeated the air, mingling with Jack’s heavy musk, delivering the coup de grace to Starlight’s poor befuzzled brain.

With two sets of lips pressed against her jaw, Starlight finally surrendered completely. She soon found herself pinned on her back, one imperious hoof pressing against her chest. Jack stood over her with a big cheeky grin, while Trixie kept kissing her marefriend all over. Starlight panted like a dog, her chest rising and falling in time with her galloping heart: it was like she had just made out with two Trixies at once, it was a wonder she hadn’t passed out.

“Huff… huff…. huff... “ Starlight gasped for air, looking up at the smug stallion looming overhead. “You… huff… cheated…”

“Now now, I never asked for your little friend’s help.” Jack tutted, his hoof tracing circles on Starlight’s chest fluff. “Isn’t that right girl?”

“Yes Daddy…” Trixie breathed huskily, shooting a naughty smile at the stallion.

Jack quirked an eyebrow, his smile growing. “Daddy hmm? I like it, keep calling me that.”

“Trixie will do anything you say Daddy.” Trixie purred obediently.

“I could get used to this...” He caressed her mane, Trixie leaning into his hoof like an eager kitten.

“Perverts…” Starlight snorted. She could feel his precum dripping on her belly, and it was obvious Jack really liked Trixie’s new nickname.

“Don’t pretend you don’t love that about Trixie.” Trixie teased, nuzzling Starlight’s mane.

Starlight grumbled under her breath, much to Trixie’s amusement. Jack chuckled alongside his new partner in crime, and he finally removed his hoof from Starlight’s chest. He trotted off towards a cushy armchair, where he sat back heavily, his legs spread far apart. Trixie stopped her cuddling to openly stare at Jack’s endowment, his lengthy limp stallionhood swinging in full view.

Jack reclined on his seat, sighing softly. “It seems my age is getting to me.” He gestured to his soft cock, a pained expression on his muzzle. “Would you mind helping an older stallion out?” He was barely done talking and Trixie was already sitting before him, her tail wagging happily. Jack smiled, patting her head. “Good girl.”

“Thank you Daddy.” Trixie purred. She eagerly leaned down to nuzzle his length, breathing in his scent. “Oh wow…”

“How about you?” Jack called, smirking at Starlight.

Starlight huffed, perfectly aware that he didn’t need any help getting hard, but she relented with good grace: she had learned her lesson about being a sour loser. She lazily made her way to him, her hips rolling enticingly. Jack watched her sultry display with an appreciative grin, his eyes following her hips. She slowly kneeled before him, crawling closer while looking up at him, her hot breath washing over his twitching length.

“By Luna’s teats, you girls are the sexiest mares I’ve ever met.” Jack said earnestly, his hooves brushing against Starlight’s and Trixie’s heads. He opened his mouth to say more, but his words devolved into a deep moan as Starlight placed a long and sensual lick over the length of his stallionhood.

Starlight hummed in delight as she tasted him, her nose twitching as she inhaled his virile musk. She nosed her way past his limp cock, and nuzzled his plump balls, sniffing deeply. She felt Trixie shivering at her side, the mare busily suckling at his tip, catching his leaking precum in her mouth. From her little whimpers it was obvious Trixie very much enjoyed her treat, the mare gulping down his arousal hungrily. Her blowjob was clumsy and sloppy, a mix of saliva and precum oozing all over her chin, her little gurgling whimpers unbearably cute.

Hankering for a taste, Starlight pressed her cheeks to Trixie’s, pushing her marefriend out of the way. Trixie whined in protest, but she quickly gave in to her lead mare’s request. Her lips released Jack’s flared tip, instantly replaced by Starlight’s mouth. The unicorn lost no time in bobbing her head over his cock, showing off her superior skills. Trixie grumbled, and had to settle for licking the stallion’s swollen balls. Jack groaned in pleasure, the stallion gripping his armrests as Starlight consumed his length, her lips tightly sealed around his growing flesh. She looked up at him, holding his gaze as she licked his cock all over.

After a few back and forths Starlight had to rise from her kneeling position as the angle of her bobbing changed, Jack’s cock becoming rock hard under her ministrations. Her lips were soon stretched to their limits to accommodate his girth, her jaw opening wider and wider as she bobbed her head down onto his throbbing pole. Only when he finally stopped growing did she stop her insistent suckling. With a flourish from her tongue she threw her head back with a noisy slurp, Jack’s cock slipping out with a shower of mixed fluids.

Trixie looked up from her ball nuzzling, staring at his fully aroused member, her eyes wide and excited. She gave Starlight an imploring look, like a filly begging for a piece of candy. Her puppy dog expression was somewhat spoiled by the strands of sticky precum crisscrossing her muzzle, but it was enough to win Starlight over. The unicorn nodded, and Trixie scrambled on her hooves. She eagerly licked his length all over, catching the streams of precum flowing from his tip, and she latched her lips around it.

The showmare was instantly choking around her mouthful of cock, her cheeks comically puffed out as she tried to fit his large flare inside her little mouth. She gurgled and sputtered as she swallowed his flowing precum, her tongue poking out in a cute display of clumsiness. Starlight even started to wonder if this was Trixie’s first stallion, or at least her first blowjob. Sighing good-naturedly, Starlight tapped her marefriend on the shoulder, gesturing to have a turn.

“You’re going to hurt yourself if you keep sucking him like that.” She whispered, hooking a hoof around the base of Jack’s pole. “Here, let me show you.”

Starlight gently took him back inside her mouth, this time looking straight into Trixie’s eyes as she did so. The showmare watched attentively, her blue cheeks flushed with excitement. Starlight bobbed her head as slowly as she could, exaggerating the motions for Trixie’s benefit, while her teasing pace made Jack moan in frustration.

He tried to grab her head and make Starlight blow him faster, but a sharp magical zap made him reconsider. He could only squirm in his seat, his panting breath becoming ragged, waiting for his tormentor to give him relief. Grinning around his girth Starlight looked up at him, allowing herself a moment to enjoy her little revenge… and she suddenly bobbed her head down, his cock plunging inside her throat, taking him to the hilt.

Jack threw his head back, hissing in pleasure, his whole length crammed into the tight confines of Starlight’s throat. Starlight held herself there, nose pressed against his groin, her lips suckling at his base. She swallowed around him for good measure, showing her complete lack of gag reflex, heavy spurts of precum splattering into her hungry stomach. Only when she was starting to see spots from lack of air did she start to lean back, her lips dragging against his veiny surface all the way to his flare.

Starlight took a deep breath as soon as her mouth was free, her senses absolutely flooded with his musk. She had half a mind to deep throat him again, but a little whimper reminded her she wasn’t alone. She turned to Trixie, the mare looking at her with an admiring expression, and she nodded towards Jack’s towering pole. Trixie gulped, intimidated, and she slowly made her way up to his twitching tip, his flare now incredibly wide and hard; Starlight could tell he was just about ready to blow, but she decided against warning her marefriend, just to see the look on her face.

Trixie carefully opened her mouth, taking him inside like Starlight had shown her. She had to strain to get his swollen tip past her lips, her head bobbing gently, and this time she didn’t choke instantly; she only sputtered slightly on the third bob. Emboldened by her success, Trixie started to take more and more of his length, Starlight watching with bated breath, ready to intervene if her lover pushed herself too hard.

After a few minutes of sloppy suckling, Trixie gurgled out loud, her eyes widening: she had reached the entrance of her throat. She tentatively tried to take him deeper, her throat convulsing in protest. Starlight winced as she heard her lover gag, tears threatening to spill from Trixie’s eyes. Starlight was just about ready to take Trixie’s place when the showmare took a deep breath… and she shoved her head down, just as Starlight had done before.

It didn’t go as well for the poor unexperienced mare.

“HRMMGGGLK”

Trixie flailed her hooves around, her poor virgin throat completely unprepared for Jack’s girth. Starlight was instantly at her side, trying to help her lean back, but Trixie batted her hooves at her, gurgling in protest. She shot Starlight a glare, her tearful eyes screaming “Trixie can do this, leave Trixie alone!” and she valiantly pushed herself farther down.

Starlight watched as her marefriend’s throat started to bulge out, Jack’s flare clearly visible under her coat. The stallion was holding on for dear life, his hooves sinking into his armrest as Trixie’s extremely tight throat constricted madly around his length. Starlight panted as the bulge travelled down Trixie’s throat, the mare somehow managing to swallow more of him despite her gagging and choking.

Mascara was running all over Trixie’s cheeks now, her eyes rolled back into her head as she forced herself down. She blinked in surprise when her nose touched his belly, and she seemed amazed to find she had taken him fully. Good thing too, considering his flare was all the way to the base of her neck; she couldn’t take another inch. Trixie gave a gurgling cheer, proud of her accomplishment. Unfortunately the vibration of her vocal cords seemed to be the last straw for Jack.

The stallion breathed out a rattling moan, his eyes closing in pure ecstasy, and he gave a shallow thrust into Trixie’s muzzle. Starlight’s eyes went wide as she saw his balls clench up, Trixie’s gurgling turning panicked as his flare grew even larger. The poor mare started to tug her head back, trying to get him out, but his tip seemed resolutely lodge deep inside her gullet. Trixie spun around his pole to give her marefriend an imploring look… but it was too late.

Jack’s stallionhood swelled like a rubber-hose filling with water, bulging out her tight little throat further. Starlight watched in awe as his release visibly shot through his length, all the way to his huge flare. Trixie gave a gurgling cry as he unloaded straight into her stomach, his first shot long and copious. Starlight panted in excitement, she could practically hear his heavy seed splattering inside her marefriend’s belly. It was such a dirty spectacle she almost forgot to help her lover. Almost.

Using her magic, she heaved Trixie back, the mare’s eyes already threatening to roll back completely, on the verge of passing out. The outline of his throbbing flare slowly made its way back up to her mouth, the stallion constantly unloading spurts after spurts of heavy spunk. After a few instants Starlight finally managed to tug Trixie far enough back, his flare bursting out of her throat with an audible *pop*. Trixie instantly took a deep, desperate breath through her nose, her cheeks bulging out as Jack filled her mouth to the brim in a single shot. The next spurt was too much for Trixie, semen bursting from around her lips.

Starlight closed her eyes as she was showered with thick horse cum, Jack’s fountaining cock slipping free from Trixie’s lips explosively. The showmare was blasted squarely in the face as she spat her mouthful of foal batter, her dainty muzzle instantly coated with a heavy layer of semen. Trixie opened her mouth to protest, with predictable results —“WHARRGARBL!”— before Starlight flew to her lover’s rescue.

Starlight took her fair share of friendly fire as she tried to catch Jack’s twitching length, and when she managed to take his spurting length between her lips her mouth was blasted full in a matter of seconds. She groaned out loud as his potent semen overwhelmed her senses, his virile seed clinging to her throat as she swallowed desperately. She barely managed to keep up with his production, huge bulges of lumpy semen travelling down her throat.

After a surprising amount of time his release started to taper down, and she found herself suckling on his softening cock to drag everything out of his length. She allowed him to slip free of her mouth to catch his last few weak spurts on her muzzle, gasping as each warm strand landed on her coat. One eye closed by a thick rope of semen, Starlight watched with panting breath as Jack’s length retreated back into his sheath, drops of cum dribbling from his tip. She then turned to her marefriend, and had to stifle a burst of laughter.

Trixie had her mouth open, a huge load of thick baby batter bubbling inside, both her eyes glued shut by a very thorough facial. She seemed torn between being disgusted at having to swallow the mouthful of spunk, and being repelled by the idea of spitting it all out like some ill mannered filly. Stuck by indecision, she only made it worse for herself as her tongue was bathed in his seed, his taste forever engraving itself in her brain. Once again Starlight came to her rescue, Trixie squeaking in surprise as their lips made contact.

Starlight moaned into Trixie’s mouth while lapping at the pool of warm spunk, enjoying the new helping greatly. Trixie made a little noise of disgust, but she happily gave every last drop to her lover. They kissed and shared Jack’s release, Trixie shivering drunkenly as she swallowed a few gulps by mistake. After a few minutes of sloppy making out, they finally separated, thick strands of saliva mixed with semen uniting their muzzles.

“... Eww.” Trixie mewled. “That was…”

“Amazing…” Starlight finished breathlessly.

“Trixie was going to say disgusting.” Trixie made a face, sticking her tongue out. “This stuff tastes…”

“Delicious.” Starlight interrupted, giving her mopey marefriend a quick loving kiss. Trixie quickly relented, her pout turning into a lustful smile as she kissed Starlight back.

“I really should have bought a camera…” Jack grinned down at them. “My friend Big Bucks is never going to believe me when I tell him about you two…”

“You can always bring him tomorrow for our next session.” Starlight teased, using her magic to give his ballsack a playful squeeze. She was surprised to find they were still nicely plump despite his huge release, the orbs pulsing as they rushed to produce a new batch of foal batter. “Or is our next session going to be right now?” She smiled hungrily.

Jack smirked confidently at her. “Just give me a few minutes my pretty, and I’ll show you what I can do.” He eyed Trixie, the mare looking up at him with wide, eager eyes. He caressed the mare’s cheeks lovingly. “Why don’t you two give me a good show, help me get started again?”

“Anything for you, Daddy.” Trixie breathed sensually.

“Okay, I’m starting to really like that nickname…” Starlight said, slowly getting to her hooves.

“Oh, you do?” Trixie said with a lidded gaze. “Did you like hearing Trixie choke on her Daddy’s cock?”

“Holy Celestia you are so dirty…” Starlight panted, marching towards her marefriend, her horn fizzling with purpose.

Trixie giggled as she slowly backed away, forcing Starlight to stalk after her. “Did you like watching Trixie suck on her Daddy’s thick dick?”

“Young lady,” Jack Pot called sternly, “language.”

Trixie put on a sheepish expression. “Sorry Daddy… eep!” She half giggled, half squealed as Starlight pounced on her, the exchange apparently too much for the unicorn.

The two mares embraced each other like they did every night, the two of them moving in perfect harmony, knowing perfectly what the other wanted. Soon Starlight was in a familiar position: her belly pressing down on Trixie’s, her head between the mare’s thighs, her own slippery pussy pressing against Trixie’s muzzle. This standing 69 was a personal favorite of theirs, Starlight focusing exclusively on the mare she loved, forgetting all about the stallion watching.

She took some time to admire Trixie’s nethers, her horn shining brightly as her magic flowed on her marefriend’s intimacy. Trixie’s slit was wonderfully narrow, framed by dark blue folds of plump flesh, her pussy lips quivering as Starlight’s magic flowed over them. Trixie moaned out loud, and the mare quickly began to slobber all over Starlight’s cunt, her little tongue teasing her lover’s clit. In contrast Starlight took her time, her magic softly brushing against Trixie’s sensitive slit, barely making contact.

Soon Starlight was rewarded by a familiar sight, Trixie’s folds opening wide in a naughty wink, her pink flesh begging for her touch. Starlight chuckled to herself as her lover squirted all over the carpet, her desperate juices wonderfully fragrant. She really loved when Trixie was in heat, the mare was just so easy to tease. She waited for Trixie to stop squirting, and only then did she start her gentle ministrations, her magic parting her folds just a little.

Trixie groaned as she pressed her muzzle against Starlight’s intimacy, lapping at her clit with expert precision: she knew all of her lover’s buttons, and how to press them. She began to moan submissively as she sucked on Starlight’s clit, giving it short little licks. She purred in happiness as she was showered with a squirt of mare juices, Starlight’s pussy winking wide open. She eagerly lapped up at her marefriend’s nectar, washing away the awful taste of stallion spunk.

Now panting in pleasure, Starlight relented in her teasing, and she leaned down to place a long lick over her lover’s slit, shivering as Trixie’s lovely perfume mixed with Jack’s aggressive musk. She took a second to enjoy the blend of flavors, and she started to pleasure the showmare properly. She licked Trixie’s clit, lapped at her folds, used her magic to press at her most sensitive spots, even the ones deep inside Trixie’s tunnel. The mare was a quivering mess in a matter of instants, Trixie too busy moaning out loud to continue with her sloppy licking.

Starlight didn’t mind if she was left unattended, she was a very generous lover after all. Her licking quickened, her tongue reaching deeper and deeper, her magic forming a squirming tentacle that coiled inside Trixie’s pussy. Trixie began to gasp with quick, short whimpers of pleasure, her legs twitching cutely as she neared her end.

Starlight held back from pushing Trixie over the edge for as long as she could, letting the mare’s orgasm build up, her magical tentacle teasing her G-spot mercilessly. It was only when Trixie’s whining became desperate that Starlight gave in, her horn flaring brightly. She gave Trixie’s clit a loooong lick, her magical tentacle suddenly grew to completely fill Trixie’s tight tunnel, and she sent a little zap of electricity just in the right spot. The effect was immediate.

Trixie took in a sharp breath, her body going stiff as her limbs quivered, her eyes rolling back. Starlight lapped at her squirting pussy diligently, teasing her engorged love button as Trixie was overcome by pleasure. The magical tentacle squirmed inside her clenching cunt, its every twitch making Trixie give a breathless whimper of ecstasy. Her body trembled in a discreet but powerful orgasm, the mare never very vocal when she came; Starlight joked that it was the only time Trixie was ever quiet.

With one last teasing lick Starlight leaned back up, her tongue running on her lips, savoring her lover’s juices. She watched as Trixie writhed on the floor, her chest heaving, barely able to take a breath in her state of ongoing climax. Starlight made her magical tentacle stir, smiling when the mare beneath her gasped out loud, legs twitching uselessly. With one last magical caress, she ended her spell, leaving Trixie to shiver and catch her breath.

Starlight spun to face Trixie, watching her marefriend’s expression with a smug smile. Trixie’s eyes were unfocused, her panting mouth wide open, a strand of drool running down her cheek. She was completely out of it. Starlight leaned down to kiss her on the brow, and she gasped when she felt somepony breathing on her exposed marehood. She turned, and found Jack behind her, nosing his way under her tail.

“What are you… ooooooh…”

Starlight’s question became a loud moan, her eyes crossing in bliss. Jack hummed as he tasted her arousal, his tongue pressing into her tight slit, searching for her clit. As soon as he found it, he began to slobber all over her sensitive nub, making her legs tremble. He’s good… Starlight admitted, bolts of pleasure shooting up her spine.

As wound up as she was, it didn’t take long for Jack’s expert tongue to bring her close to the edge, and she did nothing to hold her orgasm back. Feeling her eagerness, Jack lapped at her cunt with renewed vigor, his muzzle drenched in her juices. Starlight felt her pleasure quickly building in her belly, like a spring ready to snap… and with a well placed lick she came.

If Trixie was quiet in her orgasms, Starlight was anything but. The unicorn whinied out loud, her horn sparkling with power. She felt her pussy clench into a tight vice, her heated juices spraying from her cunt, straight onto Jack’s muzzle. The stallion inhaled deeply, his licking becoming clumsy as the scent of a mare in heat wreaked havoc on his mind. Starlight was all too happy to pick up the slack, her horn flashing as she summoned a large magical stallionhood. The glowing cock pushed Jack’s muzzle out of the way, before shoving itself deep into her oozing depths.

Starlight whinied once again, her orgasm soaring to new heights as she was filled to the brim with her own magic. Jack stared at the display, his mouth open and panting: with the translucent dildo holding her tight pussy open, he could see her insides clenching around the magical construct, all the way to her farthest walls. He watched her cervix wink obsecenly wide, her womb obviously starving for a good dose of foal batter.

With a masculine snort Jack reared on his hind hooves, his chest sliding on Starlight’s rump as he smoothly mounted her. Starlight nickered in delight, her orgasmic whinies only becoming louder as she felt his cock slide between her teats, already at full mast and ready to plow into her. He began to thrust against her belly, his dry humping rocking Starlight’s body, her magical dildo pounding into her cunt in time with his thrusting. Starlight had to square her hooves to avoid stepping on Trixie, the mare still sprawled beneath her.

Jack kept hammering into her cushy rump without ever trying to go for her inviting pussy, his cock spurting precum all over her belly, Trixie getting showered with his syrupy arousal. Starlight felt like she was going crazy, her inner walls craving the touch of a real stallion’s flesh, the glowing dildo completely insufficient in dousing the raging fire in her belly. With a loud huff she dispelled the magical cock, her hips shifting to help him slide inside, and she waited for him to claim her.

Only… Jack didn’t shove his cock into her oozing pussy like she hoped. On the contrary, the stallion stopped his wild humping, exhaled, and he began to dismount. Starlight snorted in indignation: never had a stallion refused her before! She shoved her rump backwards, trying to make him slide inside her slippery slit, but Jack dodged away, chuckling under his breath. What the hay, that was just rude!

“Now now,” Jack breathed, his strong hooves holding her hips in place, “aren’t you forgetting something?”

Starlight turned to glare at him, wondering why the stallion wasn’t rutting her brains out yet.

“I’d love to continue, but..” He sniffed the air, his eyes fluttering. “You two are obviously in heat, and I do intend on staying a childless bachelor forever.”

Starlight eyes went wide, and something clicked in her mind: that’s what they had forgotten to bring… condoms! She facehoofed, groaning out loud. The one thing Trixie and her never had to worry about when doing their sexy-necessities bag… for obvious reasons.

“Don’t tell me… you didn’t bring any?” Jack quirked an eyebrow. He dismounted her, his cock slapping against his belly. “I’m sorry ladies, but if you were hoping to get a little souvenir out of me in eleven months, you’ll leave disappointed.”

“No… we just… forgot.” Starlight groaned, the fire in her belly only burning hotter.

“Not Trixie’s fault…” Trixie mumbled, the mare slowly getting to her hooves. She had to lean on Starlight as she stood up, still a little woozy.

Jack sighed, smiling good naturally. “Oh well, that’s a shame, but we can always do other things.” He trotted towards the bed, where he sat on the edge, his cock standing proud and tall. “We can continue tomorrow, if you gals want...”

“No.” Trixie pouted childishly.

“No?” Jack tilted his head.

“I want it now.” Trixie stamped her hoof.

“Does my naughty filly want a spanking?” Jack grinned.

“No… maybe later.” Trixie blushed. She made her way to the bed, skipping on her hooves childishly. “Right now, I want to show Daddy a trick...”

“Oh?” Jack licked his lips, his eyes following Trixie’s wide hips, his cock throbbing against his belly at the sight.

She reached him, and before he could protest she jumped on his lap, his cock trapped between their bellies. “Trixie is going to make this wand…” She grasped his length, giving it a nice long stroke. “... disappear.”

“That was incredibly corny.” Jack said, smiling wide. “I like it…” He grasped her hips, whether to keep her from taking him inside or help her, Starlight wasn’t sure.

“Hey, are you sure about this?” Starlight trotted closer, a worried frown on her muzzle. “You’re at the peak of your estrus cycle Trix, this really isn’t a safe day to do it raw.” She licked her lips; she could still taste his seed on her tongue. “And he’s not shooting blanks, that I can guarantee.”

“It’s fine, Daddy will pull out when he’s close.” Trixie started to grind her hips, her slippery slit gliding smoothly over his veiny length. “Or… maybe Trixie will keep him inside, make him a daddy for real…”

“Tempting,” Jack purred, his cock twitching in agreement, “but I’ll take option one. There can only be so much greatness in the world.”

Starlight watched in trepidation as Trixie slowly raised her hips, leaving a trail of wetness on Jack’s length. They both gasped as his tip brushed against her puffy folds, the fat flare covering her tight opening completely; it was going to be a tight fit.

Undeterred, Trixie began to lower herself, needy little whimpers escaping her mouth. Mesmerized, Starlight kneeled between Jack’s thighs, just behind Trixie. She watched with bated breath as his large tip slowly parted Trixie’s narrow slit, precum and mare juices flowing around his flare as he strained to sink inside.

Jack’s cock started to bend under the pressure, Trixie’s tunnel apparently just too tight for him, and with a lewd wet noise his flare slipped off target. His dark blue cock slid over Trixie’s equally dark blue folds, the two of them giving an identical groan of disappointment. Whining under her breath, Trixie raised her rear again, and tried to take him once more. She put her hooves on his chest, gritting her teeth as she lowered her cunt onto his stallionhood. But once again, his girth failed to penetrate, to their loud frustration. Trixie aligned him for a third time, grumbling darkly, when his cock started to glow with light blue magic. She looked up, but it wasn’t Jack’s doing, the stallion looking just as surprised.

“Let me help.” Starlight breathed, now just as excited as Trixie.

She held him in place, her magical grasp assuring he wouldn’t slip away as Trixie hurried to grind her tight pussy over his fat flare. Starlight could feel Jack’s hurried heartbeat through his length, her marefriend’s juices trickling all around his cock, helping him slide inside. With a sudden lurch his tip finally managed to pop inside her narrow slit, both magicians moaning in unison as they were united.

“Oh wow…” Trixie gasped, her hips slowly sliding down, his massive girth disappearing inside her tight pussy. “Daddy, you’re so big…”

Jack grunted in reply, his hooves tugging at her foal-bearing hips, dragging her down onto his lap. Starlight panted hotly as she watched him gently stuff her marefriend full, Trixie’s quivering slit soon reaching his medial ring. Jack gave a sharp heave, shoving the rest of his cock into his mate to the hilt. Trixie squealed in pleasure, her ass slapping into his lap, a squirt of mixed fluids spraying around his girth.

“Oh my Celestia.” Trixie groaned, her eyes closing as she enjoyed the sensation of being filled to the brim with stallion meat. “Trixie is so full…”

“Perfect fit, it’s like we were made for each other.” Jack groaned, his hoof caressing her sides. “Is that the entrance to your womb I can feel?” He gave a little thrust, and Trixie squealed in delight.

“Maybe…” She wiggled her hips on his lap. “Are you going to spurt your sticky juice inside Daddy? Are you going to put a foal inside Trixie?”

“I’m seriously considering it.” Jack growled. “For now be a good girl and ride me.”

Trixie didn’t need to be told twice. She began to bounce on his lap, slowly at first, then with more and more vigor. Wet slaps echoed around the room as her firm rump met with his muscled thighs, a mix of mare juice and precum dribbling all over the floor and bed. Starlight gulped, her nose twitching as their mingled scents filled the air, and she soon couldn’t take it anymore.

Jack gave a sharp nicker as Starlight’s tongue slid over his balls, collecting a generous sample of fluids and a good dose of his masculine musk. The unicorn lapped his ballsack with shameless enthusiasm, careful not to poke Trixie’s with her horn. The stallion snorted as he was once again serviced by these two beautiful mares, and he started to thrust up to meet Trixie halfway down, their hips loudly slapping together. Azure fur met azure fur in a symphony of groans and whimpers, their pace becoming wild and almost desperate.

Starlight had to lean away as the stallion began to jackhammer into Trixie, the poor mare getting thrown around like a ragdoll by his powerful thrusts. When she went completely limp, he grunted and forcefully rolled Trixie on her back, his length never leaving her cunt. Trixie tried to protest weakly, now lying on her back with her legs dangling off the bed, but Jack ignored her completely. He was thrusting away like a madpony in the next instant.

Trixie was lost to the world as she was screwed into oblivion, her eyes rolling back while Jack pounded into her without mercy. Starlight crawled on the bed to the side of her marefriend, Trixie’s eyes barely managing to focus on her as she brought her muzzle close. The two lovers kissed passionately, Trixie’s body rocked by Jack’s frenzied pounding, their tongues intertwined.

Starlight slid a hoof between her thighs, rubbing her needy slit, the other roaming over Trixie’s heaving chest. She ran her hoof downwards, and she gasped when she felt Jack’s cock bump into it. She released Trixie’s lips, and watched with wide eyes as the stallion’s massive cock created a visible bulge on the little mare’s svelte belly. Starlight caressed Jack’s flare through her the mare’s soft coat, her other hoof now drenched in her juices, clopping herself silly.

Soon Jack’s frantic pace began to falter, his thrusts losing their smooth rhythm. He was now hammering home with a lot more strength than speed, Trixie’s limp form rocked by his dominant thrusts. The mare had a vacant expression on her smiling muzzle, her tongue lolling out of her mouth.

“I’m… I’m…” Jack grunted, giving one last brutal thrust before holding himself buried inside Trixie. He took a few calming breaths, and Starlight could feel his rock hard flare twitching inside Trixie, crammed against her cervix. “Holy… that was close.”

“Too close.” Starlight could tell by the size of his flare and his throbbing that he had stopped just on the verge of spilling his load inside Trixie’s fertile womb. “Pull out, I’ll finish you off with my mouth.”

“With pleasure.” Jack smirked.

He groaned, his hips quivering as he started to withdraw from Trixie’s clenching depths. He was halfway out when the mare suddenly came back to life, her hooves latching on to Jack with surprising strength. The stallion grunted in surprise, his cock sinking back the hilt.

“Trix, what the hay are you doing!” Starlight stared at her marefriend, but Trixie was still completely out of it: her body was moving on its own, running on pure breeding instincts. “Let go of him!”

“Nuuuh,” Trixie mumbled, lost in her orgasmic trance, “so hot… Trixie needs Daddy’s cum…”

“Oh for pony sake.” Starlight tried to pry her lover’s hoof off Jack, and she shot a glare to the stallion. “You better not release inside.”

Jack groaned, his eyes fluttering. “She’s not making it very easy, you know?” He gasped, his mouth falling open. “Oh sweet heavens she’s clenching up so tight… I… can’t… Oooh...”

“Hey… HEY” Starlight’s eyes widened as Jack started to give shallow thrusts into a squealing Trixie, his eyes glazing over. She tried to separate them with her magic, but couldn’t use all her strength, lest she injure one of them. She pushed against the stallions chest, trying to make him stop pounding into her marefriend… and she was looking straight into his eyes when he fell over the edge. “... Ponyfeathers...”

Jack gave a rattling exhale as he gave one final thrust, hilting inside his mare. Trixie took a long and trembling breath, her legs holding him all the tighter as she felt his cock swell with his second release of the night. Starlight could only watch, torn between trying something to stop the inevitable, and just enjoying the show. With her hoof rubbing frantically against her cunt, her choice was made, and she sat back to watch as Jack unloaded straight into Trixie’s womb.

Starlight felt it under her hoof. She felt the huge blast of thick spunk exploding from his flared tip, the gush of virile seed surging through Trixie’s fertile womb. His first shot lasted for what felt like forever, Trixie’s depths quickly filled with his foal batter. When it finally ended Jack gave a shuddering tug back, then he rammed his stallionhood back inside with a dominant snort, a new surge blasting through Trixie’s willing cervix.

Rope after rope of jelly-like semen were crammed inside Trixie, the little mare stuffed full of life-giving warmth. Her hooves went slack, her legs releasing her stud, but Jack was too far gone to even think about pulling out. The damage was already done anyway. He held himself hilted, his orgasm surging on and on, Trixie’s slender belly soon bloating with his seemingly endless release.

Only after his own release started to push him back did Jack relent. He dragged his spurting length out of his mare with a smooth tug, a torrent of lumpy semen gushing from Trixie’s stretched cunt. He slapped his softening cock against her belly, his length nesting itself comfortably between her plump teats, and he sighed contently as he fired the last of his load over Trixie’s rounded belly. He thoroughly marked his mare with his scent, his semen sticking to her blue coat like glue, and finally his climax ended.

He fell back on the floor, completely winded. He admired his handy work, his seed pouring out of Trixie’s pussy, her belly still bloated despite the large pool forming on the floor. He then blinked, reason returning to him, and his happy expression turned into wide-eyed horror.

“Oh my Luna, what have I done...”

Starlight sighed; she should’ve known something like this would happen. She tugged her hoof away from her drenched pussy, just moments away from cumming. It was frustrating to stop when she was so close, but she had to do something or Trixie would end up knocked up for sure… if that wasn’t already the case. She got off the bed and hurried to stand in front of Trixie’s stuffed cunt, gulping when she got a whiff of Jack’s release. It smelled… delicious. She had planned to use her magic to scoop out his foal batter, but she just had a better, much tastier idea.

Jack had done it now.

He was usually so careful, what the hay had happened to him?! Why did that little blue mare make him feel so… so giddy? He could only remember one time where he had been this careless with a mare in heat, and it had happened more than twenty years ago with his first crush, when he was still a young and horny stud. And now… now he had probably knocked up a fan of his, something all professionals dreaded above all else.

He was distracted from his spiraling thoughts when Starlight began to sniff her marefriend’s pussy, her tail twitching in interest. He was about to ask what she was doing when the unicorn leaned closer… and began to slurp on his flowing semen straight from the tap, her tongue lapping up his thick release like it was the sweetest treat in the world. He watched, astonished, as Starlight gulped down his spunk, the unicorn sucking his cream right out of Trixie’s cunt.

Trixie moaned weakly, but she was too out of it to do anything but twitch her legs. Starlight swallowed without pause, and she raised her hoof to push on Trixie’s swollen belly when the flow slowed. A huge gush of spunk rushed from Trixie’s overstuffed womb, straight into Starlight’s awaiting mouth. She obviously took pleasure in her task, not a drop escaping her lapping tongue.

Starlight’s tail began to flag higher and higher, her rump sticking out in the air unconsciously as she consumed her fill of thick stallion cream. Jack could hear her hums of appreciation as she slurped on his release: it was the hottest, dirtiest, most depraved sight he had ever had the pleasure of witnessing. His cock seemed to agree, his length somehow already hardening back to full mast, despite having just finished. He eyed Starlight’s dripping cunt, her pink flesh winking at him invitingly, and he snorted with new purpose: in for a penny, in for a pound.

“Mmmmh!?” Starlight gurgled around her mouthful of spunk, the mare blindsided as Jack mounted her hurriedly. “Wha’ dah ‘ay a’e yew doin’” She managed to mumble out.

Jack said nothing, his mind almost in a feral state of rut, his urge to breed this gorgeous mare overwhelming all his other thoughts. He quickly slid into place, his hooves hooked around her hips in a possessive grasp. His dribbling cock pressed right into her slippery opening, threatening to barge inside her cunt. It was only with great restraint that he managed to stop himself from just ramming his way past her tight slit, big heavy snorts escaping his muzzle as he kept still on top of her.

Starlight turned to stare at him, her eyes round with a mix of fear and lust, strands of semen leaking from around the edge of her lips. She swallowed what was left in her mouth, each gulp accompanied with a flutter of her eyes, the unicorn obviously enjoying her meal greatly. It made Jack want to plow her even more, and his hips started to hump on their own. His flare sunk just a little deeper, his cum-covered glans parting her folds. He realized the coating of thick semen glazing his cock was probably enough to impregnate Starlight, even if he pulled out, and he managed to stop before he could completely penetrate.

He started to pull back, and he gasped in surprise when Starlight thrust her hips backs, the mare willingly impaling herself on his pole. His flared tip plunged into her oozing cunt, her soft flesh welcoming him, begging him to go deeper. He shot Starlight a look, the unicorn looking back at him with a hesitant expression. She bit her lips, her pussy clenching around his tip, and she seemed to come to a decision. She nodded at him, her hooves shuffling to get into a better position, and she turned back to slurp on her marefriend’s stuffed cunt once more.

Jack held on for a few more seconds, knowing full well what would happen if he rutted the mare beneath him: judging by Starlight’s heated scent she was most probably ovulating, ready to be impregnated with a foal or two. He inhaled sharply when he felt her tail brushing against his balls, his hips jumping ahead instinctually. He groaned in pleasure as his cock shifted just a few inches deeper inside Starlight’s tight tunnel, her walls rippling around him; she wasn’t as tight as Trixie, but her cunt was wonderfully muscular, clenching around him as if begging to be filled.

And Jack was happy to oblige.

Throwing caution to the wind, Jack whinnied like a mad stallion and gave a mighty thrust, his cock surging through Starlight’s pussy without restraint. He grunted when his flare met resistance before he could hilt, Starlight giving a faint groan of pleasured pain as his tip met her cervix. She was more shallow than her marefriend, Jack’s medial ring barely managing to slip past her pussy lips, a portion of his cock sitting outside of her clenching depths. Jack snorted with frustration, his second thrust even more powerful as he tried to sink deeper, the third rocking Starlight’s body so hard her nose was pressed into Trixie’s cunt.

Starlight didn’t object to his brutal pounding. On the contrary, she thrust her hips back to meet his humping without missing a beat. The way his flare battered against her depths was almost painful, but the incredible bursts of pleasure made it hard to care. Jack shifted on top of his mare, his hind-hooves finding better purchase, and he began to positively hammer away madly. Starlight gave a high-pitched moan through a mouthful of spunk, and Jack’s hips unexpectedly slapped against her firm rear.

He froze, his eyes widening in realization: he had managed to hilt inside her, his cock now twitching deep inside her inner chamber. Jack’s flare had pried open her deepest barrier, and he shivered in delight as his tip was bathed in the wonderful warmth of her fertile womb. Starlight gave a loud gurgling whinny, and her whole body began to shake as she came around his stallionhood. Jack stood still as her cunt rippled around his length, the mouth of her womb clenching behind his flare, keeping him trapped inside.

He gave an experimental tug, and when he found he was well and truly stuck, he realized there was no way he would be able to pull out now. He thought about what this meant, and he realized he didn’t care. He started to give shallow little thrusts inside his mate, images of Starlight sporting a round belly filling his mind. He was going to gift her a strong and healthy foal, and it would probably only be the first of many. Accepting his destiny as Starlight’s stud, the sire of her children, he pounded harder and harder into her, sealing their fate.

Starlight gave a sharp cry of ecstasy, the unicorn somehow managing to keep enjoying her lewd meal, the stream oozing from Trixie’s pussy now reduced to a lumpy trickle. Jack knew it wouldn’t make much of a difference, since Trixie’s womb was still brimming with thousands of his virile sperms, and the thought of her little egg being swarmed by his swimmers pushed Jack into a blind rutting frenzy.

He took hold of Starlight’s trembling body, and he began to piston his cock mechanically, his thrusts short and powerful. Starlight nickered in bliss, clearly enjoying his new frantic pace, a big smile on her cum-covered lips. She was slowly pushed forward by the sheer intensity of his pounding, forced to climb on top of Trixie to avoid headbutting her lover’s messy cunt. Jack followed her closely, his flared tip keeping them stuck together like a pair of mating dogs. The two mares soon found themselves belly to belly, Jack’s heavy nutsack slapping against Trixie’s pussy as he swung his hips back and forth.

Starlight embraced her marefriend as she was screwed into oblivion, Trixie awakening under her insistent kissing. They squirmed against one another, Starlight in her rightful place on top of Trixie, the little mare all too happy to be pinned under her lover. They kissed and licked each other’s necks, Jack’s mad pounding making them both moan out loud. The scene was too much for the poor exhausted stallion, and he gave one last brutal thrust into his second broodmare.

His flare widened to obscene proportions, knotting him completely inside her womb, and his balls jumped against Trixie’s pussy. His mind lost to his feral instincts, he bit down on Starlight’s nape, making sure she knew who she belong to. With a manly grunt he gave a shallow thrust, and his semen exploded from his tip, flooding Starlight’s womb.

He came in a long and drawn out ejaculation, his balls emptying in a rush. His flare kept all his seed from pouring out of her womb, ensuring even her tubes were full of thick virile spunk. His reserves spent, he couldn’t bloat Starlight quite as much as he had stuffed Trixie, but there was still enough to guarantee she would carry his offspring. His breeding instincts demanded he made sure Starlight was his, and he obeyed with zeal. With a shuddering groan he let loose more and more ropes of his thick cum, the white jelly landing in the pool of genetic material swirling inside Starlight’s womb.

After a few more instants of feral intensity, his release finally tapered to a few final squirts, and his poor overused stallionhood began to soften instantly. He fell back on wobbly legs, his softening cock slithering out of Starlight’s clenching cunt, the sensation making him gasp out loud. He gave a breathless moan when he managed to pull out, a river of spunk following his flare, and he took a step back to take in the sight: Trixie and Starlight, both twitching and exhausted, drunk from the thorough rutting he had given them.

Two mares filled with his seed, and most probably already carrying his foals. The stream of thick stallion cream leaking from Starlight’s depths flowed right on top of Trixie’s pussy, a large part of it seeping deep inside her winking folds, making Starlight’s last ditch effort completely moot. Jack felt both proud and worried, but for now he pushed away all his worries, and focused on enjoying the moment.

“Hmm…” Trixie mumbled, catching his attention. “Daddy… more…”

He chuckled, his heart warming from listening to his little broodmare begging for his attention. He wasn’t sure why he loved Trixie calling her ‘daddy’ so much, but one thing was certain: he was happy to oblige any of her requests. Grunting from the herculean effort, he managed to slowly mount Starlight again, his semi-hard cock poking at Trixie’s tight little pussy. He had no strength to force his way inside, his length too limp to overcome her tightness, but he didn’t need to: her slit winked around him, swallowing his soft flare inside, welcoming him home.

He sighed contently, lying on Starlight’s back, his cock slowly drawn deeper inside Trixie’s pussy, her walls tugging at his meat desperately. His balls were already pulsing with a new load, one that he would spill deep inside the mare in her sleep, ensuring she was well and truly knocked up. He shifted his body to press his cheeks to Starlight’s, noting that the unicorn was already snoozing away, and he managed to catch Trixie’s gaze.

They looked into each other’s blinking eyes, sleep overtaking them, and they drowsily reached out with trembling hooves. A shiver ran through their limbs as their coats brushed together, like a pleasant electric shock, one that made them hold on all the tighter. Jack was overwhelmed by a sense of peace while he watched the mare fall asleep beneath him, their hooves still intertwined.

He didn’t understand why he felt so strongly about this mare, nor did he care about the reason. He simply vowed he would always protect her, always be there for her, for as long as he lived. He didn’t care why he felt this way about Trixie, it just felt right. He would be hers and Starlight’s stallion, their stud, the father of their many foals. He imagined the three of them, surrounded by a herd of little blue foals, and he closed his eyes, a big happy smile on his lips.

With his last conscious thought he wondered if this was what falling in love felt like, and he fell asleep on top of his broodmares, his cock buried deep inside his daughter.

... your father.

The train shook on the uneven tracks, making Starlight groan in discomfort as the vibrations shook her aching body. She was hurting all over, her coat was covered in shallow bite marks, her neck was full of hickeys, her throat was ragged, and worst of all her hips were incredibly sore. But considering what they had done in Las Pegasus, it wasn’t surprising.

It had been a little over a week since they had met Jack Pot, and since that evening they had spent almost every hour of every day mating like bunnies. The Golden Stables manager had come on the third day to politely ask them to vacate the royal suite, the clothespin on his nose unable to stop him from becoming hard just from the smell of their room. The look on his face when Jack had jokingly invited him to join them in bed had been worth the embarrassment.

They had then returned to Trixie and Starlight’s hotel, where they had continued their frantic rutting. They bought condoms on the way at Starlight’s insistence, but in the end they remained unused, unless you counted the time Jack had taught Trixie to make cute balloon animals while she rode him like a cowgirl. Of course the inevitable had happened, and as a couple of pregnancy tests had confirmed, they were both positively pregnant by the end of the week.

“You’re going to love Ponyville Daddy, you’ll see!”

“I’m sure I will honey, but I’ll need to return to Las Pegasus for my show a few times a week...”

“That’s fine, as long as Trixie gets her Daddy back!”

Starlight looked at the opposite bench, where Trixie and Jack were cuddling together. The stallion was caressing Trixie’s mane in a loving gesture, the mare purring in his arms like a giant blue kitten. Starlight smiled at the sight: since the end of Trixie’s heat, she and Jack had started to develop a sweet lovey-dovey relationship, the mare hanging on to his every word while he doted on her, spoiling her with gifts and affection. An outsider would undoubtedly mistake them for father and daughter rather than lovers, seeing how adorably they acted together… at least in public. In bed they rutted like a pair of wild animals.

Starlight might have felt jealous of the tender bond that had blossomed between those two, if not for the fact that Trixie clearly still saw her as her one true love, while Jack wasn’t selfish with his attentions: he made sure she was never left out even when he focused on Trixie, as the stud in a herd should. Starlight and Jack often butted heads for dominance, but that only made their relationship more interesting. She always came out on top anyway, if not for the few times where Trixie went against her and decided to help her “Daddy” win.

Starlight was brought out of her reverie by an eager shout. “We’re here!” Trixie squealed, pointing out the window.

“It looks nice.” Jack smiled, patting Trixie’s head. “Reminds me of my hometown… Is that Princess Twilight’s castle?”

“Humph, yes.” Trixie made a face.

“So, are we going to live in a castle?” Jack asked, his eyes going wide as he watched over the imposing crystal building. “You said Starlight has a room there, and we can’t all fit in a caravan.”

“I could ask Twilight...” Starlight said, her heart doing a backflip when she imagined having to ask her mentor if she could bring her small herd to live inside her palace. “The castle is huge, but I don’t know if I want to impose.”

“We can just buy a house.” Trixie tsked. “Miss Perfect Purple Princess can keep her lame castle.”

Starlight quirked an eyebrow, displeased by Trixie’s rudeness to her mentor… then she smirked. “I don’t know Trix, Twilight is always complaining about how empty the Friendship castle feels, I’m sure she would love to welcome our herd… and maybe…. join it?” She shot Jack a wink. “What do you think Jack, fancy adding an alicorn to our family?”

“That sounds like fun.” Jack waggled his eyebrows, half joking, half hopeful. He grunted as Trixie elbowed him in the sides, the mare glaring at both of her lovers.

“If Trixie has to share a bed with Sparkle, Trixie will need a barf bag.”

Starlight rolled her eyes, and she smiled as the train pulled into Ponyville’s train station. She hopped off her bench, eager to stretch her legs, and she levitated all their bags out the door. She left Jack and her marefriend behind, the stallion having to assure Trixie that no, he had no intentions of seducing the Princess of Friendship, and she stepped out into the sunlight. She took a deep breath, glad to have some fresh air.

“Starlight, there you are!”

She turned, and broke into a large smile as she spotted an orange-coated, blonde-maned pony trotting towards them; Trixie’s mother. The mare had visited many times from Canterlot, and she had taken a great liking to her daughter’s marefriend. Starlight put down their luggage and gave her a big hug, hopping the mare didn’t notice Jack’s scent on her coat. Considering Dandelion’s scrunchy nose it was not to be; it seemed the hours of scrubbing hadn't been enough.

“Oh my…” Dandelion coughed, her cheeks burning bright red. “I take it you and Trixie found a stallion in Las Pegasus?”

Starlight felt like she could die of embarrassment, but she still managed to nod.

“Oh that’s wonderful!” Trixie’s mother gave her another hug, squealing happily. “What kind of pony is he?”

“Well… he’s…” Starlight mulled it over in her head, trying to come up with something better than ‘he’s Trixie, but with a big cock’. “I guess you could say he’s…”

“Dandelion, is that you?”

Starlight blinked in surprise, and she turned to see Jack exiting the train, wearing a shocked expression. When she turned back she found a matching look of surprise on Dandelion’s muzzle.

“Jack? Jack Pot?” Trixie’s mother took a step back, pale as if she had seen a ghost.

“Wait, you two know each other?” Starlight looked from one pony to the other, confused. A little voice in her head started to whisper urgently in her ear, but she didn’t understand why.

“We lived in the same village when we were young… a long, long time ago.” Jack mumbled, walking towards the frozen mare as if in a dream. “Her family moved away and we lost contact.”

“I looked for you… a few months after I left… but they told me you were dead.” Dandelion whispered back, tears threatening to spill from her eyes.

“I’m not surprised they told you that, I didn’t leave on the best of terms.” Jack shook his head. “I didn’t want to stay in the guard, I did all I could to be dismissed… I wanted to become a showpony.”

“Just like Trixie!” Dandelion choked on a sob. “You two are just so much alike!”

The voice in Starlight’s mind had gone from a whisper to a full on scream of horror, and Starlight was starting to catch on. Her head ping-ponged from Jack to Dandelion, her eyes going wide. No… That couldn’t be… It was impossible… There was no way in Tartarus that Jack Pot was Trixie’s…

“Daddy, you left Trixie behind!” Trixie whined, stomping out of the train. “Why did you run so fast… mom?”

Dandelion covered her mouth, tears running down her cheeks. “Oh Trixie, you found him!” She rushed to embrace her daughter, a confused Trixie hugging her back.

“Uh… Trixie did yes.” She looked at her lovers questioningly, frowning in confusion; Starlight could only stare back silently, while Jack’s eyes slowly widened, the stallion slowly coming to the same realization. “Trixie found who exactly?”

“Your father! You found your father!” Dandelion exclaimed, confirming Starlight’s fears. “I’m so happy for you, I thought… Oh my Celestia we have to tell everypony about this! It’s a miracle!”

Trixie, Jack and Starlight exchanged panicked glances, the enormity of the situation taking their voices away. Trixie stared at Starlight, begging her marefriend for a solution, but the unicorn just shook her head, unable to give one. Jack looked at Trixie like he was seeing her for the first time, his mouth open in shock. Starlight resisted the urge to teleport herself far, far away from this situation; the moon sounded like a lovely destination at the moment.

“How did you even know he was your father?” Dandelion sobbed, still hugging her daughter.

Starlight wanted to facehoof at the obvious question, but Trixie beat her to the punch. “Trixie just saw him, and…” She turned to her father, took a few moments to think, and she smiled softly. “And Trixie knew he was her Daddy.” Her smile turned sultry, and she licked her lips, her mother missing her lewd expression. “Trixie knew she wanted him by her side, no matter what.” Her smile grew wider. “Trixie knew she wanted him to tuck her in every night, because Trixie loves her Daddy very, very much.”

“Oh that’s wonderful!” Dandelion wailed, devolving into a mess of happy tears. “You two must be so happy!”

“Yes.” Jack said gently, a grin slowly growing on his lips, matching his daughter’s expression. “Yes we are.”

The two of them turned to Starlight, watching her expectantly. Starlight looked from Trixie’s pleading pout, to Jack’s winning smile, and she threw her metaphorical hooves in the air.

“Yeah… very happy....” She mumbled, glaring at both her lovers. Both her perverted and crazy lovers. “We’re going to live together from now on, like one big… happy… family.”

Starlight sighed, and she told herself everything would be fine. They just needed to be careful and discreet, they could probably make this work...

“I’m so glad for you all!” Dandelion rubbed her tear-stained cheeks. “But, where’s that stallion you mentioned?”

…Oops.